Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Simultaneous Action Selection Board Games - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 16:07

Hey everybody, today I'm talking about my top 10 simultaneous selection games. Now, I really like simultaneous selection games because I think it reduces down time. It has natural tension as you're trying to get into the mind of your opponent. They're trying to do the same and you're trying to just counteract each other and get the get the best of them. So, if you don't know what I'm talking about with simultaneous selection, I think the best way to describe it is something like paper, rock, scissors where you're both doing things exactly the same time and trying to get one up on your opponent as I said and I'm trying to read their mind and benefit. So, uh let's get started number 10 and I'll talk through some great games. So, at number 10 I have Flamme Rouge. Now, Flamme Rouge is a it's a cycling game based or a racing game based on the um on the uh Tour de France. So, you are basically taking the role of two different um cyclists and um you are trying to win the race. So, um this game has some very cool elegant mechanisms in it and one of them is the simultaneous card play. So, what everyone's going to do is they're going to have a a hand of cards or a deck of cards and everyone's got the exactly the same same cards.

And everyone's going to flip and choose a card at the same time and um that's going to decide how far they move along the track. But, the the important thing about this is that the track is so narrow that only two cyclists can get on or or depending on the expansion you can maybe up to three or even one um can get be in a certain spot at once. So, you have to predict about you know, is that spot going to be free when I get there? Um is my opponent going to be faster than me in order to squeeze in there first? Um it also has this very cool kind of a slipstreaming mechanic where you can get away with playing lower cards as long as there's only one gap between you and the racer in front of you, you can actually just get a free bit of movement in order to catch up with them. Very thematic. Um there's a great tension about us getting knocked out of these spaces because if you both share the same spot, then you're going to waste movement and get pushed back and back in the queue. Um so, yeah, you're going to think about what other players going to play, try and just get as much mileage as you can out of those cards.

And um just yeah, just be as efficient as you can with as little as you can. And uh yeah, that that tension of getting knocked out the spots is really there. It can be very frustrating, but it can also be very rewarding if you uh get away with it. So, that's my number 10, Flamme Rouge. Uh at number nine, I have Raptor. Now, Raptor is quite an unusual game. Um it's an abstract style game where again, both players Well, it's a strictly two-player game, and both players um have a deck of cards. Now, one player is representing a family of dinosaurs where you got a mother dinosaur and um a bunch of little baby dinosaurs, and the other team is scientists. And um you're going to play these cards numbered from one to nine at the same time. And whoever plays the higher card gets to take the action on that card, um which can be very important, give you powerful kind of special abilities. But, the person who plays the lower card gets to take action points, um depending on the difference between the two. And they can use those action points in order to kind of move around the board or pick up the dinosaurs if you're if you're the scientist and try and get them off the board cuz you're trying to do, I don't know, experiments on them and stuff.

But, if you're the dinosaur, you can use those action points in order to um you know, in order to uh basically eat the scientists. So, uh yeah, it's got a very cool thematic game, especially for an abstract, and the tension is there based on the cards. You don't want to give your opponent too many action points, but you still want to use your most powerful abilities. So, yeah, it's it's that good kind of tension between the two, and then you got to get into the mind of your opponent. So, uh a nice game, that is Raptor. At number eight, I have Shogun. Now, Shogun is a um is an area control kind of Euro-style game. Um not not too much hype about this one, but I do really like it. But, what I like about the simultaneous part of the game is that um you basically draw four cards, and you choose to put these cards in pairs. And um at the same time, you and your opponent are going to reveal those two cards. And um the cool thing about it is that the the cards don't only represent the ability you take on the turn, but they also represent the initiative you take on the turn. And initiative is so important in this game because you want to get into the actions that you want to do first, otherwise your opponent can get locked out of those spots or they can have to pay you to get into the spots.

And just that that tension of who's going to go first and when is very important and that's why I think this game gets onto this top 10 because that that simultaneous action tension is just it just does shine through quite nicely. So that's Shogun, my number number eight. At number seven, I have Not Alone. Now Not Alone is a one versus all style game where one person controls this kind of alien being and everyone else are these different like marine type characters. And basically you are trying to the good guys or not the aliens are working together to try and get off the planet and the alien is trying to catch them before before they do. So what you do in this game is that every all these kind of marine players are going to try and choose a card in their hand and that decides what location they're going to go to. But the alien is trying to kind of think where the marines are going to go. So they're kind of trying to you know put a token on where they think the um where they think they're going to go to and they're going to catch maybe two or three people at the same time. But the cool thing about this is that all the different marines don't know where they're going to go or don't know where each other are going to go. So they're trying to get into each other's head, maybe try and spread out as much as they can. Sometimes you'll find they'll go to the same place at the same time where the alien is so they'll get caught all at the same time. But it has a great tension to it and it just works really well. So that's Not Alone.

At number six, I have 5211. Now this is a very simple card game where you are trying to get as much kind of points as you can from these cards. And the mechanisms are very simple cuz you had have a hand of five cards and then you play two cards simultaneously, play one card simultaneously, and then play another card simultaneously. And basically you're trying to um get the most cards of a certain color in front of you in order for those points to score. But as I said, you cuz the cards getting paid simultaneously, you don't know what's going to be the majority all times because uh you know, some people just might all of a sudden just catch up with you straight away. Um but you can also have this really cool mechanism where you can kind of force other other colors to get bust because if you go over a certain limit of colors, that color won't score. And also if you tie on colors, then the next color or the next color down will score.

So you can use that kind of simultaneous play to not only work in your favor, but in all in order to really shoot other players kind of points down. Um and just thinking about what other players are going to do is clever because you might think, "Oh, I've got I've got five cards here. I can get away with another one and I'll score loads of points." But then you don't know what everyone else is going to do because they might also play a card and make you bust. So you got to think, you know, am I just going to play it safe as I am? Am I going to push my luck and go a bit further? Um and stuff like that. So and because it's all happening at the same time, you've got to really do plan or think about what other players are going to do and not be too greedy. So that simultaneous kind of action works really well with 5211. At number four, I have Libertalia. Now Libertalia is probably one of the most interactive um games in terms of the simultaneous play. It's basically the the key mechanism of this game is the simultaneous action selection. So everyone's going to have an identical set of cards um based on these different pirates on this crew and um they're not only numbered from um forgive me, I don't know the numbers. I think they go quite high, but they've also got um abilities on them.

So everybody's going to play a choose a card at the same time and play them and um then they're going to activate on the ship in a certain order all their abilities. So they could be maybe knock out the person in front of the queue, or they could be steal money off someone else, or take a x amount of money. But then the cool thing is is that after all the abilities have been resolved, then the person who's the highest number still in the ship gets to take loot um at first choice. So yeah, there's there's kind of two different mechanisms where not only do you want the power on the card, but you also want the number on the card as well in order to get the best loot. And just the synergies between the cards are so so clever. Um but you know, by people playing certain cards and you playing a different type of card, um you know, nice and cool things can happen. And I'm just throw people off off kind of track and what they want to do just based on the card that you played. So yeah, very interesting um you know, simultaneous play on this one. Um the only thing that stops it from being right at the top of the list is there's a bit of take that in the game that I don't quite like, but um other than that it's a fantastic game. That is uh Libertalia.

Um at number four, I have a very simple game with Six Nimmt. Now this is definitely the um the lightest game on this list. Um but it's probably um you know, the easiest to get to the table. It's the quickest. And um again, that simultaneous play is the key mechanism on that. And um it's what the game's all about. It plays lightning quick and it takes about 10 minutes to play um if you play one round that is. Um basically you have a hand of 10 cards um numbered from either I think it goes from one all the way up to um I think it's like 105 or something. Um and what you're going to do is you're going to play a card simultaneously with everyone else and they're going to get when you reveal them in chronological order, they're going to be put on these one of four different rows of cards. Um and basically you're trying to squeeze in between um the difference between a card and your card, and they'll go in numerical order. But as soon as the seventh card of a row goes down, then you'll take all the existing cards on that row as a negative points because each card has a bull's head on them. And those bull's heads are what you don't want because they count as your negative points at the end of the game. And so you've got to really think about what other players are going to play.

Um know when to bite the bullet and take a row by playing a lower card, or can you get away with just squeezing in somewhere, but someone might just squeeze in before you mean meaning that you have to take the whole row. It's an extremely fun game and um definitely one of the best filler games I've played. Um I'd recommend this one to anybody at all cuz it's such good fun. The strategy is light um and very simple, but again constantly engaging and just laugh out loud moments with 6 Nimmt. At number three, I have For Sale. Uh For Sale is another filler game. Um this is uh one that I rate extremely highly. Um I've played this game to death. Um probably my most played game of all time. Um it's a game where you are buying properties at first first uh in an auction phase and then the second half of the phase you're trying to sell those properties um for the most profit possible. And that is where the simultaneous play comes in because once you've got your kind of a portfolio of properties in your hand um based on these cards, um a number of cash checks are put down on the on the table um in uh in numerical order for from most expensive to the cheapest.

And everybody is going to choose a um a property from their hand and they use a number from one to 30 and um we all do it at the same time. And then whoever's played the highest card gets to take the highest check and whoever's played the lowest card or the second highest takes the second highest check and so on. Um but there's some real contention in there because of the the huge gaps between the paychecks. So you might really think that, you know, I'll play my 25 and really go for that bigger check, get that 15,000, but the next check down is only 8,000. So um you know, if someone plays that 26, then they'll get the biggest check and I'll jump all the way down to an 8,000. So instead of doing that, do I choose to play a lower check in order to just get the the third prize and um just, you know, get a get a reasonable profit in return. So the tension is extremely um extremely fun and palpable in this one.

Um there's a great amount of player interaction as players just jump in just before you, meaning that you get shafted and get a rubbish return on your best properties. Uh just tremendous fun and um extremely light family fun game um again that I'd recommend to anybody because it's so accessible. That's For Sale. At number two, I have uh probably the biggest most sprawling game on this list with Rising Sun. Now, uh the simultaneous play in this game is a much different to all the other games I've mentioned in this one because this is uh quite a I say a small part, but it's a it's a fraction of what the game consists of. It's basically the combat mechanism because in this game uh in order to resolve a combat cuz this is a an area control game uh based in feudal Japan, but the combat system is is simultaneous. So, you have a screen and behind that screen you have like an action board uh made up of different actions.

And uh simultaneously you and whoever's fighting over this region is going to bid their coins that they've accumulated throughout the game on these different action spaces. And whoever's bid the most on these action spaces will get to pick that ability. And they're resolved in um in a kind of an order and the order is extremely um important. And because they're done at the same time, you really do have to think about what your opponent is going to bid on so that you can kind of trump them. Um so, basically what will happen is first off that the you know, whoever's bid the most on kind of sacrificing themselves will will kill themselves and they'll get victory points for each kind of troop they've killed because it's supposed to be honorable in order to do so. Um so, and and if someone's bid alternatively after that, then they kind of wasted all their money because they're not fighting anything. So, yeah, it's this really cool cool mechanism where and the tension is extremely um you know, it's really raw because not only do you have to focus on this fight, you have to focus on the fights that are going on after it.

So, you again getting into the head of your opponent is so so important in this one and I'm just thinking logically about what they're going to do and I've sometimes they might do the complete opposite but I think for a combat system I think it's so innovative and different and it just adds a whole new dimension into into a game like this. So yeah, Rising Sun is my number two. And finally at number one I have Tikal T'aukan. Tikal T'aukan is an awesome simultaneous selection game. It's a very social negotiation style game where everybody takes the role of corrupt politicians. They have a hand of identical cards or every player does. And you are going to play the one of these cards every round in order to decide what action you're going to take. So the get the premise of the game is that there's going to be a president and they're going to divvy up a certain amount of cash cards amongst all the different players however they see fit.

They can give all the money to themselves if they wanted, they give it all to another player or spread it evenly. And then once they've kind of settled on what they want to do, everyone is going to play one of these cards at the same time. You can bluff and lie to each other about what you're going to do. So these different actions are such as vote to keep the president in power, vote to kick the president out of power, you can choose to skim money off the treasury which is important because if you're the first in player order to do so then you get more money. You can choose to kind of bribe other players and you can choose to blackmail people as well which is so important because you can put your little private detective in front of people and kind of threaten them and then they probably think in your action turn they're going to you're going to play the blackmail action. But again if they play the counter blackmail action then they counter blackmail you. So it really is a kind of a multi-dimensional game of of paper rock scissors and the the kind of the bluffing and the interaction and negotiation is so great in in relation to a simultaneous selection because you can really pull the wool over players eyes.

You can try and lobby for their support and just try and just try to be as corrupt as you can, and it's just so much fun, and I'm definitely the best simultaneous action selection game that I own. Um this version here is not readily available anymore, um but it has been reprinted in a different theme um called Good Critters, so I'd highly recommend it and pick it up if you can because it is an absolute gem of a game um that I'd recommend to anybody. And um just constantly engaging, and the player interaction is fantastic. So, that concludes uh my top 10 simultaneous selection games, and I hope you've enjoyed it. Um again, I love this mechanism and um always willing to try a game that includes uh simultaneous selection in. So, if you have enjoyed the video, please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos, too. For Evan and I, see you next time on Chairman of the Board. Bye.

Progress saved