Skip to main content
Loading video...

Now Playing: Battle for Rokugan, Queendomino, Star Cartel, Harvest Island, Matterhorn

Transcript 20:14

hi welcome to another now playing vlog where I talk about some of the games have been playing lately and what I think of them the games in this video were voted on by my patreon backers if you'd like to help actual law grow bigger and better go to patreon.com/scishow and that's a little bit inspired by diplomacy the reason for that is that you are you control regions and then you are attacking other players but you're placing your markers facedown that will dictate what actions you do so you're bluffing a bit in in terms of where you might be attacking or what actions you might be taking at turn so everyone has loads of these little markers and they draw six at random each round so you are a little bit burdened by the game as to what you can choose and then you will be putting them on the board on different borders and it's quite a clever system very simple to understand if they're on a border they're probably going to be attacking someone else if they're in the middle of a region they're probably going to be defending that region but there are other special actions that can do special cool things there's different numbers with these attack and defense so you don't necessarily know how much somebody's defending whether you're gonna win that attack you're trying to control regions they provide you points at the end of the game you also have a secret objective and so you might be told that you've got to control this

Capitol or you need a different area in each region and the reason that I was interested in this game was because it reminded me a bit of Game of Thrones second edition this is a board game that was one of the first games I really loved a game of negotiation and diplomacy which has the same system of playing tokens facedown and then you reveal and you see what people's plans really were what's so great about Game of Thrones is that you can create alliances with other players and you can talk about what you're going to do you can maybe lie to people say that you're not going to attack them and then you stab them in the back and you do attack them but you can also support people in attack and that's where the a lying really works in Game of Thrones as disappointed the embattled four Roku gun there is no scope for that you can't support someone else in their attack so you never really team up all you can really do just like in risk is have truce make a pact of you know non-aggression that you don't go across this border and and so the you know there's mutually beneficial that if if you hold this line together then then you can focus on other areas because then somebody can backstab you later and change their mind about that pact it doesn't have the same scope for chatting things through going off and having a little chat outside the room that like Game of Thrones I was hoping that this was going to be a streamlined shorter version of that game and it is not sure

to place in about two hours and packs quite a lot into it but it doesn't have that spectacle and the theme and it doesn't tell the stories that I have had from games of Game of Thrones and so I can really appreciate this game it certainly offers some interesting bluffing of trying to work out what other players are gonna do how are you best going to use your tokens for each round and you've got some special abilities there's these cards that you can race to try and get which are controlled by certain regions and you all have to start the game with three special cards which allow you to look at other people's tokens or remove them from the board they're really powerful and so you have to decide the best time to use them there's a lot to like about this game it's a beautifully simple system it packs a lot into a quite a small box it's a breeze to learn the rules and it plays quite quickly in about two hours but for me I wanted I thought I wanted a streamlined version of a bigger game and actually it loses a lot of the flavor and the spectacle and really the things the reasons that I love those games in the first place so I think for the right group this could really sing but for me it didn't really hit the spot that's battle for Roca Gong King Domino is a game that came out a while back and won the spur Yara's it's a super simple gateway game where you are placing Domino tiles and building a kingdom you're trying to

score points by having these crowns in regions and then making the region's bigger and they create multipliers you're trying to get the most points it's a very clever streamlined system I like the way that you pick your domino tiles it's got a really nice production to it looks really nice and yeah I played it a few times and I didn't love it I felt like it didn't have enough to grab me there wasn't enough bite to it it doesn't have the interaction of something like Carcassonne or the interesting decision-making of capital those are both slightly more advanced games and I felt like it's maybe just too beginner for me but it certainly would be good for kids and families and I can appreciate the game it just wasn't one that I needed to own so then Queen Domino came out at the following Essen same designer same idea but adding a bunch of extra ways to make points and so I thought I was going to love it because it is a really clever system maybe if they just added a few more things I would like it and yet Queen Domino hasn't worked for me all of the ideas feel tacked on they don't feel part of the essence of the game they feel like ways to give you alternative strategies different ways to make points for sure you can buy these buildings that allow you to score smaller regions so it's no longer necessarily about having big regions you can simply buy points you have these little workers that tax regions to get the money you use the money to buy the buildings there's a lot more going on and yet none

of it made me feel more excited about the game it's still about selecting those dominoes and having big regions and having crowns and you can get types of points of different ways but the amount of extra rules that it brings in that extra bit of setup more components it's now a much less approachable game and yeah I'm not sure it's rewarded in experience I don't find it to be more fun I just find it to be more of a drag and I'm surprised by that reaction but I am someone that doesn't especially care for the game seven wonders I think that a hand rafting card game is should generally be a light experience I love sushi go and I feel this the that kind of system doesn't work with a deeper more involved game and I just find seven wonders to be not that formatic not that interesting to me I think I can respect it it's not for me and Queen domino it's a little bit similar to that it's almost the seven wonders to king domino sushi go it feels unsatisfying points ala D in the sense that you get two points for that and two points for that and there are a lot of different ways to make lots of little points but it's bitty it doesn't have that war of attrition that you get in Carcassonne where you're fighting out farmers it's where you know

there's real competition it's just trying to H up as many points as you can get and of course that's how a lot of ball games play out it's just not something that really pulls me into again so I think it's full of decisions but just none that I can really get excited about and so for that reason Queen Domino wasn't for me star cartel is a stock market card game with the space theme this is from Osprey games quite a nice production small box that they do those little sizes and it packs quite a lot of game into that small box you have a spaceship and you are trading goods that affecting that stock market and at the end of the game you want to have the most goods in the in the type of good that is scoring the most points at the end so you are affecting how that stock market moves the way you do that is on your turn you take some good so there's five or six different types of goods you'll take some cards put them in your spaceship when your spaceship is full up you have to trade those Goods and that's when you manipulate the market the type of card that you have the biggest set of the bigger and the good with the biggest set you that good will go up on the market the type that you have the smaller set of will go down and then but you don't get to keep any of those cards you'll get discarded you get to keep a middle set which then goes into your stash and that's how you might get points at the end of the game so it's an interesting dilemma where you are affecting Goods prices but you don't get

to keep those goods and so you have to kind of balance it out push them up one turn and then try and get it so it's a middle set and a future turn so you can stash it so you are effectively every time you put up a good you're putting up something that's maybe going to help someone else because they're gonna be stashing it that round there's also a race to improve your ship every time you trade out goods you can you effectively upgrade your ship and so and the ships are worth points themselves which i think is a little bit boring as a way to get points but they also give you special powers and so they give you ways to change the game allow you to trade things slightly differently and that's quite nice one of the surprising things about it as a stock market game is that you don't buy high and sell low you don't ever get to sell out until the end of the game so you're manipulating this market but the relevance of that market is only important at the end of the game and so it will swing around you can crash a stock if it goes too high it will crash back down and you might have been really investing in that so I suppose there's a kind of a timing aspect to it but you just what you're imagine with the stock market game is that you would be able to sell when the time is right and that's just not the case with this but it's a relatively short game and so whilst I think star cartel is nice I think what it does what it's trying to do quite well it's almost it's like it's a bit too long for a

filler game but there are some interesting decisions in there I felt that it wasn't enough fun enough experience for me and there there's certainly some thought to it but the interaction I didn't find to be that interesting it was a bit too long to just consider it a light filler experience and the theme wasn't doing anything for me either so whilst I can't really find like a strong fault with the game that it's imbalanced or or anything like that I just think the it's like so many games that get released these days there are so many six out of ten games and because games are getting better and better and certainly this ones are really nicely produced one with some decent artwork but it doesn't have that x-factor to recommend it above all the other six out of ten games and so it might be something for you if you really like stock market games maybe if you really like space themes but it wasn't one for me that star cartel harvest island is a card game that I picked up at Essen this is from Taiwan and you are planting and growing fruits you are trying to harvest the best crops of fruits you're competing against the other players the way you're doing that is by collecting sets of fruit cards so you're drawing them from that season the game splits up into four different seasons and then you are planting them as seeds into your you've got three different fields and then you are also adding to them to try

and grow the biggest harvest of that type of fruit and there's an interesting push your luck aspect to this game because there is weather that will affect you so the different seasons have different types of weather that are shuffled into the deck and when they come out if three of the same type so if there's three sunshine or three rain that weather is so strong that it either rains out your crops or it kind of it dries them out if there's a drought and so you lose your biggest crop it gets hard and everyone loses that so there's a timing to when you harvest your fruit because if you leave it too long you might lose a lot of stuff and so that's a nice push or like balance of because if you keep pushing on the the fruits that are the most plentiful like bananas then you could get really really big but you don't want to wait too long the other thing is that each different season has a different selection of different fruits in it and it tells you that on the border just quite nice you can really track what's going to be available so of course it's luck of the draw what you get but you can plan oh ok these fruits are only available in the spring and the Sun so I need to harvest quite soon because then I can free up that field for some autumn and winter fruits instead there's interesting decisions to the game in terms of timing and you've got three different fields one can only hold a small amount once like a medium matte or one hat it can hold unlimited so which

fruits you plant in which fields when do you harvest because a harvesting takes up a whole turn so it uses it waste time when you're not picking up cards so you kind of want to harvest everything at once but you also want to keep things growing because if you harvest now you won't get the biggest harvest because that's the thing is you're competing with the other players to have the biggest harvest a different that's one of the best ways to get points in the game so for example if I harvest four bananas I will win the little trophy for bananas and that's a lot of points at the end of the game if somebody else then beats me by growing five bananas later on they steal that trophy off me and so I was stupid to have harvested by bananas so soon and I should have waited and grown it to an insurmountable number and so there's that back and forth with the other players so place for players I felt that it went a bit too long for me the four seasons it's you know a little bit repetitive in this in the sense of you're just doing this set collection and going through and it just it went on maybe sort of 45 minutes to an hour and I would have preferred it a bit shorter certainly in a full player game I think it's an enjoyable game I think it's a good gateway game family game almost what I would describe a good parent game the rules are very simple and approachable it is engaging as an experience but it didn't have that extra bite for me that I was hoping for so

it's a little bit similar to classic set collection games like Arboretum or bonanza but in those games they've got an extra twist in Arboretum it's about placement of of your cards and in bonanza there's trading which I really love harvest island doesn't have anything extra you really just taking the car I suppose there's a bit of push or luck and whilst I think the game is good I just it wasn't quite great for me so I would recommend harvest Island to someone that's looking for a relaxing set collection game it's got really nice artwork and super smooth gameplay but I wouldn't necessarily recommend it to anyone and it wasn't one that I ultimately kept that's harvest Island Matterhorn is a pusher luck dice game that I picked up at Essen this is a relatively small box filler game where you are climbing the mountain of Matterhorn and you have two climbers and on your turn you roll a bunch of dice and you are trying to not go bust and you're trying to get numbers that match the different rows of the mountain and the person who gets both their climbers to the top of the mountain first wins the game so you roll the bunch of dice you can't count any doubles or triples so but what you can do is remove dice to kind of set them aside and so if I have only doubles and triples I can get rid of one then that will free up a number

that I can now use and so you're adding up the dice that are in doubles or triples and that is the number you have so you might get anywhere hopefully between five and twelve and then you put a marker on that spot you can't then roll that number again so you might roll again and get a different number and put that on if you get a number that matches a row that you're on one climber is on you get a free action so that's quite cool you aim for those numbers but as you start to fill up more rows you're gonna be much more likely to go bust and the more you roll them and the more you set aside dice you the dice maybe aren't gonna add up to enough because if you row but if you roll below 5 or above 12 that's another way you can go bus of course if you go bust you lose all your progress so those markers that you put down they represent actions so if you decide ok I'm done let's say I've got three markers down I can then use three actions so I might move move my climbers three spaces that's pretty much what you're gonna do you can move other climbers out the way and you can also remove these obstacles but generally you're going to move your climbers to try and get them up the mountain if you go bust you lose all that progress and it's the next person's turn when you finish your turn your markers turn into obstacles so as the game goes on it becomes fraught with all these trees and avalanches and there's a lot less paths to get up the mountain

and the gameplay is sort of fine it it's reminiscent of the classic push your luck game can't stop because it really is about how many times you want to roll those dice I found it it's it can be quite brutal because of the they can't get the doubles and triples you can get kind of hammered and and also I found it's just a bit too long on a person's turn because there's a bit of extra mass to it and having to work out what you can set aside and then you could potentially go sort of four or five six rolls everyone else is just kind of waiting that wasn't that great the mass aspect I just felt wasn't it didn't make the game that much more enjoyable maybe it'd be good for kids learning addition but it kind of just slowed it down for me I'm not that good at mental arithmetic the game didn't pull us back in it we played it I played it with a bunch of different groups but the first play it's a relatively short game nobody was like oh I want to play that again everyone was kind of done with it so it's a nice production it looks really nice Helvetic this swiss publisher had a load of really beautiful looking games Essen but I'm afraid the gameplay just didn't match and so I wouldn't recommend Matterhorn those were some of the games I've been playing lately I've put links to where you can buy all of them in the description below if you liked this video and you want to

see more in this series then please subscribe to the channel and if you want to help the channel grow bigger and better go to patreon.com/scishow

Progress saved