Top 100 Mechanisms in Board Games: 20-11
Transcript
hi i'm adam porter and this is my top 100 board game mechanisms and this is now the top 20 number 20 to 11. so let's get stuck in number 20 is stockholding so this is where i have stuff and it's worth a certain amount but the value of that stuff changes throughout the game based on the player's actions so a game i've mentioned a couple of times throughout this list already is the game habengut which is a pure stockholding game where we're buying stock and then we're adapting the price of that stock we're trying to buy it when it's cheap and sell it when it's expensive and so at the end of the game to play with the most money is going to win the game i find that really satisfying thing watching the value of things change i really love the game arcadia which is a game where we're laying out polyamino type tiles and and trying to surround those tiles in order to gain seals so these little tokens and the value of those seals is dependent on the colors that are showing on the top of a central castle and so throughout the game we can adapt that we can change the the castle pieces on the top of that castle to try and make our seals more um valuable and then you've got to choose when are you going to sell those seals in order to get those rewards really satisfying i really like the game airlines europe where you've got control of a number of different airlines you're laying out planes around the board and every now and then there's a scoring round and you're gonna score points based on who has the most of certain different types of of airlines um we can get into really heavy stuff
like 18xx now 18xx are big train games that go on for hours and hours hugely complicated lots of economics lots of money being exchanged i've dabbled with 1830 found it a little bit too much and that's probably an entry point into the genre as well but i found it a little bit too much a little bit too long a little bit daunting for me but i really enjoy the game poseidon which is a simplified 18xx game which i don't think is particularly well loved but i enjoyed it it felt like a step up from something like power grid now power grid also has a sort of a stock market of sorts in that the the cost of individual resources changes throughout the game based on the sort of supply and demand you know as resources are taken off the board then they become more expensive as they put back onto the board they become cheaper and so again choosing which resources to buy and when to power your power stations is a big part of the game number 19 is lying in games so games where you get to tell outright lies and the other players have to look at your face and think can i tell the truth and read read what's going on with you so the purest one of these that i know of is cockroach poker i absolutely love cockroach poker it's one of my favorite games this is a game where you basically just take a card and you pass it to the next player and you say this is a spider and they have to say whether they think it is a spider or it isn't a spider that's essentially it that's essentially the whole game i mean clearly there are some
minor little rules in there that just make the game work make it flow but essentially that's it lying to other people and then them guessing whether you're telling the truth or not um i find it funny i find it funny watching other people trying to lie seeing them you know not being able to hold that poker face you know see them cracking up playing it with children and they you know they're trying to tell a lie but they're giggling and it's written all over their face that they're lying getting away with it you know double bluffs where you try and you make it look like you're lying even though you're not lying so they accuse you of lying when you weren't and so you know it's really really satisfying i find it an exciting and exciting mechanism in games another game that does it really well is the game sheriff of nottingham where we get to put different resources chickens bread cheese and we put it into a little pouch and then we have to pass it to the sheriff and we say this is what i've got in my pouch you tell them what we've got i've got three chickens in that pouch and they have to decide whether they think you do have three chickens and let it pass or whether they think that you're lying and you're actually trying to sneak through some illegal bit of contraband in which case they might say no i don't think so i'm going to open your pouch and if if you were lying you're going to take a penalty and then you can start bribing the sheriff to say oh please don't open my pouch and so you start bribing them and you know it again you can get those double bluffs where you're bribing them and so they they do open your pouch but it turns out you were telling the truth all along and so then they take a penalty and
i find these games hilarious um and there's not that many of them where you get there's lots of games where you get to to bluff and maybe we might talk about that a little bit later on but there's lots again you get to bluff but games where you get to outright tell a lie i find that enjoyable i do not in life in life i try and avoid it but in games it's fun to do something that's a bit naughty yeah something that you wouldn't normally do in everyday life i find that great i find that really really engaging number 18 is another mechanism which is a bit mean spirited and i guess again it's something i probably wouldn't do in life but i do really enjoy doing in a game so a bit like the previous entry and this is specific to one game that i know of there probably are again there probably are more games like this so please tell me if you're aware of another game that uses this mechanism but it's what i'm calling here the dragon's gold mechanism so in dragon's gold your there are dragons laid out they've got different types of treasure on them and different players are going to be playing cards onto these dragons to try and defeat the dragons so each dragon is going to be defeated when a certain total number of cards has been played to it and that will be a combination of cards from different players now all the players who have played cards to defeat that dragon are entitled to a share of that treasure but you've got a time limit to agree what that share is going to be so we turn over a timer and then you just argue it out you say i want this i want
this and i want this the other player says i want this and this and you've got to argue about it and come to an agreement now if you don't come to an agreement within that time limit nobody's getting anything so you can really bully your way through that you can stand firm and say i'm afraid that's it i'm either having all this stuff or we're not having anything and it's that game of chicken isn't it how long can you hold that stance before you give in and say all right then i'll just have the one piece and i i've i mean i've played this with the games of this where it's been really a sour experience where people haven't enjoyed it at all because somebody's really gone for those bully tactics um and i've played games of it where it's really really funny and enjoyable so it's very much a game where you have to pick the players that you want to play it with but it's one of the most memorable mechanisms that i've seen in games and and those those games are the games themselves are very very memorable to me the games that i've had of it um i enjoy it i don't pull this game out very often but i think it's clever and as i mean as far as i know it's unique it probably isn't and you can you can correct me on that um so yeah this is a game by bruno for duty and kudos to him for coming up with such a clever system we've previously talked about the um contract trick taking games and this uh particularly end particular entry in my list is also trick taking games but this one is point trick taking games and i'm also
combining in this evasion trick taking games okay so in a trick-taking game um as i've mentioned in the previous video you're playing a series of cards so i play a card the next player plays a card the next player plays a card and then the person who's played the highest card um gets all of those cards and takes the trick and puts it in front of them now there's all sorts of other twists to it often you're having to follow suit so if i play a blue card everyone has to play a blue card if they've got one often there are trump suits and things like this but the core of it is we each play a card in sequence and the highest card takes that set of cards if you want to know more about trick taking please go back and watch some of my previous videos i've got a lot of videos about trick taking on the channel but in a point trick taking game the value of the cards that you've taken is really important so there's specific cards that you want and you've got to manipulate which tricks you take in order to try and make sure you take those cards and the reason i've brought in evasion is because it's exactly the opposite this is where there are certain cards that you don't want and so you're trying to avoid winning those tricks while you're trying to certainly trying to achieve winning the other tricks with the high point scoring cards so it's the same mechanism just in reverse and i find that really satisfying it's the opposite to a plane trick-taking game a plane trick-taking game is where we just play um a series of tricks and then the person who's won the most tricks for example would uh would win the game and it wouldn't matter the value of those tricks it's just the case of winning a trick is a point
essentially so in a point trick-taking game or an evasion trick-taking game the specific cards matter and the specific cards may even have special powers and things like this on them as in a game like chronicle um but ultimately i enjoy that trying to work out right in this round that the cards have been laid out do i want them uh do i want all of them so maybe there's a couple of high point scoring cards but there's also a card i'm trying to evade as well well what's the balance there do i want that trick or don't i and if i okay so i play so i'm winning a trick but then somebody plays a card into that trick that i don't want now i've got to take it because i won the trick okay i find that a really satisfying balance a nice little puzzle to work out and i think these are probably my favorite type of trick taking games number 16 is very closely related to trick taking and this is climbing games sometimes called ladder climbing games so this is where we you play a card the next player then has to play a higher card the next player has to play a higher card again or it might be that you play a set of cards so i might play three of a kind the next player has to play three of a kind but they've got to play a better three of a kind than me and so we go around the table until somebody is unable to play and then they get some sort of penalty um i find this a similar sort of puzzle to trick taking but actually i find it more engaging than trick taking and there are fewer of these games than there are trick taking games although there are some wonderful examples of it
in the hobby and mechanism number 15 is very closely related to climbing and that this is shedding games so shedding games is where you've got a hand of cards and you're trying to get rid of your cards okay you want to be the player that gets rid of all of your cards and so um when i was at school we played a um a a game which you know what i'm not gonna say the title because i don't know whether youtube likes it if i swear or not but the game was quite a sweary title uh and it was a game where you had to play cards in and it had to be higher than the previous cards so it was a climbing game but the goal of the game was to shed all of your cards get rid of all your cards before everybody else this game was reworked into a game called goost ghost or ghost it's got a load of o's in it by yellow and by richard garfield and that's a neat implementation at least a very pretty implementation of that game i used to play as a kid but it's also something that features shedding cards is the core of the game llama which was a very popular game very successful game uh by ryan kenitzia and amigos spieler a couple of years ago you also see it though in those um games i've mentioned previously i really enjoy games where you've got to say when you play a card and then you've got to do something a reaction or say something um dry maggie a speeder has a whole range of these different games like cockroach salad and tarantula tango and and plaparagai that i've talked about in a recent review but in plaparagai we turn over a card you've
got to say something and if you say the wrong thing or if you hesitate then you have to take cards back into your hand but you want to get rid of all your cards you want to shed your cards in order to win the game i really enjoy that mechanism because of the big wins and the big losses the big exciting moments you know and the the way you can pull it back you know the opponent takes you okay you've been taking cards for a while but you've not been taking huge numbers of cards and then the opponent has a particularly big loss they take a load of cards back into their hand that prevents them from shedding all their cards and you know those big swings are quite satisfying quite exciting number 14 is word play we often talk about word games in this hobby and to me it's never very clear whether we're talking about spelling games or games about word play so so i'm not using the word the word games i think is a a confusing um a confusing term a confusing genre so here we're talking about games with word play so word play would be something like code names where i've got to give a clue to the other players which is going to point them towards different cards in this grid and i want to point them to as many cards as i possibly can so i want to find a word which links a bunch of different cards so clever vocabulary knowing the other players around the table and what they're going to interpret from the clue that you give this is also featured in the recent game from blue orange called cross clues
which is a very similar much much lighter simpler version of of code names essentially where we've got a grid you're trying to connect two specifically two words um so yeah you've got a grid reference and it says right you need to connect this word and this word you've got to come up with a single word clue and the other players have to guess which two words you're trying to connect together i find it fires off a bunch of the sort of creative the creative part of my brain really trying to work out what i want to do and a lot of these games there is a bit of a problem that you know people might sit around for quite a while and think of their clues which is quite a quiet moment in otherwise a party game um so i think there are some issues with this mechanism but that not not issues enough to to stop these games being wildly successful um i really like the game huh or hein which i've mentioned previously because it uses the dixit scoring mechanism but in that game you've got to come up with a clue that points towards a certain film or celebrity or something like that and you want to make that clue obscure enough that um the other players don't all guess it but clever enough that you know obvious enough that some players guess it so the same mechanism as in dixit and in fact dixit is another example of really clever wordplay isn't it trying to come up with a clever clue that other players are gonna guess but it's not too obvious and you know it's a mechanism that just makes me feel clever when i manage to pull it off like i've
really achieved something impressive there number 13 on the list ironically involves no communication at all this is limited communication games um games where certain players or maybe all players can't actually speak to each other the game magic maze where we're all moving around this shopping mall or this maze and we're trying to find certain locations and certain items but we can't actually speak to each other so it's all played in real time and we've got this i i can only move pieces down somebody else can only move them left somebody else can only move them up and so on there's certain things you want the other players to be doing but you can't actually tell them all you can do is tap this this red wooden pawn to say do something and then thinking well i don't know what you want me to do i find that really fun the fact that everyone's desperate to speak but they can't they're not allowed other games that that use limited communication things like mysterium and deception murder in hong kong so this is where one player knows information but they can't tell you all they can do is give you clues so in mysterium they're going to give you images that represent dreams and you've got to interpret what they're trying to tell you in deception murder in hong kong they're going to place tokens onto onto a board that give you clues as to the nature of a murder and what the crime scene looked like and then you've got to try and interpret that to determine who the murderer was what the weapon was used and and so on i find that limitations on communication can create really unique situations and
unique puzzles for the players and they really help to eliminate the alpha player problem that can occur in cooperative games too so that's a real positive as well number 12 is stacking games so games where you physically put one piece on top of another to build a tower and you hope it doesn't collapse as simple as that why do i enjoy that i mean i can't really say it's just fun isn't it it's just tactile it's exciting watching that tower swaying it's there are big moments in these games you know the big moment is that time when that person puts the piece on top of their tower and you're sure it's going to collapse and it doesn't even though it's swaying in the wind that's a big moment few games achieve moments as tense as that few big strategy games achieve that and yet something as simple as stacking a bunch of blocks on top of each other does achieve it the moment when it collapses it's loud it's exciting pieces go everywhere visually it looks great it's tactile um i just think few games have moments as exciting as as the moments that you get in a stacking game and i've never played any other games where people get their cameras out as much as in a stacking game if i play a game of bandu or junk art you can guarantee that players are going to have their phones out and they're going to be taking photos of their structures i've no idea what they're going to do with these photos because no one's going to be interested but in that moment you feel so proud of what you've managed to achieve you can't
help but snapping pictures of it i mean that's a sign of an exciting game isn't it and finally number 11 which i enjoy for very similar reasons big moments in games this is flicking games another type one of the other big genres of dexterity games flicking games where we're flicking a piece across the board try and make contact with another piece or to try and get into a certain location so accuracy based flicking games i've made a whole video recently about top 10 mechanisms used in flicking games these are games that require a lot of skill or a lot of these flicking games are so games that you can get really good at croconol is a great example of a game that you can get really skilled at if you really take the time to learn or you can play it pretty casually um but big moments big wins big losses uh you know you aim the piece and you completely miss and mess up that's exciting it's funny or you make content you make an impossible shot that wins you the game there's a big moment of celebration there i think flicking games can be uh oddly thematic as well catacombs does a really really good job of this and flick them up as well the fact that you can hide behind a bit of terrain and then flick an arrow or flick a bullet out from beside it the big monsters are bigger discs small monsters are tiny discs traveling through open ground is dangerous yeah where there's nothing to hide behind because somebody else could shoot you you can see from the scenarios that are
created in games of catacombs and uh and flick em up and the different types of monsters and their powers just how kind of thematic this stuff can be the fact is unlike a dungeon crawler where you're rolling dice and moving around a grid and looking up statistics here we're actually doing what we're supposed to be doing if you want to attack somebody you run in and you attack them if you want to shoot somebody from behind a pillar you place your arrow you flick it and you try and make contact and you try and avoid that fiery pit in the middle so i just find it very dynamic um and and totally engaging and immersive so i love flicking games it's one of my favorite mechanisms as always we're also going to talk about one mechanism that i don't enjoy in games and today the mechanism well it's not really a mechanism it's a situation that can arise in certain games for various different reasons but i think the reasons are fairly uh are fairly common to each other i don't like it when i'm playing a game and i think the game is about to end because the certain sort of end game criteria is about to be hit and then somebody does something that changes that they either change the end game criteria itself or they change the game state in such a way that we're going to end up playing for another 20 minutes or so often it's when i'm not enjoying these games or i'm losing badly and i'm thinking well at least the game's going to be over soon there are a few moments in gaming that i find as frustrating as playing a game and thinking it's about to end and then
finding that it doesn't and i've got to keep playing for a little bit longer um i really think that's been some of my worst gaming experiences have been in situations like that so it could be for example when a game says the game's going to end when a certain player has a certain number of cards on the table in front of them but then perhaps a player plays a card which allows them to destroy one of the cards in front of one of the other players we've just added an amount of time onto this game which i mean that's no fun if i'm not enjoying the game i want it to be over i thought it was going to be over and now it's not i mean perhaps the problem here is that i'm not enjoying the game in the first place rather than the mechanism that extends the gameplay another example would be the game niagara i remember having that sort of situation where you're gathering certain gems from this river and i really enjoy the mechanisms in niagara the the the fantastic um table presence and the way that the river shifts that's all great but you're gathering a certain number of gems in order to end the game but those gems can be stolen from you so you can and it takes quite it's quite an effort to get these gems and so then to have the gems stolen just as you thought the game was going to finish and then you think well that's just added a whole 10 minutes 15 minutes 20 minutes onto the gameplay oh i don't really enjoy that at all i think that end game trigger uh you know if i can see it coming i want it to actually happen i remember similar instances in games of citadels
and guild hall i remember having bad experiences with these games because i wasn't enjoying it i was losing badly and then the game just seemed to go on and on and on because of the actions of the other players and through no fault of theirs because the game mechanisms allowed them to make a strong strategic move for themselves but ultimately it just elongated the game and elongated the the suffering for me and perhaps for other players around the table anyway i know that's not really a mechanism that's a that's a feeling that's a situation that games can create so please forgive me for that please do come back and watch my final video numbers 10 to number 1 in my top 100 board game mechanisms of all time please comment on this video let me know what mechanisms you enjoyed what mechanisms you didn't uh and please subscribe to the channel if you haven't already done so and i'll see you next time all the best