Top 100 Board Games of All Time! (2022 Edition) - 80-71
Transcript
hi everybody i'm luke hector from the broken meeple if you like what you see please remember to thumb up the video consider subscribing to the channel or the patreon but most of all when i talk about these games here get some comments down below and let me know your thoughts about them so i got my ipad here for the next batch of ten and we got three new games on the list mostly a bunch of droppers and one that seems to have climbed even though i'm not entirely certain why it's climbed thanks for the kind feedback about the other two videos i've done i think this quicker format is doing a good job for this top 100 and yes the transitions are going to stay i'll just try not to make them quite as loud and bombastic as before like i say gotta keep things going consistent otherwise it looks weird anyway without further ado let's get on with it get on with it all right my number 80 is the weird one this one has climbed eight places and i'm kind of surprised by that because it's been a while since i've played it i have to run it with a timer in order to make it go smoothly and yeah why has this climbed i'm not entirely certain this is kind of a freak show in this uh section of ten but it's still a great game and i still really enjoyed playing it and that is sheriff of nottingham the classic like i've got my bags i've got my food and bread and chickens and whatever and i'm trying to sneak it past the sheriff for the sheriff's side no i don't trust you i'm going to open up your bag oh unless you want to give me a bribe you know that'd be lovely yeah it's it's that great banter game that's just great for like a good party setting now i kind of want to cap the player count a little bit five players takes a while it's gotta be said although it's gonna it's kind of odd when you have three players you go around twice and
that's not too bad but then when you have four players who want you to go around twice but then with five players you only have to go around once so you technically spend longer round wise in a four player game than you do with a five it's kind of odd but i still enjoyed this game it's just it's been a while since i've got it out so this is why i'm kind of shocked it's risen because i kind of think maybe this should actually have not necessarily dropped off my top 100 but maybe fallen a little bit down so it's kind of odd but when i was doing the comparisons i was thinking you know i still like this game it's it's like i don't get it to the table as often as i would like but when i do i have a blast and i usually because i enforce the timer you've got to have a timer for that share of phase otherwise it just drags on and on and on the game needs to be quick and snappy and that's the way it should work all right so something a little bit more new here we've got the first new of three games on this list and funny enough it's still arcane wonders we're still on an arcane wonders route here this game i've actually had on my shelf of shame for a long time seriously it's like come on luke hurry up and get this played but i just kind of delayed it i mean the first time i played it was at essen where i played a four-player demo of the game i think i played the full game and i was i like it question mark the problem was it was spoiled by the fact that i had some woman there in the game who i swear is the slowest player i have ever come across and believe me i've come across some belters in my time do something do something this is like
like the one of the a very simple tableau builder and this one was literally taking about an hour per turn it felt like oh my god so much for the 45 minute timer on aquatica but that blemish aside when i got the game myself and finally got it out and played it with you know fellow gamers brilliant it's a cool great game it's this it's the artwork is not as awesome as i would like it to be compared to something like abyss for example but i do really like this combo effect like card game where you grab characters you play them with their effects but what you're doing is acquiring locations and putting them underneath your dual air board where essentially you get to like you tuck the location but then you slide it down as you explore the depths and they create little combos for you like they generate actions or they give you more resources in order to get more locations look at me i'm dr zeidberg homeowner and it's all about manipulating these little locations in your board to try and create these power turns the expansion code waters really does a good job of improving that kind of dull and boring goal end game condition and replacing it with the tribes which are a bit more interesting than that they give you special abilities also main game scoring conditions and then you got more cards on top it's a cool game the rule book could be a lot better and that does hurt the game somewhat but as i've played it a bit more lately it has become one that i do enjoy playing i don't see this really rising further up the top 100 though i think this is going
to be its peak and it's going to like stay in the bottom 20 but as i say we're on to games here where it's a mixture of eight and nine out of tens mostly nine out of tens i still really really like this game it just has a few little blemishes that stop it being outstanding but yep new to the list aquatic and for my number 78 we're going to go to gmt games wait a minute gmt games yeah uh most people would think that i am probably like pulling your leg here no no no this is a legit gmt game that i do really really like even though i don't like a lot of gmt's other games this is the sequel to a very popular euro game that's vindictive as all get out and aggressive but as much as i give that one a little bit of credit there are things that i don't like about it whereas dominant species marine i think fixes a lot of that stuff for me and there's gonna be debates until the end of time as to whether dominant species is better or dominant species marine is better for me i prefer marine and here's why the idea with this is that you are you're basically taking control of like a like a race of creatures and you're really aggressively area controlling these hexes of different terrain in order to survive get food you know like breed more and eventually score victory points by various cards that come out through the game it's definitely in your face but dominant species had a system where you pre-programmed all the actions you were doing and then they all resolved in a particular order i didn't
like that mechanic though because it meant that you could have times where out outside of your control somebody comes along messes up your programming and then you've just wasted the last half hour of the game programming waste for actions so you get nothing maureen on the other hand treats it like a worker placement action selection game where you place your pawn down and you immediately do the action but then you can't go any further behind the pawn you have to go further down the chart and so that i think just works better because it makes the turns a little bit quicker a little bit more snappy but there's still the massive meatiness and like really rich theme that is generated with marine creatures rather than the ground creatures as was before if there's a slight flow at this game it's that the card system needs a little bit of tweaking it can get quite swingy if a really good card flips over when somebody is just about to take their turn if anybody has a variant or some house rule that can solve that i'd like to know because that could really that could elevate the game from a nine to the tenth at this point but donald and speech and marine is still a euro i really enjoy it's just not gonna hit the table as much because of how meaty aggressive and so big it is right not a new game this time number 77 is down 11 places from 66. this is another mineclash game i talked about to carry on much further down the list this is one that i still give a lot of props to even though it's probably the least popular from their range certainly from a lot of players perspectives and that is cerebria the inside world or as i
like to call it inside out the heavy euro game so that's how you want to play it old man no dessert you basically have a 2v2 or 1v1 team set up where one side is the positive emotions like love and you know delight in everything and one person is the hateful emotions like sorrow and sadness and basically it's partially arrogant job that's also partially like you know card playing effects where basically you're vying to build this little structure in the middle of the board and in doing so you have to control the different sort of dreamscape areas that give you a special bonus but also allow you to get more motion cards which you place down in order to like generate like power for area control or special abilities not to mention your boards i've got a smorgasbord of ways you can customize your characters it's a unique system though on the idea that you have this team verse team thing if you've got 2v2 then each of you can kind of discuss between you it's like well if i can go there you can do this and then we can set that up of course they are aware you're discussing this so it's not like it's hidden communication so you don't want to give away too much information but you also don't want to completely be too cryptic it just it kind of gives me that euro sense for the co-op feel because you are cooperating with the player next year with a goal to beat the enemy the games can be long they can be short it really does depend on how the game plays out if you want to go really advanced you throw in the expansion that frozen the balance the balance faction i played it once in a free player game where it was a love and
hate and balance you know like one of the three and yeah balance is an interesting faction definitely a bit more fiddly to pilot and certainly does require the other two to gain up on it every now and again and if they're not aware of that the balance faction is just going to run away i'll run away with it but this one has gorgeous miniatures it's a great system i really do enjoy this one but it's not a favorite among many because of the whole team versus team aspect most people would talk about anachrony and to carry on whereas i give a decent amount of props to serebia but yeah trying to find people to play it with is tricky with the exception of one or two people i know locally who will play it if i ask them to my number 76 says drop three places whoopty do it's pretty stable it would go higher if i could get this played more often or if it has a solo mode because the problem with star wars rebellion is that when do i ever get it played it's a two player only game forget the whole four player shared resources nonsense it's a two player game empire versus the rebellion and it's a fantastic star wars and a box game where you are essentially like the rebels have got to do hit-and-run tactics while keeping their hidden their rebel base hidden from the empire the empire has all the forces all the attacks and all the tie fighters and everything and they're going around trying to look for the rebel base and eventually blow it up found anything yet nothing yet sir they can build a death
star and go blow up planets they can subjugate places and the rebellion's trying to generate more support for itself and you use these mission cards you've now got a cinematic sort of card combat system with the expansion i really do love this game the reason it's not higher on the list though is because it's two player only i rarely get it played and when i do get it played i have to re-teach myself every single rule in the game because it's been so long since i last played it it's it's kind of like that that awesome experience that you only get to experience every now and again in a blue moon and by the time you experience it again you forgotten what it was you loved about it the previous time it's it's kind of like this annoying like stalemate situation where it's constantly hanging around this part of the top 100 and it can't go any lower because i remember that i do really like it but then it can't go any higher because i can't play it often enough if this came out with a little expansion that allowed you to play it solo nobody wants to play with me or shorten the time frame that would be absolutely amazing i would love to try something like that but that being said star wars rebellion star wars in a box you want to play through the first three movies and a bit of rogue one with the expansion this is the way you go about doing it with maybe one exception my number 75 it's only dropped six places from 69 and i'm expecting the sequel to this game anytime now actually at least i hope so because i noticed they were selling at genkan but this is
in the hall of the mountain king i was kind of avoiding it for a while i was like not that fast and maybe i'll try it i'm not sure but viewers were constantly saying like you've got to try this luke you'll enjoy it and every time i did top 10 lists or other like like discussion topics in the hall of the mountain king to keep popping up so it's like fine i'll try it shut up already no i never say that but you know you get what i'm saying it's like fine i'll try it i'll take your word for it i played it and you're right it was a really good game i mean it's on my top 100 for like several years on the chart this game has you building tunnels through this map where you can pick up like various loots in that as you go along you're trying to move statues to like closer to this volcano center for more victory points but the crux of this is mainly down to a couple of things i really like firstly is the resource management system it has you're building this little pyramid of troll cards and each one gives you resources but every time you place another troll you get the resources of that card and the ones that are below it in the pyramid but you can't store more than the troll stores you have to get them into your loot box otherwise you're wasting it it's very tight in terms of resources and that's an interesting prospect but i also like the idea that you've got these spell cards on the side where every player could potentially trigger them but once they get triggered three times they go away so there's a little bit of that kind of interaction with other players in the sense of you're getting each other's way on that grid board but then you're thinking
i've really got to use that spell but uh wait a minute you've used it you're about to use it oh wait i'm only going to get one use out of it i better use it now then otherwise it's gone and they just add a nice little bit of variety to the game i'm looking forward to the new in the was it fall of the mountain king which i think i previewed uh yeah i previewed the kickstarter i think a year or two ago and i look forward to getting my full copy and giving that a proper review but also i ordered the kickstarter upgrades for the in the whole the mountain king so i'm going to make mike happy in the other room look nice and bling that'd be nice but uh yeah this one was essentially because of the fans the fans recommended this game and the fans were right in all the mountain king is still going strong in my top 100.
my number 74 is going down down down what i mean that sounds really bad it's dropped 20 places from 54. it used to be really high i swear it was even a top 10 game at one point but i don't play this one as often as i used to i've got everything in the other room in a box similar to this kind of setup but i've just never seen the need to bring it out on top of other co-op games and i think that's possibly because of the co-op games of planting it or i'm playing more of the heavier stuff but flashpoint fire rescue is still an excellent co-op game it's just not hitting the table anywhere near as often as it used to and i got a little bit of history with this because flashpoint fire rescue was the first game i ever reviewed the first time when i did a written blog in the past with a broken meeple it was the first game i ever did flashpoint fire rescue i think it might be one of the first games i bought from my collection i just thought let's start with this and i loved it and i still love it i still think it's a 9 out of 10 game you know used to be a 10 it's probably dropped a little bit but i still enjoy this one because it's thematically sound in terms of the idea that you've got the firefighters trying to put out the fire and it spreads and it could start off really small and it's like oh yeah it's okay we got it under control then it's like insane and everything goes on fire and you can't control it and then you you gotta try and save the cat but do i save the cat or the little girl or do i save the adult lady i don't know uh but the cat i want to save bikini it's like you just get into a lot of silly little conversations yeah it's a bit random you're rolling the dice to see where the
fire goes but doy it's fire it's not like you can easily predict what it's gonna do ow fire hot the professor will help fire is chaos basically it's kind of like that but yeah the theme is done really well the expansion's kind of added a little bit too much bloat and maybe that's part of the reason why i haven't brought it out as much you do get into some very fiddly rules as you incorporate some of their mechanics but i do like the new maps that they bring out they're really cool but yeah even if you just got the base set of flashpoint fire rescue it's a very simple co-op and it has a family variant as well if you want to play it in an ultra simple fashion it's still a really good game to this day but no one ever plays it and even i haven't played it for a while which is why it's dropping but i think it's not going to fall off the top 100 i like it too much for that okay for my number 73 we have another new game and well i bet you didn't see this one coming oh boy yes osprey games are really actually starting to win me over a little bit they do put out some interesting little quirky games now and again and i've been trying a few more of them including some older stuff and i've been going hmm nice stuff you know what i want to try more and so when this one came out i was like really area control with trick taking how's this supposed to work but as you might know if you've been paying attention to my channel or taking this being something i've been going mad about lately so i figured i'd give brian
borrow high kingdom i hope that's how you pronounce it brian borrow high king of ireland to try i don't think any of us expected him to say that and it really it has won me over it like it may not be the best looking game in the world i mean the board's not bad the board's nice and clean and static but yeah you look at the artwork on the box it's not exactly much to sing home about but you know the cards are okay but the main thing with this is i was just thinking how am i gonna get area control to work with trick taking how does this work and we've had stuff well i can't spoil but we've had other games that combine trick taking with all sorts of other weird stuff but in this game you're essentially as i say controlling different territories in ireland for victory points and there's diversification as well as being like holed up in one area both are decent but you've also got these little side things around the side of the ball which you've got to pay attention to as well you gotta defend from the vikings you'll get glory if you do it well but if you don't do it at all you're gonna get your territories nicked you've also got a marriage track to level up you know do you want to go marry this lady well if you do then you might get a bonus for it you know maybe a little dowry or two but then you've also got the monastery it's like well that allows me to go first in the card order but then it also allows me to better protect my areas and get more points so you're looking at these little mini challenges and they're all useful and you can't do them all but you kind of gotta do some every now and again it's a really tough decision-making process but what i really enjoy is that trick taking element you play these cards of three different colors as well as a wild numbered from i think like one or two to 26 something like that and the
idea is is that you when you play a card you don't know the follow suit but you won't win the trick if you don't follow suit so highest number wins as normal but what happens is if you win the trick you take the action at the top which usually means controlling this area on the board but maybe getting a lesser action but then if you deliberately put yourself in a situation where you lose the trick you do one of the two bottom actions you might you might on purpose lose the trick in order to do one of those bottom actions and depending on how high or low the card number is the actions get better or worse it's very easy to win but a high value card so the action you get at the top for winning is not particularly great but if you were to lose with said card it's pretty powerful pretty potent in its own regard so and the same works in the opposite direction i just found this to be a really clever game could it have a better rule book yes osprey games i love you but seriously get a rulebook at the tour you need one but it's you know other than that blemish aside i found brian board to be a big surprise one of those big exceptions to the rule where i'd normally look at the theme and this kind of styling i think yeah why do i really want to go near this but i guess i'm just becoming a trick taking fan you know what i need to look at more trick taking games yet i should really grab a copy of that i remember that being pretty cool so yeah like i say this is just an ins weird surprise for me it's already like got into the 70s in my top 100 will it go higher or lower i honestly have no idea
for my number 72 we have dropped 20 places from 52 and i don't know why it's even dropped to be honest i guess this is only so many games once you start getting to 9 out of 10 rated games there's a lot of them they've got to squeeze on somehow i already mentioned dixit a while ago i love this card system where it's the tim burton on crack style artwork as i call it and you've got to kind of look in the picture and see the hidden meaning i really enjoy the system this is obscurio this is the traitor mechanic version so with this one you're kind of like in harry potter's library i guess it's hogwarts library you might as well call it that a magic book wants out and you're trying to use the book is trying to help you get out the problem is one of you in a group doesn't want to get out they're a bookworm they're a complete nerd they want to stay here read books for all eternity it's not me i promise at least it wouldn't normally be me maybe i don't know maybe they put a whole library for the marvel comics i've never read you know that'd be quite cool but with this one it's a great system where the book again can't talk and he shows you sorry they show you two pictures and you point these little butterfly markers to point at various aspects of said pictures a bunch of random ones are thrown in as well as the correct answer but the traitor gets the cherry pick a couple of pictures where they're thinking yeah i reckon that's going to throw them off and i reckon that's going to throw them off they all get mixed and then the players have to vote on which one they think it is if they get it right they progress but the more wrong answers that they have the more of these tokens are
eroded away and if you lose them all you lose the game it's a really clever little system but it's a very easy one to do in fact this has killed shadows of a camelot for me i like that game it was cool but obscurio is basically shadows of a camelot with art cards and frankly i think it's done better and smoother but it's great that eventually you are forced to you know unless you've done extremely well in which case the traitor is really taking a break here you eventually have to figure out who the traitor is and if you can't figure it out you're going to lose the game there and then because all your tokens will run out but it's that great sort of climactic tension where throughout the game you're trying to figure out who is not on our side here and then you get to that moment and it's like right pause the timer who are you who are you whose side are you on me and it just oh such great banter such great production i think from like the art is great the book is cool it's just a cool concept the idea that you could make this with a traitor mechanic so yeah i mean it has dropped 20 places i think it's just because i've played certain other games with this genre a little bit more but it's still a fantastic game i can't see this dropping any lower frankly because i remember playing in london recently with some friends of mine and that was a little heated yes a lot of fingers being pointed at me and i wasn't even the the embosser the person who was though yeah a pus to them they deserved their win because they managed to fool everybody they did a great job so obscurio still definitely want to look
at if you're a fan of shadows or you like this whole art card system and so my 71 dropping 14 places from 57 not a big deal i just haven't played it as much lately but i still really give props to this solo game which really did take the year by storm really i mean this was the year of check game editions and frankly the way this year is going it could be the year of check game editions again have you seen the two games they're going to bring to essen ho wee they're going to be popular but this was one of their big popular games from the previous year which was under falling skies under falling skies is a solo dice game which is basically space invaders the board game increase speed drop down and reverse direction with this one you have this clever little dice game where you've got these locations and you're trying to use them to like shoot lasers up in the sky and do research and all the beat the aliens but all the while the mother ship is creeping down and sending ships in various like columns down you know pretty much space invader style to stop you and what you're doing is you're using the dice and manipulating them in such a way in order to like you know use the locations as efficiently as you can but you're also trying to dig out the rest of your base because there's better locations down there it's a really clever system there's a decent amount of dice mitigation you know every time you roll those dice you are there racking your brains going ah how do i do this how do i do this if you want more proof go check out the umpteen
amount of play-throughs that this has had on paul grogan's gaming rules channel in fact i even did one i think with uh polyhedron collider two of us you know basically worked together to do a game of it and it was great fun i mean you can have two of you work together to try and do it if you don't want to play it solo it works fine it's just two of you discussing what to do but yeah it's it's not a big box it has a little mini campaign in it which adds extra bits extra content for what you get in the box it's pretty good value and just a very clever dice game it felt like it did something very different and it works really well with the theme it took so yeah and the falling skies are still a hit for me just not quite top 50 it's more top 70 whatever as if it matters it's a 9 out of 10 i still think it's amazing so that's under folding skies at 71.
so yeah my 80 through to 71 the next batch of 10 aren't new games they're all ones you've seen before but are they movers and shakers or are they stable well that you're gonna have to wait and see that's it for me though on this episode of the broken meeple i'm luke hector and if you like what you see please remember to thumb up the video consider subscribing to the channel possibly even the patreon but most of all get those comments down below let me know your thoughts about these 10 games should they be higher should they be lower what are your thoughts do you love them or hate them i want to hear both sides of the story until next time you can either rewind back to the start of the top 100 that's how you have been working through as you can see or you can check out the last video rant that i did on my kickstarter series which is you know taking off with a bang thank you for the lovely comments on that and you can check out my august edition of that take care and remember as always they're still only games bye for now everyone