Top 10 Solos YOU Like More than Me (Follow Up Video)
Transcript
Two weeks ago, I made a video about the top 10 solo board games I like more than the majority of people based on the 2025 BoardGameGeek's People's Choice Top 200 solo games list put out by the One Player Guild. I'll put a link to my video and the People's Choice list in the description below. You should check them both out. Today, as a quick follow-up video, I'm using the People's Choice list again, this time to run down the top 10 solos you like more than me. To be specific, these are top 100 games for the people that do not appear in my personal top 100 solos list. That doesn't mean I hate these games. Let me be crystal clear about that. Most of them, I think, are good games. They just aren't great games for me for a variety of reasons.
Number 10 is the Zombicide series of games. This was 99 on the People's Choice list, which is a surprise to me. I believe that this includes all the games in the series. So, maybe the newer ones are a little bit better solo. I've only played the original Zombicide and Zombicide Black Plague. Black Plague is much better than the original and, you know, it's fun for what it is, but I didn't really enjoy it solo. For me, it's much better as a multiplayer game. Get three or four players together. It's a real beer and pretzels kind of co-op experience. The problem is you just have to control too many characters when you're playing solo. A lot of times you need a cast of characters and I didn't find it very fun to control all of them.
The setup and the game length is a little bit long for what it is. You know, there's not that much depth there. And back in the original, and even Black Plague, there are some strange rules that I think that they updated for the newer releases, which I haven't played, but I just found the whole thing to be a little overblown with all the minis and everything when the gameplay is so simple and straightforward. With a group of friends, that can be fun, but by yourself, I want something a little deeper or maybe something a little bit quicker and simpler to set up. Number nine is the 7th Continent. This was number 94 on the people's list. Now, this seems like a game that I should love, right? I love survival and I love exploration. And honestly, there's a ton of different ideas and mechanisms in the 7th Continent that I really enjoy. Lots of cool little innovations, but unfortunately, exploration just didn't work for me in this game.
I saw someone online call this game a slog, and honestly, I think that's the best word for what I felt. It just felt like a slog. As I was playing this, I felt lost and directionless, even though there seemed to be a right direction that I needed to go. Maybe I was just missing something obvious, you know, that's always possible, but I didn't feel excited to turn over the next location. I felt frustrated. And also, the survival elements didn't quite work for me, either. It felt really oppressive, and it really slowed the game down. I also wasn't really compelled by the story and the mystery. Like, that alone was not driving me forward enough. Now, maybe with some more plays, you know, it would all start to come together. I haven't played this a ton, so that's always possible, and that's going to be something that's going to come up on this list a lot. And I'm always going to mention it, you know, I like to play things a lot before I give a firm, concrete declaration of my opinion of it. But so far, all I've felt is a slog that I'm not really itching to return to.
Number eight is the Legendary series. This was number 91 for the people. So, I'm going to repeat what I just said for 7th Continent. I have not played this series very much. Like Zombicide, I I've only played Legendary Encounters Alien and I've played a little bit of Predator as well, and that's it. So, I'm far from exploring this series completely. Never played any of the Marvel stuff and there's a ton of it. I also haven't played any of this in a really long time. So, this one's definitely more my fault than the game. I have no question that this is a great deck-building game. I think one of the problems is I came to this series pretty late. Like it had already been going for a while and there were so many other deck-building games that were out and that I had already played. I remember liking this. I remember thinking it was, you know, a good deck-builder. At the end of the day, this one just fell through the cracks and I'm not really sure why. It's definitely one that I want to return back to and give it another try.
Number seven is Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon. This was number 60 on the people's list. I had very similar issues with this one as I had with The 7th Continent. Again, this could be on me, but I found this game so frustrating. First of all, the thing that it's praised for is its story. I personally didn't really care much for this story. This dark retelling of the Arthurian myths or whatever, that really doesn't do it for me. I can understand why other people like it, but, you know, it's just not my thing personally. And then once again, the gameplay here felt like a slog again. The exploration was not interesting to me. The combat system was okay, but, you know, it's like this diceless system.
But, the result of that is that everything is taking a little longer. It's just adding to that slogging feeling. I was putting a lot of work in and not getting very much back in terms of the gameplay. This is another one that I need to return to. These first impressions that I got were maybe not correct. Maybe I was missing something. Maybe the game opens up after a while and it gets better. Again, I'm going to put this one on me, but I do remember playing this several times for many hours. I shelved it and I haven't felt the need to get it out since. Number six is Scythe. This is 56 on the people's list and I love Scythe as a multiplayer game. I think Scythe is a really fun game. I've not played like all the expansions and everything like that, so I haven't like fully explored it, but if we're just talking just the base game, I think it's great, but playing it solo, I'm just missing the other players. I really want to have four players to play Scythe. I think that opens the game up and makes it much more interesting. The solo mode is great and it's like, you know, if you're just going to play solo, then Scythe is worth playing solo. I'm not saying that it's a bad solo game, but it's just one of those that I like the multiplayer so much more. I just don't feel like playing it solo. I just think it loses too much at that player count.
And that just comes back to the fact that, you know, I play games both ways. I play solo, I play multi. You know, there's plenty of games where I say, "Yeah, I'm just going to keep this one just for multiplayer play." Even though the solo is fine, I have so many other solo games I could play, I'll just play those. And there's some multiplayer games that I prefer solo and so I just play them solo and don't play them with other players. So, Scythe kind of falls in that camp for me and that's why it doesn't quite make my top 100 solo games list. Although, it's pretty close. Number five is Nemo's War. This is number 45 for the people. I get a lot of flak for not putting Nemo's War, I have the second edition, uh, on my lists, you know, various different lists. It's constantly getting mentioned by people. So, this is obviously a really beloved game. It's in the top 50 for the people. I'm always really up front with the fact that I need to play this one more. This is another one of those games where I've played it a handful of times, but I don't think that's enough. I think I need to play it some more.
And this is a funny one because I think I feel about Nemo's War the way that a lot of players feel about Robinson Crusoe. And this is what gives me pause to say too much negative stuff about Nemo's War because obviously Robinson Crusoe is my favorite game of all time, and I'm always telling people "Ah, you just don't understand it. You need to play it more, you know, there's stuff going on that's counterintuitive." But all the things that Robinson Crusoe does that I think is so interesting, like the fail forward design and the dice mitigation and the push your luck aspect of the dice. Some of that is in Nemo's War, but not nearly enough. And to me, the dice feel much more oppressive and much more punishing. I feel like I have less agency. Now, I get that's what people say about Robinson Crusoe also.
But to me, when I was playing Nemo's War, the dice weren't working for me. It felt like an old design. Where to me, Robinson Crusoe feels as modern and and new and innovative as ever, Nemo's War felt a little bit stale. But look, I'm open to the fact that I could be wrong about that. You know, just the way I feel that people are wrong about Robinson Crusoe, I might be wrong and just need to play it more, explore it more, you know, see the nuances. I don't know. I'm sure I'll hear about it in the comments. Number four is the 20 Strong series. It's a huge surprise for me cuz this comes in at a whopping 36 on the people's choice list. 36th best solo game of all time. Now, to be fair, there's a lot of 20 Strong out there.
I've only played like the first two boxes, and I haven't played a ton of it. And I like it. I think it's a it's a really fun dice game. I love the form factor. It's all really compact and, you know, travelable. The different boxes mix up the rules, so, you know, there's quite a bit of replayability. So, I I see the appeal. The themes are not doing it for me. The idea of setting these within other board games, you know, like in the worlds of other board games or whatever they're doing, eh, you know, that's not as interesting to me as say like what Unmatched is doing. Like those Unmatched themes are awesome. You know, a variety of cool IPs with just different historical characters or fictional characters that are out there. That's that's neat. Setting a dice game in the Too Many Bones universe, yeah, whatever. So, maybe that's where it's losing me a little bit, but, you know, ultimately, this would still be a top 150 solo game for me. So, you know, it's not that far off, really. It just doesn't quite crack the top 100. I suspect this will probably drop down the people's choice list in time. But, who knows? Who knows?
Number three is Nusfjord. The people have this at number 29, and this is another one I hear about a lot. I like Nusfjord, but there are just so many other Rosenberg games that I put above it. Obviously, I put A Feast for Odin above it. I think the people do as well. But, I prefer At the Gates of Loyang solo. I prefer Hallertau solo. I prefer Aranian Burger Canal solo. And I think I even prefer Glass Road {slash} Black Forest solo. There's just something about Nusfjord that I find kind of dry and dull and a little bit repetitive. For some reason, and again, I can't like articulate it perfectly, but just for some reason, this one hits me in that way, and the rest of Rosenberg games don't. You know, it's hard for me to put my finger on exactly what it is. I mean, it can't be the theme because, you know, Rosenberg themes are kind of dull and dry as it is. There's something about the actions.
It's something about the special abilities. They just aren't doing it for me for some reason. But, it is a relatively quick game. It's easy to set up. So, I I can see the appeal. Clearly, I'm in the minority on this one. Number two is Aeon's End. The people have this at number 15, and boy, oh boy, have I heard about this one. I really want to stress this up front. I don't think Aeon's End is a bad game. I think it's a good game. I've enjoyed playing it the few times that I have. To be clear, I think I haven't played the original. I think I played War's Eternal. That was called War Eternal, the stand-alone expansion. I I came to this game really late. It had already had like 50 expansions and was huge. My expectations were extremely high, and I think this is part of the problem. And, you know, that's my fault, but I do think I came in with my expectations too high, and I was a little disappointed.
Like I said when I was talking about Legendary, at this point, I'd already played hundreds of deck builders and probably hundreds of cooperative games and maybe even dozens of cooperative deck builders. It was a game in a very crowded field, and it just didn't do anything for me that I found very exciting. I didn't find the world to be all that interesting. I'm sure there's a lot of lore and story, but just from a surface level, it seemed a little generic to me. I wasn't loving the artwork either. So, I didn't really have anything like that to hook on to. And then, the gameplay felt a little bit standard or like I had seen that before. It wasn't bringing enough new to the table for me. You know, the fact that you don't shuffle your deck wasn't that exciting. I didn't find the boss battling all that engaging. I'm going to say it again though, I need to play it more. Maybe if I readjust my expectations and give it a little bit more experience then I'll start to see the nuance and it'll grow on me. Right now, it's one of those games that I know is really good but I have all these other games that I just like more and I don't know, that sort of thing just happens sometimes.
And my number one game that you love that I don't is Terraforming Mars. Terraforming Mars is maybe the one game that I'll probably never play again. All of these other games I'd happily play again. In fact, some of them I'm going to make a point to play again to just give it a fair shot. Terraforming Mars I've played a ton. I've played it solo. I've played it multiplayer. I've played the digital version. I actually played it when it first came out and there was all of this hype around it. Right away, I was like, "Eh, it was fine." I was never on the hype train for this one. Part of it is I think it's just too long. I don't think it's very good unless you play with the variant where you're drafting the cards each round and that just makes it even longer. I know they came out with expansions that were supposed to fix that. I haven't really played any of the expansions. I also found the rhythm of the game to be off.
Just like the way the turns work, taking one or two actions and you're drafting these cards and then you're only keeping a certain number of them. It's just the whole thing felt really clunky. The tableau building was just kind of a mess. It was just a mess of cards and resources. I think it looks hideous. It's a bad production. And then the shared kind of building up of Mars wasn't that interesting to me. I remember that uh Great Western Trail came out at around the same time as Terraforming Mars, and I was a big Great Western Trail fan. That's the game I really wanted to play. I mean, it's nothing like Terraforming Mars, but they just sort of came out at around the same time, and it seemed like I was the only one that was into Great Western Trail, and everyone else was into Terraforming Mars. So, I've always been a little out of step on this one.
The last nail in the coffin was when Ark Nova came out. Now again, they're not the same game, but they fill the same box for me. I would never play Terraforming Mars when there's Ark Nova. I would choose Ark Nova 10 out of 10 times, 100 out of 100 times. I also have no desire to be at all affiliated with the designer and publisher and their beliefs and their use of AI and all that nonsense. But, taking all of that out, just looking at the games, it's still just one that I've never really been into the way that the public is. Yeah, that's my number one. You'll never see it on any of my lists, Terraforming Mars. So, there you go. 10 games that you love that I only like or don't really like that much.
In the comments, let me know if there are any games that everyone seems to love that you don't. And also, which game on here would you most like for me to give a second chance to? I'll try to do just that in a future video. Well, there we go. That's all for me. I'd like to thank all the financial supporters of Totally Tabled, including the totally radical Hextra, John Kohler, Scott Myers, Kevin Qualls, and Jay Satterwhite, as well as the totally bodacious Melinda Humphreys. If you're interested in becoming a member, you can join on YouTube or my Patreon at www.patreon.com/totallytabled. You'll gain access to my new exclusive podcast Table Talk, as well as unboxing videos, and whatever extra stuff I come up with. As always, thank you so much for watching, and goodbye.