Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 14

Transcript 14:46

hi everyone and welcome to another edition of games i got rid of and why so this is a series of videos where i talk about games that have previously been in my collection but for one reason or another are no longer in my collection and i'll try give some rationale to why i came to that decision before i get to the 10 games i'm talking about today i want to give a shout out to kianda code at uk who sponsored the show um if you live in the uk and you regularly pick up board games be sure to check out their great website but let's get on with the episode so first off the game i'm going to talk about first is glass road by uber rosenberg now i will say straight up this is probably one of my favorite uv's that i played to date i have some really cool ideas here um as you are playing these cards from your hand but if you play the same card as somebody else then you don't get as strong as an ability and additionally i had a very cool way of gaining resources where you'd have these these resource wheels and if you'd gather a number of certain resources then you could automatically produce another resource and that became a real interesting decision because sometimes you didn't want to create those other resources so you had to manage it quite carefully and then you'd be picking up these tiles adding it to your board gathering resources converting resources into others and i think you know despite liking a lot about this game and i still do recommend it it's got my shield of quality just about um i do think that the thing i didn't like about the game was how small it felt so this is a game of very few points it feels like you're doing a lot of work for little in return you know low scoring game i generally

like games that shower you more in points you know maybe it's a psychological thing i don't know but after a few games of this one i felt like you know i've seen everything i enjoyed it but i'm not really got that big hook to go back to it because again it just felt a bit too small for what it was so it's a weird one because it's kind of like a full-size game but didn't quite feel like it but a good game nonetheless but not quite collection worthy so that is glass road the second game i'm going to talk about is a game you've probably never heard of called monstar this is by mega corpin who famously designed scandalous and awkward guests but this one is a very small box card game with quite a weird theme as you are trying to um or secretly got the control of certain type of monster in this kind of b movie setting and you have this grid of cards out and you're basically trying to slide these cards to consume other ones if you have a higher number or a lower number than the one you're consuming um very simple game you are supposed to be kind of not bluffing but misleading players in which your color is but it's very obvious about which color you are after you make a couple of moves um not interesting at all and to be honest not really worth talking about i wouldn't recommend it and um you know it's not really worth your time so um that's pretty obvious why that one left the collection that is monster the next game is a very popular two-player game called targi so i had very high expectations for target and this one really did not land with me at all so this is a worker placement game where you have this grid of cards

and you are basically moving or putting your pieces onto the horizontal and vertical axes and where they cross reference that's the card you're going to take but the cards you actually put your pieces on also offer an ability such as getting resources and stuff and then you're picking up these cards getting resources and building like a little set collection tableau very i suppose kind of cut through as you are blocking people off and i think that's probably one of the things i didn't like about it was how tight this game was normally i like some restrictions on games but this one you could deliberately take moves just to shaft your opponent and it's pretty obvious on what you should do i thought um so yeah i like the ideas here some very cool mechanisms i love that grid system um but again i think it was as especially as the ram went on your options became fewer and fewer and it became very obvious what you should do not only to help yourself but to hurt your opponent and a lot of people are gonna like that and obviously they do because this is a very highly acclaimed game but yeah it didn't quite land for me and it didn't quite it didn't quite sit right so maybe check out my review for target because i think i can probably explain more what i'm trying to say trying to say now uh next up i have a ginkopoulos so gingkopolis a game that i actually still do highly rate um this one definitely has my shield of quality and i think it's still in my top 100 games of all time um i think this one which is a it's kind of an abstract top placement city building game as you are drafting these cards you are expanding the city not only horizontally but also vertically i'm getting points and set collection bonuses or sorry like engine building bonuses and things um very abstract so and i think maybe

that's one of the things that did make the stand above the other tile placement games in my collection so if i didn't if i didn't have like some great great tire placement games in my collection such as glenmore 2 or things like citrus then this one would certainly be in my collection but i i feel like because i get to place games so irregularly that if i do have the opportunity to play a good target game i'm probably going to pick those other two before this one therefore it's going to be sat on my shelf for years and years to come before i get to play again so i had to make a bit of a you know a decision and say you know what let's let's keep things simple let's get rid of it happily play this one anytime because it is that good and it was really on the fringe of staying in the collection because it is a strong recommendation but as i said it's just not going to get pulled off the shelf on top of those other games so unfortunately i had to make that that hard decision of uh getting rid of ginkopoulos next up i have monasterium which is a dice drafting style game with a yahtzee mechanism so you're basically rolling a bunch of dice and then allocating um one of the pit values to a particular action and you're going to be doing that backing back and forth with your opponents and building up the pool of dice in the first place so i did really like that kind of prelude to a dice drafting game where you'd actually build the spots between you rather than just rolling the bunch and allocating them straight away and then you'll be using those guys to either kind of travel down this road um kind of send off these monks and things to the churches and monasteries build up a stained glass window to get

kind of lines and columns and points that way um a really nice well-rounded dice drafter very simple and trusted euro mechanisms public objectives that were very tight to get to a nice arc on the game because you didn't really have much time um and to be honest there wasn't very much this game didn't do right um the only problem is very much like ginkopoulos i have a whole shelf full of diced drafting games and you know most of the t series and my coinbra tris magista sulkin total and this one is not as good as those games and despite being very good it's not quite as good as those and when i have games that are comparable to one another i have to say you know which ones are the best and which ones are going to stay in the collection and unfortunately this one didn't quite make the cut despite being objectively a great game and i'm again another one that i'd recommend in its own right so that is monasterium a game that went with very little fanfare but i think it should be more respected because it's a very good game that is monasterium next up i have blackout hong kong by alexander fister so this one is a a very good game again so a lot of these games are pretty good to be honest and i can't i can't really fault this game but it was one of those ones where i played it a few times and i really didn't feel the need to go back to it because i'd explored everything um it has some very cool mechanisms you know when you're playing these cards out building them into these columns trying to get points trying to get upgrades and fulfill these kind of contract cards um some pretty interesting ideas usually trying to build these routes and establish these

with blocks and then get the cards or kind of put these buildings down and get further upgrades and ongoing benefits all the euro goodness you'd expect from a vista game but i would rather play other fister games so particularly maracaibo very rarely get it off the shelf love that game and it's much better than black out hong kong so if i'm going to have both of them on the shelf i'm always going to lean towards maracaibo so that was probably one of the reasons why again i did enjoy this one had some good card play very well-rounded game um quite procedural in the way it broke down and some of the rounds weren't too intuitive and maybe those little things worked against it but still a good game but not a great game i think so um that is blackout hong kong next up i have celestia which is a very um beautiful looking game a pushy luck style game with that can cater to quite a high play account as you are all sitting in this kind of hot air balloon together or this zeppelin and then you are deciding whether to stay in the zeppelin or jump out of it at the current spot you're at to get the amount of points but the further you push on then you are risking running out of cards which you're going to be using to overcome these dice threats or you know if you push on you've got the potential to get more points but you could play it safer and get fewer points and it's all about trying to kind of bluff the other players because everyone's got the hand of cards and you're trying to convince them either to stay in the airship or jump out of the airship um so a lot of fun to be had from this game um and i like it a lot the i suppose the reason i got rid of this one is because it's quite long for what it is it's a pushy like style game

and i have quite a few of them in the collection you know games such as you know quacks to queben berg push these are all fantastic pusher luck games this one is not quite to that standard um number one again because it's too long and number two i think the game worked a bit too hard and tried a bit too hard to be i'm clever with some of the cars they added in so they would add a lot of these special cars which would let you you know do special abilities and mess with the other opponents in different ways and that is where the confusion started to creep into the game you know when you'd be playing this to people who've never played these games before i mean are very new to the hobby it just kind of convolutes the game a bit and kind of took it away from that simplicity so um still fun to be had i would you know if you can get this from a good price i would say pick it up give it a try because it is a lot of fun but ultimately better push your luck games out there and shorter pusher look games out there so that is celestia next up i have beastie bar so beastie bar is a kind of a queueing game as you're trying to get your characters to the front of the queue this supposed to be like this nightclub queue but not be at the back because people at the back get kicked out get kind of kicked out the line the people at the front get let into the club and people all your characters that get left into the club are going to be your victory points at the end and all these cards representing these different animals um interact with the cue in different ways so um say some of the monsters or some of the animals might be sneaking past all the animals until they get to a certain number or once might automatically push right to the front of the queue some might keep knocking animals out the way the queue and eliminating from the game until they get to a certain number so all very different very unique in what

they do and i think that is one of the bonuses and one of the negatives against the game because these animals are so different what they do the rules overhead was quite high in terms of remembering what they do explaining what they do and how they interact with each other would create some quite confusing situations so it was quite a chaotic game where you you know a lot of exceptions a lot of things to remember the symbology wasn't the best on the cards and all these things started to take away and hinder the game from the simple card game that it was supposed to be so respecting what it was trying to do but ended up being a bit too confusing with the groups you're going to play this one with so unfortunately for that reason i i prefer my filler games to be a bit more simple and a bit more you know at face value but this one was just a bit too much going on so that is beastie bar and that was the i think it's the third version of it because there are quite a few different versions but i'll put the uh the appropriate artwork up the penultimate game i'm going to talk about is sunken city which is a pretty obscure game that's faded um in time by kramen and kiesling so generally nine times out of ten i've really enjoyed kramer and keystone games this one is one of the weirdest ones i've played as you are trying to race to get this treasure and return it to your base and you do that by establishing these roots by placing these big 3dq buildings on this map and using them as stepping stones and returning back to your base but you could take real big gambles and visit loads of buildings and return them all that treasure at once or you can play a bit safer and maybe grab one or two treasures and then return but that risk was huge because at the same time

there was this neptune pawn going around and any step that he would step on would automatically sink and if you're on that step you'll be returning back to your base treasureless and having to start again so pretty cutthroat you know quite take that ish um and i thought for the first few games this was really different quite novel and it was a nice game to experience for the first time you know for the first few times and introduced to new players but i think once you've played it with that particular player the again the incentive to go back to it wasn't quite there it was again quite abrupt in shafting other players and being nasty to them but i thought it was different and um it had some good ideas there but ultimately i didn't think it was going to be a keeper it was in a huge box as well just unnecessarily big box so yeah it was a good game um something certainly different and one of the weirdest games i think i've ever played but not quite collection worthy that is sunken city and the final game i'm going to talk about on this episode is a valley of the kings so this is a pretty straightforward deck building style game with this egyptian theme um you're playing cards out you get more cards get these um try and eliminate the cards from your hand to build these set collection bonuses at the end of the game and that's probably one of the things i like so i like the way deck builders use that am i going to keep it in my hand or am i going to eliminate it the way you drafted the cards in this game was quite interesting because it had this like pyramid and you could only take the bottom ones but when you took the bottom one it would come as the one from the next or above would fill in uh spot so it had that quite

cool thing where you'd have to be careful what you're going to leave to your opponent and to draft on their turn but other than that this was a pretty much a paint by numbers deck builder game very kind of synonymous with the time this was released i mean this is good at least 10 years old i can't i don't know the exact date but i think it does feel a little bit dated i'd want a little bit more going on in a deck building nowadays you know it's not my favorite genre of games anyway but this one was quite generic despite being nothing wrong with it a nice well-rounded game but just not quite up to the standard other one now so that is valley of the kings so that concludes this um video of these 10 games that left my collection hopefully this has been somewhat of use to you a bit of a weird episode because there's a lot of games on here that i like and justifying why i got rid of it is sometimes more of a gut reaction rather than something you can articulate but i did my best so anyway if you did enjoy the video please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too and also be sure to check out kianda and um if you want to go the extra step i do have a patreon account um and i'll leave the link below for that one for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved