Top 10 Favorite Cozy Games
Transcript
Hey, I'm Jamie with Still My Heart Games and I'm here with my co-worker Erica to talk about Erica, what are we talking about today?
We're talking about cozy game.
Yes, we're recording this in like late October. So it's it's all it's the fall season here in the US. It's all autumnal. It's it's a good time to think about cozy games. And we have a lot to talk about today. We'll talk about different angles of this as we share our games, but overall, what comes to your mind first and what were you kind of thinking about when you created your list here, Erica?
I love the cozy theme. Uh it's just one of my favorite things. Uh today is the perfect day to talk about it cuz it's actually raining outside here in Oregon, which is lovely and it's the kind of day that I want to play a cozy game. And I think that has a lot to do with it of like, oh, it's it's chilly outside. I want to bundle up with a sweater, blanket, and some a hot drink and play something that just feels uh maybe not gentle, but like like a warm hug, you know?
I like [clears throat] that. I like the words bundle up, warm hug. Um I I actually I don't think I even thought about this theme all that much uh until uh in terms in fictional in terms of fictional works until I read Legends and Lattes a few years ago. Uh it's a it's a great fantasy novel about running a a coffee shop. And I was reading it in the winter and I was like, oh, this is this is this is what I want right now. This is what I've been wanting for a long time in the winter. I want to curl up with a cozy book. And so it was fun to think about the cozy theme. I I think about the theme itself. The art can reflect coziness. Um I I think of something that's comforting, relaxing, probably low stress and tension. Um probably low interaction. The players aren't really messing with me, even though there can be other players at the table. I think that's totally fine.
And like you said, kind of I but I wrote down the phrase curl up with a book with a lot of cushions and hot cocoa. Like that is it doesn't have to be a game about that, but that the feeling that it gives me when I think about that sentence is what I look for in a cozy game.
Very much so. Well, I connect it with food a lot, too. Like a mac and cheese thing. Like I often describe some of my favorite shows as like, "Oh, it's my mac and cheese show." Like I know it maybe isn't the best thing ever like for me, you know, but it's just so cozy and comforting and yeah. And so, Legends of Andor Tales would be a good mac and cheese book and plenty of good mac and cheese games out there.
Well, in the comments, if anyone wants to throw in a bonus answer of what is your favorite comfort food, I'd love to hear about that in the comments, too.
[clears throat]
Ambassadors gave us some great responses, some of which we'll probably talk about more in our list, but a quick run-through of what multiple ambassadors said for this category were A Gentle Rain, Azul, Calico, Cascadia, Cozy Sticker Ville, Dorfromantik, Enchanted Ivy, Everdell, Flamecraft, Forest Shuffle, Harmonies, Harvest, King Domino, Mythwind, Ohanami, Parks, Patchwork, River Valley Glassworks, Wingspan, and Viticulture. We'll delve delve deeper into some of those games in a minute. And also, I asked Design Day attendee and friend Hilda. I think Hilda and I were talking about cozy theme at Design Day. And Hilda sent me her pick, so I thought I'd throw them out there. Thank you, Hilda, for these. She mentioned Pergola, Daydream, A Place for All My Books, San Juan Island, and Enchanted Ivy. Again, some games that we might see talked about in a minute.
Anything else you want to throw in here before we go to our panelist picks?
I love Hilda's picks. Those are all great.
Yeah. Well, let's jump right in then. Let's go with one of Hilda's picks is a game called Enchanted Ivy, and this happens to be our heavy gamer Dylan picked in this game. Dylan says, "This has been the game, Enchanted Ivy, that I played the most for the last few months. It's It's a nearly perfect cozy solo game experience for me. It's simple to set up and play, but really pulls you into the puzzle and manages to make you want to try scenarios again and again for the challenges and the high scores. The decisions as to where to place cards and guests are difficult, but they truly feel more cozy than stressful. I have not played this one. Do you know anything about this game? Have you heard about Enchanted Ivy?
I have I have heard about it, but I haven't got a chance to play it, but I think that line right there is such a perfect example of cozy of like the decisions are difficult, but it's not stressful.
Yeah.
That is the cozy game for me because I don't want something where I like turn my brain off and just kind of autopilot through something. I still want some interaction with the game, which is why Calico almost made my list. Similar sort of like very cozy theme, but still a lot to plan and think about. So, that is one of the perfect cozy games for me, really.
I like that that there can still be a level of puzzle and even a heavy level of puzzle to it if it has these other cozy elements to to the game. Our digital gamer panelists picked uh this is Garrett. Garrett picked uh Fields of Mysteria. Garrett says in a sea of Stardew Stardew Valley-like games, Fields of Mysteria has emerged as my favorite cozy game with gorgeous pixel art, lovable characters, and a world that genuinely feels fun to spend time in. One of its biggest innovations is easing some of the time pressure typically associated with the genre while also offering a deeper narrative, more charming characters, and a stronger sense of discovery and progression. The farming, exploration, decorating, magic, and relationship building all come together to create an irresistibly warm-hearted world that makes me want to simply spend time hanging out in Mysteria.
Uh have you played this one? Have you heard of it? Or I I think you have some digital games you're going to talk about in a few minutes, but uh
Yeah, I love Stardew. I played a whole lot of Stardew and this like is mentioned uh comes up regularly as a like oh, if you like Stardew, you should play this. I ended up going to Coral Island instead of this one cuz it's the same sort of thing of like if you like Stardew, you should play this. And that was the direction I went. And I haven't played my way through that one enough to jump to the next one yet.
It's kind of neat when a game resonates so much with people as Stardew Valley did. And there was a predecessor to that one, too, that I think came out a long time ago. The designer of Stardew based their game on, but it's neat when it spins off this whole genre that can scratch different inches.
Definitely.
Yeah. Fields of Mystery. I'm curious to try this one. Um Skylar So, we have a few unusual picks here, but I like the justifications. Skylar, our family gamer of all people, picked Murdoku. Um Skylar says, "Okay, so this isn't your typical board game, but hear me out. Murdoku. Yes, it is what it sounds like, Sudoku combined with crime solving. It is fantastic. It is the ultimate cozy game. Everyone gets a book, a blanket, and a square of the couch. Then you all proceed to work through puzzles at your own pace. There's no pressure, no take that attacks, no hardback chairs. It is the ultimate in cozy with a side of finding the culprit. It works great for families because the books successfully successively get more complex, enabling players to grow into the harder levels, as well as providing a sense of camaraderie when you solve it."
Have you heard of this? Have you played Sudoku? Do you Do you consider this type of puzzle to be a cozy thing to do?
Oh, totally. Yeah. I'd have definitely played a lot of Sudoku. It's one of my like, I can't sleep, I need something that's just enough to get my brain to focus on something thing that I pull up sometimes. Um I love the idea of Murdoku. I don't think that's one I could play before I try to fall asleep cuz I'd be thinking too much. Um but that sounds like so much fun. And it does it sounds like it's still cooperative in some way. It's not like you solve your own puzzle. Or I mean, you're solving your own Sudoku, but the murder mystery must connect in some way.
That is the part that I'm not entirely sure about. I can't tell if Skylar is saying that if they're working together or that they're each taking a different Murdoku puzzle and just doing them in the same space. I'm not exactly sure.
Interesting.
Yeah. We have two more panelists picks. Aaron, our solo gamer panelists, and we we there actually quite a few solo games that we're going to talk about today that are on these various lists, including Enchanted Ivey, mentioned before. Aaron says um picked Tend, the game Tend. Aaron says a not so simple farming game in the vein of the video game Stardew Valley, another Stardew Valley mention. Sure, Stardew Valley has its own very good board game, but Tend is the more cozy game in my opinion. Just pick a path or two you wish to go down, whether that's mining in the mines, fishing for fish, foraging in the forest, growing crops, or raising livestock. A cozy time will be had in this reveal and mark scratch-off dice placement game. There's a lot going on in this game. Uh I have played this one and I can It's one of those games where I see the theme as cozy as it relates to Stardew Valley, but I also found it to be a a pretty uh long game and a pretty thinky game. I I I wouldn't necessarily call my experience with it cozy. I'm glad that Aaron is having that experience in the solo play, but I was playing with three other players, and there was a lot of uh there was a lot of downtime that that maybe didn't make it feel as cozy to me.
But as a solo experience, maybe I could see it being very cozy. Have you Have you played this one, Ericka?
I haven't, but that like shows the the difference in other people's interpretations of cozy. Like Suzanne and I were talking about this of like cozy Calico is cozy to me, but not to her cuz it's too thinky for her.
Right.
And so similarly, your experience is very different from Aaron's in that. But I It sounds like one of your biggest issues was the amount of downtime, and that would be resolved with a solo version.
Exactly, yeah. And I think a long game can be cozy. I don't want to I don't want to say that's a a mark of it. And even a game with downtime can also be cozy. Yeah, I'm I'm glad Aaron mentioned this one. I think this has resonated with a lot of people who like heavier games. It brings the roll-and-write genre into a a heavy into a heavier game. Last up, uh Ericka, this is the first time that I think you may have heard from our new combative gamer panelist. So, Marco is our newest panelist. Uh and we added Marco because we don't talk about many combative games, games with direct conflict on this channel. And so I thought maybe we could represent that better. One of the first challenges I gave to Marco was Marco, can you think of a cozy game in the combative genre?
And Marco came up with the game Catapult Feud. Marco says I chose Catapult Feud because it brings back that childhood feeling of building castles and playing with toy soldiers. Except now you get to actually launch boulders at each other's creations. What makes it cozy to me isn't the absence of conflict, but the simple nostalgic experience experience of building your own little fortress, carefully positioning your soldiers, and preparing for a battle that feels more like playing with toys than fighting war. I particularly love how you can spend time planning your defenses and lining up the perfect shot, only for your boulder to completely miss or accidentally bring down half your opponent's castle creating those spontaneous moments of laughter. Despite being a game entirely about destroying your opponent's army, the competition never has to feel particularly serious because even losing is entertaining when everything comes crashing down in a spectacular fashion.
I love that that Marco found a creative way to answer this and I I I can totally see how the toy element to it and the nostalgic element of it plays into the cozy feel of Catapult Catapult Feud. Feud. Did any dexterity games occur to you with this? I I didn't even think about this category.
No, I don't either, but I I don't often lean toward dexterity games. It's not a genre that I that I like, but I think this toes that line really perfectly of like there's enough other stuff going on. It's not solely dexterity that this would be a game that I would enjoy. I played it did demo it at one point and enjoyed it cuz it was fun and silly and and very whimsical in that sense of like play with toys and then knock other people's things down.
Right. I would have part of part of that coziness too is the idea is the time of the game that you spend just building your space. During that time there's probably there's no interaction at all. You're kind of just playing with your toys trying to make something fun. You can see that being cozy.
Totally.
Well, huge thanks to our panelists for those picks. Before we get into each of our top fives, Erica, you have a few shout-outs you wanted to mention, and I have a few as well.
Yeah, um video games or digital games being one of them. Um I that is pretty much the only kind of digital game that I play is is cozy games. Um and I've got three that I absolutely love right now. Uh Tiny Bookshop is one of them, where you have a little hitch a little wagon up to your cart or to your car and go around town and sell books. Um and people will come up and ask you for recommendations, and they're real books, real titles that you can that you can sort through, which is a lot of fun. Um and then Librarian: Tidy Up the Arcane Library, where a fairy has come in and like thrown all of the books everywhere, and you have to go put them away. Uh and that has spawned a whole genre of putting things away games. Uh and there are lots of those coming out now that I'm really enjoying. Um and then Leafy Corner, where you run a little plant store. And all of those are very chill, very cozy, not stressful. Um except with the Leafy Corner, it does start making you water all of your plants. And if you as you grow your shop, you have to water a lot more plants.
I love those.
have any cozy you What was that?
I I do. Yeah, well, I like that you picked two books uh book-themed games. Both of us again, we said curl up with a book in a corner. I could see that being related to uh libraries and bookshops. I picked a game called A Short Hike. Um it's [clears throat] I think one of my favorite semi-open world games because it's a shorter game. It was it took me about 3 hours to play. I was completely enraptured in the experience. It has the pixelated art. I think that played into it a little bit, but it's basically you're wandering around an island, and it doesn't involve um uh like the type of video game dexterity where you have to like be really good with the controls. You just kind of move the mouse around. I I use my I played it on Steam. I love A Short Hike. It was it was very much a cozy uh experience for me to play through.
Um yeah, that would be probably my digital pick.
That sounds like a
another
Oh, yeah. Yeah, it's a good one. Um we both have honorable mentions and some Stonemaier picks. Which one do you want to do first?
Uh let's do Stonemaier.
Okay. [clears throat] Um I have So, yeah, I'm curious to talk to you about this. You I picked Wingspan Vantage and Tokaido as my picks. I think Tokaido is maybe one of the original cozy games that that existed in our modern hobby tabletop games. Uh Vantage to me is often times a solo experience. I'm happy to play with other people, but sometimes I just want to relax and wander around the Vantage world. That to me is very cozy to to me and comforting. And Wingspan, the art, the theme, um that one is very cozy. You picked one that I didn't actually think of as cozy, but I I agree with you now that you picked it. What's your pick for Stonemaier?
Wormspan. It's just the art gets me every time. The dragons are Some of them are beautiful dragons, but a lot of them are very cute and adorable, and I just want to take them home. But art, as you will see in my list, is a really big one for me. Um I I feel like having good table presence
[clears throat]
is important in a cozy game for me at least. Um and if it looks nice and the art is good or something is very cute in there, then it feels cozier to me.
[clears throat]
I totally see that with the art. I think the reason I didn't think of Wormspan is that it is a little heavier than Wingspan.
[clears throat]
But like you said, you you can have a thinky game and it can still be very cozy in terms of the experience it offers.
Yeah. Yeah, I was on the fence with Wingspan or Wormspan. They are both very cozy and they lean into that. Um but Wormspan for me is just just a little bit cozier for whatever reason. Um
Yeah.
Maybe the the birds are outside and it's cold outside right now, and dragons are just in dragon form, and that's they can be in cozy caves.
I have I mean lately I have been bringing Wormspan to every game night in the hopes that someone will want to play. We always have something else to play, so we haven't gotten to play it, but I think maybe there is something about this fall weather right now. I'm like, I want to cozy up and play Worms with somebody. So
Yes.
It was on my mind even though I didn't put it on my list. Um what are your honorable mentions before we get to our top five?
[clears throat]
Um Wanders Creatures, which didn't make the list because it does lean into the heavier side occasionally. Um and then the while the art on the cards themselves is very, very cute, the board isn't as cozy feeling, I guess. It's it has a little bit more of like cooler textures. Still gorgeous, everything is is beautiful. I love it. Um but didn't quite make the list for that reason. Uh Leaf is only not on the list cuz I just talked about it.
Yeah.
Um and then Tea Witches, uh which didn't make the cut because I think in the first game or two, it is much more thinky than you would want for a cozy game. Um but if I was playing it with a group of people that or a couple people that that knew the game, then it would be very cozy cuz you're just going around the the um area and gathering tea and bringing your tea orders out and it's very, very cozy. Um but there's so much going on, it's a very heavy teach, so.
Okay.
It didn't make the cut for that reason. But everything about it cuz it we've already mentioned or somebody mentioned Flamecraft already and same artist and designer and that sort of art style is very cozy.
That makes sense. Sandara Tang, I I think is the artist.
Yes. Yeah.
How about you?
honorable mentions, it was tough to cut this down to This is a list that I could have done a top 10 on easily. Um I'm glad we're we get to have this discussion though. And so the ones that didn't quite make the top five were for me were Earth, Forest Shuffle, kind of for the same reasons, a nature theme, fairly low interaction games. Everdell, largely due to the art. I mean, I think the art in Everdell uh the box to me says cozy when I look at Everdell. Um The Isle of Cats, similarly, cuddling up with a cat is something that I I love to do. Um Azul Summer Pavilion, if this was Azul like Autumn Pavilion, probably would have been on the list. It's very close though. I really love Azul Summer Pavilion. And Creature Caravan, that was one of the last ones I put on the list as I was going through my collection because it is a low interaction game where the tone of the art is cozy.
You're just kind of traveling together with your band of band of friends that you meet along the way on this journey. Um but you are also I think the thing that maybe took it down from number five was that you are fighting monsters in it a little bit which isn't all that cozy. But they're even kind of cozy monsters like they're kind of cute. So it's very close. Yeah, they follow you. They're just wandering around. Yeah, they just want to
They just want a friend. Yeah. So those were my honorable mentions.
I think all of those would have ended up in my top 10 as well. I really feel like Everdell and Wingspan kind of and I guess you mentioned Tokaido. Feel like those three did a whole lot to create the cozy genre. And and like advance that as a as a thing for board gamers and not just video games.
Right. I agree. Yeah. Um let's get to our top five. What games did make our list? Let's start with your number five pick.
Even Glow was my number five pick. Um mostly because of the art. It's just so beautiful. Um I it is similar to Calico more on the thinky side because you really do have to plan as you're playing because you're placing things in a mirror spot. And the number of times that we screwed this up in the first game was numerous. Um like
this goes here and then oh no, wait. Hold on. Got to find the numbers and match them up nicely. Um but like just creating a garden and uh to with the intention of making potions, it just felt very cozy. The uh the art did is amazing. Clementine did a beautiful job and so that is mostly why this is in my top five.
The Clementine being the same artist as Wingspan. So you get her her watercolors uh her paintings have this very much a cozy feel. One thing too that I think this game does really well to add to the cozy feel is that it is it it isn't a turn-based game. And I think we we will have we definitely have turn-based games on our list. That doesn't mean a game can't be cozy. But in this game, because of the puzzle aspect, I like that we are um I I guess we're taking turns, but we're all doing something on every turn, and we're doing the same thing essentially on every turn, where I don't feel rushed. If this was a turn-based game, I think I would feel external pressure to like hurry up and get on with figuring out my puzzle. But because we're all doing it at the same time, we're kind of just relaxing. There's more It's more relaxed feel to figure out that puzzle. Really smart choice, I think, on the part of this designer.
That is such a good point, and you're absolutely correct on that. Like having the the little spot where it shows who gets what in that turn is really interesting. But like you said, having it be simultaneous play was definitely what made this a less stressful game, um because we are feeling like, okay, well, everybody's trying to do this at the same time, so I can take a moment to figure out what's going to be most ideal for my garden. And it was interesting, both times we played, I ended up doing a lot of my cool colors on the cool night side, and the warmer colors on the like without even planning it. It's like, oh, that's interesting.
That's neat. I want to do that next time I play. Yeah. So, that is Even Glow at your number five. My number five is an animal themed game called Otter. Fairly recent play, uh so, it's just been on my mind, but it this to me is cozy largely like if you look at these otters, they're so cozy. Look at them. They have little little uh things that they plan to eat, or friends that they're going to play with on their bellies, laying on their bellies. Uh so, the aesthetic is a huge part of this. Um what what you're actually seeing here is is uh this the shared interspace interface of the of the game are these three tiles on the top that determine the types of cards that you're allowed to play into the corresponding column. On the bottom are the suits of the cards, frogs, crabs, or clams.
And in the middle is where you're playing cards, you're shedding cards into one of these three columns when you're when you're playing uh when it's your turn. Um and it's it's a shedding game, so it it has a little You talked about the feel of uh putting things away, putting things in their place and where they go in a library. Shedding game uh gives me the feel of that. Like I I am I'm getting rid of these things that I not necessarily that I don't want, but I'm I'm like tidying up my own hand by playing the game, by getting rid of the hand of cards, and putting them on these cozy-looking cute otters. Does that make sense that I have uh
Purging almost?
Yeah, yeah.
Yes. I have always felt shedding games are difficult cuz similar to deck builders of like I it's forcing me to get rid of something, but having that different mindset of like I'm putting it away is really interesting. And this definitely seems like it gives you that feel of like I'm putting this thing away. That's fascinating. I like that.
And you're not just putting it away, but you're putting it on the belly of a cute little otter. Like
It's so cute.
It's really cute. Maybe it's more of a cute game than a cozy game, but I find it cozy.
It's fantastic. So, I have a question for you. This game feels like the art design really is what makes it. And because you're like having the the cards go on the otter bellies is so perfect, and the graphic design and art is is fantastic for that. I know that when you designed Vantage, and I think Side, you were paying a lot of attention to the art, obviously, especially in Vantage. Have there been any other games that you've designed that you have really paid attention to the art side of things without or in addition to or alongside the design process?
Yeah, I would say for most of the games that I that I've worked on, I like to start the art uh while the at least the development of the game is still in the works. Um especially if it's a if it's a different world, because often times sketches or things that the artist will come up with. I know it happened with Euphoria behind me. It happened in Charter Stone. These world building elements of the artist ends up showing me from their own imagination have impacted things. I I know for sure I don't want to spoil anything but in Charter Stone like little things that the artist put on the board just as like set dressing. I was like, oh I want to know more about that and so I'm going to put that in the game somewhere. And that's happened for a bunch of other games, too. Yeah.
I love that. I feel like Charter Stone should have made my cozy stone wireless, too.
I Yeah, I think it is I I would I think it applies pretty well here, too. I have a game that's related to Charter Stone later on my list. Um what's your number four, Erica?
My number four is Creature Comforts and this is like Everdell kind of the epitome of a cozy game um because your goal is even to make your space cozy. And so the things that you're buying and purchasing along the way are to make your little den area a cozier space. And I it was just a lot of fun. I really enjoyed the um there was a little bit of simultaneous action but then um everybody is using the dice pool at at the top the left there uh to take their actions in whatever order they want and then have to put the dice pool back in the same number scheme um and it was just it was very interesting. There's a little bit of push your luck element to it because if you place you place your characters before the dice are rolled so you don't know for certain if you're going to actually be able to take an action that turn.
Um and so that was interesting but it didn't feel I feel like push your luck can take something away from a cozy game for me at least cuz I don't love gambling or push your luck or things like that sometimes but this was a softer version of it in in some way. Um and you still get a thing if you you get a little band-aid um if you didn't get something that turn because you didn't get the dice roll that you wanted.
Yeah. Just look at when when I brought this image on the screen even uh I I it it kind of glows me. There's such warmth to the game and it it's conveyed like you say in many of the mechanisms of the game as well including compensation if you don't get something that you wanted. That to me is a is a cozy comforting thing. Like don't don't worry. We'll The game's going to take care of you. You'll be okay. I I really like that about Creature Comforts. Yeah. Um so yeah.
very cozy. I love it.
Very cozy game. Great picking number four. My number four is a much smaller game than this. I picked Tussie Mussie. Started out as just an 18-card game uh by a Wingspan designer Elizabeth Hargrave published by Button Shy. Um I do have an expansion that adds more than 18 cards and it's just as cozy I think as the original. But this is a game about giving gifts of flowers to other players. Um thematically that means different things I think in the Victorian times. Um basically that's I think when this the era when this game was based. But also it's just kind of a very light uh uh set collection puzzle as you're playing. So pretty light puzzle but the art, the theme, and the idea of uh of generosity like giving to the other players being baked into the heart of the game. Um one one face-up card, one face-down card. So they still have a decision to make, a tough decision. You can still be feel a little sneaky in this game. But you're still giving gifts. I thought that all leans into the cozy feel of Tussie Mussie.
Yeah.
That does sound very cozy. It's one that I have but I haven't played yet and I keep forgetting about it because it's so small. I have it tucked away in my small game section and just one of those out of sight out out of mind things and haven't thought about it for a while but I should pull that out cuz that sounds very cozy.
We brought it on the the cruise that we went on recently to Iceland and it was great, you know, cuz it does like you said it doesn't take up much space at all. It's very easy to travel with and it does go up I think to five players. Um and it scales well I think down to two. I think we played it a little bit of two and it still worked well. Yeah. Tussie Mussie is my number four. Your number three has been mentioned earlier in this video. What did you pick?
It is also garden themed or flower themed. I went with Pergola. Um the art is definitely once again what drew me into this. The same artist that did Meadow, um Carolina or Carolina Kiełbas, I think is her name. Um
[clears throat]
and I just really fell in love with her art and sought this out. Um and it is very cozy. You're just building up your garden, um picking putting out plants and um and bugs or insects that come to your garden. It's really adorable.
I think that one cozy thing this game does in a really clever way is that it doesn't provide precise slots as to where you need to place anything. You They're They're like areas on the board like the bees are supposed to go near the beehive, but you can put them anywhere in that beehive area. And there are some puzzles too like you with the um the the ladybugs, they need to go in specific places along this this route, but you could have placed the uh the the petals of these flowers, you could you could have had them branching out in other directions, you could have had them uh spread out more, spread out. So, it gives you control over the the gardening experience of this game. I think that leans into the coziness of it.
I agree and the uh stems on the right, uh you can either put a lavender in the stem or a dragonfly when you've completed that depending on what your goal is in that game and and or how far into the game you are. And they get little lanterns that add to the cuteness of the garden that let you
[clears throat]
not necessarily break a rule but like make it alterations. So, if you're stuck somewhere, you have a lantern that can allow you to do different things sometimes or gain an additional bug.
Uh-huh.
Yeah, it's very it's a not a punishing game and I think that's another aspect of cozy games that that I really want is something that that doesn't punish you for having a a suboptimal turn or something. You still get pretty things and nice stuff to add to your garden.
And I like that the pretty things that I stuff that they're still moving you forward in the game too. You're getting points from pretty much everything. It's just how much do you lean into one strategy over the next?
Yeah.
Yeah. Great pick at number three, Pergola. Do you say Pergola or Pergola?
Oh. I've been saying Pergola, but I maybe I'm saying it wrong.
I think that sounds right to me. And my number three, I picked a place for all my books. This game is almost the epitome of a cozy game to me. It's
Truly.
It's a game about organizing your books. Exactly something you talked about with two of your video game picks. Organizing your books and recharging your social battery at home. Um and then every now and then venturing out to town, trying to be a little extroverted and buying more books and then bringing those books back so you have more books to organize on your little your little player board. Um the theme of it, the and I don't just mean like the general theme, but also how the theme is represented through the mechanisms of your social battery. I think that's really really clever. Um along with the the core mechanisms in the game that I just described. I I think it all leads to this game feeling really really cozy and satisfying.
Definitely.
Yeah.
Yeah, this is a great [clears throat] one and and the epitome of cozy and it needed to be on one of our lists.
All right. All right. Yeah, that's a place for all my books at number three. Number two, I'm still a little jealous that you played this and I haven't.
Soon though, soon. Forest Shuffle, specifically the Smoky Mountains version. I really love the autumnal theme in this and it much like how the original Forest Shuffle ended up almost on your list. I think this the autumnal version is why this ended up on my list because the the there's just something about those autumn colors that make you want your cozy blanket.
Well, look at this part in particular over here. The art on this card this just is the epitome of cozy.
Truly. Yep.
Waterfalls, fall colors, yeah.
Yeah, absolutely beautiful. Um I am excited to play this in person cuz it's just been on BGA so far that I've played it. But I will definitely be picking up my copy soon and I'm excited about that.
Is there anything uh mechanically new to Forest Shuffle that you thought leaned into the cozy aspects of the game?
[clears throat]
No, actually the opposite because they added fish and fish are not so cozy for me.
Okay.
And they're not like cute pretty fish like we find in Fangs and there's a lot of like here's a perch and here's like generic fish that you find in in the Smoky Mountains. Um and so
Okay.
to me those are slimy and not cozy.
AJ, what do you think of the cozy
though. The squirrels are great. I do really like that that aspect. Um and I I've always loved the set collection that you can do for the butterflies in the original version. Um the dragonflies in the um Dartmoor version. Uh and in this one you can collect squirrels. And um so those are those are cozier.
Okay. Do you happen to Can you let me know what this new icon means? I don't recognize this one.
It is to play a river. Um I I'm not certain exactly if that's a river and a tree card or just a river under a tree. Um but they added uh so like Dartmoor has the moors where the the horizontal cards. In this one there are some standard horizontal cards that are creeks now I believe. Um but you can also add a river underneath a tree when you play a tree. Uh and so you uh that that has you flipping the card over and using the back of of one of the cards from your hand to place it underneath a tree and then you can add fish underneath that tree, too.
Oh, I see. Well, that's really cool. I can't wait to play this.
Yeah. Currently, it's my favorite version. I don't know once I've played it as many times as I've played the other ones, we'll see. Um but I'm really enjoying it a lot.
And like we said earlier, we're recording this at the end of October. It's This game is supposed to be released at the very end of October. And so, by the time this video comes out, perhaps I will have played this game in person. And I know I could play Board Game Arena, but I really want to play it for the first time in person. So, I have a copy that I've asked my local store to to pick up. Uh great pick at four, Shuffle Smoky Mountains. My number two is Patchwork. Patchwork, game about quilting.
Mhm.
Um Uh so, both the theme, the art The theme and the art definitely have a cozy feel to me. But also, the I think the mechanisms in this two-player game of of uh having a time track that you're moving forward on, but there's not that much pressure. You have plenty of time to do a lot of things that you want to do. And you have this big circle of polyomino tiles. You only have the next three that you can choose from. So, it's not too thinky. You can plan ahead if you want, but really on your turn, you're looking at those next three tiles and trying to figure out which one you can afford or which one um which of of multiples that you can afford you you actually want to go ahead and purchase. Uh so, it's it's it's a fairly low-key two-player game, even though there's plenty of interaction in it. But I This is one that I've I've definitely cozied up with a number of different people to play the game of Patchwork.
Again, the ultimate cozy theme of making a quilt. Like, what's more cozy about a quilt?
Right.
Do you have a favorite version?
I think because of the coziness of it, I think the original quilt version is my favorite. I I do like the aesthetics of the different seasonal versions they have, but this is the one that I keep coming back to.
That makes sense. But
Do you have a different one?
Um I really liked the Was it the Polish art one?
Oh, yeah.
I liked [clears throat] But I liked the brightness of that. And I similar to you, I wouldn't count that as cozy as the original. Um I think the the brightness drew me in cuz they're like, "Ooh, pretty colors." And the different patterns and things were interesting. But the the original version is, I think, the most cozy.
I was trying to see if they had any of those shown here, but no. They are on BoardGameGeek if people want to take a look at the different versions. Yeah. We're down to our number ones now.
Yeah.
What [clears throat] is your number one pick?
My number one is Meadow. It is just It's so cozy. The art really drew me in, and that is why, like I said, I ended up playing Pergola because of the art in Meadow. And I just everything is so pretty and so just relaxing to look at. The the softness of the art is really really nice, and I love that very much. Even the the art of like just just the little house right there is like, "Oh, the little half-timbered house is adorable." The raven looks like it would be foreboding, but there's still a softness to it that I really appreciate. And yeah, it's just just the amount of thinkingness and planning for me, but really being able to still take a moment and and focus on the art and be like, "Man, this card is so pretty. I love it so much."
It's essentially a game about taking a a walk. Is that the theme of it? Yeah, you're taking a stroll in the meadow. That in itself is cozy.
It sure is. Yeah.
If anyone is curious about Meadow, the publisher was very nice to let us make a Stonemaier Rolling Realm of this. So, if you want to get a little taste of what Meadow is about, I'd say if it's a good fit for you, you can try the the Rolling Realm Realm of it. Yeah, it's a fantastic pick at number one. I wonder if Suzanna I can see Suzanna our co-worker picking potentially this one, potentially Pergola. Did she uh did she happen to mention any to you when you talked to her?
We talked a little bit, and we played through She taught She's the one that taught me Pergola. She didn't mention what her favorite would be, but my guess would be this one as well, cuz she really does love this one a whole lot.
Well, Suzanna, [clears throat] let us know in the comments if this would would have been on your list. My number one, I almost think it's a little bit cheating because it literally has the word cozy in its name. But I think it's appropriate. I think it belongs in this name. [clears throat] I picked Cozy Castle Ville as my number one.
Yeah.
This is I guess this is also maybe the most like Stardew Valley of the games on this list. This is a cooperative game about living in and building kind of watching town be built with a bunch of stickers. Tons of stickers in this game. And one really clever thing this game does with the stickers is for the most part it doesn't matter where you place them. Which seems like an odd choice in the game where they could have had all these rules about like you know maximizing your points or your goals for putting the sticker or tile in a certain place over another place. But instead they said that's not this game. That's that's a different game. Plenty of other games do that. In this game we want you to choose where you place the sticker solely based on what feels right to you. It it changes the whole tone of the game thanks to that decision.
And also it's a campaign game, a legacy game that that Megan and I play. We played it two players over the course of maybe two months. And I thought it was brilliant in how easy it was to set up and get back to the table. A lot of campaign games and legacy games I almost feel like especially when they're adding rules to the game I am almost daunted to get them back to the table. I'm like oh no, I need to remember how to do all this stuff that the game has added. Clever stuff the game has added but I need to relearn it. In this game all you do is flip the top card of the pile and do what that card says and then make one action choice on your turn. So by streamlining it, by distilling that legacy experience down to a single flip of a card, it really made me want to get it back to the table over and over again. Made it very easy to get to the table.
Um Yeah, what are your thoughts? Have you heard about this game? What are your thoughts on Cozy Castle Ville?
Yeah, I I haven't played it. I still really want to play it. I have a hard time with legacy games because of the aspect of getting the same group back together over and over again. And so that I think that's been my hang up about it. Um but I do really want to play it at some point. And I'm curious since you've played I think you said you Have you played it twice now?
I've only played it once. You can technically play it twice and take make the opposite decisions you did in the first time. But I'm I'm kind of happy with what we built the first time. Yeah.
Sure. Do you feel like there's anything in here that you wish you'd done in Charterstone since it's so many years later in development?
Um that's a great question. Yeah, and this is the game I was referring to where it is essentially a very light version of Charterstone.
Mhm.
Um There are Let's see if there's anything very specific. Uh I do really like I mean the card system of just flipping a card. That makes the game really really easy to get into. But Charterstone is a worker placement game where you right off the bat you have you have a lot of decisions you can make. Actually, in Charterstone I also echoed this idea. There were versions of Charterstone in the prototype stage where there was a spatial mini game as to where you put the stickers in your charter. And eventually I got I got rid of that. It that to me wasn't a satisfying part of the puzzle. So in that way it is actually a little bit similar to Cozy Castle. Um Yeah, I don't know if anything jump because they're they're pretty different games beyond that beyond the theme and beyond that you're placing stickers on it. I think Charterstone would have to have some pretty big revamps to copy some of my favorite things about Cozy Castle. So nothing comes to mind off the top of my head. I can say that I think this game Cozy Castle was far easier to get back to the table than Charterstone um is if you haven't played in a while.
So I appreciate that about Cozy Castle.
Yeah. Yeah, I ended up uh having to pause my game of Charterstone because of the pandemic and I still haven't gotten back to it cuz getting that group of people back together and then remembering what happened and all that. And I We ended at a um not so optimal time for myself. I I had a an event had happened and I was like, "Ah, I need to know what happens." and I don't know if I will.
And we had we actually had the same thing happen where we had it set up on our gaming table in the recessed area. We'd gotten halfway through, pandemic hit, and we reconvened a year later. I think we were still wearing masks at the time or we were still being very careful. Um but we reconvened a year later and finished it off, but it was that time jump was very difficult and it had remained in the table I think the entire time.
Wow.
Yeah, that it it was tough to come back to. I think any legacy game would be even Chris Sigurvil would be tough to come back to after that amount of time.
After yeah. Yeah, for us it's been, you know, 6 years now and so I don't know that we we'd have to relearn everything.
Yeah, you would.
But I still remember what happened to me.
That's even before you worked for Stonemaier, too.
It was, [clears throat] yeah.
Well, any closing thoughts? I love your list. Thank you so much for putting this together and for the idea for the video. Any other closing thoughts? Do you have a cuddly dog to show us?
thoughts that we are missing a key element to coziness, our pets.
I wish Walter had wandered in here on here on his own.
Well, you mentioned the animals. I think there's animals in almost all of yours. I can't remember if they're in Evenfall, but Creature Comforts, Charter all the other games of yours having animals in them.
It's true. Yep.
Well, if you listen to this, yeah, we'd love to hear what you think. What is your favorite cozy game? What makes a cozy game to you? And going back to the original question that we asked earlier, if you have a favorite comfort food or things that you think of when you think of cozy games. Let us know about that. All right, Erica, take care. Thanks.
Thank you. Bye.