Skip to main content
Loading video...

Skipping Crowdfunding - Plunging into Direct to Print

Transcript 20:33

hey everybody edo here and today i'd like to talk about something new that pencil first games is doing which is we just launched a pre-order campaign for delicious and sunset over water pocket edition so that's really interesting because it's the first two games that we are bringing to pre-order but to retail and distribution and our wet our web store um without going to kickstarter so pencil first games started with liftoff get me off this planet and we have done a kickstarter for every game since i mean and i've done a lot of kickstarters i mean i think we just finished deluxe hanafuda set in the 100 torrid diverging paths just on monday and i think that was our 18th kickstarter right so we've done a lot of kickstarter so the purpose of this meeting meeting the purpose of this um video is really to give some perspective on how we made the decision pros cons risks rewards as other publishers and kickstarter creators are considering skipping kickstarter and and you know for us it was a little bit of a perfect storm if you will call it that but anyway i thought it'd be fun to talk through it i think to give perspective we have to back up sort of into pandemic times or early pandemic times and so pencil first games was running as fast as we could doing kickstarters making titles etc and then the pandemic hit

which had a really big impact on the 100 tory because we launched literally into lockdown um and then or like the week before week after lockdown and then at the same time amongst the pandemic issues there then was the escalating ship and container pricing crisis right which persists today and at the time i sort of decided that i wanted to take a break from kickstarter not because i had any problem with kickstarter per se though there has been drama around with their web 3 and blockchain stuff just for another video but um because i didn't have clarity or confidence in manufacturing shipping timing expense costs and i didn't want to do a kickstarter being a commitment that i felt like i was obligated to meet which you should be but that we wouldn't be able to do it and so what ends up happening at that time is but i'm still working on making games with a variety of folks and we got to a position pencil first games where we had and if you go look at the video probably from uh the end of the year video i do uh for 2021 or 2020 i don't remember but i talked about a lot of these titles we had delicious so we had fully forest which we did do a kickstarter for but then after philipparous we then had delicious sunset over water pocket edition mall peak ruins and ruins which is the little solo solo game from all peak

and skulk hollow the 100 torrey diverging past this lovely dog that's making some noise but the 100 tutorial diverging paths all of which were in really good shape basically kickstart ready even our next kickstarter the siblings from trouble expanded deluxe edition is also you know well on its way and so and at the time kickstarter had not made the official statement they have today which is kickstarter creators can do three campaigns if they have a good track record it used to be an unstated thing and there was risk and so pennsylvania's games had done maybe one or two but we had never gone three deep or more right and so you know to some extent there was a concern on just just i had so many titles i could go to kickstarter and you know to some extent you can bundle games together and do group kickstarters but i wasn't they weren't so the same to do something that was like you know all the games being manufactured together and here's our dr finn's games have done has done like the 2023 games um it didn't fit exactly and actually i didn't want the compounded risk of it so i was sitting on a deluge of unpublished ready to go stuff and to some extent part of the conversation was like well how can we speed this up how can we come to market around the same time pencil first games had seen a a decent boon over pandemic in terms of uh players like flippers did really well coming to

market and herbaceous was still selling well and we had a little bit of a uh um a little bit more of a cushion than we normally have financially right we had a little bit more money to spare so one they lose their products two we had some additional money available to us and then three you know uh i don't know if i'd call it a sister company but thunder works games like dr finn's games thunder works games are like very two companies i talk with steve and keith matega very often and follow them along and there are a lot of other companies i deal with on a regular basis but uh steve because i work with him on a ton of games but keith as well and keith and thunder works games had seen a lot of great success with cartographers which was direct um torito skipped kickstarter ultimately they did cartographer heroes on kickstarter but the original title wasn't and so you know there was an interesting engagement on saying hey maybe it makes sense for us to print on our own and go for it the other thing so i guess there's another factor for us was herbaceous you know continues to be successful but flip first did really well out of the gate and we wanted to reprint so essentially part of the calculation was okay how many do how many how much product we need from those other games and then essentially i said hey like how close can i get to filling a

20-foot container a 40-foot container and what would that mean like what would it mean if i just wanted to do reprint product what would it mean if i did delicious and i worked through all the cvm and calculations and came to the conclusion that there was this uh mythic container that we could fill uh that would be essentially reprints as well as the new titles so you know we took a a large gamble so i mean the i the reprints are not large gambles the reprints are a little bit about how much we're going to print whatever but those titles have you know generated their their sort of reprint dollars as they go through it but certainly not pre-funding games is is is is a large amount of risk that we've never taken on for an unknown title and i thought about in a couple ways well one way was in regards to delicious you know and and delicious is i think a little bit more expensive to manufacture than herbaceous certainly but also full of first because it has the the pencils and the bag and it has the 200 card you know pads and things like that so it's a pretty heavy full small box but you know it's in our most successful at least in terms of quantity line right this this box this family is pencil first game's most successful herbaceous drives that but philliphous has been strong within that and um and also because it's small it's you

know manufacturing a game at a two dollar or three dollar or whatever price point is very different than manufacturing game or an eight or nine or ten price point right uh in terms of upfront financial cash that you need um also uh the art development was a little less on this than say uh fuller first there just wasn't as many cards and so the variety of reasons that this was a little bit more compact price risk-wise so it was a great combination of lower risk because it's the cheaper smaller game a lower cost excuse me lower cost and then lower risk because it sits in a family that is like ultimately needs to stand on its own and everyone should love this fantastic game but it's a game that is in a family that is has proven to be pretty strong for us and it's built on not just these small games but the what not cabinet and herbaceous sprouts and the 100 torrey a whole line of products that we've been building building around in terms of sunset over water pocket this is interesting because this is a small title this uh from a uh there's very little new art there's not no new art it's mostly graphic design of shrinking everything down but the the upfront cost of producing for of of developing this is limited uh you don't have to do rule you know the rules are reduced rules but like you're not play test you know you know it's just a smaller version of a game so that that helps

and then you know because of the success of herbaceous pocket edition but also the limited print right like these th this is a title that you know will you know i think we did 2 000 units right and so we're we you know this is this is a good solid two to three year supply um but it was something that um you know we've been very happy with this sort of ongoing performance of herbaceous pocket edition and we're eager to continue to build out our web store so this is going into retail this isn't this never goes into retail this is pencil first games only as is their basics pocket edition um as will be hanafuda as will be the flippers pocket edition albeit this this is this is not manufactured but fully for us pocket edition which is something that we're going to do next year um so which we announced on the dice tower summer event or something like that but so you know pencil first games is very active and regularly engaging the retail sector we've continued to do kickstarters but we've been trying to build out the space so a lot of time has passed since that decision point and you know when when time passes other budgeting things come into cons into play and you're like man i really wish i had that 20 grand i really wish i had that 30 40 grand um it does make you question or consider whether or not you know it made the most sense to to bypass the kickstarter because really it's just the risking that group right i think you know pencil first games has had a

really strong track record and has a strong audience and i i don't think it's going to be a killer campaign but certainly you could you know be confident in that if i did a kickstarter for a a title that fits in this line a thousand or two thousand backers or fifteen hundred you know a thousand to fifty hundred backers it's like a pretty you know that's a pretty core audience that really likes these titles this look this space steve finn's design etc and so um but anyway we didn't do that and uh decided to bring them to market together now what did that do well it meant that i could jump right in and go into mall peak and then move into haunted food and the 100 tory and still have a release this year right those titles are not coming out this year so basically pencil first games would have no release if we had done a kickstarter and waited the additional time you know these titles wouldn't be hitting this year would be hitting next year so once we decide to do all this we move forward with it um i have looked at the the locked up money and been like man it would have been nice to have that money in advance um but we made our decision and you can't want to print it but you know again the risk due to the size um was a little lower um and then part of the next interesting little bit about this was just like sort of like how do we want to release it and ultimately i felt like well this is our opportunity to draw people to our web store um you know let's let's do them together as a pre-order together incentivize it where on our web store right now if you back two things it doesn't have to be

these two it could be delicious and proliferous or some sort of a water pocket and herbaceous pocket would give you an additional five dollars off and just drive people during the pre-order period to check out our shop.pencilversegames.com and pre-order also i mean it's super neat right from a kickstarter comparison perspective is you know i as of right now actually where the product is has has landed at port and it's going to be unloaded and then shipped and then has to ship here for fulfillment but you know i don't know exactly but somewhere in the next four to five or six weeks i'll have it right so this is like pre-order and then within six weeks you're gonna get your game and then we'll release it to retail um and that's really exciting it's just exciting to have somebody buy something they're they are interested and get it somewhat soon afterwards as opposed to um kickstarter where you can wait a year right um so we we you know and and so timing was interesting we could have launched before the hanafuda we could have had a larger window and launched before hanafuda and diverging path we were really busy and i didn't want to create any distractions or confusion so i didn't and then we could have launched during but that seemed even worse so we we i talked about it with jessica and we decided hey let's tori kick started go through and then when it's done apparently the next day which she told me the day of was also her birthday which i was like he could have said something but um we we decided to do the pre-order directly after pre-order campaign is

pretty straightforward community page newsletter right we we we're not doing some big spend but we hit folks that we you know or know are interested in our stuff and move through it from conversations with keith and some other folks i had really modest expectations for um the pre-order program um i expected any like low pre-orders at 50 like high at 300 like maybe a little bit more but that was sort of where we are i think right now we're at like 120 right so you know not the low and i think by the end of it at the current pace getting to about 200 seems like it's going to happen maybe 250. um so that's about us and so we budgeted i i we've we've we've met the budget i ass budget as in like the target revenue i was expecting to generate with this so so i met the the p l ver the budget of it um and it's performed you know the way i had hoped in that these some of these orders are delicious or some of these orders are sensitive over water pocket but that's actually the minority i would say the orders are oftentimes both or the pairs and the pairs or you know we've got a number of orders that's like these plus two other games right so it's it's had a good synergy and driven a lot of additional revenue um from from our web store which is great um ultimately whether this was a good idea or a bad idea comes down a lot to how so sensitive water is going to perform pretty

it'll have a little bump and then it'll just be a regular ongoing seller from our website over time like for years and that'll be that like i'm not worried about it we printed a comparable amount or basis pocket edition which we still haven't sold out of and i think it's just going to be part of our line of stuff the cool thing is in our new prints those all those new reprints and stuff we actually talk about our web store more and what's in it whereas that was sort of a little more unknown so we'll see if we get a bump there but financially this is sort of is what it is really the whether or not this risk was worth it and and and all things consider is going to come down to how delicious done we did a a a relatively i don't know we we had we did a decent size print um one that so so what did we bring we printed seven thousand that's a big number seven thousand though is incomparable to what we've been doing in these titles in that typically from the kickstarter you'll sell about fifteen hundred to two thousand and then for a first-round title of of about this size um coming in at bringing about five thousand of retails about where pencil first games is today um and typically what that means is we will sell one to two thousand copies sort of like immediately like sort of like buy-in retailers amazon whatever and then

then it'll you know turn into a 50 or 100 or 50 100 ongoing depending on the title you could see it go big or go small whatnot cabinet first print like went really fast and second print swoller full forest was just a really consistent seller and sold out um so you know it's going to come down to a market response but you know even if i think delicious did poorly what we look at is we say okay well what if like what's the break even what if delicious you know only sells that initial 2000 and then sort of go swell what is that gonna mean well you know over time as you've been a publisher long and long you'd say well you know if this turns into a not a one year supply or six month supply but a three year supply well that's okay what the downside again is in considering this is obviously the pent-up cash and the risk of it there i think we've made decisions to minimize that risk and two i mean there's some other fault you know like not that you know you build a kickstarter audience and engaging and hitting that you know and working on producing titles for them is actually part of our audience so a lot of people will not know about it because it wasn't on kickstarter and internationally it's rough we didn't do a bunch of hubs and pre-orders internationally i shipped everything to the states which on one hand was like a big way easier for pencil first games but it does mean that if somebody wants to order it it's much more challenging in fact you know this will hit retail it'll go out but

you know if if if if you don't want to pay shipping you just some sort of water isn't going to be an option internationally because it's not going to be in retail now there's a not a silver lining but a back stop is i know what the title is after this title i know that we're going to do philipph's pocket edition so i i have to decide whether or not we're going to skip kickstarter with those titles i can and then basically maybe pencil first game says the small stuff on her own and the big stuff like skull hollows and mall peaks on on kickstarter or the weird stuff like kanafuda um but it might be that this didn't you know ultimately i i it does fine but you know not like i not i don't want to like set aside that much money or or possibly just the economy is such that pencil first games can't take on that risk like this we decided we could take it on um and not jeopardize anything else because we have to deliver other titles but it might be that we say you know what cool experiment don't want to do it again and then we do a fuller first pocket edition kickstarter and then if we did that i would say hey you can get this and you get a basis pocket and then we'd move some product that way and then be able to handle it international and if we do another one of these titles you know you add this to that campaign as a reprint if everything went well or just you know a smaller print and then you service the kickstarter backers and also international backers uh and and re you know get you know the publicity of seeing it again so

um super interesting decision super interesting thought process i just wanted to like express it uh so that um if you're considering these things you could take this into account so anyway uh if you're not familiar with either of these or you are or you just want to support pencil first games do check them out do share let people know that they're available but really the purpose of this is to give everyone some cool perspective awesome thanks bye hey everybody edo here and thanks for watching gaming with edo reviews over here on this playlist league and insider videos over here on this one subscribe share all that good stuff but most importantly play some great games thanks bye

Progress saved