Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 22:33

hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today in this uh video I wanted to talk about kind of off the cuff another top 10 list here these are the top 10 games that I would love to return to now I have a set criteria for what I mean by this because for the most part I'm pretty willing to go and and play any game with anyone but if I had the chance and the opportunity to play some of these games these I think would be at the top of my list now here's the reason why and this is kind of like a a mirror to the top 10 most underrated games I thought of some of the games that I've really enjoyed in that episode where they were rated above you know 1,000 on Board Game Geek and I decided to look at games that I've played on Board Game Geek already and have rated at least a seven out of 10 and as you can see here uh so games that I've rated is 7 out of 10 already after one or two plays two plays at most and games that I am not able to play regularly either because I either don't own the physical version of the game there are exceptions to this of course on this list uh there is no way to play it digitally which is a little bit easier for me to do once again there are some exceptions here too but I yeah so I filtered the my collection on Board Game Geek or at least when it says collection the games that I've played and came up with these 10 and so these aren't in any particular order some some of these games that you will see first I think I

have rated a seven out of 10 and they progress up to an eight out of 10 so let's get into it so the first one on the list is going to be Woodcraft so this is a uh Vladimir sui game co-designed by O Ross Arnold uh back in 2022 and I should mention too there are a lot more games I probably could have mentioned a an honorable mention but I wanted to bring up some games that I haven't talked about in a while on on the channel or podcast but I did Cover Woodcraft a while back back in I think 2022 when it came out but this was the game that preceded evacuation which is definitely on the honorable mentions list but I really enjoyed Woodcraft for its Euro style mechanisms of resource management uh action management over this Tableau or sorry this rondelle which was very interesting uh making the choice very similar to games of suis make such as praga where choosing a tile that is listed uh you know in a certain area if if it has been chosen for a while you get bonus resources uh if not you have to pay them and when you do choose one you slot them into a a new slot around the tab or around the Rondell making it a little its placement a little bit uh more strategic and forward thinking and you essentially are using these resources in the form of dice which are not rolled but the Pips on the dice can be uh representing of

different resources and they will be uh say you know if if you're cutting like a wood example in the game uh you'd be cutting them in half and and thus splitting the dice into two different Pips on or on two different dice with the sum value of what it was before and so I really like that aspect of keeping track of resources with dice I'm normally not a big fan of say dice action selection or mitigation but I thought it was really clever how it was handled in this game normally I've noticed that these sui games recently such as kaga and missina 1347 have been uh available on websites such as uh yucata.de and praga I believe is still in alpha or maybe it's in beta on board game arena and so I'm very hopeful that at some point Woodcraft will become more available to play so moving on to the next one is dead reckoning I also did cover this on the podcast and that was my last play of it this is a John declair game from 2022 as well and in this game it's a highly thematic game where you are commanding a fleet and a ship roaming the Seas and it utilizes the deck building of Mystic Veil to handle if I can find a good picture of this to handle your Fleet um and so while you're deck building your hand and giving your crew asymmetric abilities you are roaming

around uh this is the combat as well you're roaming around a map of the island and trying to score victory points in certain ways and in diverse ways as well and so I I really like the fact that in this game you are trying to do things that are different every time uh some things will be a little bit easier to accomplish than others they're all widely thematic such as gaining treasure or gaining influence in different Islands um and fighting as well and and making sure that you uh show that you are the strongest in the seas and so if you meet a certain number of criteria by the end of the game you have triggered the end of the game and you score your points and so I find it very I found it very similar to how games such as terraforming Mars are decided by the end of the game where you are trying to uh fulfill certain milestones and and achievements in the form of terraforming Mars which is uh variable in how the game ends but can alter your Pursuit and your route to triggering the end of the game and hopefully getting as many victory points as you can by following that route and so I really enjoyed that aspect of this game um I I have thought about buying it actually and that's why it makes it on to this list because I think my friends would enjoy this more thematic approach to uh a heavier you know 3 almost 3.5 weight game but I really enjoy dead r and hope to play it again soon another game that I covered last year on the podcast was unconscious mind

this was being kickstarted at the time and I demoed it on tabletop simulator uh you've got a bunch of these designers here creating a game where you are simulating the the uh friends and Associates of Freud back you know in the 1800s treating patients and learning about Psychotherapy and so it's got an element of say you know patient care that I do enjoy and uh can relate to as as a physician myself but I really enjoyed this game because even though there is kind of a you know a mash of different uh Euro style mechanisms in play I felt that they came together really well and in a thematic way with the your own tblo uh not only keeping track of the patients that you are treating and helping through their dreams but also to kind of keep track of different benefits and kind of your asymmetric specialty in in treating these patients as well uh some of that especially this this portion of the board kind of felt like uh actually wingspan in the form of creating uh your Tableau and and expanding it to activate it multiple times as you go around it and so building out that Tableau to kind of give you a p sudo engine to activate every time very is very reminiscent of um Wings spam and so to me this game kind of felt like a wingspan esque game with the action selection and and Tableau activation but in a theme and an

overall weight complexity that offered a little bit more than say a wingspan type of game does and so I really enjoyed my play of this I'm pretty sure that this is coming out soon and will be in backer's hands I I did not back this game myself but I really am hopeful that this game is well supported and can be more widely available soon the art is great and fantastic as well so yeah that is unconscious mind next is Village so this is a 2011 game by Inca and Marcus brand now this game Harkens back to the types of games that I've really come to enjoy such as agrica and other games mostly from Rosenberg from about 10 to 13 years ago or so and in this game you're kind of doing some of those similar mechanisms where you are utilizing worker placement to take actions that are spread out throughout this Village in in different forms uh resource collecting and fulfilling objectives as as you go along but at the same time your villagers end up growing up and becoming old and passing away and they be and they will be uh interred in the cemetery in the village cemetery and so this game tries to simulate the passage of time with the workers that you have and you try to build on the experiences of your former workers and it almost kind of tells a

story in and of itself while being married to a bunch of Euro style mechanisms and gameplay and so I really enjoyed this game I'm surprised that it hasn't had any digital format as far as I'm aware of uh implemented for itself and so I'm I would love to see this game get that support and I know there is an expansion to this as well I might have played it at the time you know back when I when I did play it um with that expansion but I really enjoyed it I I like I like the concept of it and I would want to return to it to see if it still holds up mechanically for me today uh as I believe I played this before I started the podcast and so I would love to revisit Village next is nucleum so nucleum is no stranger to many people's uh lists and awareness this is a g G from last year that is doing quite well for itself it's already 281 a game by Simone luani and David tury this game is marketed as a a mesh between brass and barrage whereas I feel like most of it as I mentioned on the podcast and channel this game feels a little bit more like brass than it does um barrage but I can see where the elements are in in keeping track of different uh you know ways to score points and trying to make a certain number of achievements which gradually increase from round to round making it harder and harder to do so that element is both seen in barrage as well as in

this game but you've got the route building and resource management and uh uh I guess Central board creation you know by putting your own buildings on onto this building very much in the same way as as uh brass but utilizing the actions that are all unique uh you can see them face up here uh but as you utilize these actions you all must also either choose to use them or to flip them face down to create the routs that you use to interconnect all of these cities and so I really liked the tension and the decision space behind when to use an action for its action or when to use it for uh something that you uh for a route that you want to build out and so I think this game and this game has been well supported recently with already an expansion uh delivered or or published pretty much I think as well as another one that has just been recently announced and so nucleum is here to stay and I hope to continue to explore this game and hope for a chance to do so in the future similarly to an in weight to nucleum is Elbo this is a lrha game as you can see uh by the same designers Michael Kaylor and oday now this game is a heavier re-implementation of L granha which features Tableau building utilizing uh multi-use cards now these multi-use cards feature occupations very

much in a similar way as agrica does but you can use these cards to either use their special ability on or every card has a different combination of farm uh implementations that you can add to grow crops or to keep track of animals or card income or hand size uh and all all the while trying to fulfill objectives which are also listed on these cards now this game in particular changes a few things from the base game of L granha in the form where instead of a Central Market board where you're trying to do some area majority work uh you are advancing up a track and actually in hindsight this uh track advancement with these goats is very similar to the track advance ment in evacuation by sui where you have two goats that you're advancing along this track gaining bonuses all the while and based off of where they are located you know as as close or as far away from each other as possible uh can alter some of the ways that you gain points at the end of the game I think if I remember right and so it has been a while since I demoed this game I really want to return to this game and try it out especially because lagranha is a game that I hold in high regard U I should probably rate this game here too so let's give it a seven for now and I hope to play it again uh very soon and and really dive into it a little bit more to see if the changes are something that I do approve of and enjoy compared

to the base game so that's eluru next is the Guild of merchant explorers this is a Matthew dunon game and Brett uh Gilbert game as well where it's it's a Rolland right that is quick to play yet it offers really bombastic uh play as well where you are exploring this map and placing down your cubes and and ex you know trying to find different areas of this map to create different uh combinations and and collections but you receive these asymmetric player powers in the form of cars which allow you to do uh a great drastic amount of uh different things that feel very uh much like they are breaking the rules and so I really enjoyed how fast this game relatively played it is it was pretty much a 30 to 45 minute game but uh for the weight complexity and the and the time frame I found that this game was really fun and uh I can still remember the play that I had of it uh many years ago I think this was around the time where I started the podcast and talked about it I actually played this with Jacob and so I really yeah I still remember this game and hope that I can play this game again at another point I probably don't have it in my collection because it was pretty expensive for the weight and you know for what the game was it does come in a pretty big box as I've seen before but if yeah if I ever get the chance to play this again I would do so uh so the third to last game here is

war of the Ring the card game I do own this game but I've only played it once and haven't brought it back out yet and I think the reason is is because this game is a little bit different from the variety of games that I typically play which are more Euro based this one is more thematic as a re-implementation of War of the Ring the board game where you are reliving and retelling the story of War of Lord of the Rings through card play and so this game has a lot of hand management and deck management as well you go through pretty much your entire deck maybe once or twice during the game and hopefully grabbing the right cards and playing them at the right time to win uh different areas that are thematic to Lord of the Rings and the books slm mov and trying to win them either uh getting a victory with with a certain amount of points I believe it's 10 uh before your opponent or having 10 more points than your opponent or basically having the most points by the end of the game if it reaches that point and so this game really rewards repeated play I couldn't tell you exactly how this game plays I think I could pick it up fairly easy but not as easily as other Euro games uh because of the mechanisms here they're a little bit different from what I'm usually accustomed to and so I think for that reason I haven't been able to to really dive into it because my game group has been playing other games a wider variety of games rather than returning to this one now recently as of last year this game was uh supported with another expansion as well as a way

to play it solo and so that might be a way for me to play this game in or play this game again and and really see if this game is right for me but um unfortunately it hasn't been a game that I've been able to play a lot of which I think it is a game that you must do so to really enjoy it but hopefully at some point I'll be able to do that and that is war of the Ring the card game now I couldn't help but include roads and boats here again I've talked about this pretty recently um but I I have to throw this on here because this has been one of my favorite splatter games that I've played and one of my favorite games of all time that I've have played recently uh roads and boats really reminds me um speaking of an honorable mention when I I've talked about epic or sorry Epoch uh Clash of cultures the new Jeffrey CCH game that was uh kick started that game gave me Vibes of Age of Empires and one aspect of Age of Empires was the logistical nature of finding a good place to harvest your resources as well as establish trade with uh other uh opponents during the game if you do play that way and this game is that logistical portion of Age of Empires that I really found enjoy able and familiar when I played it in this tabletop uh style of a game and this game is highly interactive uh it's hard to appreciate it based off of what you see here but this game is it's got so many different buildings that you can you can pursue it's got a lot of you

know route building as you can see here by this drawing a lot of interaction where you can use other people's routes to communally build up a wonder which also not only gives you points but uh triggers the end of the game and so yeah this game is is super modular as well because of the map you can try different ways to uh you know rearrange this map and and try to alter the puzzle that you're trying to achieve but it's got so many different um Avenues to to play and to victory that it really reminds me of like a huge kind of tech tree and I don't know it's kind of pictured here but since there are so many buildings that you can pursue to to try to build each with their own little path of how you get there it really felt like like Age of Empires again in other Civilization games where you research different Technologies to try to hone in on a certain strategy each each game and and this game I think based off of how you set up the game can really dictate what you try to accomplish as well as what other people are doing as well and so I yeah I really loved roads and boats and hopefully I this is probably one of the the top games that I would love to try to play uh over and over again if it was in a digital format but finally the last game on this list is on board game arena and so shame on me for not playing this more I have it rated as an 8 out of 10 and that is kis this is a 2005 game reimplemented reimplemented by kis 1303 but this game just shy of the top

100 has been a a huge hit uh for many people and perhaps one of the earliest worker placement games to utilize worker placement in a a modern way that is was very successful and very familiar to players who enjoyed a gria which came out a couple years after but if you aren't familiar with this game what you are doing is you are placing workers out into these different buildings to gain different resources as you would surmise with a worker placement game you have different areas where you can try to focus your efforts on whether it's progressing up with this favor track if I remember right uh to getting you know points there building up the castle as well or purchasing buildings that you can place onto this board so you are essentially expanding the amount of different buildings that you can U utilize during the game for work replacement purposes think of not only Agricola but also laav which kind of has that expanding both games have that expanding worker placement uh aspect to both where your options become more and more available but there's also a hint of Great Western Trail here where you are building out the structures that you would like to utilize in the hopefully in the uh order that you would like to do them so to to activate them because there is some interaction with the Provost uh you can move this Provost in different are in different directions in the game uh hindering the activation of

certain buildings and so there's some interaction there that is I haven't really seen in another worker placement uh straight up Euro type of game which I really enjoy and I I like the variability that you have in building out these different buildings uh some of which are pictured here uh for different you know activation and resources and things like that and so yeah this game really left a great impression on me I've only played it twice but that second play was just really memorable for me on board game arena and so this is something that I probably should get back into and see if I enjoy it even more so yeah those are 10 games that I would love to return to and for whatever reason have not so what do you think of this list let me know if I if in your opinion I should focus on one or more of these games if you have been able to do so yourself and or if there's something I should avoid as well let me know let me know what other games that aren't on this list that you would love to return to but haven't found the time to do so but as always thank you for Consulting with me today hope you schedule an appointment with with me real soon and we'll I'll catch on the next one take care

Progress saved