13 Board Game Reviews in 25 minutes! - Keep or Cull!
Transcript
Hello everyone. This is Johannes
and this is Cinear
and you are watching Board Gaming Ramblings
and welcome back to Keep or Cull, the series where we play all of the games and tell you if we keeping them or culling them.
Yes. While giving you mini reviews so you can decide if it might be a game for you or if it might not be a game for you because we are at the limit of our games. So if a game is going into the shelf, if it isn't the small one, we can fit in somewhere, it need to basically take the space of something else and it's not going to come to the point where we know like when we keep something, we're not going to say like, oh, it's keeping this and we have to cut this other thing, but it's we're basically almost at a one out, one in, but we do have the floor as well. So with that said, we are jumping into I think we have like 13 games today. Yes. Are you ready? Do you want to begin as always?
Let's do it. First up is picking backers.
Okay. Are you ready?
Yep.
One, two, three, boom.
It's a double code.
Yes. I was a bit unsure because this was a weird game and I do like some weird oink games. Basically, it is kind of like a dexterity game for two people and the other people are kind of betting on how well they will do. Yeah.
So, it's kind of weird because there's only two players playing at the same time, but you are excited for what's going to happen. There is this drone. We can show it, I think, depending on where it is in the box. There is a drone and as always, it's very easy to pack this. I think we can't show it. There is
under all of the other stuff.
There is a little thing that you have to put one finger each and trying to move it from space to space while stacking things on it.
It's very hard. We were very bad at it, but it was a fun one, but not fun enough.
I agree.
And now I'm doing the wrong thing again because that was your game, so you were supposed to speak about it.
Let me know about it. I agree with you. Um I can speak about the next game.
Oh, but then we're in in sync. Okay. Next up is Hen House. This is a card game. One, two, three. Boom.
It's a double curl. Hen house is uh shedding game.
Climbing shedding game.
Yeah. Climbing shedding game. And you have like uh two suits. Four suits.
Yeah. Two suits. Brown and white. And also inside of those.
Yes. eggs and chickens and
two cars
and
it was not very exciting.
No, it was a game.
It was a game.
Not a lot to say. It was
It was not bad, but it was not
like the the twist is that like you have these critters that you can take that can like break the rules. But in a world where there's so many trick taking and shedding games, this was just one of them.
They didn't make it.
Next up is
Mongoose. goose with an eaten band on it. Are you ready?
Yes.
One, two, three, boom.
It's a keep from me
and a cow from me. You can talk about it because that's
it's my game. Well, this is a deduction game. Yes.
And it's a quite simple and fast one, which I think it's its main strength because I've played other deduction games that are more interesting. Yes. But um this game you just have like cards in front of you and you know what the other players have of animals and like color of the animal and then you can already begin crossing out your possibilities. When you um are interact with the other players animals, you will get information that will help you figure out what animals you have in front of you.
Mhm. For me, the biggest flaw of the game, it's a short game, which is a good thing, but there is very easily in the setup. Some players might know a lot about what they have, and some players, like what happened to me a couple of times, might know nothing.
Yeah,
almost nothing because of how the cars are laid out. So, that was kind of frustrating because you will be like, there's no there's literally literally was no way for me to win.
Well, that's I think
that's not true.
Okay, I would win. No. And I'm not saying you would likely to be winning. That's not a word. But yes. Um, but in this game, you have another chance at winning than guessing what you what animals you have, which I also think is nice because if you're not that super good at that, you can take some chances and be a little lucky and you can try to collect the most food because you'll get food when you attack or uh def win a combat basically.
Yeah. Basically, you also need to know stuff to be able to do that
or just have be a little lucky.
Yeah, but that sounds not like the way you're supposed to play the game. So, do what do you want to do with it? Do you want to keep it?
Up to you because you're the keeper and I'm the keeper.
We already have some deduction games in the collection.
Yes.
That we are not playing. But if I'm going to play a deduction game, I might go for like Search for Planet X or something instead of this. So, I'm okay with calling it up to you. Also, the other flaw of this game is that you can tell other people what cards they have. Not
It's not a game flaw. It's a player flaw that you like, I'm going to take my card against your snake. Like, I'm not supposed to know that's a snake. Uh, that's like big part of the story to make it fun.
Uh, yes. So, you're killing it.
Yeah.
Next up is another oink game. It's Tropic Chaos.
Mhm.
H. Are you ready?
Yeah.
One. Do you need a paddle? Yes. Yes. One, two, three. Boom.
I'm calling it.
And I The thing is with this game,
yes, I'm okay with calling it. I played it three or four times and I'm I'm kind of like I'm happy I played it those times.
But it's a fun game.
I'm happy I got to play it more than once. It is a push your luck game. H it is maybe after play it three or four times, I kind like I feel like I've seen what it has to offer.
Basically, on your turn, you will draw the tile. There's three tiles laying face up. You will draw the tile or you will sell tiles. And if you have a odd number of times, you have to sell them all. If you have an even number, you can sell even either half of them or them all.
It's fruits basically.
It's fruits. Yes. And what you are trying to do is because some fruits are better to sell in the summer uh or or in the spring. And then there's this uh tracker basically that changes the seasons. And every time you draw a specific tile, that that tracker will move forward. And it's random when that happens. So you're trying to push your luck to try to get tiles and then try to sell them before the season ends. And it is a fun one, but I'm I'm I'm okay with calling it because of all the games.
And next up is Penguin Kaboom.
Yes, this was a review copy from Parallel Games. Are you ready?
Yeah.
One, two, three, boom.
It's a double cow.
We're on a cing run today. Um, Penguin Kaboom is a a co-op game that is fairly chaotic because it's real time and you're rolling dice and you're trying to diffuse a bomb and you're trying to basically match up dice with different symbols on a segment to turn it over to have completed that one and try to complete the next one. And also in addition to that, you have some dangers which requires you to spend some dice on that if you're if so to prevent them all from dangering.
Alerts is the name of them. I think that this was good. I think that it reminds me a lot of fuse. You remember Fuse?
Yes.
Uh it's in the same vein. It's even more chaotic. It is a chaotic and it has uh there's three different levels of difficulties. You can make it easier or hard depending on who you play with. And there's 15 missions. Some people see it and think it's kind of like bomb busters, but it's a a real time chaotic game. Like you're rolling dice and and there's an app. You have to use an app and the app will always like choose who's playing. So it's a lot of oh, it's your turn. You do the thing. And so I thought it was chaotic fun, but I don't know when I will reach for it on the shelf.
It works surprisingly well with I think we played it at the max player count.
Five, I think. Maybe six. I think we were five.
Yeah, I'm not sure. two, three, four, maybe six or six, but I think it will work well with two as well. Less chaotic will be more fun with more people.
Yeah, I think so, too. But, but that was a fun game.
Was that your game? Yes. So, now it's over to me. Now, we have Quadro Trick Taking.
Are you ready?
Yes.
One, two, three. Boom.
It's a double keep.
The first double keep of the day. This is a really fun trick taking game. Uh, this is not for the first time you play tricking games. No. Uh because this game is three to four players and every round, let's say with four players, you're going to play four rounds. You're going to have different ways to bid. So uh let's say I have this specific way to bid. I will have to bid that I will my the numbers I win tricks with. It's going to be between um 21 and 29 or it's going to be four. That's my two bits. And if I match one of those two, I'm going to get some points. And then next round that's going to go over to you and I'm going to get another one. Maybe I get a hand of five mission cards and they are double-sided. There are 10 different missions. I can choose as many as I want. And if I manage to do all of them, I will get all the points. If I don't manage to do it, I will get nothing. Then it's the third one where you are bidding on how many tricks you're going to win, but you're also bidding on which colors you're going to win the tricks in. So, you can choose to bid like blank, which is basically a trick, or specific ones, which going to be worth more points. And then the fourth one is that you are going to bid on um things you're not going to win.
So, let's say I'm going to say I'm not going to win any tricks with blue or red and I'm not going to win any tricks with even numbers. Let's say I do that. That's going to be because of that's going to be four points. Don't care about why, but that's the rules. For each trick, I do win. So, it's a very unique game
and it's kind of like it's kind of like four trick taking games in one.
Mhm.
Because this could have been four trick taking games with different bidding mechanisms. So, this is a very unique one. A really good one. H very happy that I did back this one on uh Kickstarter and I'm excited to play it more.
What I also think is cool is that you are seeing what the other players are trying to achieve. So you can also try to outmaneuver them to make them not get the goal that they want to.
First keeper of the day. Let's move on to the next game.
Uh let's see
what is the next game. Do you have a game?
Three tricky pigs.
Three tricky pigs. Are you ready? Yeah.
One, two, three. Boom.
It's a double kill. But this was clever, I would say. Uh, first off, I like the theme. I think the theme fits well with the mechanism of the game. Like, it is trick. What? Yes. And what does it have to do with the three pigs and the wolf, you ask? Well, they're corresponding kind of with the with the numbers of the suit. Yes. And um
and the suits like the different there is a yellow and a brown. And the last trick
is a brick.
This brick is red.
Yeah. And that's better against the wolves.
Yes. And then you they have different numbers. So it's not like a 1 to 12 in each.
And then there's always the lowest number that wins. But if there is a wolf in the trick, then the highest number wins. And it is a must follow.
And you're trying to u predict what you're going to get at the beginning of the game. you're trying to see like, oh, I'm going for zero tricks this turn or I'm going to win the most tricks. Problem with this game or what makes it interesting really is that the higher cards could be bad.
Yeah.
And the lower cards could be really good and
depending on what you want as well.
Depending on if it's a wolf there or not,
which makes it a little hard to predict that stuff.
Yes. But it's also like one of those where you depending on when you play it more I think like when you are in the round it's going to be like it's more more open to somebody playing a wolf now and do I have this oh no then I won suddenly it's a very very unique one. It's kind of on the edge of keeping it or not but there's so many trick taking games and we can't keep them all.
Yeah.
Next up is another trick taking game. This is big wave. Let's do it. One, two, three. Boom. Big wave, small fun. This is a must not follow trick taking game. And it sounded great from the rules because you want to be able to not follow or you want to be able to not play because then you play a charact card face down that's going to go into your trick pile in your scoring pile. And every time somebody wins a trick, they are going to move that scoring marker forward. So the more tricks won with a color, the more points it's going to be worth. And then everybody who doesn't win the trick, if they don't chill out and play face down, if they can't not follow, will be able to choose an action or an ability. It felt a bit like it was a bit lagging like because it's like, oh, we play these cards and now we got to do the abilities. Oh, you do ability first and I do it and then you and then you won the trick. We move that up and then we do it again. And it felt more forced than many trick- taking games. And just in a in like bottom line, I did not have a lot of fun.
Yeah, it was it was a game.
Was it okay? It was a game.
It was a game.
Do you have another game? I think you do.
It's solar eclipse.
A trick taking game.
It's another trick taking game. We're soon done.
There's going to be also less of them. This is we we gone through most of the ones from Spiel. Now we do have a pile of play like 20 30 ones, but we're not going to do all of them at once. So, if you hate trick taking games, there's going to be other games as well. Are you ready? Yeah.
One, two, three, boom.
It's a double kill. It's a pretty unique game, I would say, because you're getting uh a hand of cards and it has only two suits and you're bidding um or anticipating how many tricks you're going to win. And if a player leads with uh the knight or moon, you have to follow with the moon. But the one of the cards can be faced down or will have to be faced down.
So you're playing two cards which you didn't say uh which is like a main part of the game. You're playing one card round and you're playing one more card which is the same part of the game. And if it's a moon as you said the other one's going to be face down, not the chosen one. And if you play the solar one, the sol the the sun one, it's going to be face up.
Yes. But the thing is if you have the exact matching um number of the other suit, you're allowed to play that. And that is a trump basically.
It's a solar eclipse.
So, um, that was interesting.
I liked it a lot, but not enough to keep it in the collection. Next up is Arato. This was a review copy. Are you ready?
Yeah.
One, two, three, boom.
It's a double cow.
I I thought this was Okay. I thought this was a lot. It's one of those games where it's it's there like it doesn't it doesn't give me a lot of it I I don't I don't feel like it's not offensive like there's nothing offending about offensive about it. I think it's so very wrong about board games or very so very wrong about games. I think that's the name of the podcast. I listen to it. I just remember the name. I think they're saying that like there's nothing like it's not offending me like there's nothing offending with the game offensive with the game. My words you you you do things. You play cards. You get some cards in your hand. You play one card face down. It's going to go into like a little double of four cards. It has a specific place or places where it can be played. You're going to keep two cards which are basically going to be discarded to give you resources depending on the card. And you're going to basically send two cards to the other player. It's kind of a draft but kind of not because I don't never care about what you want to do. I just take the things that help me like because I I have enough with trying to make the things I want to get done done.
And then you are trying to fulfill these cards because they have a recipe on them. So it's a recipe fulfillment but you don't want to place it into the scoring part before you have to because they have an ability and as long as you have the card in your tableau you have that availability available to you. And then there's going to be missions that you're trying to complete to get bonus point bonus points. But I think they was going to be the same every time, which means
they were doublesided.
Okay, so two two different ones. Oh, no, there's four different. Yeah. Okay, that's at least good. But for me, I'm never going to play this again because it was not a lot of fun.
I liked it more than you. I think this is a fun game if you manage to play with snappy players and it goes like that. I think it was like a clever thing that you
What's Okay. No,
no, I I absolutely
no down time. It's us.
Well, but when Yeah, because you're playing simultaneously. But if you are playing with a slow player, well, we'll be downtown. Downtown
downtown. this game. If I got it like
in the beginning of my board game um journey, I would maybe keep it because it it's a fairly simple game, but it has like decision making in like which abilities I'm going to take and how how am I going to do the this thing or I'm going to focus solely on the missions and try to do that. But I agree. We will not play it.
I It wasn't bad. It was just nothing. It was I never need to play it in my life again. You have a small Oh, it's a trick taking game.
Bitcoin. Are you ready? One, two, three. Boom.
It's a color from me.
What? You're not allowed to call Bitcoin. One of the better trick taking games.
It was fun.
It's really good. It has basically one twist. Are you supposed to talk about it?
Yeah. I don't remember it to twist though.
It has basically one twist. It's a very basic straightforward trick taking game. There is one trump. You are playing cards must follow. But when you win a trick, you have to bid.
Yeah, that's
and you have cards in front of you. One, two, three, five, and seven, I think. And let's say I win a trick. The first trick I win, I can choose. Hm. Is that going to be the only trick I win? Let's say no, I'm going to go five. And now I have to win five tricks. If I do win five tricks, I get to score that five. And the point is to get all of them out of the game. Or I could do like a two, but then if I reach three, I will have to choose. Okay, do I think I will get to five and bid the three or do I want to get bit the one? And then you can also on your turn, you can bid zero. And then you have to bid cards. Basically, you rotate the cards h adding up to the number of cards you have left in your hand. Uh I think it's very good. I think it is a it's another one of those where it's it has a twist enough, but it's not one where I will teach and people be like, I don't understand it because the rules are super simple, but it has that pretty unique twist. Um, and I really enjoyed it.
It has a cool twist. I like the twist. Uh, that said, I think we have cooler trick taking games already in the collection. Um, it was fun. I just like can't keep them all. Trick.
No, we're we're obviously keeping it. We kept two games so far this round, so it's it's going to be okay.
Next up is a bigger game, 12 Rivers. This one I've been looking at since it first came out. This is the second edition from Good Games Publishing. Uh, and it is one that you when you see pictures of this or if you see it on the table, you will be you will be looking at it because it has this big 3D thing where marbles flow down. And let's talk about it. This was a review copy. Okay. One, two, three. Boom.
It's a double cow.
It is. I really I enjoyed my time with this. Me, too. I uh for me it's a bit light but I'm very happy we got to play it because it's light but it is to the point where I feel like my decisions are meaningful. I feel like there is there is a lot of great interaction because you will it feels like kind of and you said this as well feels kind of like a very light nice version of barrage or barage which because you have these marbles and they're supposed to fall down and the more I pay with my cards in the hand which is hard to get back uh the higher up on this river I can place my my tokens and when we open up the floodgates it will stop there and I can get the first pick of a marble. So, if there's something I have to have, you can get that if you pay for it, or you can risk it and go all the way down in the bottom and hope that things go down there and you get it for free. Uh, and I really enjoyed it. Then there are the cards that you get and those cards give you abilities if you discard two of the same card. H, and there is there's a lot to like in this game.
Fulfillment. Yes, I think that and goals that you rush to which also is hard because you're trying to you have to have the bond paka and if you have too many there you can't get more.
I think that this is a great game
for for the right people. I'm not saying like I knew when we got this is not going to be like a heavy big game, but I this is one of the one of the better light games I played this year. I really enjoyed my time with it, but I'm not going to keep it. I agree with basically everything you were saying. I think that it has a lot of tension, which is my favorite thing about this game is that you're thinking, "Oh, I really need that color, but I don't want to pay three cards to go all the way to the top. Maybe I should try to set one there and one with the other color and hope that at least one of them will be mine to take."
Yeah.
And sometimes u you will not get that. Sometimes you will not get anything. But that's very seldom, but that thing made me think about marriage.
Absolutely. And now we only have one game left.
And it's the biggest of them all.
You could also just take the lid, but you took the whole thing and pretty heavy.
It is luier. This was another review copy. Uh, are you ready?
Yes.
One, two, three. Boom.
It's a keep from me. I'm surprised to see a call from you.
Yes. I must do surprises from time to time as well.
Yes,
it's very big. You're placing it in front of my face.
K Johannes
Luther is a first off I have to say a really beautiful game. It's it has f my
one of your favorite artists.
Yes. made artwork for this game and it has a nice theme and I like the worker placement planning in this game because you're um placing workers but they're face down so you don't see what the other players yes you're basically blind bidding and you
the higher number you have on your worker tile disc yes uh the earlier you get to do the action. So sometimes it's really important to get to do it first because you need some really specific things to fulfill your goals in this game. And sometimes you don't want to be first, but you want to move up on that track so or get the bonus for that space. So you want a high number there. But everything seems so important all the time. You need to do everything and you won't get to do that. No. So, it's a it's a challenging game. We played it with four recently and
it's too long with four. I will never play it with four again. No,
I think it was good at two and I think it is good at three.
I think you need three to get like the tension of the bidding thing. There's a couple of reasons I chose cup.
Mhm.
First off is this.
It's Yeah, it's a big box. I don't know where it will fit. I don't know which other big game we are culling to get space for this.
Uh other than that, I Yes, it was way too long with four.
Yeah. Yes. Yes. Yes.
With that said, I really enjoy a lot of the things in this game. And when I'm thinking about it now, I'm like, I want to play it once more at least. So, I'm very happy with keeping it. We kept like this is what we kept this round.
So, basically, this was the
the keeper. So, I'm I'm I'm okay with keeping it for now.
Maybe. Yeah, I am.
It's maybe not a forever keep,
but I'm not done with it yet.
No, I I'm I will be happy to play it more.
Okay, let's make a little stack here.
So, those are 13 more games and we called 10 and we kept three two tricking games and and actually there was only one game we agreed on which was a C. We agreed on a lot of the capes.
So, which is your favorite and least favorite? I think least favorite has to be hen house and favorite has to be quattro tricktaking.
Mhm. What about you?
My my least favorite I would say big wave. I wasn't too keen on that. And yeah, Luther was my favorite.
And that is going to be the end of this video. We hope you enjoyed it. If you did, you can
subscribe
because it's
cool.
Yay. And that is the end. Thank you so much for watching. I'm Johannes.
I'm SA. And you've been watching Board Gaming Ramblings. And bye-bye.