Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Most Popular Games We Didn’t Love

Transcript 49:51

hey I'm Ryan this is my brother Daniel and this is rolls in the family and today we've we've got a little bit of a spicy topic Daniel uh this is we we tend on this channel Focus largely I'd say 90 plus% of our effort on recommendations and things we enjoy and the games we like we have a few videos where we talk about games we've gotten rid of but this is is similar to those those coing vide but kind of looking back at all of the years of games that maybe didn't work for us what are the ones that are like the most popular that we didn't enjoy for whatever reason and I I guess I shouldn't say didn't enjoy you know this isn't going to be a list where it's like people love this game and I think it's awful I think it's terrible yourself yeah maybe Dango feels that way I'm looking through the 10 games we're going to talk about and every single one of them I actually rate a sevener higher um so they're games I enjoyed but I didn't feel they were worth keeping for my taste and you know we kind of looking at that difference between how much we enjoyed it and some of these people love you know you're very possible your favorite game of all time might might be talked about today this is the video that's going to bring the haters out man yeah hey everybody's different you know not every going to like the same games we would love we always love when people comment but this one especially kind of a fun one to hear what is a game or games that seem to be really popular

people love it and it just did not land for you um you know you bounced off of it or decided that you uh didn't feel like coming back to it you can drop that in the comments below we will include links to all the games we talk about uh in the uh description they are popular if you want to go with the majority and not how we felt about it then then check those out below um this is going to be a shared list like we kind of assembled 10 games together um cuz we we do have kind of an overlap in our thinking here uh and you'll have to forgive us if we forget some details here on how you got to understand some of these games we you know played years ago and got rid of and so it's digging a little bit in the memory bank to remember exactly how they worked and what we did yeah so if we hate on your favorite game and completely describe it wrong uh yeah we apologize you you can call us out in the comments it's fine it's fine uh let's get this started though um with our number 10 and this is actually this is an interesting one so so the kind of the history here you had gotten the game Great Western Trail first actually and I played it with you and I was like man this is a among like kind of Euro games I play this was a really fresh enjoyable experience I think I played it almost four times with you and and then finally decided I I think I got to add this to my collection well right around that time they were releasing Mar IO which was a new kind of iteration on the Great Western Trail formula but oh Daniel it

added cards like almost like a terraforming Mars or something like a deck of card abilities combined it sounded on paper like this is like what I would want like um and so I actually I got it for my birthday I remember um I specifically asked for it cuz I was like I think this could be really the one that I want to own and I remember you me and and your wife played it and and it was a learning game and we were try kind of figuring things out and stuff but we all were having the same feeling of when would I ever want to play this over Great Western Trail like it it has some similarities but I think for us the things it removed were things we really really like about Great Western Trail and some of the things it added we didn't find maybe as compelling so so for example we love in Great Western Trail the deck building like get try to get your hand right before you get to Kansas City and how that affects the pacing well you don't have that anymore um and you don't have the pacing of like how many times do I go around cuz it's just once around each round I guess and you can kind of control the pacing as a group of like you could push the pace but it just was a different feel and I really missed that piece of it yeah for sure and then they some of I remember one of the systems they added in was like the country area control stuff which was like okay like you kind of

invest in these different things or whatever but I just didn't find it that compelling I don't know so it it we played it once and you I went and I sold it and I bought Grace Western Trail in the expansion I was like yep it if anything it confirmed Great Western Trail is the game for me but I felt so bad after that game because like I we didn't acknowledge it out loud right away cuz you just people are feeling like you had just got this you were excited about it and just like internally I'm just like I I objectively like Great Western Trail more yeah like you know and so so that was yeah very rarely do we uh usually we're pretty generous with games after like you know okay get through the first play you know it's a little rougher give it some time I don't know I feel like this one we really were just like well and I think it's because it shared so when it shares so much DNA with a pre game you're familiar with it's so much easier to kind of compare and be like which of these do I do I kind of prefer I know Maro also has kind of this like like campaign thing you can do but that's just not something we're really looking for in that game like we just want to kind of do oneoff games of it for sure I also like the theme of Great Western Trail more too I'll just add that D just likes the cover of the original Great Western Trail that guy he just we we both have we we both have the first edition so there you go we definitely enjoy a great rest Trail more marabo uh up to number nine so this is a game that I think a lot of people I've seen hailing it as like a modern classic

like this is being elevated to the tears of some of these you know games like ticket toide Katon Dominion like things that really kind of uh stand the test of time in this uh weight maybe of kind of lighter more accessible games and we enjoyed this one this is one that you had I played it a couple times you played it more than me had a good time with I just don't think we see it quite at that level that others seem to and I think I want to say you got rid of it um that is correct yeah so we we neither of us own it this is aul um and aul I mean it was popular enough that they just they keep making spin-offs of it I don't know how many versions there are at this point you know there's like aul chocolate Edition and you know all these different make anything um and I think it's a really solid um system and with the Drafting and kind of how it works with I just am having a hard time seeing what elevates it so much higher than maybe others kind of in this genre yeah I think one of the things for me was the thing that you were building or on your board just wasn't that compelling for me like I don't you know it's mechanically sound like how it works with like the different lengths but it's not it's very abstract and and every person you you know it's kind of the same thing you know it's not like a game where it's like oh I've got this kind of you know I think about like a ticket to ride you know you've got your own kind of unique thing that you're doing versus what

other people are doing where it's it just felt kind of very the same the mechanics are are great I will say the one mechanic that just didn't Vibe with me is uh this game can be mean especially if you're playing like well you know you can really set someone up to just get R especially if it's like two player where now it's zero some and it's like huh me destroying the other player is just as good as helping me yeah so it's kind of that combination of both uh like sound mechanics but nothing that was like wow like grabbing me um or whatnot and then you just add a little bit of the like icky feeling with you know some of the mean stuff I don't think we typically like really mean like to each other games like we're okay with confrontation but we don't like well especially in a game where it's like if this is going to be in our collection it's to be a very accessible pull out with you know a wide variety of groups and so that kind of game I'm not usually looking for like really mean moves hey want to play board games with me by the way yes um so yeah you held on to it for a while like it did it's not like we bounced off of it it's because it's a good game like it was always like it's a good game but it just was never getting played and and it's cuz it's it it's just what you were saying like the times you're going to pull it out is with like you know kind of people new newer to board games kind of just a you know um kind of an intro and yet every single time I'm in that situation I was

choosing Ticket to Ride I was maybe even going to like a qua of quinber uh you know stuff like that so um yeah when a game doesn't get played there it goes yeah we're we're we're pretty Relentless like we get rid of a lot of good games an understatement it's BR brutal we just we take them out back and we burn them in a bonfire no we typically sell them oh okay uh yes I so number eight I think is actually very similar kind of in category to aul in that it's one that seems to have been elevated to this higher status of just like Best in Class in this kind of mediumweight Eur game that we like the most on this list I one and we we put and we got it early on like after it came out way back way back in 2011 or something uh played it probably 20 times um so it's like we played a lot enjoyed it and we just kind of I think got to the point where I wasn't feeling super compelled to come back to it MH just got a really really beautiful new reprint uh recently this is the castles of burgundy and this is a stepen Feld design and stanfeld has a very specific kind of design of these very mechanical they don't typically have very uh high production value I mean the original Castle is of burgundy it wasn't exactly a looker and the little chits were like borderline card stock in their thickness like they're um but it's a really solid

game with the you're rolling the two dice and you're using those results to take these actions on the board to draft tiles and fill up your estate and it all was really nice and we had a lot of fun with it um I'm surprised just how loved this game is though I mean it is really they're I mean it's very high in the rankings it's I I see it popping up on people's favorite games list obviously the new addition I mean it was like bound to do amazing CU if people were loving it when it didn't look good just imagine if you give it the the kickstarter treatment and they did it's a giant box now and and so I've been hearing a lot about it again CU people getting the new addition and loving it um and so it is interesting because this is one of the things I'm like yeah that game was I I like that game but in a sea of kind of mediumweight uh Euro games especially like dice there's a lot of Euro games that kind of use dice in clever ways you know we've talked about like tuah and Lorenzo will magnifico and others on the channel um I'm just I'm surprised that this is the one that seems to have like reached that status you know it is interesting just with like the how games get popular because I feel like there's a certain point where if a game can build enough momentum of like people talking about it and stuff well then people get the game because they're hearing it talked you know and I don't know I feel like kind of can sometimes snowball a little bit not just and and again I we both this is a really good game but it is surprising

especially just in the kind of board game landscape today that this is uh yeah seen as one of the best whereas I think both of us are like yeah it's a it's a good game but but I don't think I think we're missing the like why is this one of the greatest you know and we've played we've played a few Stephen Feld designs I think you still have carp DM is that I do that is an ugly game yeah you thought ugly right well that one's like functionally bad like it's like hard to tell you had to like put like stickers on the back of things they they have these tiles that you need to keep them distinct and one of them is a light green and one of them is a slightly darker green and you have to hold it under the right light to determine I'm like this is horrible man yeah so so we we've played CLE Berg we played carp DM we played uh we played one game of uh trun TR however you pronounce that one on was on tblop simulator um and I think I found with Stephen Feld designs they're the kind of games that I'm like man it's a fun little puzzle I enjoy playing with it but there's just not enough there in either exciting variability or just just to want me to keep coming back to and to own it and be like this is game I'm going to play over and over castle of burgundy was probably the closest to that and it did stay in my collection for quite a while um but I kind of just got to the point where I was kind of done with it whereas there's other games in that weight that for me feel more Evergreen for my taste I

agree number seven is maybe not as popular as castleburg uh and actually this is the only one on the list that I have played in D has not played so dang if you just be silent yeah yeah just uh chat gpg over there and some peanut gallery comments what are this is a beautiful game a game that I thought maybe my wife would enjoy maybe kind of uh a little bit more accessible Gateway game that has a very appealing theme um this is Meadow which uh is a nature theme gate coming on the back of just a flood of nature themed games that I think I think wingspan broke the the gates open for that to happen I know um and it's this game of collecting these little cards that all of these beautiful watercolor illustrations it looks really nice um and you're kind of building up your habitat and the way you're selecting cards is by there's this grid and you use these little arrow tokens you have so you have one that's like three and so when you point that on a side of the grid it'll take the card that's three in from that side and you can kind of come from any angle so everybody's kind of like selecting cards that way which is like kind of interesting but in the end it's just like ultimately there's certain cards you can get to and certain cards you can't and you have to like figure out what that is and then like so in the end I I feel like you're kind of getting to the same end result of just like which of these card selections are you most interested in right now you just have to a little puzzle to kind of figure it out um for me the big thing with this game I

think there were two things one the g w it looked so good the gameplay was just kind of forgettable for me like you know you're doing this you're getting these cards that you can kind of stack on each other but there just wasn't that much meat to it which was fine if that's what that game was going to be yeah and you were weren't you looking to play this kind of with your wife too so so like it was like okay that that that could be fine that could be what this game needs to be I think the killer was pairing that with it being a like 90minut game and like and really with the number of players like I remember we played a four player game of this and it I think it was over an hour and a half um and it's like man what with what the game play has given me this game would have to be like a half hour for me to like feel like it's kidding right if you're going to go longer than that you got to be giving me something more here it just yeah I don't know it I just didn't find it um all that compelling and so then the length of it made it an easy choice to and I played it a few times um but yeah it was just like this just I am not going to be uh vouching to get this one to the table cuz every time I'm going to be like man this is going to be way longer than we probably wanted to be man Ryan here and that it gives me nightmares of my two and a half hour love letter premium game and that's when I knew that game had wonder what dangel did wrong for that to happen yes so that that's all I really have to say about Meadow and dangel doesn't have anything to say about meta

so we might we might as well move on yeah except except I do agree the artwork was uh I did really like the artwork when I saw Pi yes it looks very nice which it's so hard to know how much of that is why it's popular cuz for you know for a lot of people that carries more weight than maybe it did for me um but for me meow kind of fell flat on to number six which is a game that Daniel has played though may not remember much better than Meadow which he I don't know how I I remember how I felt after this game I tell you that so this is a game that I was seeing pop up it was getting some buzz and it kind of fitting into an interesting thing of like oh it plays in all of 15 20 minutes but is actually more of a crunchy kind of gamery game that's really unique and I was like oh that could fit a really nice spot in my collection ended up getting it this is the king is dead second edition the new edition of it um and ultimately this is a game that for me there's a few games that that land in the specific bucket and it's this bucket of it's more it felt to me more interesting than fun it's so interesting the design is fascinating like cuz it's this little area control thing where nobody there's like three different countries and no or three different like uh countries that are competing over the region so there's like three different colors of Cubes it's you know you don't have minis in this game um but the way you're manipul nobody owns any of those at the end of the game it's going to be which of those

factions one like had controlled the most regions so say the yellow Q but then it's whicher has the most influence in the faction that won so throughout the game you're playing cards to manipulate add cubes move things around manipulate the map keeping in mind that you you know you could help the position of something but then somebody else could like actually get the influence in that so it's just really weird like checks and balances but then at the end of your turn you have to take a cube off which weakens that faction and that's what determines what you're invested in so there's always this decision of I need to choose who I want to be more you know invested in by making them weaker in some area to do that yeah and so it's really mind melting because it's so such a fine line between helping yourself and accidentally helping other people because you're like well I did that and then you're like crap I don't like that line literally yeah and it also had the weird thing with like you everybody has like the same eight cards but you can pass I I forget exactly how the passing but there was this Dynamic that like you could finish all your cards and you're done but other people may have more cards left and they can finish out more um and so again there was so many things in this it was one of those ones when you read the rule book you're like man this is cool like this is really cool how this works right but I played it a couple times and it was just like I don't think I'm actually having that much fun like and the decisions like I

don't know just and I just I felt like the only way it was going to get to the table was me being like hey you guys want to try something kind of weird like and fun or kind of weird like it's like a weird experiment and it'll be fun to try the weird experiment but for me that wasn't going to be something I'm going to want to come back to over and over again totally yeah I mean the I was happy I played it once uh and I'm happy I'm not going to play it again yeah and you know if it came up down the road that like an opportunity to play it I would play it again but when I'm looking at my collection it's like these are games I want to play over and over and over again King was not one of those for me dead another that wasn't speaking of games that didn't stay in the collection everything on this list uh number five is interesting because our initial impression of it was really strong I remember we were all in the same game on this um it was us and like our our siblings really fun first play of this and it was like man what a unique game in my collection I put it on almost like a must buy on my collection after the first play and slowly over playing it more I think we found that the novelty kind of wore off a bit this is awkward guess which is this really interesting think kind of like clue deduction but kind of in this a little bit more complex and like different how you're kind of sharing information and deducing um everybody has this this map of the

house you're trying to figure out you know who killed Mr Walton you know where did they what was their motive and like what did they use or something um and the way you're deducing is everybody has these cards that'll tell you different things like where um somebody was or I it's been a little while I don't remember exactly different types of Clues but on your turn you basically people offer you cards from their hand that they're like I'll give you you know these cards faed and they have like numbers that kind of indicate like how valuable the information is and if you decide you want to trade with them you have to give them an equal number of cards from your hand so there's kind of like this trading of information you get new information and then you get to make deductions and that always was like very fun and very interesting in this um I think there were a couple things that I found hurt this one one was that for being a deduction game the more you played it the more you realized there wasn't a lot of real deduction going on like when I think real d I think like oh because I know this and I know this over here I can infer this brand new piece of information it's like search for Planet a like which I feel like is stronger with with real dedu really has strong DED here it was like I get a card so I can cross this thing off of my sheet and now I got this other thing so I can I can rule this out right and so it it's more of just like slowly ruling things out than ever there was the very rare thing it was honestly one of my favorite things in the game was when the map itself it was like oh because their

route would have to go this way and that wouldn't have crossed the room that had the weapon you know there but it was like less than 5% of the things you did in this game was that type of um and so that was a little bit like okay once the novelty wears off of kind of this being a new thing it's a little bit of feeling like you're going through the motions of just and it's satisfying to cross the things off but it wasn't quite the deductive experience that maybe we were hoping it would be the other thing I didn't like about this game you know we talked about the the sharing of Clues was a kind of a fun element of it but it kind of was this awkward thing you know where so okay I'm going to offer you Clues if you're being competitive you know you could just give someone information back that they gave to you earlier and it would be really mean and it's like do I do that so it's like weird position of you're like sorry I don't even know if this is what you gave me that was yeah actually cuz normally we wouldn't want we're like okay that's kind of against the spirit of the game to just send someone back what they gave you earlier um so I want to you know give something different but then you forget then the person gets the cards they're like are you kidding me you're like I'm sorry um so just the trading of Clues it's kind of just this like weird like oh I don't even know what to give you I think the more I played it I also realized how valuable some of those highest level Clues are um to the point where if I get dealt one of those initially the competitive side of

my brain is saying I'm never giving this to anybody I'm gonna wait until because there's opportunities in the game where you can discard I'm like I'm going to hold this I'm going to be the only one that knows it and then I'm going to discard it and and it's just like okay is that like really the experience we want to have here so it was a little weird with the clue giving never like when com competitive competitiveness and the kind of spirit of the game are like odds each other yeah yeah the fun Factor um so yeah that was another on top of that the nail in the coffin for this was probably that it was a little too long for what it was and maybe a little hard to teach and it wasn't originally in English and some of the like there specifically one type of clue that what it describes on the card does not make like any sense and you always have to explain like if you get this card what it's really saying is like this weird thing and I was like man I wish I could just like take these out of the game like cuz literally just have to explain that one card is making this rules teach harder um so yeah it it kind of was a steep decline after that first play I mean we played it a number of times after that um fun experiences but it really felt like one of those ones that's more fun to to try you know and play but maybe not own for sure speaking of game so that was a game that we had a very positive first impression was is this our worst first experience we've uh I wouldn't say it

was our our worst um but it was very clear that it was like this game is not one I'm going to be holding on to um had gotten it as a gift we I think it was just you your wife me and our older brother actually that played I think it was the four of us late too it was a little late and so there were maybe some factors in play your first play I just learned it from the rule book um but this is whistle mountain and whistle has a lot of really cool things going on of like you're working together to build this scaffolding that's going up like as the water level is rising and then you're Landing your little like blimp Zeppelin things to take actions on the scaffolding and it's like based on what you're adjacent to and you can even if you can land your size of Zeppelin in a way that it like touches more than one thing you can get multiple you know rewards from it it's really cool but holy cow talk about a game that the decision space is like an ocean cuz like anytime you can play scaffolding or any kind of building out there it's this grid that is very uh flexible like the rules aren't very restricting it's like you could put things almost however you want and so you're sitting there trying to think of every implication of everywhere you could put it but then you have that same kind of overload whenever you're Landing your blimp thing cuz it's like there's so I mean think of a normal like worker placement game there's like

a discrete number of worker placement spots that you can go and this it's like you can literally go anywhere you can go on a grid and it brings it down a little bit cuz like you want to go close to some of these different actions but man and I think there were even a few other things in the games with some of the like upgrades you could get or things that just like I I I think we broke our older brother like cuz if you in this game try to think through what's the best move I can make right now oh my go the amount you would have to consider is so much I basically came to the conclusion that the people that are going to enjoy this game are people that are okay kind of just like flying with their guts it's like this feels like which there's times where I think I'm okay with that but it felt like I should be thinking about and I don't know it was it just like came to a crawl in our session of it like we it was so slow and so it ended up being very long and yeah very very cool things but it just was like I don't think I want to play that again yeah well and to have such a it's you know I mean that was like a a Prime game moment you know of like you can pick your best hitter and to to have an experience the other game I remember we we were at an Airbnb with our family and the other game I had brought was Dune Imperium and and and I was like our older brother would probably like it and in hindsight I was like we could have played Dune Imperial

yeah and now he's never talked to us since yeah yeah never never ever since the whistle Mountain debacle of 2019 whatever that was broke the family broke yeah cool game I think there are some people that would enjoy it but but wasn't for us my brain brain couldn't handle it uh alrighty we're number three here Daniel is POS possibly the most popular game on this list probably um probably yeah and I've only played it once you've played it more you liked it more than I did you it was only recently that you got rid of it I mean it was in your top games um but but the difference between how we feel about it and how other people feel about it is still pretty pretty big and this is Sye and maybe I'll let you lead on this one your perspective just from you know you played it more times right than I did yeah so this one was one that really drew me in one presentation just beautiful like the board and everything just looks awesome and I always love that um and mechanically like really cool like I love like the AC you know you got your kind of action board that you're um you know kind of in a very ston Meer games they have a kind of common thing where you know you got your Li four actions you know kind of like wingspan or something like that um very and and I and then you're kind of you can upgrade things on your board so you're making things more powerful so there were a lot of a lot of things that

were really cool about this game and I think it's why it kind of stayed in my collection for a while the things that didn't land um in my experience one uh it was like the game mechanically was set up for this awesome experience but then what always ended up playing out left me extremely underwhelmed um one I had multiple games where the winner was basically whoever got enough movement or or was able to just like run around and get all these explore tiles like or or the little explore tokens which those explore things are cool um but like they were just kind of running around doing that and I don't know so I was like okay I also the whole like you you know you produce resources but then like someone can just you know if they kill you they just take your resources you know and and that's not that's more of probably personal preference like some people might really like that kind of thing so that's more of just kind of our personality um well and I more than you struggle with like hybrid style games yeah because like we definitely like these games that are build your own thing work on your own thing and I even enjoy a number of games that are you know pretty high conflict but when you start to try to do them together it just It's tricky to get it to land for me because you're giving me the feeling of wanting to build my own thing but then allowing that to be interfered with is like kind

of in competition with the core enjoyment of that side of the thing and so I always come away from them like liking but not loving them in most instances yeah and and for me just like the progression of the game it was like okay you start the game and it's getting like more and more exciting and you feel like it's kind of building and then right as it's like you feel like you're about to like kind of get into the point of the game that maybe is going to deliver like the the bulk of the excitement it just always felt like the game end like I just always felt like the way the game ended it was just kind of like oh okay it's over um or I don't know it just the ending wasn't that that great for me and and probably the last thing you know the kind of the way the whole the bulk of the scoring is you're like claiming these I don't know the title of it but I don't know objectives that are kind of at the top of the board you can claim those but it's like that times your uh popularity the little like heart thing that you're you're going up and I just felt like in the decision making you know you could have decisions it's like maybe you get an explore card and it's like you could do this or you could do something that gives you a heart it was always just like okay well I should probably do the heart cuz that's going to multiply my score it just personal feelings it felt like this like the bulk of the scoring was like me doing this extra like peripheral thing to boost my score versus like something

that's deeply integrated with like uh what I'm doing again someone who absolutely loves Scythe Mike 100% disagree with that that's totally fine that's just I'm just trying to you know remember uh some of that so yeah and and that's a you know it's not a short game like you're talking about this is like you know Prime gaming main event and I every time I played it it was always like and I I remember probably the best situation I had a bunch of guys that like they they play Scythe all the time I got absolutely whooped and that probably didn't help but but it was like the perfect group and even in that it was just like yeah that was good but also I just at the end was like oh man it just didn't like you know the our favorite games leave us going oh my gosh that was amazing you know that was just so much fun and and the game just never did that never did that for me so and I'll be the first to admit I played at one time and it was not a good play to like just the way it played out it ended really prematurely cuz we had like a player that kind of ran away with it and then somebody else made a mistake that basically let that player steal all these resources so they were already ahead and they just like catapulted so I was definitely left with the like oh well I kind of had like a plan of how I wanted to upgrade and do this and like I didn't get to do but realiz researching and I just and maybe it is largely the kind of hybrid style that I just was like I don't know if

this is going to be for me um yeah a lot of people a lot of people love it I mean this is a lot of people's favorite game um for sure but not one that we we have held on to I hate to to keep uh this going here on a ston Meer games uh you know we enjoy a lot of GES games are doing but couple entries here this is one that very popular worker placement game um especially I think what made me really start considering it more strongly is how the way it shot up uh Tom Bessel from The Dice Tower his top 100 list this was all the way up into the teens or somewhere up there and it was like okay it's a game that you know goes to six it has a nice theme uh this is viticulture and and viticulture is a nice fine game it's a little bit of a weird game because the way they've iterated on it makes the product line very confusing because there's like the essential Edition but then there's like the Tuscany expansion people are like need the tusky expansion um all this but um I had the essential Edition I didn't have the Tuscany uh expansion which there's probably people in the comments that are like if you tried it with Tuscany it would change your mind but from what I understand I don't think it directly addresses some of the things that I you know like about VI culture um so one of the things that bothered me a little bit of VI culture was just the Uber Randomness in the cards and now there are a lot of games I love that have tons of randos the cards like terraforming Mars or Arc Nova or some of

these but it in this it there's a lot of these cards in viticulture which are like and it's been a while so forgive me but it you can get something or like if you meet some condition or something you can get points and so there's times where you get card draws late in the game and one player could get it and be like yeah there's either like this engine building thing that it's way past the point where that would be helpful and this thing I can't do this card is literally worthless to me someone else could get to draw a card and go I already have this this is like two points which could that could win the game like that could and so that always felt a little bit like even if you're on the side of the one drawing the card it felt a little bit like well that was lucky like I didn't really do anything to you know and whereas like I think some of these other games that have luckiness in cards it's more obscured in how you have to use the cards it's like yeah maybe you got some cards that went really well together but you still have to kind of like make it happen this is like guys I just drew two points yay uh in a race to 20 a race and so that and that's the other big thing here is is the race and I found that I did not like the cuz basically once somebody gets to 20 or above that that's the final round and it's that paired with the way that you primarily get points in this game is by growing The Grapes turning them into the wine you have to like put them in the cellar to age the

wine it's this multi-step process okay and it's a multi-step process that you can't really like accelerate like it typically is going to take multiple turns for you to get this to ultimately fulfill a wine order and so almost every time I played this what would happen is somebody realizes in the last round oh I could actually make a run for 20 points this turn like if I maybe it's because they drew one of those cards and like oh suddenly I can um but they realize they can do it and so they start taking actions that everybody else is like oh they're going for it and what happens is those people look at what they're doing and go well I'm in step three of four of of my big move right that's going to do these big wine orders and there is nothing I can do about that like next turn I was going to turn this all into to all these points but you're ending it this turn and so then I'm left this round kind of walking through the motions of like well where can I squeak out some points but I completely lose any satisfaction of finishing what I was doing and converting it to points and so it kind of felt like you're almost guaranteed there's going to be players at the table that had this like really crappy willing to finish the game which is like which the final round ideally should be the most exciting point in the game right it should be when you're doing your biggest things and most of the table is like uh yeah and it made me realize the advantage to the alternative uh kind of

design Choice which would be something like like maybe a teristic uh age of innovation we' talked some of these games where everybody knows the amount of rounds it's like we have six rounds and the advantage of that is in this type of game where you're planning doing multi-turn things to you know make things happen you always get the satisfaction of finishing on your own terms now you sometimes botch that but you can like know that you could have done things differently yeah you you dangle specifically that I'm talking to the directing that at me right um but in viticulture it can be like you didn't even know you thought for sure we were going to have another round mhm and then you're just left with this like uh uh and that's kind of a symptom it's something there's some advantages to race mechanics that's one of the downsides to race mechanics is often times when somebody can make it the other people's realize it and realize that they're going to fall short uh and so for me that really paired with the randomness it really killed viticulture for me um I still enjoy it I still rate it decently it probably rated 7.5 MH but it just yeah it wasn't one that I was going to keep around yeah yeah I age which brings us to our number one which Bo I enjoy this game quite a bit and it and this will not be because of lack of plays I've played this almost 20 times I think and this is a game that on paper uh seemed very tailored to our taste CU

we love Cooperative games we love games like Mage Knight with like cards and card effects and variable player powers and all of this everything pointed that we should love Spirit Island and for a long time I liked Spirit Island quite a bit um but slowly realized things that I did I learned a lot about myself through playing Spirit Island and what I like in a co-op game that's good um which is good but I tell you this is I mean you see this popping up so often as people's favorite game of all time and it's it's really big in the solo Community as well right um it's got a lot lot of good things going for it there are a few things specifically and this is one that over 20 games I was able to like really diagnose what wasn't working for me one thing I learned about myself is in a Cooperative game I love the drama of an unexpected opponent like when we talk about some of our favorite games whether it be eldrich or some of these and there are varying levels of how much luck is in the game and that's why a lot of people might not like those but I do really like when the opposition is throwing you curveballs and like something happens and like oh my gosh and like the breth of the types of things that can happen is like a lot of different things in spirit Island you know almost everything that is going to happen you know exactly which region they're going to ravage in you know exactly which region they're going to

build in the only unknown really is which one they're going to explore in which you even that you can deduce a little bit based on what's been dra and you're going that and so it's very known which is what a lot of people like about it it shifts it from being this randomness of the opponent and instead it's presenting this puzzle for you to figure out the solution to with your cards um but then on top of that the variance in the types of things that can happen is not very much it's like they explore they build they ravage and it's a bunch of just Little like guys that are all kind of the same you know the map very quickly becomes a sea of kind of the same stuff that sets the puzzle for how you're gonna kind of clear things out so that was one big thing for me is is just lacking that drama excitement in a Cooperative game uh the second thing was kind of the game Arc in in spirit Island at least in our games we typically found you go through these rounds of oh my gosh they're spreading where what are we going to do but you're getting more powerful which is a lot of the fun of spirit Island you get new cards you're upgrading your you know Spirit um and typically we would get to a point where we get over that hump um sorry this is turning into Ryan rant to Dango about spe Island but you get over this hump of oh we turned the tide right like we got this under control we can maybe start thinking about regions that are you know just being explored or

being built instead of just worrying about what's currently being ravaged yeah and typically once you get over that hump and you're only getting more powerful as spirits you like know you're going to win the game um but usually there's at least a round or two that you have to finish out the game and for me that is like a no no in Cooperative games like I want my Cooperative games to have tension right up into the end you want the last if I know I'm going to win like let you know we win I don't want to play more with that being a known entity because the the draw of the Cooperative game is the are we going to which is why we like our Cooperative games so hard uh hard Cooperative games Spirit island is very tunable and that's probably what some people will say to this is like you just got to tune it to where that hump is right at the right spot so that you you win and maybe that's that's true but man that's asking a lot to like pick the exact difficulty for the exact group to like get the exact experience that you're looking for um so didn't didn't love that um the third thing is one of the things people like about Spirit Island and I agree this is a nice trait is it really avoids like Alpha gaming of one person directing everything mainly because there's just so much to think about like with your spirit and what cards you have it would be very difficult for someone they'd really have to go out of their way to be like telling people exactly what to play yeah and so everybody's kind of doing their own thing and figuring out what can I do

with my slow powers and fast Powers this turn to to address things but this is a Cooperative game we're working together on the map and so there needs to be a certain level of well what are you accomplishing and what am I accomplishing and so everybody's kind of simultaneously solving this puzzle and usually I'll throw out like oh I think I can get these guys over here okay so you're not going to think about that you're going to worry about over here and so everybody's doing that and it's a crunchy puzzle here we're talking of how you could play these and how you do this and so you kind of get to where you you maybe figure something out but if anybody realizes something like oh I actually could do this like get this along with this or oh oh I actually don't have enough to do this you've like reset everybody else's puzzle because now it's like oh I need to do that well I have to completely do something different or like oh you're doing the thing I thought I was focusing on you realize that you're super combo actually took care of it took care of it right and so it's like well I got to find something new to do and so man you can get into some long planning periods like if you I found if you even bump from two to three players the amount I I really wouldn't want to play with four but the amount of that that can happen of somebody you know just the interactions and F staying on the same page uh really slows it down and it it doesn't feel as excitingly Dynamic cooperation as maybe we get from some of these other games now I could see two players that really

know Spirit Island and know know each other's Spirits just really locking in and and being able to work really well but for me that was definitely a downside for it yeah well you know what's interesting this game in some ways feels similar to like Mage Knight a game that we love in terms of like cards kind of complex things but in Mage Knight you're kind of off for most of the game you're kind of off by yourself uh so you don't really have to like you know do and then and then even in the end uh you know you're fighting the same thing you know you're you're you even kind of get to do your own separate battles within that but Mage Knight does have have you know randomized enemies that do have a wide range of kind of exciting abilities that can be thrown against you the comat on the enemy side of things um and so I can see the appeal of spirit Island I see for for a lot of people where they bounce off these other Coop games because they don't enjoy that Randomness and they don't like losing because of a random output and so Spirit Island presents them with this very low Randomness puzzle that they can then feel very clever with how how you

than what I gain in that yeah yeah it feels like Spirit island is the board game for people who don't typically like Cooperative games it is what I see often times it's people are like I finally found a you know a heavier Cooperative game I really like and it's like okay I that makes sense to me right you know why that that happens um there you have it those and like we said these are good games like we we games um but hopefully we were able to articulate why these did not land as we had hoped for us and uh did not hang around in our collections um if you know feel free to defend your favorite game down and explain why maybe it works better for you U but hopefully you found it interesting uh why these ones maybe did not land for us well hopefully you didn't click off already uh hit a Down thumb down because we hate it on your favorite game uh but thank you for watching and if you want to hear more about us talking about uh games that maybe didn't land for us uh super well we actually have a whole playlist to our uh games that we've C from our collection so you can click on that here if you want to check that out uh we've got another video here as well and we will see you in the next one

Progress saved