Skip to main content
Loading video...

Table Talk Back E11 - This Old House... Rule!

Transcript 15:49

hi everyone welcome to watch it play table talk back my name is Rodney Smith and I want to mention we had a donator of a fundraiser donated at The Advertiser level so I have a quick plug that I need to make right here Lamplight games has got a project up on Kickstarter called space junk and there is a character card that is strikingly familiar the artwork for the game is being done by John Arosa of mice and Mystics Fame and the graphic design is being done by Jamie kegy of the secret cabal gaming podcast so hopefully one of those factors encourages you to check this project out we'll put a link to it in the description of this video we'll be plugging it as this month goes on now before we move on to the topic I know I'm going to get asked about this setup and that's my own fault it's kind of hard to ignore all of this I am assembling right now the Miniatures to the Drop Zone Commander two-player starter set a lot of times the games I have set up in front of me during these table talk and TalkBack episodes are just games I'm learning playing or curious about at the time it's not necessarily an indicator that we're going to be covering those games it also provides a little visual variety to these episodes but this is one that I'm actually thinking about maybe doing a a gameplay sampler video for just to show you a round of play and in general how the game is played it's a Miniatures game so it's quite involved I don't think I'll do an entire series on it but that's part of the reason why I'm assembling these Miniatures here all right but now let's get into your contributions to our tabl talk discussion and I have these on the iPad this time people noticed I had these paper printes before and I was just throwing them out what a waste and what a great idea why not use this digital device instead the First Response comes

to us here from Misty Kau she says my sister taught our family to play Uno from Hell which features the house rule where anytime a card is played any number of players can play on it it gets really crazy when the wild draw four card starts flying then whoever is next to the last person who played a card gets bombarded with cards this rule definitely keeps you on your toes uh Misty I'm not even sure I entirely understand that house rule but it does sound crazy and a little bit intriguing so so thanks for sharing that that one with us gorgeous popsicle says I enjoy host rules but we don't often play with them because we don't remember the exact rules we've come up with the next time we're playing and halfway through a game we'll suddenly remember a house rule from before we really need to start writing these down uh I just thought this was a very Charming response and that's why I included this here and who doesn't like the name gorgeous popsicles Chris Brown says my gaming group enjoys playing Shadows over Camelot but we don't speak in character as the rules suggest okay listen I am not a big fan of house rules I indicated that in the first episode but I agree with you there anytime a game asks you to include some role playing in it if you feel like your group that you're playing with is just finding that uncomfortable then it's going to be awkward to do that and I certainly do not mind house ruling those kind of rules out of the game especially if it doesn't feel necessary like if you're playing a role playing game okay fine but if you're playing a board game where role playing is just an added amount of fluff and flavor they've thrown in there

yeah I'm fine moving on and not playing with those rules Ian OU says the closest I've come to a house rule is when we accidentally played a rule for Bonanza incorrectly for a long time without realizing it when we finally did discover our error we tried the correct rules and didn't like the game as much so we went back to our incorrect version I racked my brain for this because like Ian this happened to me but I can't can't remember which game it was and when I discovered the correct rule of course I started playing that way and I stuck with that correct rule because I again I I do prefer to avoid house rules where possible but like Ian I found that I didn't like the game as much as when we had been playing it incorrectly and I imagine this is probably more common than we realize I wonder if any of you have examples of that let me know in the comments if you do Grump Chong says we usually incorporate house rules in the interest of fairness for example in Dominion the game is supposed to end when the appropriate deck or decks are depleted but we will continue around until the player to the right of the starting player gets a turn so everyone has an equal number of turns essentially eliminating start player Advantage it's been a little while since I've played Dominion but I also dislike start player advantages and I really prefer when a game has some way of compensating for that sometimes they'll give the other players an increasing amount of starting gold or victory points or some some other way of balancing that out so I think that house rule sounds really good actually uh pillinger says I think you have to be careful when making a house rule that you don't break a game more

while you're trying to fix it take Monopoly free parking lengthens the game artificially as a player who is almost eliminated might get a second wind this was brought up a lot I'm not sure if you guys are familiar with this or not but there is a house rule Monopoly that has almost become a rule I know growing up I learned the house Rule and I didn't realize it was a house rule I thought I was playing the real way of playing Monopoly it was until I was older that I discovered it was wrong the idea here being that if you have to pay taxes or pay because of a card you've drawn then you put that money on the free parking space and then anyone who lands there collects all the money that's accumulated this means that players don't get eliminated as quickly as they should so the game of monopo can really stretch on and on and on and on and really for quite an arbitrary reason although there's a lots of arbitrary things that occur in Monopoly and that's one of the reasons why you have to be careful when your friends teach you games now I'm your friend and I'm going to teach you games but I have a lot of people watching and making sure that I don't insert some of my own mistaken interpretations into the rules when we create our rules videos Raphael B says I don't like house rules I prefer to beat the game like it is when my friends asked to use a house rule I feel like I'm cheating and if we want a game with host rules I feel frustrated Rafael I think you pinned it down I mean that's one of the biggest reasons why I struggle with host rules cuz I don't really feel like I'm playing the game correctly anymore and so if I win for whatever reason I don't feel like I really want especially if it's a Cooperative game and we're doing something that makes the game easier and also I find it's not quite as satisfying

it's another reason why I don't really like when uh designers to games include a whole bunch of variants at the back of the rule book hey here's a whole bunch of other ways you can play the game I feel like in that case the design didn't really know what they wanted to create so they're just throwing everything in and hoping you find something you like I much prefer when a desire presents here is the way I intend for you to play the game this is the best version of the game that I knew how to make I occasionally these variants can be helpful especially if they're variants to allow you to play solo or some other way Mike Bennett says for me rules tweaks should only happen if the written rules don't address it directly now that's another situation actually where I'm I'm quite okay with house ruling sometimes in the middle of a game you just because of certain card combinations there isn't something in the rule book that covers it maybe there really wasn't a good way for a rule book to cover every single combination so I do prefer pulling the group at the table and saying what do we think makes the most sense and hopefully coming up with a solution as quickly as possible so we can get on with the game e storus says in pandemic after placing the initial disease cubes we put down our first Research Center where we think it helps us the most instead of in Atlanta this way we feel we have a more diverse experience and we remove some of the randomness from the game now I normally don't like house rules that make games especially co-ops easier I said that already but that one I actually do kind of like interesting one thanks for sharing that Michael Carter says there are so many great games out there that play fine with the rules as written that I don't bother with house rules I'd rather just get rid of a poor game and play a game that was properly

play tested I don't have a lot to say to that Michael except that I tend to agree if I play a game and I don't like how it's playing my instinct isn't to change it it's just to put it aside and go play a game I actually do enjoy but that said uh byj says I think house rules can add more depth especially for games that you've played a ton of times at conventions we also use some house rules to make games easier to learn and understand but also to shorten the game play I think you actually raised two very good counterpoints there to my general dislike of house rules if you've played a game a lot you've kind of played it out but you you know you enjoyed it why not extend the life of it why not tweak it a little bit and try it in this new way so you can continue to play this game that you enjoy but maybe just in your own way also I feel like it if you play the game a lot then you understand how the game balances and works and you're less likely to incorporate a house rule that's going to break or or damage or imbalance the game in some way and talking about changing the rules to suit a situation I think West A Mountain built agrees and he said or she I only really do house rules with my children if there's something they don't or can't understand at their age but when they get older there will be no house rules or Mercy now that reminds me I house ruled the game of kazone when I was first teaching Luke we just removed the farmer rules cuz they were a bit more complicated um so yeah I I actually I think that is a good reason to house rule you're kind of testing my resolve here a little bit guys on my feelings towards house rules crabel 1337 or crab Elite says me and my group play The Lord

of the Rings living card game and ignore the rule that you're not allowed to tell someone else which cards you're holding in your hand this game is cooperative so you should in our opinion play together and plan together what's best for your group boy you guys are really making me feel like a hypocrite cuz I totally agree with that when I play that game I play with my cards face up on the table I encourage everyone else to as well and I get a lot more satisfaction at a feeling what we beat this very difficult game most of the time by having to really puzzle out how can we best work together I feel like it really makes us feel like we're doing this cooperatively as a team we're bringing the best to the table from our own decks and then seeing how they cleverly work together and I find that the most satisfying also when we lose we really feel like we lost together we did our best so it makes that defeat all the more crushing which I enjoy yeah maybe I do like house rules Gary Pearson says I generally don't house rule I figure someone who has way more experience than me took the time to put together the mechanics of the game and they must have had a reason to even if it's not immediately apparent to me Gary that is my instinct too when I play games especially when I'm first teaching a game and someone pipes up the table maybe within the first round and goes a this rule is broken that should be fixed and listen that's not to say that I have't occasionally encountered a rule right away in a game and I think how did this pass by the designer scrutiny and the play testers this doesn't work at all but my instinct is to believe that it has been play tested that there is a

purpose for the rule and that the game maybe should be played a couple of times before we pass that kind of judgment I do try on principle to trust the designer's instincts and not just their instincts but their efforts in play testing the game and making sure they got it right gears 894 says I personally like House Rules as long as everyone agrees that they don't mind using it before starting to play if I have any host rules I'd like to play with I first mention it to everyone and if we all agree that the rule would be better then we play with the house rule listen I think we can all agree that if you are going to play house rules that's the way to introduce to do at the start of the game make sure everyone's comfortable with the idea of using it and then go ahead and proceed if everyone agrees and I'd like to close with this comment from Robin Le who says once you've bought the game it's yours to do with as you see fit there aren't any rules police that are going to come knocking at the door if you don't abide by the rule book exactly at the end of the day if there's a rule that's just getting in the way of you being able to enjoy that game that you spent your money on then why not change it and get on with enjoying the game I certainly agree and you know I realized that I started this video in the original table talk episode being a little more staunchly against house rules and as this discussion went on and you guys provide these different responses I had to reconsider my position I think I actually am a little more open to host rules than I first imagined myself being now I want to sh share with you guys some of the video responses we received once again I really appreciate that I'm going to put a link in the description of this video to those separate individual responses you can go there and actually see the full responses but until the next

episode thanks for watching we decided that we would share one that we use in our household with the board game Dixon here's the game I'm sure you're familiar with it the house rule that we use with this game is to not allow people people use inside jokes to play the game yeah and in this game in particular it seems to make a lot of sense because if someone gives a clue that only one other person will get really alienates everyone else and that seems to make a lot of sense with this game in particular since a lot of the time it's used as a a Gateway game in order to get people who usually don't uh play board games more into them the objective is not so much to win as it is just to have a good time yeah exactly to make the game harder I think is always worth some some R wolves I just remember a great example of this is about the Richard l r rules for horror that he posted on the Fant flight website while ago and and it was clear for me that the I think it's 13 rules he added there and it became clear for me that the some of those rul should be in the game since since for the start of the game and maybe he they didn't put there just because with with you made the game way harder for starter and for casual players oh hi Rodney I watch it play players Watchers chaps and

Chets let's talk about house rules now house rules don't mean you cook I clean let me tell you a funny story about households before going into what I believe we should be doing with house RS this beautiful game played it for many many many years with my family and cousins and uncles and aunties and we loved the hell out of it I then migrated to France and I played it with my French family but we played and they were playing it wrong and then it occurred to me that I've never ever read the rules so I read the rules and you know what my friend family were playing it to the letter they would play exactly the rules as they should be played and it was my English family my side of the family that had adapted and made house rules for this game and played it their way and thought that was the way they we supposed to be that was how it felt to me you know this is how I was taught the game so let me sum up house rules house rules are for groups of people that have played a game many times and enjoyed the game but but have tweaked it to make it their own and make it play better and make more enjoyment for them to sum up quickly house rules are good if you're playing with an existing group of people who played the same game households are bad if you're teaching new people because if you teach

them and they go away and play that game with other people and they play with their house rule that you've taught them and the other group of people are actually playing by the real rules they're gonna feel a bit of a a wheel weating yeah so house rules rule one house rule I forgot to mention is I am always the green player

Progress saved