Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Top 15 Games We Played The Most in 2022 - The Cardboard Herald

Transcript 21:58

hello and happy New Year everyone it is 2023 and to celebrate here at the cardboard Herald we're going to go over the games that hit the table most in 2022 as is the now traditional review and reflection of the past year because this is the second time we've done this and two times establishes a pattern and therefore we can call it traditional but keep in mind I'm a reviewer and I play a lot of games even though my instinct would be to hit the same games over and over and over again I am definitely spreading my attention about as many games as I can in order to have content for the channel but I think it's still interesting to reflect on the games that I did repeatedly come back to whether or not that I had reviews associated with them for the channel and yeah sometimes that's going to be the quick and easy games but not always which I think says something in and of itself to have a large boat and heavyweight game hit the table repeatedly so with all that out of the way let's get started with our top 10 really top 14 games that I played the most of in 2022. coming in hot with a seven-way tie for seventh place we have wingspan sprawlopolis Santorini the Gilda Merchant explorers Doon Imperium cartographers and Agricola now wingspan is one of those Evergreen games in our

household my wife and I both really enjoy it she would rate it as one of her absolute favorite games it's something that is accessible and fits into a relatively narrow window now that we have a lot of experience with it and can knock out a game easily in under an hour but it still has some meat on its Paulo bones adding to this it has the appeal of the ornithological theme and the presentation feeling like it's straight out of a scientific book with certain Birds tax and a particular resonance between what the bird power is attempting to convey and the real-life biological behavior of the bird is really interesting and has not grown stale and of course this year we have the release of wingspan Asia and I'm counting the two-player mode of that as plays in traditional wingspan even if they are Standalone separate games or combinable in the traditional way of playing which I'll have a review of that incoming on the channel soon you can probably anticipate that this is going to be on the list for 2023 looking back from the point of view of 2024 as well now sprawlopolis I mean it's a button shy game it's so small and Compact and you can bring anywhere it's a game that I bring to conventions and brought on trips to conventions Liz here it was part of the travel kit and it's one that plays fantastically at coffee shops for it being a relatively late acquisition for me in this year getting around October I made sure to get this played again and again and as part of a review

but also because I enjoyed it that much there's something about the incredible ease of entry with the game the approachability the accessibility but that nuanced puzzle yeah having the different goals sometimes be in contention with one another can make it a little uneven in its challenge level but because you can play a game in about 15-20 minutes it just makes you want to play it immediately again Santorini is another one of these really small games where in truth seven sessions of this is probably more like two or three actual sessions where I made sure to break it out over the course of the year we just played it in sequence a couple times every time that it broke out Santorini to me is one of the all-time great abstracts and it's one that I don't think that I would get rid of my collection unless I were breaking it down to like 10 or fewer games when I think of anything compare terrible in that chest or go or showboo sort of Zone Santorini is the one that always comes to mind that I want to play the problem is there aren't that many abstract gamers in my life who really respond to this type of game so this is kind of a for me game that I have to force to the table but I always enjoy it when I do and usually my opponents do as well Gilda Merchant explorers is such a fantastic Riff on the traditional Roland right flip and right sort of game not having you actually have to write

anything you're using cubes you're using those Euro abstract pieces to spread yourself amongst the board and it feels like you're not really diving into anything until about a quarter of the way through the game at which point the complexity the the really satisfying meat reveals itself in terms of the the exploration cards that you acquire which are your unique powers which will repeatedly act in each of the following eras it's a fantastic way of kind of outfitting you with your personal asymmetry in a very simplistic system and always feeling like there are Stakes like you could reach out a little bit farther and if the cards just line up right you could get this Perfect combo but that could also break bad and you can alternatively do something much more conservative for as simple as it is I love the sense of agency that you have in the game I just wish it weren't the game that could absolutely break into chaos if someone bumps the table do an Imperium what more do I need to say it's that wonderful mix of worker placement and deck building with a little bit of auction building area control at the end of every round that just works together and is better than the sum of its parts yes there was an expansion that came out this year and I was excited to play that I mean immortality introduces one of my favorite aspects of Dune the the the Deep Dune lore that I wasn't anticipating having references to these things like chair dogs I mean they're talking about

Axolotl tanks in this expansion and if you've only read the first book or you've only seen the movies then you don't even know what you're playing with but nonetheless even if an expansion wasn't coming out I'm still very hot on this game and want to see it hit the table more often when I'm looking for something in that Lords of Water Deep ish level worker placement Zone this is the one that usually is my family's go-to cartographers well I mean it's a flipping right it's easy to get to the table but it's more meaty than a lot of flipping rights that you have and it's the one that's the most appealing to me it has that brilliant incredible theme having you make fantasy maps I mean that's what I've been doing anyway since I was like eight years old after every red wall book and every sort of Shannara or whatever book I read I wanted to just draw my own maps for my own fantasy worlds and this game empowers me to do that and still has not lost its charm after many many many many plays a lot of the charm does rely on you putting your own artistic Flair into the world and it's a game that every player could theoretically take the exact same move and sometimes moves are a little bit obvious so they're there's room for the cartographers to evolve a little bit but I still think that it's my favorite game in the whole role player Pantheon that's come out so far and it's my favorite Thunder Works game period is just a damn

good set and now we have all of these maps to play finally on the seven-way tie we have Agricola and to tell the truth the games I played of Agricola were predominantly solo plays Agricola is a game that I don't really think of as a solo game because of the contentious worker placement with other players but I discovered in the latest revised version of Agricola you have a campaign mode solo play in there that adds this interesting level of carryover from game to game to game with you being able to preserve one of your powers from the previous game which made it so much more interesting and compelling yes I have played it multiplayer a little bit this year but almost always I made sure that I was advancing on my Campaign which I am still working on and try to get back to when I get I don't know free hour hour and a half to myself to play some dang Agricola as the campaign goes on it starts feeling really constraining and really tight which really takes the efficiency boxes even more than the traditional experience ever did now to a two-way tie for sixth place we have Arkham Horror lcg and the king is dead which if you had asked me if an area control game was going to hit into my top 10 most played games of this past year or a combati area control whole game I would have laughed at you because those are just not the games that I get

to the table most often I like them I have a lot of them I really enjoy playing them but even games like Pax Premiere or root or small samurai Empire so my absolute favorite games they just do not hit the table as often as some of these other Euro games Campaign games uh abstract games but the king is dead is so beautiful and minimalistic having only eight cards having only eight rounds as you go through the eight power struggles only eight actions that anyone's playing and works fantastically as a two-player game it's a game that I always want to play and I'm always eager to have that chicken experience between players I like it at two players I like it at three the four player team mode is also pretty interesting but not my favorite way of playing and adding the asymmetric Loadout of cards where you have the same five cards plus three unique cards to yourself just takes it to a whole new level and this is one of those games so that I can get people to enjoy even if they don't like those traditional area control or dudes on a map combat games by detaching you from specific faction alliances it takes away from that sort of take that feeling that a lot of people want to avoid when they don't like these types of games it's so Machiavellian it's so accessible and it's so minimalistic I mean I'm going playlists a ton from here on out an arc more of the card game I played a lot of edge of the Earth I played a lot of the base game all over again we're in the middle of going through another playthrough of the base three scenario

campaign we have some new characters from the individual investigator packs that have come in the mail carrier is a fantastic character and I'm really enjoying that deck it's one of these games that continues to deliver and even though I thought the base scenario and even the expansion scenarios would get a little bit dull playing them over again both my wife and I have found that we've wanted to play them again just to see them from different points of view make different choices see the different characters it's continuing to give rewards and it's one of those that we go to when we're not in the middle of driving through some other campaign hey everyone sorry to interrupt the video but re recent events need to be taken into consideration it's New Year's Eve and I was editing this video to post tomorrow which you'll hopefully get to see unless something goes really awry but I realized that some of the order is a little bit off because I recorded this video maybe a week ago and since then I've played one more session of wingspan which means that it indeed is part of a three-way tie with eight plays but then a major disruption happened because I also got undaunted reinforcements so I was super excited to dive into undaunted North Africa and played three consecutive solo sessions of that and I'm kind of counting I I'm fudging the numbers a little bit because I like

undaunted so much I'm counting North Africa and Normandy together and yeah I got eight plays of it so undaunted comes in in hot for a surprise twist placement in the tie happening at eight plays what a game what an incredible system in general which I played a lot of the multiplayer but reinforcements introduce a solo mode that is honestly one of the best solo modes certainly one of the best combative or Skirmish shoulder modes that I've ever played it is it is ridiculously good and North Africa I can't wait to play Stalingrad it's on the Shelf over there anyway back to the video and here we are done with ties here we get to the accelerated number of plays where it jumps dramatically up from eight plays to 13 with Spirit Island and this is 10 with Spirit Island base and three West Spirit Island Horizons the kind of entry level Target exclusive version of spirit Island but I'm combining it all for 13 because that's a full-fledged version of spirit Island and that 10 base group had nothing to do with any sort of review content I just love Spirit Island that much one of my all-time favorite games I'm going to make sure that it gets to the table and even though it's a fantastic solo game the predominant amount of plays that I have with this are two player as for Horizons I love the new Spirits I think

that in spite of them being more accessible and easier to chew they still have a lot of thematic and mechanical individuality that makes them cool additions to base Spirit Island that I would want to play even against adversaries or some of the more difficult scenarios that the traditional the full-fledged game presents and that's actually one of my criticisms of Horizons as a pack in that it only presents vanilla Spirit Island without some sort of adversary without different blight cards without these different levers that you can pull and yeah you could say well you should be able to get the base Spirit Island if you want to move move on grow up from Horizons but as a standalone product I would have liked to see some more versatilities more replayability and not have it rely on just changing up the spirit Powers with playing the same old challenge over and over and over again nonetheless Spirit Island still an absolute Banger and still absolutely in my top three games I am going to be playing this I think for the next 10 15 20 25 years you're going to see a lot of spirit Island content on this channel as we go here at number four we have 14 plays of the oh so impressive Arc Nova probably my favorite game from 2022 so far there are a couple games that I need to knock off that list before I start doing any sort of end of the year wrap up which we traditionally do later on in the following year so expect that maybe

February at earliest more likely to be sometime around March where I'll reflect on on all of the 2022 releases I managed to get my hands on some of them came out late in the year and I'll talk about all that then but at least from first blush looking at it now Arc Nova just took me by storm you know that I'm a huge terraforming Mars guy and this absolutely delivered on all the best aspects of terraforming Mars for me and kind of overcame some of the worst Tendencies of the game that is also kind of combined with the fact that I really like Aries Expedition which just barely did not meet the list but nonetheless I really haven't had any drive to play terraforming Mars in spite of me long saying that it is one of my top three favorite games along with root and spirit Island and so where does that leave Arc Nova well I did review it this year so I made sure to get some plays in with this and I did play it three times solo this year but in spite of this being a bigger game which typically takes at least 90 minutes even as experienced players we made sure to get some business done with Arc Nova I love the synergies I love the tension between conservation and popularity I love the fluidity with the Action System when you really get rolling and utilizing them efficiently it just satisfies so many

boxes I like playing it solo I love playing it two-player my major criticism with the game is that it doesn't really achieve anything better by playing it at anything higher than two player it just becomes a longer game not necessarily a better game but as a two player game Arc Nova absolutely took my heart away like it it is now Bae and I love playing it with my bae number three is Marvel Champions because it's Marvel Champions it's so Poppy and quick and easy to play it's something to sit down and just bang out a couple games with and this is another one where the predominant amount of plays that I put in were solo because I love playing single handed solo with Marvel Champion so much though a lot of these plays were using the spider verse campaign and I played a lot of two-handed solo just to kind of get a feel for how the two Spider-Mans interacted with one another but this year I did a lot of campaign playing for Marvel Champions I did the Red Skull stuff I did the Guardians of the Galaxy stuff I'm just at the very end of the Spider-Man stuff and I got the X-Men stuff sitting on the shelf looking at me from behind the camera so I got a lot of Marvel Champions to play I do really like the campaign structure though I think in 2023 I'm going to be focusing more on just building decks and trying different new things with different characters rather than kind of locking myself in all the time but you know

we'll see how it goes it's still an absolute favorite I worried about it kind of growing stale when I first reviewed it back in 2017 or so but it's continuing to deliver I I really love Marvel Champions number two is another shorter game shorter than Marvel Champions but another Cooperative game and that is regicide the best game that you already own even if you haven't purchased anything called regicide because it's played with a standard deck of cards you could get the official regicide cards but the the standard deck of poker cards that you have sitting at home is going to work perfectly fine and it's amazing that I got 22 plays of this gay man with me only really learning about regicide in the last quarter of the year I made sure to play this again and again and again it's one of those ones where every time I lose I just want to play it again until I win and in spite of that I still had many many many many sessions of this I haven't played a lot solo it is usually just me telling someone hey have you heard of red side let's play this it's one of those games that's perfect to break out at lunch at the office if you have a co-worker who's willing to entertain you playing games or you have some friends who can come over to the coffee shop and play um and it's also one that's great to wrap up a session I played it some at Pax unplugged this year showing to other people and I even played it on an airplane absolutely over the moon with regicide

and it's my favorite game to play with a standard deck of cards coming in at number one is the game that I knew was going to be up here and yes it is another relatively short game or actually just is a short game coming in usually at 15 to 20 minutes I have a whopping 31 plays of Kabuto Sumo in this year and yeah some of that is review content we reviewed the expansion as a Kickstarter with the early prototype version and then we took a look at the expansion after it came out but this is a game where I was introduced at the very beginning of the year at platypuscon 2022 by Michael Dunsmore who did development work on the game and co-designed the expansion he's an Alaskan or part-time Alaskan he showed the game to me and I just could not stop playing in this game that is still one of my absolute go-to's to play with my wife to play with my son kids love it adults love it it just has this great feeling of tension and momentum and skill and dexterity and it's hilarious and thematic and unconventional it's unlike anything that I've ever played yet it is so intuitive to sit down and play it as soon as you see the first turn happen you're like I know what this game is all about but even after playing 30 games I'm still developing my skills with it love Kabuto Sumo and those are our games like we played in 2022 so many games and I'm interested in reflecting on it how many of these were Cooperative

games as I grow older more mature as a gamer I'm realizing that I'm spending more time with Cooperative games because I love the storytelling potential the uh interesting collaborative problem solving potential nonetheless there are a lot of competitive bangers in here but I want to hear from you what are the games that you got to the table most in 2022 what are the games that you most want to get to the table in 2023 and have you noticed any interesting Trends about your own gaming as you've developed as a gamer put it in the comments below and as always thanks for watching thanks for supporting thanks for being an awesome community and here's to a wonderful 2023 in gaming

Progress saved