Skip to main content
Loading video...

10 Overrated/Underrated Board Games on the Board Game Geek Top 100 | King's Court

Transcript 24:09

pardon the interruption i'm kyle king welcome back to another episode of kings court welcome back to foster the meeple a channel all about board games and board gaming things buckle in folks cause today things are gonna get a little bit dicey because i'm gonna go over five games in the top 100 on vgg that i think are overrated and five that i also think are underrated now i want to preface this real quick overrated has a very negative connotation like if i say over something's overrated it's automatically assumed that i don't like it or that i think it's bad or that i think the person that likes it is dumb and i just hope you guys realize that's not the case now as i go over these overrated these games i consider overrated i'm gonna be a little hyperbolic and i'm gonna get a little bit passionate possibly this is just for fun when i say overrated it means to me it means this game is ranked something on bgg and i think it's higher than what it should be and same thing for underrated these are games that i like i just don't understand why they're so low and this is for me for me for me for me let's dive right in we'll start off positive and we'll go with the first underrated game on my list and this is at number 94 it's going to be lord of the rings journeys in middle earth now this game is underrated to me because of what it does is not necessarily necessarily unique but it really invokes the theme now i'm not much of a campaign co-op person at all i rarely play cooperative

i play campaign games even less but this one just really like excites me and i'm not even that big of a lord of the rings fan i didn't watch the movies until last year and i do like them quite a bit but it's just fun to dive in that fantasy world and it doesn't the components are really nice and what i really like about journeys in middle earth is that it's app based and it tells you what tiles to put out and you start off with like two tiles on your table you can see which way you can explore but you don't know what's necessarily coming so it really gives you the exploration and like discovery aspect i'm just like surprised it's not higher considering the theme considering the components considering how much content there actually is out there for it i'm just a little surprised it's not higher than 94. especially considering mentions of madness which is like its predecessor is so high up all right so let's go into overrated my first overrated game in the top 100 is going to be at 95 and that's raiders of the north sea raiders of the north sea is from shim phillips and garfield games i actually like garfield games pretty well i think more people like garfield games more than i do but i like the west kingdom trilogy i love paladins and architects is a pretty good game but raiders of the north sea is a game to me that makes a very good first impression or a very good second impression and then it really falls off after that it's kind of like the movie beer fest you watch that in high school and it's like the funniest thing in the world and then you watch it 16 years later and it's horrendous raiders of the north seas just like has a really unique work replacement mechanism of like placing on a worker taking the action and then picking up a worker and that's your new worker for the next round and when you pick up a worker you also take that action so you get two actions around that is unique the problem with that is

all the actions are pretty boring and you have to do a lot of them before you get to do the cool thing of raiding which is how you're going to get points but the problem is when you go raiding you kind of like destroy everything you've just built up and thematically that makes sense because you're vikings and you're going to valhalla and and all of that it just kind of frustrates me spend so much time building up your engine only to kind of like strip it away and i'm just kind of surprised it gets this much love because like it's never exciting for a viking raiding game i would just i would just rather play champions of midgard i'd rather play blood rage which is drastically different but like they're just better games that invoke vikings to me all right back to underrated my second underrated game is going to be at 85 and this is gonna be key flower key flower i'm sure was higher up on the list before i think it's just kind of dropped you don't hear much very many people talk about key flower anymore i don't know if it's not readily available i think it's in print still but key flower is a it's kind of like an auction worker placement game where everybody has meeples behind a screen and you can either use those meeples to bid on tiles to put in your little city or you can put them on tiles in your city or in other people's cities to take that action and it's just a really fun mechanism a lot of like interesting play between the players of the table while also being like just a really good like work replacement game and resource management game it's just such a solid euro uh it has a ton of interaction the 85 just seems low for like just like how balanced and how pinky that game is my next overrated game i have a feeling this one might get a ton of pushback this is number 74 and it is five tribes

five tribes is not my style i actually have problems with five tribes because it's not just the ap thing so in five tribes if you don't know it's kind of like a mancala system and if you don't know what mancala is it's just like you pick up everything and then you drop it off one by one on different spots until you drop off your last one and five tribes does that and at first i was like oh my god that's really cool each meeple there are five tribes there are five different meeples but each meeple triggers a different action and so that is that's really interesting that's really cool i understand the appeal of five tribes the problem with five tribes is i think this could be a my group's meta problem but the green meeple gives you an action of buying cards and those cards are like used for set collection points and i found that to just be kind of broken and op and i also think set collection is like kind of a boring mechanism in gaming in general so when you're taking this game that has a lot of ap of like what's the best move really thinking about like where you want to drop off these meeples and like the best thing to do is set collection it just it just kind of bores me some of the actions are just more fun but they're not as lucrative points wise honestly i see why people like it but i just 74 is still too high i don't know if it needs to be in the top 100 honestly but that that is just me so my next underrated game is gonna be 76 the voyage is a marco polo that game is underrated because of exclamation point camels and that is exclusively for middle class joe in the discord he gives me a hard time about like marco polo because i call things

out for being boring and he makes fun of that you can get camels that's not the only reason marco polo is underrated marco polo is a worker placement diet with dice game so everybody has five dice and you roll them whatever you roll is the power on that die so if you roll a one it's not going to get you as good of items or what you necessarily need to do like if you need to use it for movement it's only going to get you one movement spot whereas like a dice with a five can get you five movement spots but the thing with those dice is if somebody already goes to an action space that you want to go to you can still go there but it's going to cost you the pips on your die so if somebody already went to the spot to move and you also needed to move this round because you just have to because moving is hard you will go there and if you need to move five spots you're spending five bucks and money is tight and all the resources are tight and it's just like a constant like you're never going to be able to do everything middleweight euros like your marco polos like your lorenzo magnificos and your choirs and those middleweight euros that's a it's a very crowded field and i think they're all kind of competing with each other and it's hard for them to like state claim and it's a little bit of an older title and had a second rendition so i'm sure that's why it's at 76 i just think it's a little bit better than that my next overrated game comes in at number 48 and this actually has two games on the top 100 which is a completely separate problem which i will get into later i promise you but number 48 is the crew and the crew is a cooperative trick taking game i am from the midwest i love trick taking i grew up on euchre i mean i think euchre could be one of the reasons i fell in love

with board gaming because i just love gaming with my family i love playing cards on holidays and so trick taking is in my blood so when i heard about the crew i was like excited because i just like i like trick taking games even though i'm not a big cooperative player i was down to try because i've played the mind before and i knew it was kind of like a mix of the mind where you're not speaking but the crew doesn't really work for me for a few reasons first reason is i like trick taking games because like euchre and spades because it's kind of like mindless and just like conversational game i like playing euchre at holidays because we would have the football game on and we would all just be talking and talking about the football game and you're just kind of just playing cards and i know people like well that sounds dumb and it might be but that's why one of the reasons i like it it's like comfort food and in the crew you're not allowed to talk it's just it's all silent somebody's gonna say like you can't talk yeah you technically can talk but you're not supposed to it's supposed to be silence because you're all trying to win certain tricks and you can't talk about it honestly if you can't talk about it is it really cooperative if you're not working together so that's another problem my second problem with the crew is it's pretty dang easy if you have played trick taking games like me and all of my friends have i've nev we've never struggled to complete a mission and we may have lost twice out of like 30 plays and we won that mission the next time we played it and it didn't matter if we started with the first one or we started with mission 40. we just found it pretty easy to win and yeah things got dicey and there were those fun moments of like oh i hope he plays

this because i need to play this card there there was that the crew is not necessarily like a heinous game i don't think it's a 0 out of 10. i just i'm shocked that it's in the top 50. absolutely shocked i don't understand why people there are so many better trick taking games there are so many better cooperative games there are so many better hidden information games i just think it kind of was like unique at the time and like it just i think it just shot up the charts because of like what it did it's like oh my god a cooperative trick kicking game automatically i'm in but it just doesn't work for me and i think i speak for the other people at ftm they also think the crew is overrated but let's move on to another underrated game and this one you guys might think is kind of weird that i'm calling it underrated 62 is azul and you're thinking azul has five different renditions and bass as well as getting a second edition the three themed into chocolate and you're like how is that underrated uh well just because it's at 62 really azul is i think azul is the perfect entry-level game it's very easy to teach it's beautiful it's very quick to play it's as interactive as you want it to be it's as interactive as the players want it to be i like to play a pretty cut-throat hate drafting game of bezel like when i play with jeff he also likes to play that style and it's more of like we are trying to get the highest score we can but we're also trying to stick the other person to where they have 10 tiles at the bottom because that's going to get them negative points so if you can't place tiles you have to put them on the bottom of your board and that's like negative points and you're just trying to stick a person with negative points it's it's so much fun it creates such memorable moments i don't

know how many times we've cursed at each other through discord based on our azul plays but you can also not do that you can completely ignore what the other person is doing and just focus on you and have just the good of a time and it's also the same thing with like why like tricky games you can kind of shut your mind off and just play the game you can play it outside this is a game i play with my wife out on our patio and it's just a really fun summer time game great game for couples great game for game groups you can play it at two or four it's still gonna hit 62 is woefully low in my opinion i think it's just a perfect perfect entry level game it should be way higher anytime anybody asked me for a suggestion to get into board games i think azul would be right there with everything my next overrated game is at number 28 viticulture now viticulture is by stone meyer games that is work replacement game where you are making wine and i don't even drink wine i drink pepsi but you can't go to a party with ring dings and pepsi viticulture has a few issues for me and i have played with tuscany i'm going to stop you right there commenters and say have you played with tuscany yes i play with tuscany tuscany does make the game a little bit better i don't hate viticulture i did own it for a while and the only reason i got rid of it is because i have two friends that also owned viticulture so if they didn't own viticulture i would still own it i'm kind of like baffled that it's like people's number one game it is a work replacement game that doesn't do work replacement in like a super unique way the grande worker i guess is kind of kind of a neat implementation of work replacement but what i don't like is that it's it's never really about the wine it's a lot of card draws and i like

card drawing i don't mind randomness in my games but when it becomes like a race to find cards and it's not even the card the card problem like if it was like if the cards just built your engine instead of giving you points i'm all for it and i've heard the visitors from the rhine whatever the newest expansion was the rhine valley expansion i've heard it fixes a bit and i've never not had a chance to play with it so bear with me there viticulture should be about making the wine right you should be making wine you should be fulfilling wine contracts to to win the game and you don't really have to do that and if you do do that you only really have to do it once and that's over seven rounds and that's just that's just doesn't sit well with me another problem i have and this may just be a me thing is i like scythe what side does with how money is points and i think that was a big miss with viticulture i think money should have been what decides the who decides the winner it just makes more thematic sense to me if you're running a wine business points is so abstracted out and money is tangible and it makes sense like you ran the best vineyard you and you can prove it flush with cash john ralphio style my last underrated game comes at 52 i'm gonna say right now this game is in my top ten i tried not to do this because like i've already have a top 10 video you guys and gals already know i like those 10 games so i tried not to do this but this one could not be ignored 52 is claims of caledonia i'm really wondering how it's not higher ranked and it's got to be because just not being really in print anymore 52 is still pretty high for a game that came out a

few years ago and not really in print i guess but i think it should be so much higher it gets this design philosophy from terra mezca and guy project both those games are also in the top 100 i think teramisca's like 22 and guy project 7. so it gets its system from two games that are higher up already so that makes me think it's underrated but it takes that system and it puts it an economic spin on it and it puts the stock market in there and you're constantly manipulating the stock market and trying to sell and it has contract fulfillment and it has area control and it just has all these little euro bits that everybody seems to love and i can't believe cleansing caledonia doesn't get more more praise for what it does the actions are relatively simple when you compare to other euros it's it's not a bad looking game it's a relatively small box it was pretty inexpensive when you could get it i i'm just like i can't believe it just never got as high as some of these other middle to heavyweight euros like gaia project like terramiska and those games are infinitely harder to learn clans of caledonia i could teach you clans of caledonia in 20 minutes a guy a project i've played six times and i'm still not sure i'm playing it correctly that's my last underrated game i tried not to pull games from my top 10 but that one i i just could not ignore it i'm still shocked claims of caledonia is not in the top 50. my last overrated game it's your big boy it is the number one game of all time it is gloomhaven i've mentioned with the crew that the crew had two games in the top 100 and it shouldn't this was the other one that does that and that's jaw's the lion joe the lion is at number five gloomhaven has two games in the top five jaws of lion is the exact same game as

gloomhaven that makes no sense to me and jeff brought this up on a previous video because we were discussing this we were discussing how like bloomhaven has two games the crew has two games agricola has two games ti4 and ti3 are both on there brass has two games and it's really like if the games are the same system and there's nothing really that can like truly separate them like the pandemic legacies i get put all of them separate they're completely different games bgg has to figure something out with having the same game in the top 100 twice and i say this as like a zeroth world problem like who the heck cares this is bg's top 100 it's not that big a deal but like in the context of this argument is it is kind of a big deal for what this is it just doesn't make sense to me why gloomhaven should have the game number one in game number five and when frost even releases whenever that gets out delivered it's also gonna be in the top five i guarantee you gloomhaven has three games in the top five uh when frosthaven releases and that's absurd to me but let's go into why i think bloomhaven is a little overrated blue maven is now five years old when gloomhaven came out and one year after gloomhaven came out if it was number one i'm all for it i understood in 2019 why gloomhaven was number one it just doesn't make sense to me now in 2022 why gloomhaven is number one it is a dungeon crawler that was kind of a first adopter it wasn't the first dungeon crawler but it did something that made you pay attention it gave you 90 scenarios it gave you an rpg video game level of like leveling up and building a character it gave you tons of content it

gave you tons of map titles that gave you tons of minis it was a kickstarter that was like over a hundred and some dollars when gloomhaven came out on kickstarter and it released everybody's like oh my god i got this massive box this is so phenomenal look at all this content i got it it was exciting i get it when i got gloomhaven i was so excited i took a picture my daughter was one at the time i took a picture of her with the box to compare sizes it was a joy to get gloomhaven but now like i'm not even sure if gloomhaven is like my biggest box on my shelf i don't even know if it's in the top four it set that trend um which i don't know is is great actually but it set a lot of things in place but it's almost been surpassed there are tons of dungeon crawlers and now all those dungeon crawlers have apps to assist because gloomhaven is a ton of maintenance the gloomhaven helper app which is not produced by gloomhaven it was like some third party created it is a huge help but if you don't have that let's say you don't have that it's so much upkeep it's so much dealing with monsters and health and flipping through a rule book and checking statuses and the monster movement oh my god the monster movement is ridiculous i had a note in my phone every time i played to like bring up when we needed to do monster movement to check to make sure we were doing it right and like to be honest with you folks i'm not sure i was we were still doing the movement correct i don't get as frustrated with losing in other games as i do with gloomhaven losing gloomhaven sucks it sucks so hard because if you lose you gotta do you gotta replay that mission if you lose you just spent four hours if you lose you just did all of this setup you just

got your game group together you just you scheduled this night and like i i'm a person who thinks cooperative should be hard i like spirit island i like how tight pandemic is every time it's a it's a race robinson crew so brutal i want my co-ops to be hard but with gloomhaven and it being a campaign and it being a long campaign 60-some scenarios to play through the main storyline 90 if you want to play all the side missions or something like that so when you lose it sucks oh my gosh we've been playing gloomhaven for literally four years we're almost done i think we have four or five scenarios left and losing is terrible it's the reason it's taking so long this is maybe more of a me problem but i get kind of quarterback-y in gloomhaven because i don't want to lose i care so much about winning i kind of wish we would have house ruled it that way if we lose maybe we just don't get we don't get experience points we don't get coins but we can move on because it's really made it to the point where it's just annoying it puts me in a bad mood i think about what i did wrong and that's not the case for other games between jaws of the lion and basically haven i'm well over 100 hours i also think the scenarios have gotten kind of stale are all pretty much just kill all the monsters there's nothing truly unique about them and it's a masterpiece in like balancing don't get me wrong the monsters and the many and all the different characters and how they all interact with the map and how balanced it is is mathematical genius give them props between that and the card play i get why it was number one in the first place truly but they are like after playing this many hours of it like

nothing excites me about gleamhaven anymore i i just can't envision these last five scenarios showing me something that i haven't already seen in the previous 50 i've played that's kind of a tough pill to swallow for me i'm just like really really surprised that so many people have been like so okay with that and i think other campaign games they may not give you the scenarios quantity that gloomhaven gives you but sometimes less is more like destiny's was five scenarios and that was perfect i think people got excited about more content more content more content because that's what our hobby is we're always searching for expansions we're always searching for more when we back up on kickstarter we go all in i'm no stranger to this i have all of unk i have not played olivonk i will never play olivak so that's kind of my my issues with gloomhaven and i think there's a few reasons why it's still number one i think it got a huge huge influx of tens when it got released because for all the reasons i stated i think it gets a huge influx of tens because it was kind of the first of its kind and to be fair it did get tens because it is a good design i still like gloomhaven gloomhaven is still an excellent game the design is great what isaac childress did is genius level he deserves all the success he got and i hope it keeps coming for him frost haven't gonna be another massive hit i'm not taking anything away from the game because i do like it however i think people have rated it tens for superfluous reasons over gameplay reasons i think it's a game that deserves to be in like the top 20 top 15 that would not shock me but the fact that it's still number one five years

after release is is kind of crazy to me you may ask me well kyle if gloomhaven is not number one what should be and maybe you're not asking me that i don't know but if i had to pick a game for bgg number one i'm not gonna pick blood rage which is my number one game of all time i get why people have problems with blood rage or may why it may not be everybody's cup of tea if i had to pick a game for bggs the board gamer as a whole number one what game do i think would make the most sense as the number one game of all time it would be brass between a combo of birmingham and lakeshore make them one entry and make them the number one game i think brass does things so well it's complex but it's not so complex that not every everybody can learn it i think there are a few touchy rules that are kind of fiddly especially in birmingham it is relatively easy actions you're playing cards to take actions i think it has a ton of inner player interaction so i think people that like play interaction will like brass i like people that like economic games like brass i think people who like euro games will like brass i think people who ameritrash may even like brass because the theme does kind of come out it's very thematic there is some luck involved and there's a lot of strategy and there's a lot of like player manipulation and there's just a lot of ways to to win the game and to be competent at the game and i also think you can not be that great at it and still have a good time because you're still doing something you can still have turns that feel good so that's the game that i think as a community i'm surprised is not number is not number one but there you have it folks those are five games that i think are overrated and five games that i think

are underrated in the bgg top 100 i know i preface at the beginning but i cannot go without saying again that this was all in fun if you think i'm wrong please tell me but just like just don't be a jerk about it if i called one of your favorite games overrated i don't think any less of you i still think all these games are great there's a reason in the top there in the top 100 i'm in the minority if i say it's overrated obviously i get it i just want to i just think it's fun to to kind of talk about this stuff and get into debates of like this is overrated this is underrated i think it creates a lot of good dialogue if you're interested in buying any games such as from the bgg top 100 may i first suggest checking out your friendly local game store if you're ever in columbus check out the guard tower on trebu if you're ever in halifax go to the boardroom game cafe on barrington if you enjoyed this video please like and subscribe comment below let's chat come and join us in the discord we'll chat there and i think that's all all right stay sweet and i did the mind is okay um it's not really a game like media excuse me the next reason is i think it's overrated i just lost my thought give me a second here jamie i'm sorry i'm sorry i'm sorry i believe oh okay i know what point is sorry jamie that's a lot of editing for you

you

Progress saved