Skip to main content
Loading video...

18 Board Games Ranked - Episode 17

Transcript 29:45

hey everybody and welcome to another edition of month in review so this is where I take a look at all the new games I've played over the previous month and I rank them for my least favorite all the way up to my most favorite now there's a very steep incline this month I've got 18 games I need to talk about ranging from pretty awful up to pretty spectacular and before I get started on the list I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor kiienda dot Co dot UK who are my go-to online retailer here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get a five percent off your first order but let's get started on the list okay so at number 18 are my least favorite game of the month is Tumble Tree so this is a kid-friendly dexterity game as you are placing these cards on top of the actual game box which is like this cylinder I suppose so which is supposed to represent this tree trunk um and you're basically trying to put these little cards on which are circular or discs and all these cards have a different rule on them so some might say um you need to drop it from a certain height some might say you need to throw it onto the the top of the tree and stuff like that now the problem I have in this game no because by the sounds of it it sounds pretty fun um you know a little bit of a dexterity never hurt anybody but the issue with this one is that all the cars get distributed randomly and a lot of these cards are much more difficult than what the other ones do so like for example the one where you have to throw the um the card onto the uh onto the tree was really difficult it very rarely succeeded and some of them

were very easy where you could pretty much just place it where you wanted and um yeah it was an absolute Breeze so it's pretty much that you know the winner was going to be determined by who got the best cards or the easiest cards um and it went on way too long as well you know you're talking about half an hour at least if not more than that to uh to play this game and it should take you know 10 minutes so yeah a little bit too um too long in terms of its time frame but uh it was it was fine I mean I'll play again if it's for a bit of steady fun but yeah massively imbalanced and I think we even had to create some rules ourselves to make it a little bit more interesting and number 17 I have another game that is more tailored towards children this is zombie teams so this is a very simple Cooperative Style game as of course you are working together you will each have a character and you are trying to venture off collect these supplies bring them back to the center before you get overrun by zombies um very simple almost pandemic-like system where you have a number of actions such as moving from one spot to another and picking up these crates you can pass them along to the other players and you can fight off these zombies as well so you can probably imagine how this is going to go I know this game does have some kind of Legacy element to it now I only played this one once so obviously there wasn't any um any Legacy element to it that I experienced but I think the game itself was too simple it was pretty much obvious what you had to do or what you should be doing and it's either going to work for you or against you depending on the randomness randomness of the spawning points of the zombies or the event cards that are drawn so not quite my cup of tea and very simple I can see as a introductory game two no younger Gamers

this might be a good option but for me personally not what I'm looking for at number 16 I have guards of Atlantis so this is completely like out of the left field for me I'd never normally play games like this but we went to a games night and somebody brought this along with them we had six players um and I thought this is a good option because this is a team based game and it's based on the kind of MOBA style computer games as you are trying to kind of push your enemy back to their region and try to achieve the objectives and things everybody's got their own massively distinctive unique character with all their own unique abilities and um you know decks of cards and production-wise this game looks phenomenal some of the best little Miniatures I've seen are really kind of charismatic characters and it looks great um the gameplay itself again not quite to my tastes um it's one of those games that's going to definitely benefit from playing it time and time again with the same people because you'll learn what the other characters do whereas you know five out of the six of us have never played this game before we had no chance of knowing what each player was capable of so it's just a matter of just trying things and hoping it worked out because there's no way of predicting what anybody else could do um I thought it was a little bit um it could have had the potential to go a little bit too long I think fortunately it ended up um you know finishing quite early because we played pretty poorly um but yeah just not my style game a little bit too swingy a little bit unpredictable and wild um and chaotic I suppose um but still some good elements here and I can see why people would like it if you do like these more you know American

um Style game so this one is just yeah not to my place at all but I'm glad I played it because normally I wouldn't get to play this kind of thing at number 15 gingerbread house this is a pretty simple little puzzly Style game as you're laying towels on top of existing tiles you know build it building up you know vertically as well as spreading out on this little I think it's a little three by three grid um and basically when you're covering up these symbols you're getting these tokens and then you're using those tokens to acquire cards which will essentially give you victory points it has this almost Splendor feel to it as you would want to be the first to grab the ones that you know you are building towards before you know to stop you from diverting off into Plan B to make you feel more efficient and you're trying to line up these tasks because if you cover up the same type of symbol you get a little bonus you know very paint by number stuff it's been done time and time again and I think it's been done to a higher standard so this one was a little bit forgettable for me but I actually had to go back and look at a video to see how this one worked because you know I almost forgot how it played it was that it was that mundane I thought so that is gingerbread house at number 15. at number 14 I have a gricola family Edition so I've never actually played the main Agricola game now from my general feed back I've got is that this game is you know pales in comparison to the proper Agricola and I can see that being the case because this is definitely um you know pure entry level worker placement there's nothing really here that sets it apart to a ton of other work replacement games out there that fall on that you know entry level bracket this one you're trying to collect resources you're building up these pens and things that were enclosures for your animals giving them a space to breed to

get your victory points um it has this cool little incentive thing going on where you know if you neglect a spot it can build more and more resources up um and yeah I thought it was fine at best it was rapid you know very quick game but the decisions again were fairly obvious worker placement done to its you know a predictable fashion I suppose and I actually think I prefer the two-player only version of Greco Cloud view all quick just big and small I think that was slightly better than this one again just you know a fine as an entry level work replacement game but you're going to quickly Tire on it on because there's there's not much depth here and there's not many things to go for so yeah unfortunately it was a bit of a miss me but I still need to try the main Agricola at number 13 I have a doppelganger which is a game that probably shouldn't be ranking as high as it is this month um because the game itself is very silly you are simply drawing a card which is going to have a celebrity on it and then you are basically writing which one of your friends you think is most like that celebrity you're reviewing them and then whoever's kind of got the most votes is going to all whoever's voted with the majority it's going to get points if you're the only person to vote yourself you're going to lose points um and so on so yeah pretty simple stuff here but I actually did quite enjoy this one because it did kind of just encourage some interesting discussion you could find stuff about your friends that you didn't really think before find it find out stuff about yourself just to understand you know the perception of other people as you so it was quite a nice little Conversation Piece something that's going to get very tiresome very quickly you know you can only play this one once or twice and once you've gone through that deck of cards you're pretty much going to be done with it but it

works you know for a family occasion it's going to be a good little conversational piece so that is doppelganger at number 13. at number 12 I have Iota so this is a pretty much a pure abstract Style game as you're building up these rows and Columns of these cards and these cards are going to have different shapes on them and all those shapes are going to come in different colors as well now all you're going to do with your time you're going to play one of these shapes we'll try to build on one of these columns or rows I suppose but the as soon as you play the second card in a row or column then you need to follow that pattern so for example if I play a blue triangle and then a green triangle that means that um the rest of them have to be triangles or if maybe the first two shapes are blue then they're gonna have to be all blue that kind of thing so um you have this this kind of luring mechanism where sometimes you could lead opportunities for your opponents to finish them because if you say added the I think there's a third or fourth card to a royal column the points really did amplify um so you have to be quite careful with the opportunities you left to other players and it was quite actually it was quite an interesting game now I think maybe the interest of the game didn't quite weigh up with the fun you could have from the game because there was pretty much always a a correct play you know if you wanted to look at the board and nothing scrutinize every single placement then you could optimize it but if you're going to do that it's going to drag the game to a halt and it's going to become a little bit too brain burning and again not much fun so I think you know the best um the best abstract style games to kind of strike

that correct balance of being fun yet still thinky this one I think the bounce is a little bit off you know despite being an interesting design I don't think the fun was quite there but I would play it again because it was again quite a quite an intriguing little game at number 11 I have dandelions which is a quirky little filler game as you are going to be rolling a bunch of dice and then you're gonna be allocating these dice to these different pestles um and essentially you are trying to get the majority of your dice on these petals because each of these petals is going to give you a certain amount of points that each dice on it but also there's a scoring mechanism based on the pit values on these as well so there's kind of these kind of two little um ways of scoring points um I thought the idea of itself was quite funny a very simple little 15 minute filler but this was one of those games where I think the the housekeeping and the actual thoroughness that you need to think through of each of your placements did again overwrite the fun factor of it because most of the um you know most of your time you're just gonna be working things out you know if I play this one I'm gonna do this it's going to change this and do that whereas most of the good fillers you kind of sit back and just enjoy the process and the game almost plays itself but you still want a little bit of decision now this one I think is a little bit too cumbersome in terms of just yeah the the obstacles and the speed bumps that actually get in the way of the fun so yeah it was fine maybe um with more plays that will iron out a bit you know I've only played this one the once so who knows but I was you know I didn't dislike it but I didn't really like it either so that is dandelions at

number 11. at number 10 I have what the actual factual so this is another party game as you are trying to basically predict the answer to a quite a difficult question question so basically every round somebody is going to know the correct answer to this question and everybody else is going to have a fake answer to give and they're going to basically be put on a spot and have to come up with an answer so something might be um now what what's the correct term for a 100th of a second and then everybody will write their answer down reveal it and um or kind of say their answer and then people have to try and vote what they think the correct answer is and you know most of these questions are so obscure that you're not going to know it and of course you're going to get points accordingly if people will vote for you and you did Bluff you're going to get points if you guess the correct answer you're going to get points and so on so we see a lot of games like this you know these boulder dash style games um and this will work I think sometimes it was a bit too difficult to think of an answer because the questions were so weird um but I think once the game got flowing some questions were pretty good and you know um quite interesting I suppose um but I think the small issue I had with this game was that a lot of the questions you could actually know the answers for because they're not that obscure some of them are really obscure but some of them you know you've probably heard it in trivia before and if you actually know the answer it's not quite obvious what you should do because there's no rule in the rulebook that says if you know the answer you get X Factor points or anything like that so that should have been addressed and I think maybe took it for granted that nobody would know the answers but I think in actuality people would at

number nine I have the first of the Euro games this is Alma so um I've actually just released a review for so be sure to check that one out this one has some very cool things going on in it as you are utilizing this three by three grid of tiles and all you're going to do with your attention you're going to draw a tile blindly from this bag then you're going to slide that tile either on one of these horizontal or vertical rows or columns and any of the tiles that remaining in that Royal column are the actions you're going to get so it might be getting money it could be um refreshingly kind of um overspill area so somebody else can use that row or column it could be buying or playing cards it could be investing in these kind of unique powers as you go it could be moving your boat along this track which is going to kind of gain you more points as you go so it has a cool mechanism itself was was fantastic I really liked how that worked now the problem I had for this game was the way that you actually gained points because most of it just LED back to drawing these cards blindly from this stack and then caching in tokens that you just might so happen to have or might not so happen to have to get a big chunk of points that for me felt a little bit flat and it felt like the rest of the game didn't quite merge with the way you're getting point it just felt like a a Road to Nowhere really in fact like most of it was Superfluous because of the way you gained the points so yeah again be sure to check out my review to understand what I'm saying in a bit more detail but had a lot of potential here didn't quite hit for me and um yeah I don't really see any reason to go back to it for that reason at number eight

which is a family weight kind of um stock holding and commodity speculation game um as you are trying to invest in these companies you know Buy Low sell high that kind of thing um at this game I think it tailors more towards the higher play accounts and we played a six player game which was quite nice and all you got to do when your turns you're going to draw two tokens from this bag and one of which is going to show the actions which you can take which might be investing in companies they're buying and selling stocks um some of them might say you know jump a company up a place on the hierarchy to make it worth more or maybe you put one down to make it worth less that kind of thing um but the other token is going to relate to the shifting of the value of these companies they're gonna these tokens are going to range from I think there's value one to six they're simultaneously everybody's going to reveal a card which is going to relate to one of these companies and say everybody chose the same card or a bunch of people choose the same card then that particular company is going to fly up in value and it's all about again buying low selling High I like the way that the kind of the disparity between the low stocks and the high stocks change on the companies change because basically the polls start getting further and further apart the longer the game goes on so what that means is that if you've got a company that's really far behind yeah their stocks are going to be really cheap to buy but towards the end of the game they can actually cost you a hell of a lot of money because they're going to be worth you know massive negative points and the same applies to the positive ones as well it's a very Dynamic game it's quite swingy and chaotic but sometimes that's okay it

only takes about 45 minutes to play which is you know right on the money for me so it's not one of those games it's going to be a complete brain burner and it's not going to you know fry your brain in terms of all the maths you're going to be doing it's pretty much one that you're going to just you know roll with the punches just go with your gut and see what happens and sometimes that's the kind of game that I you know I like to play at number seven I have a Botswana which is another commodity speculation Style game where all you're trying to do on your turn is you're going to play a card and you're gonna pick up an animal now all these cars are going to relate to the different animals in the game and the most recent card of each animal type played is going to be the value of that animal in terms of the points you're going to gain and these values are going to range from zero up to five I believe so and the game is going to end immediately as soon as somebody plays that sixth card of an animal type so it's all about finishing the game at the right time when all the animals you've collected correspond to the highest values of the cards another one of those games where you kind of need to play the first half of the game kind of just going on a whim not really much you can do but I suppose you can try and collect the animals where you know that you have the higher values for because hopefully you can sneak that card in and make all the animals worth a fortune but of course all the other players are going to know that and try to tank the value of that animal so very simple I'm always amazed with how everybody can't see a manager to make these games based on one core mechanism and just make it work with Nicks no rules and um Botswana is a strong example of how he does that and it works you know very quick game Talking 15

minutes you can play several rounds to try and balance out the chaos Factor if you want to but personally I like just playing one round or two and just see how it goes but love this one um I really like this one I should say I love this one um and yeah maybe it's all girl made maybe it will fall slightly but right now I'm happy with where it is and it again it does what it does in a very small concise little package that is Botswana at number six I have next station London which is the most recent game on this this is a 2022 uh release and this is a flip and right Style game but with a Twist so you know of course the flipping right Style game genre is massively convoluted it's saturated and doing something different is where these games start to shine out and I certainly think that next station London does that as the Twist on this game is that each round you're going to have a different colored pen or pencil and all you're going to do is on your plan you're going to or everybody's time you're going to flip over a card which is going to show which um basically station you need to draw on this under Underground map I suppose and which kind of stations you need to connect to and the idea is you want to be trying to spread this route as long as you can because every or the every one of these group references that you go to is going to give you more points I'm just going to multiply with all the different stations you stop in in one of those spots so it's kind of got this again this polarity of wanting to spread up but wanting to stay tight as well spreading out is going to be great because it increases your multipliers but staying close and concise is nice because when it comes to the Future times where you're drawing a new line Associated to a different color you are

going to have more freedom because it's going to get Tighter and Tighter and you're not going to be able to cross paths with an existing trade line so again I love that kind of puzzly nature of it and it has this additional twist where if you manage to use a station or multiple of your train lines then you can get other points as well so I love the you know the variety of ways you can score points like I didn't mentioned that you get points by crossing the River Thames in the center of the board and it's just got enough going on but not too much again the four rounds feel nice and we always engaged always doing something it scales well there's a good solo mode and it just kind of ticks a lot of boxes when it comes to the great um you know flip and right style games now for this one for me I'm pretty sure this is going to kind of slot straight into my top 10 you know flipping right star games out there takes about 25 minutes of play get a lot of kind of bite in that 25 minutes and I really recommend it at number five I have a choir which is the oldest game on this list because this game actually goes all the way back to the 1960s and is the third of the kind of economic stocks and shares you know quantity speculation style games this one for me I think is aged wonderfully um as all you're doing on each of the rounds you're going to put one of these tiles on this Big Grid I suppose and these are swiftly representing these companies and as the game develops these companies are going to grow they're going to start connecting with each other and the bigger companies are going to start swallowing the smaller companies and it's all about kind of buying stocks in the not any of the bigger companies because they're going to give you loads

of points at the end of the game but also in the smaller companies because you can sell those shares at a good price once they get you know absorbed by the bigger ones and you can even trade them in for stocks for the bigger ones it's all about again doing things at the right time merging them at the right time predicting what other people want to be doing um yeah just just everything you really want from a um you know from an economic game um maybe stays a little bit too long on the table you are talking around 90 minutes here I would have loved it to be 60 Minutes uh but that is a nitpick because there is certainly the depth here and there is the decisions here and I enjoyed it a lot it certainly impressed me I wasn't quite sure how this was going to go because I know a lot of people say um it's still great a lot of people say it hasn't aged well I do think it has h12 but I enjoyed it a lot so I'm quite looking forward to playing this one again actually I definitely made some mistakes I wouldn't do again and I definitely think it's a strong way to play this game is to play with hidden stocks and shares rather than playing with public information because the game does actually say you can you know you can choose which one to play and I think you know kind of trying to remember what other people invested in and going on your gut reaction is going to keep the game moving along at a better Tempo rather than trying to completely accurately Master everything out um so yeah really impressed that is acquire at number five at number four I have Brazil Imperial so this is another game that I've actually reviewed in depth already so be sure to check out my review of this one um and this one was one of those games that intrigued me massively I knew this was becoming what was coming out for a long time and you're finally getting my hand on the

copy I'm very happy to say that um it's definitely lived up to my expectations so this is a euro 4X Style game so if you don't know what 4x Star Games is it basically means expand exploit and explore and exterminate and this game has all those facts in it however the exterminate is isn't as strong oh isn't so confrontational or destructive um as a lot of other ones are which suits me perfectly because I don't like you know massively destructive games but this one has a lot of similarities to a game like Scythe where you're simply selecting an action resolving it and constantly increasing and building up your engine by not only acquiring these cards which are great but also trying to you know move these resources from one part of your board to another one meaning that when you take these actions in the future you get an additional benefit to do things more efficiently you're expanding out you're discovering these mystery tiles you're building up these buildings um you're kind of racing to get these objectives done and and it getting your military units on the board you know fighting not any other players but also um you know neutral units on the board to get points you have tons of different options to go here it really is an efficiency engine and the resources flow flow smoothly it's not one of those games where you have to completely you know completely squeeze a stone you're getting blood out of a stone to get a single resource or two this one is a bit more generous which I think helps the game with its pacing I suppose because normally with games like this I find they're a bit too slow and stagnant to get moving this one just you know from the get-go it's you know full steam

ahead which I think suits the game perfectly so to get a game with so much going on in a you know 90 to 100 minute experience for me is fantastic so yeah go check out my review that is Brazil Imperial so at number three I have Nippon by what's your game and this is a game I've had on my shelf for a long time really happy I've got some for the table out because it is pretty damn spectacular very dry um so bear that in mind you know definitely a mechanical Style game um and I suppose one of the main factors in the game when it comes to the point scoring is area majority but I like the way that you have to build up a bit of an infrastructure before you can really compete in that area majority because the area majority is going to basically synergize directly with your resource management because you're going to be acquiring these companies what different Industries and acquiring colds spending those cold manufactured goods then using these Goods to put your influence on the map and I like the way that works there's a diverse route of strategies can go down in terms of Point scoring as it has this kind of tailorable um post scoring well you might think you know what I'm going to really focus on um getting these Trends on board which increase your influence and for every train I have I'm going to get x amount of points and you can get these bigger multiplier tokens which will get really Amplified depending on the strategy you want to go for tons going on in this game again a little sniffer like this isn't really going to do it justice but if you want a medium heavy weight economic um you know resource management engine building slash error majority

game this game is such a strong example and I have recorded a review of this one so hopefully that'll be dropping in the next week or so at number two I have the Magnificent which is a circus or Carnival themed game and the main mechanism of this game is a dice drafting which just so happens to be one of my favorite mechanisms of all time and this game does it as you can probably tell about its ranking to a very high standard and the Twist on this one is that when you're drafting these dice of different colors um basically the highest pit value of the colors that you draft that around is going to be the fee you have to pay in terms of you know your money which is you know a finite resource you have to balance it quite carefully and but the additional Twist on that is that the more you draft the same color the they start to kind of compound on each other so say I drafted a two the first time then I drafted a five of the green then you know the first time's gonna be worth two but the second time it's going to be worth seven because you're going to add the five to the two so you get stronger and stronger actions as you go but of course it's going to cost you more money but what you're trying to do in this game is that you're trying to acquire these cards and then put on these performances but to basically trigger these cards you need to lay a foundation of these polynomial tiles on your personal player board which will give you little bonuses as you can kind of cover things up and they'll also correspond to these scoring cards that you'll have to choose at the end of each round and so I love the fact that you when you draft one of these die you'll not only get to take an action but you also get a bonus action depending on the the card that you've placed on which could be a little manipulation tool that

it could be getting you like an additional coin or so but each of those cards also relates to a scoring criteria such as if every row you complete on your player Board of these tiles you'll get x amount of points if every one of these shapes you'll get x amount of points so it's all about trying to tailor your strategy and pace yourself to align with the cards you have and put on these putting on these big performances is also important because not only are you going to get a bunch of victory points and it's going to be your main way of scoring points but it's also going to associate to the new cards you get into your hand for the future and I love the way that works there's also a small degree of worker placement in this game where you can take these little kind of auxiliary bonus actions to get a little bonuses and things and it just comes together in a real harmonious digestible package with the potential of some huge Combos and some big satisfying scoring which is all things that I love particularly when it really dates back to the die strap so yeah very impressed with this one I think it's a delight to play and yeah just um just a home run so that is the Magnificent at number two and finally at number one and my favorite game of the month is Brussels 1893. So This truly is a dry mishmash of mechanisms but those mechanisms do such eyes are harmonized in my opinion to a very high standard so this one I suppose the main element of the game is worker placement where you have a big grid of work placement spots however each round only a fraction of those spots is going to be used and that is going to be the first

Player's Choice on how that is divided up and that ties in really well to the fact that you can actually buy or buy establish these buildings and take these workplace and spots and establish them as your own meaning that if somebody else goes to those spots you get a reward as well so you can kind of you know make sure that only the spots including your buildings are in the active area of this round which is quite a cool little twist and additional mechanisms of this game is that you're trying to acquire this artwork and sell it based on this really Dynamic Market which you can manipulate to your you know to your personal preference to get more money and victory points and I think the thing I like most about this game is the way that the worker placement and area control or area majority is a kind of balanced or mixed together because whenever you place a work at one of these spots you need to dedicate at least one value of money and basically what that means is that at the end of the game or end of the round whoever's put the most money in each column is going to get a bonus Associated to a bonus card at the bottom of that column which can be great things such as climbing tracks which will give you more points for different things and stuff like that you can establish these characters and get them into your employment which will give you kind of cool little special powers you can use but you need to weigh in the fact that you need to pay their wages at the end of the game and if you can't you're going to lose a bunch of points so there's so much going on here and you know a lot of individual mechanisms but it all seems to flow quite logically and it's like a bunch of things that you've seen before so it all feels familiar um but a lot going on here and the way it all merges together is just an

absolute Sublime experience so so impressive Brussels 1893 I know this one is getting a reprint this year with the old expansion that goes with it so it's going to be quite nice that it's going to be more widely available but again if you are a fan of dry Euros you like worker placement you like a bit of um you know a bit of trap climbing and loads of different ways to score points then Brussels 1893 is exceptional so there we have it those are the 18 new games I played throughout September 2022 hopefully you've enjoyed this video and you found it useful if you have please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and be sure to check out my other other content too additionally if you want to go that extra step then I do have a patreon campaign which of course I'd love to welcome you along to help support the channel keep it growing and keep it going strong but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved