Scarface 1920 Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Scarface 1920
Scarface 1920 is a 2023 game from Red Zen Games that combines worker placement, deck building, and area control with a Prohibition-era Chicago theme. Reviewers agree on its scale and presentation. The Dice Tower ranks it second on its top 10 list of gangster games and calls it a big, grandiose game that brings its theme to life. Watch Review describes it as a player hand management and area influence game in which you take the role of a gang boss in 1920s Chicago.
Opinion on how the game plays is far more divided. Board Games UnLocked ranks Scarface 1920 second on its list of the worst games of 2023, and a later video from the same channel gives it a 4/10 after a full playthrough. Quackalope plays through the game on camera with clear enthusiasm for its systems, while still complaining about the chaos of the time track and the way rival actions can undo a turn.
The consensus, to the extent one exists, is that the theme and table presence are strong while the mechanics can feel slow, punishing, and hostile to player plans. Most of the disagreement centers on how much player interaction the game allows and whether that interaction feels fair.
Core Mechanics That Define Scarface 1920
Area Influence and Crime Control
Players spread their gangs across the neighborhoods of Chicago, placing members, Thugs, and businesses to control districts. Board Games UnLocked argues that area majority is the game's core, but that it is not a true Euro, because job cards and police raids add take that to a design that would otherwise be about building your own gang. Scoring happens at the end of the game, when each player adds up the money behind their screen and then applies bonuses for the businesses they control and the associates in their hand, deck, or discard pile.
Deck Building Through Associates and Jobs
Players recruit Associates from a shared market into their decks, and each card brings an ability that can be used as an action. Quackalope's playthrough shows how quickly that snowballs. A Boss upgrade can let a player repeat abilities, and the Alderman can return all of a player's people from the authorities and the Underworld in one action. Jobs add a second layer of goals: players draw jobs, keep one, and complete it by meeting its requirements, and some abilities let a player ignore one requirement when doing so. Board Games UnLocked still calls the jobs fun, even while criticizing the take that they create.
The Scarface 1920 Experience
A Crowded, Reactive Table
Quackalope's playthrough is full of reactions. Bodyguards and cop cars move across the board, guns are spent to kill rival members, and speakeasies and brothels change hands within a single turn. Plans rarely survive a full round intact, and the game asks for constant attention to what every other player is doing. For players who enjoy reading the table, that tension is the appeal. For players who want to execute a plan, it can feel like constant interruption.
Pressure From the Time Track
The Extra Extra phase advances a time track and reveals two news cards that stay in play until the next Extra Extra. In Quackalope's game, beer protests doubled the requirements for making a sale, which forced a rethink of a turn already in progress. The reviewer described the time marker as the bane of their existence, and the phase's cascading effects, including raids that can be triggered by the track, make the end of each round feel like a second turn of its own.
What Makes Scarface 1920 Stand Out
A Theme That Reviewers Credit
Even the most critical reviewers credit the presentation. Board Games UnLocked gives the game a poor score but still calls the theme stellar. The Dice Tower highlights how much of the activity is tied to the setting, including hiring people into your group, running around the board, and engaging in illegal activities. Quackalope describes the box as big, beefy, and beautiful, which suggests that the production itself is a large part of the first impression.
Layered Options Within a Single Turn
Quackalope's playthrough repeatedly stresses how many paths are open in one turn. Players can move people, gain alcohol, upgrade dealers or lawyers, recruit, or strike at rivals, and the Boss's abilities add more on top. The Dice Tower describes the game as having a little bit of everything, combining worker placement with deck building and a strong theme. Meeple University explains a solo mode in which an automated opponent called The Enforcer has its own starting deck, Boss, and crime marker, so the same options are available to a player without other people at the table.
Potential Drawbacks
Take That and Pacing
Board Games UnLocked says that when a player spends an entire turn having actions wiped by a rival, the design is thematic but not fun. The same reviewer calls the game slow, boring, and long, and says that correcting a rule mistake did not change the overall verdict. Quackalope's complaints about the time marker and the Extra Extra phase point to a related concern about how long the game takes to settle into a rhythm.
Board Layout and Card Text
Board Games UnLocked dislikes the board layout once more than two players are involved, because some players cannot easily see the market. The reviewer acknowledges that this is not entirely the designers' fault, since a shared market is hard to lay out for a large table. The problem is more pronounced here, the reviewer argues, because the cards carry a lot of text and the market and actions sit on one side of the table, which slows down every hire.
If You Enjoy Scarface 1920
Players who enjoy Scarface 1920 for its area control and deck building are the audience Board Games UnLocked points to when recommending Tyrants of the Underdark. The reviewer calls it extremely solid as a deck builder with strong area control, and says the recommendation holds even for players who are not familiar with the Dungeons and Dragons setting. Players who value the mechanics more than the Prohibition theme will likely find similar satisfaction there.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"I love this theme. I think this is a stellar theme and they killed it."
— Board Games UnLocked
"It's big, it's beefy, it's beautiful in so many different ways. Has a lot of interesting gameplay and take that."
— Quackalope
"This is a big grandiose game, the biggest on my list. And I think it does a lot of fun bringing that theme to life."
— The Dice Tower