Skip to main content
Loading video...

Better Than the Original? - Two Birds of a Feather

Transcript 9:22

Hello and welcome out to the Dice Tower. I'm Wendy Yee and today I'm going to be doing a comparison video of some mainstay games in the hobby or just games that have been around for a while and their new counterparts or their new not really second editions but just something that has like the same name. Um it's concluded in the series in some way and I just kind of want to compare them and see which one is better. So first off let's start with Catan versus Catan on the road. Now Catan is something that I played a lot as an entry level hobbyist and I've come to realize it's really not of my taste. Um and a big part of that is the the die rolling in between turns of you know on other people's turns. I love getting stuff on other people's turns but I don't love when I've strategically gotten really good spots but they don't actually hit and they don't actually come up and so I've just come to realize that's not my favorite and the negotiation in it is a part that I honestly very regularly forget about. Um I'm usually just like oh I don't have enough stuff. Oh yeah I should negotiate so going into Catan on the road I was a little bit like I don't know if I'm going to like this because I don't really love the original and holy cow it fixed everything about the original that I didn't like. Um for one I think the trading is really interesting because you're always getting stuff if you're giving up stuff and um it's such a big part of this game and you can really get ahead if you're willing to give up a lot of stuff to other people and so I think that that is just it creates a positivity and it creates a sense of

like combined wealth that I really enjoy. Also super fast super zippy you don't have a lot of hemming and hawing that you have in a bigger game um which I love big games but um yeah, just for Catan, I just think that this is great. So, Catan on the road, definitely a win. So, if I were to give both a score, for me, a Catan comes in at a six, and Catan on the road, um, that one's going to come in at like a 7.5. So, definitely significantly better on that. All right, next on my list is Aquatica and Aquatica Duellum. Okay, this one I was excited for because I love Aquatica. And if we're talking about scores, like Aquatica to me is a 10, right? It is like right up there with one of my favorite games. I absolutely love it. I think it's amazing. So, when Duellum came out, I was like, a two-player version? Yes.

Um, and I knew it was going to be a little bit more, you know, in each other's face, because that's the point of a two-player game, right? Is you're more interactive, you're more involved with each other. And I have to say that every single thing about this game, I either disliked, or it made me go, I just want to play Aquatica again. Like, I didn't like the little board that you're moving your characters, and you're moving back. Like, I don't like tug-of-war very much. It's a fine mechanism. It's not my favorite. Um, but I really hated the adjusting of the market, and how we were inverse of each other. And, um, yeah, the whole thing, it just made me want to play Aquatica. So, for me, Aquatica is a 10, and Duellum is a four. Like, absolutely did not like it. Don't think it needs to exist. Begone, right? Um, so, the next two games I want to talk about is Flip Town and Flip Voyage.

Now, I was in the review for Flip Town: New Frontiers, and in that I compared Flip Town: New Frontiers a little bit to Flip Town. I talked about which one of those was my favorite. So, if you're interested in that particular mashup, uh, go check out that review. But, if not, uh, Flip Town versus Flip Voyage, uh, this was interesting because I really enjoyed my first play of Flip Town. I really enjoyed my subsequent plays of it. And I like that Western theme, and I don't play poker. I don't know a ton about poker, but I did enjoy that little bit of like, "Hey, poker hand, shoot 'em up. Let's wrangle some cattle." You know, like all that kind of stuff, right? Or still stagecoaches. I think cattle was in the second one. But, um I really enjoyed that theme, and it's it's not typically one I gravitate towards, but I did enjoy that. Um so, I was very excited to play Voyage. And when I played Voyage, it just didn't feel as exciting to me, and the mini games didn't feel as enjoyable. And so, in many ways, they're very similar games, right? I do think that the Western theme is a little bit more exciting than the submarine theme. Um but, I really think that it's the mini games that just didn't really speak to me. Now, walk you like not walking around in mud, going around on the little map, and like collecting little goodies, I thought that was fun. Um some of the upgrades were fun. And it is a little clever or it's a little silly to be like, "Hey, I'm giving up crew member to go fix something." And it's like, "What are they doing? Are they just like sticking their fingers in holes in the walls as like water's coming in?" You know? Anyways, I think

that it's a little silly in that regard, um how it works, but yeah, just comparing the two, Western Legend not Western Legends, um Flip Town definitely better. All right, next up. Oh, so anyways, if I were to rate those, I'd say 8.5 for Flip Town, 8 for Flip Voyage, right? Very good. Both of them are great, though. Uh next up is Thunder Road Vendetta versus Ignition. Now, Vendetta's a much bigger game. Ignition is a smaller game. And so, for me, these are very similar, right? Um you get the same fun, the same excitement from both. I think that there's benefits to having the bigger game, the more maps, the all that kind of stuff going on. I also really enjoy the pit stops that are in Ignition, so that you don't feel like you're completely out of the race. You can just pop back in.

Um you're definitely still behind, but yeah, you could kind of just keep going. Um I think for me, if I were to personally own one, it would probably be Ignition just because it's a smaller box, smaller footprint, a little bit easier to teach and get onto the table and go. But I think they're both fabulous, and if I wanted a really good like yeah, let's play game, I'd probably play Vendetta if I had access to it. So, um they're very similar to me. Both are 8.5s. I think that they're great goofy smash 'em up racing games, you know. They're just fun. All right, last on my list is Wingspan versus Wingspan Pocket. Now, this is one that I'm not a fan of Wingspan. Never really have been. It's never sung to me. Um and I wanted to like it. Like I I definitely wanted to, but it's the resource die rolling that I just absolutely hate. It just frustrates me. Frustrates me so much. Um and so, going to the card edition, I was like, "Okay, I'll try this. Yeah, that's fine."

I probably won't love it. It's fine. But you know what? I really have enjoyed it, and I've oddly enough, jumped into a bunch of games at a variety of different conventions as people are sitting down to play it. They stick up like some green flag or something that says, "Hey, we want players. Come play." And as I've sat down to play it, I've been like, "Oh yeah. This one's just so easy. It's so easy. It's fun. I enjoy it." I don't think it blows anything out of the water. I don't think that it's like drop dead amazing, but I do really enjoy it, and it's really easy to teach, and it's really easy turns, and it doesn't take that long, and yeah, it's just a fun game, and you're putting the cute little eggs out on cards, and your birds are firing off, and you know, you're doing stuff. And so, it's something that I enjoyed. So, anyways, if I were to come in with scores for this, Wingspan, five for me.

Not interested in playing it again. I don't think it's a bad act like actively bad game. I'd be like a four or lower. Um a Aquatica duel, right? Or duel'em. Actively bad. Um but Wingspan, it's just it's not of my taste. I'm not going to play it again. I don't enjoy it. Yeah, it's just not for me at all. Uh whereas Wingspan pocket, I give 7.5. I think that it's fun and I really love just how easy it is and welcoming it is, but still has some really good stuff in there. So, I don't feel like I'm playing just like a kind of a babyish entry-level game. And that sounded really demeaning and I didn't mean it to be that way. Um but yeah, I just I like that there's some good strategy in there and I can find some fun combinations of ways that I can get different birds to work together.

So, I'll see you fire off your engine all the time. All right. Well, there you go. Those are my comparisons between two different games. Um I hope you enjoyed this. Uh tell me if you have differing feelings from me. Do you think Wingspan is the bee's knees and uh Wingspan pocket sucks? Let me know. Anyways, I'm Wendy Yi. This is The Dice Tower. Have fun gaming.

Hey, uh thanks for watching another video here on The Dice Tower. Uh we really appreciate you stopping by and checking our things out. Thanks so much for joining us today. And hey, if you really like what we're doing here at The Dice Tower, then there are different ways to support The Dice Tower. One of those ways is through Patreon. We have links in the description to this video. We have links to lots of other things we do down there. So, definitely check it out. But either way, we're glad you watched us. Tell your friends about The Dice Tower. Until next time though, I'm Tom Vassal and I hope you enjoyed this video.

Progress saved