10 Board Games Ranked - Episode 18
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to octopus edition of month in review so in this series I talk about all of the new board games I played during the previous month and I rank them for my least favorite all the way up to my most favorite now I have fewer games than usual this month with only 10 but that's a nice round amount and to be honest this month has been a pretty high quality one where there's been no games on this list I actually dislike they've all been decent at least and before I get started on the games I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order but let's get on with the games at number 10 that we have Grog Island which is a lesser known bidding Style game designed by Michael renick who's made some pretty good games such as Pillars of the Earth and co-designed Merlin actually um grug island is a bidding game that utilizes dice as a kind of thriving mechanism and you're going to roll these dice so at the start of each turn and they're all going to be assigned to a different color and you're going to use the pit values in order to determine your bid however you have some restrictions as only though you place these dice is important because you can only ever descend in value or be equal to a value so like for example the first spot you would have to be like a five and then a four then a three and so on or you can match but what's important is that the more dice you use it's probably going to secure you the victory in terms of winning the bid but it'll also reveal more of these token spots for your
opponent to take when they pass so it has this cool trade-off if you know am I going to try and compete for the bid what am I going to pass when there are a lot of these tokens revealed and I really did enjoy that twist now as soon as the player did win the bid and everyone else has passed then you're going to spend your money to the bank and then you're going to be Distributing your kind of workers out on the board and trying to control these different building types based on these objectives that you're given at the start of the game and some of these objectives are going to kind of crossover with other players like you all might be competing for the same buildings Etc some of you trying to get you know majorities on the islands some of them you might get points based on collecting certain cards and things um but I did like the way that the you know the bidding mechanism the tokens and where you can actually place your your workers on the buildings all mattered and they all synergized really nicely now unfortunately I think that big mechanism was where the game Peaks I thought everything else was kind of lackluster but yeah I'd like to see that mechanism used again in a more involved game and I thought it was just a little bit lacking for me in terms of the decisions and yeah I thought there's better video games out there unfortunately but yeah I liked it I certainly didn't like it at all and it worked quite well but I think um you know even from the vibe I had from the other people I was playing with they didn't seem to enjoy it too much which of course could you rub off on me as well so that is grog Island a good effort but not quite a keeper at number nine I have Murano by Marcus and Inca brand now this is another game that uses hidden objectives and through the form of these cards that you're collecting
throughout the game and these are going to have different criteria on them such as you know have X amount of these buildings on this island or have a matching number of the customers to the shops that you have on this island and so on so they're quite delicately balanced objectives which can become a frustrating exercise as inevitably players are going to be trying to reach their objectives which could just passively mess with yours so you need to be kind of uncomfortable with the frustration that this game offers at times which was kind of one of the negatives for me personally I like to kind of be able to do my own thing without having to worry too much about my opponents messing with me I mean whether they're meant to or not but essentially in this game You're Building buildings on these different Islands getting points for doing different things and collecting these gems trading on it for money again trying to tell you your strategy towards these objectives and I did really like the fact that in order to complete these objectives or be eligible to score them you had to basically give up one of your workers to that matched Island which could become quite costly and it is a kind of a Min maxing exercise to try to get the most out of each of these cards and I did like that puzzle now I did you know in addition to the um no the mess around messing around with other players which I did find annoying I did find another part of the game quite annoying at times which is the action selection mechanism which was essentially like a rondelle I suppose but with multiple pawns that you could move through the form of these these gondoliers I suppose or gondolas and you've been moving them I'm trying to take the action you took you know you could move one spot for free I think everyone after that would cost you money but what would happen is that every now
and then there'll be this huge bottleneck where all the boats would be scrunched up together and you'd have to spend quite a bit of money to take the action that you actually want um and sometimes that would like kind of lay the foundation for your opponent to get it cheaper the next time then that could become quite annoying as well but I'm probably making it sound more negative than it is because it is quite a fun game a little bit swingy at times in terms of rap drawing things randomly you know through card draws you know for the objectives that you want and these gems you're drawing from this bag but I can see this has an audience but it wasn't quite right for me and I've kind of come to notice that I think games that have hidden objectives as the main mechanism or one of the mechanisms tend to not Shine for me and I think Murano has solidified that so yeah not quite a recommendation but still some promise with Murano at number eight I have the Manhattan Project energy Empire which is a medium weight worker placement and engine building Style game with some pretty cool things going on I particularly like the use of dice as at the start of the game you generate the energy you're going to get but that could come with pollution which was another part of the game I really liked as your player board will be divided up into the kind of air the uh the land and the Sea area and as you took more powerful actions you could contaminate your land which could cost you victory points and different things as the game went on and I really like that kind of concept back and forth for trying to keep your your kind of environment clean I really did like that they also thought there's some good potential for some big rewarding terms to actually build up your engine um because these cars that you collect
would come in three different colors and the more you kind of stockpile on one color the more rewards you could take now I would have liked the game to have kind of took a different approach when it comes to diversifying you know when you collect different types of cards you get bigger rewards because it felt like the main strategy would be to just keep on you know tunnel visioning on one color and just milking it that way rather than having an incentive to do different things so again that was a small little Christmas I had there the rest of it I thought was nice again I'm kind of a bit hitting this when it comes to medium weight worker placement games this one was nearly there it nearly broke through for me because of those different things I mentioned you know the dice and the environment but the rest of it felt a little bit samey and it felt like a lot of other games out there and the big thing I um or my biggest critson I suppose and funnily enough that this is the same criticism I had from another game from this designer um so I felt that the resources in the game were too generous now I don't like anything Ultra tight by like a certain degree of tightness and harshness when it comes to getting your resources making them more valuable this one just seemed to shower you in resources and it felt like you could do anything at any time and that for me is normally a bit of a red flag and um it stops me coming back from it so yeah I would have liked to have seen it be a little bit tightened up just to make it a little bit you know harder to play I suppose so I did like this one I didn't love it and therefore it's not going to stay around but I'm glad I played it because it did have some positive attributes that is energy Empire at number seven I have a village rails
which is a small box Tableau Builder game very puzzly in its nature as you are building this three by four grid of cards and these cards are going to have multiple railway lines on them and you're building up this network trying to score as many points as you can based on the scoring criteria on those cards and on top of that you can get additional points based on these objective cards that you can assign to those lines now as soon as one of these railway lines is completed by going off that grid they're going to score your points and going to give you money based on these Terminus cars that you assign to them which is going to give you more money depending on certain criteria as well so I did like this trade-off of how many points am I going for here do I want long lines do I want short lines but when do I need to resupply my kitty of money to keep me going and to get the cards that I want and I did like the drafting mechanism in this game as well as though you know the first one you take would be free but everyone you skip over you have to deposit another coin on which makes it more inviting for your opponents um from the description you can probably tell how this game plays there's a lot of games out there like this but I did like this puzzly tangible nature of the railway lines crossing through each other and so on so a nice game I think my biggest criticism is the lack of replayability I feel like once you've played probably five times or so you've seen everything and you'll be ready to move on but it is Affordable it's a small box and it's a nice little game so that is Village rails check out my review number six I have Hamlet which is another 2022 release now Hamlet is a
communal Town building game as you are building this map um by placing this very unconventional tiles so you know most power placement games come with you know hexes or squares this one they are all wild and wacky shapes which is quite nice and makes it stand out from the pack in that respect and you're building buildings getting points as you're doing so aiding for endgame objectives trying to complete contracts uh but the thing that makes this game unique is the fact that when you produce resources those resources are not your own personal resources they do not go into your supply and they remain on the board ready for all the other players to use them and the cool thing about this as well is that when you build a new kind of building or you know extend the map you need to be able to convert or create a route from the resources that you need to the building that you're building and you do that by placing your workers in certain orders and by placing these donkeys on a board which will create a pathway and a clean route going to transfer those goods from one place to the next so I did really like that almost um logistical puzzle in the way it worked and particularly as the map got bigger and bigger you need to place those um you know stockies and your workers quite carefully so that was quite Nifty definitely the thing to differentiated this to a lot of the other top present games and city building games out there now a nice game I did enjoy it at least around an hour maybe a little bit longer I'm pretty um pretty intuitive in the way it works I think maybe you know you need to get your head around the way that the resources are not your own at first but I did like the way that you know producing resources is not only
going to help the other players but you do get rewarded for doing so by getting money we're just going to let you get kind of the tiles that you want in the future um so yeah really nice well-rounded game some hit or miss with the production I think something iconography is a little bit small gets some rules a little bit fiddly at times but some of them some of the production as well was Stella you know these metal coins in this game are fantastic but again a decent game I'm pretty happy with it and I'll happily play it some more so that is Hamlet at number six okay so let's get started on the top half of this and this is where my recommendations are going to begin and we're going to start at number five with a game called mask men so mask man is actually an older game it goes back to 2014 and is published by OIP games who most recently and most notably came out with a game called Scout which is a mentally popular little ladder climbing card game now masked Men actually has a lot of shared DNA with a game like Scout it is another shedding ladder climbing card game however this wanna listen because it makes us different to a lot of the other kind of ladder climbing games is the fact that you are determining the strength of these suits as the game progresses now all of these suits is going to be represented by a kind of a Mexican Luchador wrestler and as the game goes on as I said you're going to be determining the strength of them by initially you know playing one card is going to be you know the foundation that two cards is going to be stronger than that three cards is going to be the next strongest wrestler and so on but it does mean that as the game goes on you're going to formulate this
kind of totem pole or a hierarchy of wrestlers meaning that in the future if I played say three cars of a weak wrestler I could play three cards as long as that wrestler is stronger in the standings and again you're just trying to shed through these cars trying to get rid of them as quickly as possible this is a game of layers it's um quite an obtuse game and I think you know despite there only being two rules in the game it's certainly a game you need to play a few times in order to progress or to process how the game works because it is a little bit different and a little bit a little bit weird in the way it works but I definitely think it's worth pushing through that initial learning curve because I think the dividends you get on the end is worth it because it's a very clever little game that you're going to constantly be thinking of clever moves and um you know feeling you're feeling clever when it does work your way so yeah definitely if you like your little card games and you like trick taking you like ladder climbing then this one is definitely one to look at so that is mask Med at number four we have the oldest game on the list going back all the way to 1998 we have the Classic rhino kanitzi again Samurai so Samurai has been a game I've been hunting high and low four for a very long time and I recently got my hands on it I'm very happy to do so you can see here it's ranked very high on this month's standings and in fact in My overall top 100 it's come straight in there and I've found its place this is a really well Ultra streamlined and clever it's kind of Airy majority Style game as you're trying to claim dominance on this map of Japan by surrounding these different cities and
towns and collecting these items on them you've got three different types of items and the idea is that you have to be the majority holder of two out of those three to automatically win if that doesn't work out then you're going to be if you're a person with the most of one type you're going to be the winner and so on um and you're going to be taking turns by placing these tiles out from a player five that you have in front of you behind a secret screen now these tiles are going to have specific logos on them Associated to particular things you're collecting or they can be more generic Samurai which can go anywhere but are generally a little bit weaker but of course much more flexible you have some very clever little tiles you can play as well such as ones that will switch the location of the things you're collecting they can be one such as taking tiles back into your hand and redeploying them so you've got some cool Little twisters some little powers that you can utilize um you know Ultra fast game takes around half an hour to 45 minutes to play Rich in the decision making every decision matters in the game and it flows beautifully smoothly and yeah I can certainly see why this one's you know stood the test of time people still talking about this one people still recommend it and yeah it still feels fresh and Innovative so love games like this and this is just another kind of you know again it's going to fit seamlessly in my collection because there's never going to be a time when I'm not going to want to get this onto the table so that is Samurai and hopefully I'll be reviewing that one soon at number three I have Zango which I think is the heaviest game on this
list this month now Zango is published by watch your game who used to make some fantastic Euro games very dry and that certainly um describes this game but still very clever very rich in the decisions you're making so Zango it's essentially an area majority Style game and an engine building Style game and I love this key decision of having a hand of cards you're either going to use those cards to increase and improve your engine but risking discontent amongst your people which can potentially nullify your engine or you could use those cars in order to take an action it's all about trying to pace yourself do things in the right order and maybe you want to build your ex your engine before you take an action to get more you know rewards for doing so but every single one of these cars you play has a unique number assigned to it when you play it to take an action you need to be higher than the existing card to take some actions or lower than the existing card to take some other actions which is another little wrinkle and thought you know a little bit of thought you need to think through on your turn so yeah I really do like that it does become quite a brain burnery exercise as again you're looking at these cards thinking that I've got a new system from engine and then I'm going to use this one then I'm going to play this one here hopefully the numbers can be lower so I can play this one and so on they're holding off until the numbers right for me to play this card um yeah just tons and tons of depth here you're building pagodas on the board and getting points based on cards you have in your engine you're getting endgame scoring you're going for these public objectives which are going to actually multiply with each other if you get more of them achieved which is another little
twist I haven't seen before lots of tailorable strategy am I gonna get punched for this or this or this what am I doing well in and hopefully I'll get a better multiplier on that um yeah yeah I have reviewed this one I will upload it very shortly so if you do like your Euros on the heavier end of the spectrum then zanguo is certainly a Hidden Gem at you I certainly have my biggest surprise of the month and probably of the Year this is Caesar's Empire another 2022 release and if you are in the camp of less is more then I'm pretty sure you're going to love this game so Caesar's Empire is a simple set collection and root building Style game as you are placing at your pieces on these roads and connecting to the next available City now when you collect these cities you are going to get the token on of that City and they're going to be in different colors and only your highest one of each color is going to score at the end of the game but you're also going to get a smaller token which will score you points based on a sliding scale date are you going to get more different ones or even collecting the same ones will get you even more points so you kind of have this macro look at the board when you start and you can think you know what I'm going for these tokens I'll try in that way however there are additional twists on this game that whenever you complete your turn you're going to trace your route back to Rome in the center of the board and get a point for every one of your pieces that you pass through but the twist is your opponents will also get a point for everyone they pass through that passes through their pieces
so this is constant trade-off of getting points when it's not even your turn trying to get shortcuts and divert routes away from your opponents so they don't get they don't get rewards from from your times as well and it's just a perfect example of a streamlined experience zero blow on the rules it feels like a connection design but it's not and it is just a wonderful game that takes around 30 minutes to play scales great from three to five you know if you want to you know a five player game that isn't on the party variety this is a great one to look at thinky clever very accessible and you could easily teach us the families and yeah this is definitely um impressed me immensely I'll be massively surprised if this doesn't end up in my top 10 or even top five of the year when it comes to 2022 releases that's how much I think of this game a little bit overproduced but hey it's a nice product it looks great on the table but yeah the gameplay is fantastic so that is Caesar's Empire at number two and finally at number one and my favorite game that I played throughout October 2022 was Shipyard so Shipyard is actually an older Vladimir Suki design that goes back to 2000 and nine and it's still considered to be one of his best games but sadly it has been out of print for quite a long time now so getting your hands on a copy is going to be hard work but if you like Rob Dells which I just don't happen to do so and this is the definitive rondelle game as you have rundowns within rondelles within rondelles but essentially what you're
trying to do is You're Building these ships like drafting them and then you are trying to fill up fill up these ships with the right crew with the right safety equipment and with little speed boosters and things with the aim of trying to score points through these short-term objectives and long-term object term objectives because at the start of the game you're going to given a bunch of these um hidden objective tiles which might say things such as every size five ship you'll get when you make at the end of the game you'll get x amount of points or for every one of your ships that you put a a Lifeboat on you'll get expanded points and so on but I love the fact that halfway through the game and at certain points you actually have to expose or discard some of these objective tiles to narrow you away to a certain specific objective so it starts up wide but it funnels down to very specific needs on what you're aiming towards so I did like that flexibility there I like the um this idea of trying to get build your ships up and sending them off as soon as they're complete through these guitars that you complete When You Reach certain checkpoints you get points of different criteria um so yeah I did like that mix of short term and long-term Point scoring the interaction with the other players is cool because you know when you move things on the rondelle it's going to impact that you know affect the next player's decision and what options is they have and it's just a really nice put together game it's quite bitty because there's a ton of components here but hey it's quite thematic as well and I like the way it works and I like the way it all comes together and it certainly feels distinct and I can't really think of any other game that fits
the niche of Shipyard it feels different which is quite a hard thing to achieve nowadays but I went into this game expecting to like it and I really did as you can see if I'm number one here and it's gone straight in to you know a pretty uh respectable ranking factor a highly respectful rank so they're my favorite game of the month is Shipyard so there we have it that's this month's 10 games hopefully you've enjoyed this video if you have please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too and inevitability I am going to be releasing content on each of these games because I think they're all worth talking about even though I like some much more than others as usual thank you for joining me and I'll see you next time on chairman of the bud bye