Skip to main content
Loading video...

TDG: Cody's Top Ten IP Fantasy Games (July 2026)

Transcript 16:38

Hello ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the discriminating gamer. Say, what do you call friends you like to eat with? Taste buds. Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at my top 10 IP fantasy games of all time.

All right ladies and gentlemen, my top 10 IP fantasy games. Now, of course, intellectual property, I'm talking about games based on books and movies that have a fantasy theme that are part of a kind of a larger

[snorts]

intellectual property. So, let's go ahead and jump right into it. My number 10 is Horrified: Dungeons and Dragons. Dungeons and Dragons is a huge IP with tons of books and some movies have come out based on it. And Horrified last year came out with a Dungeons and Dragons version. I love Horrified. I think Horrified is very fun. All of all of its iterations are very fun, but I really like the Dungeons and Dragons iteration because it has the 20-sided die. And you roll the 20-sided die for various game effects. There's I think it's the Beholder. You roll the die to determine which of its eyes limbs are going to activate. But it was really fun. Great artwork like all the Horrified games. Fun characters. Some really fun and challenging monsters. Of course, you've got the monsters have their own mini maps here and they they are great. They are a lot of fun. I I really enjoyed Dungeons and Dragons and the IP is great and then this Horrified game system is great. It's a great match here. So, that is my number 10, Horrified Horrified D&D and that is from Ravensburger.

My number nine is The Lord of the Rings deck building game Fate of the Fellowship. Now, this is from Cryptozoic and this is part of the Cerberus engine meaning this is essentially the same kind of game system we see in the DC Comics deck building game which is one of my favorite games of all time. Uh but here you take the Lord of the Rings from the first film. You've got screen caps from the first film. And you essentially play through uh as the different heroes, you know, uh Frodo or or Aragorn or Boromir or what have you. You play these different characters as you're fighting the different enemies and villains that they meet in that film, uh the fate of the Fellowship or the uh Fellowship of the Ring rather I should say. And as you're playing through that, you are um you know, getting better cards, stronger cards, you're leveling up, getting rid of weaker cards. It's a very fun system and it's great applied to the Lord of the Rings here. So, that is my number nine, Lord of the Rings deck building game, Fellowship of the Ring.

My number eight is again D&D. This is D&D Betrayal at Baldur's Gate. Now, this game is a riff on Betrayal at House on the Hill, which is a haunted house game. And in this game, uh it's it's it's fantasy. You take that same system where at the beginning of the game you're kind of exploring, you're moving around, you're finding new areas and buildings and what have you. But, as you go, more signs pop out, you have to roll dice to determine when the haunt is going to begin. I can't remember what they call it in this game. But, when the haunt begins, essentially one of you is a traitor, the rest of you are working against them, and you have a specific random scenario that pops up. And this game is very random. And the game has very interesting stories and moments that pop up. This is not a game you I really think these Betrayal games you really want to be gamers to play them because if somebody who is not good at the game or not that invested in the game becomes a traitor, it's not going to be very fun. So, you really want to play these kinds of games with people that really are gamers.

But, I love the fantasy stories that came out of this game. And, you know, I love games that tell good stories and this one definitely does. But, it's just you know, it's kind of a fun random uh fantasy borderline horror game and I really really enjoy it. So, that is um my number eight D&D Betrayal at Baldur's Gate. That is from Wizards of the Coast Avalon Hill. My number seven is a game that I just played recently and this is The Witcher: Old World. The Witcher: Old World is a game that of course is based on The Witcher books. Um of course the TV series too, but they I think the the the game's more based on the books.

[snorts]

But, what happens in this game is you uh you and your friends take on the roles of Witchers and you're going around a board, you're going to different locations and you're exploring them. You can explore the city or the countryside and oftentimes this will lead to quests and story adventures that you go on and you got to go to another location to fulfill that. So, you got kind of that open world feel here. But, then critically you're fighting these monsters and these monsters you go to their locations if you can get a trail token meaning you get a token that has the that uh geography whether mountains or sea or forests, uh you can get the jump on them so to speak. Get you can go for against the monsters. But, it's got a really good kind of a deck building aspect that lends itself to kind of a card battle mechanic. Uh as you're the Witcher you're playing these cards and they have little tabs on them and you can build combos off of these tabs that give you more strength and and and deal more damage to your enemy. And then your enemy has this great system where their health is their cards and they they're discarding cards for their health but then they can decide when they play a card if they're going to do a bite damage or a charge damage. Really fun.

Game has a lot of surprises. Has a lot of I think there's a lot of deep story here. Really there's a really good another storytelling game that gives you a lot of great advantages. It's got one of the things where if you go exploring the person next to you draws the card and reads the choices for you and you make the decision. I really like games that do that quite a bit. So, this is my number seven The Witcher: Old World that is from CD Projekt Red. My number six is a game that uh just came out again. I think it was early it was either late last year or earlier this year. I can't remember. I it several times. Really had fun with it. And this is a Game of Thrones Legendary, Legendary Game of Thrones from Upper Deck. Um this is you know, most Legendary games, the default is they're cooperative games, and this one is a competitive game. You each kind of have your own player board, you know, and you you take on the roles of the houses, the Starks, the the Baratheons, the Lannisters, the Dothraki. And you are competing against each other. You have allies that come out on a board that that that people are trying to defeat. Um and you're trying to go after each other players kind of mastermind. They've got their own masterminds there. Really, really a fun game. Very um you know, it really drive drags you into the to the Game of Thrones IP. The artwork here is great, and it's just a lot of fun. And frankly, I I hadn't played a Game of Thrones game in a while, and I forgot just what I love about the the the the IP, the books, and even the TV show first seasons of Game of Thrones, and that's translated into a game so well.

So, I really enjoyed that. That is Legendary A Game of Thrones, my number six from Upper Deck. My number five from Repos Productions, this is Lord of the Rings Duel for Middle-earth. This is a game that is based on Seven Wonders Duel, which is a great kind of well, it's a card game, but it's also kind of an area control game, and there's a lot of fun stuff that's going on here. But in this game, you get these cards out. Some of them are face up, and some of them are face down. And you are trying to do set collection here. You're trying to control parts of a board. There is a track if you're if you're the um you know, the fellowship, you're trying to kind of move Frodo and Sam forward on the track. And if you're you know, Sauron, you're trying to move the Nazgûl closer to them to catch them. It's really fun. It's it's just it's a clever um IP take on Seven Wonders Duel. And I had a copy of Seven Wonders Duel, and I got rid of it cuz I much prefer to play Mount uh uh Duel for Middle-earth. Uh much more fun game in my opinion, although I do like Summoner Wars Duel.

Uh, so that is Lord of the Rings, uh, Duel for Middle Earth. That is number five and that is from Repos Productions. My number four is also a Lord of the Rings game and this is Fate of the Fellowship. Fate of the Fellowship is Lord of the Rings Pandemic. Essentially, you've got a game here that is, um, all the goodness of Pandemic of enemies coming at you and you having to take actions to to to keep keep them at bay, keep the barbarians at the gate, so to speak, but it's set in this wonderful Lord of the Rings universe. What's cool here is as all that is going on, you've got Frodo and he has got to get to Mount Doom and all the other characters that you play are are there trying to help him and run interference for him. Uh, as they are moving there, there are other quests you have to fulfill. You have to there's like three other quests you got to fulfill before Frodo can drop the, uh, ring in the Mount Doom, but they're they're all moments from the movies and well and the books of Lord of the Rings and you're trying to fulfill all these things before you can actually get Frodo to Mount Doom. They're challenging, it's fun.

Play this game several times. In full disclosure, I have not won it yet. I have come close, but I have not won this game yet, but I have a lot of fun every time I play it. It is a hard game, it is a challenging game and it is an incredibly fun and immersive game. You really get into the Lord of the Rings, um, you know, stories with this game quite well. So, that is my number four, Lord of the Rings, Fate of the Fellowship. That is from Z-Man Games. My number three is a game that came out years ago and I haven't played this game in a long time and I'm chomping at the bit to get it to the table again, but this is from Monolith. This is Conan. Conan, of course, is based on the Robert Howard Conan the Barbarian series and what is awesome about this game is it has one of the greatest mechanics in a board game I have ever played and this is the river. You've got up to four players are Conan and his buddies and then you got one player who is the the has the river in it.

And what the river is is you can as the villain as the enemy spend uh your currency which are the these crystals, the energy crystals. You can spend them to activate your you the various enemies you got on the board. But the problem is the ones to the right cost a lot more than the ones to the left. So you've got to spend money again in the energy getting these these smaller ones out of the way so that these bigger ones become more affordable. And then once you play them, you're not going to be able to play them again for a while because when you play them they go to the back of the river. It is a fantastic system. They actually adapted this for Batman Gotham City Chronicles which is also a very fun game, but but Conan just has that great fantasy uh theme to it and it is just an incredibly fun and innovative game. And again, I'm I'm chomping at the bit just talking about it. I got to get this one to the table again. So that's my number three, that is Conan and that is from Monolith.

All right, my number two, this is you know, for a long time this was like in my top 10 games of all time and I just haven't played it enough recently. So it's kind of fallen out and in fact, there's an expansion and I got the expansion and I've never played the expansion. I really got to get this one to the table again before too long, but this is my number two, A Game of Thrones: The Board Game Second Edition from Fantasy Flight Games. This game is amazing. Essentially, it is kind of a Game of Thrones riff on diplomacy. It's got that same idea where you've got all the different houses, the Lannisters, the Starks, Baratheons, etc., etc. One of them is not strong enough to win by themselves. So you've got to form alliances. But as soon as you start coming out ahead, those people that were allied to you are starting to think, well, wait a second, I don't want them to win. So they turn on you. So it's a great game of trying to figure out who you can trust and and when to backstab and how to avoid a backstabbing and all sorts of great things.

Tremendous game. I played this a ton back in the day and again, this is another one I'm talking about I I want to do. I actually had a company send me a great insert. I did a video on their insert, and the insert is beautiful, works great, and again, I got to play that expansion. So, that is my number two, A Game of Thrones the Board Game from Fantasy Flight Games. Okay, before we talk about my honorable mentions, one thing I'm going to tell you that's not on this list, War of the Ring. I've I I've never I I I never played a complete game of War of the Ring. I started to play it once, and I liked it, but I just never gave it a shot. I keep thinking that's a game I've got to play at some point, cuz people always bring it up when they talk about IP, fantasy, and stuff like that, and Lord of the Rings games. I really want to play it, and I will at some point, but I haven't yet. So, that's not on the list. But, now my honorable mentions, Harry Potter Hogwarts Battle. I am not a Harry Potter fan. I just never read the books, never saw the movies, don't care.

Uh but, I like the game. I thought the game was pretty fun, a fun cooperative game where you're going against the enemies. It's It's an older game, about 10 years old, and it kind of felt that, but I still really enjoyed it. Uh Jonathan Strange and Doctor Norrell, this was a game based on the books. I never saw the books, but I didn't watch the TV show about kind of um Napoleonic era England and magic. I've heard it described as Harry Potter for adults. And it was a But, the game was pretty fun, you know, you're implementing the magic to it to to achieve the goals. There's there's there's different um cards and stuff that you would use. I just remember really enjoying how you were playing the cards in order to influence the the actions that you were taking and the magic that you could perform on your turn. Really fun, it was kind of an unusual game as well. Um Dungeons and Dragons Builders of Baldur's Gate, this is one we played I think last year. Kind of a again, kind of a worker placement game where you are building up different sections of the city of Baldur's Gate, and the, you know, villains, the enemies attack and try to knock you down and take stuff, and very fun, and again, unusual uh Dungeons and Dragons game that I enjoyed. Uh and then finally, uh D&D Tyrants of the Underdark. This is another great deck builder area control game where you're moving your forces around the board in order to try to um you know, take certain uh areas and fulfill certain objectives. But, what I liked about that game was you had different decks that you would play with. You had all these different kinds of decks that you could use. So, there's a lot of variety and replayability in the game. All right, my number one game of all time when it comes to IP fantasy.

It's a game I bought, I want to say 2011-2012. Played it a lot back in the day. Again, another game I haven't played in forever. And it's a game I keep thinking I got to play cuz I want to do a review on it. I've never done a video review. I think I did a written review back in the day, but I've never done a video review, and I got to do it cuz the game is amazing. Fortunately, it's also out of print, but this is D&D Conquest of Nerath. D&D Conquest of Nerath essentially is a fantasy version of Axis and Allies. I'm hoping maybe Renegade will be able to get the IP and and run with it because it is so good. Instead of bombers, you've got dragons. Instead of tanks, you've got mages. And what I really liked about this game is you got kind of four corners, and you can play everybody against them everybody for themselves, or you could do teams. And I really preferred the team game. I thought that was just tremendous fun. But, what I really liked about this game is you also had like these heroes that could go on dungeons and do like these quests to get treasure and other items and stuff. And that is just so much fun. It just heightens the experience so much when it adds that other layer there that just immerses you in fantasy.

Fantastic game. I'm hoping I'm hoping I'm hoping we see this again in print someday, but I'm not holding my breath. But, this is Dungeons and Dragons Conquest of Nerath. This was from Avalon Hill Wizards of the Coast, and that is my number one. Well, ladies and gentlemen, what do you think? Do you like these games? Do you not like these games? Would you put them higher? Would you put them lower? What do you think? I'm always very eager to hear what you have to say. So, please please please leave a comment here on YouTube, on BoardGameGeek, on Facebook, on X. We'd love to hear back from you. And uh please like this video, subscribe to the channel. Now, if you do really like what you see here on this channel, I would humbly ask you to check out my other channel, that is Cody Carlson, PhD, where we talk about history, military history, books on history, fun things like that. And uh it would mean the world to me if you would subscribe to that channel, as well. And also, too, if you do really like what you see here on The Discriminating Gamer, I would humbly ask you to click on the Super Thanks button and leave a tip.

You know, time flies like an arrow, but fruit flies like a banana.

CAPTAIN, OUR SHIELDS ARE DOWN TO 35%. IS THE FEDERATION SERIOUSLY DEALING WITH AN ALLIANCE of the Romulans, Borg, Ferengi, and Klingons? Cuz we SHOULD JUST GO HOME.

Progress saved