10 Board Games Ranked - Episode 31
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another chairman of the board ranking video so whenever I play 10 new to me board games I make a video like this and I rank those games for my least favorite up to my most favorite and it normally includes quite a diverse range of games now before I get started on these 10 games I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer and if you use the link in my show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order number 10 I have a cheating moth now this is part of the Cockroach Poker series of games and in this one you are trying to shed this hand of cars by following the last player to play a card but the Twist on this one is that there are these moth cards in your hand and you cannot shed them without cheating essentially and each each round is going to be a kind of a sheriff style player who is trying to monitor all the other players and tried to catch them cheating um because again the only way you can get rid of those cards is by Choosing by either you know you could throw them on the floor you could try double drop a card you could tuck them up your sleeve um and so on so I could see the gimmick here and I can see what they were trying to go for but for me it was a bit too wild a bit too chaotic and a bit too ungovernable really so not really my style of game but I can see if you have the right group or if you're playing with kids they might quite find it quite funny but for me it just it kind of goes off the rails and that novelty Factor runs thin pretty quickly and I didn't really have the patience to just watch
every player like a hawk and see what they were doing so again a bit of a bit of a jarring game with my own personal taste and that's why I didn't really enjoy it so that is cheating moth at number 10. at number nine I have Dragon's Gate college now this is an older dice drafting game by nskn who are the modern day board and dice and on this one I can see why it's not quite as refined as a lot of the other dice drafting games put out by that company but I did like one of the mechanisms here where if you would draft a die belonging to another player then they would also get to take an action of that same value and what you're trying to do here is a lot of traditional Euro stuff building a bit of a polyamino thing on your player board trying to climb a bunch of tracks um the idea of this one is that you are trying to improve the skills of these students these kind of Wizardry students and then send them up these different spots on the board to get some points but if somebody sends them to a certain spot then nobody else can go there so it's a bit of a race in that respect and again other than that a bunch of tracks you're going down getting bonuses um getting money converting money into points at that kind of stuff now for me this game was no it was a bit of a mess of what it was trying to do with how it actually played out because it feels like a Euro game but there were so many elements that just felt a bit wild a bit random a bit swingy um especially when it came to these card draws because you'd end up drawing these cards
that were just you know arbitrarily let you climb tracks and it would give every player bonuses and money and it you know if with these Eurostar games you want something with a bit a bit of an autonomy something with a planning and it was very meticulously balanced things out and stuff whereas this one it just kind of showered you in resource resources and a lot of that wasn't even your own doing so I felt like I had very little control in this one and planning wasn't really rewarded I just thought overall it fell into this execution and was a bit of a mess so I can see why this one has faded Into Obscurity I wouldn't really recommend it considering how many Great die strappers are out there at this time at number eight I have Mycelia now this was a prototype version of the game because the game is launching on Kickstarter in September but this is an abstract strategy game all about mushrooms and where you are essentially trying to spawn these mushrooms on the board um use them to create spores which will give you more influence to build more mushrooms essentially but I did like some things going on here in terms of the movement of your mother mushroom where you could look at the Players you could steal their spores you could chain your spores together you could block players in and I did like this card tucking system as well where once you once you've built these mushrooms and you've exhausted them you could tuck them behind your player board which will give you a follow-up bonus and even let you build a little bit of an engine which is quite unusual for an abstract strategy game now I did have a few issues with it mostly when it comes to the usability um you know I am colorblind this game was not colorblind friendly at all um an
issue that I believe is being fixed for the final version of the game and it also felt the game outstanders welcome by a little bit um and there were also some things that I thought could possibly rub some people the wrong way because you know with an abstract strategy game you tend to like them to be a bit more predictable this one the way you spread your spores on the board was semi-random because you'd have to roll this die which will show which direction the wind blew now I didn't mind that at all but just objectively thinking I could see that maybe fans of pure abstracts might not find that to enjoyable because again they want that predictability with this style of game but check out my full review if this one interests you it sent me a beautiful looking game it has a lot of upsides but one that I'm not sure quite gels with my own personal tastes at number seven I have a royal visit now this is a rhino canitzia tug of war Style game as you're trying to manipulate these five pieces on this track now you're essentially trying to get the king to your area um or you are trying to kind of gradually pull this Crown to your area and that is going to be um determined by the positioning of the different pieces on the map and you're going to do that by playing these cars in your hand to either move the pieces you have some special powers that you can use by kind of teleporting certain pieces along or moving this whole Court along because the king piece cannot actually move um outside the parameters of his two guards that sit on either side of him and that's added some pretty pretty cool um situations that you could use to your
advantage or used to block your opponent Etc so these tug of war style games can generally don't work for me but I thought I'd give this one a go because I do love running clear the game so much um I love the look of this game it's produced wonderfully and I just I just love the vibe of it but I still don't think I can get away from that rigidness of the tug of war no I do something then you undo it then I do it again and it kind of becomes a bit tedious to me but despite that what that this game does have a few more tricks up its sleeves and a few more exciting moments than those traditional tug of war style games but I don't think it did quite enough um also I thought that luck was quite significant in this game you know by the card you've had um in your hand but the game was quick enough to kind of forgive that I suppose so one that I think is objectively a pretty good game but I don't think I'll be leaning to play this one above so many other great two-player games in my collection at number six I have Olympus so this is from the estari series of games from um over 10 years ago this is from 2011 and this is kind of an abstracted civilization Style game as you are trying to spread your influence on this map when you control these regions you're going to have access to more resources you're going to use those resources in order to buy new technologies to get better more efficient and more powerful at doing different things in the game the coolest thing about this game though is the fact that it uses a Time Track
and I've never seen that before in a game of this magnitude I suppose at least in relation to being a you know a sip Style game where you know the player furthest behind on the time track keeps on taking actions um until they overlap the other players and then again the player behind will then get their turn and it'll be pretty cost or expensive in terms of time to buy these new technologies but you could get discounts on them um you could even end up I'm getting bonuses by getting a bunch of the Technologies from the same column in order to get kind of discount on these big chunks of points through these monuments a remarkably smooth game one that I did enjoy a lot actually and it you know objectively at least in isolation in terms of maybe playing this game once um I would say this could probably sit higher on this list but thinking ahead I think this game severely lacks in replayability I think once you've seen everything you've kind of seen everything um but again there's some really cool things to do here I like the way the combat Works in terms of if you are the attacker you will always win the combat but depending on each player's military strengths it would cost you more or less time so I really like the way that worked it's a very simplified refined version of resolving combat and you can even get these cool bonus cards where if you collected certain symbols when you've got to a certain point to the time track you get bonuses or penalties depending on how many of these Zeus kind of icons you had on your Tableau um I did enjoy it a lot again I can only really knock some points off because of
the lack of replayability but I'm really glad I'm glad I played it and as a piece of game design I think quite highly of it but next year sadly because I can't Advocate the replayability and it has to sit at number six this time at number five I have Cuba now Cuba is a kind of a Midway Euro um that really does focus on that supply and demand mechanism it's a card driven Style game as each each of your terms you are playing one of these five cards out which will give you an action um you can use this actions to kind of buy and sell Goods again the more um a market is filled up of certain type of good it means you're going to sell it for a few of coins um if that Market's empty you're going to sell it for a chunk of coins you can build buildings to get build your engine up and go to convert resources into other resources um you can make these deliveries to these ships and get big points that way the longer those ships have been in the docks the more points they're going to be worth um but that kind of tug of water is going to go on there because if you leave it too long then other players are going to sneak in there before you I really love the individual player boards in this game as one of the roles is that you harness resources based on the rows and columns on your personal player board it kind of reminds me of a game called Santa Maria if you are familiar with that one and my favorite thing about this game was the fact that the role that you didn't choose would give you votes in terms of influencing the state of the board so it let you do things such as changing the prices of tax that you'd have to pay changing the kind of um
tariff you'd have to play in terms of giving resources back to the game to get victory points and we would let you change um just pure Point scoring methods so you could say I'm going to use all my votes in order to make sure that people get points based on how many buildings they have and of course if you have more buildings than your opponents you're going to do what you can to get that law into play and I always love it when games um use that mechanism it reminded me of a game called Lancaster where again you could change the laws through influence I'm a bit like Olympus I think this game is pretty excellent I think it's very good but once you've played it you've kind of played it and you've seen everything so again as a piece of board gaming design I think it is fantastic but I don't think it can go the distance and it does doesn't quite have that mileage to keep on coming back to this one and I know there is a very highly touted expansion for this one which I have not got and I have not played so maybe that would inject a lot more life into it um but I really like the design I really enjoy my play of it it looks amazing now this is like the quintessential example of how I like my board games to look and feel um but yes sadly I don't really feel the hook to come back to it despite me enjoying it so much at four I have pinata now this is another two player only game it's a hand management game as you're playing cards on your side of these um boards that will flip over so what you're essentially trying to do is that you are playing cards on your side to match with these sweet tokens
uh which color color code with each other and once you've played a certain amount of cards on your side you can start playing them on your opponent's side to start trying to sabotage their score and these kind of um scoring tokens are always flipping from going to wanting to be the play with the lowest amount of cards or the lowest value of cards to the highest value and so on you're collecting these candies in order to um build up towards these contracts and if you end up fulfilling I think it's three out of the five contracts you will automatically win but again it really does tie back to that that unique mechanism of once I played my you know one two or three I think even four cards I can start playing on my opponent's side so you you really do have to start juggling some plates thinking do I want to build this up but my opponent could play here next and ruin my score there but anybody needs that color to get that contract so I need to go there first a really cool Dynamic uh little game here I think there could have been a smoother mechanism in terms of um card management because after a certain amount of um after a certain type the contracts have been taken some of the candies are kind of rendered defunct you don't really need them anymore and those cards are going to end up clogging your hand up so I think it would be nice if there was a method to get rid of them or maybe do like a two for one mechanism in terms of playing those cards out as a different color something like that and this game didn't quite address that at least to my knowledge so a nitpick there but I did really enjoy the gameplay I think it's quite um quite a distinct two-player game and one
that I'm keeping around for sure so that is pinata at number four at number three I have herbaceous now this is from the pencil first series of games by Dr Steve Finn of biblios Fame and this game actually does use a mechanism that was kind of made famous in biblios at least that's where how I know it where what you're doing is you're drawing um two cards on each of your terms and after each draw you have to decide whether you want it for yourself or if you want to put it into the communal pool but the second card drawer has to go in the opposite direction so if I wanted to keep the second one the first card the second one would have to go in the middle and vice versa and what you're trying to do here very simple set collection trying to collect um duplicates of the same cards different types of cards pairs of different types of cards and even just that little kind of random wild cards as well but I love this mechanism of there being a constant built up shared pool in the center of the table and before you take your turn essentially in terms of drawing the cards you have to decide whether you want to use one of your scoring cards and lock them in place never to be used again for the remainder of the game so it does have this kind of chicken mechanism of are these cards going to make it back round for me and kind of improve on my score here just don't want to pull that trigger um I suppose a really Pleasant game I mean these pencil first games are a bit strange because they are so simple they're so Bare Bones and pure but they
seem to have some kind of sprinkling of magical ingredients to elevate them above so many similar games um so I'm quite excited to talk to to talk to you guys about this one and I think I'll probably do a series or a video covering all the petal first feather style games because I do have them all now um I think bar one so um you know fluiferous herbaceous delicious um and even the whatnot cabinet and I think there's another one as well called Sunset over water which I haven't played which I want to try next so I really like this series um and this is another strong one that could not be more simple at number two we have the second Rhino kanitzi game with ingenious so this is an older game definitely a family way abstract strategy game as you are playing these two-sided tiles on this board like all these tiles have these shapes and symbols on them and you're trying to build up these lines all those certain symbols in order to score more points of that type but they are hexes so there are so many different directions these lines can kind of sprouts off and this has the Tigris and Euphrates mechanism where at the end of the game your lowest scoring category is your final score so you cannot really neglect one um and you need to keep be keeping them all as level as possible and of course as strong as possible but if you reach the top of the track of a certain type of color you get a back-to-back turn which of course can be very powerful and the board does quickly gets swallowed up
so you're having more turns is obviously going to be very advantageous that's pretty much the gist of the game just draw a towel added to your little um Supply and play a title or play a tile and drop at the end but that's as simple as it gets you very minimalist gameplay but that idea of being able to create so many chains and stuff is very interesting and I just like the way this one works and flows and I love that tigression Euphrates scoring system which obviously has put Ryan on the map in so many of his games and this one is so pleasant it's like one of those games that it kind of can fit into any collection and it kind of bridges that gap between being more traditional board games it probably play as a child into the more modern era and it definitely can cater to such a wide audience hence why I enjoy it so much and the final game of today and the only game that's going to get a Chairman's Commendation at the moment at least because perhaps Engineers could creep into accommodation um anyway number one is framework by uve Rosenberg now on my channel over the years I have really um spoken highly of Nova Luna another kind of abstract tile placement Style game this one is 80 to 85 maybe even 90 the same game as Nova Luna but this one just elevates it a little bit more for me um to make the potential to create bigger chains um you know more more available I suppose and I preferred
the drafting system in this game to Nova Luna because Nova Luna used that Patchwork system if you are familiar with that game um much like um Olympus where if you're the furthest behind on the track you get more turns until you um overtake your opponent this one is a much more simple drafting system where you just draw as many tiles equal to the number of players plus one and then in turn you draft them but the first player gets the remaining tile as well and you're trying to build this big framework Believe It or Not of these tiles to try and fulfill as many of these objectives as quickly as you can so it retains that racing mechanism of the original Nova Luna but again there are more colors here to be used there are more restrictions in terms of how these tiles are scored because sometimes you need to score a certain type of objective before you can do the next one even though you might have the first one completed I mean just all these little wrinkles and especially the drafting system make it a flow a little bit more smoothly smoothly for me I think it's just a bit punchier um but you know I don't want to sound like I'm um trying to knock down over Luna because I think it's an amazing game and there really is kind of a you know a hairs width between the two but all these little things um improve framework for me over the original Nova Luna um the only issue is that this game isn't quite as pretty as Nova Luna it's a little bit more drab looking but that's the sacrifice I'm willing to make for for the Improvement in the gameplay and it really is an excellent one and um one that well my favorite UV Rosenberg game uh for sure so that concludes the
video a big range of games here you know medium weight Euros very simple card games uh maybe some abstract strategy games as well now if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye