My votes for the Golden Geek Award Nominees 2024
Transcript
Hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor. My name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor. Today in this video I'm going to go through the nominations for the uh board game geek uh yearly the golden geek uh nominations for the awards uh this year. So uh the way that this works is they have different categories and in each category we'll start with the two-player uh game category. you get to rank the games from, you know, one to however many there there are. If you haven't played it, uh then you can put Na and all of these will be um linked together and uh you know, added together and we'll have winners and nominations later on. So, I wanted to go through and off the cuff share some of my thoughts on some of these games that I was able to play from last year or that I have played this year uh and perhaps have reviewed it, perhaps not, but I did want to give my thoughts on them. So, most of these two-player games I have not played. Um, I've heard of quite a few of them. Dune War for Arachus is a two-player version of let's see uh I knew Oh yeah, War of the Ring the second edition. So that seems pretty interesting to me. I would, you know, out of all of these I would be interested in playing this one. Flat
Iron is the new game by Isra and Shay that looks interesting as well that I have not had a chance to play. Other than that, I've heard really good things about Kelp, uh, Shark Versus Octopus. I think this is a twoplayer trick-taking game, uh, head-to-head tricktaking game, I believe. And yeah, lots of good things to say about this game. so far, but the ones that I have played are a Robin Hood and Lord of the Rings Duel for Middle Earth. Um, I haven't played Star Wars Unlimited, the new TCG. I have played King of Tokyo Tokyo Duel, I'm pretty sure. Uh, so I'll give this uh as my bronze medal vote. I liked the Lord of the Rings duel for Middle Earth more than A Just Robin Hood. I think a Just of Robin Hood is a deeper game. It's more, you know, set in in history or, you know, Robin Hood if if it was historical, you know, um, lots of legends behind it, right? But, um, it it plays like a historic war type of game for two players and that's really fun.
You can play this on board game arena, but I enjoyed the Lord of the Rings duel for Middle Earth more and I found it was more easily accessible and easier to bring to the table and so um and probably cheaper, too. So, I was able to buy a copy of this and play it and really enjoyed it. So, I think my opinions still hold true from when I played both of these games um a couple of months back. and I do like dual for middle earth more. So that is going to be my ranking for two-player games artwork. So this one I will have a lot of opportunities to uh to talk about some of these games. Um, I'll only mention the ones that I have played. And I think for artwork as well and presentation, I think something that will make the game play better and not only not only look great, but also it helps in its function and how the game plays.
So, so I really enjoyed The Lord of the Rings Duel Middle Earth. Once again, the artwork is stunning. Um, I really enjoy Dutra's work in how he layers some of the cards and the board as well. The if we want to bring up a an example of this, uh, let's see if we have an image of the track, right? Um, I love the panoramic view of the trek from the Shire all the way to Middle Earth or sorry, uh, Mount Doom in Mordor. So, that's going to be the one to beat. Unconscious Mind is really good as well. Um, the blend of different art styles for the real world as well as dreams really captured uh my interest in how the game looks and I think it the iconography also helps it play well. Let's see. Uh, so those I had already uh voted for. We've got arcs. I think arcs is the art is okay. Um, I guess I'm not the biggest fan of the artwork and the and the art style in these games. I think it's it's fine. Um, the fellowship uh the artwork is okay too for is okay. Harmonies is good as
well. It doesn't help the I guess the aesthetics or the function of the game as much, but it's it's good to look at. Let's go to Japan is fun as well. SETI. There's a lot of pictures and um kind of akin to how Ark Nova is, right? I think it's a little bit more artistic with the cards if I remember right. Uh but it's more like picturesque type of uh presentations rather than like brush work or something like that. Uh Wonders Creatures looks good. I haven't played this one yet, so I won't rank it. And then Worms Span, the obviously the dragons look really good as well. So, I think I'm good with the the first two here. So I will just kind of based off of preference and taste probably let's go with uh seti three worms 4 harmonies five uh fellowship six from 7 oh uh let's go to Japan 8 and nine yeah so these are the only two games that I haven't played there. Uh yeah, I I doubt that a lot of these lower ranks will affect the overall ranking too much. You know, I think other people might uh be in the majority for for some of those. But I think yeah, I think this also has to go
with Lord of the Rings Duel for Middle Earth for the way that it looks, but also how well it uh comes together. So, cooperative games. Looking at this list, I have played Dead Cells. I've played The Fellowship. I've tried The Gang a little bit, but I'm not going to rank it because it's uh I barely peruse it. I really haven't played it with other people. So, Leviathan Wilds, I did a review of that with Jacob. I played Slay the Spire recently, and that's it. So, which out of these are my favorite cooperative games? I really I really liked Leviathan Wilds I think the most. I think this game was one really easy to get into and play because of the uh the spiralbound notebook. Um, I like the cooperative style of this game where you can really help someone out and you're aware of other people's situations, but you're mostly working on your own character and you're not really quarterbacking and telling what other people should do because everyone has their own set of cards essentially. And it played pretty quick.
And that's probably why I liked it more than Slay the Spire. It's very similar to Slay the Spire in terms of how it cooperatively works. So, out of I think my number two is going to be the Fellowship because what it does play a little bit quicker than Slay the Spire. I mentioned before I'd rather play Slay the Spire as a video game, but I mean it's it's a really good game either way. Um, I like the fact that if you do fail, you don't spend I mean, you're you're meant to probably not make it all the way to the third final boss in Slay the Spire, right? Like in the in the video game, but it it just feels so disheartening to me when you do spend hours making your way towards that end goal and not being able to reach it. Whereas with fellowship, you can go through a hand pretty quickly in 5 minutes or so or less and uh if you don't make it, you just reshuffle and and redal. Um the newness and the I guess the element of discovery is still there with the fellowship and so I haven't finished it yet, but really look forward to doing so. And so it kind of still has that new game like what awaits this legacy type of game feeling. And so I think that's why I'll put it at number two. So I will
put Slay the Spire at number three cuz I liked it better than Dead Cells. I like the system better. And that's it. Okay. Expansions. So I haven't played the new Arcs expansions. I've only played the base game. That looks really fun to do. I haven't played this. You know, the four shuffle uh expansions, expeditions, Gaia Project, Heat, all of these are really good and things that I would really be interested in playing. I think out of all of these, the one that I would be most interested in is the White Castle Matcha. I forget what this expansion does for the game. I think it adds a new resource and uh a new place to place your members and so it kind of opens up the opportunities a little bit more uh for where to place it and it's already it's a really fun game and and how tight it is and so I am curious to see how that would pan out. um Obsession, you know, more characters that would be really fun to play with Gaia Project as well. If the Actually, I think I might have played the Alpine expansion on board game arena. I hope you know if if I'm wrong, correct me. But if if so, then it just added some more cards with different effects. And so that just adds
some more variety to for shuffle. I will rank that one. But the one that I have played the most is Turbulence. So, I think out of all of these choices, the the turbulence one with the additional scenarios and missions really makes it uh feel different every time. And I I am biased because I do play this more often with a friend uh on a regular basis. And so, I do have a lot of experience there. I will give that one the number two. And everything else I'm just very interested in playing. even you know terraforming Mars Prelude 2 arcs especially I would love an epic gaming session to experience that with but we'll see so the most innovative games here so I've uh you know what how does you know what mechanisms are brought you know new to the game or if they're delivered you know old you know familiar uh I guess mechanisms how are they delivered and brought together in a new and innovative way. Um I I guess this is what this is going at.
I So I think arcs. So I've played arcs. I've played from Let's Go and STI. So only four rankings here. Um I do appreciate what Fromage is doing here with a more timing like aspect. It's not as it it's kind of like a reverse um Zulkan if you think about it. Whereas with Zulken and other games, you place your worker on a spot and you wait so many turns before you choose to pull it out. For Mage, you you know, you forward that with I'm going to place this worker here for three turns and then you'll know exactly when you get it back. And so I think that mechanism is pretty fresh and interesting. Uh the way that arcs comes about it though with how intricate a system can be of a sort of forex space type of game with trick- taking elements I think is the most innovative way. And so I'm just the sheer complexity with the sheer elegance of the card system I think is is very interesting. it and I I I think this this category is somewhat subjective, right? It's it's not um exactly uh you know objective to say what is innovative and what's not. And so I think that is definitely going to be the most innovative followed by
Fromage. I think Formage does a great job. I the game didn't come together for me as well as it does for most people, but I will give it that it is mechanically and and thematically pretty innovative as well. Um I love cheese and so I I love the theme of it. And then out of the the next couple of of games here, uh let's let's go and set neither one strike me as something that is super innovative. I would say let's go to Japan for its theme is a little bit more innovative than SEI is. So I will uh leave it as such. And as for the rest of these games, I'm not too familiar with the games that I haven't mentioned yet.
Bomb Busters is a fun um fun short little game that uh I was interested in playing, but I haven't yet. And so that's Yeah. All right. So, light game of the year. I've played Captain Flip. I've played Castle Combos. Flip seven. Yes. Mlem and River Valley Glass Works. So, this one's pretty easy. Castle combo is I think the best one out of all of these. It's a very simple game, easy to teach, but the variety in the cards is the kind of variability that I enjoy in games. And just to give you a sense of what that is, you're you're building a very small tableau and drafting cards, all of them individualistic in what they are and how they work. And so, uh, it it's a somewhat tactical game, but it's easy and short enough to play over and over again and still be fresh. And so, this is definitely up my alley when it comes to lighter games.
for the rest of these. Flip seven I think is going to be next. I think I I do really enjoy the different kinds of cards you have in this push your luck type of game. Um I've got this going pretty consistently on Board Game Arena right now and it's it's just a good time. River Valley Glass Works is kind of an Azullesque type of game where I prefer Azul over River Valley Glass Works, but it was pretty good. And I guess I would rather play I don't really particularly enjoy these these two games, Malem and Captain Flip. Um, I guess I'll give it to MM and then Captain Flip uh for the four and five. I would love to try Rebirth and Cities. I think those two would be interesting games to try as well in the future, but um we'll leave it there. Medium game of the year. All right, so these are some pretty good games here. I've played most of them, actually, uh if not all of them except for Endeavor. Uh I I thought Endeavor would be a heavier game, but I guess it's not. And this is one that I am wanting to play and probably will play uh pretty soon and review. Uh I would love to have this reviewed uh before I approach the year's worth of games again at the end of the year. But out of all
of these games, I would say that my favorite is going to be Harmonies. Harmonies is the perfect way for me. I I mean, if if you just watched the video that I I did uh playing with my wife uh to celebrate 500 subscribers, uh we had a great discussion and playthrough of this game and how this is my preferred method of tableau building. Uh compared to Cascadia, it feels like my wife said, very much like tiny towns and a zool, right? So, it's kind of a combination of those two games. So yeah, just really really enjoyed this game. Out of the next ones, I would say the next highest one would either be Duel for Middle Earth or Wormspan. I think Worms I think for this category I'm going to go for Lord of the Rings cuz it does feel more middleweight than Worms Span. I think Worms Span is a little bit heavier and this would make more sense if Wingspan was here. I really I really did enjoy Worms Span. And I I do like Wingspan more thematically, but Worms Span mechanically was just as good, if not better. And so I look forward to playing this more. Uh, and uh, I think I will own Wingspan, but I would play Worms Span more probably. I don't know. So that's an easy number two and three. Uh, out of the next couple, the Fellowship will
probably go four for me. Um, I think I liked Windmill Valley next the best. Uh, it's a Danny Garcia game where it it's very much a Euro style game. I reviewed it on the channel and quite enjoyed it. I like I guess I like Formage better than Let's Go to the Let's Go to Japan. I think Let's Go to Japan is fun thematically, but um you know, it it feels very much like any other kind of I guess tableau building, deck building, I don't know, kind of game. You're not building a deck. Sorry. Uh it's it it's fine. I think it's more aesthetically pleasing than mechanically sound. And so that's Formage has the edge, I think, both in terms of theme and as well as how it plays. Uh, River of Gold has received a lot of praise, but it didn't really stand out to me as something that I would want to return to. And Slay the Spire probably, despite my gripes about it, would probably probably hit the table more than River of Gold would. So, yeah, Endeavor Deep Sea would probably go somewhere higher.
Um, I'm I'm I'm thinking top five probably, but I would have to play it first. So, all right. Finally, heavy game of the year. So, this is where a lot of my interests lie. And some of these games, about half of these games I've played. So, Black Forest. Okay, so we got Black Forest and Collution. This reminds me of when I was ranking my uh games from last year uh my my top 10 games back in December and I remember trying to uh differentiate between these two. I believe I gave it to Black Forest and I think I still would. I I I'm a sucker for Rosenberg games, as you know, and Black Forest utilizes a lot of the same mechanisms as one of my favorite games of all time, Glass Road, and so it's pretty hard to beat, but Colution is pretty close behind it. I Civolution has the legs, I think, to make it quite far in terms of what I enjoy. Next would either be STEI or arcs. And I think Arcs has a lot of potential to be one of my favorite games. I know it's going to come digitally. I'm sure STI will become a digital game as well, a lot easier for me to play and um dive into. I think STI is going to be right
now the game that I would approach first. You know, I think it's easier to understand and wrap my head around based off of my past plays. Arcs is still a little bit more of an outlier uh in terms of theme. You know, I don't tend to gravitate towards the Space X uh 4X type of game, but it's still very interesting. I was blown away when I first played it and would love to uh try it again. I would love to try Andromeda's Edge. I enjoyed Dwellings of Elder Elder Veil, which is this is a space version uh kind of a a second edition or a like a sequel to, right? Um so I would love to play that. Uh Unconscious Minds I have played of course and I probably would play that ahead of Inventions. I I I remember putting this on my list. It was pretty low on my top 10 list, but I think it inventions will be bumped out pretty quickly because it's I think it's a little too abstracted for my taste in terms of a civilization themed game from Lera. And yeah, so out of the ones left over, um I do enjoy uh the Garfield game um Garpiel games. Um, they all kind of, you know, it's I I feel like people who look at my tastes and see the the appreciation that I have for the nuances between the Rosenberg games, I feel like would have the same type of appreciation
approach as they do for the nuances seen in the Garill games, right? And so, um, to me, these games kind of feel would probably feel a little similar. I've heard Ezra and Nehemiah have a lot of like they they conglomerate a lot of the cool mechanisms that you see in like Paladins and other games from across the different uh trilogies, right? So yeah, I would love to play all of these games except for Mennefer. I think while mechanically pretty sound, it's a little too dry for my tastes. So yeah, we'll see if we ever get to those in the future. So, those are my rankings for uh heavy game of the year. Now, I don't know if I'm going to go through these as in depth. Uh I'll give Flip 7 my number one here for party game. It Yeah, I that's probably one that I would return to the most out of that. I haven't I haven't played any of these games. I know about knights because I did um help back one game from this designer uh a civil a civilization print and play that looks pretty interesting. So I'll probably if I get access to that a review on this channel solo games. So yeah, some of these games, what would I play solo? Probably Colution. Uh, I really liked how this AI uh was uh done in evolution. I am
planning I do have a copy of this game and and will do a live play of this solo at some point because I want to I I want to do that. So, uh, Slay the Spire number two. And that's it for that. Uh, a lot of these other games I don't really know much about. I've kind of heard of Kingdom Legacy. That one looks interesting to me. Uh, Imperium Horizons. I've played the Imperium games. I do prefer Captain's Chair more. Um, Bloom Haven Buttons and Bugs. Also, uh, I don't think I'll get around to this one, but I've heard good things about that one, too. Thematic game. All right. So, which one in my opinion approaches the theme?
And what theme would I, you know, appreciate the most out of all of these? I think STEI SEI out of all of these was just so cool in how it approached um in Euro style mechanisms the search for intelligence and space you know space travel or space exploration right so I just loved how thematic this game was that's an easy number one for me um and then looking at the rest of these these are pretty good I mean arcs Unconscious mind was really good thematically, too. I And yeah, these are all really good. Uh I I guess for theme, I'm going to go unconscious mind as number two. I think it approaches the theme really well and um represents what you would do as a uh clinician, I suppose, or a psychologist, psychiatrist in this time period. I I think that it meshed really well in this game. Uh, the Lord of the Rings duel for Middle Earth really had that push and pull type of feeling that you see in the movies and books. I'll put arcs as number four because I think it does bring a lot of the mechanisms and and feeling and theme uh together uh for a space for X in a new and innovative way. Um, let's go to Japan. Yeah, that's probably a Yeah, it'll go there for its
theme. It's pretty new. I'm surprised that Fromage isn't on this list. I think that's a theme that is interesting and novel. Uh the trick- taking game. Yeah, this one. Yeah, it's it's so hard to rank all of these. These are really close. I really enjoyed how each mission has reflected different parts of the book. So, I even though it's number six, I think it's really good. And yeah, so that's that's it for that. Uh, here are the war games. Uh, you know, I I'm going to leave this alone. I don't want to sole my votes as a Euro game player on some of these other war games that probably deserve it more. Uh, you know, a lot of these historical type games, um, GMT games as well. Uh, yeah, they probably deserve it more. So, I'm going to leave that alone and I'm going to skip over best podcast.
I don't want to I I will vote for a lot of these. I do enjoy um a ton of these. Uh Game Brain is probably my favorite because this is the podcast that really got me interested in a lot of the games that I enjoy now and I resonate with a lot of what they say. And so, but I I really love Decision Space, Blue Pig, Pink Pig, Board Game Barbecue. Yeah, all of these I've I've really enjoyed listening to and I think they all should they all deserve to win honestly. So, I'm going to go to the app. This is something that I am familiar very familiar with, right? Um, as I tend to play a lot of games online. So, okay. I didn't know that pocket was on on this. Uh I will rank that. I do collect the cards in this game, but I um I mean I don't think the Pokemon TCG is on board game geek, so I think that's weird. Uh yeah, out of So I have played a lot of these games. The one that really speaks to me is Dune Imperium. I think the way that this game was implemented made it so feasible and so easy to play. I I like the online uh matchmaking that uh Direwolf does. Uh so I think this one has a lot of people on it and is a game that deserves uh a digital implementation and is done really well.
So that one is definitely up there. And they implemented a fast forward button. So, this made it even better to play. Uh, I've heard a lot of good things about uh I So, first of all, I have played Clank and uh yeah, I think I'll give this number two for the for similar reasons as Dune. Same company. They do a really good job Direwolf does with how well they implement these games. And so, that's an easy one. And two, the Code Names app I have not played, but I've heard it's really good. the I did not know Point Salad had a an app, but I think it is back as of yesterday on Board Game Arena. So, that is great. I'm I have played uh Calico and so I'm going to give that a number three. The only issue that I have with Monster Couch, which which is the publisher for the digital version of this, and Wingspan, is that the online matchmaking system is quite often um hard to have games continue because people there there's no penalty for not being able to play a or keep a game going, right? If you decide to leave or not play, um there, you know, there's no way to modulate like the reputation that you have on Board Game Arena to filter out people who might not play. There's no way to change the asynchronous nature of the game, whether it's it's only real time or 72 hours, right? There's no in between.
So, while I like the game and the implementation is nice, aesthetically nice, the matchmaking is not as great. So, actually, I might put this as number four. And then we'll give Pocket a number three. It's This is a fun game, you know. This is Yeah. Uh Stone Age. did not know this had a digital version of it. I'm sure it's great. And the rest of these games, Mountain Goats, I've played on board game Arena. So, I did. Yeah, that that's where I would go to it. And I have not played the uh uh specified uh apps for the rest of these games. So, that's it. So, there you go. I'm going to leave it on this. This is like this is my comfort zone right here. But uh those are my nominations and my picks for the uh Golden Geek for last year 2024. And we'll see who the winners are.
I think everyone here deserves a win and a nod and a mention. And hopefully they get their due uh for these amazing games that have come out in the last year. So, thank you for joining me on this journey. Hope you schedule an appointment with me real soon and I'll catch you on the next one. Take care.