Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 3
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to episode three of games i got rid of and why now this is a series explaining uh the games that i've previously left my collection and i'm giving you a reason for that so i'm going to talk about 10 games today so let's get started so first off is a game that very narrowly just didn't make the cut in staying in my collection this one is carpe diem by stefan feld now there are so many things about carpe diem i like this one is a a tile drafting and tiled placement game where you are trying to get points by um fulfilling certain restrictions and objectives it's a it's a very fast flowing game only takes about 45 minutes to play and it's certainly on the lighter end of uh stefan feld games now there are some particular things i did like about this game the the card the actual tile drafting system itself was um was really good as you walked around this kind of i suppose a little rondelle i'm collecting tiles and the but the thing that really stuck in my mind with this game was the the way you actually scored um in the game how you scored points because you had this randomized grid of cars with all these different scoring criteria on them and then at the end of each round you could place a disc in between um a couple of those cards and score both of those criteria but from then on that particular spot couldn't be scored again by anybody and um yeah and on top of that you have to be uh ahead of this initiative track in order to score first so you could really build towards things but if it wasn't first in initiative then somebody could jump in there
and snatch that spot before you and i really like that i mean i'd love to see that system used again the only things that stop this from staying in my collection was number one i thought that the tile placement itself although it was meaningful i would have liked to see lots of interesting shapes and things in terms of the buildings they're all just you know straight edge just straight edge connectivities and it didn't really have a lot of lots of innovative ways to join things up etc and the second thing was that the the decisions themselves just seemed quite restrictive because you would really have to narrow in on one of those objective cards and scrape by about particularly in those earlier rounds and before you knew it you know the game was coming to an end now maybe that's the way i played i don't know um i i am in two minds about picking up this one again and giving it another go um but my gut instinct tells me that you know i played it a few times the first time and it just didn't quite hit the heights i wanted it to which is a shame because um it had so many things that i did like uh the next game i'm going to talk about is uh the castles of mad king ludwig this is a game that i've talked about extremely highly um throughout my channel and i still do think highly of this when it still holds my um my shield of quality um this one simply didn't stay in the collection because um i played it so so much um a great tile placement game listeners where you're building a castle trying to um you know please or satisfy the king and score different points as well as doing secret objectives um
the but the reason this one didn't quite stay is because um i ended up getting uh glenmore two chronicles which i prefer the tile placement in that one and number two i always played this one with uh one of my close gaming friends and he liked it more than i do um so i i happily sold it onto him so it's still in my kind of gaming circle i can still play this one i like but um ultimately you know he can enjoy it more than i do and play with his family so uh yeah it's kind of a halfway getting rid of this one because i can still play it when i like that is the castles of mad king ludwig the next up is a a second game by stefan feld this one is the castles of tuscany this one came out last year um to a lot of hype actually because of the success of its i suppose it's older brother the castles of burgundy um this one is has some similarities but also some differences to the castles of burgundy where you are placing tiles on this board scoring points and combinations you can get a little bit of engine going in this one but the core the kind of the core system and the core mechanisms uh were quite a bit different and a bit more streamlined than the casters of burgundy where this one is very much card driven as you are picking up different cards and i'm cashing them in to do actions and for me that i thought the difference between the um the satisfaction you get from the castle bergen in this one was quite dramatic in relation to the rules overhead in between the two so i was thinking that this was going to be much well i wasn't sure what to expect initially but when i read the rules i
thought you know it's going to be much easier to explain but in reality i thought that the castle's burgundy isn't a particularly difficult game to teach um and you know just that margin more of complexity created a hell of a lot more of a game and for that reason this the kind of gap in in the market in my particular shelf wasn't quite there for the castle of tuscany and i didn't really see the need to um have both of them um don't get me wrong i did enjoy this game i thought it was fun it did play it quite smoothly but ultimately yeah i'd always go back to the castle of burgundy over over this one hence why it is no longer in my collection uh next up i have chate ochate is a relatively unknown extremely small box tar placement game designed by reina kenitzia this one has a real abstract nature to it as you are building this map made up of nine tiles so a very small footprint of a game um and you are trying to well one person is sorry it's a strictly two-player game one person is going to be the land mass and one is going to be the sea mass and you are essentially trying to manipulate the ball by placing tiles or spinning tiles um to create the bigger of surface area as you can of your terrain type and as soon as that night tile's placed then that the game is going to end and whoever's got the biggest connection is going to win really quite cutthroat of the game um quite thinky probably more thinking than it would initially um spring to mind and you know what i don't really have anything bad to say about this one uh the only reason why i didn't stay in the collection was because it didn't
really get played i mean i i if i tend to play two-player games i generally don't play strictly two-player games anymore i tend to play um bigger more involved euro games that work well with two players whereas this one you know is one of those filler only a 10 minute game that you can play with one other person um it works well it's fine it's pretty cutthroat as i said i'm quite uh quite ap prone is particularly because you have to do plan plan things ahead quite carefully and be aware of what your opponent can do but as i said it just didn't get played and didn't quite get the appreciation that it probably deserves um hence why it didn't stay in the collection next up i have a modern classic with citadels now citadels is one of those games that did fall a bit from grace for me a game where you are drafting these cards um all these different roles which interact with each other trying to collect money and build buildings to get lots of different points um i had quite a bit of success with this game you know i stayed in my collection for probably a year or so i got it to the table quite a few times but the more and more i played it the less satisfaction i got from it because i always found that the game dragged on a little bit longer than it needed to just on one too many occasions i think it outstands welcome and on top of that from a strategic perspective and gameplay perspective i always thought that it was more beneficial just to build what you can rather than try to tailor-make a strategy or get points that way i always thought rushing the game was um a really strong strategy that was
almost almost won every time at least in my experience and for me when that happens i thought i think that the the legs of the game are cut off from beneath it and it's always just a matter of building what you can when you can and um that just doesn't quite do it for me so that's why citadels didn't stay in the collection up next up is a funny one with uh the clans of caledonia this one is an extremely highly rated game it sits comfortably in the board game geek top 100 it's a euro star game as you are trying to farm the land i suppose by sowing resources and gathering resources gaining money upgrading your player board and so on um so very light interactive game you know not not terribly interactive but quite you know uh you know a farming simulator really um some things about this game i did like and some things i didn't like so the things i did like were in terms of the it had a market where you could buy and sell resources which a lot of my favorite games have that but the things i that didn't quite leave me satisfied with this one was the fact that it didn't really have the highs and lows that i like in gaming it didn't really have those um that crescendo of excitement it was very much stayed in third gear from start to finish and flatlined for me now objectively i can see that the game was solid i think i rated it about a seven at the time of my review probably fallen since then maybe about six um and again objectively i can see it's a good game but for me didn't quite reach those heights and it fell a bit flat and some of the scoring
i thought in the game was a bit obtuse um and just didn't leave me quite satisfied and no way was it going to stay in my collection uh next up i have cole baron the great card game by one of my favorite designers wolfgang kramer this one is the card adaptation of cole barron the board game and you know what another game i still speak extremely highly of because it's a great entry level worker placement game based purely on cards as you are placing cards down as your workers and collecting um kind of carriages uh collecting coal and locomotives in order to try and load those um carriages and ship them off to fulfill orders works really well it has this cool work assist work replacement system where if you go to a certain spot the other player has to always raise it by one in order to go there themselves and that can really wrap up there's some good scarcity for the worker placement spots which i think is a necessity for worker placement games um and you know it did a lot of things that i do like about it and you know what from a from an objective standpoint and from uh the the viewpoint of someone just getting into the hobby i can see why this would well i could highly recommend this as one of your staple games actually and i do think it's extremely underrated but for me personally now at this point of my kind of gaming career i like working placement games to be a bit more involved than this one i like to have them on the heavier end of the scale um and you know for that reason it would have just sat on my shelf and ready got
played because most of the people i play with are slightly more experienced now but as i said from from a lot of workers games are touted as being you know they go to the lord and what lots of water deeps the the uh the stone ages i i put this coal baron uh the card game up there with those because i think it does hold its own and should be way more revered than what it is next up i have code names another modern classic if you want um extremely popular game where you have a team versus team and you're trying to help your teammates locate certain words on this grid by giving clues i over the years i've had a lot of hits and misses with this game sometimes it's gone down really well sometimes it's become a bit over competitive and got a bit toxic um and for me ultimately the reason why this didn't stay in the collection was because it's been replaced by so many games i think there are a number of games that do what codenames does a lot better than what codename does it and quicker not any faster but in a way that downplays the analysis for us as it downplays that um that horrible tension in between the teams um games such as cross clues or if you want the game your end of things you got to crypto and i just find the game's way more interesting and with those on the market there is no way i'm gonna choose to play codenames over those next up i have a coliseum another wolfgang kramer game and this one was a staple of my collection for many years i played this one um you know lots of times and had just loads of fun
over the years this one is a set collection game as you're collecting tiles trying to put on these huge performances and get points a game that has great um inbuilt strategy in the game because you you naturally want to progress from show to show and in order to do that and to put on these bigger productions you need to plan accordingly i think it's a wonderful entry-level euro game beautiful production no matter what version of this game you get and it still strongly holds my shield of quality uh the only reason this one left my collection was because i felt like i'd explored everything this game had to offer has to offer i went a long time playing this game without even coming close to winning and when i when i reached that point of winning it um i thought you know what i've put on every show i can i've done every possible strategy um and you know what let's let's let's move on to something else and um invest that time in playing playing something new but no disrespect to the game and no certainly no fault in the game this one i think is brilliant that is coliseum and finally the game i'm going to talk about this uh this episode is cult express which actually is a um a relatively recent spilled jars winner this one is an action programming game that takes place on this 3d train as you're playing these cars and trying to move your bandits around pick up loot and shoot each other a real nice wild western theme with great table presents um extremely digestible easy to teach has a gateway level game and
i think it does a great job of enticing new players because not only because the visual aspect but because the gameplay is fun it's unpredictable it's wild and in a good way you know normally i don't like games that can't be i don't have a good degree of autonomy over them but this one it all works in the favor and it's part of the charm of the game uh scale as well you know probably plays four to six or so players in in a in a really good fashion but the reason that didn't stay in the collection for me was a bit like coliseum really um played this one out quite a few times over the years um done everything it needs to do and again no no real instead to go back and play it anymore it would just be more of the same and um you know with so many games on the market i like to try new things and um getting top express just didn't have that extra reason to go back and play this one over something new so uh there's another 10 games there actually probably one of the the in fact definitely the strongest bunch of games that i've put on one of these lists yet yeah i don't really think i dislike any of these games um yeah actually i don't just like any of them whatsoever so they're all really strong games but for one reason or another just didn't quite stay in my my collection which i basically i do like to run quite a tight ship and only keep the best of the best um and these just didn't quite um have their claws in to stay or keeping their space on my shelf so i hope you've enjoyed this video if you have please hit like and subscribe to my channel and you can also check out my other videos too um and i hope you're enjoying
the series really so um i'll see you probably everybody else next time on chairman of the board bye