Board Of It's Top 10 Heaviest Complexity Board Games!
Transcript
Hi everyone. I'm Tally. This is Farrell. This is Spven. And we're Borovit. And welcome to our video which is called Borovit's top 10 heaviest games.
So we're going to go through what our most played heaviest games are. As you'll probably know if you follow this channel, we tend to lean and prefer the heavier games. They make up a good part of our top 10, top 20. So we're going to look at two metrics in this video. The first is number of plays and the second is complexity according to BGG just because we needed some sort of arbitrary cut off for complexity.
So we've taken anything that's above 3.5 out of five uh on BG's rating system in complexity. So all of our games will be there or higher usually higher.
Yeah.
So let's go straight in with number 10. So, in at number 10, we have John Company second edition. And this has a BGG complexity rating of 4.45. And we have 11 plays of this game.
Yeah, that might be the highest in complexity. We'll see. Or it's definitely up there, I think.
So, uh, yeah, 11 plays. John Company, second edition. And this was as of last year my favorite game of all time. Probably still is for slight spoilers,
but it's essentially a sirical take on the uh East India Trading Company and the kind of terrible things they did in India. And you play as kind of members of different families. And it's kind of an abstracted way to show how cutthroat things become when everything's abstracted out to kind of a map on a board and how cutthroat things become and savage and brutal. So, it's almost more like an RPG than a board game in some ways in that, you know, you're playing these families, you're making deals, you're trading, there's a lot of table talk and negotiation because you're all in it together, yet you're all in it to win it cuz only one person can win it. But in fact, the entire company can fail and everyone can lose.
So, I think what I really like about this is it's a game that just has so many outcomes and it's such a sandbox of possibilities. that there's so much interaction, so much craziness that even though this is a very long game, like we've even played the kind of long game where you play like back to back to back errors, uh we've got it to the table 11 times, which I mean in hours is like probably like four full days of our lives playing John Company.
Yeah, that's true. I think a lot of that is because we've actually introduced it to some people and they have also really enjoyed it. We have a friend that's requesting to play it all the time even though it'll be, you know, 9:00 p.m. on a Sunday and like let's get John company out and we're like, "Okay, no, no, maybe next weekend." But yeah, no, it is a really great game. I think the beauty of it in a way is it is complex. I'm kind of surprised it's that high because what you do turn to turn isn't that hard, but it's the decisions that you make can make.
I think you would say that because I run it like a games master.
Maybe. Yeah, maybe you're just really
because you like you've never had to do the events in India, right? Or things like that.
That is true. Um, but yeah, like you said, a lot of it is
what happens off the board, let's say, because you're doing a lot of negotiating. You can be like, "Hey, uh, uh, chairman, please make me the manager of shipping." So, a lot of the fun that we have with this game is down to that element, I think.
Yeah. But yeah, no, I think it is easy enough to get to grips with compared to some like other games that are similar to this. And I think like you said, you run it like a games master.
Yeah.
And the order of events kind of goes around the board in terms of like step by step by step. And there's a lot of different phases. Yeah.
But it's still clear, you know, what you should do on each step. But yeah, it's the decisions that you need to make and what the implications are of each of your actions which makes it so complex. But yeah, we've had a lot of fun playing this and getting into the role playing part of it.
Yeah. So, very very worthy number 10. And I would expect in the future this to keep climbing uh being my favorite game. I'll look for any opportunity to play it even though it's kind of a special occasion game. But with that, let's move on to number nine, which is even more of a special occasion game. So, in at number nine, we have Oath. And that has a complexity rating of 4.12. And we have 12 total plays of this game.
Yep. And we don't have the box to show you cuz it's down in the basement.
Don't want to go down in the basement. No,
there's board games everywhere that fall on top of it.
Exactly. So, this actually has kind of gone up. I'm not sure it would have made the list. Uh but the last couple of months, half year, one of our gaming groups has ended up playing it because they wanted to experience it. So I think we've had two or three games.
Yeah.
Uh with some friends. Essentially, Oath is a very strange game and also very complex obviously. Uh it's kind of like a legacy light type game where you're trying to you're kind of all different people in a kingdom and you're like vying for different win conditions. So depending on your allegiance basically it gets very convoluted in terms of who can win what where.
Yeah. But uh you know it's kind of comes to life through a lot of unique cards with a lot of unique card actions um that are kind of attached to different locations or different people. So that kind of makes each area unique or each person unique. Uh and you kind of have a core six actions that you're using to to battle and kind of claim land and and gather resources to have more than someone else cuz maybe that means you'll win. So where the legacy comes in is that once you play a game, uh the board state more or less kind of keeps lots of elements. Uh and it's based upon who wins a little bit. So areas they control will be the ones that that remain and things like that, but it it does hold over and you can kind of make these grand campaigns. And our Kickstarter version came with a journal that we always write in.
So yeah, what what do you think of both then? Especially now that we've got it out after like we played it a lot when we first got it and we haven't played it till now.
Yeah, it was super interesting getting it back out again after all that time because like you said, we played it so intensely when we first got it and then going back to it. I don't know. I found this with a few games that we haven't played in a few years recently, but it just wasn't as hard to get back to as I thought it was going to be
because when we first got it, it really did boggle my brain. Basically, again, it's one of those things where it tells you what the actions are like on your cards, but it's again the implications of what you do. I think here is way more convoluted than say what we had before with John Company.
Yeah.
It's just so abstract and like, okay, if I do this, what does that mean? Or like what am I trying to do to win? I think it was very difficult in the beginning to get that.
But going back to it,
I agree 100%.
It was so much easier now. Maybe it's just because we've played so many more games now.
Um, but we were able to teach the friends that had never played it before like pretty easy. They grasped it as well.
Even one first game.
Yeah, exactly.
Yeah. One thing about Oath is that it's a very king makery sometimes. And it that's what it came down to in
in the last round where it was one person or the other person would win I think based on maybe your action
and it was very much like you had the deciding factor really of who would win. So that's something to avoid if you don't like that. But um I guess one of the benefits of oath in that sense with the kingm is that
it's supposed to flow into the next game. So I think she kind of made you her I can't remember. She was a chancellor because she won and then you were
citizen.
Citizen. Yeah. So then you kind of made a coalition going into the the next game and then me and the other player were outcasts.
So then it was kind of um it it was a bit funny. So you're supposed to take it through which is I think nice in some ways.
It's one of those games though where right at the end you can spend a long time thinking about that final move that you need to do again because it did come down to me just deciding who would win. one of them was going to win either way. So you sit there for a long time thinking, okay, but if I do this, that will happen or I could do this and that will happen. You're really trying to
grasp a way that you could possibly do something for yourself and then it's just not there. So it can be quite slow as well in that regard. There was that famous game that we played where a player fell asleep and then ended up winning.
Yeah. And that's also the kind of game can be.
Yeah.
So I think you're right. It was it was wasn't as bad as when we first started playing it and that's probably just experience with board games. We found it with other ones. We played like kind of like a mediumweight Euro uh Clans of Calonia and we found that really easy compared to when we first playing. We thought it was this like really crunchy uh meaty Euro back. Yeah,
but it was really good to go back and unfortunately almost as soon as we finished like kind of or finished our two games and got back into it, one of the players has like moved to different country.
This is what happens sometimes when we try and play our like we get a group together with a favorite game and then people move away. That's what happens when you live abroad
cuz I think I would be much more interested than I was like a few years ago in playing O some more. But we'll see. But he is also coming back actually next month. So maybe maybe we'll play it. Who knows? Um but yeah, so that's Oath and we'll go to number eight. In at number eight, we have Barrage and that has a rating of 4.11 in complexity. And we have played this game 13 times, which I'm a bit shookiff about to be honest. Well, I think
it would be more
important to note that these are since we have started the channel and we definitely played it a fair few times more before
the channel records. Exactly. Yeah.
Yeah.
So, cuz I think we had a we had a real good time with this game with a core group of players who really enjoyed it and we definitely got a number of games in
who also moved away.
Yeah. And then I think since then we've really struggled well because it's a very complex game. We've not really shown it to many people except for one and yeah we just haven't really got it except for us two and it's better to play with more people. So it's one of these things but it was we still got some games in here and there with all the expansions coming out. Yeah.
So why don't you say a little bit about
Yeah. So this is a very heavy dry energy themed Euro. Our favorite type of of games to be honest. So it's basically about making hydro electric uh
power in the Alps. So you all take on kind of different companies which have some like small asymmetric powers, but you're basically fighting over limited space on the mountains and trying to get build build dams to capture the water, put conduits in so that you can generate electricity and basically create energy. But yeah, it is just complex because it is because it's very very tight basically. Yeah, it's uh
the resource management is so tricky because basically once you've used up resources on something, they go into a wheel and there are only certain ways to turn that wheel to like get those resources back. So then you can use them again to build something else. So you really have to plan very well, but at the same time, you've got the tension that someone's going to take the space that you need.
People can also um put dams in front of your dam so they can kind of capture the water that you're planning to get. So, it's very mean.
Yeah. And it's it's quite brutal because it's, as you alluded to, it's worker placement and it's just very very tight. I mean, there's, you know, one of the main goals of the game is to produce energy and there's like one space that kind of depending on player count that gives you plus two and then you might only have no bonus and then you might have a negative.
Yeah. and and so if somebody on their first turn of the round just goes plus two space unless you have a lot of money
to kind of do that space again you're you're out of it right so it's kind of very brutal in that way as well and that plus two might be the difference between you filling a really big contract or only doing like a little piddly one you never know right
so there's a it's definitely one of our all-time favorites uh for all the reasons you mentioned we love the brutalenness there's kind of a nice variety iety of different ways you can go about it because there's also neutral dams. So, you can kind of get like a quick start by by building off of a neutral dam and kind of taking the water that holds, but then you can never really upgrade that dam. Yeah.
Or you can build your own, which is more tedious and more resourceheavy, and it might mean you kind of score less the first few rounds, but then later you're kind of set up for some big turns.
And of course, there's the brutality of the other players kind of literally blocking you off from getting anything.
Yeah. Uh, so a lot of fun and this is one that's going to be in our collection forever. I think
there's been a lot of expansions now and I think once the newest kind of wave is fulfilled, we'll probably end up doing a buyers guide.
Uh, something I'd quite like to do and cover like everything, all the expansion maps and factions and
yeah, I really like the aesthetic as well. Just like looks so yeah, big fan of that. So yeah, one of our favorite games, BR.
So in at number seven, we have Canburn Eevee. And this has a rating of 4.3. And we've played this game 13 times.
Yeah. Well, I think you should take it being your favorite game.
Okay. So this is a complex fel larda Euro. It is worker placement and it's about manufacturing electronic vehicles in the most favorite topic.
Yeah. In the most efficient way. So you can go to a number of different spaces. So you might need to get car designs. You might need to put the cars on the test track. You need to go to the warehouse to get parts. But in typical Vital Lerta style, there are a lot of cascading actions and bonuses that you can take. And one of the key kind of gimmicks about this one is that you have a mean boss called Sandra who comes and marks your work um whenever she on an ad hoc basis basically.
Whichever worker is the laziest gets punished.
Yeah. If you're the like
least trained or whatever.
Yeah. Worst at your job in the different departments, then she will come and um deduct you some points basically. So that's the gimmick is you're always trying to kind of get trained in the different areas, but you also need to complete the actions. You need to make sure that you go in the right order because certain things need to happen in the right way to be efficient. And obviously the worker placement uh element, you're going to have people blocking your space. So it's also depending on that. So yeah, it's just an efficiency puzzle
and I love it. It's my one of my favorite games of all time actually. Um, yeah, I think it's it is complex, but I think it's one of the maybe more accessible Vitala games just because there is a bit of an order in which you should do things to create the cars.
I would disagree somewhat.
Yeah,
I think you think
I think it's mostly still circular that you can do anything. I think there's like one rubber stamp move that you have to do last as I remember it. But because you can get like designs, you can get parts, you can get like there's a lot you can do not in any order.
Yeah. But the what the other player does also sort of like dictates that in a way as well. So I don't think it's completely like open sandbox of what to do. I think there is still a most efficient order which you should try to do it because again like Sandra you know she'll come and mark you in this department so it drives you to do things in a certain order I would say rather than just being completely open and seeing what happens. I think it's easier to grasp and say like on Mars or something like that personally.
Um so yeah what do you think about this game?
Yeah I mean I prefer on Mars uh but it's still a very good game. It's yeah, like I said, I think I'm not sure where it rank in in my Valers, but definitely a very good game. I'm more indifferent to it. The number of plays we have is definitely down to your love of it, but I'll always play it basically. I don't have anything like too much against it. Don't have anything too much for it. There are heavy Euros I'd rather play, but yeah, I just I don't have like so much to say about Campban really.
I love the little wooden components. The cards are super cute. Like putting around the test track again, I always I feel like I keep saying this for every game, but the aesthetics in this one really please me. So, they just like again looks great on the table and the components are very nice and tactile as well as you would expect from a game like this, I think. But yeah, there's something about this which just like clean and soothing to me.
That that makes a lot of sense, I think. But I mean there is some great elements like the the Sandra element of of kind of punishing the the last player in certain areas is I think that's really fun and a really great gimmick. And there's kind of an optional variant where you can play with friendly Sandre and we just can't fathom why you'd want to do that cuz it's our favorite part.
It's too nice for us. I think that if it was just like that I don't think it would be one of my favorite games actually. It is that part of it which makes it more unique than other kind of similar games that are like this is is mean Sandra.
So yeah, I am a big fan of this game and if you're into this sort of thing and haven't given it a go, then I would personally fully recommend it. At number seven, we have Pax Familiar second edition. And this has a rating of 3.85. And we've played this game 14 times.
So, we've actually got it out twice within the last week after probably a hiatus of two years or something.
Must be longer.
So, it's definitely jumped up a few spaces, but it it's very similar to John Company, which we talked about, the same designer, same publisher, historical setting, but in this case, um it's set during the Great Game in Afghanistan. You play Afghani people trying to play the great powers off of each other to kind of carve out your own land power and at its core it's a tableau builder as you kind of fill your court with cards that let you take actions and there's also a big element of area control in the middle. So the gimmick you could say is that there's three different factions and you can be any one of them and you can change faction at any time. the drop of a hat. And you might do this for a number of reasons, but essentially you're trying to make your faction dominant and then they kind of win in scoring, but then multiple people might be members of your faction.
So then you're trying to have more influence than they do. Or if you're kind of uh all tied or no one's dominant, you could end up just uh scoring based on how many discs you've got out essentially, which you do through various ways and buying cards and stuff. So, there's a lot going on, a lot of interactivity. Uh, yeah. So, what do you think? Getting it back out.
Yeah. I was amazed how quickly the games went. Actually,
it went really quickly for this type of game.
Yeah, we played it in what, under an hour per game, I think, something like that. Maybe just a little bit more, but it was pretty quick.
Um, so we managed to get two games in, which was super nice. But again, not sure if it's just because we've played so many games now, a bit more experience. But yeah, we managed to get into it again super easy after such a long
Yeah, I think I think this is a big one where we really struggled at the beginning when we first got it just because there's so much going on and so many like options in the sandbox when you play. Whereas now, we played it uh sorry, I taught it to someone new and we had like two relatively competitive games right off the bat. like everyone knew what they were doing, you know, some some pointers to our friend who was new to it, but it really surprised me.
Exactly. Yeah. This is the famous example for me about how uh we always, you know, are proponents of giving games a chance because it was the sixth game and I remember that very specifically where this clicked for me and up until then I was like, "Yeah, it's okay, but I don't really get it. It's not grasping me." It just seemed flat, I guess, of just, you know, putting cards out. you do some actions, but I don't know, something just clicked on that sixth game and I realized how to manipulate the game a little bit more and how sneaky you could be and how you could pull a lot of moves and
thinking about the options that could be and then trying to make them happen rather than just kind of going through the motions. So yeah, it was uh an interesting example and kind of how like why we always give games more chance than maybe other people would
because yeah, you just need to go through and explore it. Especially this one, it has like a huge deck of cards all based on historical figures.
Yeah.
And you just need to get through them a little bit so that you understand the options available. So, yeah. And I really enjoyed getting it back out again, and I'm really keen to keep getting it back out and not leave it such a long time. Yeah. Now,
always uh also a big fan of the aesthetic. It's really beautiful. The pieces are so nice. It just looks great on the table. The map is cloth as well, so it just adds that more authentic style. So, I think was always bit of a showstopper out on the table as well.
Yeah.
Yeah. big fan.
Yeah, I mean it was really great to get it out. It's one of my all-time favorite games and it had been a while and yeah, just had two great games of it and I think this Yeah, like you said, this is why I'm proponent of always giving games a chance. I mean, sometimes you can tell that they're just not good games. But I think there are certain games where uh particularly coldly games where you need to know if you're buying that game that you've got to play it
x amount of times. You've got to give it that five plays to make sure everyone's familiar with it. You understand it. You're not
tripping over simple rules that change the game.
So, I think that's very important. It's a great example of of kind of what you can get out if you put the time in.
So, that is Pexamir second edition. So, in at number five, we have Eclipse: Second Dawn for the Galaxy. That has a rating of 3.65. And we have played this game 15 times.
Yeah. So, again, box is down in the basement at the moment. Very big and heavy. More of a occasion game.
But this is one of my favorites and maybe my favorite space game. Although, actually, I think that's a lie. It's probably voidful, but very close.
Uh, so this is kind of massive box euro where you are kind of doing very generic 4x space stuff, but there's a lot of really cool parts um in in this game. Mainly through the fact that you build out your civilization through kind of texts which are randomly drawn out of bags. So kind of variable each game what's available
and a lot of these are going to let you kind of manipulate your ships. So your ships are very kind of buildable in almost uh a Lego style way to be honest. You can take things off and put things on. Uh so you can kind of build your ships to be really bulky and defensive or to be really nimble and have huge cannons basically uh and everything in between. So there's there's quite a lot of fun in in how you can make yourself within the game asymmetric, but you also play as kind of an alien faction who have their own asymmetry on top of that. So it's not like crazy asymmetry, but but it's enough to make it interesting each time you play. Uh and and I just really like the kind of yeah the system is kind of a very tight in some ways like action economy system because you have to pay for the number of actions you take which is dependent on how much money you produce. So there's always like this scramble and trying to find ways to do a little bit more.
Yeah. Exactly. Very tight as you would expect a kind of like euroesque game to be. You're always scrambling for one more resource.
Yeah. And yeah, I think that's why I also really like this game. So, I'm not usually so much of a fan of games where it's heavy combat or like combat focused, let's say.
Um, because it annoys me where games you like spend the whole game building up your army just to have someone come and like destroy it and then you have to like work very hard to build it up again. I think with Eclipse it is hard to build it up because you have limited actions because you always have to kind of pay. But I feel like everyone's kind of in the same situation. And because it's yeah, more like Euro element, it's satisfies that part that you still want to like optimize, I think, rather than just being outright kind of territory control. And I think because like you say, you can control what your ships are like and how much defense they have, like upgrade the guns and all of this. It is a lot in your control as to how the combat's going to go.
And also you have um or in um
is it in all of the games? I think it's all non um player enemies. So, I also personally quite like that that you can have a conflict with a nonplayer enemy to gain points or explore or do whatever and gain territory, but it doesn't necessarily have to be like with someone across the table
in a way. So, I think control that a little bit more
at a lower player count as well that you you both start with them on the board and you kind of randomly find them. And I think that's a nice speed block to make it from just being all out. Everyone's attacking each other all the time and it makes it more focused on your economy, which I think helps the game.
Yeah, exactly. And the different factions kind of have a little different gimmick, right? Like there's the I can't remember what it's called, but there's one where you you should build outwards and become your own little plant. Are they plants?
Yeah, I think so.
Um and like be away from everyone else. So, or some be a little bit more confrontational. So, yeah, it's also quite fun to kind of
play the different factions because it can be a quite different game, let's say, depending on what faction uh you have. But, yeah, also a big fan. And it's quite nice uh that you can play that at lower player counts as well. Um we've played it.
That's a big part. That's why it's got so many plays.
Yeah, it's, you know, still super fun to do that. So yeah, it doesn't feel so much like you you lose like too much with lower player counts. So
yeah. No, I think this has so many plays on the strength of the fact that you can play it two players and also just it's one of my favorites. Uh yeah, I just like everything it does and how it comes together. A lot of fun. Eclipse Second Dawn for the Galaxy. At number four, we have ISS Vanguard. That has a rating of 3.66 and we have played 19 games of this.
Yeah. So, this is a bit of a weird one in that we actually don't have the game anymore. So, Isis Vanguard is a campaign game from uh Awaken Realms and we provided it as a review copy and in this sense it's a campaign game which is why we kind of have so many plays. We played it a lot to do the campaign.
Uh and I think in the end I ended up playing it a lot solo.
Um
and that's because we we kind of said this cuz we reviewed it. In that review, there was a lot to like about the story. I think the story was very well done, but the core of the gameplay was basically rolling a set of dice.
Yeah.
And kind of like symbol matching.
And there wasn't any evolution of that throughout the campaign. And it also had like a kind of weird, which I think is a very awakened realm thing of being quite difficult.
Yeah. like it was almost like nemesis level difficulty. Uh so it was quite easy to to to lose and get beaten. Uh and especially when you're kind of at the mercy of rolling random dice and trying to get specific symbols.
It it came across as like too harsh
for the story it was putting across, if that makes sense. So I think we got a bit disillusioned with it. Um and we ended up giving it to a friend basically. So, we haven't played it in in years and yeah, we got the solution just because it never evolves itself.
All I can think about is the music that we would play.
I can still imagine it now. It's like haunts my dreams.
Yeah, cuz there's an app that you can use and it has like voice acting and stuff and it had but it had background tune.
It was quite good. But yeah, I can just imagine it now. Yeah, I think this type of game is just not my favorite type of game. um kind of narrative cooperative like story driven games. But that said, we did have, you know, some fun with it. I think the like you said, the story was quite well done. I thought the app was really cool, actually.
Um but yeah, I think it just got a bit repetitive person. Maybe it's a bit harsh.
No, I think that's true though. I think it it almost Yeah. You just can't do the same thing every mission, every like the core of what you're doing was just rolling a bunch of dice and hoping it matched.
I think particularly for me there between the actual game you do the what was it called like the upkeep phase.
That my favorite part.
Yeah. Okay. So I did absolutely nothing. So I would just be like sat on my phone and it was like that part was like quite boring to me.
Yeah. Um, so then I think you would do all of that upkeep and it would could take like 20 minutes or whatever and I'd just be sat there and you like, "Okay, all right, we're going again." I'd be like, "Just like hours and hours." Didn't we play once for like eight hours or something? Insane. Yeah. And then I just Yeah. I think for me, we overplayed it sometimes in terms of like session lengths,
especially because Yeah. you were driving all of the upkeep part and I had nothing to do. So I was just like, I don't know. Yeah. Just got a bit boring for me.
Yeah. But it is good and like the produ again like the production was I thought like very very good like
yeah so I think there's a lot to like about it but in the end it just yeah it wasn't something wanted to play for as long as it went on because of the gameplay essentially and nothing else.
Yeah. See you is Vanguard.
In at number three, we have the brass series. So, brass Birmingham and brass Lancasher put together.
Yeah.
The average complexity rating across the two is 3.85. And we have played these games 21 times.
Yeah. So, one of our channel's all-time favorites, one of the first couple of, you know, like top top 10 heavier games on top 10 BG that we played, uh, and we instantly took to it. And I I honestly think that out of all the games in this list, Brass is a bit of a misnomer for me because I find the rule set really intuitive
and I almost don't see the complexity there. I would personally rate it a lot lower. I think we just it's one of those games that we're able to go back to without getting the rules out. Even it's been a year, three years. It's I think just very intuitive to me.
Yeah.
Uh but in terms of what brass is, it's kind of a business management game
some ways where you're an industrialist um in the 19th century and you're maybe even 18.
I think it's 18th cuz it's 17. Yeah. 18th.
17th. 18th.
No, 18th. 19th. And you are Yeah. So you're building factories, you're producing goods, you're shipping them around,
boxes,
uh, cotton, all these things, and you're basically filling out a map with little tiles. They kind of either produce kind of components or you can flip them to make money and get victory points. And at the end of the game, whoever has the most victory points wins. Um, but you have to connect everything together to transport stuff and sell stuff. And you can kind of interact with other players in that way cuz they can block you off or they could even in Brass Birmingham use your resources.
Yeah.
So, a lot of fun.
Yeah. And uh the like little trick there is that you have a hand of cards basically
which either relate to cities in the area which means that you can go ahead and just build anything you like if you have the city card but some cards are more to do with the industry and then if you use those cards you have to like have an existing connection. So there's also a bit of like added
planning let's say
um about how to do the best with the cards that you pull up. But no, yeah, I totally agree. This is a game I think the game where the most don't know how to describe it, but go back to it and I just instantly remember it.
I think the rules are just so ingrained in my mind now. Maybe it's because we have 21 plays by now.
But yeah, I just absolutely love this game. I don't think I would ever turn down uh Game of Brass Birmingham.
No,
it's an alltime channel core core recommendation gameplay. It's just so clean and so smooth and so polished. It's just an absolutely absolute delight to play.
Yeah. I mean, there's kind of limited goods that you can like go after, let's say. So, manufacturing or cotton or whatever, but I think there are so many different ways that you can go about it. In one game, you can really focus on trying to do like the cotton mills in another game. You could try and go after those high value pottery factories and sell that. Uh the links also like in the first it's split into two eras. So you have a canal era and then kind of all of your links are wiped off the board and you have a railway era. You could also try and just go after like a lot of links. So there's really a lot of different options and obviously it's very dependent on the cards that you get into your hand
as to where you can build. But the satisfaction is getting the most out of those cards and being able to try and like go after different things. Let's say
I think a great strength is the two halves where yeah,
you could have a poor first half, but you generally do get a lot more points in the second half. So sometimes it's it's kind of almost better to do worse because
kind of the first level of buildings are all wiped off the map.
So if you don't do that well necessarily, you could end with a clean slate in the second half. whereas if you've done better, you might be tied to certain places and it makes it more difficult,
you know, when you start basically.
Um, so there's some interesting elements like that.
But I just think, yeah, it is, like I said, so so smooth, so fun to play.
Um, just something very fulfilling about playing it essentially.
Yeah. Maybe I just want to say quickly about like brass laner as well. Um, so this is for me it is a little bit harder, right? Does it have a is that more the more complex one?
I It's a weird one because I think I can't remember now. I think technically it has less going on in some ways.
Yeah, but I think that's what makes it a bit more tight. So they have shipping yards and brass ship, but it's very very limited where you can do that. They're very high value, but there's maybe like
three spaces, something like this. I'm like weirdly good at lancasher and the majority of times there's something about it that really suits you.
But I think it is a bit more stressful and a bit more tight because each there's less going on basically but then that makes it more more tight where you have a lot more options in Brass Birmingham. I think
both really good games. I think we talked about this in our buyers guide and some of the comments with uh the viewers, but I think everyone has a different preference and it's usually down to like what you play first.
100%. I've seen 99% of the time whatever you played first is the one you prefer.
Yeah. And that's definitely the case for us. We came to Birmingham first. I really like Lancasher like good. But just this like has my heart let's say because it I guess introduced us to the to the game. Um
yeah.
In at number two we have the Great Western Trail series. So this is all three games. This has combined complexity rating of 3.85 and we have played all of the games together 25 times which again I'm a bit surprised. I feel like that's more as well. I feel like when it starts getting into these numbers that is a lot of time but we have played it a lot.
Yeah. Again there's definitely a couple of plays at least that were uh pre
pre-record
pre- channel for the first the original game you see here. So, and in order, uh, the most we've played is the first game and then Argentina and then New Zealand.
Yeah.
Um, and I think we've said before in our buyers guide, our favorite is Argentina.
Yeah.
And then then is quite close with the others. And when we say favorite, I mean it's a very loose term because we love them all so much. We literally did just play Argentina at the weekend, which has boosted that up
uh by a play. Uh so this is a series where you're essentially managing cows or sheep and you're kind of delivering them to uh a train or a marketplace or a ship or something.
They're going on holiday.
Going on hold to go on holiday and you kind of go around this loop on the board. So you kind of go like bottom to top and then you will kind of loop back around and go again and again. Every time you go around, you're kind of pushing the game further or closer to the end. And it comes down to hand management because you have a deck full of cows or sheep and they have different values and you kind of want unique values and high values when you get to the end to kind of trade them in for money. Um, but on the way there's all kinds of action spaces that lets you get money or upgrade your player board or what you can do or get different cows or you know uh and I think for us it's the pinnacle of games that are enjoyable to play every single moment especially or not especially but even when you're not winning but especially in the context of this game I think yeah
I think it's a game that some games you play and you feel really I don't know exhausted and annoyed at the end that you haven't won. Whereas this is just like
yeah I I wish I'd won but I enjoy
be the one to talk about this point because you win the majority of games. This is like a feeling that I have to endure 96% of the time.
Yeah.
But yeah. No, exactly. Um it's just so enjoyable to play. There's something about going around in the loop. You're almost kind of playing against yourself. I think that's what makes it so enjoyable because you do keep going around in the loop and you always want to optimize your hand and what you're building and doing the objectives that
you're by the time you go around back in the loop
you want to beat what you did the last round. So I think that's what makes it enjoyable to me in a way is
yeah you're not in like moment to moment you're not in so much like competition with anyone. It's just at the end when you count the points, of course, you can see, but just that satisfaction of always going around and improving what you're doing. I think it's also great because you can go a lot of different ways with these games as well. I mean,
one of the core parts is the kind of deck management and hand management of your cows because like you say, you want to get unique cows and unique values by the time you end the loop. But you could actually have a game where you don't like lean so much into the cow part because you could just go after buildings or doing a lot of objectives. There's a lot of different ways to score points.
Yeah.
So I think that makes it very enjoyable kind of game to game as well. Um you can kind of in the beginning think you know what this game I am going to try and go after cows. It might not happen because of what comes out in the market or kind of other people could take the cows but you yeah you can kind of set a little bit of a strategy from the beginning and then try and
execute it basically. But yeah, big big fan of all of these games. Didn't I rate Argentina as my number one game of all time?
I think so. Yeah.
Yeah, I think I did.
Yeah.
So, I I think yeah, there's a great decision space in that when you move around the board, you don't have to stop at every space. Although you are limited somewhat in how much you can move, but you kind of are deciding, do I want to go to this space? cuz there's kind of something to get at every space, but time is also limited because people getting to the end make the game kind of get close to the end. So then you don't want to be the one who's only been round once when everyone's been round twice.
So there's a lot of spicy decisions in where to stop. And then you have these different routes such as kind of
um moving your train along the track or increasing your deck or building buildings. These are all ways to get big points. Uh, and and you kind of can lean into them all a little bit or you can lean into one really hard and neglect the others. And I think there's a lot of interesting decisions there moment to moment as well because you do want to do everything, but money is always tight, so you're very limited.
Yeah. And stopping at the spaces on some of them. It allows you to basically like cycle through your hand so that you can try and get that unique spread, let's say, by the end. So sometimes you're like, "Okay, don't necessarily want to stop there, but I also want to try and get rid of this card out of my hand because I have a duplicate on the hope that I'll pull something else." But then you could also get a bit of money from doing that. And just yeah, deciding
whether you want to stop or not um at each space is also like an interesting decision like at every turn basically. And then can be quite snappy as well the turns for the most part.
So the game usually go on a couple of hours to a few hours if you've got more people. Yeah, it's definitely like a three-hour game with four players.
Yeah, but it doesn't feel ever like a slog because the turns can really be like, okay, move my person, put a card down, get some money, done, and then move along. So, it also keeps it like nice and snappy as well.
Exactly. I think last thing to say on the complexity is I think this one uh it's a bit like Ras Birmingham where it's definitely heavy but there's something about it that I feel like it's only heavy because there is so much going on.
Yeah. um and it's overwhelming rather than it's complicated because the turns are very quick and very simple and it's not you know like say John company where the turns are also very simple there the implications are staggering here the implications are a little bit less I think it's just that there is so much that you could think about but one thing I really like is this looping structure because it means that once you've gone around in one loop as like a new player you have seen everything pretty much in the game. You've seen all the spaces, you've seen all the actions, and things will come up, but you're kind of ready to go almost properly.
Yeah.
And I think that's something that that is really great about this game.
Yeah. Side note, really want to play Maraco as well.
I'd also love to play Maraco, which is very similar in terms of the moving around in a circle.
So, that was Craos and Trail. Okay, so in at number one we have Roots. This has a complexity rating of 3.81 and we have played this game 42 times. So quite a jump from number two.
Yeah. And I mean so Routt famously is the uh kind of woodland game of war. So you have some cute meeples and critters who are having a very brutal war in the woodlands. Uh and I mean I think core of the reason of so many plays besides it being one of our favorite games is the fact that each faction is completely asymmetric.
Yeah.
So they're more or less playing their own little game in a shared space. So there is a lot of uniqueness in terms of different plays with different factions and you often do need to play as all the factions to to understand how to stop those factions cuz a big part of the game isn't just pursuing your own own goals. It's knowing how to stop other people and how to block them off from getting points in the way they get points.
Yeah. Exactly. So you really got to play to understand like for me I need to play as the faction. Yeah,
myself to understand the future if I'm playing against them how to stop it. Otherwise, it's just a bit distant from you. But yeah, we love this game. We like to play it with two players. We have like some uh the clockwork uh expansion to kind of fill the board out a little bit, but we also
found some people uh to play with, which is super nice because I think yeah, we were struggling to find a group for this for a long time. We tried to introduce it to people when we first got it. Didn't really Yeah.
click with any of our friends. But yeah, we have found some other people to play now. So, we've played a fair few games in the last like year or so, I would say.
Yeah.
But yeah, not really much else to say apart from Great Game. I think it's like really fun to like play as all the different
uh factions as well. And there is so much content that we have for this. So, I think there are some factions that I still haven't played despite us playing 42 times.
I've only played like once or something.
Yeah, exactly. So, there's still more to explore even after all of those plays, which I think is pretty impressive.
Yeah. Well, there's new factions coming as well.
I think with this game, it can be a little bit um say stressful. That's a little bit the wrong word, but I think this is a little bit similar to GWT for I always like have fun playing it even if it's
can be a little bit frustrating what other players are doing because
you can't really plan your turns because by the time it gets back to your turn
I mean the board state could be completely different and obviously it is a war game so people can just you know deliberately target you and all of this but I don't know it's just fun like it's just not that deep right it's just you can be like very very behind you're like okay well it was good game. It was fun. You know,
I think how I
feel because the factions are different, there is an element of fun of exploring them
and trying to to get the most out of them.
I I think one thing that I've noticed that's really great is we've definitely sat there and we've played games and we finished the game and basically the winner was decided by not quite turn order, but you know, it's that if you didn't win on your turn, I was winning on my turn. sat there and
different asymmetric factions is is quite
I think a great thing and that's part of the fun for us that we sit there afterwards and we go this is brilliant and that's why we've played it so many times
100% and again to keep harping on I'm very like onedimensional today But production is excellent.
No, but come on. The meeples.
We should have just filmed this once, then I could have just edited it in.
Yeah, just have a clip of me going great production.
Great production.
Yeah, but it is though. It's amazing to have on the board like all the pieces, the colors, like the art on the cards, just all of it is fantastic. Can't wait for Frog expansion.
Frog expansion all the way. So, that was our top 10 heaviest games. We hoped you we hope you enjoyed getting to see the heavy games we play and what we're playing, why we play them, why we like them. Uh I think we're also going to be coming and doing a video on the least complex games we've played.
So we'll do the inverse of this. Uh but we really appreciate you watching. Please comment, like, subscribe as you wish. It would really help us. And we'll see you next time. Thanks so much for watching.