Games I got rid of June 2019
Transcript
Kia Ora and welcome to the games i got rid of in the first half of 2019 one of the side effects of reviewing so many games i've been doing over the last year and a bit is i keep getting more and more games turning up unfortunately the place where I have all my games my shelves don't get any bigger so more games come in some games have to go out and these videos are to explain the rationale about why some of those games left my collection some times its because I really really hated them some it's because there are just better games and do the same thing and others because they were ok games but ok games just don't cut it anymore so sit back relax and enjoy my takes on why I got rid of these dozen games it was raining outside the rain rained heavily and rained down Rainily on the rain-soaked Street I got out of my car and stepped into the rain across the street and got into the elevator and took it up to the top floor the sergeant was there to greet me he offered me a chair and gave me a doughnut and coffee it was raining I said to him we really need to solve this case and he agreed and offered me a doughnuts of coffee I then got in the elevator and took it upstairs in the rain the donut offered me a seat and the coffee said to me we need to solve this case in the rain massage would put my chair in the elevator and we took it in the rain to the coffee the coffee stepped out of the elevator and turned to the sergeant and said the donut needs to solve this case we then entered a 16 digit number into the computer detective a modern crime board game might be the most disappointing game I've played in a very very long time I was incredibly amped for this game I loved the Sherlock Holmes games I loved murder mysteries I loved
criminology I'm one of those people who watches crime show documentaries incessantly my father was an investigator and when I was growing up I used to go on my school holidays with him up and down the country conducting investigations so I've always had an interest in police work criminology forensics and the investigations process and I was like wow finally this will be the ballgame for me and it just wasn't the game fell completely flat with me and my partner and we just couldn't get over the dialogue we couldn't get over the writing we couldn't get over how stilted and repetitive everything was in the game so what was billed to me is a fantastic detective just felt like busywork it felt like drudge work it felt like repetition and the sitting was weird you like some elite crime unit but you're investigating a theft from 70 years ago it was just odd an odd choice for a first story to bring you into the game is to investigate a cold case from World War two so yeah I traded this one away almost immediately it's very rare but I trade away a game after only playing at once but yeah detective that was one of them next up for those of you aren't aware our gale force nine has recently got the rights to the Dune board game they're going to be reprinting Dune for the first time and well nearly as long as I've been alive this this is an old game it's been out of print forever it's one of the Holy Grails of board game collecting and while this game had been remade as Rex from Fantasy Flight Games the sitting never quite worked as well as it did with the June setting and I would find myself explaining the factions within Rex using their Dune types so I say I am these
guys are the be together at or these guys are the Fremen because unless you're a big Twilight Imperium fan you don't know what these factions still what they're about so with the announcement of the Dune reprint very happy to get rid of bricks hopefully the person who gets it really enjoys it because actually a very good game it's a very solid game it's just not Dune next up is a game I was really amped to try it because it had a whole bunch of mechanics that I thought worked really nicely together it had a little bit of everything it had auctions it had bidding on things it had area control and deck building all built into one game and I thought wow this would be this we need it so it's gang warfare game it's city of remnants and sometimes the some of the game is not greater than its parts individually these systems seem really well but you put them all together and it's just a mess it's just a mess of a game city remnants just doesn't deliver on its promise of being this intricate gang building area control game it's just messy and the developers even know that because they rereleased the game in a streamlined version called neon gods and that's still not very good yeah we played it a couple of times about five years ago and it just hasn't got back to the table ever since so I put it on a tray table at wellyCon and someone picked it up for about 20 New Zealand Dollars mixed ups actually a pretty good game it's Android infiltration this is a pushy luck game where you're conducting a heist busting into a complex and try to make it out live as much loot as you can carry before the alarms go off and you're all captured so there's a cooperative element to it there's a competitive element to it and is a push your luck element to it and we legitimately
enjoyed playing this a couple of times six years ago and it's just sat there ever since and whenever we look across the shelf no one ever went our infiltration let's play that one again so after five or six years of not being played it's simply taking up shelf space at that point so again I put this on a tray table at well econ someone picked it up and I'd even sleeves the damn thing and it's got these wonderfully big taro sized cards that that look gorgeous and it's not really a case of wanting to get rid of the game here it's just the fact no one wanted the plants so how'd it win next up is a game I reviewed quite recently and that is between two castles of Mad King Ludwig this one's going out for two reasons the first of which is I really like between two cities and I've got the expansion for that and I just don't know when one would get playing over the other and when you've got two games occupying such a similar space you kind of have to pick which one do you like which one do you like less and that one has to go and the second thing is one of the people of my regular group has rather poor eyesight and literally cannot play the game keeping that game around bring it out on game night he's like I can't see the icons I can't actually play and that's kind of a terrible thing to have sitting on your shelf between 2 cities love that game it's still one of my top twenty or so games in my collection I absolutely endorse and adore it between two castles of Mad King Ludwig I really don't think I needed it in the collection not saying it's a bad game it's just I really like between two cities I don't need both then we have Mission Red Planet's now missing two planets a pretty good area control game it's it's light it's pretty easy to teach and I've got quite a few
area control games that by a disposal including Tammany Hall El grande and eventually Galilean moons if he gets his acid to Garen actually puts that on Kickstarter which I've been waiting for for nearly a year now I've seriously enjoyed playing Galilean moons when I got to play with the prototype and he still hasn't put it on Kickstarter so get to it yeah mission Red Planet not a bad game just taking up space no one really wanted to play it that much and I just put it on the table well econ so I'm picked it up to 20 bucks next up we have Megaland and so this is the second push your luck game I've got rid of because my group apparently doesn't enjoy push your luck games Megaland is fine for what it is and that's an easily accessible short playtime push your luck game you can set up play and be done in 15 minutes most of my groups don't want to play that kind of game and because it really doesn't have any solo value it's not much point keeping it interestingly enough I gave this one away to someone who was really interested in getting a copy and that's a Sam MacDonald the designer of architects of the West Kingdom so it was like oh my god I wouldn't mind grabbing your copy of mega land up you serve off to him it went so if the next game on the West Kingdom Series turns out to be a dinky push your luck game you can blame me please don't then we have planet steam a game I got in an 80% off sale what's an eighty percent off sale you ask well that's when a company goes completely bankrupt and they have to sell all their stock to a shady online distributor who then on sells at the peanuts so I paid 16 New Zealand dollars for planet steam which is around about at the time seven or eight US dollars and I thought that was
a really good deal and I brought it home and I was like ah who wants to play this but sat on my shelf for three years with me going oh here's three or four games we can play this week which one do you want to play and planets team never got picked not once and maybe I could have made a harder case for getting it on the table and maybe I've missed something here with planet steam but three years no plays no takers yeah what are you gonna do it's just gotta get sent on and I ended up selling that for 10 bucks I made $2 profit on this and that is how you make money off board game media is buying games that 80% off and then selling them for $10 or I could do paid previews I guess anyway moving right along to a game that no one who watches the channel or pays attention to the channel will be shocked about and that is Arkham Horror 3rd edition and again Arkham Horror 3rd edition is not a bad game it's actually a pretty good game if you're the kind of person who enjoys what Arkham 3 is I am an ahkam horror to that I loved Arkham Horror - I have everything for arkham 2- I didn't need Arkham 3 other people did like don't get me wrong the game needed to be made and to be sold and needed to introduce a whole new group of people to the alcohol franchise but when you've got a game without expansions you don't need a new one unless it's really really really really really better arkham threes different arkham threes got its own character its own flavor but personally for me I don't think it's better one of the fascinating things about reviewing Arkham 3 was that it prompted me to do
this very long video on Arkham 2 in addition where I interviewed the designers of Arkham one two and three and got their comments and incorporated that into a long-form video and that really crystallized for me how much I enjoyed up in second edition how important a game that was to me and why is absolutely no need for me to replace it in my collection I think that's a bit of advice to keep in mind just because there's a new edition doesn't mean that editions going to be better for you new doesn't mean better for everyone so if you do have an old edition of the game you prefer to the current edition there's nothing wrong with that and then we move on to two games that I'm getting rid of not because they are bad games at all but because they are good games and by good I mean they're perfectly serviceable games they're fun they're okay but shelf space is just a premium and those two games are far light and Klondike rush both these games suffer from the same problem in that while playing them I enjoyed the game I thought it was fun there were good decisions to be made they were enjoyable but when we were done I didn't think about them again and I think about bad games after I played them and what could be done better and I think about great games and what I could do next time good games that are just ok they're just they're solid leave me in this weird space from like ok I've played that and that's about the level of engagement so yeah I played those games I had fun doing it I've passed them on to other people who will enjoy them more than I will most likely but I can't rip on those games because there's nothing fundamentally
bad about them so they're in a bit of a weird gray space for me the good but not great and also not memorable games and finally we have a game that I traded away the day I published a review of it and that is Batman Gotham City chronicles so Batman's not a bad game I'd actually play it again anytime I've really enjoyed playing it again and I traded it to a friend of mine who was one of the testers for the video or some other board games that I'm gonna put on the channel so off him I got a vengeance Kickstarter Edition and museum Kickstarter Edition in trade but the simple fact is this game takes up so much damn space it takes something that same space as six other games and while I would have liked to have kept it I couldn't find five or six games to get rid of to justify keeping this one game and that's a curious logistics about these big Kickstarter games like I've got Lords of Helles I've got gloom Haven and I've got the starter box for C'thulhu wars these take up huge amounts of space and the room I have is only so big my shelves are only so big I can't just stop power board games in the corridor like some kind of hoarder as much as I am tempted to then trust me I'm tempted to a time so just keep games but you've got to make a hard call and I enjoyed playing Batman I enjoyed it a lot and I'd gladly play it with Conan who's picked the game up off me yeah the guy who picked up the game of Batman off nice named Conan and Batman is a remake of Conan it's just one of those weird coincidences getting a lot of games as something I've done for a very long time
and it's becoming a bit of an occupational hazard when you're reviewing games because you know I'm putting up one to two videos a week on different games so in order to keep up I'm getting one to two games a week that's one or two games that I'm having to find storage space for all once or two games I'm having to on sale or trade to people it also means every game gets added to collection there's another one you have to choose from when it comes to game night so if you've got 30 games in your collection and you play once a week and you get through two games a night you'll get through those games four times a year if you've got 200 games on your shelves and you game once a week and you get through to a night it's gonna take you two years to get through that so at some point a collection becomes unmanageable or unplayable now my collection is a little odd because a lot of my stuff is so lovable or two-player which means I can get to it a lot more than my two regular game nights a week but there's a danger in this hobby of overloading yourself with cardboard and for the first time in a very long time I actually have a of shame I always prided myself on getting a game and playing it live in the first week or so I now have games that I've had for months that I haven't been able to get to yet simply because of the demands of a channel and work I have some damn good looking games on that shelf of shame as well and I'm probably gonna do a video on that in the coming days so I think I'll leave you with one final thought on this and that is if you're looking to buy a game ask yourself am I actually going to be able to play this anytime in the future I mean your goal might be I want to buy a whole bunch of games for retirement and that's fine that's a that's an admirable goal but if you're slapping down 200 us
on a Kickstarter campaign that will take a hundred hours of play and you've already got six of those on your shelf that you haven't got to yet ask yourself why the hell am i doing this I mean I run a YouTube channel that reviews board games so I will eventually get through all the games I have and I will put them on the channel so operating a high level of churn is kind of understandable in my position but I worry that for some people the gating is more important than they're having and that's kind of troubling to me I don't want to feel like my channel is part of a machine that is encouraging people to buy things they don't need or they don't really want and that's why I want to keep doing these videos to tell people that it's okay to get rid of some games it's okay not to have everything in your collection it's okay for another friend of yours to own a game and for you to borrow it off them if you want to play there's literally no need to have a thousand unplayed board games sitting in your garage and if you enjoyed this video like it subscribe to the channel and check out our patreon