The Worst Games in Quackalope's Collection - Friend Edition
Transcript
hello hello welcome to quakkalope today we are looking at the 10 worst games in quackalope's collection okay to be clear you're just talking about jessie because i don't have worse games period yeah we're doing we're doing best collection we're doing best friends edition on this one now here's the thing we're going to cross promote with this i did earlier a video on alex radcliffe board game co's 10 worst games oh alex has a ton i get a lot of flack for the record of course from who from alex well-deserved from his community okay and oh you deserve all the fun and over on board gameco's channel he actually before i moved here did a top 10 worst games in quakaloops collection as well on jesse on me specifically so we're gonna have a board game co-edition over on his channel link top of this so you can go help him pass us in subscribers and we're going to have a clack a little you know best friends edition so william oh no oh wait this is your show my friend is this my show did you get like did you get like five and five of both of our libraries like from like joint quack a lot or did you let's see let's see what do you have sadly it may or may not be equal okay we're gonna start i really hope it's not me i'm gonna be heartbroken with number 10 we're gonna break jan's heart a little bit do not bring millennium blades what are you doing okay you're wrong about all of the mountains now you're wrong you're wrong i played this you're wrong we both own
this copy yeah neither of us are getting rid of this yeah well i yeah yeah you're just wrong okay so number nine disregard this you're starting very very often very justify yourself in the hall of the mountains is a is a game that i play jay i'm so sorry he knows not of what he speaks sorry to be a hundred percent clear none of these games are bad games these are just games in their collection that i don't personally like all that much you just have bad tastes maybe i have bad taste maybe they do they definitely do anyway in the hall of mountain king is a game that i played with jan and sarah shaw a little while back and it is a tile laying kind of spatial reasoning game where you are trying to you know build out the hall of the mountain king the mountain king of some troll and blah blah blah yeah yeah basically this is a bad idea basically it's tetris it's tetris guys and i don't like tetris who is this tetris because of the polyamino pieces yeah yeah it looks like every single title game ever what are you talking about most piling games are squares this is an absolutely fantastic game where you're doing your very best to build out a hierarchy of different mountain trolls that are diving into the caverns and doing their very best to move monuments and collect resources and progress into the center of this volcanic mountain if you like polyamino
if you like action selection resource management if you like structures and programming to some degree because the way you're building your pyramid out most especially if you don't like your friends play that game if you want to enjoy your if you want to enjoy your time with this don't play with jesse he's just going to ruin the next game we have this this is this is once again this is just things that i weren't really swearing about tapestry oh okay tapestry a civilization game that maybe civilization a little bit too little light jamie i love your games i am a stone meyer he's talking oh wow by the way he's going straight jamie right now tapas you don't even know this guy what are you doing man hey oh my god i go we gotta go with what comes naturally tap is streaming up so tapestry is a civilization game that it may be missing a couple of different things to make it a true civilization game the first time i played tapestry admittedly it was late at night and it was even later at night when i finished it because it took four hours it was ridiculous and i played it a second time i played it a third time it got faster but it didn't get any more interesting for me it is literally the only stone wire game i don't own nothing nothing to say look okay so they did not edit this list before
so can you tell one of the things one of the things that i really appreciate about tapestry is how consolidated the civilization feeling is in here right this is much more i believe an econ a tableau building game or how would you describe it it's not a tableau building it's like developing this economic engine this is all about efficiency of actions sure okay you're sitting down you're looking at the puzzle on the board and you're doing your very best to be precise with every turn you take i'll give you it's not a civilization game bad marketing but it doesn't make a bad game i don't know it doesn't make a bad game i said at the top of this video none of these games are bad just some of them i don't like all that it's just some of them are the only stonemeyer games he doesn't own did you hear him i heard him oh jamie too all right so we're going to go back to another game that i played with jan that because of the way he taught it to me do not bring out terra mara oh okay petrichor yep yep yep and it's not because the way i taught it to you that is the game that's the way he learned it and he taught it to me and it what i am is this one really i really want a reason he doesn't like this i really wanted to like petrichor i i don't i don't love petra core either what was it well i like pepe you're not defending it it's still in my collection no no it's a good game i like petrichor you even played it a second time and yes as the second time when you actually learned how to play the rules
it it was better but our play through was just so disjointed and you ran away with it and i had no chance and you were stealing my raindrops and we didn't understand that that is the game though you must have thought it wrong no i did teach it wrong i did teach it wrong yeah this is one of those plated once experiences it just goes way way bad it went way way bad it really did it really did so jesse why do you like petra core though i like petrichor because it has not only beautiful a beautiful title which is the smell of rain like that that essence that exists after it rains it's a great it isn't it is also a study components are great aesthetically a very interesting interesting game and it is a it is a uh the core concept of the game is a little bit of territory control with like point salad style scoring at the end of it and for me it abstracts territory control in a way that i find really interesting and really compelling the idea of raining down on an uh you know on this landscape birthing up different plant matter there's a lot to love here i don't know like it's in my collection i don't know if it's there forever so i'm not sure you're wrong but there you go it's there for now this can become very very messy it's on the way it could be i had a real hard time growing anything because like i said jan kept stealing my ring okay so um so another game i'm not too sour about this list so far i'm just saying you better not bring out taramari at any point oh my god here it is another game from the jan i'm gonna talk about this this game is amazing i haven't actually played it a hundred percent yet but i know it's
awesome we went through it i know it's awesome we couldn't make it grand we we're gonna give it a shot what are you talking about we gave it an hour we gave it an hour no we didn't it was like 30 minutes okay justify taramara why is it on this list taramara is on this list because i don't know if jan just didn't learn it or we didn't learn it or we weren't listening that is also an entirely possible thing that it might have happened but i just i didn't understand how it worked i had no clue how it worked and when we started moving through that i still didn't know how it worked and granted now i've seen a couple other videos maybe it works pretty well but my one experience with it just wasn't great why are you so passionate about a game that you apparently don't haven't played through one you don't care enough to teach appropriately it's not that i don't care enough to teach appropriately i just was excited about the game and i grabbed the rulebook and i thought i could learn it in time and i wasn't able to learn anytime it's like it happens it happens i fully admit that jan but why haven't you learned it and then taught it oh ask me how many games in my life i've actually played not that many so percent i love how you probably that is a justification anyways what so one of the things that got me very excited about taramar is actually the team behind it virginia giggly flamina stefano luperto and antonio tinto they have done some amazing euros like uh i think lorenzo magnifico is one of them okay so they are incredible together and they have
proven themselves time and time again and the innovation in this title and the level of variability that it is within the work replacement is absolutely fascinating you have tableau building you have direct player interaction you have combat here as well but it does not feel extremely punishing and above all wrong and above all you have the idea that you can send workers out into the future in order to make incredible actions but unfortunately never come back all of that sounds fantastic for a game you haven't played and taught so poorly it ended up on the list you're responsible for that one for the record i'm also excited about that title i blame you that it's on this list folks once again sure games that are great the design team behind terramara is great and i'm sure terra mario is a good game i just didn't have a good experience these are a lot of plated ones as well just a lot of plated ones isn't it i swear to gosh of monster lanterns in there that i've played a bunch of times and still don't not monster lantern oh oh project you're wrong
kind of spatial reasoning which i don't like you guys like this a lot i've played it three or four times with you now and each time i come in dead last and have a very unhappy how good's the mouth feel on this it's actually fantastic i wouldn't know jesse it's your game oh maybe i will never play it again i also try i tried them out yeah i thought i thought they were candy project lg and justif like defend this one it's easy it's a poly amino game of engine building that is light accessible and yet provides enough depth once you keep digging into it that it's just it's always a good time every time you open that box it is absolutely stunning the artwork is simplistic minimalist but also compelling and gorgeous components are fantastic it's it's a it's a fantastic design i love everything about it yeah absolutely frustrates me i don't know that it's the special i've ever played doesn't have to be i'm always happy to play it alright so this one might actually not be controversial for you guys because this is something that i've played not with them but with other people non-controversial all of these have been controversial it's gonna be controversial but maybe not with you guys oh i don't care about this one you haven't seemed to play it mice and mystics this is in your collection if you guys don't know if you haven't like been to quackalope.com seen some of my articles that i've written i am a story based gamer mice and mystics are a story storyboard based game and i really like story games i really wanted to like mice and mystics
i have i've played five times with a group that uh of college friends we haven't beaten the first boss it's frustrating because it falls into one big thing about me it comes down to dice rolls if you don't get the dice you need you're not gonna make it anywhere doesn't matter how much cheese you have it doesn't matter how many weapons you have it's just there's a lot of cheese it's not gonna it's not gonna go well for you so this one's in my collection it is uh i got it because i really like what plaid hat games is doing with things like uh forgotten waters here's the thing this is the i really like forgotten water by the way this is like one of the first furries into story based games still in shrink wrap it is and don't you take my moss flower slash red fault red wall little excursion don't take that from me i don't take that i took it stop i took it it's right there and it's number five anyway
more controversial than i thought anyway so moving on you've heard me talk about dice rolling god damn it oh no wrong this is a project elite is a co-op game where you are trying to destroy a bunch of aliens that are trying to kill you and what are you doing you're rolling dice it's amazing it feels like an action movie it is everything this is only one box of two there are two boxes that are this big no no everything from project blues is in this box well there's another box downstairs did you see it it still says project elite on oh no yeah you're right i do have two boxes exactly but i consolidated it from seven boxes i consolidated seven boxes of products leaning to two that's pretty impressive sure and there's like a huge giant worm monster thing that's next
but here's the thing this is probably a game that i'm not interested in playing again i'm with william on this one that's a bad game in your collection no no no you're both wrong this game is absolutely amazing i'm glad mostly if you've ever wanted to have unaltered unalterated fun unadulterated fun while you're with while everybody with a board game feel like you're in an action movie and actually live out every single scene of that flick and you are the star of it also the fool of that film this is your game starship troopers the board game incredible most of the games so far for the record have been from jan's collection i feel like i'm doing all no actually you're super wrong on that the most are from yours i've already i've been keeping count okay paying attention okay i've been keeping this is number three but it may be the most controversial yet it's we're currently four four to three oh put it down wrong uh wow how can you be so wrong on everything hate cockroach poker uh yeah you're no i am not a bluffer no i can't do it i've done it poorly and guess what i i did theater and improv and all sorts of things through college you know high school you know what's funny i know how to bluff and act you know what's funny i think this entire list is a bluff i'm just glad that's what i don't have to listen to his opinion anymore oh i don't care at all yeah i stopped listening after the first game all right he brought in granted i didn't
hear any defensive cockroach poker is the best party game i have played yep i love every single second of it you sit around you drink you play it with friends no you laugh apples to apples is better we're currently tied that that was a joke dixit is actually the best party uh what no well no obscure isn't the best one but still it's really good yeah i know you're wrong it's not a party game by the way yes i know i i corrected myself i just can't you just can't wait for this i'm so disappointed number two thought he would have compelling arguments really like good games that he's like yeah oh my god i hate this thing ah tayden oh jesse isn't this like close to your number one once again a game that i have not played with you but with our friend matt the story was so convoluted i did not understand it i hate the combat in this game no sense what are you doing jesse i don't know if matt taught it to me wrong or i just was you were picked that day you were playing a sequence of cards that continued triggering off each other that fully elicit and i never got the cards
i got mutilated on our first combat i got downtown you claim to be a story-driven player and you're putting tainted grail the tainted grill probably in my top ten yeah it probably is you know you know what this sounds like jesse ultimately it sounds like will just has so many plated once experienced that have gone sour and we just all suck at teaching games that that i mean that that could be the real title of this list quacking sucks at once goes wrong i'm sure you have no interest in this game i have zero interest in trying it but if the combat is better would you try it again you know here's the thing matt taught him it right matt knew the game he did you played this with matt matt doesn't teach games wrong he's not you he's not you yeah you're right matt studies yeah wow i think the major and reasonable complaint around this game is the one thing you didn't bring up which is that there's a bit of game mediation to try to lengthen it like a lot of awakened realms games but outside of that the theming the story the way you can dive through the storybook the i mean this is the best game that awakened romans has produced with the exception of iss vanguard which i have not played will become probably it will probably replace this one but right now tainted grail is the one game on my list that is like i want to play this campaign all the way right after kdu mm-hmm we need to get you playing sleeping guides sleeping oh silly being
autism take it off get to the side okay oh last one guys it better be james so this is number one better this is number one if it's millennium blazer monster lands i'm going to be so sad we might have it have a real guess you just figure this out that's a that's your real guess i don't think he's played blades or monsters that's true it's true people who listen to anything i don't know i don't have an access to kingdom death i have not played kingdom death okay okay people who listen let me guess this let me guess wingspan give me a plate at once give me like a little intro about this it's a podcast driven one you said it's a podcast is cosmic frog still behind us ah it's cosmic frog that's exactly what it is it's cosmic frog yeah but you didn't invite me on cosmic frogs
you're pulling dwellings of elder i don't play dwellings of elder veil number one in my opinion the worst collection that i could find i was not expecting this video to be this close we should release our coverage of dwellings of eldervale before we announce that that william's lambasting it defenders again once again go ahead once again these games are good games if you enjoy them yeah none of us believe that caveat why do you hate this game why do you hate dwellings of eldervale hate why do i hate dwellings of eldervale because maybe jan taught it to me wrong nope maybe i don't it really i hate dwellings of eldervale because of the combat no we didn't we didn't play 100 correctly okay so jack taught it right we didn't play that incorrectly either we we played it what about the combat we played it incorrectly enough that i felt i had no agency in how to direct my combat how to make it feel better i rolled six dices six die to jan's three plural is multiple times dices that actually played right by the way and i lost the combat yeah not just once not just twice three times and i didn't understand what else i needed to do and by the end of the game i won what i didn't understand how it happened and when you played it and when you bleeded you we i like i didn't catch that you were collecting all the end game scoring cards so we also played that wrong but we
played that part right i mixed in expansions here in a way that you didn't and i do think that improved the game i really like dwellings of elderville i'm going to be honest and we have coverage of it that we actually need to produce i i was really fond of this game i didn't here's where i'll side with you i didn't understand the world's hype about it but for an ameritrash euro style i thought it merged those two cultures in a really cool way ah this is not actually in my collection no no it's on the way out but it was still here and not gone yet so that's oh because quackle needs to cover it uh but this is one that i'm not going to keep similar to you um i just i didn't love the merging i didn't love the merging i i agree with will that the combat feels anticlimactic most of the time and the work replacement spots feel a little bit um superfluous of the types of actions that i want to convey in the game so here's the thing this might leave your collection oh it's well it's going into yours but it may come down so once again i still have number one i really do number one on quackalope's worst games list wow that quack-a-lop has wow well if you've enjoyed this video here's what i can say alex over at board game co has another top 10 worst games in my personal collection and i don't think there was a single oh there wasn't any overlap no cross
overlap so it is worth watching both whatever the case [ __ ] you william we'll see you guys please write your letters to quackalope at jesse anderson care of p.o box down below p.o box down below please 56 12 56 frederick frederick maryland please write your letters they need them 21702 they need your letters folks we'll see you next time