Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Surprise Games

Transcript 28:24

welcome to jungkook's games today i'll be doing a top 10 surprises list and what i mean by that is these are the games that surprised me the most with how much i enjoyed them or did not enjoy them after i did get to play them i have some notion of how much i think i will enjoy most games when i sit down to play them and these are the games that surprised me the most by being significantly different than my expectations now there are positive and negative surprises in this list they're kind of mixed up overall but i tried to rank them by just how big a surprise that actually was now before we go into that i would like to mention that if you'd prefer to listen to this vlog instead of watch it then you can do so by searching for the jungles games podcast wherever you normally listen to podcasts i'd also like to mention that the only reason this video is being made is because of the direct support coming in through the patreon campaign now this was actually requested and voted on by the contributing producer level supporters of the channel and that is why this video is being made so with that in mind if you too would like to directly support the channel and the creation of videos like this one then please go to patreon.comgames to learn more uh the last thing that i'd like to ask is that if you end up enjoying this video that you please click the like button for it down below as well as the subscribe button for the channel all right let's now start talking about games and we will begin with the 10th game on the list and that one is brass lancashire now brass lancashire is a new version of a game called brass which came out i think in around 2007 and these are designed by martin wallace now the reason this was a big surprise to me is because up to this point i had never really enjoyed a martin

wallace game i played automobile back in like 2010 it was like one of the first 10 modern board games that i got to learn and it was an awful experience i might actually like the game now but i was just way too new into the hobby to actually enjoy that game i don't remember any of my issues with it but i do remember being in the middle of it thinking wow this is taking forever and i'm not having fun so after that i i've played a few other martin wallace games that i can think of one of them was a study in emerald which was a pretty big failure for us and i guess via nebula was my favorite martin wallace game up until i got to actually play brass and i thought via nebula was fine but it wasn't like my favorite game ever and i did end up getting rid of it from my collection now brass is a game that i had heard about for a while i first really fell into the hobby in like 2008 2009 so brass was a couple years old and a lot of people had very high praise for it but when i saw images of what the board looked like and then especially after i played automobile i just had this bad um expectation of the game i just didn't think it would be for me so when i ended up being able to play brass lancashire which is effectively the original brass just with a nicer artwork i was blown away by how much i loved that game i remember getting up from the table from the first time i played brass and just being so excited like i was just talking so loud and so much i had so many things to say and for the following week it was pretty much all i could think about was brass and wanting to play brass again so this was a pretty big surprise for me considering i expected it to be just a dry martin wallace experience and probably just another game that i wanted

to try so that i could say i had played brass and move on i certainly didn't expect to love it and end up getting a copy in my collection and uh play it a bunch and that has all happened so that is why brass is on the list let's now move on to game number nine and that one is keeper now this one actually has a pretty similar story to brass um up until the point where i played keeper the only other key game that i had played was a key to the city london i think i had played that about a year before i played keeper for the first time at board game geek con and i played key to the city of london at the previous board game geek con now when i played key to the city of london the first time i had i didn't really have a lot of expectations and i ended up really disliking it honestly i considered putting it on this list for a negative surprise but i don't think it matched up with some of these other ones but because of that after that i was like well maybe i'm just not into these key games because a lot of people had good things to say about key to the city of london well the next year bgg con rolled around and paul grogan offered to teach me keeper he seemed like he really liked it and i said you know what i'll give this a shot sure i didn't really know anything about the game except that it was a key series game so i expected to hopefully not hate it and i remember after playing that one for the first time i was just blown away what an amazing game that one is and i'm not going to go into the specifics of the mechanics in this top 10 list but i definitely was blown away by the innovation that was in this game it has this crazy folding infinitely folding action selection board and some wonderful work replacement ideas with a lot of interaction between

players and quite a bit of engine building i enjoyed that one so much that i went out and bought the fancy version of the game that have a little painted on silk screened meeples that you can play with or i guess peoples sorry and yeah that game just really impressed me way more than i was expecting and it's one that i don't really expect to leave my collection and i went into it you know just hoping i wouldn't hate the experience all right let's now move on to game number eight and that one is i my favorite things uh now this one i was able to play for the first time at essen uh i think that was 2018. yeah i was hanging out with my friends elaine and efka from no pun included um we hang out pretty much the entire time when we go to essen and they were super excited about this game called i my favorite things but when they actually got a copy of it and you know showed it to me i just did not get what the fuss was about they opened it up and it had this little metal mailbox and had all these little sleeves and they were just really into it but for some reason them being into it did not rub off on me and i was just like okay whatever have fun with your silly little box with you know that silly little mailbox in the middle of it uh but later on at uh that essen we ended up getting to play this one they they tried to get all this to play and i was like okay sure um what's this game actually about and i found out that it was a trick-taking game about making um essentially top five lists uh on your friends uh i'm not gonna go into the specifics of it i've done an impressions vlog that you can search jungkook's games i'm my favorite things and learn a lot more about it or see other people's videos but i was blown away at how much fun i had

actually playing this one um i went into it thinking it would just be a silly little party game uh with maybe a neat little trick but uh we laughed the entire time we had such a blast um you know it's such a ridiculous setting where you might play this trick taking game where you put a card down that has a word on it somebody else puts a card down that might have a drawing on it somebody else puts a card down that has you know a completely different word like you know i might put a card down that has a cat then another card comes down with a little poop emoji and someone else puts a card down that says like ice cream and then you actually resolve a trick with it it's ridiculous that it works and it totally does and we've actually made a hybrid copy of this one amongst our friend group here in california and we've played that one a few times too so this game was a lot better than i was expecting and to the point where we've actually can't come up with variants for this one in the box when you buy it it plays up to i think six players and we played a 10 player game of it by tweaking the rules a little bit because it really doesn't matter if you win or lose in this game this game is all about the experience of playing it's all about the journey not the destination with this one and uh yeah it definitely surprised me let's move on to game number seven which is mandala and this one is yet another positive surprise now this is a two-player only card game that came out a few months ago and i remember seeing photos of this one online and it's it's got these square cards with some nice colorful mandala type art on it and then you have this big cloth mat that you put in the middle of the table and then you play these colored cards down and everybody was raving about this game uh now oftentimes when a bunch of people rave about a game that

makes me interested in it as well but i found myself feeling incredulous about it i saw the photos i learned a little bit about how it played and i just thought that doesn't seem very interesting to me you're playing these cards down into different areas in front of you and at a certain point you score the cards and you take the cards in front of you and you get some points for it it's two player only and it just seemed so simple and it just i just didn't get it uh well fortunately for me somebody put a mod for this one up on tabletop simulator and because there was so much buzz around it i figured i may as well give it a shot i didn't think it would be terrible but i was pretty surprised i ended up actually playing it i mean this is the top 10 surprises list so that shouldn't be surprising but anyway this game is so tense and so tight with such an elegant simple rule set um that i my expectations were completely thrown out i mean i might again i expected it to be just kind of the simple whatever game i'd play once and then we'll have played it and then move on but instead i played it a bunch online i ended up buying a copy and i've now played it a couple times with jessica here and she really likes it as well it has a great classic game vibe to it and you know i feel like i probably should have had higher expectations going into this one because i have enjoyed a lot of um card games similar to this in the past i think the fact that it was two player only uh definitely brought it down in my mind a little bit not that i'm against two player only games at all i think it's amazing that they exist but i usually prefer to play games with more than two players two players is usually my least favorite player count overall because i like

being able to talk with other people around the table when it's not actually your turn and anyway that's just a personal thing for me so um once i was able to actually play this one i became very happy that i had and now i'm super glad that i own a copy and um i think it's likely we're never going to get rid of this one i'm glad that jessica liked it because i've played this one like seven or eight times now and up until i finally taught jessica i had never lost and now i have lost in fact i lost really badly the last time i played but i've still really enjoyed it and it was definitely a surprise for me okay let's now move on to game number six and this one is ecos and this is the first negative surprise that i'm going to be talking about uh now this one came out i think about a year ago or so and i was very excited about this game i had a lot of things going for it a lot of things that i thought i was really going to like in the game uh it has uh this system where you are pulling tokens out of a bag and then those activate essentially everyone's stuff in front of them so there's kind of a simultaneous nature to it it seemed like it had engine building with the cards you put in front of you that can then be activated by those stones and then the actions that you are doing with the cards that are in front of you affect a communal land mass where you're actually building that land mass out you're putting a bunch of animals on it the animals are moving and i just love the idea of a competitive experience with a communal area that is alive and it's alive because of the mechanics of the game you know i did this because it got me points i had selfish reasons for you know moving this uh elephant over there or you know this cheetah over to the spot i had selfish reasons for putting water

over here and you know maybe even ripping this land mass apart and because of my selfish little mechanical reasons to get victory points the earth moves like you have this amazing moving thing in front of you and at least that's what i was expecting uh now i got a copy of this one i actually did a full playthrough of this one on the channel if you'd like to learn more about it and i played it several times and i remember playing it the first time and really trying to convince myself that i liked it i don't think i actually enjoyed that play but i was expecting to like this game so much that um that kind of overrode my actual opinion of it so i played it again and then i think i ended up playing this one three times i can't be sure exactly it was about three times and i remember the final time i played it i just kind of gave up on this pretense that i should love this game and realize that i really dislike this game in a lot of different ways i'm pretty sure i went into all of those in an impressions vlog so i'm not going to go into detail about that here but the the promises of the game of this living land mass that kind of got there like there was definitely a great amount of change that happened in the middle that was probably my favorite part of the game but there was a lot of other issues with the game that just did not click for me that again i'm not going to go into the details of but i just sometimes you go into experience saying like wow a b and c these all just really line up with what i like in a game and then you actually play it and it does not necessarily meet your expectations and unfortunately that was ecos for me so i i did end up getting rid of my copy of this one um i know a big reason i was expecting to like this game as well is because it was designed by john d clare who made space base which i think is excellent and i guess this just goes to show that

um just because you like one game from a designer does not mean you're gonna like all of them all right let's now move on to game number five on the list and that one is concordia venus now i say concordia venus in particular because this is like the fourth expansion for concordia and i really liked concordia in fact when this expansion came out i think concordia was probably one of my top 10 games but for some reason when i learned about this expansion it just did not do anything for me i heard that this was a team-based version of concordia well i've played concordia a whole bunch at that point i thought it was an excellent fully competitive game and i remember um i was at essen when this was released um i stood in line at the booth with afghan elaine because they really wanted to buy it i got all the way up to the front and i just decided not to spend my money i just didn't get it it seemed like it was a lot of money to just get an expansion for a game i already like i'm usually not that high on expansions anyway which is probably one of the main reasons why my expectations were pretty low for this but anyway i just moved on and didn't really worry about it well a few weeks later i went to board game geek con and a bunch of my friends were very interested in playing this one so we got the copy out we learned the rules and we sat down to play a full six player game of concordia venus which means three teams of two and i loved this game it was long it was like closing on three hours and everyone around the table was experienced with concordia so it was a much longer game than concordia normally is but it was exceptional i absolutely loved the experience it was this amazing thing where you took a game

i already loved that was already a top 10 game and just heined it just like completely leveled it up to the point where i can't remember if i made that my favorite game of the year or not but it was certainly my favorite game or my second favorite game of the year it was one of the best gaming experiences of the year and i've played it many times since then again i'm not usually crazy about expansions because normally they just add bulk to a game and i oftentimes don't play a game after i get an expansion for it because well i have to read the rules to the game again to remember how that plays and then read the rules to the expansion and the expansion's all mixed in but concordia venus is absolutely the exception again i probably should have had higher expectations considering i loved the base game but my preconceived notions about negativity towards expansions brought this one down and uh left me so completely surprised when i actually got to play this one and everyone i've played this with has also really liked it to the point where it's essentially two different games at its core it is still concordia but they play so differently overall and honestly this experience has really highlighted to me just how much i actually like team-based games um before this it never really occurred to me but that is one of the reasons i love teach you so much because that is a team-based game and as time has gone on and as i've played more team-based games the more i realize i just love that way to play games so nowadays when i see that a game is team based i'm actually much more interested in trying it because of experiences like concordia venus that surprised me so much all right let's now talk about game number four which is terraforming mars

now when this game first came out it was a phenomenon it was like everyone was talking about this game that people were talking about it before the game was published and once the game was published it was just like every single podcast every single video all anyone in the board game media sphere was doing was talking about terraforming mars and i was not having it i just did not buy into the hype at all um it just seemed like it was being way overblown it was published by stronghold games and oftentimes there was very big claims about stronghold games and that didn't really meet reality from my experience so i just didn't bother tracking down a copy almost to spite the situation if that makes sense like i didn't want to play this game i just everyone was talking about how great it was it could not be that good i'm sure it was mediocre or at least i was sure that it was completely mediocre and that everyone was just captivated by the hype cycle well a few months later like many months later i was at board game geek con which you're probably starting to hear a trend for i try a lot of games that i'm not sure if i'm going to like at board game geek con and so i've quite often been surprised at board game decon but i went to board game decon and i ended up being invited to play a full five player game of this with a bunch of other people that i know from board game media kind of in the twitter sphere and i said sure you know what let's give it a shot it's board game decon they're going to teach me this game it's probably going to be totally mediocre and that's just the way it's going to go so you know the convention came i did a bunch of stuff played all my things and then it was time to play terraforming mars so i went over sat down

and proceeded to be completely blown away by this game man i i was so ready to just dump all over it i was so ready to have my expectations of it being overblown and i was so unexpecting the idea that um i could actually love the game i remember walking away from that five player game and going back to my group of friends and just telling all of them i was just like holy cow turf remarks is really good and i think many of them were like yeah that's what everyone's saying and i was like yeah but everyone's saying it so it can't be right i guess sometimes that is actually the case and there are probably more games on this list at least one anyway when i glance down that is going to match up with this again so i guess i i fed into some anti-hype and it set myself up for being really really surprised by this game i've played terraforming mars a bunch since then i got a couple of the expansions um although i think my favorite way to play this game is um just the base game with the prelude expansion and the corporate era stuff like all the stuff from the base game plus the prelude expansion the other ones don't really add stuff that i really like and i think the core basis of this game is really brilliant so this was a circumstance where everyone really should have been talking about how amazing the game is in fact i just played this one like three weeks ago for the first time in a probably a year or two and i was once again blown away at how incredible that game really is uh and yeah wow that one really caught me by surprise all right let's jump into game number three which is indian summer now this is a game that i picked up at um essential i think this was 20

18 17 uh don't quote me on that either way one of the two that i've gone to and i was really expecting to love this game you could probably see where this one's going already now this is a gorgeous polyamino style game and it was the uh the sequel essentially to cottage garden which to a certain extent was a sequel to patchwork all of these games were designed by uve rosenberg and i loved patchwork but that was a two player only game so when cottage garden came out i was quite excited for it and we did get to play a four-player game of it at board game geek con and uh it was fine it didn't really blow me away i was expecting to like a little bit more but it was a bit of a letdown so a year later when indian summer came out i was fully on board it's like okay this is going to be similar-ish to uh to cottage garden because it's going to be polyamino puzzle building with multiple players not just two players and man the artwork just gorgeous i love the look of this game thematically you're essentially putting out all of these tiles that have leaves on them and then these adorable animals burst through the leaves on the forest floor like how jolly and wonderful and joyful is that well i hated this game what a surprise uh i got a copy of it as a press copy uh while i was at essen and we played it i think that night because i was so interested in trying this one out um we popped all the pieces out of the cardboard and we sat down to play at the uh the restaurant kind of area down below at our uh hotel and it was an exceptionally dull experience i remember i played it with i believe ekka and elaine and somebody

else i can't remember exactly but either way we were all just looking at each other being like is this it this is is this this is it and wow i just i walked away from it feeling like surely the game isn't that bad surely it was just a bad experience maybe just bad lighting bad setting i don't know so i decided to give this one another shot i think i played this one two more times maybe just one more time and proceeded to loathe the game more and more every single time i played it now i uh did a review for this game uh this was made back in the before times when i used to make reviews so if you'd like to hear about me talk about the details of why i dislike this game so much then just search for that one it should be pretty easy to find but yeah my expectations were really off on this one which is a shame because i love polyamorous games and i just adore the artwork in this game i so desperately wanted the game to be good and i to this day i wish that it was i ended up really liking spring meadow which was the sequel to indian summer that came out the year after that one that's a really good game i still have it in my collection but the art in that game is effectively tiles with snow on them i really wish i had the game of spring meadow with all of the indian summer art assets on it but i don't think that's actually going to happen but either way this one was a very big surprise anyway at least as far as how disappointed i was so let's now move on to game number two and this one is gloomhaven now i hinted before that there was another game kind of like terraforming mars on this list and that one was gloomhaven now i remember uh when this one first went up onto kickstarter for the very first time

i was a subscriber to uh the rado run through youtube channel i still am but i was way back then as well and i remember seeing this pop up in the feed and i clicked on it knowing nothing about the game and i remember watching most of the the run-through video and thinking there's no way this game works like it just it was this dungeon crawl with all these cards and all these fiddly bits and it just it looked like a train wreck that was my honest interpretation of it i remember glancing at the kickstarter page and thinking you know just just another kickstarter you know just promising all this stuff with all the stuff and it's just it's it's going to be a train wreck it's not just not going to work so i didn't think about it anymore from that point on but then when the game actually shipped one of my friends did back it on kickstarter and um they asked me if i wanted to play with them the very first time they sat sat down to play it they actually lived next door to me at the time so it was very easy for me to say yes and so i just decided to go over there and see what the trainwreck was like well i was not expecting to fall in love with the game completely after even just that one play i remember being halfway through that play thinking how could i have been so wrong you know my all my expectations based off of what i saw on that first kickstarter i think the issue is that so many kickstarter campaigns promised the world and under the liver gloomhaven promised the world and delivered the world and the moon and maybe a couple other planets as well just it's something that does not happen that often where everything comes together so well with such brilliant mechanics and an incredible ridiculous amount of

content in that first box it's just a very surprising thing it skyrocketed up the uh board game geek rankings um you know all the way up to the top um i'm not sure if it's still number one i think it might be uh and you know it it skyrocketed up to the top of my rankings as well i wouldn't say it's my favorite game at this point but it's certainly a top 10 game uh i've played uh the copy that i ended up getting uh well over 30 times realistically my only issue with gloomhaven is that i'm never going to finish it because it was too long i wish it had been split up into like multiple chapters or something like that so i could have completed a story bit thematically and then moved on to the next one but our play group um just couldn't really last the entire length of this campaign so mechanically this one was an exceptional experience i loved playing it 30 plus times with my friends coming over to our house and i think it's just an amazing overall system i have a copy of gloomhaven jaws of the lion which is that smaller experience which is probably going to be my actual favorite gloomhaven but i'm not sure if i actually have plans to play that one but i have a copy so hopefully at some point i do uh because it seems like it's all that good stuff in the box without the box having so much stuff that i never actually complete the campaign uh but either way gloomhaven absolutely surprised me um it's it was a bunch of promises that actually came together uh in a very rare way so we've now reached game number one on the list and that one is alien artifacts now this game i had very high expectations for and the reason for that is because at board game geek con which again i've said so many times um

many years ago i don't even remember how many years ago it was the year before uh alien artifacts was released so about 11 months before it was released um i actually got to play a prototype of alien artifacts i played it with the portal games guys and um i enjoyed playing this prototype with them so much i asked them if i could borrow it and i took it over to the other side of the convention and uh taught this one to my group of friends and played that with them and they all loved it as well it was such a elegant cool system to get this kind of very light forexy vibe in a card game and i just had so much fun playing the prototype i took it back to them and i told them it was exceptional and i could not wait to play the final version well about 10 or 11 months or whatever uh later the final version came out and a copy of it got shipped over to me and we hated it it it just did not work it was such an incredible experience because i had played it before i played a prototype and thought it was an amazing backbone to a game i thought it was such a great start and i couldn't wait to see where it would end up going what i didn't expect to happen was that they would actually layer so much stuff on top of this elegant backbone that it just completely broke apart from all of these different things that just did not work together it was just way too many things crammed into a pod shuffled around and it just did not work um to the point where um in i think yeah that one game i played with all my friends here and i ended up playing another game at essen i think later on that year just to to make sure i wasn't crazy but when i played it here with my friends uh one of my friends got up from

the table when we were about three quarters of the way down with the game and said i am not going to play this game game anymore it is making me so angry i cannot play it anymore and this person was there with me at bggcon and played the prototype and loved the prototype just like i did so he also was just incredibly surprised i guess all of us were who got to play the prototype and enjoyed it so much so that is why alien artifacts is at the top of the list because i had the um the extra ability to try that prototype and already know that i really loved the game or at least i loved where i thought the game was going to go and then i ended up playing the published version and realized at some point between the prototype and the final version a serious course correction had happened in the overall design process and it was a game that i i really disliked and so did my friends so unfortunately uh my biggest surprise game overall is on the negative but i think there's pretty good reasons for that so uh that has brought us to the end of this list uh this was an interesting one to put together definitely thinking outside the box from a lot of other lists because i was trying to rank them by just how surprised i was and there were certainly some games that just barely missed the list as well i know that uh the boldest was one lowlands was another one that i considered there's a lot of games on there and it's really easy to be surprised even though there's so much information you can watch videos about a game you can read up on them i didn't mention this in the mandala a bit but even after i read the rules to mandala i was not at all convinced it was going to be anything special so often times you just have to sit down

and play the game to see if the magic works like all these abstract ideas and little colorful pieces of cardboard and plastic do they actually turn into the magical experience of a good game and you know sometimes you expect it to and it just completely falls flat and you're effectively looking at a bunch of inert pieces on the table and sometimes it comes together in this amazing experience where you have this alive uh thing in front of you that might have you non-stop thinking about it for weeks later and um that's both of these things have obviously happened numerous times over the years and uh i hope that you've enjoyed me kind of going through some of these stories for what i think are the top 10 biggest surprise games that i have so uh yeah that's going to bring this one to a close as always i'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this channel including these producer-level patreon supporters if you too would like to directly support the channel in the creation of future videos just like this one then please go to junglesgames.com support also if you enjoyed this video then please click the like button for it down below as well as the subscribe button for the channel thanks for watching

Progress saved