Beyond Solitaire Podcast 156: Pete Pellegrino on Gaming at the Naval War College
Transcript
it's ad break time I'm proud to announce that the Beyond soliter podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations although the kickstarter campaign for their next game hydrologic cycle has ended I'll let you know when you can lay pledge clgs also continues to offer classes and partnership with Gen Con their next course will be intermediate roleplaying game design with aloy Lanta and it starts on June 19th I know it will be fantastic reports from alloy students have been nothing but glowing and I'll also include a final plug for myself if you like the show and you want to support it you can do so by going to patreon.com beond soliter thanks to listeners like you I've been able to keep upgrading my subscribing to streamyard and more but for now let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from beond soliter and this week on the pot of very special guest this is Pete pelino uh he is a wargaming expert and he's a contractor who works for n Simco but he exclusively supports the naval war college so how you doing today Pete I am well how are you I'm doing all right I'm super excited to talk to you how do you end up being a contractor who works at the naval war college for all right so this is the long story um when uh I was active duty military I was in the Navy uh and I was basically I was coming up on close to like my last assignment and I managed to Wrangle into becoming part of the military faculty at the naval war college so on our you know we got my assignment we got the house
packed up we're moving across the country from Washington State to Rhode Island where the naval work Lodge is and I get this message from the work college that says hey yeah about your orders no the faculty member you were going to replace didn't leave he extended for retirement purposes you whatever so you can't have the job you thought you were going to get which was a teaching position basically says but if once you're on campus really the the big Navy all they know is that they sent you to the war college and they expect us to manage the local Personnel movements and whatnot so from Big Navy's perspective you're still coming to the war college but we're gonna stick you in wargaming if that's okay I'm going wargaming I've played Risk okay I I suppose okay yeah and they're saying it's maybe a year at the most and then we'll we'll work out and get you into your teaching position it's like okay I show up that year goes by they say hey we're ready to moveie and I'm like going uhuh this is kind of interesting this whole wargaming thing is kind of cool I I'm good where I am just leave me in war gaming so now fast forward I get to the end of my military tour uh and I'm going to retire and I'm thinking can I just take off the uniform and put on a coat and tie and move over two cubicles and stay here at the time there's a federal hiring freeze so we're
not hiring any uh government civilians but again the the dean or the the uh of the center for Naval Warfare studies where warging fits under said look we want you we love to have you you need to find some way to keep beans on the table until the hiring fees is lify probably in a year um but if you stay local you know be around okay and we'll see what we can do like I'm like well okay I wander back down to my desk and the lead contractor uh for external support to the warging department because um our war G department is so large that we need both uh government civilians uniform military folks and contractors to be able to fill out the ranks because the whole department runs over 126 people so uh so we already had contractor support in place and uh my my future then boss wanders in and he's he comes into my office not unbeknown to me he had just talked to the dean and basically says hey I hear you're looking for you know trying to figure out what to do with the rest of your life and you retire um it would come down my office and let's chat and I I'm getting the fatherly mentorship thing you know the guy who's retired ahead of me George is 10 years older than I was he's you know so I'm thinking he's just gonna got again give me all that fatherly advice about what to do when you retire and stuff and and as I'm talking I in hindsight I realize oh that was the job interview oh crap all the stuff they tell you about you know when you're were going to retire from active duty how you're supposed to handle that first interview
and get I completely blew it because I didn't even know I was in an interview so George basically said hey we're going to bring you on as a contractor um and when if and when the college finally offers you a civilian position no harm no foul it's business decision on your part happy to to let you go and you know and to have you go into government service but I'm G to make it hard for you to leave Contracting and he did so basically what happened was he offered a a better compensation package than what the government was and it did give me lot of flexibility to work outside of the college which is where a lot of my my my gaming experience outside of the military came from so I I became a contractor and just like that first job when they tried to move me out of War gaming to become a teaching when they came around ready to hire me as a government I went can I just stay a contractor this seems to be kind of cool that's what happened I just stayed a contractor for 20 years so we'll come back to that but I just wanted so I I was actually surprised to hear this so you did not do any War gaming during your actual career like yeah like in the military before going to teaching or any of that no and this this was the uh one of the some of the senior Folks at the work College just assumed that I had come from some sort of of War gaming background if not from a hobby side of it from an exercise perspective you know big military exercises and stuff and I had some exercise experience uh one of my
military assignments was putting together training exercises uh but really that doesn't there are some similarities but not a ton of similarities between the exercise world and the wargaming world uh and as I as I tell people my first two three years in the job I did the whole shut up and listen uh I was surrounded by Wicked smart people uh and and and one of them uh who will self- admit that he has the the social skills of flesh eating bacteria and so my secret power was to be able to take what he was saying and repeat it in a way that didn't irritate people and so people thought I knew what I was talking about it's like actually I'm just channeling him but I'm doing it nicer hey you know it works out sometimes so that that's kind of how I just stumbled along into it now my parents will say sit there and when I told them that I was into this into this whole wargaming thing they were like well duh and I did the what do you mean duh what he says well when you were a kid you were tearing apart every game you got you tore apart and made another game out of it's like oh didn't I okay I'll take your word for it I kind of remember that but I I don't remember it as well as my parents seem to remember it and that it was a foreshadowing of things to come when it came to the the wargaming approach so that's really interesting so you know given that that wasn't part of
your training um what made you a True Believer that it should be part of other people's training and do you wish you'd had it yourself now yes uh to add the last part first oh yeah definitely matter of fact I I avoided uh a couple of war game opportunities when I was in uniform because it just seemed like it was going to be a nuisance and it's like really I don't can't send somebody else I don't want to go kind of thing which again in hindsight was a mistake uh so I think it was that the first again the first couple of years the folks I got exposed to I I uh I was I had the opportunity to work with Peter pea uh for a while which obviously had a huge influence on my thinking and if you're going to get plopped in anywhere where you're going to absorb the the best and varous people thinking about uh War gaming it's at the naval war College you know it's got the history the inner War period uh War plan orange all of that uh all kind of there is rooted in the college and the college has been gaming since uh well its Inception 1884 by 1887 War gaming as part of the curriculum and it was that way through uh all the way through pretty much so through post World War II beginning of the Cold War uh and so if anywhere was going to going to get me dipped in the Kool-Aid it was there uh and and that's something I often because I teach a warging class uh in the in the winter and in the summer and I have to remember that my gaming experience is the old where you stand is where you sit thing um is somewhat unique in that uh we're blessed
with a building I got 100 10,000 SQ Foot wargaming Center largest in DOD with an adjacent building with another a couple hundred, square feet uh I've got 120 plus standing you know a faculty uh faculty and staff at 120 some uh I'm Mission funded our budget is ridiculous so that's typically not what the rest of DOD gets to work with and I have to kind of dial down I say dial down but I have I've got to readjust and think about well how do we do what we do with only a fraction of the staff and a little bit of money and maybe no facility at all type of thing for because that's a lot of the who comes to to take our class are other folks in DOD which have some or or US government that have some connection to gaming now but like me had no training for it they just found themselves in a position where they said oh you well you're the war gaming guy like I am okay is there a book yeah you'll just figure it out oh my Lord so it sounds like you take you get a bunch of different people taking classes at the naval war college so who is the naval war College really for because you say college you think kids yeah but that doesn't sound like what you do right yeah so within the the world of professional military education there's different tiers so you've got all your undergrads that are basically at the US Naval Academy right so they're all and I'm strictly from a Navy perspective so they're at the Naval Academy and again they're all getting their Bachelors so they're Anapolis
then when it comes time for what is essentially grad school the Navy has two graduate level education sites uh it has montere California the Naval Postgraduate School montere California which is where you'd go if you're trying to get a master's like in engineering or Aerospace or what more of a of a Masters of Science you you'd find yourself out in Monteray if on the other hand you're trying to get something which is more national security policy strategy type of uh defense Affairs that sort of thing you'd come to Newport Rhode Island where I am uh and that would be you get a master of arts in defense studies from us and even within our program we kind of have basically What's called the intermediate course and the senior course or Advanced course which is really just what what rank are you if you're kind of a mid-grade officer uh which means you're probably lieutenant commander commander so you've been in the Navy somewhere between 14 is 10 to 14 years you'd be taking our our I don't want to say the junior course but it's the intermediate level course and if you're more senior you be taking our more uh course and it's not it's any harder or easier that's not really the point it's more or less what are the sorts of responsibilities and future uh jobs you're going to have at this point of your career versus being more senior in this point of your career that's kind of how the curriculum varies but yeah that's that's kind of the difference and in as far as who attends obviously Navy but all the service College all the college all the service colleges all have you know agreements that hey we'll send some of the army guys and the Army
Air Force will send us some so you get much more of a joint feel to it as well as civilians that are in different parts of the secretary of the Navy's office or different parts of of the defense establishment or US Government um will also send civilians to it so we get a pretty pretty broad cross-section folks as well as International officers so you are listed as a lead game designer and adjudicator so when you are designing games for these classes what kinds of games are you designing are we talking like kind of board gamy stuff like you would think if you're a hobby board gamer are we talking Matrix games uh a mix and how are you how you choosing for situation yeah so the first thing which is is counterintuitive is that I don't do much work for students so like most most major colleges you kind of have the the the student teaching side and then the research side it's the naval war College due to due to its history uh right now the wargaming lives on the research side so most of who I'm gaming with is for actual operational Fleet commanders and and not the students which we can we can spend a whole podcast on why that's wrong I would rather be engaged with the students um that said we are slowly bringing more gaming back into the classroom for the students but most of what I've done so that's the minority case the majority of what I do is I work on games which are designed to help the
chief of Naval operations think about his what are called his title 10 responsibilities which really really just means uh the man train and equip for the United States Navy as well as then the the commanders who were out in the Pacific or uh in Europe and thinking about how they have to deal with potential adversaries in their particular Geographic areas so the type of game runs the Gambit I mean yep um we do stuff that looks like the tabletop kind of stuff that is probably the minority case um what we're doing more of is the giant floor game which is just super cool when you got you got a yeah it's like a giant board game on the floor right I mean that's that's basically what it is uh you've got a you know giant map usually we put them up on uh uh slightly up off the floor a little bit on 18inch risers but otherwise it's ship models and again a map that's 30 feet by 20 feet and we're walking around on it fighting you know playing Godzilla moving Giant things around there's just something super Visual and and immersive about the giant map that you don't get when you're sitting in front of a computer display all the same information a digital map with you know little dots all over it that represent uh adversary in your own uh flea or you can be walking on the giant map with little model ships that's just so much cooler it's the map with the little model ships and it's just so much more immersive I don't know what it is psychologically it it's it sucks people in um so that's another form is we'll do these giant floor giant uh
floor map type of things and then for our biggest games and our big games I see our big games I'm talking about 400 participants give or takee uh will be across our two buildings each building's got multiple game cells they're all in their own little rooms and this room represents some Maritime headquarters and this room over here represents somebody else's headquarters and they're all staring at a bunch of computers with projection and whiteboards and and they're running around in that room so in all those cases what I'm trying to do is and is a colleague of mine at the army war College calls it being a decision space engineer or as as i' I've got some association with the commercial side of things um uh from a entertainment and hobby gaming side where we we talk about curating the game experience so the experience that we're most interested in from my my day job perspective is the decision process and and how is it that if I give you a bunch of information you think about making a decision and how you manifest that decision which then with the enemy's decision creates a new set of conditions you have to make more decisions so I've got to think about well what is it what decisions do I want you to make what information would you need to make those decisions how am I going to show it to you how am I going to give you the tools to think about it and then how do I get it out of your head and then just out type of thing it's it's we call it the Indo out process right input do out and that out
then has got to you know take some tangible form that then adjudication or other folks can manipulate and and figure out what happens and give you some more feedback so depending upon the the type of problem uh our particular sponsor all our games are sponsored by a a commander of some sort uh whether it's European command or Pacific command what's his problem uh as we say uh is it that you don't know what to do you know what to do but you don't know how to do it or you don't you haven't thought through or you don't think you've thought through all the wh ifs because this is that whole problem of no one can come up with a list of things that would never occur to them so we stick him in a war game to try to expose you to all the ways things can go sideways and we tell them look my game or any game cannot show you the way to win but you'll probably learn a half a dozen different ways you're going to lose and so this is sort of like Edison and the light bulb you and they said Hey how do you feel that you know you had all these failures and trying to make light bulb this is you know pretty feel B he goes I feel pretty good I now know 99 ways not to make a light bulb so likewise I know 99 ways the enemy can can really make a hash of my day uh which is probably useful to have yeah I mean it does sound like useful information um so a couple of questions like this is this led to so many questions so the big board we're gonna see the big board um uh so that model of gaming it sounds
like there's a lot of I guess kind of resource um use to make games that are that big so you know I feel like when I talk to a lot of professional War Gamers they kind of have oneandone games where they make specific games for specific groups and then they kind of move on to the next one um but this sounds like quite an investment so are you running the same big games over and over and refining them or are you always doing something new and different it's a mix so we have like some core games that are are every year we're revisiting that particular battle problem uh we may adjust it slightly because of just changes in in enemy Force structure or you know who the United States is worried about next year so those are these enduring games that we're playing all the time but then we do have the whole hey I got a I got a a a niche problem and I'm just looking for your help to help get understanding this part of it what can you do for us thing and usually those are the pieces parts are larger problem sets like uh right now we're we're working on a a game where we're looking at some Logistics challenges uh and the problem with Logistics is oftimes if I'm having one of these massive games where we're playing an entire you know a area of responsibility for someone's battle that's thousands of square miles Uh something's going to have to get abstracted Something's Gonna have to get reduced in detail because we just can't game everything everywhere the same level of detail so some stuff is going to get rolled up into a lookup table somebody's stuff is going to get turned
into a die roll well at some point that that guy who's whole life just got reduced to a die roll wants to look more deeply at his little piece of it so those are then we kind of do the okay we're going to do a separate game um and we're going to really focus on at a much lower level at a higher degree of detail your specific problem set and we may only do it for that particular Commander once part of our problem is just demand um we're in high demand and we only got so much bandwidth yes we're big but uh we get asked to do a lot of games so at some point someone's going to have to be told no and we go through a whole prioritization process each year about who's going to get a game and who's going to be told sorry you know reapply next year for your chance to do it so yeah so it's it's a mix of that um we do try to reuse stuff but at the same time we don't want to fall into the Trap of well I got the stuff so I'm going to make your problem fit the stuff I have as opposed to thinking about no what's your problem I'll figure out a game that addresses it and not inadvertently bias my answers the old well I got a hammer so all your stuff's gonna start to look like nails as opposed to no what is it you got maybe this year it's a hammer maybe it's a screwdriver maybe it's an orange I don't know interesting and then you know one thing I wanted to ask too you know said you had 400 people playing one of these games how do you keep 400 people suitably engaged at the same time because it's not just how do you logistically manage it right like the whole point of a game is that people
have to be like into it the whole time how do you keep 400 people into one big game yeah so I'll say that we don't always and we call it the USA Today Factor where if I poke my head in a game cell and I see some people reading the newspaper they're reading USA Today then I I SC I screwed up and that obviously I did not provide uh the right kind of decision space that required them to be engaged in it and there's there's two sides of this problem one is it's my fault as a designer I I thought I understood the decision space and the people who would be engaged by that decision space I thought I brought the right people in but obviously I missed somewhere and then I'm just I'm just not providing the right input for them to feel like they've got a role to play the citate on the input to be able to provide meaningful output uh now again that I I don't want to say oh no we're perfect we don't ever do that yeah we do we screwed that up from time to time the bigger problem is when because of the popularity of the games they become event onto themselves and we get folks who just want to invite more people it's like well okay I designed this event for about we thought we looked at your problem we thought about the the issues you have the sorts of decisions that would need to be made and we figured this is about 120 player game I would need that level of expertise you don't want too few people that you don't get the necessary crosssection of experience but I W I don't want so many people that again I got people who are bored because we just brought too many
of them and I can't entertain them all so I want that happy balance and based on our experience we think 120 is about right the sponsor says oh uhhuh 120 yeah so we've already invited 40 people from this other command because we just think it would be cool to have them there it's like well okay wedding planning you're right it's like no no you had a plus one you didn't get a plus 10 I said plus one now I'm cousins the cousins who said cousins I said no kids what happened so yeah that becomes a challenge in that when the sponsor just keeps wanting to pile people on and I understand why they do it I mean they're not just trying to crash the wedding they they think that there's utility in having those people at least exposed to the things we're going to be talking about and doing because ofttimes we find that even commands that are in the same geographic area have a hard time in the course of a Monday through Friday work week getting together and doing the sorts of things you can do at the naal war college so it's it's almost like hey it's an event onto itself we can go there and even though yes I understand that in DC you're just three blocks away we never get together but if we go up to to Newport we can spend the week together so I think it's important that you come meanwhile from our end we're sitting there going but I didn't need 50 people in that cell I needed five I have work for five I don't have work for 50 well find something for them to do no it do doesn't work that way just leave uh 47 USA Today in there for yeah so that is a
challenge but basically what we're trying to do is we have to think about both from a a who's thinking about it and and realize that a lot of the people that I have coming are very senior officers and we have the joke about senior officers don't type okay they they're they're past typing they want to sit there and talk about the Battle and some point someone's got to fill out the move sheet okay and if it's not the Admiral then it's the three Lieutenant commanders they brought so that's funny you know we do have that whole Staffing it's like a whole little mini Staffing issue and we do have this running joke about how increasingly blue commands because they don't get a chance to get together and practice these large scale things where they're going to be working with multiple headquarters in different time zones across thousands of miles of battle space so they want to use you know our our gamees without to do that that uh they induce a player hierarchy that the game itself doesn't need and I liken it to chess okay you can play chess as a team sport I mean there can be 10 of us on this side of the board all right and you get the pawns on the left I'll take the pawns on the right somebody gets to play the Kings in the middle we'll have a special group for castling we'll have another special team for okay you you can do it that way but it's not the most effective way to play chess all right meanwhile on the adversarial side the folks have to represent the bad guys they're all about just yeah let's keep us small and lean uh we don't need to replicate that adversary's whole heart we're we're not even sure what it is exactly but let's
let's keep it tight and and most of those players tend to come out of our intelligence Community you'd expect because they're the ones most knowledgeable about the various bad guys that we we worry about um and so they play a lot just because there's only so many experts in Phil you know Iran North Korea the Russians China whatever there's only so many Experts of that so invited to play a lot of games and just by virtue of playing a lot of games you get good at playing games it's kind of like a no-brainer when you're a gamer okay was like well yeah done but for people who don't play games as much um they come into a war game environment and they stumble over the transition between okay this is not your day job it's not the way you would really organized or really fight because you're not really fighting you're in an abstracted version of the fight and for example it's not going to be a 247 operation here we're only going to game from 8 and we're all going to be beat by 6 o'clock at night we don't want to do this 247 that's not going to be the tempo if this really goes down so we're playing for less time we're playing time jumps and in an accelerated timeline because no one actually wants to play one to one time because that means that every war is five days long because that's how long we play Monday to Friday kind of thing so obviously we need to accelerate things uh you're not going to have all the staff support and there may be 1,200 people in your staff back at headquarters you brought 20 of them here so you can't do the same sorts of things you do there as you can here and that's
hard for people who aren't used to that mental shift that every gamer goes through this soon as you sit down at the table and you you Orient yourself to the game and you get that whole okay so in this game I am who okay I'm Jack the river okay got it all right and you are the Constable's looking for Jack okay got it and this is our this is our play Space the back streets of White Chapel you can tell this is a game I have but you don't sit there and go well you know when I was a police officer on the beat this is not the way we would have Oran I I don't care right right you have to make that mental shift to accept the the bounds that the game creates and to solve the problem within those boundaries as a quote unquote professional war game we're going to try to the greatest extent possible align Not Duplicate but just create some alignment with the way the military thinks about and fights Wars but I can't do that 100% because it isn't a simulation we're not running one to one time and you're not you don't have your whole headquarters here and not everybody gets that so that's one of so it sounds like a lot of your challenge is also just deciding what games to take and why uh this is clearly it's a huge event um you know people are applying to get their games made and to get attention how do you decide uh who is I guess important enough to get a game this year yeah yeah it's who puts the most money on my desk is what I'd like to say but that's not the way it works uh the so basically uh down in DC
of the Pentagon uh the the office of the of the Navy the chief of Naval operations there part of them this is their job because that when they put out a calling message each year and we sit back and between them so they typically looks for the topics of interest that I have right now the most interest for the United States navvy we then look at it through the lens of yeah but what's gameable because not every problem necessarily is appropriate for gaming at the work College not that it isn't doesn't need a game it just doesn't need a game with me and and part of this goes back to that whole we're big right we we call ourselves the T-Rex of War gaming and so yes can T-Rex eat rabbits yes they can is it the most effective way for a T-Rex to feed no probably not so since we're big we want to take on the big work uh because we have the big facility because we have the big staff and whatnot so something which is smaller that again no kidding really does just need a 10 20 player game they can be played in the DC area can we get another organization to do that like the center for Naval analysis is a good example or Sebastian Sebastian Bay uh works and it might be more appropriate for their organization to do it could we do it yes but can Sebastian do 400 people and no he can't so again part of it is figuring out kind of whereby scale who should be doing what games and then What's the total capacity of the system basically uh the problem with our big games is big games take a long time to put together so our we call our Cradle to grave cycle runs about six to nine
months from the time someone says H I think I want a war game it's going to take about six months or so to get the game executed and then tack on another couple months on the back end for all the analysis and report writing so it's going to take a while and so again and that's part of our our limitation is just the physical space the number of humans and the clock just or the calendar I should say about just how many of these big games you can jam into the calendar over the course of the year so yeah so this actually leads to my next question I was I was just sitting here thinking like how do they collect all this data for this um so how do you effectively collect and then report on information about war games that are this big yeah so it used to be when I fir when I first got involved uh the analysis part was an afterthought right we we put all our energy into coming up with the game and then we go oh yeah analysis um someone go get an analyst uh we kind of give them the hey uh we got this really cool game we put together uh H see what you can do with it you know in terms of analysis so we rapidly said that's a bad idea so now we do what's called analysis UPF front and the idea with that is when we first get the team together to start thinking about a game you're going to have the game director which is just basically the guy an overall in charge but then you're going to have the game designer who's going to be sitting there thinking design thoughts um you're gonna have the game developer who has to take the design and make it into something this is the whole
architect and general contractor analogy so the designer your architect and the developers got to build it basically I I was told once that Pete you have beautifully designed games they're impossible to play I went okay I I get that beautiful writing what's it mean so so you got the developer there someone representing adjudication because usually what happens is the designer in the designer's head he's got the sponsors problem that he's trying to think about how do I make a game to answer the sponsor problem the developer is thinking I need to make a game that's playable by the players so the player Equity is represented by the developer the sponsor's equity is represented by the designer uh if it's a big game that's going to use closed adjudication then that's a proc process onto itself and so someone's sitting there going this is all lovely but you're not giving me nearly enough time to work out the interaction between forces since you want to do a turn every 20 minutes that's not going to work so you got someone representing that Equity the adjudicator and then the analyst is there because he's sitting there going okay we have a research question we have hypothesis we've got a problem statement and I've got to hear enough places in the design and enough places in the development process where I'm going to be able to get data data streams that are just going to be able to then do postgame analysis with and here are the tools I have to do it and and so what we don't want to have happen is designed the game only to have the analyst say well you know had you asked me sooner we could have put an event in right here and we could have done a
survey and I've got tools to do surveying and then I have tools to do the analysis of the survey results but you've already scheduled this chunk of time there's no way we can wedge in at this point so it's a little late so I'll have to try to do something on the during the the out briefing plenary process oh but wait you decided to do it in the auditorium which I understand why it made sense to you because there's lots of seats in the auditorium there are no computer drops in the auditorium so if we had done it in this space over here we could have done realtime surveying and using a web IQ tool what so it's keeping those four people in that kind of that conversation to understand where the opportunities are for each of us to fulfill our own perspective on it and one of the key documents that's going to come out of the whole process is called the Decap the data collection and Analysis plan which is how am I going to analyze 400 people's input type of thing that and that's and usually at the at the most basic level we have an awful lot of note takers every cell it's going to have multiple folks with clipboards kind of thing and and computer terminal stuffed in Corners to dash over there and take their notes and stuff on um for the our big games because we do use all the moves are computer-based the computer itself is you know we're we're uh It's All Digital actions so this the system is recording all the actions took taken over the course all the adjudication results are all you know part and parcel of just the fact that we're using a
computer but as we like to point out that's not the whole story because often times we say all I get from the computer is what actions the players decided to take what I don't know or all the actions they decided against because they didn't get put in the box so it's what did you decide not to do which might actually be more interesting than what you decided to do so how do we catch that by having people in the room going oh yeah they debated an hour and a half over go left go right and in the end they decided to go right but here's all the reason they didn't go left it's like oh that's that's some good stuff that's interesting yeah so one thing this also makes me think about is it I feel like throughout the process and I think this is true of all war games but maybe even ones that are big it might be even more true so we know that you know a war game can't perfectly encapsulate reality you're working with unknowns you're working with assumptions about what another country or another a you know another acting group might you know want or how they might behave so there's lots of ways to accidentally kind of insert bias into the process so when you have adjudication and Analysis as well how do you train people to consist instantly select the same things as important how do you spot like where something needs to be recorded and then also you know if you're making decisions about how things turn out as an adjudicator how do you do that in a way that's fair and not just based on what you kind of feel should happen yeah so
big topic right and the uh and uh we're always debating this on how to how to tune adjudication so adjudication runs the Gambit from what we call rigid adjudication which is just rules okay so every game you know you buy off the shelf yeah even we joke about how games don't come with umpires okay Dungeons and Dragons okay but any roleplaying game that has that role okay got it but even that role is defined within some sort of rule set so that's a rigid adjudication process is where you're just following the rules to the other end free adjudication which is depended upon the professional expertise of the subject matter experts you stick in adjudication pros and cons on either one uh what's nice about the rigid rule set world is that everyone's playing with the same set of same set of rules everyone gets okay I can look at the rulebook and it says this missile is this effective against these targets so I shouldn't be surprised when I miss because it was only 20% effective it says so right here on the table but I was to take a chance you know it is better than nothing we threw the die I missed okay I'm not surprised it's said so right here in the rules imagine that same problem now where we've got untested weapon systems technologies that have never seen a fight and we're all supposed to somehow know like that example of that missile that only hits 20% of the time that these new weapon
systems hit what percent of the time I we don't know we've got some engineering models they're littered with assumptions we got maybe some limited range you know testing data on a range again range isn't range testing ranges aren't actual conditions um we might have a real world event right now Ukraine Russia generating information Gaza is generating information uh the uh the naval actions in the Red Sea with the houthis generating some information so we have this hierarchy of how do you know what's going to happen and it goes from I have fought this war before no kidding okay so that's at least a a real world we real two years ago we fought these guys and this is what happened it's two years old but that's as good as it's gonna get then we have the okay is that no we haven't fought these people okay next next rung down okay next thing down is well have they fought somebody like us and we watched to learn about how they fight no okay all right next Rong down um have we seen them exercise because all major militaries do exercises at some point and we tend to watch each other's exercises to see how you're exercise that's an imperfect indication of how they might fight because usually exercises come with a whole set of constraints that prevent you from quote unquote doing it the way you'd fight we like to say the whole train to fight and get know in the end there's a lot of limitations on what we can do in exercise so but have we seen them at least exercise h no okay next
rung down um do they have at least some test range data that we were able to spy on we've seen them just try to you work on their kit okay um were we able to steal some stuff it's called foreign material exploitation you know where you get friend of a friend of a friend to buy the bad guy stuff and eventually it makes its way back to you all right no not okay do we have like defectors what do we have from the intelligence record I'm down to I know a guy okay so I've gone from uh we have we've had no kidding operational experience all the way down to well I know a guy who seems to think he knows some stuff okay and where are we along that spectrum and when you're down in the I know a guy world the problem with I know a guy is well my guy says this is the way the Russians operate their submarines well my guy says your guy is wrong and my guy says so we we have what's called SME on SME violence or subject matter exper on SME violence where the experts are fighting amongst themselves about what quote ought to be the right answer answer so this is where we get into this whole is it how important is it that my answer is quote unquote right from an adjudication perspective when we really don't know and this is where I go back to a historical example so uh Admiral Nimitz commander of the Pacific right World War II uh he spoke to the naal war College after his retirement in 1960 and he was
reflecting on his experience uh during World War III now nimt was a student at the war College in 1923 so you think about the state of of War of Naval Warfare in 1923 so we're not too far removed from dreadnots and Banes okay submarines are coming up as about as often as they go down so that's an improvement um so there's a lot of of again he's fighting that that was his experience uh in terms of War gaming at the college he was wargaming with the Navy the 1920s that's clearly not the Navy that he went to war with the 1940s massive developments happened during the in war periods in terms of of uh aircraft development and submarine development particularly as well as the Advent of the aircraft carrier and over the battleship Etc so we know from the historical record that we got a lot of the adjudication rules during the inter War period wrong we know that we had Japanese Aviation Naval Aviation wrong we assumed that they were going to do it the way we did it so we kind of we did the mirror image uh bias problem and in hind yeah yeah that was wrong um night fighting we got wrong uh submarine employment we got wrong uh radar got wrong torpedo performance we got wrong operations we got a lot of it wrong in hindsight Nimitz would be particularly aware of that given his experience but when he spoke to the
students he never mentions that part uh in terms of being a detriment to why as he reflects back on his nval his Naval education his Naval training and World War II why wargaming remains so important even in hindsight given all the things that went arai in terms of we didn't have the rules right and it's because nimt didn't perceive War gaming as being a I think about and therefore you tell me what happens it's I'm given conditions how do I think about it and make a decision and none of that was was to a detriment because we got some of the pieces parts and some of the details wrong he saw the value and the fact that everyone who went through War gaming in the 1920s and 30s had an intimate understanding of the geography we don't get geography typically wrong they all they all understood how far apart these places are where are Pala and Yap and quadine and where are these places um they all understood the challenges of logistics they all understanded the tyranny of distance they all so a lot of that Crosscut whether you went to the war College in the 20s or 30s or the 40s and it was about having so many people exposed to so many different aspects that yeah we got parts of it wrong but go back to what I said earlier I'm trying to help you figure out how the enem is going to mess with your day not find the one solution and if you want the one solution then you're going to want to think that I've giving you all the best data performance data of all
the kit being used in the fight when I can't guarantee you I'm getting it right any more so they could in the 20s and 30s guarantee that we got it quote unquote right but if I give you the mental toolkit to work with whatever you get stuck in front of you I've probably done you some good so that's that's probably our some of our biggest challenges is yes we want the rigid rule sets because that keeps everybody in the same sheet of music but at the same time there's just no rules that exist for some of this stuff because we've never fought with it before so I'm relying on people's best experience and again realize the best experience you know your best experience and my best experience may not overlap at all so we've got very different views of what the right answer is but as long as I get you learning how to react to whatever answer you get I think I'm probably doing some good that's a good way to put it so you don't just do military war gaming uh I noticed on your online profile that you also work with corporations with kids so when you're working with a corporation how does your way of talking about war gaming change if at all and how do you game something out for business that wants you to help them do better business as opposed to you know a military situation where you already kind of have accepted traditionally certain qualification the first time we did this was weird so uh it was a popup event sort of in terms of it came out of left field uh and the uh it was a one of the big Fortune 100 it companies and so I was super conscious
about demit ring I don't I don't want to talk in commander and and combat and your enemy type of thing so we kept making it the manager the CEO type of thing and within like a couple days they're all like no no tell us War Stories want War Stories so right that was that was a little odd all but what we Tred the way we tried to approach it with this idea that um the first thing we discovered that with a lot of businesses they don't have a a systemic way to plan their way through a problem they're relying on the fact that hey I've got I got lawyers here that I'm paying six figures for there the answer is in their heads that's why I hired them I don't need a process I just need these lawyers or I just need these Engineers or I just need these experts type of thing we used to have the joke about what if they all go to a convention and get hit by a bus now what what's your continuity plan they go we hire more lawyers oh okay okay that that's an approach might we suggest a better one so what we tried to introduce to a lot of the companies and and they want to fast forward to the gaming part and one of the things we tell them is you need something to gain you need a strategy to game what is your strategy oh we thought that's what the game did no let's Okay so let's back up and we basically introduced them to what's the military planning process uh where you kind of go through a a stage where you're trying to
Define what the problem is trying to understand what the intelligence is telling you about the the battle space then come up with some potential courses of action which are designed to try to exploit your strengths exploit their weaknesses and from a b business perspective that's relatively easy for them that translates across it might be that you've got awesome Logistics um they've got a limited distribution in the southwest you've got a supply chain which is pretty robust their supply chain is relatively fragile you whatever so it that was an easy trans ation for them to think about it in those terms um then having gotten to the point now where you've got a couple of three options that you now want to try to understand what are the strengths and weaknesses of each of those options now we're ready to move into a gaming environment where we can try to start to pick at stuff it is funny how some companies see their their competitors as antimatter to their matter it's like well they don't just exist to be a pain in your butt okay I think they have shareholders and I think they have employees and I think they're just tra they just happen to be competing in the same Marketplace that you are um and but otherwise they're they're not just there to ruin your day that they didn't sit around and say you know what I think that company needs a competitor let's let's be a company and go mess with them and getting getting companies to stop thinking of them as being antimatter to their matter and simply understanding that they are competing in the same space as you are you've got strengths and weaknesses they have strengths and weaknesses how is it you're going to exploit your strengths and and and or
your opportunity or take the opportunity to use your strengths against their weaknesses to be in a better place from a a market share perspective so that was it was interesting they are pretty willing to do it I mean to engage in the activity once you kind of set it up that way um some are more excited about it than others a lot of it is personality uh some managers and Senior executives are or more or or more risk averse than others which means when we start pushing some extreme idea is in terms of uh thinking about well this is an option they're like no it's not it's well it is it's not physically impossible so it is and we do this on the military side we we talk about this idea that never assume away what your adversary might do if it's physically possible just because you've never seen the yopan do that before doesn't mean that they couldn't yeah but there's no could they do it yes then we have to consider it it might High unlikely because like like you said we've never seen them do it in any exercises or any of but could they because otherwise you're just wishing away adversary capability then when when you find out that they do have a death ray and we said they might have a death ray then you're completely caught on the back foot so it's trying to get uh folks to understand that that space like that and to use that thinking um which kind of brings that gaminess into it um and they usually kind of again they they once you get them going I've had some great games and and and played with compes and stuff that uh uh things that now we take for
granted like especially in the the Telecommunications side of the house where it used to be everyone was in their own Lanes you either made Hardware you made software you delivered content everybody stayed in their own lane not anymore so yeah you're and and we actually had a game with a company where they were starting to see on the horizon maybe some of that and they wanted to start thinking through what happens when a lot of you know what used to be Netflix just showed somebody else's content didn't make their own content that's Universal's job that's you know 21 20th century Fox's job that's somebody else's job they're just a distributor yeah but what happens when the distributor wants to make content you that's Madness you say is it so a lot of those games just expose people you know get people to start thinking about and popping those sorts of ideas up because back to what I said earlier no one can no one can think of a list of things that would never occur to them you've got to get yourself out of your own little you know Cocoon of thinking and to get that that adversarial for a small a um push back to be able to say yeah but what if they did X that's not probable didn't say it was I said what if so how does this also apply to your work with uh younger students so I know that you also do some historical uh game designs for it's high school students right yeah yeah primary high school students yeah high school students seek that's Boy Scouts that that girl you in The Scouting bro yeah yeah so uh on the
historical side of things uh one of our little mantras is we want to expose students to the same dilemmas that they that the historical counterpart they're studying had to wrestle with without preordain the same outcome because otherwise it's a drag to play right you know if you're if you're studying the Civil War and you know that well we're playing Gettysburg well How This Ends I don't want to be the South you know kind of thing yeah got it and so most of our games are designed such that uh historical research understand kind of what are the pivotal moments and this is something that also we have students do by the way um I get students to make their own games uh yeah because there's nothing like make oh you you know from stuff you're do with George you know there's nothing like making your own game to learn about a topic make a game about it and you'll come out so much more you know informed than you were um before you tried to wrestle with a game about fill in the blank so yeah with students um bunch of other constraints kick in classroom duration you can't play a game that goes for two hours if you're trying to do it during the school day all right because you're a school teacher you know this yeah we got like a 55 minutes and you're lucky if they come in on time and if they don't start getting anany right before the bill so yeah exactly so you've got that time limitation you you want to avoid and this is hard when you're doing military games because military games often come with a factor of attrition so what happens to to Johnny and Amber when they had the the second platoon
Fifth and they're gone they're wiped out they got they got obliterated 20 minutes into the game what do those two students do now well they're a problem okay because right they're disengaged so you've got to come up with all sorts of clever ways um to think about how do they get how do we either reconstitute forces do they get a secondary role to play and one of our games I've got this big game where uh it's a it's a trench game so it's four one history program that's East greenish High School here in Rhode Island and uh someone complained years ago that the game was just all rolling dice whatever game we were playing therefore it was all luck and I didn't want to get into the time of well no it's the statistical distribution of prob okay it wasn't the time to to do that this wasn't math class but I took the on board and then that winter over Christmas I made a dexterity game uh so I just okay no dice all dexterity so what the game has is a board it's a it's eight feet long four feet wide and it's uh styrofoam battle space all these trenches This World War I all these trenches car craters and stuff and little burnt trees and what it's sticking up and the students have control of basically meeples mounted to Bases movement bases and they're jumping up out of their out of their trenches and they're trying to move forward and while they're doing all this the opposing side has pom poms and they're
throwing fistfuls of pom poms small pom poms are rifle rounds big pom poms or artillery that they have to turn around backwards and throw over their shoulders they can't see where it's going they have to kind of Loft it and do indirect fire um they're throwing um oh I took I took bath those bath scrungy things uh yeah right and I disassembled I took them apart and I have them throw it like poison gas so I've got yellow ones that are mustard gas I have to W them up into tight little balls and then when they throw it of course it expands and drops where they don't want it to and it lands on their own troops I get green ones for chlorine gas um so it's all dexterity based now because it's World War I part of what we want them to understand is the horrific attrition rates from the war so their troops are getting wiped out constantly they're getting obliterated and the problem would be then they're out of the game the game mechanism is when all those troops die uh I've got student helpers who are sweeping up the dead meeples and they're going to a table called the called the rest the the rest and restore table so they hang out there on that table for a turn cycle then they move over to the reinforcement table and then they reappear in the battle space like fresh troops coming in from the rear at the back of the table and those students have their forces back so that keeps them playing and every time the player every time those meeples die and they go to that casualty table I got a student scoring so we're keeping
track of how many times forces die to be able to then to do this whole attrition discussion later but you get to play the whole time your force is never quote unquote you know you're never eliminated as a player right which works super well you know from that perspective um and we play for about it's a madc cap uh just about an hour um because I've got to the advantage in that whole program of a super receptive social studies department where they've given over the entire day to a series of games for the entire 10th grade so I'm I'm playing a couple hundred students at a go cycling them through multiple games we do it all day long um it's great kids you super engaged um who doesn't like throwing pom poms I I can't decide if I want to teach at that school or get there I had the same thought when I first got introduced to this program this was a you know a friend of a friend of a friend type of thing who was a school teacher you know School teachers obviously talk um and I'm I'm listening to this history program I'm going where was this when I was in school I had great history teachers but actually I did get into introduced to wargaming in a high school history class but I didn't get to throw pom poms now I'm resentful so honestly I feel like could go an entire other episode I'll go into the softball questions but I I feel like we might have to do this again um but for now um what games are bringing you personal Joy this is why I look at my shelf okay
so flame Rouge flame Rouge the bike game is the bike game I love flame Rouge just so what I find so captic about flame Rouge is it's done in a way that one it's it's that whole no one wants to be the the guy who's in the P you know who loses badly at a game okay right uh right there's no fun in being that you want to get a sense that oh you were you know I was I was in there I was in that I was in way I could have won type of thing I want to play again because I I could have won flame Rouge does a beautiful job in that in that pelaton of bicyclists um and keeping everyone in the hunt for the victory um and you talk about the game afterwards because I I bike you talk about the game in the same language you talk about a bike race so it's a wonderful uh emulation of a bike race so family likes flame Rouge pandemic Legacy so here's our story about pandemic Legacy we have been playing for years the same game we have not gotten through one game of pandemic Legacy in six years now because the problem is we only play it when certain family members are together which only happens like Christmas you know so we're only the number of touch points we get to actually play the game are so few that we joke about how we look at the little little card about how you're ready on how things is going goes we started this game in 2012 oh my God and we're not done yet um but so the
the the Legacy part of it has taken on its own you know family lore because of that's been going on like that for so long so we again we don't get to play it as often as I want but um that's one uh Secret Hitler okay all right social deduction games you know fun for the When We Gather everybody up type of things we like secret hiters um code names uh another one that that that play well and then letters from White Chapel which is a Jack the Ripper secret movement game um we like and often I play Jack because then it's become this whole um beat up on on me everything can we win and I I've got to admit there was one game where I lost on the first move oh no and I have not been able to live this down and it was just it was I I I picked a strategy that was a bit risky uh I thought I've won all the other times I can win this time too and I overplayed my hand and I screwed it up and I lost on the first night and my son and his wife will not let me forget this you know they're just clinging to their one moment of Victory after so but yeah and because I obviously the from the the wargaming part of it and whatever everyone expects me to have like a stack of Avalon Hill games I don't um I I there's only one variant of axis and allies I enjoy playing it's the guato canal that was actually just
re-released by Renegade games I think it has a wonderful mechanic in it in terms of it Salvo fire battle box which I think is awesome um and M 44 uh I play um but that's about it for that kind of game uh otherwise yeah we're we're a wide thematic group um there's certain me family members that enjoy the the just the two-player kind of you know Strate head-to-head stuff like Oni Tama my one son and I like to play a lot of on Tama uh or War chess is another one other ones it's family games and the crazier the better uh Galaxy truckers is a PO one that out that comes out just because the whole craziness of building your spaceship and then you know having it all fall apart in space type of thing everyone kind of likes that so that's some fantastic uh and then if people want to follow your work online where is the best place to find you yep tabletop history.net is where you'll find a lot of my War gaming stuff and other stuff and that all came about because of the pandemic basically um I had a bunch of work that was just scattered on all sorts of different platforms and uh different places and then I was getting pestered K why don't you make a website why didn't you make a website well because they don't have time because they don't have time and then the pandemic gave me time so it's yeah all on tabletop history.net beautiful uh Pete thank you so much for coming on uh this has been a really fun conversation I hope that I see you at Circle DC maybe next year uh but either way this is absolute Delight uh we really appreciate your
time yeah right and uh definitely then everybody out there uh please don't forget to like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming