How to design a PUSH YOUR LUCK board game *Top 10 mechanisms*
Transcript
hi I'm Adam Porter and this is my board gaming vlog and today I thought we'd talk a little bit about pushing your luck in games so push your luck or press your luck games as they tend to be called in America and the reason I wanted to talk about this topic was one of two reasons really one was because I've just picked up the quacks of qward Lindbergh expansion the herb witches which is a really good expansion just to add some more of the same really more variety to that game which was my favorite game of last year but also because I have my own game where is it it's over here so throne which has just come out with whiz kids has just come onto the market particularly in America and I think it's coming up soon in the UK so this is a push your luck dice game with trick-taking sort of mechanisms in it and so I'm going to come back to that after I've gone through ten different things that we tend to see in push your luck games ten mechanisms that tend to make up this genre and we'll look at how throne incorporates some of that stuff and why I enjoy the game so um my first starting point for this video is to talk a little bit about blackjack so of course in blackjack casino game a player will be dealt a card and then they will turn over subsequent cards from a standard deck and they're trying not to go over the total of twenty-one now face face cards so cards the king the Queen the jack they count as ten and an ace may countless and eleven or it may count as a1 depending on the casino and
depending on the the the game type the rules that you're playing but you're trying to get close to that twenty one closer than any other player but if you go over twenty one you're going to get nothing and this is a gambling game you're playing against the banker in order to try and beat them and win the pot of money that's been put in there so that's our starting point so let's look at how modern games have used push your luck to to add that sense of tension to the game and these games tend to be extremely tense there's there's lots of stress about you know and huge rewards as well is it's so much fun when those risks actually pay off so the first game we're going to look at is a game called tempura from yellow and this is a good example I think just to start us off with the basic concept of going bust in tempura players attempt to avoid going bust by drawing indigestion cards on a player's turn they may do one of four things the first option available to them is to play a card which matches the top card of the discard pile the second option is for them to draw cards from the deck equal to the number that is the sum of all the cards that are in that discard pile so if there were four two cards in the discard pile and a player might choose to draw eight cards the third option available is to play in that action card adding to the sum of the cards in play or changing direction of play or skipping some of the players and the final option is to play two identical cards which allows you to set
aside the discard pile and start a new one the round ends when a player draws any indigestion card and in each subsequent round there are more interesting cards added into that deck and the game ends when a player has drawn three of these throughout multiple rounds the player who's drawn on the fewest indigestion cards wins the game so in tempura if you go bust too many times then you're out of the game and ultimately the player who who goes bust the fewest times so when one players gone bust three times the player who's gone bust the fewest times wins the game it's a it's a fun little game it's a little bit like uno or something like that cut shedding game it feels like that in one sense adding cards to the pile and have you got the right cards to add or do you want to pick up cards but it's got that neat little thing of if I get too many of that that indigestion card if I get one of those interesting cards in fact come out of the deck then that messes up my whole round it's a neat little game and beautiful to look at the second game that I wanted to look at it uses a system which I'm calling ante up so ante up is not quite the right term for it but I couldn't quite work out what what to call this so an ante in poker and a gambling game is where you you put money in or you put chip sin and that just says I'm gonna play in this round but it increases the value of the pot for whoever wins that round to whoever wins that round gets additional
points because you've put something into it and of course in poker you can then raise and the pot will increase in value so what I'm talking about here with this this category of games which I'm calling ante up games is where we have a central pot that increases in value depending on the player actions in dice heist for museums are placed on the table on a player's turn they turn over an exhibit card and add it to the corresponding Museum sometimes the card will indicate that an additional card should also be added the player then chooses to name a museum and then roll a single die in an attempt to beat the value of that museum ie beat a two three four or five with a single dice or the second option available to the player is to instead pass their turn and take a second die so they build up a pool of these dice if a player beats the value of the museum they take all the cards which have gathered there but if not they've wasted their turn on the subsequent turns their fall players can amass a small collection of dice making it easier to beat the harder museums and collect the most treasures but spending too many turns gathering dice often results in treasures being snatched from under your nose by a lucky dice roll from an opponent at the end of the game cards are scored in various ways after facts are worth 1 or 2 points each gems are worth more if they're contained in sets and paintings only score for the player with the highest combined value so dice heist is a tiny little game from a eg didn't make much of a splash at all but Trevor Benjamin and Brett Gilbert who who are friends of mine are experts
at making these landscapes they've made a whole range of dice games and they're some of the best dice games that I have but dice heist is my favorite of those and it's one that I played a lot as a little filler because I loved the simplicity of that push your luck aspect do I bide my time and just gather some more dice but I means the other players can run away with it or do I just go all that for those lucky dice rolls it's very very light and there is a lot of luck in it but it's so simple to teach and it's it's it's full of those sort of stand up you know yelling punching the air sort of moments that you want from a game like this um the next thing that we're going to talk about is also relating to those traditional sort of card games and and gambling games so this is comparing games so game that they're called comparing games comparing card games poker is a comparing game where you reveal your hand and everyone looks at each other's hands and you compare and you see who's got the best so the game we're going to look at is another game from yellow and that is kobayakawa kobayakawa features a tiny deck of only 15 cards each player is dealt one card and then one is turned face up in the center of the table on a player's turn they can either draw a second card then discard one of their two cards face up on the table in front of them or they can turn over a card from the central deck replacing the one that's been revealed previously once each player's had a single turn then players have a round of betting and this is very simple each
player starts with four tokens and to bet a player just has to place a single token in the center of the table this means that they think they have the highest card in the round all players reveal their cards and the value of the central card is added to the total of the player with the lowest numbered card after doing that the player with the highest total wins all the tokens plus one from the central pool and after seven rounds the player with the most tokens wins so in kobayakawa the push your luck moment is that bit where you decide are you going to ante up are you going to throw another token into the pot have you got enough and in cobia Cour there's this because there's only 15 cards in the deck you can do quite a lot of card counting and you can't balance the odds there you can walk you out to some degree and then work out whether you want to take that risk or not and of course in push your luck games that's part of it isn't it it's looking at the odds and trying to make a mathematical decision is it worth me taking this risk or is it not and of course the the presence of other people around the table changes that because it's not just about the maths it's also about knowing the psychology of those other people what have they done in previous around today a cautious player are they a risky sort of player what do I think they're gonna do in this round and that changes those calculations and makes every game dynamic even if you can calculate the odds the likelihood of you winning you can't account for the behavior of the other players so another category of
game that would fit into a push your luck sort of genre is is just a betting game this is slightly different to the ante up thing where we throw money and increasing the value of the odds of the pot what we're talking about here is a game where I actually place a bet on whether I'm gonna be able to achieve something or whether somebody else is gonna be able to achieve something and I might get great rewards based on whether my bet has come true or not and my favorite game in this genre in fact my favorite push your luck game altogether is Zach Vella x game of travel calm rouse enough toy welcome rouse all players start with 200 s value worth of chips then they simultaneously bet how much coal any one player can draw out of the fire without revealing a devil the vets are all reveals and then bets of one if any player equals or exceeds the amount that you've bid players then reveal coals from the fire one player goes first and reveals tokens repeatedly until they either choose to stop or they're forced to stop because they've revealed a devil if you reveal a devil you're revealed coal is deemed worthless and your total is zero after all players have had a turn at revealing coals the player revealed the most cold pieces gains 50 points worth of chips the player who revealed the highest total value from their coal also reveals 50 points worth of chips and if your bet exceeded the highest amount gained by any player at the table you lose your stake but if your bet was lower than the
highest amount you double your stake in subsequent rounds coals are not returned to the board until it's nearly empty so players adjust their future bets based on the current game state and when one player has exceeded 1,600 points worth of chips then the game ends and the player with the most chips wins so I've toyed welcome raus is just great it plays with lots of people it's easy it's beautiful the components are great that chips the poker chips of really good quality poker chips it plays in a relatively short timeframe it's exciting it's swingy you're back and forth you never quite know it's got this great thing with the school track around the side well you never quite know exactly how much someone's got they have to position himself in a place where it tells you roughly what they've got so you got some idea who's ahead but you haven't got any accurate figures to base your decisions on until at the end when some of those right I've done it I've beaten 1600 and they reveal their chips and then we see who the winner is it's just fantastic the X the the the changing board state as those coals come out so that every round just feels that little bit more tense and you think actually this is right most of those Devils I've gone this is the round where I can really go for it brilliant brilliant game and really cruelly over all the hooks you know nobody talks about or Volcom rats but it's one of my very favourite games so that brings us on to bluffing games so bluffing games and games that are all about bravado and about taking risks so the game that I chose to categorize here
is welcome to the dungeon another game from yellow actually yeah it's got loads of great push your luck games so this one is a game a small box game a lot of these little small box games tend to come from Japan and I think this is one example again with a really small deck a bit like Kobe Yukawa but this one works very differently it's all about making the other players think that you're going to be brave enough to take the risk and you have some information that the other players don't have because you get to look at cards that they don't get to see let's have a look at how it works in each game of welcome to the dungeon one adventurer has chosen for all players to share players then beat to see who's going to take that adventurer into the dungeon in the bidding phase each player goes in turn and they may either play or pass if they pass but take no further part in the round and they can't gain success cards from the dungeon if a player chooses to play however they draw a monster card from the deck they secretly look at it and then they decide whether they want to add it to the dungeon deck making it more dangerous for the player who dares to try their luck in that dungeon or otherwise they can discard that monster and instead sacrifice an item belonging to the adventurer making them weaker when all other players have passed the remaining player must take the adventurer into the dungeon with whatever equipment they have left the player adds up the health points of the adventurer including any equipment they then reveal monster cards one by one
from the dungeon pile and if the adventurer has equipment which can eliminate that monster then the monster is discarded if not the adventurer loses health points equal to the monsters strength never play among trees to get an adventurer all the way through that dungeon deck without losing all their health points then the player gains of success card if the adventurer is killed in the dungeon then that player flips that play a card over if this happens twice they're eliminated from the game but if a player gains to success cards then they win the game and each game features a different adventurer with different health points and equipment with varying powers and abilities so welcome to the dungeon was followed by another game welcome back to the dungeon that just added in new special powers and and shook things up a little but it plays exactly the same and in fact the two games can be combined in some ways they're really good little filler games with really exciting moments and and actually it's quite nice that moment where we all sit back and we go right go ahead you know people have been bragging about what they can achieve and then you say right you go and then that one player basically plays on their own but you will get to watch and either cheer them along or jira and take pleasure when they fail terribly that's very unique in that game it's not that mini games where we just eventually all the other players just sit back and let one player go and we all just laugh and clap and clap along as they and as they play you know and that's the sort of feeling and welcome to the dungeon and that's one of the things I really like about it so the next game that
we're going to talk about all the Nets category we're going to talk about is games where you play versus a banker so if you think back to the original analogy about blackjack in blackjack there is a banker there and here different rules to the rest of you maybe one of his cards is facedown one of his cards is face-up usually ties are broken in the favor of the banker so we've got some slightly asymmetric play there but he's the one that all the other players are trying to beat so an example of a modern game that uses a system of that slight asymmetry in this push your luck mechanism is the game part of us also buys Aquifer lag in each round of Poulter fuss one player takes the role of the innkeeper an innkeeper throws several barrels onto the table the values showing on any standing barrels are reveal to all the players the other players now secretly indicate using cards how many points they wish to play for the innkeeper now repeatedly throws the barrels setting aside any which are standing up and increasing the total each time the innkeeper can stop at any time but they go bust if all the barrels are lying down after they've thrown them the total value of all the barrels is recorded and special effects are applied doubling or canceling the values of various barrels the players then reveal their cards if the innkeeper went bust the players receive the full points that they bid for but if the innkeeper did not go bust then a total of all the players cards are added up and if this
total exceeds the total on the barrels ie the players were too greedy then the innkeeper gets all the points from the barrels the greediest player then loses points equal to the cards that they played and the least greedy player gets points equal to the cards played by the greediest player if the total of all the cards was below the total from the barrels then the players do get their full points are they bid for but the innkeeper also gets the difference between the card total and the barrel total the game ends when a player's score 75 points and wins I find part of us a fascinating game I mean I love the the components it's so much fun throwing those barrels and they could just be dice but but the - you know a coin because they're double double sided really but there's something just fun about chucking barrels and seeing if they're standing up or not check them onto a beer mat and the box is full of these little beer mats to throw these dice or these these barrels on it's a lovely production and the game is actually really good it's it's it's a little convoluted the whole thing about how it scores of working out who scores what at the end and of course if you don't understand the scoring then it makes all the other decisions throughout the game void so it takes a little bit of getting into but it's actually fascinating once you play it works really well I'm gonna move on to another category now which is a very broad one which is about drawing cards and of course we see in in push your luck games games often where you just draw one card at a time and then and then see what happens a bit like in blackjack when you turn over one
card at a time of course this is also something that we see in games where you draw a token out of the back one token at a time in after Volcom wraps you're turning over one kool token at a time or it might be a dice game like Yahtzee where you get to roll than you think doing tyree roll or do I stick okay and so in this case we're looking at the game bye-bye black sheep where you actually draw cards from the other player's hands in bye-bye black sheep players are attempting to gather sets of three matching animals and playing multiple triplet sets on the table wins you the game each player holds a hand of seven cards and one of these is always a black sheep on a player's turn they repeatedly select random cards from other players hands placing them face up onto the table now any point the player can stop drawing and place cards from their own hand and from those just drawn from the other players hands into a face-up zoo the display of cards belonging to that player they can place as many cards as they've just drawn - - and if a player draws a black sheep then they must stop drawing immediately and take all of the drawn cards into their hand and they can't add any of them to their zoo all players refill their hands and the next player takes a turn there are various special cards which spice up the game drawing an eagle allows you to request a specific card from a player playing a mole allows you to look at a player's hand of cards the magpie steals cards from another player's zoo and a player wins when they have a set number of triplet sets of
cards in their zoo display depending on play account so bye-bye black sheep is a little twist really a twist on that genre of turning over one card at a time but the difference here is of course you know that every single player has a black sheep in their hand and you don't want to get the black sheep so you can focus in on the players who have lots of cards in their hand and avoid the ones who don't have many cards in their hand but you may have some idea about which cards each player has in hand based on what you've seen them pick up previously and you know you've want those cards so you might have to target that player even if there are greater odds of hitting the black sheep in that particular instance so it's got all these really fascinating little decisions in it again it's a little bit more complicated than some of these other games to explain although the rules are very simple really but but that added complication if we're drawing them from player's hands just adds just a little bit of extra interest but also a little bit of extra complexity to the game a lot of these modern games are chucking in special powers all over the place we've just seen that in the game bye-bye black sheep that it has cars with special powers and there's one game in particular that goes overboard with these special powers the whole game is about these special powers and that's the game captain carcass all dead man's draw as it's known in some of its editions I think this originated as an app but it went on to become a card game based on the app and the version I've got is the version called captain carcass in
Captain carcass on the player's turn they repeatedly turn over cards from the deck to reveal treasures they can stop at any time and collect the Thresher cards they've revealed but if they reveal a second card of the same type then they lose all of the revealed cards putting them in Davy Jones's Locker and then they end their turn at the end of the game the players score points equal to the highest card of each type that they've collected and the highest scorer wins the fun in the game comes from the chaotic special powers on the cards so if you draw us giant squid you must push on and you've got to draw to further cards if you draw a knife then you remove a card from another player's collection and add it to Davy Jones's Locker if you draw a map then you take the card from Davy Jones's Locker if you draw a net then you place a card from your collection instead of whirring another card from the deck and you use that card's ability a drone allows you to look at the deck before you choose to draw and so on so there you see the chaos of the special pallets this is a pushy luck game where you're turning over card to try and not to go bust you know you're you're taking cards from other players back and forth another game it has loads of special powers in it is the game Port Royal I really like the game Port Royal apart from the fact that it feels quite long and it feels quite it takes a while to get through that deck and it's sort of it's a euro game really the special powers aren't there's chaotic as the special powers in in something like bye-bye black sheep or in Captain carcass and it feels like it wants to be something a bit more substantial it didn't quite work for me a little bit
too much complexity a little bit too much in the duration of it if it was shorter and a little bit more condensed I think that's a great game but I know loads of people who absolutely love it and I know this hugely popular and had lots of expansions so that's one that might be worth checking out if you like that sort of thing right we're moving on to another category now which is the games that have simultaneous play so the example I have here for you is the game cracks of cred Limburg which I talked about earlier now quacks are Creveling burg I always play that simultaneous some players will play it take it you know we roughly go at the same time but we don't keep exactly in sync and I think most of the strategic decisions in the game come when you make sure that everybody turns over a token at exactly the same time and then we all look and see right have they have they turned over a token or have they actually revealed an empty fist and you know actually they found out early you know and we've carried on and then are we gonna go bust or not so let's have a look at how quacks of quibbling burg plays in the quacks of cred lingburgh players are filling their cauldrons with various magical ingredients attempting to generate enough income to buy even better ingredients to use in the next round but trying not to push their luck too far by drawing one too many explosive ingredients from their sack each round starts with a random event drawn from a deck of cards subtly changes the rules for the round the players who are below in the scoring get a mild leg up in the form of a rat
token which partially fills their cauldron making it easier to reach the highest scoring spaces play as them simultaneously draw ingredients from the sack adding them to their own individual cauldrons and ingredients interact in a variety of clever manners but if a player ever goes over the limit of seven points worth of white ingredients then their cauldron explodes and the rewards are severely diminished depending on the space the players reached on their track they received victory points and rubies and money which they can use to buy new ingredients then all ingredients old and new a return to the player sack and the process is repeated in each round the player sacks get more powerful than the various combinations they've created with their various ingredient powers and the game comes with four variants for each color of ingredients so each game feels quite different as the mark of ingredients changes after nine rounds the game ends the highest scorer wins right and finally we're going on to another game which also uses that sort of simultaneous play that's reveal of are we staying or are we going but the category that I wanted to mention here and again I didn't quite know what to call it but it's this idea of a prisoner's dilemma type game now the prisoner's dilemma I won't go into it now but it's a game theory sort of mechanism where you choose to either cooperate or to be selfish and the rewards are going to be different based on how many players choose to cooperate or how many players choose to be selfish in diamant players advance through a cave grabbing
treasures and avoiding traps a card is revealed to all players and rubies are placed on it equal to the number shown they're then distributed evenly to all the players with the remainder remaining on the card all players then simultaneously reveal whether they wish to continue or exit the cave and if a player exits they take all the rubies which are currently left on the cave cards and they take no further part in the round if multiple players exit at the same time then they must share the rubies evenly leaving any remainders behind if any players are continued in the cave then another card is revealed and so the game continues with card after card and lots of rubies being added if a trap card is ever revealed then nothing happens but if a second identical trap card is revealed at a later point all the adventurers who are still in the cave are killed and they lose all the treasure they've gathered in that round rubies from previous rounds are safe they're placed in the players chests and they can't be lost after five rounds the highest scorer wins so the prisoner's dilemma bit there is the fact that if I leave and I'm the only one to leave I'm going to get huge rewards and if everybody else leaves and I'm the only one to stay then I might get huge rewards but if I choose to leave and lots of people leave with me my rewards are much diminished because I'm gonna have to share everything okay and that's the the crux of the game is that trying to be the only one going it alone either by advancing further into the cave on your own or by leaving the
cave on your own and taking all the rewards with you that's the fun in DM on it plays brilliantly with large numbers of players it's really fun it's really tense it's really quick and it's very very beautiful in its most recent production again by Yello they just seem to love these push your luck games so coming back to my game throne throne is a trip taking dice game for 3 to 5 players lasting half an hour it combines trick-taking elements of games like hearts or trumps with push your luck mechanisms of dice rolling games there are cards in the game but they're purely there to provide special abilities for the different rounds the massive number of possible card combinations ensures that every game of throne is different and provides a new challenge to the players the game is structured like a traditional trick-taking card game each player has a selection of dice in four different suits which are the dice colors and on their turn players roll dice trying to beat their opponents score but they must follow the suit led if they're able to but they're not able to follow suit then they can roll any color of dice in an attempt to trump and in thrown a trump is a roll of 6 the single die the winner of the trick gains points based on the number of dice their opponents have put into the trick and each round is going to introduce new decisions to the players as optional powers are assigned to each dice color so players may be able to discard a die to re-roll one of their own dice or indeed one of their opponents dice they might be able to discard a die to end the trick early or to change the scoring
conditions or add extra dice to supplement their original roll the game's themed around fantasy medieval characters and as with most trick-taking games the theme is really pretty loose but the powers recall the abilities of such roles so the reinforcements card is going to add more dice the wizard will alter your own results and his evil counterpart the sorcerer will alter your opponent's results the noble increases the value of a trick etc the fun in the game comes from pushing your luck by spending diced of re-roll your results or adding extra dice in the hope of pushing on to victory but of course that can never be certain because dice tend to have minds of their own so which of these categories that we've talked about does throne feature I mean it's a trick-taking game right and it's a dice game how is it a push your luck game well it really is I mean the answer is that you can't go bust in in enthroned but you can fail you might throw some dice in there and anything odd you know what if I just spend one more dice to utilize some sort of special power then that could just be the thing that pushes me to victory but that dice can either succeed or fail and so you can be throwing good dice after bad you know and and and and that's it's not quite like going bust but that idea of success or failure and taking those big risks is really satisfying there's certainly the sense of an teeing up of increasing the pool the value of the pool every time you throw dice into
that pool the pool gets more valuable for your opponent's so if you throw one dice in then that's a relatively sort of okay there's slightly valuable trick there but if I throw three dice in there you can be sure the next player is going to want to win that trick because you win points based on how many dice your opponents have used so the actual currency you're using the things that you're betting with are the very same things that determine whether you win or lose and it's it's it's a really interesting sort of way of playing you know I you know this by throwing you more it makes me more likely to win but if I lose it also increases the value of the pot for everybody else this is a comparing game so we all look at our results we all compare them and then the winner takes the whole pot and and so it functions like something like poker or Kobe Yukawa in in that sense or something like pontoon or blackjack it's definitely a bluffing game it's a game of bravado it's a game of you know and looking at the other players and thinking what are they gonna do is it worth me taking this risk or are they just going to undo all my good work on a future turn how many dice do I think they're gonna chuck in what can they afford to use what special powers could they use based on the dice that I can see on the table and of course everything is visible you know what everybody's got so you can try and read what the other players might do there are special powers all over the
place so it ties in with things like captain carcass in fact I think captain carcass was a little bit of an inspiration for me and making this game I love all the messin about you doing captain carcass you turn over one card it allows you to do something else and then you can use this special power to do something else and then you get a choice of all the special powers that you've now got laid in front of you and I play a card and then that allows me to choose which one of these powers I want to activate for a second time and then there's a whole lot of extra cards and captain carcass that change up the rules and you can you can switch the rules from round to round so there's tons of variability and replay value in that box and the likewise in throne there's a massive number of different possible combinations of those different cards that you can use and that just creates so many different types of experiences in the gameplay and lots of funny moments where people don't recognize that a certain sort of combination could lead to this so they think they've got the got the win and then a player pulls off a clever combination using one card power and in another card power and maybe a lucky dice roll and and then they take the pot so it's very satisfying from that point of view as well so the pushier luck stuff is strong in throne that's where the fun in the game is it's recognizing how many does to throw that's based on turn order if I'm early in the turn order then likelihood is that other players are going to be able to manipulate my dice or manipulate their own and take the pot but if I'm second or third from the last in turn
order certainly if I'm final in the turn order then it might be worth me spending a little bit more because the rewards are already there to be seen and I know that nobody can mess up what I've already achieved so anyway I love this honor of games I wish there were more of them other ones that I've enjoyed is it deep-sea adventure or deep ocean adventure the oil games one the only reason I don't have that in my collection is because I think it's a little bit ugly it looks a bit like a prototype and I can't see myself actually pulling that out and sort of showing it to people I'd like to get a game out and everyone to go hard looks nice and that's good whereas I can't honestly say that about that point games production so I'd like to see that with a more lavish sort of production another one that I know a lot of people enjoys the game Celestia and from blam Celestia didn't quite work for me I can't quite remember why I played it a couple of times never quite got my head around the decisions in it but then I know it's another hugely popular one so it probably deserves a mention and then of course CID Saxons classic can't stop which is perhaps a little bit too abstract for me but really good push your luck game I know I know my nieces and nephews haven't really enjoyed that one with my brother now the other games are dice games of course there are tons of dice games that used to push your luck every time we have a reroll in a dice game that is essentially a pushing your luck mechanism and I haven't included those in any great numbers in this list because I suspect I'm going to go on to make a list of my favourite dice games at some point anyway thank
you very much for watching I hope this was interesting for you if you enjoyed it please watch some of my other videos on BoardGameGeek I'm Adam 78 on YouTube I'm Adams Borg in wales on twitter i'm at board game wales thank you very much for watching all the best