The Founders Behind Cascadia, Calico and Point Salad | bgss ep_037
Transcript
Like Molly was saying, there's like a 2-hour debate about whether we should put this bag in that game.
And that was a 50 three versus three thing. And he just sort of did a like, hm, thanks. And walked away, which is fine cuz like
Well, I mean, I remember feeling really gutted cuz we were like, "Oh, the AEG folks are here." And like, "Let's show them the game." You know, usually every time I put an ad up, one there'll be one comment on Meta where someone's like, I don't want like some you're a big established publisher and you shouldn't be on Kickstarter anymore. And I think like do you hilarious?
He said, "Whatever you do, just like don't make another nature themed rolling, right? We're only going to put three games out next year and one of them is a nature themed rolling." Right. So
sometimes the joke with us is like we designed Point Salad and then we started with Calico and Cascadia as our like
it's just like like we peaked very early.
Today in the board game secret show I'm talking to Molly and Sean from Flatout Games. You might know them from little games like Calico or Cascadia or many many others. They've been making games together for almost 10 years. We get into what it was like pitching Point Salad to an AEG executive. Why they still run Kickstarters even though they're this behemoth of a board game publisher and what a store owner told them to not do next and they completely ignored. And without further ado, please welcome Molly and Shawn of Flatout Games to the Board Game Secret Show.
Cool down here. Okay.
Yeah, it's uh starting to cool off just a little bit here in the Pacific Northwest.
Yeah.
Are you excited about that or sad about that?
Uh Sean's probably sad. I am indifferent. I like all the seasons.
Yeah, I like them all until about January and then we have another what, six months. Are you both born and raised here in the Pacific Northwest?
No.
Yeah.
No, we are uh born and raised in Canada in this part of the world really.
So, this is like, you know, the winters here are absolutely nothing then.
Um well, they're they're a lot more gray. We got a lot of sun in the winter uh on the prairies and so
Yeah.
Yeah. Well, I'm I'm from San Diego and uh this is I I like to complain about it in every um I was in fact I was just having a we had a game night with some people from uh from the channel and uh and I was just saying they was like, "Oh yeah, I heard you talk about the weather a couple times." Like, "Yeah, any chance I get, I'll I'll complain about the weather up here."
Where are you from originally?
San Diego.
Oh, sorry. I missed that.
No, no worries. Yeah, it's San Diego where it's perpetually, you know, well, the summer gets gets pretty pretty hot, but yeah, for the most part it's perpetually beautiful. And I never appreciated it until I moved up here. But uh And so you all uh survive Gen Con.
Yeah.
Yep.
Uh yeah, we go for like almost 10 days. Uh, and the show the like exhaul hours are like it's just like this feels like a tiny part of the
week. So, what are you doing there for so many days? Meetings with designers and getting pitches on games and stuff like that.
Uh, we don't really take pitches. Okay.
We don't take pitches. Uh, but we usually meet with most of our partners, our fulfillment partners. Uh we have a big partnership with AEG and so you know they're there a few days early too. So we usually use that time to have in-person meetings and go through the games that are coming and just you know meet with any new team members they've got um and just spend time all in the same place you know going out for dinner playing games.
So did you get many games actually played at Gen Con? If I can play If I play one published game every Gen Con, it's a total win. Not one of our games.
We played We played a few actually. We got They were mostly party games, I would say.
We played Jibberjabble, which was
I wanted to play Jibberjabble. Is it Is it good? You liked it? Really?
So good. I would play it. I would play it anytime. Yeah. Are you party game folks? Like in general? I know you're You know, you don't I don't think you do. Have you done a party an actual party game?
No, but
I don't see one. No, but
No, but they're coming.
Okay. All right.
Oh, this is this might be a scoop. I don't know.
Yeah. Like, well, we're going to get we're also going to get into another genre later on in the interview uh that you all are jumping into as well. So, it sounds like this is this is kind of like a moment of expansion for Flatout.
Yeah, it feels like we're taking on a bunch of different new things for the next like three years.
Well, we we're going to talk about that, but let's actually start all the way at the beginning. Actually, probably starting at a Gen Con essentially in 2017 if my research was correct or at least a little bit before that.
Yeah,
tell me about that. So, I I think I actually have a quote from you, Sean, that you said there was a moment where you felt like you weren't pouring um enough. You were you were pouring plenty of time into the hobby, but you weren't contributing anything. What did that lead to?
Did you say that?
I guess I said that.
Yeah, you you said it on some podcast.
Ah,
whoa. Um, this is such a great question. Um, wow. I think it's so it's so long ago. Um, so we started designing games uh in 2016 and
I man I got bit I got bit probably the hardest of like Molly Rob and I like and I really got obsessed with the sort of like community around game design. And so I was like this is cool. I'm going to use all my PTO just flying around the country going to board game conventions. And I was like, you know, just such a wanted to be a sponge in terms of like just learning about game design, getting into play tests and designing all the time. And at that time, I think it was one of those things where um got lucky enough in Seattle to meet a bunch of people who were also kind of at that stage in their journey and just like working on game design work. And there were quite a few of us at the time that I think um started to have things happen in the board game industry like around the same time, right? So there was um you know we started play testing at uh so Emma Lurkins lived in an apartment building in Seattle and it had this great like public space on the
mezzanine
mezzanine floor and so every Wednesday night we would get together. Um there was uh myself uh folks like Randy Flynn who designed Cascadia, Joseph Chen who did Fantastic Factories and who's worked on a bunch of
This was 2016. You're around all of these people that now you're working with.
Yeah.
Oh wow. Okay, cool.
That was 2016 2017.
That was 2018.
2018. Yeah.
By the time that got rolling because I wasn't here then.
Yeah. Um, I just remember one of the big things that was really interesting was we went to um a local convention called ETX and we and they have this Lucy Award. It's a game design award and Joseph and Justin had done Fantastic Factories and they won the Lucy Award that year. Um, and I was just like a big fan. I was like, "Oh, they're the guys that made the like Lucy award-winning game Fantastic Factories. It looks so cool. They seem so cool. And I remember there was a Play Test Northwest, which is an amazing play testing organization here in Seattle um and and the surrounding area, um just organized like play test events at local board game shops and at local conventions. And so I had kind of gotten gotten involved and we had our first design, Dollars to Donuts. And I had it at that event and I was just play testing it. Um, and Joseph came and sat down and he play tested and I was like, "Oh my god." I was like starruck, right? Because I was like, "Oh, here's this local designer." And he like won the award this year.
And you knew who he was right then.
Yeah. I I feel like Well, it was probably like a name tag thing because of the convention. I was like, "Oh, that's I put two and two together." Because through Play Test Northwest, we had kind of seen probably seen each other around at different events and things, but I had never met Joseph. and he sat down and he played Dollarship Donuts and he was like he was like, "Oh, this is really fun. Like, this is a cool game." Like, you know, he gave feedback and things like that. And I just remember feeling like, "Oh my gosh, this is so cool. This designer who's designed this award-winning game now is like giving me like positive feedback on the design." So, I was really excited to come back and tell Molly and Rob about it. And um and that was I think right
2017 probably
2017. And then we started, you know, going to more conventions and pitching our games and that sort of thing. And so, um, I think one of the things that was exciting for us, our like big break was definitely like the Cardboard Edison award. So, we decided to submit dollars to donuts for the Cardboard Edison award, which is this, I guess, mostly like an online game design award. This was shortly after that, like in 2018, 2018. January, February 2018.
Yeah. And we were like, "Okay, Dollars to Donuts is like feeling in pretty good shape. We're going to pitch it at conventions this year to publishers. We're going to hope to get it signed." And we had just that um that over the holidays at the end of 2017, I had been messing around with a concept that was basically the design for Point Salad, right? Molly and I had play tested a bunch of times. I had actually met up with Joseph uh at one of the play testing events that holiday and he played Point Salad and he was like, "Oh, this is really good." He's like, "This is really, really good. You should keep keep going."
When we took it to Orcaon, which is another local convention, the Seattle area, and we took it to Orcaon and played it with a few people and uh yeah, I got a sense that like, oh yeah, this is working. People were just like, oh yeah. Mhm. It's a game and they didn't really have any feedback and I was like, "Oh, it's because this works now." Like, we've There were a whole bunch of things that were in the game that Sean was like, "Actually, let's try it without this mechanic or let's try it without these cards." So, we got it really streamlined basically to the place that it is
Point Salad when you knew you could design board games, not Dollars for Donuts because that was the first one, right? But it didn't get uh signed.
Correct. It got signed I think shortly after that. So, Dollars of Dones did get signed first by Crafty and then it was at the next ETX, so the ETX 2018 that we submitted it for the Luc we submitted Point Salad for the Lucy Award and it came second. Uh, and that is where one of the former AEG leadership was is local to the area and came to ETX and I pitched it to him. He walked up to the table where we had the game and he was like, "What's this?" And I said, "Well, you know, the quick pitch on Point Salad, which we've gotten pretty good at at that point."
You tend to get good at that, right? Because you have to It has to happen so many times.
Yeah. And it's a pretty straightforward game, right? Like there's double-sided cards and you're doing this on your turn. you're either taking this or this and this is what you're building. Um, and he just sort of did a like, hm, thanks. And walked away, which is fine cuz like
Well, I mean, I remember feeling really gutted because we were like, oh, the AEG folks are here and like, let's show them the game. And he was just like, uh-huh.
So, they were wearing like AEG garb. Like, you knew that the pitch was
relatively, you knew who he was,
you knew it was important, and then it was just like, okay.
Yeah. Yeah, I was just like, "Thanks." You know,
so we were debriefing with Rob because Rob's Rob's in Manitoba still. Um where we all kind of started playing games and and stuff together. So that's how our connection to Rob is a good friend from years ago. And we were debriefing with him and I was like, "Yeah." We were just like, "Oh, the AG folks like looked at it, but they didn't really seem interested, so like I don't think anything's going to come of that." And literally as we were having this conversation, I get this like email. We get the email
it was a Facebook message to our
little Flatout Games Facebook page, which Yeah.
Wow.
It was like, "Hey, I I uh really liked that point salad game you had. Um, are you going to be at Origins by any chance? Our CEO will be there and I'd really like for him to play this game. We might have a slot like for next year or
I don't think it said that much.
I don't He might not have said that much. basically just said, "Are you going to Origins?" Cuz John's answer will be, you know, at Origins and would like to play.
Sometimes when you're excited, you read more into stuff, you know, then you go back later like, "Oh, maybe it wasn't that great."
Yeah, maybe it wasn't that bored. Yes.
Which was amazing because then you and Rob went like Sean and Rob went to Origin like a that was like a month later, like three weeks later even or two weeks later. Really?
Is this 2017 or 18?
2018.
2018. Okay. And at the time, the other part of the story that's like concurrent to this is that we were going to submit dollars to donuts to the cardboard Edison award like I was mentioning and we decided at the last second. I was like, "Guys, I know we put all this time into making this dollars to donuts video, right? But I'm like, I really think we should submit point salad, too." And then and Molly and Rob were like, "God, this like we had to make these videos and stuff." And they're just like, "Really? Like we this has already been so much work. Like, should we?" And I was like, "No, guys, we should really I feel good about this." part about this like I had just moved from Seattle to Victoria to take a job and I was staying at an Airbnb and I had to Sean had written the script for all of us or we'd all written our own little parts of script and the only way for me to record my piece in that Airbnb was to prop my phone up on some like throw pillow on the bed in the bedroom and like sit against the wall on the floor and I was like this is the crazy stuff you do just because you're
That's how you make it in board games.
Oh my god. I know. It was like uh press it press record, not knock the phone off where it was precariously placed against the pillow, read my like memorize the thing I had to say, say the thing and then like awkwardly and then just send the file to Sean and be like, "You have to edit this." Like
it was um it was pretty cringe video. We still I think have it posted. We'll send you a link for anyone who's listening.
Okay. Yeah, that's great.
Be fun to look at it. It's pretty hilarious, but
we'll probably just put it in right here.
Yeah. Oh god.
It's our original cardboard Edison submission and it was um
it was like one of those like things where like we we thought the game was cool but you know we had put all the stock into Dollar Donuts. It was a game we had been working on.
Yeah. But anyway, so then all this stuff had happened like Molly was saying with the stuff and we're getting ready for Origins and that was around the time that like yeah we they announced the the moment that felt like I always remember this moment because like it feels like we like made it as board game designers was getting the email. It was like early in the morning. I remember waking up seeing this email in the inbox and was like cardboard Edison being like you made the finals of Cardboard Edison four point salad. I was like oh my god. I mean I just remember like how much elation right after like years of like going to convention
two two years
okay a couple of years of like you know like just learning about game design thinking about game design like going through a bunch of games that didn't even like before points out there or before dollars to donuts there
covered full concepts
prototypes of how many games did it take to actually get to an uh this award moment Okay.
So, there were
a dozen probably.
There were a lot of games that were like a deck of playing cards and like a bunch of black and white dice that I had
and we were like trying to make just simple things. And then there was at the time there was a big craze for like 18 card card games because buttonshy was sort of really really popular at that time and it was like oh you could if you do an 18 card card game it's a great design challenge for yourself and like you could pitch it to buttonshy and it could get published and so
lots of like little micro game designs and things like that. But yeah, it Dollars to Donuts was one of the first like spatial tile things we ever like put together and it, you know, it it worked enough that it got signed and published, you know, like it ended up there was a lot of refinement that happened to it through the years, but it was
So the year though that I have for Crafty is 2021. Is that just how long it eventually took to come out?
Yeah.
When was it signed? Was it signed relative early or did you take a lot of rejection before you got to that point?
It was signed I think even before point. It must have been sometime in the spring 2018.
Yeah.
Was before you went to Origins, I
think. So, yeah.
Yeah.
Wow. So, you had did any of the older designs ever get resurrected and turn into any games we know now?
Good question.
No. Um, one thing that's interesting is that like propolis is a design that's really old. Um, oh, really? And at one point, AG, like kind of we were already kind of co-publishing with them, but we were still designing things. So, we had done Point Salad, Truffle Shuffle, and 10, which are our designs that AEG published. Um, and then the next one in that kind of like line was was going to be like a game was called like Realms. It was like originally the original
it's like a medieval town classic old school theme
and and they signed it and their dev team kind of worked on it for a while but wasn't they weren't really getting it to a spot where like they felt good enough to publish it and so that was one that like we kind of got back from them. and they were like, "Look, we, you know, we're doing all this stuff with you all with all of your co-published games." And so like there was a little bit less like um pressure to like keep publishing our designs. And so, um, that was one of the ones where, you know, propos came out last year, like it we kind of
sat there, it sat on the shelf for a while and then you got a real bee in your bonnet about wanting to make it
and then like we we changed a lot of that game and then you put a like one of our dev teams together for it. So, Joseph and David, who we'd worked with already on a few things, and um and then Emily Vincent played it and was like, "Yeah, sure, but this theme is dry." She maybe was nicer than that about it, but
um and so we spent an afternoon at the kitchen table thinking about other things that it could be. And when we landed on bees, it like in my mind was like, "Yep, that's it. We figured it out." And it was so easy after that to then have a few pieces of the mechanics and the theme really work together, really sing.
Um,
yeah. And then we're like, "Okay, this is great." And then Dylan Vanini's illustrations, like I think they're it's my favorite game. like
Yeah, he does such a great job.
It's It's your favorite illustrated game or your favorite game that you've published?
Oh, favorite illustrated game.
Okay. Illustrated game.
I mean, I Yeah,
you've worked with some heavy hititterter artists. I was I have that in the notes uh later on a little bit, but that's uh it is a really cool looking cover. I haven't played it yet, but that it's such a unique art. You don't you it's weird like all of the art you have is you know you you obviously have like Bethyl and it's a very distinct but they're all feel different but the same at the same time. I don't know what it is. It's like this cozy cute feel. Is that like on purpose?
Yep. Uh yes. And also there a few things that we I mean Sean and I spend a lot of time uh picking colors for the games. Like we spend a lot of time talking about what the palette is going to be particularly for all the components
and then really doing a lot of art direction
to get the look and feel of the game just from a color perspective. Um, there is no 100% black in anything.
Okay.
Do you have an artist already signed when you're doing that step?
Uh, yep. Usually,
generally, yeah, generally,
but like that's the combination, right, where we're going to have to make decisions on like what color are the meeples or the beeples or what color like it's not just what the art is going to look like. That's sort of a separate thing, but like what are the colors of everything else in that product?
Yeah, that's very interesting. So, I just interviewed the Kinson keys guys and they were talking about working with ENO tool and how incredibly which I believe you have an ENO tool art, right? Was it fit to print?
Yeah.
Um,
how incredibly involved he is, not only in the art, but the actual production of the game. It it partially might be because they were new publishers and you know I think they would probably say the same thing. They didn't know what they were doing. But how often is the artist involved in the actual production or even parts of the game design versus I'm just fulfilling a contract and and producing our components for you.
The thing that's so great about Ian is that he has graphic design
skills background and and an interest in doing that work. And so it's like the most seamless visual process for both the illustration, the art, and the graphic design. So, and that game really needed it like
Fit to Print because it's like the whole look of the newspaper and all the pieces. It was so great that he wanted to take that on and then
do more of the graphic. I mean, it's such a graphic game and do more of the graphics.
Yeah. Yeah, I think one of the things so we're I would say we're pretty heavy-handed um art directors at Flatout Games and that's why there's like a relative consistency to the stuff but also we've worked with Dylan Manini as our graphic designer you know he's been part of our collab and part of our team for you know since
from the beginning
from the beginning with Calico and he did the illustration for point salad we kind of you know the
strong armed agree there is we got we were there was some initial sketches for Points that we didn't love and we asked AG like, "Hey, can our friend Dylan do the illustrations for it?" Like we really like his style and um so like we've been working with him forever and he's such a talented graphic designer and like you know we work really well together so we can really put a product together and it it's a really streamlined process. So like when we work with artists um we usually come to the table with like some ideas but also we want the art the artist to be able to have creative license and want to be able to think about like how does this visually look and so there's a lot of things that like we have a vision for and then we want to try and like sync up with the artist and be like okay what like
yes and no like sent some stuff back where I was like there are too many like just once something's out on the table and you think well like from a user interface user experience perspective like we need to reduce the number of colors. Um and so there were some illustrations on the game that's coming perennial where the cards the illustrations on the cards I just felt like had too much and it was pulling away from being able to look at the thing you really needed which was the polyomino shape and then which of the things you were going to draft from the central drafting board. And so we just asked to have a few colors changed to minimize the number the kind of the visual uh
whatever the
which is it's a tricky thing, right? Because sometimes um you have to balance like being able to like like allow an artist to really like feel like their art is like they're really flourishing in the art in the game, right? they're not just like a, you know, illustrator for hire that they're like invested in like the overall like look and feel. And the the balance of that is like we've actually had the opportunity to work a lot with Beth and like she's a gamer. She loves playing board games and that like same thing with like Dylan as a graphic designer or Beth or Ian like they love playing board games and so like understanding user interface and like how things look on the table and all those sorts of things like it's really really important. Um, I know there's a lot of folks that like work with illustrators or graphic designers that aren't as into board games and that there's I'm sure that can work too, but it's such I think it's such an asset have someone who like kind of understands this product type like with you know graphic design for graphic design and art for board games is
is tricky because some sometimes the best illustration isn't the best illustration for the component that it's there because of uh the context. text or how is it going to be laid out on the table next to something else, right? You like have to understand kind of the 10,000 foot view. And that's why when I say like we're heavy-handed like art directors, I think we take a lot of pride in like the product development of FlatOut Games. And I think like we, you know, there's a decent amount of consistency there in terms of like how we've developed the products and so um yeah, it takes time um and energy, but I think
and arguments Lots of fighting.
Okay, good. Let's get into that. This is what we wanted here. We can clip this for uh shorts.
So, art now are are we um are are we bumping heads together here or versus the artist?
Yeah.
Both. No, mostly internally, I think.
Okay.
Yeah. So part of the way that we publish games is through our collab which is involves generally we usually with the designer of a game that we sign and then with Dylan the graphic designer and anyone else like who's might be part of the development team to work on developing the game design further. Um that becomes our like collab and that's a project by project group of people who are working on the project together. Everybody has equity in it. So we take the Kickstarter profits and split them based on how many hours we all put into it and that sort of thing. Um and so within that we try to be basically like a consensus building [snorts] team where we all talk about what's best for the game and like how what direction to take it. Who is the audience? Like there's a lot of decisions about the development and the rules for the game and like what you know how heavy or how light are we trying to make it and um and then in on top of that
the product itself right like the the componentry or the visuals all those sorts of things
trade-off on cost production cost and which components are worth you know a few more cents and which things can we bling out or not bling out. Um,
I mean a recent a good recent example is Honeypot has these cool little folders that in the game and I think they they feel really like unique and different. Um, but it's a component that like Okay, so this was like late in development. we're like working on the game and like getting all the the rules sol solidified and we're working with uh Randy and Ashwin and Joseph um on this and we like somehow the concept of the like folders came up and of course I'm like the production person and I'm just like okay that's cool but like is it necessary and like we got to figure out how to like make them so they aren't like they don't get ripped or like is the how does the fold work and so we had to go to the factory and like get a bunch of different prototypes down and things like that. And that was one of those things where I'm so glad that we like took the ef like the team was like we should really fight for this thing because it's like a it's a component that makes that game feel really different and unique to other card games. Um but again it's like one of those um challenges within the team to just be like should we do this thing?
Should we not? Oh, it's going to cost this many more extra cents in the game. And like, you know, there's just a lot of like like publisher level decisions that we do as a broader group and try to like build consensus. And I think it's cool because we worked with a lot of folks like Randy and Ashwin and Joseph and everybody's got uh you know Emily like a lot of the people we work with as designers also have like ties to different like publishing, right? Joseph's published a game, Emily's published games, Ashton's published a game. So, um, we are lucky to have people we collaborate with that have like an understanding of like an overall product, not just a not just a design because a game is like,
you know, game design is very important. It sort of builds the foundation of something, but what makes a truly great board game on a shelf really is the whole product, right? Is it like the right price? Is it the right are the rules written correctly? Is it like what are the all the contributing factors to making like a hit board game? There's a lot there. Um and so yeah, we try to do a lot of consensus building within our team, but that just takes more time and sometimes headbutting when you know you've got a group of six people and it's like three versus three and we all feel really strongly about our position and then it's like you have to figure out a way somehow to to go back to who's the audience. And that's sometimes where Rob, Molly, and I have to just make a final call to just be like, well, this game is this is what we're trying this is the goal of this game and this is what we really believe it is as its identity and so we should probably make this choice based on X.
Yeah.
Yeah. How important is it setting kind of the vision for the product slashgame slashdesign in the beginning so everyone's working off of the same exact foundational understanding. And does that get done often? It typically gets done before we even give the designer an offer on the game. So, if we can't imagine the product and roughly cost it out and understand like box size, components, uh timeline, when the game's going to come out, do we have a slot for it? What's the vision for the game? If we can't if we don't have a tangible thing, I don't think we would even sign it. like it has to be like as if it's already a thing.
How often does that change substantially from what you originally assumed and does that create in the collab model difficulties that wouldn't necessarily be there in the typical designer artist publisher relationship?
Such a good question. Um I'm trying to think about stuff that changed.
I know our shelf of games is over here. just like look at things. Um, Pelico isn't really the fair example because it was the first one and I have memories of like a hourlong conversation about bag or the token, but uh
we didn't have a to there was no tile bag in Calico. So originally you just would like stack the tiles like you do in Cascadia, but the tiles are quite small and so it's kind of fiddly, right? But we we you know in those days we had like we put on Kickstarter and we had a bunch of stretch goals and the Kickstarter did really well, like surprisingly well and we were at a point where we're like well it would be cool to have like a canvas tile bag like we should should that be a stretch goal? And then that was one of those things where I was like, "Guys, that's like a 50 to 60 cent item. Like that adds like5 to$6 dollars to MSRP. Like is it going to be harder to license?" Like there's a lot of like publisher level questions you ask yourself. You're like, "Oh, that's but like does it add value, right? Like is this game going to And we kind of all were like, you know, there's just something. It's like a game about quilting, having something fabric in there like and it just it'll make the game experience better." And like we I just yeah like Molly was saying there's like a two-hour debate about whether we should put this bag in that game.
And that was a 50 three versus three thing I think. I mean the funniest thing about that is like that bag is like compared to the weight of the game and the double layer like player boards is like so insignificant
yet it took up such a well it's those little details like you know there's um you know sometimes I was talking to Peter C. Hayward and he talked a lot about uh component hooks and maybe they're not nec where where the it's important because it's like the one little thing that really gets people into it. I think about a party game that I just got from um game head size-wise and you have the the the string or the string with the uh with the little um pellet or whatever. I'm sure there was a cheaper way that they could have done size-wise, but it's a cool component hook and I'm sure it sells games. So, that's probably part of the discussion, right? Is is this going to be an eyecatcher or something that's a that's going to pop out on a show floor and get attention, whatever it is.
Yeah. Table presence is something we think about a lot. Like if someone walked by a table of people playing this,
would someone go, "Oh, that looks really neat. What's that?" And you know, in large part, we're relying on the art for that.
Yeah. But
that's a like with our games a lot of the the decision m like one of our sort of core tenants is like we want to make really accessible games in the sense that try to make well like attainable in the sense that like we don't want to price anyone out of like enjoying our games like um we want to make the game as inexpensive as is possible to like deliver the experience that we think it deserves. But we, if you look at our whole catalog, like we don't really have examples of like blinged out games, right? Like we don't really do like fancy deluxified versions of things. Like we really want to make the game like Cascadia is probably a good example, right? Like it has the wooden tokens, which is really nice and those feel like nice and premium and deluxe, but like it's like it was also really important that like Cascadia was like a $40 game. It could have been a $60 game with like some different components and things like that, but like it was really like about for us like artwork goes a long way, right? Like beautiful artwork like that's a cost that you spend once no matter what how many times you print it, right? And it's like
that's the kind of thing where it's like it doesn't make sense to not have incredible artwork and graphics and like make your product the best you can be. Cards and cardboard are relatively inexpensive. And if you look across our games, there's a lot of cards in cardboard and we've like
we don't love working in plastics when we can avoid it.
We haven't done anything in plastic.
Not so far. Yeah. So,
yeah,
it's like it's just one of those things that we've done as an approach. And um yeah, I mean that's not for everyone. Like I think we probably could sell deluxified versions of our games to people and make three times as much on Kickstarter or whatever, but um it's just been we've been fortunate enough to like I think people it resonates with people that like are you know our smallbox games are $25 and they pack a lot of game in there. So we're we're proud of of that. I think
well I think you're on the right side of I don't want to call it history but when you walk around Gen Con or Origins this year I saw tons of small and medium box games relatively few big box giant deluxified experiences and I think that's you know it's tariffs and inflation and all of that stuff. I wonder if we ever go back there or is there's just this this newfound um I don't know the price sensitivity is going to stick around forever. Where do you all see that going in this industry? And do you see the same thing that I saw which is people are going more towards your style as opposed to the other direction that 2021 and two really brought us? Yeah, we actually have we this is also not announced but we are going to go with an even smaller box size uh in 2027.
So there'll be two games that will kickstart that'll So the biggest thing in that Kickstarter will be three [snorts] games and the biggest one will be in the current small box size and then two other games very different from each other. Uh both in a sort of half half size of that box. Um, sometimes it's just a design challenge like the things that PE people around us are working on like
we want to design those games and then another project uh that we we it's our design that just seemed to be the right fit for that oxiz. But we had really noticed that shift already. And so it seemed like well this is what we're doing in the design space and the games we're signing plus um it feels like the industry is moving in that direction at least right now.
Yeah, I I would say that Kickstarter is an a really interesting landscape right now. Um we're sort of we might like we're like a a dying breed in the sense that we make like simple family weight board games and and put them on Kickstarter. And I think it's getting it's like harder and harder like if you aren't offering like a $300 pledge level like how do you make like shipping pencil out like that's really really difficult. Um if you're like average amount per backer is like $19 like it's really challenging to like get the critical mass and we're starting to see like across even our own campaigns and peer peer companies and stuff like the numbers of backers on Kickstarter seems to be in decline. Um, but there's still these there's still those mega projects, right? There's still, you know, um, a good example is, um, Cardboard Alchemy has Whisperwood right now on and that's a that's a big, you know, $259, it used to be $300, now $259 like top pledge, right? So,
did they lower that?
They lowered it, right? And then they were like, okay, like they were responding, I think, to the fact that some folks want like felt like they wanted a lower price point. And so like that was like so you could see that in real time, but there are still those big projects that um it still makes a lot of sense to crowdfund. And if you can get be getting an average backer pledge of $100 plus dollars or whatever, then it makes some sense.
Then you're 15 to $20 of shipping,
yeah,
is a smaller percentage of the whole thing. We've Yeah, we've managed to do this thing where we have like a fall Kickstarter generally and then like a winter Kickstarter and we deliver them all on the same like fulfillment
spring summer.
So that means that our backers that like back both campaigns, they get their stuff like
together,
manufactured and shipped together, which helps a lot and they pay less for shipping. for us as a small company like we have, you know, like Rob, Molly, and I do all of the like logistics, customer service, like all the crowdfunding stuff is like the three of us, right? So, like dealing with all of our six different like fulfillment partners and all these sorts of things. So, all of that stuff is we don't have we haven't contracted out that stuff. So, like Rob is like a wizard with spreadsheets and he's figured out how to work with Kickstarter and GameFound and like figuring all like good workflows for all that stuff and like we have to just be like really conscious of how efficient we are with all the like not fun stuff of being being a board game publisher, right? Like it's just the the dayto-day like making sure games get to people, right?
It's like that's that's the other half of the you know the fun creative side. But it
half 70.
Yeah, I was going to say what percentage actually is that unfun stuff. If for the people that are out there thinking you made it sound pretty easy so far, uh the f fun is relative. Um
I would say the design part the development and design part is no more than 30% even less 20 probably 20
of the of dayto day. Well, even if we took like a five day week, which we never do. We're doing like six or se six and a half day weeks. Uh we do dev like Monday nights and maybe Tuesday nights. So maybe a day's worth. So it is about
Yeah.
20% of a week.
Yeah, that's about right. And you know, like the I think it's all really rewarding, right? Like it's exciting to like, you know, we're really really fortunate to have like folks that really I think really enjoy and respect the games that we're putting out and are excited about flatout titles and like that's like I do a lot of the like day-to-day crowdfunding stuff like setting up the pages and you know responding to every comment and every message we get and things like that and like it's I find that really rewarding. Right. Obviously, there's parts there's days that are hard and there's times where something goes wrong on fulfillment and people are super upset and some people want to be mean to you and that's never fun. But by and large, we like have an incredible community of people that are just like supportive, excited about the games and that's like that makes it that makes it really fun to just like know that there's so many people around the world that are just like there to support us and I don't know
excited about playing the games. So we have never put this we should probably put it in some kind of marketing thing but our line that motivates us or like the core it's not really a value but like the core principle is we are making the games we want to play and so it's really exciting when other people want to play those games because we're making them because we're like this is really fun. I enjoy playing this. The irony is that I typically don't get to play them very many times after they're published games, but um that there is like it's a it's a labor of love and then it's really fun when someone comes up to you at a convention and talks to you about how much fun they're having playing a game or they're you know the Kickstarter comments are grouchy and excited but uh and sometimes at conventions people are really mad because they don't have their game yet or something too by
Oh really? So, you've had face tof faces with people that are mad about delivery.
It's not that it's it's not that often, but
yeah,
it is funny because they Yeah, it's like I don't know that they know all the time like when you It's funny because we we work our booth, right? Like we're just at the you know, it's like and it's sort of like sometimes people catch on. They're like, "Oh, you're demoing this game. Oh, you're the designer of this game." Or, "Oh, you're the like owner of this company or whatever." And like we're always there. And yeah, there have been a lot of like fun funny funny interactions where people have like, you know, um discuss like figured out. They're like, "Oh, that's cool. Like, I didn't know you were the person involved in designing this or whatever." So, it's fun to just like meet people and have those interactions.
Yeah, I would imagine the vast majority of are hyper positive, but probably takes takes a back takes you back a bit if somebody is a little bit, I don't know, confrontational around their delivery. I would say whatever people are mostly like that on social media and on the Kickstarter page.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. You know, face to face stuff like that. I mean that that's the downfall of the internet is that that anonymity, you know. I was talking to Tom Bassel at at a Gen Con and I was like, did people ever because we were talking he interviewed uh with me and I was like, you know what, the most of the comments were actually really really good. He's like, oh, that's surprising. He's like, I read out every single one. I went and read that that interview uh multiple times. read every single one in there. I read all the comments on on Dice Tower and I just block them if they're, you know, if they're rude or whatever or just just leave them alone. But I had asked him, "Did you have anyone that like actually comes up to you and says any of this stuff?" He said he like recounted one time in all the years that he's been doing this that someone's actually come up to him. But if you go read the comments, you would expect, you know, many other people would have done that. So, um, uh, anyways, you had mentioned, um, you have a specific customer that gets really excited or your customer or your community, I should say, gets really excited when you're putting new stuff out. And it seems like to me when I look at your catalog, you are speaking to a really specific person. You're not trying to um, hit on every level of complexity. You're not trying to hit all of these different themes. There's certainly some uh publishers out there, especially as they get larger, obviously, you know, you want to move more units, you want to broaden your customer base. How intentional is that for you? And do you think that continues as having this really core DNA around light rules yet crunchy decisions, cute
boxes, generally small? That's at least my perception of of the brand. We are at a very interesting turning point for a whole bunch of reasons about the games that we have in development or like just about to start working on. But I think we have been pretty intentional. We also I think I said this years ago in a interview with Casual Game Insider and so and it stays in my brain because I think like at least personally um and I think kind of politically, economically we sort of feel this way about no growth for growth's sake. Um like we are not interested in taking over the world. It's just not who we are. It's not like we want to make good games and we want to get games out for people who are really enjoying them and we want to involve as many people in the process and share in the profit with them. Um we are at an interesting point because we are kind of growing and but we're strapped for time.
We're getting a little crunched on time I think but um
expand expand expand. We also want to be doing things that are ch like a little bit more challenging, right? So, we've put out, however, I'm going to look over there, like, you know, 10 big like our bigger box games, eight or 10 of them. And like that many smaller box games and that we have a whole cycle like I know every month what kinds of things are happening and what that process is like, which is great because it's getting to a like welloiled machine
plays. We roughly know how many hours it's going to take. We roughly know all the things in a calendar year that need to happen, the key deadlines, but uh a couple of things are happening. Our friends are designing different types of games. Uh and we want to be trying development on different types of games. So feel like we're we'd like to keep things like pretty core to our our kind of audience. And
yeah, like I'm I'm still like really obsessed with puzzly Thailand games, so like that's always like that will always be my passion.
You guys like those?
Yeah, we're kind of into those ones. Um I think that will always be a part of our brand. Like we've got, you know, I'm super pumped for Perennial. That's probably like my favorite one so far. And so like, you know, getting to work on these designs and like um designs in that realm is part of our DNA. And I and so I think like people that like the Calico, Cascadia, like those types of games, I think we'll we want to continue to be the publisher that makes those types of games, right? Like or one of the publishers that you can rely on for like that kind of thing if that's your jam. Um, but we're definitely like the other thing that we always say is like we make the games that you can share with your friends and family. So like we like gateway games that are easy to teach because it allows you to share the hobby with different people who might be interested in a different theme because of the theme or something or there might be like a simple mechanic that someone latches on to or like you know a lot of people like spatial puzzles and so if the if the rules can be simple enough and we include family modes with a lot of our games because sometimes you want to play with your parents or whatever and they're like kind of they would sit and play a game, but they're not super competitive or they're not super into like having it be a bunch of rules or whatever. So, like just making experiences where you can share it with other people, but also still they're still hardcore games, right? Like you could like we still love playing them.
We're hardcore gamers who play everything out there and like they still work in a game group, but they can like go beyond. They like I feel like I always want our games to have range, right? they're sort of like not targeting like one specific target audience, but like you know like
I definitely see that like Cascadia is my favorite game that you've made and it is a go-to staple that I will teach to absolutely anybody at any time and I don't get bored of it. I find so typically I'm like mediumheavier, you know, gamer, but we've play all kinds of all kinds of stuff. And if I can find those games and put them in my toolbox that I'm excited about to play, but I can also get it to the table with absolutely anyone, they have so much value for me. And that's kind of that that is the DNA that I see coming out of you. I haven't played everything, but you know, we have a we have a pretty heavy library of flatout games as I look at as I look at the list here. Um, so I was just wondering if you're gonna stay there or now you're your friends are making different games. Maybe there is kind of like growth happening in the future, but your core DNA will stay in this this area.
I think like weight wise a lot of our games will still stay in that area of like these are games that you'll want to share with
Yeah.
friends and family. like they they I don't we don't have anything in the pipeline that's like a really heavy game
and I don't like it would be fun and interesting to kind of go that route sometime but we also don't play a ton of heavy games right like
like our jam is like all the games in like similar range to like
flatout games like you know we're
a fan of the like family weight stuff so that's sort of like that's what we know. So it you know it doesn't mean that if somebody pitched us something we couldn't be like oo you know as as we might talk about later in this interview.
Yeah.
There's some some really big projects that really
are really different than anything else we've done. But that's you know
so if if it if we feel like it's a it's a game product that's worth making and we get excited about it. We're like well okay like this is cool. This is a new challenge. So,
uh, yeah, we're going to be branching out, but I think our like our core approach to making games isn't going to change. So, that'll that'll stay the same.
Right. So, we're circling back to crowdfunding. You mentioned it's more difficult in and you're trying to stack these games together, shipping, so on so forth. It's difficult to get uh people to get excited, frankly, about having to pay shipping relative to smallbox, less expensive stuff. Like, have you thought about other ways to get people excited in crowdfunding? Do you see this as or is this a really core uh component of you being able to bring a game to market? Is is having to go to crowdfunding? It really removes a lot of the risk. That's for sure. Like I would ne like it's funny people are often comment you know usually every time I put an ad up one there'll be one comment on Meta where someone's like I don't want like some you're a big established publisher and you shouldn't be on Kickstarter anymore. And I think like do you hilarious
like we have a nice looking logo and nice looking game. We are
well it's probably because you're connected to AEG. That's probably where that's coming from even though totally separate I would guess.
Yeah. Yeah. Uh and and I you know I resist responding being like we're really not that big. Um, yeah,
but uh
I think there's a value Sean will probably have opinions about this too. Like Kickstarter or any crowdfunding platform is really this great opportunity to see how people respond to something to see what is exciting people about a thing. Um, and to get that kind of guaranteed, you know, however many hundreds or thousands of backers. um and to be able to give them something. We usually have a an expansion, mini expansion, free promo in that. And so it's this like you took a chance on this early on. Um and then get the product out there. Um it's just the rhythm we've been in. And I I don't see us not doing it. M
there might be some reasons why just in terms of production or timing or something like Landmarks didn't go uh Cascadia Landmarks the expansion for Cascadia didn't go to crowdfunding and that was partly a timing thing and then Cascadia Junior we didn't take to Kickstarter because it was really not the Kickstarter audience but so it's not like every single thing but uh sort of built into our rhythm now of doing stuff so
yeah I've talked to some publishers and they say like the size of the box really is a limiting factor on crowdfunding and and sometimes they won't even take you I think IV Studios I was talking to and they said they won't even take some games um and granted uh the games I think they're talking about are smaller than than stuff you typically um make but it's just an interesting thing right like I think it is such an important component of getting the stuff we love into our hands especially from small publishers and I definitely put you in that in at regards and frankly when you're talking about business size all of these are small businesses. You even look at places like like AEG it's like you know relative to you know the Fortune 500 these are just minuscule teeny tiny um you know companies. So, uh it's just it's it's interesting to me and it's like also trying to think about like how you you still provide value for the user or for the customer. Um when it is not you're not making a deluxified version, right? Like you're not making the two different versions like that has to be tough, right? to get people super excited about
the margins are like we give a massive discount off the MSRP which I I think a lot of people have a philosophy that that's not a smart move on crowdfunding which like I think you know when we put a game on Kickstarter that's like $29.99 or $29, right? Like it's a $40 retail game and then we sell the Kickstarter edition as a $50 game because it has a $10 expansion in it. And so like we're giving like a $50 game for $29, but I think some people just like attach the value to like what the pledge level is. They're like, "Oh, this is like a $30 game, right? Like Cascadia is like $29 or like so sometimes like the value proposition. I I think we have like still a very strong value proposition, but then it's also like it costs us like some like 20 plus dollars to like freight that and ship it and they like last mile shipping like well not even manufacturing, right? Like it costs over $20 to like deliver that to someone's home in
so landed to somebody's home. You're selling it to them for 29 bucks and it's over 20 bucks that you're
you're spending. We charge
we char we charge
$9 we prices have gone up
the prices for the ship like we do charge shipping but we subsidize a big chunk of the shipping too so we don't usually charge people the full cost of what it costs us but like so the margins for those games really mean that we like rely on the like critical mass, right? Like if we launched a Kickstarter and we only had like a thousand backers, it'd be pretty rough, right? Like it'd be
it would be hard to break even on that. And so we've been fortunate enough to have like a pretty strong following and we really just like try to get those price points down to where like this is a strong value proposition because it is hard. Like people can wait for retail for some of our products and then they can get them from their friendly local game shop. They don't have to pay shipping and stuff like that. And that that's also great, right? Um but it's a pretty important like way to keep our collab going because we're independent of AEG for our crowdfunding, right? We do all the work for the crowdfunding. We do all the manufacturing and the crowdfunding, customer service, all that kind of stuff. Um, and that's what our collabs like bread and butter. Like we split the profits from that. And that's really the best way that people can support us directly, right? It's like back the Kickstarter. We'll try to give you perks. We'll try to like make it as inexpensive as we possibly can while maintaining some margin for our team
and know that that's going directly to the like six or seven core people who worked on the game
and [snorts] so how important is that truly buying direct from you right like I think a lot of that is people do wait okay I'm going to wait to get in my FLGS and we certainly want to support them some will get it from Amazon or what whatever it might be But that is a huge hit on you uh right from like a margins perspective
and we're not talking about you know huge margins out of the gates either way and likely you know especially the the big online retailers are cutting off of that MSRP already so it's um it's you know it's always a race to the bottom regardless like talk a little bit about how important that is.
It's really great. Uh, I mean a a lot of retailers across the world do get the Kickstarter editions. So, you know, you can buy from the FGS a Kickstarter edition. You know, there's however many,
you know, 50 of them or something globally who who take a chance and bring that product in. I mean, they're getting it earlier than it's going to be in retail. So, there's some incentive there. Um um it's Kylie at Games Unlimited in Pittsburgh who did a thing I think it was a Tik Tok or something a while ago and it um just on the comment about like who's where are you buying your games and someone said to him like oh like Amazon must be your competition and he said from a games perspective and just from an industry perspective like the biggest competition is Netflix or you know people doing things that aren't playing games, right? If people are buying games and playing games,
that's great. However, they're getting them, right? And I think we definitely feel that like, yes, our bottom line is better if someone backs the Kickstarter or late pledges on Gamefound or whatever the case may be. Uh but if they want to buy it on Amazon, particularly for people who are living nowhere near a friendly local game store, uh though many of them do ship, so if you have one even remotely close to you, um you should call them up and say, "Uh do you have this game and can I can you ship it to me?" Um, people are playing games and that's the number one objective because the more they're playing, the more they're buying games, the more they're playing games, the more likely they are to keep playing games and buying games and going to conventions and, you know, eventually going into their local game store and maybe their local game store is running great events and then they're meeting other gamers or they're having, you know, a great time in a third space in a community. So like there's so many things to consider that yes, if you want to support people directly, buy from them directly, but we want people to play games.
Do you sell direct at retail or is that AEG does that for you?
AEG does all of the retail sales of the retail edition. So we have a handful of the Kickstarter editions, which retailers, you know, we have our core group who buy from us. Um, and sometimes some years they do and some years they don't and some years they do a big order and then they don't do an order for a few years. Um, but uh, AEG has all of the retail like they have the big DRO relationships which we don't have.
So Point Salad was uh, published by AEG. Correct. There was no FlatOut games at that point.
That's right.
Why did you create FlatOut games rather than just continuing to design? like why why do the crazy route of all the 70% unfun work that you had talked about uh instead of just continuing to design and and have fun
entrepreneurial entrepreneurial spirit um because uh yeah we wanted to do more of the more of the work we wanted we wanted to do we wanted to experience more of the work. Sean can tell you the story of how Calico came to be, which was our first
my wife.
Yeah. Uh but I think like all at least Sean and I really have the like we love being there's like a sales piece that we like maybe me the most. Well, and also just making the product like my passion is actually like I I think it's and we've we've um we've got a game Sasha Quest which is coming out soon from Weird City uh Games and they're like the most lovely people and we love working with them and um it's so fun to still just like be able to design a game and then like release give it to somebody else to be able to um
you're continue the development of the game, right? I think that's like super fun and interesting and like still a thing that I hope we get opportunities to do.
Yeah,
it's hard it's like it's harder to find time to design stuff that you know like maybe isn't the best fit for our company or we don't have time or a slot to publish it, but like somebody else like a friend of ours or somebody we know in the industry is like excited about it and like we want to work together. But um I think like for us like it's the passion about like just making games and also like I get really excited about like we we talk a lot about like making our friends games with them, right? like um you know Randy and Joseph and Ashwin and Emily and um Pete McFerson like people like they like we have a really fun time working together and so like it's cool to just be able to like be a developer on something that like you know like Pete designed and then we get our hands into it and we all kind of mess around with them like it's very collaborative right and I just really like that sense of like collaborative design and having a sense of agency and control over like the whole process to like getting it to become a project, right? Like product.
Um, I guess that's the like that's the thing for us that we like feel like we wanted to try it out because we wouldn't we weren't sure and we got very very lucky to like build a super cool and awesome team with Calico and was successful and like
to this day people still love Calico and still buying Calico which is like so wild. Like the whiteboard statement for when we started working on Calico was like be on the shelf next to Azul and everyone was like haha. Like Azul had just like blown up, right? It's like okay cozy like mediumweight family game like with a theme that's not
soft theme.
Yeah. Theme that's not dungeons or whatever. Like this like you know Wingspan was really popular time like we had just played Wingspan. I think the same weekend we started working on dev on Calico when we played Wingspan for the first time with Beth and so it had just come out that that was like in January or whatever and so those games are like this sort of like cozy board game thing was like just starting and we were like oh this is so cool we're so into this right we freaking love Azul and
so that was the like thing like be on the shelf next to a zool and like never in our what like that's just the thing that you like dream of and we're like we're a first-time publisher like there's no way we're even going to get into distribution. If we get a thousand backers on Kickstarter it'll be this massive success and we'll all feel feel great about it. And so to have that game like be what it is and then of course Cascadia which followed up after it's like a lot of times the joke with us it's like we designed Point Salad and then we started with Calico and Cascadia as our like that's it. just like like we peaked very early like those are like those three games are just like
hard how do you like it's hard to top that and in a lot of ways like I love our whole catalog and and things like that and I think there are games that will come along that will surpass those hopefully but it's uh
or give them a run for their money
we were very fortunate because it gave us a lot of momentum and excitement to keep doing what we're doing right it's like there we you know lots of publishers there's publish 20 or 30 games before they get an evergreen, right? Like it's it's hard to like create a game that continues to sell beyond the first year that it's released. And so we just feel really fortunate that um you know, a couple of our games have been able to do that
sustain.
Do you ever create a game where that's not a goal for it to be an evergreen? meaning like you don't you think it's an important thing to produce, but it's not going to be the next Wingspan or Calico.
You just never know.
Well, I would say you just never know, but I feel like I kind of knew with all of those three that they had some momentum even before.
When you say three, are you talking about Calico, Cascadia, and Verdant?
Uh, Point Salad.
Polo Point Salad.
Yeah. Um I don't know if I mean in your in the process in the in the whole we spent like two years working on something
if we didn't think we should make this game. We wouldn't spend that time doing it. And so you I think I'm going to say this out loud and then I'm going to get quoted on it and
but like everyone wants every game to be a bestseller. Um you hope it finds the audience of people. I think you never know what else is going to come out at the same time. You never know what other trend is going to kind of surpass it. You never know, just whatever weird thing is gonna make it or break it. But I don't think we go into projects without thinking like, you know, let's put the best thing we can out and hope that it sells for as many years as possible.
I I was going to say 100% we think they all will be evergreens, right? Like like we don't make that many games in a year, but like we pour so much love and time into like every single one of them to make like it it the best version of itself. I think there's ones where we like it's funny like forage is a good example where like oh it's funny like the industry was like don't make a nature themed rolling right nobody wants that. Like it was just like one of those things that I think
it was actually Kylie again from Games Unlimited was at Gamma uh two years ago and he was at a session. It was a great session by the way. Uh I think you can if you're a Gamma member, you can watch I think they have a maybe a video of it. It was things board game store owners wish publishers knew. And man, I was like that's like the number one session I want to go to because I think this is going to be so interesting. And it was hacked. Like the room was like some crazy event. Like it was people standing sitting on the floor like every space in that room was full and all three publishers said great stuff. It was totally or all three game store owners said great stuff. It was totally worth it. But we were like in the thick of the forage which is a nature themed roll and right game. uh in the thick of development on that or getting close to and uh someone said like what not don't what you know what games do will you not need or what games some question like that because he'd also said something like party games make any party games at Christmas any party game you know people are just looking for party games at Christmas um he said whatever you do just like don't make another nature themed rolling right and I was just like oh no oh no that's like we're only going to put three games on next year and one of them is nature themed role and right.
So,
have there been many instances where you've gotten feedback like that and you just kind of stuck to your guns and it was, you know, the right decision to not listen to people.
We both look over at the shelf.
Yeah.
I mean, so one good example is Fit to Print, right? It's a real time game. Yeah.
And that's just like poison, right? Like there's just so many people that are just a no
on real time.
Um, but it's like I don't know. In my opinion, it's like the perfect real time game. It's so thematic. Yeah. And it's like it's exactly what it's like to frantically make a newspaper like that. It just it it's just like and Pete's design was so clever and like just like you know it was like one of those things where like okay this is like on brand for us. It's a pile game. It's puzzly whatever. And like we kind of knew that that game just has a lower ceiling, right? Like there's just going to be so many there's just going to be people who just like that's not their thing. And so like as a publisher it's like sometimes tough to make that swing because it's not like we're some kind of like an agency who like has done all the market research and they're like okay we need to make this game that's this weight that's like this many players and whatever you know like a lot of it is like our personal feelings about the the artistic merit of the thing and the hope that you know we will be able to do a good enough job of making it the best version of itself so that it can find its audience no matter how big or small.
And like obviously a game like Cascadia has a massive audience and that's super cool to like be able to like make a game that has that broad appeal. And I think a lot of our games do, but when we make something more niche, like Nocturn's a really good example of a game that like I just think is is such an amazing design that our friend David did and you know, we poured a lot of like effort and love into like thinking about like the theme and the artwork and like making that a product and like it hasn't it has definitely not been like as commercially successful as like some of our other games, but like the merit of like making that and like just the process of going through it like there's like we don't have any regrets for any of the games we've published. Like they they're all really special to us and we've managed to, you know, get paid for our time to create the art and like um we're just really fortunate, I think, to be able to like, you know, I was talking about like in an industry in board game publishing and design like we get to like make stuff and there's like an audience of people who will generally buy it, right?
Like I I I work as a landscape architect and like we have to go out and find jobs or find clients and things like that. It's like I can't just manifest a landscape, right? Like, right. I feel so lucky as a board game publisher to just be able to like
be like, "We think this idea is cool and we can like put in the hours and make the art and and and produce this thing and we have enough of an audience that like
crowdfunding
generally speaking. We can it can pencil out and it can be worthwhile spending the time doing it." And that's just such a gift. It's like so incredible that we get to do that. And we're very fortunate to everyone who supports Flatout Games because it just like lets us keep going and hopefully it's a mutual benefit that we get to make games that people like playing.
You know, it's funny. We've been fulfilling the Kickstarter um to the Kickstarter backers on the 2026 games and uh one of the things we have on the Gamefound page is like an all-in buy all the titles for whatever amount it is. Um, and two different people within a day had either taken a photo of that uh or like the order like the ad for it or and someone else had actually just laid them all out like on the floor on the table or something and posted a photo and said like what's everybody's favorite and I I mean I read a I I read almost all the comments from the moment that it got posted. Um, what was interesting to me was, yeah, like it's Cascadia and Calico. Uh, but the number of people whose favorite games on there were one of the other games in the catalog was really great to see. And people were like, "Wow, Nocturn." They were like, "That's a sleeper hit." Or like, "It's a totally underrated game."
And, you know, other people like lots of people like Verdant and I of course come in and say like, "It's my favorite of the tril," you know. Um, but it was it was nice to see that like people are really enjoying and have a place for all the games. So people will say like deep dive is a game that yeah they absolutely would play with their families and with younger kids, right? Like it has a place for them. So that kind of reinforces the like every game has a right
a place and a role. Yeah,
that's kind of where I was going about, you know, your target customer and if you're going to kind of expand or or pivot at all because I think what's great about FlatOut is you can have a true fan for your games because it kind of serve your entire line. Well, and and when I say the same person, it's obviously, you know, people with wide varieties of of of likes, but basically if somebody likes something, they almost sure surely will like a lot of what you're doing. And I would imagine that's a huge um advantage, especially when you don't have the advantage of, you know, hype in Kickstarter, crowdfunding, deluxification, you know, so on so forth. And I I really do think that's that is the case. And that's every time you come out with something, I know for sure that um we're going to enjoy it.
Like I just, you know, just know like I was uh perennial. I think I was I was looking at at um Gen Con. I was like, "Oh my gosh, my wife is going to absolutely love this." Like she loves your stuff and you know, I've I play everything that she wants to play and I appreciate that you exist because they're still very interesting to me. They're not these just beautiful games. They're incredibly crunchy,
right? Um, you mentioned theme a little bit. You have not been shy about nature themes.
Is the market oversaturated? Is Kylie saying no nature themes or was it just rolling right? But no, really the real question is
it was it was specifically rolling right,
right? And I I I talked to uh Emily from Pink Hawk. I did a playthrough with her on her her cat game and and I asked this same question. It's like is there enough cat games? My I go to my FLGS and it's nothing but cat games. We love cats, so we're always going to say no to that. But is there a point of oversaturation with theme or are people just going to continue to eat up cozy nature themes as an example or cat themes or whatever it might be?
Okay, so I have lots of lots of thoughts about this. uh one is that I feel like the even though we're in this you know uncertain economic time I do feel like the industry is kind of growing the number of people out there who are interested in board games is growing say in North America like Europe's a different you know they've got a different history and trajectory
but uh let's say in the UK and Canada and the US in particular, there is this like growing crowd of casual gamers. And I think that there's lots of reasons for that. And as people come into the hobby, they are looking for all kinds of different themes. And I think the number of people who are looking for cozy games and specifically cat themed games or nature games is growing. So it doesn't it to me it doesn't seem like oh it's going to be oversaturated like
say 20 years ago did someone say like oh no more space games or like please don't give me another medieval themed game.
It was like that's all they are like it's that's what it is. And so people like it's just a different game with different art and different mechanics but it's all just like
you know some colonial or like medieval themed game and we all played them and lots of them are excellent. Um, so I just think as the hobby grows and the and the diversity of the people who are playing, I think you don't there's never going to be too many of those games.
Yeah, I don't think there's going to be an oversaturation. I I run a a small uh community platform called Cardboard and I match people to games and one of the best predictors that I have is theme.
Bottom line, it's it's if you like nature games, the best predictor I have is another nature game. There's s there's a ton of other elements that I look at when I analyze this, but theme is such a huge predictor. Space as well is is another one that's just like, you know, it highly likely to like basically uh anything space, especially if it's in their wheelhouse around complexity and such. So, you know, I I see I sometimes see like the the the internet groaning about, you know, oh, another n anthropomorphic, you know, forest theme game. It's like, no, people are going to continue to eat that stuff up and I I will as well. Like I think um you know I but I do like unique takes on themes as well. I like you know but I'm I you don't listen to me. I have like hundreds and hundreds of board games and and I'm a psychopath. So like what I say.
I just wonder is like the regular person um going to get going to get tired of it? Probably not. I don't know. I You'll keep producing nature themed games, I assume. Yeah, it's funny the three games. Well, I guess one uh I'm just trying to think about next year's lineup. I wouldn't say there's
I think we just really want to make inviting games. I don't think we want to make theme like a a deterrent for someone, you know, like I think that's that's a big part of it. And we're really like mechanically focused designers and
probably most of the designers we work with are pretty like
pretty mechanics first and
like that's just our jam because like we that's what I mean especially me like that's what gets me excited about a game is like oh what does it do mechanically that's interesting but the the the journey to an amazing product is like finding the marriage of like a theme with a mechanic that makes sense that reinforce that they reinforce one another and then invites the greatest number of people into that thing, right? It's like um you know, Calico was not didn't have cats, right? When Kevin designed it, it was about quilts and we needed like a scoring token to put on the quilt and we were like, "What would you put on the quilt?" And we're like, "Oh, how about cats, cats, and buttons?" And
Right. Yeah. It's not a cat game. It's it's a quilting game, right? You forget that. Yeah.
Yeah. And so like it just became part of the game's identity which was a great thing because it was fun and we got people to submit their own cats to get put in the game and like it was just like that those kinds of things are really exciting when they like come together and it's like who doesn't like a thing that's inviting and warm and cozy or you know like Cascadia was about like that was Ry's design was called like lands and creatures and it was like it had gorillas and it was just sort of like about different biomes and biomes and animals. And we were like trying to think like, well, maybe we should make it about
a specific place,
specific place here in the Pacific Northwest. And we're like, we're all passionate about that. That would be really fun. And then we sort of were like, well, the name Cascadia is just got a nice ring to it, right? And so like then it starts to influence like, oh well, how would these different animals form on the landscape and stuff? And so the theme and mechanics, even though Cascadia is obviously very mechanical game.
Yeah. Um, but it's just one of those things that we get to celebrate a place part of the world that we just like feel passionately about. And like Perennial, like we're from the prairies and I did like graduate research on, you know, prairie ecosystem. So like that's a game that's just like close to our hearts because it's we're moving to a different uh landscape and celebrating like that. And again, like a mechanically heavy game, but we get to bring in a part of ourselves that we're passionate about in it in the theme. And we think it's something that's inviting and beautiful and like thing and that will bring in new gamers potentially who are really like gardening or really like prairie plants and like maybe this is their intro into board games. So, um, yeah, that's it's um we we don't choose themes necessarily for like I don't know. It's it's just it's a fit thing, right? It's just sort of like how can we what can we
It's not a marketing thought per se
where you're like this is going to be the thing that sells it. It has to meet since you're mechanics first, you're trying to find a theme that complements the mechanics.
Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. So, how important though is theme and art to actually selling a game? I was talking uh on this show to Jay from Bezier Games and he says the art, the front the box cover is the most important element of the game even more so than the design.
I He's obviously thinking of this from a from a sales perspective in customers act because because if the customers doesn't pick it up and and buy it or try it, it doesn't matter how great the design is. I think I think there's a lot of truth to that. I think that like art is so huge and and product design like the overall package of a game is like really really important.
We fuss [snorts] so much about so many board game mechanical things like about balance where we're like should this be a two or should it be a three and then then we play a lot of published games and we're like this should have been a three. Can't believe this is a two. Why? like, you know, like we fuss over a lot of stuff balance-wise with our games. And I I would say I'm relatively proud of how balanced our games are. Um, and that gives them a lot of longevity in the sense that people really those our games have been played a lot by what I would say are fairly smart designers and developers. And I think that has
very smart. I would say very very smart. that has value, but at the end of the day, a lot of times they have to stop and be like, we're in the territory of like 1% of people who play this game might realize, you know, like is there some like little balance issue that we're really struggling with or like
Well, so we play the game like a hundred times and yes, Cascadia people might play Cascadia a hundred times, but uh
yeah,
it Yeah,
let's let's be realistic. I mean, most of the games on people's shelves get only played a handful of times, right? And so, you just have to like understand that and and that's that's sort of part of like what I mean a board game collection is like you're not just playing the same game over and over again. You're like having different experiences. It's and and and so I think like it is really like the art and aesthetics of a game are like one of the things that people will identify, right? the theme is like something that they can connect with. Yeah.
I don't I like there there are mechanics like deck building or worker placement that are strong mechanics that people might have an identity where like, oh, I love deck building games. I'm going to buy every deck building game there is out there. Let's go get all those games, right? But I think people really do connect with like theme and art and like the aesthetic of a thing almost like first, right? Like that's the like I I think to have a truly successful evergreen game, you really need both.
But if you were just going to like if you like if you you can put lipstick on a pig, right? Like you can put you could put a game that you didn't develop at all that's actually like probably kind of bad and has like incredible art. Like it'll sell for the first it'll go through that first sales cycle for sure.
Um and so I think like
Oh, you won't reprint it.
Yeah. you you might not reprint it or or like maybe you will because maybe it transcends it because the theme and the art is just like such a great experience that like
maybe the game is like a little less fun or it's not balanced or like they didn't take into account all these other things, but like you just love it because you're like I just really like being a dog walker or whatever. Like I just identify with that theme and like I get into the thing and that's just like like you know what it's like okay like I don't even like the mechanics of Verdant but like man I love house plants and I just love seeing all the plants down on the table or whatever.
That's why I backed Verdant.
Yeah,
that 100%. Yeah. Yeah, we we're we're we love plants and
and anything in that in that uh regard and and as soon as I saw that I backed it. In fact, it's the only thing I I backed from you. Everything else I bought from from retail. But uh but yeah, I backed that one specifically for it theme cuz I thought it was just so cool. Like house plants and arranging them to get the right light and everything like it was so so awesome. But it was also mechanics. Mechanics still got me. I would say the qualifier was this idea of arranging house plants. Um because at that time it was just an odd theme. I just liked it. I thought it was cool. The art was also very awesome. But yeah, it it was super super important. I I I do think theme and art is the easiest disqualifier for people. Um and that can you know it definitely can stop people from ever seeing the brill brilliance um of the design. And you have been like I think we we said this earlier, you mentioned Beth's name a couple times, but you've been privileged to work with Beth on on multiple projects. Um, how has it been working with Beth and how important has that relationship been been to not only selling games but being able to, you know, uh, you know, produce awesome products for people?
Huge. Uh, like the fact that she lives in Bellingham and she's
Oh, I didn't know that.
Oh, I need to meet Beth.
Uh, really is amazing because that meant that we met her at Orcaon the first time, maybe. or maybe you'd met her beforehand, but like we know her and
and she's also one of the best humans. Like just full stop. Like she's so awesome. So Beth's a a good friend and she's and like people are like people get excited about Flatout Games because of like the mechanics or the designs and like they like the designers that we work with and they like the designs from us and things like that. And that's something that people say a lot. But like the overwhelming thing where people will get excited about a new game is like it's Beth's art. We love it. people that that's like a huge driver for a lot of people that they're like I'll buy anything that has bet soil art on it, right? And so it's like that's a that's a big deal and she like she's just so she's like incredible at what she does and we're really fortunate to get to work with her and it's been it's been fun and it's a huge part of our like brand identity, right? like Flatout, where would Flat Games be without like those signature beta of those
covers and you know like the Calico I remember like getting the Calico cover art and like we're all just like oh my god and we have another game coming soon where I'm just like oh the cover.
Yeah. Stay tuned for like early November to just be like oh man
it's the best.
Yeah. I'm looking through her games that she's uh that she's illustrated. I have not disliked one that I've played. So I don't know. Maybe she just has an eye for picking the right game, too. I don't know. Especially since she's a gamer.
She's a gamer, so she knows. Yeah,
that's crazy. Viticulture, Wingspan, Cascadia, Calico, like so many great I love Three Sisters, Verdant, Herbaceious. Um God, you just keep going down the list here. Tussy Mussy.
I love that one. Yeah, so many good things. Anyways, yeah, I just I thought that was uh it's it's interesting when I see a publisher work with the same artist over and over and and it's got to be part of the relationship. Obviously, they have to be talented, but that that that that connection between the artist and the actual like end product I I just found find super interesting. So, that's cool that you found Beth and I need to meet her since she's up here in the Pacific Northwest.
Yeah, I would say come to Orcaon, but they're not doing it this year.
I know. I I have never been to Orcon and I was I was like this is going to be the year. This has been my year of going to all conventions. I got laid off, so I have like nothing but time. So, I'm just like, uh, you know, I went I went to Dice Tower West. I went to Origins. I went to Gen Con. U, we'll see if I I haven't ran out of money by um PAX Pax Unplugged. Yeah. Right. But Oricon was also something I want wanted to go to. Um, but I was so sad to see that. Are they going to do it next year or is it just like
I they I pause because the it's a volunteer run. And so I think they were sort of like we need a breather. So I'm hopeful that they'll be they'll be back. And um you know there's a lot of amazing people in the community here that have been a part of making that happen. And so you know I'm sure regardless like we'll be able to get a strong like convent a local convention together between you know whether or continuing or something else popping up. But yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah. Especially up here, we have so much time to be indoors. Like we need we need cool conventions.
I know. And that one's at the time where I'm not annoyed, you know? The fact that I spend so many summer weekend like
Yeah. just going to Gen Con is great and I it's part of the year, but the idea of spending, you know, four days of the summer on a weekend indoors, uh, every year
and because we go like Saturday to Tuesday, two weekends get eaten up by
Yeah, I hate to leave up here in the summer, unless of course it's, you know, fire smoke season, but it's like I feel like I only have so much and I'm not going to go back on weather, but I just I do love our summers. They're so incredible. like it's what you you pay for this. Um so we've uh we've alluded to to this and I was so taken aback and also pleasantly surprised when you showed me Whisper Stone. This is your puzzly RPG, correct?
Yes.
So tell me about it. Give the audience a bit of a pitch. Um and you can send me uh photos and I'll I'll throw them up here as you talk about it.
Great. I gave it the other day, so if you want to Okay. Well, Whisper
I feel like I'm typing about it all the time. So,
Whisperstone is a puzzly role playinging system and it is designed uh by our friend Nick Tran and his sort of philosophy was he's like, "Okay, I want to play D and D or some classic role playinging experience with my kids." Then when he was like he like he didn't play D and D growing up. So he's like okay I've got all the I've touched all these other uh parts of nerddom and man I don't have my like D and D badge. That's weird. And so he's like he's like oh I'm going to play it with my kids. And he sort of like looked into it and he was like holy smokes this is like a lot and it's not very streamlined and it's like it's intense right? And so he being a game designer was like there's got to be a better way than this. So he de designed and developed um an RPG system that really is sort of like a gateway RPG that's designed to kind of um present as a board game. So it's got physical puzzle pieces and every player has a character frame and the rules are all encoded in the different equipment that you equip into your character frame. So if something fits in like a puzzle piece, you can equip it. And if it doesn't, you have to, you know, level up or, you know, somebody else in the party maybe can fit it based on their class or whatever. And so it really streamlines a lot of the rules of role playing into this really like fun table presence like system. Um, and it's not a
GMless experience. This is very much like playing role playing, playing a role playing game with your friends and having a a game um in Whisper Stone we call it an adventure master, but like having um having an actual experience where you have a dialogue and you have, you know, the
creating a shared experience.
Yeah. the shared the shared storytelling experience and really embrace the fact that there is somebody who is sort of facilitating that rather than a lot of the like
kind of board game RPG things are going GM right you can run it solo you can run like so there's a lot of selling points to those obviously but you know like it was really important to Nick to be like this is like I want to do role playing right and and so so um we're working on um a core set that has a campaign adventure uh as part of it and then we're working on an additional campaign adventure and then a box that has a bunch of oneshot [snorts] adventures. Um Whisper Stone sort of designed to be uh the all of the aspects of it are designed to sort of like get it to the table. This is the RPG that you will actually play, right? The sessions are designed to be a little bit shorter. Um they're everything that you need is in sort of like a master spoiler at the start of the adventure guide. And so to run the game, you only need to spend like 15 minutes to set up for like a whole campaign, right? You don't have to spend a whole bunch of time preparing for your party to do this adventure. It really the the way that the game is designed helps facilitate it's like training wheels for an adventure master, right? Like it if you've played RPGs
and you understand kind of the flow of a role playinging experience or you can especially if your players haven't played before and you can kind of guide them through it. It's just everything's on the table. The players can see what they have in their inventory. The players can see what time it is. The players can see, you know, their own health and all the things. And the the adventure master can see they can there's a few tools that they can use to understand placement, like where's where people are relative to each other or on a path. Um, and and also to me the most important thing, and maybe I zoned out when you described this, but like if you're equipping your player character with some weapons or tools, uh, you can see what you have, but you can also see what's in your backpack or your inventory, and you don't have to like look down. What did I scroll? Scroll in my like scroll in my corner of my player sheet. Uh, was that a sword? What was this again? I don't like uh maybe I have this thing. Did I use that? Did I give it? You know, did I sell this? Did I forget to cross it off? You're like, "No, I have it. It's physically there, and if I want to change out, I'm holding a torch, but now I think we might be there might be a combat situation imminent that I should switch it out."
And you just pull it out of your backpack and you can equip it on your frame. Um, and then you know if it gives you any special powers or any special defense or whatever the thing is, and you don't have to look it up in a book. It's like right there um on your little paper doll player basically.
One of one of the things that's really cool about it is like because we have all these phil physical components, there's also like really fun puzzles that we're designing into it. So like if you you know if you like escape room in a box type puzzles and riddles and things like that, like the adventures come with like those things kind of baked in. So, as you're exploring the world, you you know, the adventure master has a bunch of things that like you'll encounter dungeons and then you get to do special different maps and there's like it's there's a lot of really fun stuff that you can do when it's not when you're not just selling an RPG that's just a book, right? And so, you get to do a lot of like fun component things. Our modules are going to come like in a little like box, not unlike our standard board games, and they'll have punch boards in them with a bunch of new pieces and things like that. So that like as you continue to play different adventures, you'll build a bigger toolkit of like different parts. And so if you want to homebrew adventures, you can totally do that as well. You'll have like a kit of parts to be able to do that. So we're really, it's an incredibly ambitious project. Um we're working on, you know, getting all the box organization right and like finding the right like number of components and right price point and developing a lot of the um doing all the writing. Um, the other thing I should mention is that a big part of our about of this project was the world building for it. So, Whisper Stone set in this magical world where um, you're all magically evolved anthropomorphic anthropomorphic animals
and uh, and so what's cool about it is that it has this really interesting theme of the Whisper Stones or these like sacred stones that have helped um, the animals of these different biomes like connect with their environment. And that's sort of like what gives them power. And sort of the like um antagonists of the story are the collectors and they're trying to like take the stones and like consolidate power,
consolidate knowledge,
knowledge and power from the sort of like wood the hinterlands. And so they're sort of like building these like mechs and machines that are powered by these like um stones that they're stealing. And so there's this a little bit of a like nature versus machines kind of theme to it which is super cool. And so like building up all of those sort of like um different factions and things has been really fun. And so you get to like kind of get immersed in that sort of a world. And it's a also we found that it's really fun to like roleplay as like anthropomorphic animals because it gives you like a little bit of a grounding to just be like oh I'm a bear so I you know it's a little bit more fun to role play in that way. Like it gives you an invitation to just like know a little bit about like well what would a bear if I was a bear in this situation? What would
Yeah. Like I was a lion and we were in the jungle and then I just spent so much time complaining about like you know the mane I had was super hot and was just like sticky and irritating, you know, because you're like okay well now I'm this big old lion in this kind of damp horrible forest and
right
what am I experiencing? And so I don't have to like imagine a whole character. I only have to like build a bit of the personality on a thing that everyone kind of has an understanding some stere kind of in a way stereotypes about animals but like you know I know how big I am or I know like you know what my character is like a little bit you know you can play against character too but because right you know we've also had like feisty little like squirrel warriors who've done things too but like
and are you tabletop RPG players in any other form or is this also new to too.
Well, speaking of playing making the games we want to play, uh, this project really appealed to us and I would say me specifically who had always wanted to play RPGs or people had always been like, "Oh, you should play this RPG." And it always felt like, "Okay." So, then they, you know, the first thing they sit down and they're like, "What's your name?" And I was like, "I don't what? Like, that doesn't seem like a great entry point." And then it's like you don't really understand how the rhythm of the game works, right?
Um I did do a how to play Dungeons and Dragons three session class and at the end was like okay I get that now but I don't think I want to play it because we spent three hours battling like five goblins
and not any of the like really really fun like being at the tavern kind of goofy stuff. So, this isn't going to take a three-hour class to get to the table.
No, no. The adventure master needs to read the adventure master guide to get a sense of like basic rules. So, there's some lifting from the adventure master in advance of a session, but then the actual like when you're running the session,
it like the players don't really need to know more than a few simple kind of procedural things. And then the thing I would say is having played this now multiple times that uh now when someone says like oh do you want to play this like super arty like conceptual RPG or do you want to play you know whatever Blades in the Dark I'll be like okay sure I get I get the like wall has been broken about how this experience goes. So, uh, I wasn't, but if this is the like selling feature for Whisper Stone, which is like I'm the audience, someone who was very curious about role playing games
now has been kind of coached through because so much of it was simplified for me. Um, and you know, physical things I can look at, I can build my character.
Um, now I get it and now I'm hungry to play more role playing games. So, this is a big pivot, but what DNA, flatout DNA, is making its way into the game.
Oh, so a few
anthropomorphic animals.
Yeah. Um, I think I think the theme like we we're also really fortunate to be working with a couple of illustrators that are phenomenal. Lucille Lea, um, she's in France and she's doing all of our location art and and she's just incredible. really cool style and like beautiful colors and she's just done such a great job. And then Rewinter um is doing all the like character art and she's doing like our box cover and things like that and all of our all the little like items and armor and things that you wear. Like she's doing all of that stuff and she's just like
and they're working together like they're not working together specifically, but the things are working together very well.
Yeah. And and like there's We're super excited. It's got the like classic Disney kind of vibe, like animation vibe to it. So, like this handdrawn um style, which we're just like super excited about. And so, that is, you know, we're that part of it is like we're looking to make a product that, you know, fits on the shelf with the rest of our games, right? So, like
approachable approachable theme, approachable art, uh yes, puzz puzz like puzzly. So,
and I think
it's the DNA.
Yeah. And and Nick had sort of originally designed this like mostly to like sort of introduce like um like younger audiences into RPGs, right? That was a lot of like his early play testing and things like that. And that was like part of or part of the target audience. And we're sort of like I think we want to expand that into like people who are like Maui was saying RPG curious but maybe haven't been able to get into RPGs because it's too abstract for them. This gives a little bit more like just so much easier to get into. Um and so I think that part of it is is like the flatout DNA is like expand the audience to as wide as we can and make this sort of like a game for as many different people as possible. And then another thing is sort of just like mechanical balancing and stuff. We've got this really interesting like um wisp dice system which is part of like the core like um
the core combat and other parts of the game. But you're sort of like it's it works on a really simple dice system. The game works on a really simple dice system and it was originally kind of like pretty simp straightforward roll to resolve, but um we've added these like um bonus dice with certain symbols that if you you know
collect them and bank them, you can pull off different attacks and things like that and do special things with your different pieces of equipment. And so that's something that like we've been spending a lot of time on development trying to like get that system right. And it's it's also it feels like you know we're building an RPG system and part of the reason it's we've been working on it for like three and a half years and part of the reason it's taken so long is like we want to launch with enough confidence behind the system. So we didn't want to just put out like a single adventure like we're working on a bunch of stuff concurrently. So when we do launch the game, like there'll be opportunities to like have a one, you know, oneshot adventure so that like if you just have some friends and they're just over for the afternoon or whatever, you can play Whisperstone, right? It doesn't you it's it has campaign and the campaigns are also designed to be a lot shorter than like Gloom Haven or something, right? They're supposed to we're aiming for like 8 to 12 like two to three hour sessions to like run through a full campaign. So, it's not like you have to commit the rest of your life to like finishing one of these adventures. Like
um there's enough player progression, but at the end of the the end of those sessions, like you kind of get to see the full arc of the story and get to like, you know, be part of that world and that location for a certain amount of time and then, you know, you can
travel somewhere else,
travel somewhere else and start a new character and do things like that. So, um, yeah, it's incredibly ambitious, but I think we're putting the typical like flatout game spin on everything is just like making sure all the components are as high quality as possible and the mechanics are tight and um,
yeah,
approachable, puzzly.
Yeah,
it sounds like you're building a system, right? Not just a game. Is that is that the the vision is you know obviously if all goes well and and and it and it and people buy it to continue this on as a system into the future.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I say that I'm like uh we should be so lucky,
right? Of course. Of course. But that's you know that would be it's not like you're just trying to put out an approachable TTRPG per se. You're trying to build a system that is doing something slightly different.
Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. And and that's that's a big part of the ambitious part, right? It's like we want to build a community around it. And like the thing is the challenge for us honestly is like finding the audience for it. Like we know that a slice of our audience will be excited about this and lots of people have already talked about that and we've had it at our booth for a few years and there's certainly like a lot of our fans who are not interested in RPGs. So that's like a big chunk of our audience that's like already like not interested in it. However, there's a whole audience outside of our normal like what people expect of FlatOut games that could really get excited about this particular game. So it's it's our challenge is sort of like finding the people who are excited about it because we've been running demos of it and explaining at the booth for like
few years at Gen Con and other events and people instantly like if they're if this is like something that they're interested in like if they want a like introductory RPG and they know friends that they're like oh my friends I can't get them into RPGs like this is the game and like they're like really really excited to the point where now it's just like
they're like, "Um, when
Yeah. Hurry up.
When do I buy it?
I don't need all those one shots right out of the gates. Just get me the game."
Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah. Exactly.
When you took this on as compared to now with hindsight, how much more difficult has it been? And I spoke to the IV Studios guys and they um they're producing a deck builder that actually has a campaign mode and it and they said this by far has been the toughest thing that they've ever done because of the story element and trying to kind of fit everything together and it's just so much more difficult to create something that was like a narrative experience. Have you felt the same way? It's been a lot because it feels like it's every part of a regular game process, development, production process, but like even the box which we finally now like we have uh it's a prototype. We've pretty much nailed the box down. It's like so much more complicated. So, you know, as opposed to like the Cascadia box that's like it's this big. It's the same dimensions as Calico. throw it all in there like thing in it and we're good.
It all fits. It like the punch boards fit. The thing's all right. Okay, we're good. And this is like, okay, well, we got to have this 17 punch boards and they all have to fit in the box when it ships, but then they're going to get punched so they won't take up as that much space. And then it's like, you want to make the space for all the player characters to have their little boxes between games to fit in. And then you want to have a really good system for the AM to be able to flip through all the little pieces. And you want to make sure like and have it be the exactly the right size. So like just it's like amplifying any single piece of it. Plus it needs a world and it needs stories and the stories have to get tested and the stories are not just like an hour or an hour or 30 to 45 minute play time. They're like two hours and there's 12 of them or whatever. So uh there's that. Uh it's like
right
it it's just ramps every single regular component out of making a game plus adds a whole bunch of totally new things for our team into it.
Yeah, we we didn't think it through when we started, right? Like it's just like we were ambitious and and at the time, you know, Molly, Rob and I were like, "Okay, this is like way out of our league." like um but at the time we were sort of like okay it's like we're ready for a challenge right like we we made like a lot of cool puzzly family weight board games and and we'll continue to do that right like at no point we were like okay let's shift our let's pivot our whole business to like make this other thing like the reason it's taken so long is that like we're really excited about making board games and we're going to continue to be excited about that and also you know investing uh all that time and energy where you're also not making the things that you're you you know are a more sure bet at like returning on investment, right? Like, you know, the for this for this project to like pencil out in terms of like the number of hours we poured into it and the like labor of love, it's going to be really challenging, but we're just so excited. Like it's again, it's just like it's like it deserves to be out in the world.
Yeah.
We're really excited about the work that Nick's done on it. We're really excited about the work that we have a team of about 13 or 14 total people like
some people working two hours a month, you know, like it's just we have a big team of really passionate people who have limited availability. That's how we like kind of structure our team. And like that's like in some ways like really nice because we have worked with a lot of people on this project that don't have a lot of experience like either writing for RPGs or designing for RPGs or like you know I'm diving into some development stuff and I'm like okay I've never developed an RPG before. But like there's a lot of folks we're relying on on our team who do have a lot of experience in the industry. And so like it's been a good cross-pollination of like working with some people that have a lot of experience and other people that are new to it. So, like it's been a learning experience and it has been so so so hard by like by orders of magnitude harder than anything else we've ever done. Um but you know that's just that's
that's where you find growth.
Yeah. I mean
Exactly.
Yeah.
Exactly. That's what I just you just keep telling us.
You're growing. You're growing. You're growing.
I will be a better person. I will be a better person. I will have more skills. I will be stronger. It won't kill me. Yeah.
So, when are we going to see this? When is it hitting crowdfunding?
Spring.
Yeah. 2027.
Yeah. Hopefully spring next year. So, we're getting a lot closer. Like this year at Gen Con, it kind of felt like people were like, "Oh, can I buy this now?" Like it like the components are getting really close. We ran our
first like session of the core adventure to like over a dozen like sessions of it at Gen Con, which is super fun and cool and like just to see like again one of the selling points is that like the tutorials like built into that whole thing. As a player, you just sit down at the table and like you're playing an RPG, right? Like there's no rule like the rules teach like is baked into the adventure. So, it's like some of it's kind of in world and some of it's just like, okay, we're going to set up and you get this thing. But like what's cool about it is that that like almost like a video game. The other thing I was going to mention is like I don't have RPG experience, but I play have played through my life a ton of video game RPG. So, like that's my experience. And so, like one of those things is like the tutorial thing, right, that like video games can do so well that it's so much harder to do on board games. We're sort of baking in some of those elements of like sit down at the table and like you'll just learn how to play it and the AM will just like guide you through the learning experience of it and in no time flat you'll have like players got to sit down at Gen Con for like 90 minutes and they got a big chunk of the way through like they did a handful of tasks on the way to like doing something in the actual adventure and they learned like all the mechanics of the game and you know got to the point where they're like, "Oh, this is so cool. I'm super excited about this. I want to play more." Right? Like, and so that's the hook, right? It's that like you can hook
people and get people excited about RPGs in like a very short amount of time because they don't have there's no session zero. There's no like, "Okay, do your homework and then come over to my place on Saturday and we'll do a 4 hour D and D session or whatever." It's like, it's just designed to just be simple and get the table. So yeah, it's uh it'll be fun.
Very excited about it.
So we have a little time to wait on that one, but what's next is perennial. Is that your next campaign?
That's right. September 15th.
And this is the core fan. They're going to be super excited about this one. Right, Sean? You said it might be your favorite u of this style that you all have with tile laying.
It's so unique. Uh it is a polyomino game except you are aggregating and disagregating the the single squares in into polyomino shapes and then out of polyomino shapes and then back into polyomino shapes. So, uh, its core thing is just like you play four rounds. Every round you draft twice, you have a bunch of tiles on your like playerboard and you are just figuring out how to assemble them and then place them onto your garden in the best way possible to score, you know, in the handful of ways that you can score. Um, but it is the draft where you're choosing a tool that's a shape and then you have to draft those single tiles in that shape of that polyomino, but then they don't stay in that shape once they're on their board because they're just single tiles.
And so then when you draft again, you're thinking about, well, I need that other tool shape for later. And also, I need more of like the blue flower and I need a rabbit or I need whatever. And then they're all on your board. And then you use all the tool cards that you've used to draft the initial draft and then only get to place onto your board with those tool cards that you have. And so there's a lot of kind of assembling and disassembling and reassembling um but using polyomino placement.
Do you all enjoy to break our brains?
Right. Do you love that that crunch? Um I I have probably been the crankiest uh person on developer uh play tester on this game and uh we have scaled it down and down and down in terms of like
um
so it used to be worse
like there were just times when I was like I this I can't we can't this is too crazy.
Yeah. The game was at like a in terms of like a spatial crunch, the game was at like a at a at a nine out of 10 and we probably dragged it down to like a 7.5 out of 10. And then one of the big breakthroughs in this tail end of development was like finding a really awesome family mode where we just took out the part where you have to like then use the shapes to reassemble and just let you like place on your board like wherever you want. And that as a like entry like as like a cozy like simpler game just has like a really satisfying drafting mechanic and then just a really calm like oh I'm going to plant my garden. I'm going to place these things here. And so like that breakthrough I'm like oh this game has so much range now because I'm like the family mode is like like it's not trivial but it's it's still a really great like like lightweight to light to light medium I guess puzzle. And then if you want like a solidly medium to like you know getting in the heavier range in terms of a spatial puzzle then you play like the full game. And then of course the advanced mode adds extra scoring and all that kind of stuff. And the solo mode has all the fun like different challenges and things like that. I've been playing through all the solo challenges and tweaking all that stuff over the last couple months. And so I've been having fun just like breaking my brain and trying to solve these puzzles.
So, if you if you like spatial puzzle games and thought maybe like flatout stuff was generally a little bit too light, um, this one will be like this one. I would
I don't think many people say that.
They're pretty crunchy. I mean, but they're deceptive. They are so deceptive. Like I played Well, okay, here. Let me calibrate your seven and a half because um I played Alpine Lakes. I've only played it once. I played it at Gen Con uh at the at the house I was staying at and I was and it might have just been cuz of my first play, but man, that thing broke my brain having go being able to take it up the next level and like I I just couldn't We also played it on the um on the you know the advanced mode where we had the extra goals and stuff. So that might have been it as well. So where is that in your crunch mode
or scale? They're probably I think they're probably similar. Like we've gotten Perennial down to a spot where like it feels similar in weight to Cascadia Alpine Lights. Though I will say like the game perennial is doing the like reviewers circuit right now. We've heard from a few reviewers and previewers like their take on it and like some of them think it's like really really approachable like because the core rules are really simple but if you're not a spatial thinker like it can really mess with your brain because it's like okay now think about where to put those five tiles in this exact polyomino shape and score in all these different
and that you can flip like you can you can flip the polyomino
right
like whatever it is you can have it in any orientation and so you have to be able to think like, okay,
if this was rotated, you know, 90° or
So, it it kind of depends on what you find. Like, it's still rules [snorts] light. It's still very much in keeping with the rest of our games.
More rules light than a whole bunch of stuff we've done. Yeah.
More rules light.
Really, I mean, in general, your honestly, I think your rules overhead typically from what I've seen comes in scoring.
Like, that's to me is is is the is the rules overhead. I've never come across in your games that aren't incredibly easy to learn other than, okay, I have to go look at all of these different things I have to score. How am I going to do this? Um, you know, it's it's it's great. So, you know, I don't know how much how what they're what experience they're pulling from,
right? that the thing that's funny is like our games are always like, "Okay, we'll get you doing the thing and doing the thing's not hard, but like master." It's like it's that stupid trope of like it's it's easy to learn, hard to master. And everybody says that about their games or whatever, but I'm like I believe that in flatter games, right? If you look at a game like Cascadia, right? Like it's
like you can play Cascadia like pretty competitively, but like you can you can also just like easily easily get into that game. Same thing with Calico. Like David Yeti and I did a lot of the development on that game and like full disclosure like the solo scenarios and challenges are way too hard on that because like the two of us were just like pros at the game and we're like oh yeah we'll do this challenge and it'll be like you have to score 70 points and there's like so many people that are just like Calico I can't get past challenge number two or whatever. And so like with Cascadia, I think we we fixed that a little bit. But like it was one of those things where like I love that our games can be so easy to get into, but if you really want to like play them competitively like we get to in our dev sessions where we really get into it and we've played it a million times,
it has that ability and depth. And so I think perennial is still a puzzle that is like really scratching my itch even though I'm played it hundreds
so many
many times hundreds of times now already. So
and what what's the date that that launches?
September 15th.
All right. So this this will be out before then. Uh go follow it. There is a link down below for sure.
Um the last thing that I want to ask you is an impossible question but in five years what does success look like for Flatout Games? I would say, you know, like that a handful at least of games are are still in print, you know, headed toward I mean Cascadia is probably in an evergreen.
Cascadia for sure will continue to be
and then um that you know the handful of things that we're working on now. We've got some really interesting 2027 releases, 2028 releases, and 2029 even releases we are very excited about.
Wow, you're looking that far out. 2029. Okay, cool.
Yeah, the pipeline is full.
So, you're not signing games at all.
That's on our regular kind of track. And then of course uh I would hope that um Whisper Stone is much beloved and finds its place its like rightful place in a world of role playinging um in the role playinging world and has you know a handful of more adventures coming for people to keep keep adventuring. Yeah.
How many games are you putting out a year in five years? Same.
Same.
Three. Three to four. Three to five.
Yeah, I think so.
Sean, what about you? What's What's success look like?
I think success looks like us just still getting to make games with our friends and incredible.
It's much more heartfelt like
Yeah. I mean, success is just being able to still um get a group of people together that are excited and passionate about a thing and um just like having like I said, we get to make art and people can like get to play it and appreciate it and just support us in doing what we're doing. So, I mean, I just I hope that in five years we're still able to say that that's the case like it is now. So, that's That's the aspiration is to just keep on um making things that people love hopefully.
Yeah, we're almost at 10 years now. So, which is crazy.
Yeah. Can you believe that? I know. When I was doing the math, I was like, "Wait, yeah, you guys have almost been doing this 10 years. That's that's quite an accomplishment."
And then five more years. Like 15 years. It's a good run.
Yeah. Well, I've already taken too much of your time. I and I still have about a half a page full of questions here, but this has been so awesome. Uh, and when I started doing uh interviews, interviewing you all were was absolutely on my list. And I'd always been sad that as a reviewer, when I used to review games a lot that I'd never connected because I'm up here in the Pacific Northwest. So, we have to get together. I'd love to play some games with you sometime, play test, whatever it is. Let me know if there is ever an opportunity because I am there.
That sounds great. Yeah,
beautiful.
Let's make it happen.
Thank you very much and have a good night. The lights are almost out where you are. So, um, you know, we got to Yeah, we we took it all the way down to the end. So, thank you very much and we'll have to do it again.
Part two. Yeah. Thanks for having us. This is
awesome. Thank you so much. Have a great night.