Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 100 Board Games of All Time! (2021) - 40 to 31

Transcript 32:26

hi everyone i'm luke hector from the broken meatball and thanks for joining me on another video if you like what you see please remember to leave a like and a comment it means the world to me to know that you're appreciating the content which i know you're doing for a lot of these top 100 so i can't thank you enough for it don't forget there's also a little mini patreon campaign if you want to help support the channel even further we're getting closer four more segments to read off this tablet we're on to the 40 to 31 this time the games are just getting better and better no debuts this time though you have seen these 10 games before on the list there have been some risers there have been some fallers and some steady ones as well so it's a bit of a mixed bag but yeah nothing new on this particular 10 just some fantastic games so without further ado get on with it my number 40 has remained fairly steady only climbing four places from 44. uh no particular reason why it's grown i think it's just remaining steady in the 40s and that is probably the first major hit that garfield games were able to do which is raiders of the north sea this isn't well is it my favorite of their games you'll have to wait and see but this one is a really cool worker placement game which granted is this high on the list because of the expansions check out my beyond the base game videos for more details on how they work but as the base game alone it's good but i wouldn't call it amazing but when you throw in those two expansions hall of heroes particularly in fields of fame but mainly the halls of heroes one it does bring a good amount of new life into this game it's pretty simple going i mean you essentially punk a worker down do the action and then take a worker off

another spot and do that action you're building up a crew of vikings and you're going out and ransacking towns and villages and monasteries while getting luke to give to your chieftain with the expansions you can drink mead in order to give you a temporary strength you upgrade your armor the crew have different abilities some have ways of scoring they have one-off discard abilities you want to trigger off little effects there's a lot of things going on in this game but the rules are very very simple and with the play mat that i've got with the resources and the good production quality in the game it's a beauty to look at as well it's just a really good fun game overall but as i say in those beyond the base game videos if this was just the base game alone i feel this would be a bit lower on the list maybe closer to 100 even because i don't think the base game has enough in it hall of heroes is such a good addition to this game in adding fields of fame just kind of completes the set in one big collector's edition backs no less but a really solid one at 40 to start things off raiders of the north sea my 39 has risen quite considerably in fact i'm kind of shocked it was this low on the list last year 22 places this has risen i think i've been playing it a bit more often not only just online on board game arena but also with some friends of mine who are also fans of this game i've managed to play it more with some of the expansions included as well which i've got funky little cards powers yes i'm talking about relax i'm not gonna get the dice out i'm

talking about seasons seasons is a great card game where you know res arcana tried to come and do this in a simpler manner unfortunately it was boring but this one is the one i go for where you're doing a tournament over three years with a variable timer that moves into different seasons as you go into each season you roll these huge glorious chunky dice i'm not going to get them out i said i wouldn't and you roll these dice and they get you manner in order to play cards with special powers but the season dictates what dice you roll in what manner you can easily get it's a lot easier to get say water and air in the middle of winter than it is fire for obvious reasons but then conversely in the summer good luck trying to get any water so as you going through these seasons you kind of have to plan ahead as to what manner you're gonna need and when it's likely to get there but as you're drafting these dice from a pool that's rolled the die that's left over dictates how fast the timer moves which is a mechanic i adore in all these dice placement games where the last die has an impact it's another choice you've got to bear in mind it's gorgeous to look at the dice are so chunky and gorgeous stop it and with this it's just a really good fun game and it's climbed a lot because i think i've just remembered how much i like it more because there was a bit of a gap from last playing it but recently it's hit the table more and with the expansion cards i've managed to see oh yeah there's some really cool interesting stuff i can do now whereas if you play the bass set alone you see the cards come up every time and you kind of get a little bit bored with that

throw in two expansions though you don't even have to throw in the weird mechanics that the expansions have one has these little like player powers you can have or like little ways to tweak the game another has a moon die that you roll for other points you could actually just ignore those bits entirely from the two expansions and simply just bolt all the cards into the deck and use them honestly that's kind of the way i do it really but it means you get all those cool new cards which is really what the game needed it didn't need more mechanics it just needed more funky cards but yeah a massive climber from liverlude here 61 to 40 no 61 to 39 22 spots hopefully it will still remain in the top 50 because it's a fantastic game i just wish there was a solo mode for it well i've not heard of one maybe somebody in the comments will tell me otherwise but 39 seasons where are those dice

my number 38 has been pretty consistent 41 to 38 pretty steady and this is as near as makes no difference comparable to detective the portal game that i talked about before the fact that it's six places above means i like this one slightly better but honestly the two are kind of interchangeable because they give me different feelings this is chronicles of crime from lucky duck games that's there in all its masterful glory with a bucket load of scenarios i still haven't played yet you know there's a lot of content for this game but this is the deduction game where you're figuring stuff out by scanning qr codes dog pig dog pig loaf of bread system error you have a scenario like say a murder scene has happened and you go there and you can look at your phone to see the actual scenario like the scene as you look around like a madman or something with these like little 3d glasses tapered to your phone and you look at the scene you can get cards to give clues you scan them with various people like your forensic scientist or the hacker or something like that in order and witnesses in order to find out more of the story and solve the crime there's a lot of different scenarios and the base set alone but then you start getting into a noir setting a red view kind of suburb setting now the new sets have you going to the future to the past to medieval times there's a lot of variety in this game way more content than i'm ever going to get through in my lifetime but at least every time i feel like playing a new scenario which i tend to play this only solo i can just literally whip out a brand new scenario go with it multiple levels of difficulty

technology that just works so seamlessly and so smoothly the only slight quibble i have is that you're on a time limit to look over a crime scene and if you miss stuff out it can really hose you for the rest of the setting that's a bit of an annoyance you should have all the time in the world to look over a crime scene just because in the movies they only spend 40 seconds looking at it doesn't mean that i have to spend 40 seconds looking at it i'd like to take my time but you know that little blemish aside still really enjoyable and as i say it's as near as makes no difference whether this is comparable like whether this is better to portals detective or not detective gives me a much more heavier engrossing uh sort of deduction story whereas this one's more the pick up and play simple uh game but with a bit more variety shall we say like i can get casual gamers into this one i might hesitate to bring them into detective as a casual gamer so it's different strokes it's different feelings but both of them are fantastic games as is this one at 30. i was going to remember i'm not in my 40s here by 38 chronicles of crying number 37 has dropped 16 places from 21 it's a filler so it doesn't tend to get rated as highly although there are some exceptions i guess but this is still a fantastic two player game in fact this is gonna be one of my favorite two player games that i own yeah this is definitely one of like the top five two player games in existence this is from emperor s4 games who do a lot of little games and yes i know the shelves look a

little bit bare at the moment i went to a convention recently and i haven't unpacked those games yet but emperor s4 has one of their lines as the best game they've ever made which is hanumakoji i have used this game so often when i've been teaching new players at dice portsmouth events or at conventions or even just at the cafe saying oh we're brand new to games and you know me and my girlfriend here like to play games every now and again do you have a recommendation for two players panama koji it gets brought out i love this game such a simple rule set such a basic premise here's a bunch of cards in front of you geisha cards you're trying to win favor over each gay yeah try not to think too much into the theme here but you're trying to earn the favor of these different geisha and you do it by collecting the cards represent the items they use and having them on each side of your board so it's a majority holding so i hold two of the cards you hold one the geisha is mine again don't think too much into the theme but that sounds pretty basic doesn't it but you have these four action tiles that you use and each one has a thing like play a card and reserve it for the round discard it out of the round uh pick i pick you choose like here's three cards you pick two i get the other one you know here's four cards you pick a pair i get the other pair and each of you has to do these four actions but when you do them has a colossal amount of difference even though it's not apparent because the earlier you do it in a round the less information you have about who's winning what favor but you have more choice of what cards to use but if you use it later in the round you have all the information there but you don't have

as much choice as to what cards to use it's this wonderful conundrum that you find yourself in and there's no right or way sorry right or wrong way to use the action tiles but every time you play this game no matter what order you do them in you regret it by the time you get to the fourth one it's just so clever and if you can't win make the winning condition after a round you go again but obviously you've got to win the favor back from certain geisha while protecting your own oh it's such a cool rule set looks gorgeous easy to teach i have never had this go badly with anyone i've showed it to in fact embarrassed for practically owe me royalties on this game for the amount of copies i've sold of this when i've taken it to a dice portsmouth event shown two people it and they go up and they buy it you know it really does happen and i am beyond excited for the fact that i have been sent not only a new version of hana makoji so a bigger box with you know slightly different artwork but the mini expansions they've released eight seven or eight mini expansions for this game with different action tiles and i mean they're not revolutionary like changes you know they're rinsed and repeated a few times but they're mixed in different ways but eight different ways that i can play this game and a sequel to it called geisha's road that uses that similar mechanic i cannot wait to play these games so badly oh my word but yeah this game fantastic such a good two-player game if you have not tried hannah makoji and you want an easy to get into but very clever

and puzzly two-player game you are doing yourself a disservice if you don't try this one hannah makoji it's dropped a bit so it sounds like well why has it dropped so much if you're raving about it well there's a lot of games i enjoy it's not a big deal it's still going to be in my top 50 until the end of time hannah mccoy fantastic my number 36 has dropped six places from ferdi no big deal in the movement this is a stone mirror game that boy doesn't get a divisive reaction from people you either love this game like i do and think oh it's a really really great game has its flaws but still is so beautiful and pleasant and just a wonderful new idea or you hate its guts and you wish it would burn a painful death and you would be standing over the bonfire gleefully like grinning burned you yeah really it does get an abnormal reaction from people and this is of course wingsman wins man the very popular game from you know stone meyer and elizabeth hargreaves and it's just a wonderful pleasant game tableau building you're building up rows of birds with different special abilities especially with the expansions where you've got the european birds and the oceana birds that all have different like end of round powers triggered powers your immediate powers it's like all sorts of things going on but it's just done with this wonderfully pleasant ip of birds i even managed to taunt my dad this granted it was a bit of a slog because they need really simple games and this game is not

really simple but you know he's a bird fanatic so i had to try and teach him but for everybody else it just goes over really nicely it's just very it's easy to play easy to learn but it has a lot of depth because of the way that you trigger those bird powers is there a bit of luck in the game yeah but it's an hour long game big whoop you know it's not the worst light offender for lacking a game and even then you can mitigate some of that lack particularly the starting hand by just simply incorporating a house mulligan rule i do it every game and so why don't you but it's just really nice it looks absolutely gorgeous on the table particularly if you get the play mats from lizard dang they've got some beautiful ones there that you can use on there but on top of that you've just got those little mini eggs which it's always tempting to eat them because they do look like chocolate mini eggs but on top of that you've then got the birds themselves with gorgeous artwork it's just such a beauty and i enjoy playing this game with three or less players yeah that is the one that caveat i have with this four players is okay if you all know what you're doing i will refuse outright to play this with anybody with five players it's got a great solo mode but solo two and three player is your sweet spot with wingspan and if you do that you're in for a good time but it does drag on a bit with too many players my 35 has dropped seven places from 28 no big deal it's just hard to get this one to the table i suspect that's the only reason why it's dropped a little

bit plus there's a lot of content for this game that i have even more that i've now kick-started but i don't know when i'm gonna get the time to go through this game with that much content it is a colossal box from aeg and it's definitely a niche game i talk about things like bloomhaven and that being a niche game and technically i still feel they are but this is definitely a even more niche game and that is edge of a darkness edge of darkness is basically the big mother of the card crafting mechanic that john declare has done mixing the card crafting mechanic with a communal display of cards that you're individually crafting then with worker placement then with a cube tower that basically represents threats that you're gonna fight along with all these different action boards that you can tailor with every game whether it's a specific scenario or just mixing and matching wow this game has a lot going on there and wow do i love it it's such a cool unique game there's no other game like it the card crafting mechanic is fun already and you're forced to do it every turn so you're always getting to craft something but then the cards go into a communal deck and into a tableau row where it's possible that other players could use the cards that you've made yes you get some money for them doing it but maybe you want the card to use so it's a bit annoying that you've made it so good that your opponents keep nicking it so you have to keep adapting to what's there and craft different cards make them make a little less tempting focus

on the strategy that your opponents aren't gunning for so they won't necessarily take your card but then sometimes you want them to take your card because you'll get it back eventually and you'll be able to use it not to mention you'll get a bit of cash so it's a weird balance to get into play but it's definitely a bit over produced i mean you do have a huge box with this weird cube tower that has three cards put on it you drop cubes in it and depending on when the colors come out and how quant what quantity they're in represents which monster attacks you although it is clever that the reverse side of the advancements that you put in the cards to craft them represents the monster that could potentially attack you it's got a decent theme and even though the story behind all the scenarios is not particularly gripping or really anything you care about the fact that you can have all these different locations like 20 plus locations and the base set and then with the expansions you can go out into like desert lands a frost haven type thing and the newest one i think is going to be a very druidic style one that i've kick-started the uh what's it called i can't remember if it's all the wild or something but whatever you know there's three expansions of this game so i've got a lot of content for this game already and more on the way it's definitely not an easy game to get into but it has a wonderfully good well-implemented solo mode if you want to play only solo and certainly with two or three players it's an absolute blast it's gonna be pretty long fiddly with four though i do say i would rather play this at free cat but honestly i'd quite enjoy playing it solo it's got a really good mode for it allowing you to try out

all these different combos or locations and that a really cool unique game definitely a niche one though my was it my number 45 edge of darkness my number 34 has risen 15 places from 49 and a lot of that has come down to the days of the siege campaign that i've played for this yeah you know it it's this war of mine this war of mine is one of the best story driven games i have played it is wonderfully gritty and dark and miserable which doesn't sound like something that should be high praised right now honestly this one is just really represents that kind of war-torn civilian-type setting you know like you're not involved in the war itself that's going on it's the fact that you're dealing with the ramifications of said war surviving scrounging for food and supplies just to get a bit of water to feed yourself the next day keeping your morale up because if you get too miserable you just end up going out and committing suicide or doing something insanely nasty it's really dark especially with the days of the siege campaign and that's why this has risen because i played through that campaign it's an expansion check out my beyond the base game video if you want to find out more but it's one of the best campaigns i've ever played it changes the rule set to introduce new elements while keeping some of the old stuff intact but the story that you play for it is again gripping it's intense the choices you make have major ramifications so i could

play through this night many different times and come up with all sorts of different story elements i never found and you get so invested in the characters you want them to survive you want that orphanage to do well and you put all your effort into keeping your orphanage going only for it to then go south at the end it's like oh god it's painful you know again i go into this in more detail in my review but i just think the the only thing that lets this one down is that i wish it probably had some app implementation you know it could really use something not like for just the story element that's fine i think there is actually an app for the story element i mean to handle maybe some of the fiddliness that the game does have but it's got a very good tutorial book to get you into the game it's definitely hard as nails like this thing is gonna beat you down relentlessly but you throw on the this war of mine soundtrack from the pc game and play this with like two or three survivors maybe one of the scenario sheets in the first expansion and you're in with one of the most immersive board games that exists on the planet it is that great for immersion it's dark it's gritty it's depressing at times you gotta be comfortable with that setting if you want something that's a bit more happy-go-lucky thing this is not the game for you trust me on that fact but if you want something dark there's very few games that you can get that's better than this one i already mentioned i think tainted grail a while back this is the other one in that dark lineup of games that for some reason i just get a kick out of what's that say about me i don't know

i'm generally a happy person maybe i just like a dark setting to balance it out a bit i have no idea they just tend to make for much more interesting stories this war of mine sitting very well now at number 34. my number 33 has dropped eight places in 25 doesn't get as many plays as it used to but i still really adore this game and this is my favorite of the mind clash games if anything lets it down at the moment it's probably a little bit too convoluted for its own good once you start throwing in all the expansion stuff you know fractures of time was a great expansion for it but all the extra stuff on top of that it's like okay seriously the game's got enough going on as it is of course it's an acronym anachrony from david tercy is my favorite of mine clashes games this represents time travel so well i cannot believe that it's so hard to get time travel right but this one does it you essentially are preparing for a meteorite that's going to hit you like i say this is one of the most immersive euros in terms of a theme here as well you're preparing for a meteorite that's going to hit you're planning for the evacuation but you want to be the faction that kind of rises out of the ashes and takes over once everything goes on you know when it's going to hit so you're prepping for it you're getting buildings you're getting employees to like work those buildings to get your resources you're preparing for the evacuation you're researching big mega projects but also it's got the most wonderful concept of a debt system ever you essentially can go back in time because everybody's got you know time travel technology but

it's a little messy it causes paradoxes and you might be in trouble if you're not careful but if you miss out on a time when you could make a specific project you can go back in time and go make it then but in doing so what you can also do is get resources from yourself in the future i need some water or a mech or some like crystal this round so i'm gonna basically get it from myself in the future so hey this round i've got some extra crystals but at some point in the future unless you want the timeline to screw you over you have to then go back in time in order to actually pay yourself the crystal back how could i have been unthought in the 90s and traveled back to oh no i've gone cross-eyed i've never seen time travel theme done so well like that it's wonderfully clever it's wonderfully thematic and you can throw in as many different time travel movie references as you can it's difficult not to quote something from back to the future when you're playing this game it's very heavy it's got a lot of rules it's got all sorts of modules that complicate the game you inferior that i will refuse to use because frankly it's too complicated as it is already yeah not too complicated but it's very complicated fractures of time is a great addition which again makes it even more complicated but really does add a cool like thematic element to it and i certainly would like to use it in every game i play but yeah i'm pulling this out with very specific people because of how involved it is it's a table hog but it's a great thematic euro and i think

this must have appeared on both our lists for the top 10 female games formatic euro games that paul grogan and i did i think we both had this on our list because it is wonderfully thematic as i say as i've been raving about definitely want to get if you are a heavy euro games fan but want a bit of theme that is inaccurate my number 32 one spot from 33 it's gained wow it's slowly rising up although i'll be interested to see if the cold war expansion for this is going to make it go higher or keep it about the same and it will just drop this is the manhattan project energy empire which is the one of the three games that have been released in this line that i put my stock behind i like manhattan project sort of i wasn't a big fan of two minutes to midnight this one though it definitely feels like a spin-off outside of the range is definitely a fantastic game though the rule set for what is a mid-weight euros is very streamlined so smooth it doesn't feel like it's got clunky moving parts you essentially are building power plants to get energy to build buildings that can get you points or trigger off various effects but using certain power plants generates pollution on your little mini-map so air land and sea you could get pollution or even nuclear waste and you gotta clean up or else i'll turn you into a tree or otherwise lose points you're trying to uh like kind of please the united nations with various resources different events can happen

that can score you points in different ways but also throw some good and bad effects on the game but everything's just really smooth acquiring the buildings from three different sections is easy to do getting the power plants with these cool custom dice you know do i want to get water do i want to get hydro power or solar power it doesn't give me much energy to use on the buildings but it's clean it's reliable or do i go for the full nuclear waste die which costs a bit more to build it gets me a ton of power but is almost certainly going to generate me nuclear waste on a regular basis that i've got to clean up top that with the worker placement aspect of putting the dynamic way of doing things where you put your workers out it blocks people potentially but then you recover your workers when you want to so you know i might decide i'm going to recover them at this turn you're you're putting yours out waiting for someone to hurry up and get off that spot they then do you jump on it after they do dwellings of eldervale uses the when it's downstairs uses the exact same style mechanic this is kind of luke laurie schtick really you know it's even in whistle mountain another game that he's done which uses a similar style of dynamic worker placement it works great this is definitely one of one of the best midweight euro games that i've played it's just i don't know for something that could have been really clunky it's so smooth with a fantastic rulebook to boot now the expansion unfortunately minion games went out of business so i don't know if you're ever going to get this game and you know the expansion had to be picked up by i think grail games or someone else in order to actually publish it i have got that on kickstarter so i am definitely going to

get that expansion lord knows when but it'll be interesting to see what it adds i definitely want to see if it can add something to make the game even better but who knows we'll have to wait and see even without that though 32 it's still high it's a 10 out of 10 euro fantastic if you get a chance to pick this up off a bring and buy or a second hand sale i definitely recommend you do manhattan project energy empire my number 31 has dropped 18 places from 13 it used to be and it was pretty high i still love this game though the main problem is that it's difficult to get it to the table it's a big giant box full of farming urinary goodness this is my favorite uri rosenberg game and i've had to double check my tablet three times now to make certain that i don't make a mistake on that claim but i'm pretty certain this is my favorite uri rosenberg game that is fields of arl i love caverna agriculture i give respect to but i'm not the biggest fan of its restrictiveness but if you want the most sandbox euro game on the planet you get fields of all with tea and trade expansion you can play it with three players because normally it's only a one or two player game frankly i'll play it with three players and i like it with two but i'm mainly playing the solo because it's just i love sandbox games and this is all that farming goodness theme wise from the other games but turned up to 15. it's ridiculous i mean let me put this down for a second i could illustrate right so you can get animals you can farm peat you can

dehydrate your more so that you can build like extend the dikes out to the coast you can farm wheat and read and stuff like and flax and things like that you can build buildings you can go make clothing of three different types you can go trade with the local villages you know give them supplies for points let's include the expansion of it all right you can go export to various other countries i can bake bread i can uh build sheds i can get animals i can have my pigs and cows and horses on my field you know what i could just stockpile for the winter you know what everything's got a tool that makes the action better on the worker placement board so i could upgrade the tools you know my axe is not particularly good at the start of the game but if i upgrade yanks it now gets me more wood maybe i'll just spend the whole game getting all my tools up to spot it is ridiculous the amount of stuff you can do in this game and with the tea in trade you have tea as a resource that again can be points everything it's a point salad through and through you can get half points for various stuff i have won this game against other players by half a point it does happen but it feels rewarding when you play it it feels like wonderfully formatic you can have a completely different strategy every single game without fail and you probably will never try the same exact thing twice at least not for a considerable length of time it's a big box it's got a lot of rules in it and it certainly is not one that will hit the table often even in a solo mode because

of just how much there is which is why it's dropped a bit from my 13 but it's no contest now i was kind of contemplating is it this one like a burner i prefer more it's no it's no contest anymore it's fields of art it is my favorite uri rosenberg farming game in existence it is sandboxy it is like i said it's point salad is that even a word i don't know i'm rambling now all i can say is if this is your type of game and you've not tried it definitely give this one a shot all the farming goodness you could get in a euro game fields of art wow it's alright now and even my chest is dying away from up all the time huh i'm getting old 30 to 21 is next and again no debuts on the 30 to 21 so that'll be 10 more games that you've heard of will they be as much of a mix of standees high risers and folders as this one we'll have to see but ah you if you're seeing me go on a high when i talk about these games now as if i wasn't before it's because they're getting better and better these are all games i rate a 10. these are games i adore at this point like these are benchmarks for designers and publishers and genres like i'm thinking hmm i need like the best that minion games ever made well here's energy empire i need the best of ue rosenberg's work it's fields of all we're getting into those ones that i just hold as legendary status even if they have flaws you know no game is ever perfect they're just ones that i can spend all day just raving about to people and lose control of my own life there my own mouth

faculties in order to get my point across they're just such good fun games and hopefully you're enjoying me raving like a schoolgirl about it so uh you know three more videos you've got plenty more yet do you like or dislike these games do you have any tips to enhance my enjoyment or someone else's leave it in the comments it's really interesting to read the stuff that you have there and to see how your tastes align with mine if you enjoyed this video please remember to leave a thumbs up though it means the world to me to know that you appreciate the content that i'm putting out as it really does take up a lot of time particularly the top 100 don't forget that the channel is unofficially sponsored by satu.co.uk and if you want to see some different content on the channel you can check out the latest podcast where i go on a bit of a rant about the june board game or you can check out the recent detail review i did a descent legends of the dark the big humongous game from fantasy flight a bit late to the party but hopefully the opinion still stands take care and remember as always it's only a game bye for now love you all

Progress saved