Top 10 Board Games With Smooth Gameplay
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm talking about my top 10 smooth board games so these are the games that do a great job of ironing out the creases that can potentially cause players to disengage from the game for example they don't have overly complicated rules they don't have too many rounds or phases or get bogged down in a fiddly housekeeping or anything like that so these do a great job of keeping players engaged from start to finish so at number 10 i have navigator by mac gertz now this is a rondelle based game as you are taking actions based on this action wheel where you can move one to three spaces which can either let you kind of build ships that can let you travel along the map and it can let you invest in point scoring opportunities uh invest in warehouses where you can buy and sell goods and set up plantations and things or colonies is absolutely a wonderful euro experience but the way this game does such a great job of keeping players engaged in the game and keep things flowing smoothly is that there are no distinct phases at all there are um although there's three kind of sections in the game where at one point you um the cost will ramp up into investing doing certain things um it does that in a free-flow manner because when a certain people get to a certain checkpoint in the game on the map by traveling a certain distance then all the prices automatically hike up which can really affect the flow and the feel of the gameplay and um just really do kind of throw a span in the works how people approach the game a really great game i said no housekeeping at all it's just a wonderful game where you can invest in different scoring points and different
ways to scoring points because you can you know invest in maybe in focusing on exploring locations or focus on all your different colonies or different things like that so a really solid euro game and i think it's sneaked into my top 10 this year so that's how highly i think of navigator and a big portion of that is because it is so free-flowing and um really smooth once it's on the table so number 10 i have navigator at number nine i have istanbul uh which is a kind of a a middleweight euro game maybe on the lower end of that um as you are moving these discs around the ball around the board which is made up of all these different modular tiles so you have a stack of these discs and you are moving one or two spaces and dropping a worker off from where you when you ended up your move and then taking the corresponding action it's a race style game as you are trying to collect resources and trade them in trying to collect money and trade them in all to get these rubies um because the first person to get ruby or a certain amount of rubies is going to be the winner but again this game doesn't have any rounds or phases it's just completely just taking turns um until you fulfill the five or six objectives that you need in order to win the game and then it will stop right stop right there and then so a really free-flowing game one that doesn't um one that doesn't ever stop it's always ticking along nicely that race element shines through really strongly and i think a big part of that race and tension is because there is no start and stopping in the game it's just always churning forward and um building
momentum throughout and that's why istanbul is my number nine at number eight i have architects of the west kingdom now while architects of the west kingdom isn't one of my favorite games it's um a really solid kind of entry level worker placement game which you do all the normal things such as collecting resources trading them for buildings and so on and a lot of people will talk highly about certain aspects of this game which is actually not what i want to focus on on this particular um particular speech already um so a lot of people say oh this is great because you know the compounding resource gathering so when you put workers on a certain spot and when you put another one there you get double the resources and you put another one there you get three times the resources and so on so that kind of forward forward momentum is really nice um additionally you can choose to kind of round up and arrest other people's play player pieces if you think they're being too greedy by going to a certain spot but all of that is is great but the thing that i really took away from this game was that the game doesn't have any rounds off phases whatsoever is constantly ticking along um because as i said when you you have so many workers but when you run out of workers you're generally going to have quite a few on a certain spot which means that somebody else is going to round them all up and send them to jail and you get them back as a certain action and you just keep playing along and i think this game did a really good job of that um there's lit next to no disengagement whatsoever and i find that with a lot of these um or most of them in fact probably 99 of these work placement games you know you're placing things onto the board either taking it rewards instantly and then at the end of the round collecting them all back
or you're kind of laying them all out and then collecting all your rewards at once whereas this one you don't have that stopping at all that's always moving forward and again there's no stopping and starting no tedious housekeeping and um i thought that deserves high praise and certainly one that um holds its height or holds its own on this list even though it's not particularly my um you know my i like the game but it's not one of my favorite games at number seven i have the palaces of carrara so this is a game that doesn't really get talked about too much i think it's not the easiest game to get hold of this is a kramer and keystone game another kind of resource management game as you're collecting marble and building buildings but in this game not only is it extremely streamlined but you are always just taking one of three actions again with no housekeeping whatsoever apart from adding a few bricks onto this resource wheel and when it's your turn so all you're going to do is you're going to kind of take resources from this wheel which is going to fluctuate in costs at least in terms of the marble you want to get you're either going to do that you're going to build a building or you're going to score one of your criteria because you have kind of five different cities or six different cities i forget um and you're going to score kind of all the all the buildings that you've built in those cities either being points or money but the the interesting thing about this game is that you don't actually have any particular points where you're building score you actually get to choose when you score your buildings but it has this kind of chicken chicken mechanism where you can only score a certain type of building or a certain city once and if you do that then you're going to
stop your opponent from doing that so that's where the kind of the tension comes in rather than being any race in terms of phases or anything like that it really is player driven but again with next uh well no phase whatsoever completely free-flowing and um no housekeeping at all apart from placing a few bricks and a few new tiles on the board from round to round which is um completely uh a breeze so that's why uh planets passes of carrara is at number seven uh at number six i have kashgar merchants of the silk road so a game that i almost considered putting on the list was splendor splendor really popular kind of engine building games you're collecting towels and using those i'm sorry um collecting poker chips and using those chips to buy cards this one has a similar kind of mechanism where you are kind of building an engine of cards up but you have three columns and at the front of those columns you're going to have a card and you're going to choose to activate one of those cards and then move it to the back of the row um you're going to be using that to either kind of collect resources or fulfill contracts but again this is all you're going to do from start to finish everyone's going to be doing the same thing constantly expanding their different caravans which are these columns of cards in order to be as efficient as they can in order to fulfill those contracts quicker than their opponents do it's a race style game where i think you're racing to get to 25 points um it doesn't take very long but again it doesn't have anything that's that draws this to a halt you know you can plan your turns ahead you can um you know your turns are over in just a few seconds and then it will go on to the next person so
it has that real um engaging up time where you're constantly head down in your cards and trying to weigh up what you're going to do next and um again no scope to be disengaged or lose interest for this game because it does just keep you on your toes and keeps playing along really nicely and has some nice satisfying combinations and synergies and things and which you can really sink your teeth into so that's why kashgar merchants of the silk road is at number six at number five i have probably the smoothest um and simplest game on the list this is um blue lagoon but the reason why this isn't at number one is because it does actually have um the game is pretty much cut in half where the first part of the game is played out everything's taken off the board pretty much and then you start again so that's the only reason why it wasn't higher on the list but still it comes this highly because the actual time when you are playing the game is so simple and smooth so all you're going to do on this game is you're either going to well the i should explain what the board looks like first so the board is going to be this map of all these different islands of different sizes and you're going to be putting these tokens down onto the board just these little desks and you're going to be using them trying to either link up the different islands you're trying to collect different resources for set collection bonuses you're trying to have the majority by having certain the most amount of tokens on each building and so on so you've got all these kind of very simple ways of getting points that have been used in so many other games but because it is simply just a matter of placing a disk down continuing from where you've left off and just spreading out your presence on the board it just does go tick along really quickly and all it is just put your disc down your opponent does and so on
and go back and forth and halfway through the game you are going to um well an option is to place these buildings down in the first round and then from the second round of the game you play exactly the same way but you can expand from where you left your buildings in the first round so a slight tweak which can add some quite interesting elements of strategy and give you some nice lucrative spots to try and lay claim to for the second round but yeah certainly one of the games that has next to no scope in terms of analysis paralysis but still has meaningful and interesting decisions and lots of ways to get points and just a testament to uh reina knitschu's designing prowess because um he does do a great job of streamlining games down to the core and um but i think for me blue lagoon is the best example of that so at number five i have blue lagoon at number four i have paris uh another game by um kramer and kiesling uh this one came out last year so i think it's the most recent game from this list um and this is uh i suppose a game of two mechanisms one being area control or area majority and one being kind of a time track where you have this track or this line of different tiles which you can move your piece as far as you want along to get the bonus but you can never move yourself back but all you do on your turn in this game is you take um a new tile from a stack and put it on one of these cities and you know where these um what districts these cities are going to go in but you don't know exactly which ones they're going to be and then you're going to either place a key on a new spot to either um you know lay claim to or to kind of
invest in a certain spot and get money um and uh give yourself the option to uh move your presence up in that region um or you can choose to jump up from where you already are into the next highest level building or to the next building by paying the difference and i'm trying to get the majority at the end of the round as soon as there is a number of keys in a certain location then there's going to be another area majority um score track where you try trying again trying to chunk your opponents and get the most points but again a game that doesn't have anything else other than that always moves along nicely um doesn't have any um anything to slow the game down apart from just drawing the tile each turn and adding it onto the board and i think this does a great job of being a fresh and clean design in 2020 while still having nice core and strong mechanisms and having enough interest in gameplay um to balance out with that with that smoothness um which which just does a solid game in its whole in this whole kind of um in its entirety so that's why paris is at number four uh number three i have a game that i don't talk about very often actually but a game that's immensely popular this one is scythe by stonemaier games this one is a engine building again another area majority style game i suppose a hybrid between euro mechanisms and american american game style mechanisms where you are trying to um you basically start on the corner of these big maps and you're trying to build up an engine trying to spread your presence out trying to manage resources to build new mechs
which are going to be used to um you know traverse the board and collect tokens and lots going on in this game is another kind of race style element as well actually where you want to be the first to fulfill a certain number of objectives such as um you know beating your opponent in battle a certain amount of times or getting to a certain point in these tracks for example um but what what really did stick about my in my mind about this game is how free-flowing and how smooth it is because all you do is you take one of these actions and by moving your pawn on your player board into a new region paying amount of resources and taking action based of it based on that um but you are constantly investing in upgrading your board making smoother and more cheap and efficient um but a bit like um a lot of these other games that they're you know you are so focused on your own player board you don't get bored on other players terms because they are so um so easy to make a decision and to um keep things moving that you aren't really bogged down by the kind of announcer process of other people again no boring phases or cleanup phases or anything like that just and for probably one of the most involved games on the list and this one does a really magnificent job of managing all the different systems involved without bogging it down with with housekeeping or anything boring that's going to again cause people to lose interest so i think that's probably one of the key reasons why scythe is so popular because it did such a great job of smoothing out all those edges and just to keep people involved in the gameplay and that's why scythe is at number three
at number two i have a bit of a modern classic with hanza to tonica now this is uh i suppose a root building style game with another element of engine building where you're taking one of only a few uh actions such as adding cubes onto the ball to build these routes and once you complete a route you can invest in trying to control these different cities and you're trying to build up links of those cities etc so pretty dry euro mechanisms but um because you have a real cool economy of um of keeping resources flowing through your system just by taking simple actions then again you don't have to you know at the end of phases you don't have to do collect all things off the board and bring them back into your pool and be able to use again that is actually embedded in the in the actions you take themselves and i think that's fantastic and i think a lot of that kind of elegance and grace of these classic euro games is lost nowadays they they don't often strike the balance of being um smooth and efficient um with be having the interesting rule set and the crunchy decisions behind it i think a lot of them kind of focus on you know let's throw as much as we can in the game who cares if we have a really tedious cleanup phase and phases and rounds and those things you've got to manage um but hanson detonica completely transcends that does a great job of just having quick snappy turns where you're constantly building momentum and putting things on the ball collecting new regions um investing in your own player board and ramping up and being more efficient at other things just a brilliant game one of the one of
the great euros really and one that stood the test of time um really strongly um maybe not going to be for everybody in terms of its dryness you know it doesn't have any theme whatsoever it's not the most exciting thing to look at unless you like this kind of dry euro aesthetic but still i don't think you can knock how smooth and well implemented the rules are um and do and do a great job of just um i said being smooth and um and fun gameplay and finally at number one the game that popped into my mind instantly when i thought about making this list this is concordia another game by matt gertz who designed navigator which was the number 10 on this list um navi uh sorry concordia is uh another i suppose uh a game where you're traversing them out building trade posts um trying to manage resources to buy new cars to give you more scoring opportunities but i love the hand management system in this game that keeps people clicking along here because all your actions are dictated by cards you have in your hand but when you run out of cars because you can't use them um back-to-back you know once you play them they're played until you play another car to pick them all back up into your hand to be able to go again and because everybody's doing the same thing there's never a point where everybody collects all their cars together they're all just investing in their own little engine and building their own routes but there's some good player interaction involved as you're kind of stepping on each other's toes and getting other places before other people making making things more expensive for them but yeah this one does the the best job just because of that card system and um just again you can map several terms in advance has a real deep gameplay satisfying
decisions um great strategies but still having such an elegant card mechanism which is just absolutely magnificent and i think one of the strongest um objective designs out there on the market because it is just a real um a real sign an example of design finesse and by matt gertz and uh one of the euros that i think everybody should try and i think even a lot of people who don't like euro games who think you know they're boring and dry whatever um i've never really heard anybody look at concordia and say that wasn't good because it really is fantastically balanced fantastically designed and a big part of that is because of how smooth it plays so this that concludes my top 10 smooth board games i hope you enjoy the list something a bit different if you have enjoyed the list please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too and also i'd really appreciate if you check out my patreon page where you can back just a couple of pounds a month in order to keep the channel going uh for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye