How to Get Personalized Reviews and Recommendations on BoardGameGeek
Transcript
hey I'm Ryan and this is rolls in the family and if you're watching this there's a good chance that you like board games and if you like board games there's also a good chance that you may spend some time on the internet looking into board game reviews trying to figure out what's the next game you should get what's going to be your next favorite game of all time and one of the challenges you might find in this process is that all of the reviewers on the internet have very different tastes in games and the weight of their review for you personally is really dependent on how much their tastes align with your taste you might see somebody that really dislikes a game but you see that they all the games they like and dislike don't match up with you so that doesn't really mean a whole lot for you personally so it can be a little difficult as you kind of start to learn which reviewers you align more with and kind of trying to gather the information that's a little bit more personalized for you to make decision wouldn't it be nice if you had a way to for a given game you're looking into see a list of review feedback that is curated to people that have similar tastes in games to yourself so that you really are getting you know applicable uh information about whether this is a good game for you well I am here to tell you how to do exactly that using um a feature in Board Game Geek it's utilizing the geek buddy feature and I think it might just be the most underrated feature on Board Game Geek no
clickbait here I actually do think that there's a lot of people that maybe don't know what you can kind of do with this feature um and I found it to be very very helpful for myself so I'm going to kind of walk through what my process has been for kind of building up this tool that then I can use to get that personalized kind of review feedback but let's back up a second because maybe you're watching this and you're like I've never even heard of board games geek um so I have it pulled up here Board Game Geek at its heart is like the most popular board game Centric website database you can think of it similar to a site like um IMDb for movies or any of these sites that like uh are a database of a lot of things so like all these board games are in the system but then it has a lot of user generated content and that's really where Board Game Geek thrives is it got popular you know it started way back in the early 2000s really gained the popularity um and got a lot of user contribution whether that's in reviews or answering questions or in the forums like if you go into any given game on Board Game Geek and look in the kind of forms and stuff of that game it's very populated with valuable information and that's really what elevates the site to be um hugely powerful is just the wealth of information that has been collected there over the years um and so I highly recommend it as a resource generally speaking um for board games um but I'm going to walk through um kind of the
process for building up this system of geek buddies that will allow you to get this personalized feedback and I actually created a new rolles in the family account so that I could kind of do this from scratch instead of using my own account and that is the first thing that you want to make sure that you'll have done is you'll need to make an account on Board Game Geek um one thing that's kind of interesting with Board Game Geek when you make an account you'll notice something like you won't be able to add a profile picture an avatar and that's because Board Game Geek actually uh well there's a few features that they kind of like they make you work for it a little bit but they kind of have a currency on the website called geek gold and you need a certain amount of geek gold to actually purchase your avatar to be able to do that and then you can get other things on the site like micro badges or tip people's comments with gate gold it's just kind of like this internal currency I will say if you are making a new account I have uh my account and Daniel's account linked down in the uh description below go ahead and just send me a message on Board Game Geek and I will send you some geek gold and you can get yourself an avatar um you know we want to help our roles in the family viewers out be able to get their identity on the website slash I've just amass more geek gold than I know what to do with over the last 15 years so I have no problem sending you some if you send me a message once you have your account though um let's kind of walk through the steps and and just at a high level we're going to kind of go through this process of first building up a list of geek buddies and specifically geek buddies that um we think have similar tastes in
games to us now you might hear geek buddy and think like what is this Facebook for board games and that maybe honestly I think why some people maybe haven't explored this feature as much as they're like I'm not looking to Social Network on my board game research site um but there's some very powerful things that you're able to do with this geek buddy list as we'll then follow up after that with so what I would recommend is starting out by thinking what is your favorite board game of all time hopefully there's a game that comes to mind for you or a game you just really really like and you're going to look that up here on Board Game Geek so in my case if you know if you know me well you know that I'm probably going to say Agricola is the one that I would first think of classic um and so I'm going to go to the game page here and I'm going to go down to the ratings tab so we're going to click into that which you can see lots and lots of people have rated this game we can actually see 74,000 ratings and 14,000 comments on agria and here I am going to click on the 10 bar graph here to sort specifically by people that have rated it a 10 or a 9.5 or 10 um so this already is pushing me towards people that have a similar opinion of Agricola to me we're going to filter this further though by going to this comments drop down and going to has comments so now we got people that have rated it extremely highly but also filled in the comment field because Board Game Geek allows people alongside their kind of reading to add any comments here and this is where this gets really powerful is there's a lot of users that use that
comment box to put their thoughts on the game sometimes to borderline huge review length comments of their thoughts on the game and that's really what we're going to try to lean into here we are trying to find people that have similar tasting games that rate a lot of games and rate new newer games like are still active um and that leave really useful valuable comments on a lot of their entries so what I would usually do here and I'm going to do a much a bridged version here is I would scroll through here and every time I see a comment that like feels valuable you know it's like okay like you know this one he's got some information here this is a nice comment uh this one maybe you know there's some of these if I was really doing this I'd probably be more aggressive of um just opening a bunch of them you know I'm just I'm on a Mac so I'm just doing command click to just open tabs um of all these different users and so um I'm just going to do a few examples here but you really would want to be doing a lot of them so that you can try to find as many as possible and then for each of these users you're going to go into their profile and you're going to check a few things the first thing I would check is I would scroll down and I would see how many board games have they rated overall in this case this person has only rated 33 games and so that's probably lower than the threshold I would recommend I'm usually looking for people at minimum of rated a 100 games just because the value in this is going to be them having rated more things that
we're maybe interested in looking at so I would pass on this one now I would look at the next one I'd scroll down 43 games again probably not enough um to justify me adding them and you can be as picky or as not picky as you want here but um I found that being a little bit picky you can still usually find enough um ones that are good picks so here I like what I see 313 board games I like the nice bell curve distribution it shows that this user kind of you know if I see somebody that's like almost all their ratings are tens or something it's like well that's probably not um going to be as valuable and so the next thing I'm going to do is I'm going to click into these ratings which you can do by just clicking that number and I'm going to sort by their highest rated so we know they love Agricola cuz that's how we found them but what I now want to see is do we align generally on other games now you're not going to align on everything like it's it's different individuals but you're looking first I would look through the highly rated ones and be like do I see ones that are like ooh that's one so for example for me personally I see teror Mars here I'm like I love terraform Mars that already is another sign that we're kind of maybe aligned in our taste Through the Ages is a game I really enjoy underwater cities is a game I really enjoy so I'm liking what I'm seeing here and there's nothing up here that's like a oh I really don't like that game and they're rating it really highly so then the next thing I do is I go down probably to like their four ratings um about and I just look for any like no goes like if there would be a game down here that's one of my
favorite games or a game I really love that might make me question if this person aligns with my taste as much um so I kind of look at these low ones he actually this is a game I also rate very lowly so that's another sign of alignment um and I don't see anything here that really would uh cons conc ER me about how we align and so that has now passed all of my filters for whether this person would make a good addition to my geek buddy list and so I'm going to go back um to this page and on their profile there's this little arrow they kind of hide this feature here there's this arrow that you can drop down some actions on that user and there's an option to add geek buddy so we're going to do that and we're going to click yes um successfully added to our geek buddy list and so we would continue that like I said I'm just doing a couple examples here um this person 683 games love to see it um really good comments lots of plays I'm a fan of ter mytica Feast for Odin and so you're going through this process just individually evaluating you know is this going to be someone kind of how you want to be thinking about it and especially with the comments is like if I was looking into a game like this would would a comment like this be like valuable you know cuz if it's coming from somebody that aligns with your taste that's going to um give you some good information so let's go back and add this one as well so I have already
before recording this added a bunch of geek buddies on this to kind of get ahead to prep for filming um and so you can see if I go to my geek buddies in the drop down here um if I click edit I can see all my geek Buddies here look at all these geek buddies and really more is going to be better um I think here let's actually look if I go to my profile and I go to geek stuff we can see that I have 83 geek buddies now eded on this count I think on my main account I have like 170 something um and that's what I actually you know use for this I think you really would want to be up closer to that it it's just going to make the feature more powerful the more good quality geek buddies that you're able to add and it's something you can come back and you know like I'm going to spend uh you know 20 minutes just trying to beef up my geek buddy list a little bit um is going to going to pay off but once we have done this so say you know you've built up your close to 100 geek buddies that you've curated um I I use the example of AG Grio as being like one of my favorite games what I would recommend after that is like go to your second favorite game and do the same process there then I would say pick a game that you really love that's pretty different from those games so in my case I did a grickle and terraforming Mars first and those are both pretty kind of like Euro game strategy games they're kind of in a similar space but another game I really love is Elder chorer which is a three-hour Cooperative highly
thematic very random kind of role playing dice chucking it's the type of game that there's a lot of people that love Ag griol and tering Mars that would hate Elder Tor and so I want to look up Elder Tor because I want to represent that piece in my taste and people and especially when I find people that rate something like that highly and rate things like Agri or some of these other games I like highly it's like okay we we have a similar uh taste kind of across these very different types of games so kidding on on different genres that you really enjoy is going to be helpful for rounding out your geek buddies and then the other thing I would do is think of what's a really new game that you've enjoyed so when I was doing my example I recently played slay of the Spire the board game really really enjoyed it and so I went through the process same process with that game and the reason for doing that is everybody that's raided slay the SPID of the board game which came out like within the last year is clearly kind of G to playing a lot of new games I mean not necessarily a lot of new games but you want to find people that um are playing new releases and leaving this feedback on it cuz that's going to allow you to have information about newer releases which is often a way that I use this list but once you have it all finished let's actually look at how you're going to use this um to get value out of it so if I navigate back here to my geek buddies section you'll notice that way to the right there is a ratings link so let's click on that um might take a bit to load here
but this is essentially kind of like how you would look at board game Geeks top 100 and it's the aggregated top games of everybody on the site here I can kind of get that view but just through the filter of my geek buddies which I've already identified as being similar in taste to me um so the default view here doesn't have a minimum number of Raiders so obviously there's tons of things that people have rated a 10 that it's only one of my geek buddies has done and it's like you know maybe more obscure or just not a lot of people have played it so what I would recommend and it's going to depend on how many geek buddies you added total to be how much you could kind of drive this up um but let's say like 25 minimum Raiders like I only want to look at games that at least 25 of my geek buddies have raid did um and then you can do ones that you don't own that would be looking at like if you actually use board game Geeks collection feature to Mark what you've own and haven't rated now on this particular example account I haven't owned or rated any games so this is doing absolutely nothing for my filter um but you have those options and then you can click go and what this is going to do is give me a list a ranked list by rating of the highest rated games among my geek buddies that have at least 25 ratings so obviously it makes sense that AG gria is way up on here because that was one of the ways that I drove the game interesting to see Gaia project so high up a nine out of 10 with 38 ratings I do really love Gia project I ended up um selling it and replacing it with age of
innovation which is 95% the same game but if I hadn't played it this would have been an excellent recommendation for me I really enjoy brass I really enjoy arcova so I can just looking at this it the it I can see that it aligns with my taste strongly um and obviously if I was actually doing this on my account where I've added games into my collection and rated them those ones wouldn't be showing up because I've already played them but if I scroll down here Liz booa is actually the first example of one that I haven't played and so what this tells me is like man Liz booa might be one that I want to check out like it it seems like people like me really like this game and so the next thing you can do is over in this column there's an analyze button and if I click that it is now going to give me all of the ratings and comments for all my geek buddies that have rid this game and so this is where you are getting kind of what I described in the intro of this personalized list of review like feedback on this game and so I can kind of read through these I mean these are people rating at 10 out of 10 you know what kind of information and you'll see that depending on how the types of people you've added in you'll get people that are putting a lot of information in there you know a lot of it's really valuable stuff um because you already know that you know you're at least similar taste to this person um and so you can kind of scroll down and see all the high ratings oftentimes it's very nice to look at the people that don't rate it so highly and kind of why Why
didn't it work for them I mean here it's pretty strong we're not even seeing anything below a six um but you know another one like let's say Ark Nova is a kind of new game it's a game I enjoy but if I was looking for that i' you know 10 out of 10 scratches that terraforming Mars it well I love terraforming Mars um you can kind of look through these and it's it's you're not always going to have comments on everyone but if you've built up a good list you for most games will probably have a good amount of personalized information and I mean look at things like this this is a hugely valuable uh amount of feedback on a game to be able to kind of better understand if it is a fit for you so that's really now the tool that you have at your disposal you know you can kind of go through that ratings view to kind of just get a list of maybe find out about games you didn't even know about and then read about them um but then you have this analyze feature and the analyze feature is actually built into every game page so let's say for example that I um wanted to look up like a new game so for example a game a very new game that I have had my eye on is seti search for for uh extraterrestrial intelligence and this is a very new game um you'll see much fewer ratings here but you'll see this geek buddy analysis link right next to ratings and comments clicking that drops me straight into this view where I'm going to see my geek buddies um information on this game now this is a very new game so we're probably not going to have very much
we've got a few ratings here but the little bit I do have says man they're really love I mean 8.75 we've got 9998 um and this person seem to have absolutely loved it um kind of talks about quick actions but full of combos that's all stuff that makes me go oo I think this is definitely a game that I should keep an eye on and so this is something I have used a lot honestly since I've set it up whether it's with new games that I'm checking out I often am looking into you know so many games have come out over the last 20 years I haven't played a lot of them so a lot of times I'm looking back at a game from 2010 that oh this one actually I wonder if this is one I want to try and I usually have a lot of feedback to go off in here so I am curious that's basically it kind of the offering I I definitely recommend going back and trying to grow that geek buddy whis because it's just going to make it more and more valuable um I'm curious if anybody watching this does this already like how underrated is this feature maybe everybody's already doing it I'm just making an assumption here but I have a feeling that even some people that have been using Board Game Geek for a long time might have not kind of known how you could use the geek buddy feature to get this kind of feedback hey thanks for watching if you found this helpful thumbs up the video maybe subscribe to the channel for more board gaming content like I said we have links down below to board game geek to my profile on Board Game Geek I I'll get you some geek gold if you ask for it um
otherwise we've got some other videos here you can check out on the channel and we will see you in the next one