10 games I got rid of in 2018
Transcript
hello and welcome to games that left my collection in 2018 this is a list of 10 games I've gotten rid of over the last year or so not every game needs to stay in your collection especially not if you found a game that does much the same thing only a lot better for you but what I think is interesting is the rationale behind why I got rid of each game why they're no longer taking up shelf space and why I've handed them on to someone else so they can have enjoyment with them so let's get straight into it and the first game I got rid of was CO2 now CO2 is actually a pretty damn good game I actually really enjoyed this the environmental theme and the carbon credit trading was really neat however a second edition's coming out and I'm actually not getting that second edition you see one of the guys I played the game with who's one of my best friends is one of New Zealand's experts on the carbon trading scheme so he goes off to conferences internationally to talk to people about emissions trading and he ordered the second edition and I figured well I'm probably going to be playing the game with him most of the time because he's part of my regular group and as an expert in this field it really feels like he should be the one that owns the game and not me and in some ways this is a pretty important lesson for me I don't have to be the one that owns everything I don't have to be the person in the group that owns every single game other people can own games and I can borrow them off them that's fine that's great especially when the game is of particular interest to that person I suspect some of you watching are that person in your group the one that owns absolutely everything and while that's a cool position to be in because you've got a whole bunch of games sometimes you feel like you're the one accepting all the financial risk and cost of everyone enjoying the hobby so
it's actually quite neat for other people in your group to go actually this is the game I want to own I want to add this to my shelf and for you to go cool you you get that one that's awesome I don't need every single game next up is dead Panic now the same guy who owns CO2 also owns Castle Panic and we played that a couple of times and I thought it was a really neat little game it just had really cool basic mechanics it was a fun Co-op and a great little shared experience and I thought oh well I wouldn't mind getting that for my collection because of course I have to have every single game I play at other people's houses but then I saw they were releasing dead panic and I was like oh I can get a game that's actually slightly different zombie theme oh that might be quite fun turns out it wasn't turns out the Simplicity of Castle Panic is kind of undermined by the extra mechanics added in dead panic and I thought the mix just didn't work where Castle Panic was a nice light game you can pick up and play easily and just have a good laugh about dead Panic just didn't work something about how the characters moved around the board and interacted with the zombies just made the game not feel right what I'd gone and done is thought I'll get Castle Panic Castle Panic was fun oh I'll get dead Panic instead that should be just as fun it turns out they're actually quite different it's a classic case where I probably should have just gone actually I enjoy the original game let's just play my friends copy let's not bother reaching for something else so yeah no regrets getting rid of dead Panic next up is a game from my list of game games I played entirely too much and that's Elder Sign the problem I had
with Elder Sign is I actually don't mind the game at all but I play the app like 100 200 God knows how many times on the way to work it was a perfect length for a game for my bus ride into work each day and for a while there I was playing it quite a bit the problem with that is I'd go to set up the board game and be like why am I doing this this just takes forever the app absolutely killed my interest in playing this as a solo on the tabletop or as a multiplayer game me out sign not a bad game at all it's just probably a better phone app than a board game I really wanted to like the scent second edition I really enjoyed the scent and when second edition came out I was really amped up about it and I picked up the core box and a friend of mine picked up the core and a few other bits and pieces as well and we played a full campaign the one in the initial box and it was okay but it wasn't particularly good and I had some real problems with some parts of the game in particular how wounded characters are treated you get knocked down you get to stand back up with Stuffle hit points and you get knocked back down again so it encourages behavior from the overlord player where they just focus fire on one character and just keep wounding them over and over and over again and that makes it really unfun for one person who's getting picked on so that wasn't me and the campaign game I was playing a rogue character but i' had minmax so they could move about 20 spaces in a turn so even if the overlord did want to hit me I was already at the objective at the other end of the map I also own Imperial assault which I think does this a lot better you the overlord character in that has to split their fire and try to wound all four characters which just
makes for a more interesting experience for everyone because one person's not being picked on and while there's only so many Dungeon Crawlers you can play and I've got Imperial assault descent first edition and Gloom Haven and that's enough to keep you occupied for a pretty bloody long time next up real controversial opinion Aldrich horror is garbage okay it's not garbage but I really like second edition of Arkham Horror most of the praise I heard for eldrich horror was that it was faster it was streamlined it was just a better Arkham Horror and as someone who's played like 200 plus games of Arkham Horror I was so excited to get aldrid horror and then it hit the table and all I could think was this is an improved version of Arkham Horror wow I must be totally out of line with what everyone else is thinking because I'm not enjoying this at all and the reasons I didn't enjoy it were as follows and Arkham Horror Clues were quite plentiful so you had this push your luck ass where you might have banked six or seven Clues and you just spend one at a time to roll additional dice this created a bit of tension within the game as you're like I'm burning my resources is this actually worth all the stuff I'm burning to do this and that created quite an interesting bit of tension because you might burn two Panic about the third one and then get lucky on it or then you might fail it and go ah I've just completely wasted most of my resources and now I can't do the thing I want to do alrich hor reduced the dice PS of characters quite a bit and also reduced the ability you had to re roll dice so frequently your turns were turn over a card check what skill I've got oh I'm
rolling two dice do I get a five no rerolls no ability to modify that just two or three dice to roll if I get a five I succeed if I don't I fail and Arkham hor could adjust the sliders on your character to prepare for situations if you knew what was coming if you needed to close a gate you could boost your fight or your will and make sure that that roll was easier there's none of that in alrich horror now I've heard that in the expansions they add Focus tokens and a few things that help you reroll stuff but that's fixing the game after i' played it enough to want to get rid of it the other thing is we played Arkham Horror so much that we know the game inside out so it takes 2 hours for a four-player game this isn't the 6 Seven 8 Hour game that people talk about for us so Aldrich Hara wasn't any shorter but it just felt shallower now there is some stuff I did like about Aldrich horror which I would have loved to have seen in Arkham Horror specifically about the great old ones they made them more characterful and the Mysteries that you had to solve were were more interesting and varied but the core gameplay boiled down to turnover card do I roll two to four dice if I get a five I succeed and it just felt really really flat oh and playing Charlie Kane might be the most boring experience in board game history you sit in the location you buy stuff you give it to other people it really bugs me when the optimal way to play someone is so utterly boring anyway got rid of Aldrich horror zero regrets still play Arkham Horror still haven't played Arkham Horror Third Edition though I guess guess we'll get to that at some point and speaking of disappointing
games from Fantasy Flight games here's Fallout now I am a huge Fallout fan I've played fallout Fallout 2 Fallout tactics Fallout 3 Fallout New Vegas and Fallout 4 haven't played Fallout 76 or the ones that were on Console big fan of the franchise and Fallout was one game I was really looking forward to I mean I was super excited about this an adventure game by fantasy games who were known for doing games of big bling and lots of parts and stuff and I was kind of hoping for an Arkham Horror type game sit in the Fallout universe and what we got was this competitive game with a weird Victory point system and huge gaps in its narrative one thing that drove me up the wall was when a character would be at one location discover a clue but then anyone could act on it so if you were on the opposite side of the map you could go and complete that assignment and it just didn't make any sense to me and the Victory point system was just bizarre it just wasn't the game I wanted from Fallout and I really gave us a goal I played it like half a dozen times and each time I was like this just feels incomplete it feels undercooked it feels like a starter box for something that's going to have a hell of a lot more content that's going to validate it later on and I'm kind of over that business model of buying a core box that's incomplete and pretty broken and then having it patched by expansions kind of the same deal with Aldrich horror I figured the game was going to get fixed eventually but did I want to buy the six expansions that would do that for me now if a game's core box
doesn't deliver a solid content and solid play experience I'm not going to buy all the expansions and fix it later on sorry Fantasy Flight foreclosed is next wow this is just a terrible game but in my defense I didn't actually purchase this I bought a game from overseas via the BGG market and when I opened the game forclosed was inside and I messaged a guy and was like hey um cheers for the game The Game's all good but why is there a copy of foreclosed in there and they were like oh oops that's where that is um yeah just keep it and after looking through the game and having to go with it I was like wow I know why they didn't want this back it's garbage like I try not to be negative about too many games unless they're absolute Abominations but for clothes is just rubbish so in the interest of paying it forward to people I added it to a game I traded away uh without telling the person so they got to open the box up and go oh wow there's a bonus game in here and I'm like oh that's where that is so if you ever do end up with a terrible game and you're going to trade of some description just Chuck it in the box and hand it off to someone else so they can have fun with it you never know it might end up with someone who actually likes the game but in forclosed case I'd be really really really surprised next Up's a very popular and iconic game Fury of Dracula now Fury of Dracula is not a bad game and I'm not going to rip on it but I have some issues with it the biggest is that it's just a pain to teach people if you are
teaching people you have to play Dracula as a new player picking up Dracula is going to really struggle and have to ask questions about what the different cards do and an experienced Dracula against a group of people who don't know what they're doing is going to run rings around them and that's not necessarily A positive play experience you either have to play down so people can learn the game or you play your ability and people just get stomped I also think this just a bit too much happening in the game it's one of those 19980s games that had a lot of moving parts and a lot of extra rules that might not necessarily add that much to the experience but the death Alpa Fury of Dracula was last Friday uh which is a simpler more streamlined hidden movement game with a Friday 30 theme which I really like and that's also one that's a lot easier to teach and because of the way the rounds reset having a strong first act as the killer doesn't really determine the outcome of the game this is just a case of having a game I wasn't going to play particular often and having a game on the Shelf which I thought did much the same thing only in a bit more streamlined way with a theme I preferred so yeah last Friday gets the nod Fury of Dracula gets sent on to someone who'll appreciate it and on that note Shadows over Camelot is another one I got rid of Shadows is a pretty damn good game um it was the first hidden Trader game I played and I played this a bunch in the 2000s but ever since Battle Star Galactica came out this one's been sitting on the shelf Gathering dust I don't know if I'd played it in like 6 years when I finally decided to get rid of it and that's not because it's a bad game at all it's just
because the groups I play with if they want that hidden Trader experience they're going to play Battle Star Galactica and shadows of Camelot just occupied much of the same space and I know there's people that prefer shadows and that's fine that's all good it's actually a pretty damn good game but for my particular audience my particular groups Battle Star wins every single time when we said which one of these do you want to play I've also got dead of winter which would sometimes get into the play schedule ahead of Battle Star but with both those games on my shelf Shadows of a camela had no chance and finally the number three ranked game on Board Game Geek Through the Ages a new story of civilization I say this a lot but no game is for everyone and Through the Ages is not for me it's also not for the groups I played it with who thought the game was absolutely awful now I appreciate Through the Ages for its design and I've actually ended up playing it a a bit on the app because that does all the bookkeeping for you but it's just such a time consumer there's so much fiddling around with cubes and the game just has a heck of a lot of downtime when it's someone else's turn there are a few other points I particularly didn't like about the game as well the first of which is if you're in last place militarily you are everyone's Target and you just get absolutely stomped by everyone and the game also has way more player in first place gets heaps of cool stuff the player in last place gets stuffed cards in any other game of ever played so a lot of games have catchup mechanics but Through the Ages is just full of beat down mechanics which was not particularly fun for the person in our group who was in last place and just
kept getting screwed over and over and over during the game there's also the Thematic disconnects that I don't particularly like having an army of cannons and failers fighting against jet fighters the ages fly past so fast whilst also taking forever it's a strange combination of a game being simultaneously to deep and busy while being thematically really light and that combination just didn't work for me but as I've said I've played it on the app and I appreciate it as an app game because I can play a game of that in about 20 to 30 minutes instead of 4 hours my only real regret with this one is that I got rid of it just before I started the channel because despite my reservations with the game I think it's one that would do quite well as a 3-minute recap because I suspect there's a lot of people out there who have found the game intimidating and complex but would like to see a simple summary of it so at some point I'm probably going to have to borrow someone's copy and do a video of it but anyway those are the games I got rid of in 2018 if you enjoyed this video like it subscribe to the channel and check out our patreon