Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 28:45

so the title is our taste have changed over the years does it suck I don't know see I was going on there I was sitting thinking older sucks but that doesn't address what we're going to talk about but it does suck it does suck our taste had do our taste I don't know I don't know you got us into this you pigeonholed Us in this sucky title thing through the titles of these videos suck no yes

all right so we know we're celebrating our like 10th year of the podcast and go team I know and so I've been doing a lot of personal reflection over my taste in games over the past I guess we've been playing pretty hardcore for about 20 years now God really yeah it's been that long and so I was thinking about how my taste over the years have changed and it's it's I've gone from one thing to another thing to another thing to where I think I finally at my old age settled into a rut of things that I really like and now by scope of games that I like that I must have must play wanna play it's really I'm finding well I'm glad you've had this self-reflection this um wanting to do this reflection on how your games have changed so when you pitch this to me I started thinking about it and I don't know if my game takes because I've mentioned this on the show has really changed over time because if I go back and I talk about you know playing games growing up you know when it was too hot to be playing outside and things like that and I always went towards various games like Stratego and then I've talked about when I went to a store and bought a bookshelf game Panzer leader and then as I continue to look at my collection and how it is I'm seeing that similar theme

so did I know something back when I was 14 years old I don't know but I will agree with you that what I have played or have been playing over the past 20 years has greatly changed okay is it okay has your taste changed um yes and you know me best and I think the reason why my taste has changed is because my length of time a game can last has changed that's fair so all right so one thing that used to draw me into the game was theme uh when there's when there's so many games to choose from I was like I don't know this looks cool because I like the theme I mean I went out and on a whim bought the Starcraft board game extremely due to the fame now that may have led that one game may have led to you I don't like long games because that was a very long game no no that did not lead to that that was okay it's very enjoyable very enjoyable so no but then what what I found out is I started buying all these games based on theme but you know there's this running joke it's like you know if uh if if something's based on like a TV theme or movie theme the game is going to suck in lots of cases that was the case and so me just strictly picking up a box and going all right just just based on this box cover and what it's about I think I'll get it and try it and I found that that just wasn't doing it for me and I

probably realized that maybe about 10 12 years ago okay and see you were in my wallet back then so we would play a game and then I would want to add it to my collection but I have found that for me that the length the duration of the game comes playing Starcraft was enjoyable but you and I had because we could start late we'd start at 8pm at night and we could go till midnight one o'clock so I think I think there's a may have been weeknight gaming nights too it could have been it may have been Friday it may have been it had to be Friday because we all you know we worked Monday through uh Friday of course so it was a Friday night show up um but I do think it was what we enjoyed and we we enjoyed the various types of themes um because I mean Katana was a great game or Catan doesn't matter to me um you know but is it a what was the theme you know well the only reason why I bought that game is because I did the thing of what you know I was typing in what are the most popular board games and that just kept floating to the top that ticket to ride right so I got those two strictly based off Yahoo searches which is probably what I was using back then wow that was pretty good Yahoo I like that Mr Jeeves or whatever it was back then oh look at you not showing your age on this as you're getting older back back back when I was using my Netscape browser yeah oh man that was a

good browser too okay but so over the 20 years though you're right you were and I were driving towards what seemed popular and we were able to find out over those years what mechanics did we like and did you ever have a particular mechanic has your mechanic Choice changed over time so that's when this transition started happening when I realized wait a minute the theme of the game is not what's really doing it for me but some of the mechanics in the game is what I really like and I remember really honing in we played a ton of Puerto Rico a mess of Puerto Rico and that is at its core it's your basic resource collection turning in resources getting victory points plus the idea of choosing a roller I guess to do a secondary function so that was my first really jump into Euro so I'm like oh I like the strategy of a spreadsheet if I get this many resources here and I turn in these many resources to get victory points so then I started diving in to mechanisms oh I like how you did the little symbol for Dry diving well since since there is a video cast of this I can't do some uh you know some video stuff here so yeah if you're listening on the podcast make sure to go follow us on our YouTube channel so you can actually see us in person now you probably don't want to do that just stick to the audio yes I agree but so you you saw Puerto Rico um then for me you know it was the set

collection or but and I always talk about this on the show it's just how much I loved Pillars of the Earth you know what was the first time you probably played that uh was it before we started the podcast or was it after oh yeah it was like before I think it was before okay but then again these past 10 years have been a blur I know everything has everything has come pressed I could have played that two years ago and it may have seen like 10. one of my early work replacement games was Lords of water deep and that really got me liking work replacement games okay and I remember playing Lords of the Water Deep from from back then um and learning about it but that was right when we started the podcast but I feel like I played that before Pillars of the Earth I could be wrong well I do know that I played Pillars of the Earth before you and I went to our first origins together okay all right Carlson that's right at the beginning of the show or yeah right before the show started or right at the beginning because I remember you remember Mayfair you had to play so many games and then you would get a discount that was so much fun we had to collect the badges if you could get a complete set of Katan resource badges you got your name put onto a drawing oh man that was so much fun yeah and you got 50 off and I remember spending my 50 off on nuns on the run back then because I was looking for a big game for a lot of people but I know I played world of uh

World Without End I think is the uh next one in that series okay I'd have to look it up because certainly the brain is confused with World of Warcraft um but I I knew that I was looking for that next game in that Series so that's why I was thinking I played Pillars of the Earth before we started the podcast but to that point every game had to meet the same expectations and it started me on the liking of the um gather the resource convert the resources worker placement you know standard Euro type thing standard Euro type thing so but what happened was as I got into those and really enjoying different types of Euros you know uh we I can't remember when we played Dominion but that sucked me into you know deck building games which I tend to like but as we got and started doing the podcast all of a sudden we were playing a lot of this samey style games a lot of the collect resources turned them in uh for victory points and then I was like it was my eyes were starting to glaze over after a while because they were all a little too samey then it's like well but I can play this or this and kind of get the same feeling so then I started going kind of going back to well maybe theme does interest me and I think there was this turning point for me in in 2016 when the Arkham Horror lcg Game came out because I like card games I enjoy the theme of that game but all of a sudden Not only was it very thematic but the

mechanisms was very there's a lot of resource management uh it's a very thanky strategic game and then I started realizing wait a minute you mean it's possible for me to have a theme I really really like and the mechanisms of the game I really enjoy and that's what I've kind of converted to today to where I need Fame and I need something fun to play and I have people like well Marty that's everything it's like but not I don't know that it's really everything I think there are a lot of Euro style games where the theme you see is pasted on paste it on themes even though I may have enjoyed my time with it we'll probably stay on the shelf more often than one with a theme I really like okay and I know that As I Am shifting my focus I am looking at what do I do over the next five to ten years and how am I this is sad man now you got me sad I'm sorry why because I'm thinking about as my mental state deteriorates over time seriously my ability to comprehend rulebooks my ability to teach games I'm seeing I've loved in the 10-year span of us going from these very simple Ticket to Ride type games to complex thought-provoking engine building constantly thinking ahead I'll move after move after move and now I'm beginning to see well you know what as I continue to play these games

outside of our little gaming group my gaming group can't manage that nothing against them it's just the time is not there the patience is not there for trying to get one of those big thinky games out on the table you know right and I so I'm looking at that so where do I want to be in in the past three years I've shifted my focus to okay what games will I when I want to get to the game to the table with people what do I need to have on my shelf meanwhile for me I'm looking at and you're getting into these are the historical games especially the one player and I've had historical games for a long time like I said Panzer yeah and and so I think that's where I want to have this discussion because I've started realizing why am I so into historical games and I found that I've always liked history and there's some really cool themes games out there that's really interesting to me but there's some really brilliantly designed games that are a lot of fun to play and I'm I'm finding in this little niche of historical games is kind of scratching both itches and it's funny on our Discord Channel I was was talking about historical games and somebody said I just don't see how you get into it it just looks so boring to me and I totally get that okay I'm not in history or anything and let's face it this is this is something that a lot of people say you pick up a lot of GMT boxes and they

ain't gonna do it for you you pick up the box to Andy and Abyss where there's a soldier on there with a gun and it's just kind of black and white it's like why in the heck would I want to play this where right beside it was Cuba Libra was just a coin game like Andy and abyss and that one appealed to me more because it was a colorful box and also a theme that I knew but even though they're very similar in style so I totally get I don't get the appeal but the thing is I think it just comes down to it's a theme that I'm interested in with a lot of really cool design ideas that make me really enjoy the game prime example undaunted World War II two two cool theme interested in the theme and the history of the war combined with my favorite types of games deck building games but which I'm with you it's also games that I enjoy watching on TV when I say this stick with me okay I'm a Star Trek fan I know that what some of my favorite episodes anything to deal with changing time time jumps anything like that um the original Quantum Leap and I look at TV shows that I've enjoyed where history changes and these games give you that uh capability you can change history this battle has changed you've talked about the coin system how can you influence Cuba's development or outcome

we talk about Watergate two-player game you and I really love that game how can we influence the Watergate can it change you know so any type of those type of games which is you know over time as I look back at this when you say hey look at look at how yours change I'm like but I've always liked games that have told me how I can change history that's the yeah you guys going historical kick so I got examples of games that are not historical that I when I look back over the years what game stuck out to me it's because the theme meshed well with mechanics I like prime example it's not historical at all Netrunner I thought Netrunner thematically was brilliant to bring in that dystopian hacker type thing to the table with really cool mechanisms um Lord of the Rings actually kind of did that for us I just didn't realize at the time the idea you got the fellowship trying to go nine sights so and I look back it's like well it's not just the story creams heck uh as the recording as a recording today um the game found just launched for uh Elder Scrolls Theory games dude I am so psyched for that game I know it's not until 2024 I love Elder Scrolls I love the idea of building a character and like role playing and I know that chip theory has some really really good game mechanics and rules built in their games so I am

super hyped for that and it has nothing to do with history but that goes back to your um video games you talked about Starcraft um so would I be if knowing how I am if I saw that game found page and seeing that price point would I be would I be looking at you saying I want that the only reason why I do is not because of the games I've played previously from Chip theory is because of how much time I spent in Skyrim how can I change that Universe how it can be fair it's not Skyrim I know I know the only reason why I said that I was watching a video from them today and they said y'all there's not going to be any reference of arrow to the knee because it's a different timeline it's from Elder Scrolls online and the only reason why I say it's because for myself too I kept saying Skyrim I think in our last episode when I was talking about it's just Elder Scrolls um but anyway no I I am super excited now here's the thing you have another Elder Scrolls game you do have a Skyrim game right now don't you yes I do um I was so so on that because I just didn't know much about it but I'm more interested in this from Chip Theory just because I trust them that the rules will be good but you also have shied away from Legacies that's that's true that's that's 100 and Campaign games campaign so over time you're looking at okay there was that theory you know that pandemic Legacy it

was all these Legacy games all this is a cool idea you know let's be able to do this isn't it neat to be able to have undiscovered rules and change things out I still enjoy them the but the problem is I don't have a steady group to game with to do that right I can't we you know that is a commitment of you know 12 plays minimum yeah and the last one I did was my city with our friends go ahead with our friends and we did it via over Zoom because we we were it was easy to do kind of like you're doing the video with Cuba Libre I was able to video the cards turning up so it wasn't easy but I have shifted now do we want to go back to any Legacy games that's not going to happen right right um you have really shifted towards because you and Donna play a lot of two player games it's like anytime we get a chance to check out a two-player game I know that you're super interested because you think hey here's something that you and Donna might enjoy well well that's because I gotta finish living with her you and I you know we're not in the apartment anymore dude no no I know that I'm just saying that you you said you're you're looking at the next five ten years and you're kind of curating curated curating your collection and you're probably gonna hone in on those games more often than you would say probably a legacy Style game just because of the chance of getting it to the table Yeah so in five or ten years I expect you to have your shelves shifted a little bit

to where when the boys show up here's the thing the boys aren't really playing board games anymore oh they're they're the d d aren't they well d d and uh video games video games yeah okay but when they come over for a family dinner here you go you're gonna drop a hour hour and a half game here you go guys let's play this game no okay I won't they they're not really interested in that and unfortunately for me now if I was to say let's pull out a commander deck and play Commander they'll do that all day long okay I kind of have to instead of lead them to play something with me it's like if whatever they're interested in I'll play with them so I know that yeah so when's what's the earliest that a hobby game can be played by like five something like that yeah yeah I guess I got feeling those will start showing up on our shelves eventually here in about 10 years I mean hopefully not any time uh uh uh too soon you're not getting any younger dude you need to get these grandkids rolling in man so back on topic so I is talking about For Me theme and mechanisms and like last year I I see right over your left shoulder you have Arc Nova on there probably considered the the top game if not one of the top games of 2022. I think it's a very clever game I enjoy my time with it but the theme I just didn't really care about and as I'm playing the game it's like it's I'm I'm enjoying the things I'm doing and then when I put it away I didn't think about it but then I compare that to a game that we played just a couple

months ago John company um heavy game but I kept thinking about it because the theme meshed so well with what we were doing in the game right you know and that I'm just finding those experiences stick with me when I can apply the theme with the game and that's why I think that's why I like Arkham Horror so much Lord of the Rings lcg was really cool but you're controlling a team of people and I wasn't really attached to them quotes in Arkham Horror I'm playing this one character he can never change and it just keeps getting better so it's like what I'm excited about Elder Scrolls creating a character making him better and taking a momental journey right artnova the hurt is best of two players there you go that's why it's sitting on the shelves haven't done it yet haven't had the time to teach Donna this game so I mean it's about Zeus also it's about zoos I mean how benign is that but then if you look past the shelves you see Memoir 44 D-Day dies you know so there's the military game showing up again just because that's that's why I enjoy all those you know we we got the you know the David Thompson um undaunted series you know I'm I'm thinking about also my future son-in-law I'm like he's going to be he's in the military he may not want to ever play him but at least this will be something that can interest him so yes I'm thinking ahead

how has my tastes changed over time it's beginning to be structured around events in my life more than anything got it and what's interesting unfortunately I'm probably going to miss out on a lot of good games just because now the theme isn't catching me another hot game from 2022 was flamecraft with the cute little dragons and it's like everybody says it's amazing it's like I I just have no interest in playing and it's it's just like it's just not grabbing and I know before I get chastised and and the comments and everything if I sat and played it because it's so well loved I would probably like it too I tend to like what people generally like it's just the theme just never grab me and I know we make the joke all the time about oh look it's another nature themed game it's just there's so many out there and there's probably a gym out there I haven't played but the theme just isn't grabbing me and I know somebody's gonna say well Marty it's the same thing with historical games I I get that no I I some people are going to be more drawn to Nature games which makes total sense that's definitely a wider appeal than maybe an historical game but it's just that's personal preference at that point but I see for me that I don't over time I don't think theme has ever been a major part of my decision really okay yeah okay because of what this is I'm interested in it okay all right strike that yeah point I mean geez oh it's a military box here it is okay does it matter what

military like for example uh middle I don't know why in ancient combat Romans Greeks uh Middle Ages even lend me your ears yeah maybe even more so than possibly World War II and maybe it's because of my ignorance of those I'm just more interested to learning more about that so is it any type of military conflict or is there you know myths anytime any kind of military conflict but if I were to rank them it would probably go um it would be World War II and then we would put Vietnam conflict and then we would move on down and I think a lot of it has to do with keep going down is the um then go to the the knights and Napoleon conflicts things like that um I think it comes down to the armaments that they have where modern day combat just doesn't really interests me as much and I don't know why but and the theaters and we've gone from how our change to our historical here on historical gaming podcast type talk and I'm trying not to do that y'all I know that that immediately that just turns people off and I get it but I think we're just trying to make the point is that beam really drives well me personally into stuff that I like even if it's not historical it could be something else uh it's just the theme is going to grab me

more so as long as the game is it has to be both it's gonna it's got to be both or I'll plant once twice and maybe never again yeah but to your point I would say at the beginning of the podcast when we were looking at this it was going to be theme or something that I knew about to to draw me in over time it then became all right what what mechanic is there what mechanic do I enjoy the most that is the one that I'm going to levitate toward gravitate towards not levitate gravitate towards and then now I'm immediately grabbing the Box flipping it over all right it is X hours long requires x amount of number of people to play and here's the theme yeah all right here's the mechanics that I can tell from the back so that is what I'm looking at now so I I'm the same way our requirements of what's going to stay on our Shelf probably is getting narrower and narrower over time yes right as I looked as I look at them yes or what will come in on the shelves yeah because you know because we've played so many games over the past 10 years I there's a there may be a mechanic that I like and 25 games that'll come out that you'll have that mechanic so that's like well I know I can play any sort of game but which of these 25 am I going to hone in on and it'll probably be towards the one with a theme that I like the most okay and I will look for a time frame

I really will but you still well that's because of the group that you're going to play with you still be willing to play a longer game occasionally I guess oh yeah even though even though we make fun of me getting my switch out and being grumpy when uh we have the big I love our Saturday game days but even that has gone from 10 hours to six hours okay that's true it's just once again I have gotten older to where it's like okay the brain has saturated the gray matter has soaked up as much as it can and and am I over taxing the system a little bit if you put down you know you always talk about ending the game but if we just I'm very excited that we're going to get to play an 18xx game yeah very excited you just picked up Maria yeah okay um I've got I forget I've got a oh uh the Civil War GMT game I'm very excited for us to play that yes so I'm looking forward to those but do not put Maria on the table in an 18xx game that ain't happening that's right open with a small game a long game small game and now it's pretty much it's the long game only yeah we're going we're playing we're doing the long game that's what we're playing for we don't get to book in the long game with anything anymore so let me ask you all this that have been uh watching if you're watching on uh YouTube what has your tasting games

changed over the past 10 15 years uh and if you want to you can join us on our Discord Channel let us know are your thoughts there what are you into now it's a theme is it mechanics is it a mixture of both are you just looking to have a good time I think what it comes down to I Just Want to Have Fun and now I might my window of fun is kind of narrow to what I see what uh what's gonna fit that hole and I think mine's an hour and a half regardless of what it is whether it's flaming dragons or give me a good game mechanic get me some dice on the table for an hour and a half I'll be a happy camper you good

Progress saved