My Board Game Gripes!
Transcript
wearing the glasses hey everybody today I'm going to be talking about my board game gripes yes controversial hard to talk about I'm someone who doesn't like to rock the boat but this is a video that you might be able to relate to one where there are certain things in the board gaming hobby that could be just a little bit better it would just make the teach and getting into a game so much more smoother so strap on your seat belts everybody because here we go we are going to talk about things that really irritate me in board gaming the first grip that I want to talk about comes from a recent gaming experience one that proved to be a little bit frustrating at the beginning but once we got into the game it was super fun and I thought wow such a small thing that was overlooked by the people who published the game really may have impeded people's enjoyment of the game the game I'm talking about is actually sitting on this shelf here it's called tribes of the wind and in tribes of the wind basically each player has element cards and the backs of the element cards you can kind of exploit when you're playing cards from your little area and
you're basically exploring different Forest tiles sending your wind uh people over to those Forest tiles to build Village and cause a little bit of pollution at the same time but this game is scattered with iconography there's like plus symbols larger than symbols less than symbols forward slash uh icons Galore uh in particular the icons with the people because depending on how many elements that your neighbor has compared to how many you have and whe both neighbors have more or less than you it's this whole mathematical equation of iconography that just really overwhelms you when you're trying to learn the game but actually on your turn all you're doing is playing a temple uh playing a card and that's it if it was literally described like that to me I'd be like H that's pretty easy but scattered with all of these different icons on every card just made this game quite irritating to learn and so my board game gripe with tribes of the wind is not with the actual game itself cuz the game was actually really fun but was the fact that this game did not include a player Aid with all the icons explained on it I had to actually go to board game geek find someone else's player Aid and have it on my phone in order to just get my head around what all these icons me because most of the time in the game you're looking at these icons going what does that do hang on a minute what does that icon do what does that mean again and you're spending all this time
clarifying this when because it's such a pivotal part of the game they could have printed onto four or five cards and then there you go what a much smoother experience and teaching experience this game could have been one of the Glorious things about board games is that when you open one for the first time it's unraveling all of the cool contents inside one of my biggest board game gripes is picking up a giant box like this beautiful one from Santa Monica and then opening it up inside and realizing that when you take away the rule book look how much empty space is inside you could fit an entire midweight Euro in there like seriously look at all this space that's left over and I've even got the long weekend expansion and without the long weekend expansion in here I honestly think this could have been literally a third of the size it is a grip because all of this space here potentially could have been space I could given to another game that's sitting on my shelf at the moment I've got some games sitting on the floor sitting on tops of cupboards I could have easily placed another game there I guess one thing I could do is probably tuck in another game inside the box but yeah just because it's got a really big cover always necessarily mean it's going to have a lot of contents inside in fact I probably paid for a lot of oxygen in this box or a lot of a one of my
favorite things about board games is showing pride in my game collection when people come over I'm really excited to take a game off the shelf and allow them to peruse and look at the game and feel excited about wanting to play it and sometimes when I visit my friends places who also have board game collections I like to Peru their titles and be like ooo this is kind of cool what is this game about and so it kind of starts this really cool conversation of sharing each other's collections one of my biggest gripes is when a game prints things on the side of the box that doesn't really showcase what the game is truly about and it in some ways it kind of hinders the marketing value behind the game itself have a look at this game this game is called far away now it's a game which I tried to put on my shelf but because it's one of those smaller games I often slide games in like this into my shelf look what happens when I slide it in if I slide it in what the the title is upside down this is the lid of the game so am I expected to turn this game around store it upside down so that this is the right way up it kind of looks a little bit funny when the back of the box is on the top and the tile of the box is face down not sure if that's a printing error but the next game is one that is an absolute favorite of mine I love their other games but this game has such a beautiful box cover and I think wow if
you have a cover that looks like this why not take it all the way around the sides of the box or at least to one of the edges of the box but what you get on the edge of the box is a box of text and then on the other side you get another box of text in a lighter box am I supposed to just display this and see this box of text on the side it kind of looks like the um nutritional box on on the side of a cereal box like it's not going to really draw my attention in and want me to take it off the shelf to play I mean I always display it with this side cuz this is beautiful it's also got this like deep side on it but it's kind of a little bit dark for my liking but this one is vibrant inviting really sells the theme of what this game looks like it looks wonderful of my shelf on this side but then when you turn to this side you're like what is this an essay but my next board game gripes is all about legibility of a game it really irritates me when a game is so well produced but then they pick a font that is so difficult to read now I don't know about you but when it's really hard to decipher rules and troll through rules and really just kind of understand how a game works if there is a font there that is like really super cursive or done in a way where it's hard to differentiate the letters it makes makes that process 10 times more difficult and so this
rhina kitzia game Sumatra whilst it uses this very stylish font it's very hard to distinguish what the letters are and in the game there are all these numbers that are really hard to see is that a four or is it a n there are like that's like the Crux or the like heart of the game and if players can't even actually distinguish between a 4 and a 9 in a game how a play is going to ever enjoy the smoothness of the game and games really work well when the flow and the teach and the visual accessibility of the game is easy to comprehend no one wants to come home from a really long day of work get out a game after dinner and be like what what font type is that so aerial bold Times New Roman whatever is your pick as long as we can read it my next board game gripe is to do with the packaging and it's when board game Publishers for some reason decide to use metal tins as a way of containing their games Metal tins are I don't know they're frustrating in order to store them somewhere securely where it can actually display the game these two examples of using tins from Sushi go and susho party are prime examples of why I don't display these two games first of all Sushi go yes it's protective literally you could throw it into a river and it'll still survive but
when you place it vertically the lid slides off because the weight of the cards inside pushed the lids the lid open and so I can't even store this vertically unless it's wedged against some other games so I've got to store it like this otherwise all the cards will randomly fall out then you've got Sushi go party which is kind of like a modular version of sushi go and inside Sushi go party you have this kind of insert that sorts out all of the different uh groups of sushi cards and sets and you can kind of mix and match what you like but the problem with this uh particular box is as soon as I try to stand up vertically everything starts wanting to slide out and there is no place on my shelf where I can comfortably squeeze these games in without the lid just randomly flipping over and all the cards is falling onto the floor and the last thing I want to do is turn around and be like Oh my goodness why is half my sushi goet on the floor all mixed up and then I have to spend all that time sorting it out whilst they do serve as really great protective measures for your game and also really good storage containers for some of your condiments uh they don't really really uh work too well in helping to display the games and feeling compact because even the shape of the tin itself just really h i don't for some reason just really don't like gaps around the corners and the edges and it just ah a a fing now you might have noticed that my dining room is kind of like behind me it's also my gaming table
that I like to extend out I'm actually sitting on my dining chair at the moment but on the other side of this camera is actually my kitchen and I have a kitchen drawer which is full of Ziploc bags ones that games have come with and I haven't particularly used because you know what I really don't like the use of plastics and I think they're a much better solution for storing all of these board game bits inside game boxes these days that we really want to encourage Publishers to use those environmentally friendly Solutions because our environment is precious to us it's precious to me and I want to make sure that when I bring a game to the table that it's it is environmentally sustainable and so when I see just a bag or a roll of Ziploc bags just thrown into the box for you to sort out I just think is there a better way to do this and some games have really achieved some great Solutions zoo tycoon in fact has all these tuck boxes to hold the hundreds of different animals um in the game in the tuck boxes so all you have to do when you play Zu Tycoon is open the lid and you can just pull out the animals and then close the lid at the end of the game beautiful Leaf is another game that does that I also want to showcase this game called Duba wer double wer is like a polyomino stacking game where you're kind of like in Mumbai by India and you're delivering different food to different customers but what's cool about this storage solution is that the game board comes in
puzzle pieces so there's like pieces that stick out the side here but those puzzle pieces on the side actually function as the lid of the storage boxes so if I were to open this storage box you'd be able to see that all the polyomino pieces are stored in a very organized way everything here is made from cardboard everything is printed onto the cardboard the frame was very fun to put together but at the end of the day when I finished with the game I slide the lid back on which is a part of the game board and then everything fits really nicely into this game box which really has everything that you need look at that doesn't that bring a tear to my eye has a little storage box which you open the lid these join into the edge of the game board even has Rule and game reminders on the lid of the box but then when you open it just seeing like how everything is organized in such a thoughtful and really logical way look at the color cating of those polyomino tiles and you know part of the scoreboards on the back of the lid and just closing it and just placing it all back in the Box there's no need to like unpack it reduces setup time it's environmentally friendly and oh my goodness more
game Publishers should really do it that way it my next board game grip is one that I don't know if there's a real solution to because each game is unique and when you're teaching or explaining a game through a rule book or a video there's certain approaches that work best for some games and not so much for others so for example if it's a dexterity game it's easy just to demonstrate how it works if it's a really difficult Euro you might break down the board into different regions and explain how different region Works before connecting it all together there might be a central interlocking mechanism that combines and connects everything together that you might start with but at the end of the day different games have different ways that need to or different approaches that help people to understand how to play but one thing that I find incredibly frustrating is when a game uses all of this meta language language that the person who's picking up the game for the first time has no understanding of so one rule book that I really struggled with was from the game Boku now don't get me wrong I love studio jubile and I love the inspiration that the studio jubile Universe has had on the designer of this game but the way this rule book is written is a little bit mindboggling yes there's a lot of flavor text yes there's a lot of symbology yes
there's some diagrams but they use words that I'm like what is that so there's Boku cards there's the spirit token there's the Hikaru Hill there are all of these different languages or language choices that I'm just like what is that is what's the difference between the forest and the Hikari Hill what is um a yo-kai card and a pilgrim I just basically would love to see if games can just use the most basic language as humanly possible move the Red Cube over there when the Red Cube goes there get $2 I don't want to this flowery text of like move the uh fancy little Idol into that position then gain two magical tokens from the land of mystica yes I get the theme is important but I prefer my themes to be in the game mechanism and in the game play itself all I need to know when I'm learning the game is what do I do how do I get the bonuses and what the bonuses connect to if I can just get that little pattern of connection then I'm a happy person because I've learned how to play I do like how rule books tend to separate the flavor text from the rule instructions which I think is really really good but then when they start using like put the
pilgrim and put the iura Rock in this spot I'm just like what's the pilgrim again what is the iura which one is which how does that go where does the dice fit on my board which color dice what are the PIP Val vales what do these symbols all mean it all becomes like a an overwhelming flood of information that makes it harder for me to just get and into and enjoy the game and Boku is actually one of my top 10 favorite games of all time and now that I've gone through and committed like one or two days to go through the rules and I also learned how to play the solo mode and don't get me started on the solo mode for this game uh now it's like it's so enjoyable I love it it's not that tricky to understand all right my next board game gpe requires you to enter the board game Zone there's my little shrimp tank and I've also got like a whole other like shelf over there so my next board game gribe is all down to box sizes and you can see how I've kind of Tetris this entire shelf I've tried to squeeze and fit and place all the Box is in so that they have a particular order yes there's a particular Arrangement I've got the two player games at the top kind of the code name size boxes here and then the big tall boxes squeezing a bit of Vladimir Suki on the side here but yeah the size of board game boxes I
would feel it would be better if they're a little bit more consistent kind of like shoe sizes this is size seven shoe size this is a size three shoe size this is a size 10 shoe size and then I don't know it would make actually arranging and stacking the games so much more pleasant so much more visually aesthetic and oh my goodness when I find a series of five games that are all exactly the same size I think this is my favorite part of the Shelf is I've H sagata why are you so tall but basically this particular shelf is my favorite because it all just lines up so neatly it's immensely sad fying now I'm a person who likes to read things in sequential steps and sequential order so my next board game gripe is probably a little bit more personal and I think different people who read uh prefer things structured in a different way but I like to pref I prefer things that make sense in order I don't like rule explanations where they jump around to the end of the game then jump to the beginning and then into the middle It all becomes um a mess and so when ru books kind of structure their layout like it's all jumbled up or partitioned in all these weird ways it does really confuse me and it could be just a personal thing but games like Spirit Island at the front of the book it says how to read this book this rule book is divided into three main sections game setup sequence of play and game
Concepts read the game setup first tick excellent Mak sense then read the sequence of play next okay yeah I know the steps but then now search through the whole back of the book for all the game Concepts why why do this to me basically as you're explaining the steps say this is what the concept is and that way I'm like okay when the Invader phase is happening this is the concept the concepts mean that you actually have to keep flicking back and forward to look at the examples what was the step in the game and then what was the phase and then what was the concept which part which phase does you know the energy and C play go to uh the boards and the lands uh what and then like Invaders does that go with the Invader phase which part of the blight happens and then when does the power trigger oh my God it's just like it actually makes it more confusing more difficult to navigate and the fact that I'm flicking back and forward and if you look carefully don't ever do this but I've actually highlighted certain phrases where I've played like three or four games of spirit Island I'm like this game is so easy how is everyone not winning this game and then I'm like oh I made like five rules errors simply because the information wasn't in the section that it should have been in when I was trying to learn the game from reading a book from front to end it's
just imagine like reading a story and theyve taken like parts of the story and just thrown it at the end of the book and you're like okay well why did that character do that oh I need to flick you know 50 Pages ahead to find where it happened I love Spirit Island and don't get me wrong it is a brilliant game but learning it really just made me it caused me to make a lot of rules mistakes which could have been overcome if it was just sequence a little bit more intuitively uh it is also another game that suffers without a play like please everybody put a player Aid in your game it really makes that stepping stone into the game so so much more smoother when dinosaur world first came out I was super excited because it was like Jurassic Park you get to build dinosaur enclosures look after your dinosaurs genetically kind of create them as well as take your guests on Jeep rides throughout your park fun fun fun fun fun love it love it love it love it however there was one gripe that I had with the production of this game in this game when you visit tiles you add boredom tokens the bord bom tokens are this tiny they're like the size of like maybe a fifth of my fingernail these things are the most fiddly things I've ever seen because every time you touch them it flicks and every time you touch it it sticks to things it's basically like the smallest
token I've ever seen in a board game and I don't know about you my fingers AR really that big big they're actually not that big so I I can pretty much pick things up without using a set of tweezers but wow if you're going to make tokens please make them big or have a different way to track them and I know in this game I've now resorted to using dice just cuz they're easier to track less fiddly and more visually appealing on the table so I kind of found my own solution for that problem my next board game grive is to do with different colors and being able to differentiate between similar color things now in that example earlier where I had a game of Pou everything in that game is green like green to every single inch of that board maybe there's like dashes of purple and magenta here and there but essentially it's 98% green so why on Earth would you use one of the player colors as green and brown like are you kidding me this whole board is green and so why on Earth would I pick the player color green to go onto the green background where the board already looks so busy the way it does why would I put pick Brown on a game which is all about going to a forest everything is already Brown it's like please pick colors that make your game stand out or conversely mute some of the background colors so the player
pieces do lift a little it makes it visually easier to see all the play on the board all the regions of the board all of the actions all of the icons that already my brain has to process without all the extra artistic confusion and it also applies to things like where you've got meeples of all different colors and the red meeple is very similar in color to the orange meeple and similar in color to the pink meeple if you're going to use cubes in your game please make sure that the color of the cubes stand out they're distinguishable from each other and they're clear and easy to see and really pop off the board because one thing that can really oh makes me really upset sometimes is like losing track of where I am and that can be really frustrating especially when the game is so good and so enjoyable that small things like that really do make a difference my Boku game now has little stickers uh so A friend bought me a set of stickers which I've attached to um all of my player pieces so now they def definitely stand out but without those stickers it's basically green on green on green I do have to pick this game back off the shelf again because I have another grip with tribes of the wind and it's this is this game is not alone in doing this next gripe that I have and if you turn the box to the side where it says how many players what the AG is for and what the play
time for is I've really found a game that has matched that play time this Play Time says 20 minutes per player it took me probably 45 minutes to learn the game then another 20 minutes just to decipher the iconography I do find that whenever I look at the play time on the side of a box I do take it with a grain of salt in fact take the play time and add 60 Minutes to it that's probably a more accurate representation of how much time per player you're probably going to spend on the game so if it says 20 minutes per player it's probably going to be you know 60 minutes per player or 80 minutes per player that's more accurate and sometimes I wonder why they even put the play time there anymore because most of the time it doesn't really match up with the real amount of time required to set up learn the rules play the game and then do all the scoring at the end maybe there should be like a fstep breakdown setting up 3 hours learning to play two days playing the game 5 minutes packing it away and never playing it again 3 minutes so what are some of your board game gripes please feel free to list as many board game CES as you like in the comment section below because sometimes when we just air some of these things out we can
kind of be like oh my goodness I've never thought of that oh my goodness this is such an important thing that a lot of people are struggling with and it's when we kind of share our struggles and share our experiences and our stories that we truly grow from this experience and hopefully we all have less board game gripes uh yeah but basically if you really enjoyed the value added content of my video please consider liking subscribing and um watching my other videos on my channel would truly appreciate if you really want to see this game channel grow please head over to my patreon page and support me there for exclusive patreon only videos otherwise this is Danny S I hope your next board game experience is a really smooth one now that we got the gripes out of the way