Buzz Chat Episode 3: A Chat About How We Rate Game/A Special Announcement
Transcript
Hello everybody welcome back to board game Buzz today my name is Carly I'm Kim and today we're doing another Buzz chat episode I love Buzz chat episodes we don't do them nearly enough we need to do more um but so today what we kind of or what I wanted to kind of focus on or do a a buzz chat at episode on um I kind of wanted to chat a little bit about why like how we go about raing our games yes and the reason why I wanted to do to do this is because we are a fairly new channel and every channel I feel like kind of does things slightly differently I'm just kind of like right off the top of my head like Alex from board game Co he rates on a 1 to five scale instead of a 1 to 10 scale and then like thinker themer um Amy and Maggie they do like 7.8 or 6.1 or like they're kind of more like um what's the word like precise kind of more like precise with their ratings um and so I kind of just wanted to chat about what our ratings kind of mean to us just to kind of have that clarification on the on on the channel um and so people can kind of come back to this video if they need to to kind of get the clarifications on what our ratings mean I think that's kind of an important thing to chat about considering that we are reviewers like it should be clear about what our reviews like what our numbers are um in my personal opinion so yeah and whenever like Carly and I are going into like a review video we always kind of have this conversation between ourselves and general like talking about why how we come to that like review and what that
number means for us and whatnot and it's was just like yeah that should be important information not just for us to share between ourselves but for the people who are actually engaging with the content and kind of be a little more transparent with just what what the numbers mean and I also kind of want to nail down a little bit more what what certain numbers mean because I feel like before in like some previous reviews I've done I felt like some reviews have kind of been a little bit more wishy-washy in regards to the numbers so I want to like really nail down what these numbers mean so moving forward will just be more concrete and like you know like we know I feel this way about the game that means it's this number yes you know been there done that and like well and it's hard and I don't know like it's hard because we play so many games and feel like lots of times or I guess not lots of times but there definitely are times where I play a game and I kind of feel like this about it it's like I like I do like it but there's also stuff that I'm like okay on or maybe a couple things that I actually don't like about it so what does that it's hard it's a lot harder than you would think to like come to a solid number on so many different games yeah like starting to compare it to like other games that you enjoy or have played or where it falls into that scale of them and like like I rated this this game that before but like wait do I I think I would give it this number but do I actually like this game more than I like that other game and it's just like I don't it's so yeah it's hard and it's hard also because as we continue to play games we try our
best to like play games you know a decent amount to get a really good kind of well-rounded thought on the games that we review like playing it at a lower player count playing it at a higher playing it with our kids playing it with each other playing it multiple times but having said all that there are games that you know you play a handful of years down the road and you're like oh I don't like that as much as I thought I did or ticket to right yeah sorry or oh I actually like that a lot more so I feel like your thoughts and opinions are always changing which also makes it hard well then how who you're playing the game with too that is actually the main thing that and the first thing that I wanted to talk about do we rate games based on the game or based on the the play of it yeah because there are there are games that you play and you have just a wonderful time around the table it's so much fun you're just loving it you're like this game is amazing and then you break it out with a different group and it's like a completely different vibe and I feel like your excitement level or your enjoyment of the level goes down it's like such a hard it's such a hard thing to like come to terms to but I do think that plays of the game influence the game a lot if that makes any sense or influence your it influences your opinion of games if you have a wonderful time with a game versus a terrible time with a and it's the same game well like it kind of makes you realize like oh maybe this game isn't as like versatile or as amazing as I initially thought
because if they're not enjoying themselves playing or it like makes like one game that I'm thinking of specifically is evolution I have played that game with people where it's a lot of fun and we just have like a grand time playing it but then I've also played it where like it doesn't feel as fun because not everyone like enjoyed playing it or didn't like the aspect of like carnivores coming and attacking you and like eating your species so it it is it's hard reviewing games when I feel like the reason like well not the reason yeah there's lots of reasons why I've loved having Kim on the channel many reasons but one of like the primary reasons why I've loved having you on the channel is because it's so great to be able to sit down with you because I kind of have like that Baseline I'm trying to think about what what it's called you know like in math like when you do like mathematic equations and it's like you need like um a neutral what is it called do you get what I'm saying no variable variable I think that's what I'm thinking of I that's what I'm thinking of like it's just it's nice cuz I can sit down and play a game with you and I know that you just like you're able to to approach it with the mindset of a reviewer you're able to like kind of see the game for what it is even if you don't like a game or if a game isn't for you you're able to see you know what is still good about it or what other people could potentially like about it um yeah you you just like you have that
reviewer mindset which as reviewers we have to go into games with that we have every single game and I really try my best to like even if I really didn't like a game try to find the good in it try to find what people could like about this even if it didn't work for me our personal feelings like might I mean hopefully that like might mean something to you cuz if you can relate to us and you feel like I have a similar kind of like enjoyment level or like I I Vibe you like Vibe with Carly or you Vibe with me or whoever you Vibe with and we give you like yeah this is a 10 or this is a seven and you know you kind of like feel that board game soulmate connection like you're like okay then I would probably feel that way too but um it's like so that's why it is important to be like well people who like these kind of mechanisms might like this game and if you don't like those mechanisms you're not going to like this game even if I think like this is fantastic um someone else might and as like hard as it's for me to admit like race for the Galaxy that's not everybody's game like I'm like I don't know I'm surprised you just said those words right I'm like a little nervous but it's just so I I just like noticed that like our numbers they mean something to us and like hopefully they can mean something to you we're here to give you our review give you our rating let you know what those numbers mean to us individually and then obviously to to your research take it for what it is so do you think that oh hi I want to talk
to Kim you to what's up buddy I had a bad because I have a minion dream you had a minion dream oh no what happened bad dream huh yeah I went oh I went downstairs and the minions got me the minions got you like the minions in um the from the movie or like a different kind of Minion a few moments later okay so Beck and woke up so we Beckham's joining us for the rest of our Buzz chat today huh oh let go over there here there we go so how do you go about rating when you like when you sit down when we sit down to like rate a game mhm how like do you have like a certain method that you use in regards to rating games or like how do you go about how do you like come up with a number so I'm thinking about think I'm thinking about theme I'm thinking about the enjoyment level of it like for personal like my personal enjoyment level of it and then I'm thinking about my enjoyment level of who I'm playing it with around the table so like those things factor in like how I come up with reading a game um ease of play is something that like I think about so like I might um I guess for me if it's going to be like a complex like a heavyweight game that takes a lot of like time and understanding to learn um it better be amazing like if I am investing you got to have that payoff yeah you have that payoff um it better be amazing so it's
going to be harder for me to I think come up with like actually if I think about like heavyweight games that are going to be like 10 out of 10 because um like it if I'm like Nemesis for instance spending hours reading through those rules and finally like getting it out to the table like it took a long time to learn and play but like man it was worth it or even just when we did um flow like I was thinking like I keep thinking about the game I'm like I told Carly I'm like I think I would actually give that game a 10 out of 10 I like I think I would I keep thinking about it yeah I keep and I'm like that's what I keep I keep thinking about it too like yeah it's just one that I keep like okay I I actually really like yeah and it was like so like for that one because like I'm I have Goosebumps like initially after playing it well maybe because it took but like it took us a long time to like learn and puzzle through but at the end it was just like it was so satisfying and fun a game that I think is an easy like seven is wingspan which I know some people would give that game a higher rating for me wingspan is a Seven and Seven is something that I think is like worth having in a collection for me like I like it's good it's a good game I enjoy playing it I will absolutely play it if you want to play it um often times I think it's worth teaching to other people but like we also don't love it yeah I don't like love it like I would play Splender over wingspan um cuz for
me for whatever reason like there's just and I like I like worms span a lot more than I like wingspan um worms span I don't know what I get I don't I think I give did I give it an eight in the video I think I actually give it a nine I can't remember I don't remember but like I think it's actually a nine that's my cuz like when about the ratings change Yeah the more I've played it the more it like keeps Rising for me to yes so like that's sometimes you have to take that into account too like that's why it's important for us to like just give you the information I know that sometimes our numbers fluctuate eight um is something I'm going to feel a little bit more excited about and I'm like I definitely like want that one in my collection um like it leaves if for it to be an eight it's got to leave that like that like half to have that slight more punch factor nine is like I love this game definitely want it like should be in my collection want to play with other people but where I can see like I can still see some of those like things that might like that keep it from being a 10 and then a 10 is like a game that in your eyes you feel like is just a perfect game you absolutely love it MH just yeah love it like I feel like it just leaves me so excited and like I just want to keep delving into it and like let's just play it again and again and again and that has been like I've said race for the Galaxy learned that game eight years ago and it's still like
I just remember being like Oh my gosh like it took me a while to learn it I was just like but it just like filled something in yeah so I I I definitely feel that way about games around five is kind of where I start to actively like dislike something around five is where I like okay like you said like I would rather be playing something else I'm start like I see stuff about it that I personally really don't like like most of the games we review on the channel are between a seven all the way up to a 10 those are the most um those are kind of where the ratings kind of tend to fall the reason why is because I tend to I vet things before they even come on the channel like I go through and I'm like okay I am like I only put games on my channel that I'm genuinely interested in I've said that from the beginning I will continue to say that if I were to review every single game out there there would be a ton of games that are lower than a five yeah so coming back to like our ratings yeah most ratings kind of do fall between a seven and a 10 cuz I've already I already have an inherent interest in the game and reviewing games it really does take so much time it takes a lot of time to learn like to learn the game that we we have good handle it um and so yeah I mean all that kind of go goes into why we vet games we're board game enthusiasts we're excited and we want to like talk about the things and board game and share the things that make us like excited and happy about board games and want to share that with you guys so that yeah you the more maximize fun
maximize enjoyment maximize just like the joy that tabletop games can bring to like individuals and families and friends and yeah so we talked about me and like how what I kind of think of like as a seven eight nine 10 9 10 um what what for you I arac I love love the ls of arnac so the reason why I rate I would rate that one to 10 and again I was in between for the longest time I was like arnac is a nine I love it it's a nine but then I was like if I really love it that much why is it not a 10 like why why is arnac not a 10 for me and I I couldn't think of a reason why yeah so yeah arnac arnac is a 10 for me I think it's a game it's a game that I could I always want to play it's a game that um I just I love all the different mechanisms that it introduces I love the gameplay I love the artwork I love the theme the Indiana Jones going out and exploring it just it just hits everything that like I want from a game basically it has worker placement it has deck building it has you know Resource Management it has the huge beautiful table presence the huge board like literally everything that I want in a game is just like check check check check check I guess when I say arnac I mean specifically arac with the missing or with the expansion in it that adds the um variable player Powers so like you play as different characters so that specifically is what I think cuz I think without that arac would be a nine but
with that expansion that adds different player it adds that little extra punch where it's like okay it's a 10 for me with that expansion I'm very similar with you in regards to my feelings on the ranking system what I do when I'm reviewing games is I I review a game and give it a number based on the way that it's presented to me so if it's a light game I'm looking at it through the scope of I'm comparing it to other light games I'm not comparing it to Big heavyweight games that even though I might prefer heavyweight games more that's not what that's not what like a light game is it's meant to be a light kind of breathing game I guess I just compare to similar weight classes and I com I I review it again in the light that it's presented and the way that it's it's presented to me like everdale everdell is like you know a mediumweight game so I'm I'm approaching it and comparing it to other mediumweight games uh that that are in you know that are in um in the industry at the time that's kind of how I go about getting numbers um because I think it's unfair to to try to compare stuff to other things that are like wildly different so I try to kind of compar to similar items if that makes sense yeah we should do um lists like top 10 in each of like those category like top 10 like small games or like easy or like yeah like family weight games top 10 heavyweight games top 10 yeah because again that that's how that's how I rate games that's how I review games and when I'm coming down to a number it's like okay like like there's going to be um a review coming
up for like a little lightweight card game I was like okay I'm not comparing this to Arn know but I am comparing it to other lightweight card games and how do I feel about it compared to other ones so that's kind of where I primarily kind of get my numbers is from that and I think that makes sense and I like I think part of my like I said it's for whatever reason like in my head I'm like can I give simple game such a high rating but like I should do that in terms of like compar where it actually falls yeah compared to like other games in that same kind of category I think it really helped nail down a number because it kind of helps take your own personal bias out of it a little bit because again us being Gamers we' kind of tend to play heavier games we tend to play games with a lot going on and I I prefer that I think you prefer that too over like a light game but again if a light game is brought to us it's not saying that it's a heavyweight game it's saying it's a light game so we should be comparing it with in the realm like I said within the scope that it's presented to us all right so having said all that um I do want want to kind of so something that I want to be starting like moving forward with reviews is um in the description of all of our videos I want to add like a little chart that talks about kind of just like a little brief chart that kind of says what each little number means and I'm actually just I decided we kind of have been talking about this um on what each little each number oh you're so sad want to go to Kim really quick this see really quick
distract um I do we kind of were discussing about like what our numbers meant and I actually went to BGG to see exactly like what their numbers like cuz they have like their rating system and they actually have a description for every every single number so I was like oh you know what let's just go and kind of see what what they did um and they actually lined it lined up almost exactly with kind of what we were talking about so I think I'm just going to adopt this um and put it on the channel basically a one was like awful I love the little thing it says defies game description so one is awful two is very bad won't play ever again um three is bad likely won't play again four is not so good but could play again five is mediocre which makes sense cuz it's like you know take it or leave take it or leave it um six is okay um seven is good so now we kind of start getting into like kind of actually having desire to play it um eight is very good enjoy playing and would suggest it nine is excellent and then 10 is outstanding we'll always enjoy playing so that is kind of the system that we're going to be going off of now um so now after we play games and we kind of get our thoughts um we're going to kind of refer to this list and based on you know our feelings that's where our ratings are going to be um so like I mentioned that's going to be in the description of all of our reviews moving forward just to kind of have that reference that you can kind of look back on um if you kind of need more clarification about what our reviews or what our numbers kind of mean when we're
giving ratings something else that we're going to be doing though um which is a brand new thing to the channel that I've been kind of I've been messing around with this idea for a little bit I really wanted to do it and finally I was like you know what let's just let's just do it um so we kind of were talking about games that we rate a 10 um games moving forward on the Channel games that we rate a nine or above we will be giving a special little like award over here on the channel for um so it's going to be called the um the the oh my goodness what is it the queen bee queen bee oh my goodness my mind's gone my mind's gone so it's the queen bee the board game buz queen bee award which again will be awarding to those games that we just feel like are particularly excellent um and so yes so moving forward that's what we're going to be doing on the channel and it'll be fun because like Kim mentioned at the end of every year we can do a little video looking back on on you know the handful of games that we just thought were particularly excellent that year that we were able to play um so yes that's something kind of a little fun thing that we're going to be adding to the Chanel channel that we're going to be doing I think it's just going to be a fun little touch little little fun touch to the channel I think age so all right so thank you for joining us for this kind of chaotic Buzz chat episode chatting about why we rank games but I think it's a good one to have I think it's a good thing to have on the channel um just kind of chatting about our reasoning behind ranking games because again every channel is different so I think it's good to have kind of that perspective on what how we are approaching our games um and kind of yeah how we do that you guys to get to
know us a little bit more a on a deeper level and like the way we think about things and experience things and um you should definitely leave comments about how you rank games yes yes definitely leave a comment about how you rank games um and what what what what what game would be a 10 for you like what what's a 10 game what is a 10 game what is in your eyes like a perfect idea of like a perfect game so thanks so much for spending some time with us today we hope you have a great rest of yours and we will see you next time