Top 10 Pirate Games - with Tom Vasel
Transcript
Hello mateys, I'm Tom Vasel and welcome to my top 10 pirate themed games. Pirates, one of the most misunderstood groups of people in history. And by misunderstood I mean they were pretty terrible people, but we love to romanticize them in games and then books and movies. Well, so be it. I do like it. I do like the swashbuckling pirate theme and even if it is mostly silliness. Um and it is one of my favorite themes in board gaming and honestly for the until the last decade, there was not many good pirate games out there. There are a lot of good ones now though and I want to tell you my 10 favorite pirate themed games. So let's get going. Number 10 is Ahoy. So Ahoy is from Leader Games and is a game that I was kind of late to the table on. The other folks in the studio played it and I just never got around to it, but Ahoy has two very different of there's four different factions in it.
There's two big factions going back and forth and swashbucklers and then there's two factions that are kind of pirate / merchants and it doesn't really matter what faction you are. I guess one faction you can feel like you're the Royal Navy, but they all feel like pirates to me. And so you're moving around and and the asymmetrical nature, this is something Leader Games likes to do, works well here, but it the idea that there is four different factions, but pairs of two kind of play the same way. And so this faction's fighting this faction and our two people are just trying to make a living, but also mess everyone else up. And I like this a lot. It has also some fun cute artwork. Not as piraty maybe as the rest of the list, which is why it's number 10. That's Ahoy. Number nine is an older game on this list from 2002 and that is Pirate's Cove. This is uh published from Days of Wonder and was their one of their first big box style games. And at the time we were like, "Wow, this is an amazing-looking game." Nowadays, it would look maybe more ordinary, but I still was very impressed with this game.
Simultaneous selection, you're picking which island on the board your ship is going to go to, and you go to these islands to collect resources and upgrade your your ship. You have these rings on these ships that you move them up, getting more crew, getting more cannons, things like that. You might find items like a parrot that's on your shoulder that gives you a special ability, etc. And then you want to get treasure and go in the middle and bury this treasure for victory points. But if you go to the same island as another pirate, then you fight, and you fight in a simple way with dice shooting at the other person's ship. There's legendary pirates like Blackbeard and stuff going around that you might have to fight, too. It's very lucky in many ways, and it's a very family-style game, but it is very piraty. Pirate's Cove. My number eight is We're Sinking. There is a lot of social deduction-style games out there nowadays, but I think this one works really well. You are all pirates on a boat that is sinking, but there's treasure, and there's enemies that are shooting at you, and there's sea creatures that are fighting. And on your turn, you're all making actions. You're all picking, and you you want to pick up the loot and stuff it in your pockets, but you also want to keep your ship from sinking. Or maybe you want the ship to sink. And there's different ways to win.
It's a cute game that works better in big groups. It says three to six players. This is one of those ones that's best with five or six players. Best with a bunch of people all sitting there arguing and going, "Wait a minute. You were supposed to help man the cannon and fight that thing off, and you're not doing it. You're the bad guy." Uh so, now I'm going to pick up treasure. Oh, we all picked up treasure? Now our ship is sinking, and it don't matter how much treasure you have in your pockets. I think there's a lot of fun aspects to this game, We're Sinking. Number seven is Libertalia. Now, there are two versions of Libertalia. There's the original one, um and then the reprint of the game from uh Stonemaier Games, which I believe is called Libertalia: Winds of Galecrest. So, Libertalia is very piratey. Libertalia: Winds of Galecrest is piratey, but with animals. And honestly, I love the original theme better.
But, the Stonemaier version has some better mechanisms. They streamline it a little bit better. I wish there was a way to make some sort of Frankenstein where I have the art from the first and the gameplay mechanisms of the second. But, the fact of the matter is they're both really good games. In each game, you're all going to start with the same nine cards from a big deck of all different special guys. You might have a mutineer and a cabin boy and a drunk sailor or whatever. And you can play these cards in any order. You're going to play six of those nine cards, and then draw six more. Everyone gets the same six of this big deck. But, you have the three left over. Now, you have some different cards than other people have. And it's so it has a very similar feeling to Citadels. But, this Paolo Mori game, I think, is really fun trying to outguess everyone else and get the treasure. Loads of fun. Libertalia.
Number six is uh or Black Fleet. So, Black Fleet uh Black Fleet is a game in which you're a pirate. You're also uh the world you're Well, you're a merchant, a pirate, and the Royal Navy. There are all these ships in the board, and so you're trying to get your merchant ship to go around and deliver stuff. You're trying to take your pirate ship and go after other people's merchant ships. You are trying to take the Royal Navy and go after other people's pirate ships. Nothing you have is safe, ever. And it's silly and light and fun, and I'm really surprised sometimes that this one just wasn't a bigger hit. It's so easy to play. This is from Space Cowboys. They make a lot of games like this. And it's one of those games where it's just kind of rocking fun. You're going to sink my ship, and I'm not going to get mad because I'm about to sink yours, and then we just get another ship, and we keep going. And it it it has always a video game aspect to it than that. And I like it a lot. That's Black Fleet.
Number five, I suspect will be some people's number one, and that is Dead Reckoning. This is from John D. Clair, some beautiful artwork. This is AEG and this is throwing everything into one box, which is why it's not my number one because there's a lot going on in this. It is a card crafting game where you have members of your crew, but you're making them go bet get better as time goes by as you play them. You're going around and you're going looking for islands and looking for treasure. There's a really fun uh dice tower mechanism for combat. There's so many cool things, but it is very lengthy, very long. There's a lot going on in it and man, a streamlined version of this could be my number one, frankly. I There's a lot of cool aspects to this and I wish the exploration was stronger, but there's no denying it is a fantastic pirate game. That's Dead Reckoning.
Number four is Treasure Island. This is a very specific game based on Long John Silver and the book Treasure Island. And in this game, Long John Silver is hiding treasure and everyone else is using deduction and reasoning to figure out where this treasure is. Drawing circles, lines on a map to figure out where it is. It It's a different feel than every other game on my list because this is a logic deduction game and you might like this game even if you're not a fan of pirates. The artwork from Vincent Dutrait is very piraty, but I just love this concept. There's hidden treasure, we're going to find it. Let's narrow down where it is and I think that's really fun. Treasure Island. Number three is Forgotten Waters. Forgotten Waters is from Plaid Hat Games. It's in their series of games that use an app. This is the first one in that series, but it is they're all so much fun. This Forgotten Waters where they took their ideas from this this card system that they have with a called Crossroads where you're going to have different events happen to you and you're going through worker placement.
It's cooperative, but you're all working together and you need to find the right things to do, but you also have your own personal goals. Random events will show up. There's some really funny things that happen in it, but there's also a very serious pirate adventure to be found in it. And when you're done playing this, it just you feel like you've had a grand old adventure, Forgotten Waters. Number two is Rum and Bones. Now, there are two versions of this. I always like to say Rum and Bones second edition cuz I think it's much better than the first one, but frankly, they're both out of print, so get whichever one you want. This game here is a MOBA style game where you have your basic old boring pirates running at each other and fighting each other in ships. This game never took off because it's a huge game for two players. Big game, you both put your pirate ships next to each other. You're running these pirates back and forth and then you you have these five heroes and you're switching out.
You only ever have three in a board at different times that do all kinds of special abilities. Very fantasy-esque pirate flare. Some of your pirates get to do cool things. You're just slicing and dicing all the the little ones, fighting the other big ones, and it just has this cinematic quality to it with all the miniatures that CMON makes for one of these games. I found it to be a lot of fun, two-player style game. Although, you can play two on two, a four-player game. I've done that before, but it's best with two. Rum and Bones. And my favorite pirate game from Rockman Games is Seas of Havoc. And this is a game where it's all down to your ship. You have a ship on the board and you're just moving that ship around collecting treasure and blowing the snot out of other pirates. How do you do that? Well, it's a deck-building game. I've always liked deck-building games and this game uses deck-building for something really fun. Just like Clank! used deck-building to go and delve into dungeons, uh Seas of Havoc uses deck-building to maneuver your ship, go around, shoot at other pirates. You have a special ability. You pick a pirate uh and a pirate ship and mash them together. They kind of have a little special starting deck, but you're getting other cards and just moving around and just blowing each other up.
It's silly fun, but it also feels strategic and interesting. And it just it also has a a very good time length. It doesn't overstay its welcome. And it's a game that I find to be quite a bit of fun, and that is why it's my favorite pirate game. What are your favorite pirate games? What are ones I missed? You might go, "Tom, what about Merchants and Marauders?" Well, there's too many There's too much merchanting in it for me to love that one, but there are a lot of good pirate games out there. Tell me your favorites in the comments. Until next time, I'm Tom Vasel, and you're watching The Dice Tower.
Hey everybody, thanks for watching another video from The Dice Tower. Hey, do you want to learn more about us, communicate with us? We have a Facebook group, we have a Discord channel, lots of different ways to get involved with The Dice Tower. You can find that in our link tree link below, so just click that, it will take you, and you can communicate with us on Facebook, join our Facebook groups. There's lots of cool things that you can find and become part of The Dice Tower. Thanks so much for watching, I'm Tom Vasel.