The Original Top 100 Revisited: Cosmic Encounter, Lost Cities and More!
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vasel and welcome to my top 10 games of all time from 21 years ago. I'm taking a look at my top 100 games of all time. We're at the top of the list, 10 through one in the year 2005. And where are those games today? Cuz your gaming change tastes change a lot over 21 years, and mine are no different than most, I suppose. I played many games in the meantime. Have any of the games made it till today? Well, the answer to that is yes. So, let's take a look at them starting with number 10. So, number 10 here is Lost Cities. Lost Cities is a game that has been on my list for a while. I've always enjoyed the game, still like the game. It made it till the year 2016, 10 years ago, where it was 172 and then kind of has fallen off the list. I'm not sure where it would be now, but it's still a game, as you can see here, I have a very high rating on it. This is still a game that I me and my wife played it a lot. Um this was very early on in our marriage.
We're coming up here on 27 years of marriage, and uh so this is 21 years ago. We had only been married for 6 years, and this was something we played a lot when we first got married. Um and we really enjoyed this game. Uh it just really was fun to play these cards back and forth. It was just a good two-player game and really like this one. I have a very soft spot in my heart for this game if only for that, cuz I played this game a lot. In fact, I have a trophy uh from winning the chairman of the board at Origins 20 years ago, and the championship game was Lost Cities that I won a single round of.
So, uh very very amusing uh game for me, and that was my number 10. Number nine is Age of Steam. Now, this made it to 2009 where it was 163 and then fell off the list. And Age of Steam just wouldn't even come close probably even make it my top 500 these days. I've dropped quite a bit on this game, and that's unfortunate because there's a very beautiful version of this out now from Eagle-Gryphon Games. Uh Age of Steam is a game that when I played it blew my mind. This idea of picking a different role, uh getting a special ability with that role, placing out such a fierce and back and forth pick up and delivery style game. But then they made other versions of it. I've already mentioned on this list Railroad Tycoon, which for me eventually surpassed this, or also the follow-up Steam, which surpassed this. And then other games have taken the place of this. I still like the whole idea of picking things up and delivering them to another spot. Age of Steam has fallen pretty far, but there's no question that this is a very solidly well-done game.
At the time here, I was a very big Martin Wallace fan. This is not the only game of his in my top 10 at this point in time. Uh but I I did like this one, but like I said, it has fallen off for me. And speaking of Martin Wallace, let's go to number eight, Liberté. Liberté is a game that was taking place during this for the French Revolution, and it does not look particularly fancy here. Although at the time, I was like, "Look at all these blocks." There's three different factions in this game, the the you know, the people who are revolutionary, and we have the royals and the moderates, and you are trying to control them. But what fascinated me so much about this game was the fact that there was two alternate victory conditions. You get to the end and you would score up your points, but there could be a revolution or a counter-revolution could take place, and then scoring happened differently. I was really fascinated by this one. It's been on my list in 2011, it it was 95, and that's the last we saw of it. As time went by, I was a little more this game just didn't stand out. I kept I would teach this game to new people all the time, and I found that I was the only person enjoying it. And then started to wonder maybe the game wasn't as strong as I thought, that there were some neat concepts to it that I really enjoyed, but for me it just didn't have a lasting effect. So, this one is kind of gone, and I don't know if I will play it again, actually. But at this time, I was loving it.
The next one, El Grande, was my number seven. Today, it is number 149. So, still really high up there. This is the classic, the original area control game where you're using these boring cubes to control fairly ugly board. They have a new version of it now, which is a little nicer looking, for sure. But this is just straight-up area control. I think this game scales really well. I believe it's on my top 10 games that scale well, because I think it plays well with three, four, and five. And the idea of playing these cards and that card giving you a special ability and the number of people to play out there. It hasn't aged as well as it could just because there's so many of these cool games out there, but there are very few games that do one thing. This is area control. There's nothing else. They added some stuff in the expansions, but basically the base game is just area control, and I thought that was a neat concept, and I still like it to this day.
Number six, 21 years ago, was a tie for me between two games that are very similar. One is Memoir '44, and the other is Commands & Colors: Ancients. Both of these are in the series the Commands & Colors, which started with um the original one was called Battle Cry, a Civil War game, and then the second one to come out was Memoir '44, which was just re-released. In fact, I just recently did a comparison of the new version compared to the old version from Days of Wonder. This is one of the games that put Days of Wonder on the map when they were just publishing mega hits. This game was huge for them, but paled besides Ticket to Ride, which came out the same time. Um and I loved it. Finally, and this this picture, which is you see so many times as you miss exact picture here.
Um finally, I get to play with green army men on the map. And I remember when it came out, there was a big backlash. This was not a real war game, blah blah blah, because of who cares. It was a war game. It is a war game. It's just not as difficult as those other ones, and this one has stood the test of time. Uh Memoir '44 uh was last seen on my list at 201 in 2021. Although it's easily just a little bit above there. Um uh this year, I when I was doing the list, Commands & Colors: Ancients uh hit my list at 193. And so that might even be tied with Memoir '44. They're very similar in some ways. Commands & Colors: Ancients isn't as cool-looking with miniatures, although the wooden blocks do look neat, although have fun stickering them. But I think Commands & Colors is a better game because of it's all about the lines and controlling leaders and trying not to get your line broken and working together. A lot of really cool concepts. But honestly, it's what what I'm in the mood for that day.
Do I want to play a more strategic control your line and try to outflank the opponent, or do I just want to move around tanks and artillery and troops and refight World War II? So, they're two sides of the same coin. I like them a lot, and they were tied, and I still enjoy them to this day. All right, number five for me is Wallenstein. Wallenstein, a game from Dirk Henn from Queen Games, is a game again with cubes. Apparently, I was very enamored with cubes in 2005. But Wallenstein, what I was enamored with in this game was the cube tower. That's this device here where you would drop cubes. There's little shelves in there, and not every cube would come out the bottom. Now, honestly, that's a cool mechanism, but it is not why Wallenstein is on my list. And in fact, today Wallenstein is ranked 130, still very very high.
Um but it's that cube thing is really neat, but there was a game that came out before this about the Crusades, which was all about the cube tower, and that wasn't it. This game has such a neat mechanism where each round of the game, there's a bunch of actions that are going to come out, and you are assigning all the different territories you control these actions. A couple of them might be battles. And each round of the game, there's a few battles that occur. But that's you're also taxing and getting grain, and there's just a lot of things that are going back and forth. Really enjoy Wallenstein. They made a follow-up to it called Shogun, which is essentially the same game uh with a a Japanese map. I don't like it because the map is longer. I like the more centralized map. Shogun did add some rules, but they eventually put them all back into the second edition of Wallenstein, which is the one that I rank very highly today.
So, that was my number five. Number four, still on my list today. It is now number 26 today, and that is Ticket to Ride. Ticket to Ride, a game that when I played it, I was fascinated. I remember seeing this game. The first time I played it was on a hotel bed. Uh the the director of Days of Wonder brought us up to his room to show us this game set up on the bed and put it out there, and I was like, "Yeah, it looks looks fine. Looks cool. It's a Days of Wonder game." But he was acting like this was some amazing game. And I at the same time, he had been showing us Memoir '44, and I was like, "I want to see more of those tanks, but I'll play this train game." And we played it, and instantly I was hooked. It took the idea of rummy, holding these cards in hand, playing sets of cards, and it made it so accessible and so fun and so entertaining. This game just what a wonderful game it is. It's another one that me and my wife like to play back and forth. Fourth, she's a bloodthirsty monster in this game. But uh we it I liked all the different maps.
This one has really stood the test of time. Love Ticket to Ride. Number three is Twilight Imperium third edition, which was eventually re-implemented by Twilight Imperium fourth edition, which frankly, it's weird now to look at this one and say this one's almost 10 years old. Um but Twilight Imperium fourth edition was basically Twilight Imperium third edition like 3.5. You know, they it's the I I I've never played Twilight Imperium the first edition. I have played the second one, and the jump between the second and the third is massive. The number of changes, the idea of taking some ideas from Puerto Rico and bringing them out. It honestly is Christian Peterson's masterpiece. Corey Konieczka being about just an amazing production. This game is not on my list anymore. It was last on my list in 2016, 10 years ago, at 55, and it's fallen off. And I still think very fondly of this game, but I just don't play it today. It's just so long. I love it. I just don't love it 6 hours of loving it. But I still, if I do have a chance play it and get involved, it is fantastic. It is neat. It is amazing. The fourth edition has expansions and all kinds of cool things. There's just so much in this game.
It is something to stand up and applaud, and every game that has come out that is this, you know, massive forces, these monsters and dudes on a map type games, they all stand and look at TI4. Every space game they're like, this is TI4. They try to make TI4 light. And this is like one of those games that people will still be talking about in 30 years. And that was my number three. But number two is still on the list today. And in fact, as of today, it's number one. The most consistent game on my list, and that is Cosmic Encounter. Cosmic Encounter, a game I first played when I was 13, loved it then, and now, 37 years later, I am still enjoying this game that is almost 50 years old at this point in time. This is the newest version, 2008. So this version itself, which I call the new version, is almost 20 years old. And I It was number two before this version even existed. I was talking about the Mayfair edition {slash} Avalon edition before this.
But they did a great job, Fantasy Flight, and they did They They trickle out content for this. Every few years, there might be some more aliens, some more stuff, and I'm okay with that. If they never made another drip of Cosmic, I'm fine, because I'll never play everything that's already out there. This is a game I consistently play. Every year I play it at least two or three times, which is more than almost any other game, and I've played more than that even. It's such a great game, and I love it so much, and yeah, it's it's it will I can't imagine it's ever falling out of my top 100, let alone my top 10. And number one, though, is not on my list anymore. The last time we saw it was in 2012, where it was number nine. I think they made a second edition around then. This is Duel of Ages. I remember when Duel of Ages was announced.
This would have been a Kickstarter, but it wasn't a Kickstarter at the time. But they said, "Duel of Ages comes out, and there's seven expansions." Seven expansions for a game? And they said it's not the number of people on each side. Uh if you look at it, it says two to 16 players. What? It's not measured by how many turns, it's measured by time. You say, "I'm going to play for 2 hours." You have Paco's Bill Bill fighting a robot from the future, fighting this monstrous alien, fighting Beowulf. What? All this stuff really appealed to me. And so when I got this game, I was predestined to like it, and like it I did. Talk about the number of variety in things that can change and differ. With these seven expansions, there was so much of it. I loved it. It was my number one for several years. It was in my top 10 for a while.
They eventually came out with Duel of Ages II, and I was very excited to see how they would change it and how they would streamline it, and they didn't. They made it more complicated. And in fact, the newest version of this, so we see Duel of Ages II, and then the newest edition of this is called World Spanner Factions. And you'll notice my rating here is an 8.25, cuz it's almost great. I love all the aspects of I love the new heroes. There's so many cool things. But it's still just a little too complex for most people to get into. And that keeps me from playing it all the time. It's kind of what knocked off my list. I want a game that I can sit down, teach people, and we're up and running without having to look in the rule book and go back and forth. But still, there's something to be said about Blackbeard shooting at me with a machine gun, and here I am some diplomat from Mars, along with a psychic, and we are trying to fight you back, but we only have a baseball bat. And Joe DiMaggio's with us, and he But he's in the middle of a golf game.
That sounds bonkers, but that's what this game is. And so I will always have a soft spot for this game. It was my number one 21 years ago. Probably not today, but still one that I think highly of. So, there you go. We have made it through the whole list, folks. We made it to the top. Those are my favorite games from 21 years ago. Um so, thank you for joining me for this look back through my original top 100 games of all time. Tell me what you think about these games in the comments. Until the next time, though, I'm Tom Vasel. We'll see y'all.
Hey. Uh thanks for watching another video here on The Dice Tower. Uh we really appreciate you stopping by and checking our things out. Thanks so much for joining us today. And hey, if you really like what we're doing here at The Dice Tower, then there are different ways to support The Dice Tower. One of those ways is through Patreon. We have links in the description to this video. We have links to other That's what other things we do down there. So definitely check it out. But either way, we're glad you watched this. Tell your friends about The Dice Tower. Until the next time, though, I'm Tom Vasel, and I hope you enjoyed this video.