Variety Vlog Feb 2016: Q&A, Scythe, Stone Garden, and more!
Transcript
welcome to John gets games this is my end of February 2016 variety Vlog as you can see on the left there are several different things I'm going to be covering so feel free to jump ahead to the part that most interests you or stick around for the whole thing so over the last month a couple interesting things have happened in Johnny gets games land the first of these is that game land games reached out to me to do some play testing for tiny epic Western uh this happened after I put out that playthrough uh for the game when it went live on Kickstarter and uh they specifically needed help honing in the details of the solo variant for the game so that was very interesting I ended up doing uh 25 play tests and a bunch of tweaks and writing a whole bunch of emails back and forth it was really great being involved in the actual end game design of a published board game that was super exciting a great opportunity and hopefully in the future more opportunities like this will come about and the other thing to note is that the channel has simply been growing at a very surprising rate over the last month to month and a half I think part of that has to do with the tiny epic Western playthrough and Karma Cafe through that I did two very big kickstarters but it's just really cool like I'm used to the graphs all being relatively flat and consistent but man suddenly about 40 or so days ago it just took a turn up and it kept going up and up and up and up it's by far the best month of the entire uh life of the channel in fact and at one point I looked at it in over a 30-day span the last 30 days I had received 20 of the overall views I'd ever received on my channel in those 30 days which is pretty incredible because I've been doing this for almost two years so uh it's been very bolstering it's great to see that
kind of increase in engagement in subscribers and viewers and comments and all that kind of stuff so I'm very excited with how things are going and I hope it continues speaking of increased audience engagement now let's go into the question and answer section I asked for questions in the last Vlog a month ago and I got two of them so uh let's start with uh Jonesy 1977. the question is what are your top 10 favorite games of all time and why also what are your favorite kinds of games or would you call yourself an omni gamer who could enjoy all kinds of games well the answer to the first question is I did do a top 10 uh board games of all time in fact I did a top 20. uh just this last month partly because of this question and if you want to take a look at it there's a link in the top corner of the video you can click on that to go take a look um answering the second question I think I am kind of an omni gamer there are some things that I really dislike in general like a game where you have to lie or argue a lot like the resistance and werewolf and all those kind of games in general and predisposed to actively dislike those games also games with timers like I don't know Bananagrams oh my gosh I'm so bad at that game I really hate playing it because I feel like an absolute because I'm also not great at word games but I can tolerate word games but oh my gosh war games plus like timing stress I just get so anxious and my brain locks down in general I just really dislike those games uh when you look to pretty much all other kinds of games I like most of them I mean very very heavy games that take more than two to two and a half hours in general I'm not that big a fan of I have enjoyed to
a certain degree but they're not something I run for I'm probably uh mostly a Eurogamer with lots of indirect interaction and 60 to 90 minute play times that's like that's where I love the games I just love that kind of stuff but I do play Amer trash style games as well I love throwing dice around whether it's in a euro-y sense where you're doing interesting um complicated things with them or just throwing dice every single turn in a yahtzee style uh setting I like both of those things I think in general I shy away from abstract games a little bit where there's like zero Randomness because it almost starts to feel like work if you're just doing my mind versus your mind just going at it I can enjoy those certain degree but like I said I think Euro games are my center but I do like a good variety of games party games I've enjoyed to a certain degree but I very rarely find myself actually going out of my way to play them the second question comes from Hua Chen who says regarding your Cyclades review I have pretty much the exact same base game problems I've heard the expansions fix these problems particularly Titans but I wanted to get your thoughts on if you've played it now one of the reasons I'm answering this is because many people have asked me this question and to sum up my issues with cichlidies it was a wonderful gaming experience that had a very unsatisfactory end game uh usually due to a pegasus card or a couple other circumstances where you could be having tons of fun and then the last 10 to 15 minutes or just oh a big letdown you don't feel like you get the big payoff and no I have not played any of the expansions for Cyclades and I want to at some point like I've mentioned thinking
about going out of my way to get it but it's pretty expensive and if I'm being honest in general I don't actually like expansions that much for board games I'm not a big expansion person it seems like usually when I get an expansion for a board game I will never play it again I got the leaders expansion for Seven Wonders and like two years ago I've still never played it uh I just I feel like the moment I get an expansion my interest just tanks down um I got the expansion to Evolution I haven't played it since I got that expansion and so I feel like if I got the expansion for Titans I probably would never get around to actually playing it and I know that people are very curious about my opinions if it changes from one thing to another and the other thing is that I loved cichlidies like four years ago um and I still have um a soft spot in my heart for it but I don't do dudes on a map kind of board games that much anymore I found myself shifting much more towards euroe style things so I was not terribly interested in going out of my way to get it and to play it at some point I do hope that I have the opportunity to so I can see how it plays differently and hopefully if I love it in that setting I can still go out of my way to grab the game but um yeah unfortunately I've not actually played that expansion it it's kind of a more General thing that I just don't do expansions for the most part I hope to be answering more questions like this when I do future Vlogs so please uh send them in to me if you have some questions of your own that you'd like me to answer in the next one all right now it's time to talk about a game that's getting me really excited right now and I am a bit behind the times here I'm going to talk about scythe and this game was huge last year it had a humongous Kickstarter people
have been hyped like this one for a very long time and if I'm being honest when it first came out and I started seeing the art I thought the art looked great and then I heard that it was an area majority game and in general I'm not a huge fan of every majority style dudes on a Mac games and I didn't give it that much attention uh and I kind of moved on but recently I was given the opportunity to do a live play of this on table topio with several of my board game media content uh Creator friends uh like um Paul Grogan from gaming rules uh efka and Elaine from no pun included and uh John Perkins from actual law and we we did it live on the stream and so we get to play there and I really like the game I'm very excited to actually play the entire game because unfortunately we had some technical difficulties it's got some really cool stuff going on here uh specifically the things that surprised me about the play of it and have me excited are the simple turn structure you have four different actions you can do total and you can never do the turn you did last turn so every single turn you have three different things you can do and the actions are move or increase your military power or do some trading to get resources you don't control and to produce resources on the hexes that you're currently on and that's pretty much it there are secondary actions that you could do sometimes like building a building building a Mech and uh upgrading your player board but for the most part it's a very simple game it's just like move and then produce and then make something and then move and then produce and also the movement is quite slow which I really like in general you can only move one and then if you upgrade it two spots with a given uh
unit on the board so you're less likely to get blitzed by somebody suddenly and lose a lot of your stuff uh like in a territory control setting I also like that the game kind of encourages and discourages combat uh for the one on the one part you lose popularity if you chase away the workers of your opponent so the workers just create goods for you um and popularity is very important it changes your endgame uh Victory Point modifiers and it also is something that you can spend to get good stuff so if you don't have enough popularity you can't get that really good stuff um on the flip side you do you do have the option of doing combat but when you do it you have to do a blind bit of resources and it can be quite costly so it doesn't mean that you're going to be doing combat over and over again it seems like you're going to do it somewhat sparingly and the threat of combat is going to be a bigger deal than actually fighting each other and on top of all this there are two layers of asymmetry to every single player there are a bunch of different factions that have their own special ability and their mechs have special abilities as well like with how they can move and that kind of thing on the board but you also get a random secondary player board that are also all asymmetric so every time you play the Black faction for instance you will probably be playing with a different set of actions on the bottom so it's most games when you have asymmetric facts actions every time we play that faction it's going to be similar but no not right now not with Scythe because you might at one point have the faction that makes Mex really easily and suddenly you have lots of mechs and you're going to play that way or you can have the faction that's
really hard to make mechs but you can upgrade really easily in that case you change your plan accordingly it's got a whole bunch of cool stuff going on there's a lot more and I think I've probably talked about it enough at this point but I am very excited to play this game more now that I played it a little bit I essentially needed a little bit of a taste to see what was going on and now that I see how much is going on and how simple it's all cut up into little bite side pieces but how much uh depth and potential for strategy there are in the game I'm very excited to give this one a lot more attention so now let's go into my gameplays of note segment and here I'm going to talk about specific sections of games that I played and why they stood out to me the first of these is a game called stone garden and right off the bat I had never heard of this game before I went down I do a twice a year trip 500 miles south I drive down to spend a long weekend with some college friends and play a bunch of board games and just hang out and see their kids and all that and when I arrived there one of them had borrowed this game called stone garden from a co-worker and she asked me what I thought about it and I said I've never heard of it and then I saw the bits and I was blown away it is this gorgeous production game of Thailand where you're putting little tiles down that have like raked sand patterns on them and then you were placing these amazing Stones down I genuinely thought they were actually made of stone at first then I picked them up and saw they were flat on the bottom and they're obviously made of some sort of plastic but they are gorgeous like the entire production quality of this game is really cool so then I started reading the rules and it was um published in Japan and it's quite difficult to find it actually and it's
also quite difficult to find a good set of translated rules online so I read a couple different ones and we ended up playing it for the most part correctly and the big thing that stood out about this game it's a Thailand game is that you it's a little bit different than standard Thailand game where you draw Thailand you put it down and then and you where you put it is what matters in this game you can actually give tiles to your opponents you can say hey do you want this tile it's not very good for me and if they take it then you get some virtue points which are essentially a currency that let you place the stones in your garden and if you never give tiles away you're probably not going to ever get enough virtue to place as many stones in your garden as you'd like so it has this interesting Cooperative nature where you might say oh who wants this tile and a couple people say they do and then you decide who you're going to give it to and then you have a win-win situation the flip side is if you say I don't want to give this style anyone I want to put it in my down in my area somebody could say you know what I'm going to steal that tile from you and it's going to cost them virtue and again you need virtue to get those stones and that's where most of the victory points comes from is placing those stones in your garden and where you specifically put them so you lose that tile but you gain a bonus of consolation prize of virtue so it kind of helps and they lose virtue in the exchange there are several other things going on here but I was really impressed with the game the overall idea of being able to give tiles or steel tiles but the penalty for having a towel stolen for you is not that bad because getting a bunch of virtue is really good it can be kind of frustrating you're like I just need to do more virtue to put this massive Stone down and it's going to give me lots of points uh at the end of the game I had this gorgeous little
stone garden in front of me I felt great about it and I ended up winning with that stone garden it seemed like the person who has the better looking stone garden is probably going to win which is a cool thematic tie-in and I've talked about this one a little bit too much it's just a very interesting game that I'd never heard of and I wanted to let you know about it next up we have Mombasa I was super excited about this game in the last Vlog and I finally got my copy and I've played it once with other people and then I played it a second time as a solo three player game and then recorded a full playthrough of it that you can actually see on my channel so talking about that game with my opponents it was an interesting experience I enjoyed it overall but I was a little surprised at how heavy it was I was told it was kind of a heavy game but man this is a seriously thinking game you're not going to be joking around too much with your friends while you're playing it everybody he kind of spent most of the game staring at their area and staring at the board and looking back and forth trying to figure out how they can get to where they want to go because there are so many interlocking moving pieces I ended up coming in third I ended up losing the game and realistically it was my fault this game is about kind of getting influence in four different companies and I went out on my own too much I went crazy influencing one company and the other two players didn't care about that company because they were ignoring it they were doing other ones so that company got beaten back and I didn't give very many points for it realistically I think you need to do some piggybacking with what the other people are doing and I didn't do that I was gunning for a special ability it didn't really pan out for me uh so I enjoyed the game even though I came in last and I'm looking forward to playing it again uh it was a bit long at three players uh it was like three hours and
15 minutes but none of us have played it before so I am interested to try a four player game where things will be a lot more clustered but I think before that I want to try a two-player game maybe with one of those people I will play with four players to keep the downtime and the general length of the game low and next up is Quinto which is a very different experience than the Mombasa gameplay uh this game has three different color dice in it and a pad of scoring sheets and some pencils and that's it it is essentially the big brother to Quicks it's produced by the same company that makes Quicks and I was very excited to give this one a shot once I read the rules because it seemed like a very simple dice game that had a surprising number of decisions so I've now played it um uh two players and six players but specifically I want to talk about those six player games uh it was a surprisingly engaging and Loud fun experience first of all it's a fun game in general you are doing lots of things every single turn somebody rolls a dice and everyone around the table gets to write numbers down on the little pad and where you write them down is going to have significant ramifications on the future so you want to think about where you're going to put it and you usually have quite a few slots especially in the early game what I wasn't expecting is how many stand-up die roll type situations there were because since when that person across the table rolls the dice you get to use it you are so vested and you're like begging them like no no no don't use the orange side you the yellow and the purple dye and you know and then somebody across the table is also begging for something else and they roll the die and while the dice are bouncing around you're like please be a six and then if it ends up being a six you just stand up you're like yes and you feel so engaged it wasn't even your
turn like that other person across the table decided what dice to roll but man you're just so vested and uh the game has a re-roll mechanic uh where if you roll the dice you don't like it you could roll it again which seems like on its face to be a luck mitigation Factor but what we found is it was a awesome sense of tension because somebody would roll the dice and it would be the number you want and do and you'd see them go to reroll it and you just be so heartbroken or you would see them re-rolling and they'd get the number you wanted and you're so happy there was I was really surprised at how engaged and uh fun the overall experience was we played it back to back with six players uh last weekend or so so I'm looking forward to playing this one a bunch more the sessions I've had have been quite a bit of fun now let's talk about deception murder in Hong Kong I played this a few times but specifically I played an eight player game of it last weekend and uh just to give you some background this is a hidden roll Style game where most of the people are investigators but one person is going to be the murderer and then one person knows who the murderer is they're trying to communicate that to the rest of the people uh using a very abstracted Shackled uh voiceless system where they put little tokens down onto boards with a bunch of Clues on it and so it might be like um what was the person wearing and you could talk about how you know they were wearing nice clothes or shabby clothes or they were naked and they could try to figure out what that means as too far as how this person was murdered and where because every person has several pieces of evidence and several pieces of murder weapons in front of them so what ends up happening you don't argue about who was the murderer and who wasn't you just say I think they used this weapon and this
key piece of evidence points to that person being there uh to one person and if you are the murderer and somebody does that to you you just make a good argument for somebody else's There's No Malice that when you acute when you make an um accusation about something or even just postulate that it might be this kind of thing over on that other person they never get you know bristled and like no it can't be me it's another person they usually say that's a pretty good point uh if you look over there there's also this other thing so it's like a very pleasant experience so anyway the a player game we threw in extra roles you could throw in an accomplice and a witness so the accomplice is kind of on the murderer's side and the witness is on the investigator side um the accomplice is um they wins it they win if the murderer does and the witness knows who the accomplice and the murderer are but they don't know which uh and at the end of the game if the murderer is found and they can say who the witness is then they still win so the witness needs to try and guide people towards one of the two people that they know is the murderer without being too obvious about it and I was a little worried about this um adding in all these extra roles and everything but it ended up being a really good play of the game we won on the last uh guess of the game I thought for sure we were going to lose because there's so many pieces of evidence out there but the final guess that somebody made won us the game and then they couldn't guess the witness it was a really fun experience and in general I've had fun with deception I'm probably going to be doing a full review of IT relatively soon but this specific play I was happy to see how well it was at eight players the box says it plays four to 12 players and it looks like that's probably a relatively accurate assessment and lastly we have safranito which I
played at Victory point games down in Berkeley they had it in stock this game came out quite a while ago and I saw the Dice Tower review of it and I was pretty intrigued because it's a dexterity based Euro game where you are throwing chips down onto the board and where they land will let you buy goods and sell Goods so you're trying to buy low and sell High obviously and then you actually make different sets of goods but you also need to be able to land this disc on a certain spot on the board to even have access to it and the disc has a hidden aspect to it with some numbers and based off of how many people land on that will increase the how much it sells for and there's a whole bunch of weird things going on so I was happy to get a four player game of this done and I I lost by a very large amount because I was not playing correctly I don't think I mean I was playing correctly but I spent most of my money on getting my first card because what you're trying to do is there's you win if you get three of these set collection cards and so you're trying to buy low sell High to get money but realistically you just need money to buy the correct things in order to make those sets work like having a lot of money they get in the game doesn't matter and I was dumb I spent like all of my money in the maybe a third of the way through the game and then I spent the next third of the games trying to get some money back and by the time I was rolling again somebody won the game but it was a weird experience I feel like two out of the four players wanted me being one of them enjoyed it quite a bit I'm intrigued to try it again and then the other two people were pretty lukewarm and I could probably convince him to play it again but not necessarily because it really is a weird situation like you're you have this Euro east side
where you're trying to buy low sell High make sense you know what's what are your opponents going to do can I get there before they do but then also you can just throw your chip down and miss and all your plans are gone you know or you'd hit it and then somebody else throws theirs down and it knocks yours out and it's like oh crap now I can't do anything with that my plans for this turn are kind of borked so it's a weird mental dichotomy that I found a little bit refreshing and definitely a bit goofy it was a quick game like 40 minutes so if it was too much longer than that it would probably start to overstay it's welcome with its wonky weirdness but I enjoyed playing it I hope to get it out again and now for the last segment which is new games have acquired since the last time I did one of these Vlogs I only got 10 games over the last month and a half which is actually pretty good for me I'm trying to pull back on the reins a bit and one of this seven of these games came from one big order from card house where I got like Mombasa Nippon signorier Dimension a whole bunch of games and as you can see over there there there's quite a few different games that I've got and I was looking at it and I played almost all of these now in fact I think the only one I haven't played yet is signorier and I'm hoping to fix that in a week or two so I feel pretty good about getting these games onto the shelf and then getting them onto the table at least once uh I I've enjoyed everyone like none of these have been a stinker yet you might have noticed that I had no uh disappointed with section in this Vlog because I have not played any bad games in the last month and a half which is pretty cool like I feel very fortunate to uh be able to say that so uh yeah let's uh wrap this thing up thank you for watching this Vlog I hope you found it interesting uh once again if you have
any questions you'd like me to answer in future q a sessions please uh either email me or put a comment down in this uh YouTube video there's all sorts of ways I'll throw it in and I'll get it answered if you'd like to see more Vlogs like this one as well as in-depth board game reviews and full game playthroughs please subscribe to my channel you can also directly support the channel at patreon.com John getsgames thanks for watching