Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Board Games That Got Better and Better - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 17:44

hi everyone today i'm talking about my top 10 ball games that got better and better so whether these were games that initially i thought were just okay and now i think they're pretty good or whether i initially thought they were good and now i think they're excellent or even excellent now i think they're phenomenal so yeah these are the games that i thought that jump was the most noticeable for me and they always seem to be on that incline just just climbing up my ranking so um let's get started at number 10. so at number 10 i have scythe now scythe is probably one of the most popular board games out there today and i think that played a big part in the reason why initially i was somewhat underwhelmed by it because this game had a level of hype surrounding it that it just couldn't live up to um so yeah after my first i thought you know that was that was okay um but the more i got to play i started to understand why it did take off to the levels it did because this not only does this game do a great job of kind of mashing together the hybrid systems of like euro games and american games because you've got the resource management of a of a euro game but you've got some conflict that you'd expect in a more of an american style game and also the visual aspect that that is almost unmatched because this game is stunning to look at and i think that yeah the more i played this one the more i started to appreciate the um the engine building and it's just just the the smoothness in general of the game because i think this is uh one of the best examples of just streamlining a game into your player boards and it does a great job of just ironing out all the creases that can um you know make you lose interest because turns in this game are extremely

fast you know by the time you finish your turn it's pretty much your turn again um and you can also piggyback off the actions of the other players the engine building is so satisfying as you are taking tokens off your board making things more powerful but also making them cheaper at the same time and it comes together in a wonderfully puzzly aspect to it it's got a nice level of resource management as i said lots of different ways to score points and big multipliers as well like like you would expect in a more involved euro game so it does strike a wonderful balance of just um just appealing to so many different people and i think that's probably a big part of the success of scythe and that really did start to resonate with me the more and more i played it so um yeah a lovely game that is scythe at number 10. at number nine i have concept so concept probably well it is in fact the most simple game on this list um it's pretty much sharad just condensed down into a board game so when i played this initially i thought you know this is this is a bit it's a bit of a flat line for me why don't we just play shiraz it just seems like it's a game for the sake of it but the more and more i played it the more i started to appreciate how creative you could be when giving your clues so you know you might have to give a clue relating to a certain film or a or a song or an actor or something but you can be extremely um again creative and clever with the way you link these clues together to help your or the other players guess what you're trying to portray and um i started to uh enjoy how all the challenge of getting these um or relaying this information

and it did start to resonate with me and um now it's become a game that i would happily play with anybody in any circumstance i think the familiarity of a game like charades is gonna instantly help other people understand the rules of the game and um yeah it's always been a hit to be honest so um that's why concept is at number nine at number eight i have ship shape now ship shape is another relatively simple filler style game as you are collecting these different tiles and you're trying to cover up your basically ship's hull because this is a pirate themed game to show certain symbols to cover up certain symbols but all these tiles are really interesting because they have certain sections cut out of them and certain shapes still there and you've got to map things out you can flip them and turn them to get the most optimal layout basically and um again initially i thought this was pretty simple the decisions were a bit a bit straightforward and pretty obvious but i think that started to be a positive thing for me as um sometimes you just want to play a game that's a bit more chilled out and this really has become a go-to game for me it's just climbing up and up and up in my levels of enjoyment for it and a bit like concept as well always been a hit for me whoever i played this with and it scales really well you know accommodates a lot of different different player accounts and it's just an enjoyable puzzly style game and i'm starting to enjoy puzzle games more and more and um ship shape is probably almost at the forefront of that and um yeah definitely an underrated and under-appreciated family-friendly puzzle-style game

that is ship shape at number seven i have a game that's very popular again uh one that's always been high in my rankings you know i've always appreciated this game and had a love for it this one is concordia so concordia i always say this is probably objectively the best game design out there i think this game has uh the game just down to a t there is nothing here that doesn't need to be there it really is a designing or kind of a designer's masterpiece i think this is just wonderfully nuanced so many different things you can try so pure and clean and just streamlined to every degree and i think again a bit like scythe the more and more i get into the hobby the more games are out there you start to appreciate those things um as you get more experience and i think concordia is is leading the way in that um because there is nothing i could even suggest to improve this game i don't know i'm not a game sign or anything but usually there's something that doesn't quite hit the spot for me whereas concordia i just look back at it and think wow this is just amazing it's just so pure and um the strategies you can take the blocking the positive player interaction where it's still meaningful it is the quintessential euro but it's just such a fine example of that and um the you know the the economy in the game the hand management of the game the strategy the tactics it's all just it's just so wonderfully balanced and i think balance is the world that i take away from concordia

and um yeah those games are are really leading the pack in my personal enjoyment nowadays and um yeah concordia just continues to amaze me that is uh that's my number seven at number six i probably have the most consistent slow climber this is istanbul so istanbul on the face fit is a pretty simple it's a racing style game as you are traversing this map of istanbul by moving these tokens dropping one off as you land and um and taking the action corresponding to that and you're collecting resources you're collecting money you're um increasing your wheelbarrows you're trying to um increase your capacity to carry goods from one place to another and um i the more i'm kind of um introduced the expansion to this one as well has helped quite a bit because i think on the on the base game alone is pretty light it's pretty simple and accessible but those additional wrinkles of the expansions have just amped up for me quite a bit and it's really become one of my favorite games and with most of the games i play i tend to my enjoyment for them tend to diminish the more and more i play them but istanbul has just consistently just perked my interest the more i play it and i'll happily play this one anytime anywhere and um because it is so easy to explain but the depth on it is great it has amazing tension you can block people make them spend money you can um take so many different paths to victory and you have to be on your toes ready knowing to when to take a plan b or knowing to zig and zag it's just one of the most accessible but

deep games out there and um for me it just takes all the boxes of what makes a great game and um yeah istanbul just consistently um continues to impress me that is why istanbul is at number six at number five i have grand austria hotel now this a bit like concordia i've always enjoyed this game i think it's wonderful it has some wonderful combo building has a great theme as well as you're trying to manage this um this hotel trying to feed your guests trying to send them off to their rooms happy and um score lots of different points you can utilize these staff cards in amazing ways but yeah the more i play this one um i tend to enjoy uh distracting games anyway and this one is certainly one of my favorite dice drafting games as as you take actions if they got the most if if that's the most commonly rolled dice value then you get more powerful versions of their actions but the the lower valued ones or the ones that have been rolled less frequently are rarer so you might want to take those even though it's going to be at a lower action because it's your only opportunity to do that and that core decision really does um does work for me again i love the combo building and the way you can string your actions together i find that really satisfying i think all the characters in the games in terms of the powers you can get are very dynamic they're all strong and you want them all i can really pay dividends and um yeah this it's become one of my favorite games ever i think initially it's um it was always in my kind of top you know 30 top 20 but now it really is pushing its way

into my i think last year is in my top five so um yeah just continues to um impress me and my enjoyment for it never ceases um to to rise so that is grand austria hotel at number five and number four i have two now tua is pretty a great example of a dry euro this is probably one of the most mechanical one of the most mathematical games out there and i think initially that is what didn't quite connect with me because i think i thought you know who who's going to enjoy this really you know i tend to like dry games but i can appreciate why people don't like them particularly this one as well that has an art style that's not for everybody it has a real throwback art style which feels a bit stuffy but again i enjoy it but i appreciate other people don't and yeah first i i started to think you know this is this is so massive um you know you're using dice and you are um basically dividing them to take actions and those divisions and all the maths behind the definitions is quite strenuous and can be work at times but the more i played it the more i started to actually enjoy that part of the game i started to appreciate all the the variability of the game as there's so much different things you can do different setups from game to game which changed the game or the feel of the game massively and i love games that are interchangeable and feel different from time to time and i just started to appreciate how pure this game was and how well it works together like clockwork basically um additionally it was a quite a strong point where i

didn't like almost hard-nosed player interaction and um getting into the face with other people really just screwing them up and this game does almost feel mean at times because you can basically take other people's dice without their permission you do have to pay them for it and compensate them but that can leave people kind of rubbed up the wrong way but now i i think that is a key part of the game and i really enjoy that part of the game and to be honest this game does lean more towards the tactical side to things which again gives it a different vibe because most of the games i play tend to lean on the strategy side of things but this one is more reactive but i love the synergies between all the different buildings i love the threats that the game throws against you and you have to almost semi-cooperatively work against the uh the game to fight them off and it just feels distinct it feels unique and i can't see this game ever falling out of favor of me and i hold a strong place on my shelf and my appreciation just grows and grows vertois at number three i have a taken you obelisk of the sun so to can um is one of my by one of my favorite designers daniel tashini uh and he almost well almost in fact he does every single time hit the ball out of the park for me you know every game you've done it's almost like almost a nine plus out of ten and um naturally i was extremely interested in anticipating to kenya to be as good as those games and when i first got the game to the table you know another dice driven euro i think this is going to be for me i hope this is as good as the others and

i was i thought you know this game by the time i finished it at least i thought this game is really solid but something about it just didn't have that magic that the other games did you know games like um games like toto khan or or tristan justice and but i i always felt like you know i need to play this one more time because i this he's a designer i trust a designer i feel like i need to give him the benefit of doubt and the more i played it my enjoyment went up and up and now and now this is equally as good as those other games and i just enjoy it i enjoy it so much this is such a clever game as you are drafting dice you are using to take lots of different actions you can build a bit of an engine up you got to consider the color of that dice because at certain points in the game they're going to be worth or they're going to fall on the negative side of the scale they're going to be shadow dice so they can be light dice and you've got to weigh that up because you can score negative points or fall out with initiative order and um this is just a wonderfully put together game uh i think cheney does a great job of holding a certain standard in terms of his quality control of all these euros that he brings out and i'm always fascinated by how he uses dice in weird and wonderful ways and again to kenya it's just held our standard and my optimism about his design prowess just continues to be um to be up there so to kenya obelisk of the sun at number three at number two i have trajan so trajan another game i've always enjoyed um very dry again um as you are using my color system to

take different actions um basically it's a smorgasbord of different actions you can take lots of mini games getting points in loads of different ways so it's a point style of star games where you're showered in points um and i i thought initially the game i i did find it quite uh quite exhausting a bit of a brain burner as you are you know trying to map out as efficiently as you can try to map out these colors of these tokens and these mancala bowls because you can get more actions if you line up certain colors and it's it's pretty deterministic you know you can't you can't wing this game you have to map things out very carefully and i'm like that can be tiring so it's not a game i'm always in the mood to play because i know it requires a lot of brain power but you cannot fault how well this game is put together and um objectively this game is so good the strategy is fantastic as you can map out your turns you know you can do ten times in advance if you wanted to um and that is just a big part of the games you're trying to go down a certain strategy path and milk as many points as you can out of the game and yeah this is last year they came in my number two games of all time so out of the hundreds and hundreds of games i played this is the second best one and it wasn't always that way you know i did always enjoy it but it didn't always excite me to the level it does now and this is one of those games that is just you know it's a masterpiece it's just a phenomenal and one of the best games ever made and that wasn't that apparent to me when i first played it and now it's crystal clear this is just amazing

trajan at number two and at number one i have in the year of the dragon so in the year of the dragon is another steppenfeld game like trajan uh this one however has an extremely different feel to a game like trade you know spell is mostly known for his point style style games this one getting points is like getting blood out of the stone it's a much lower scoring game and i always i always describe this game as being a game of attrition because it really is about weathering the storm and trying to overcome all the obstacles the game throws at you so basically the the board is going to show a number of towels which is going to be a number of different threats or kind of tragedies that the games can throw you such as you know drought or or hunger or disease and you've got to have the right kind of um crew members in order to overcome those obstacles you know having the right doctors or having people who are going to produce food you know your farmers etc and getting those people in houses is important you need to get them in the right pagodas you need to be able to feed them in the pagodas so it's such a tight game and you've got a resource rob manage your resources to the to the smallest degree the tightest degree to be as efficient as you can so that you only need those crew members for the time you need them because as soon as you're done with them you need to get rid of them and get the new ones in in order to fight the new threats coming in and that is such a compelling decision and every time i've played this game my enjoyment has gone up drastically from the last at first i thought i suppose maybe i wasn't expecting a failed game to feel like this but when i did start to feel it to

understand what the game was about again that it really did start to resonate with me i started to think this game is so clever there's nothing else really like it out there yes it's punishing but that is where the fun lies it can it can be stressful um you know managing your resources is absolutely um exhausting but is just amazingly put together and um by the end of the game you just feel like you've been dragged through a hedge because um you do really have to think you know be on your toes and just adjust and um keep keep um keep pushing on to the best of your ability so that is my number one it was the game that um kind of popped into my mind as soon as i thought up this list because it has just been big jumps year on year on how much i'm enjoying this one so uh number one in the year of the dragon so i hope you've enjoyed this top 10 list if you have please hit like and subscribe my channel for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved