Skip to main content
Loading video...

Rolling Realms Redux - Realms Tier List and Review

Transcript 21:56

welcome to allies or enemies I'm Jess and I am Shan and today we are talking about rolling Realms Redux and I really want to call it redo but apparently I am wrong and this copy was provided to us for review but the thoughts in this video are all our own and the new version of rolling Realms is a sequel to the 2021 game and in both of them they are roll and right games that are incredibly variable with each card being representative of a different game and in the original one it was all ston Meer published games whereas for this one it's all games by different Publishers which is interesting so we're going to be going through what's in the box and then for the very first time doing a tier ranking of all 12 Realms that are included and also note that this is our first video in the new studio we're back in London so we've switched back to our London SES we'll see if this sticks or not but this is our first one back in London so let us know what you think of the new it's basically the same but of the new wall behind us but let's before we get talking about the game let's check out how it's played at the start of the game each player has a pen a scorecard a resource card and a deck of possible realms then one player randomly chooses three of those realm cards and all other players

find matching ones and you're ready to go each turn one player rolls both Dice and everyone uses those same two numbers to add to their Realms each realm card Works a bit different but in general you can only use one dice in a round per turn and the goal is always to use those dice to accomplish goals that will gain you Stars maybe through exploring a map or filling rows and columns with with shapes or winning wars in Wonderland while you do all of this you will also be gaining resources pumpkins let you adjust dice Hearts let you reuse Dice and coins give you extra dice after nine turns of rolling and playing dice you add up the Stars you gained plus your leftover resources then you erase everything but your score randomly choose three new Realms and do it all again after three full rounds or nine realms you add the scores of all three rounds and a champion is named so that is how it's played and you may have noticed it's exactly the same as the original Rolling Realms but there is a bunch of stuff that's different mostly the stuff that's in the box so first of all that is the Box itself and I feel like one of the big reasons this game even exists is because it's kind of the big box for Rolling realm so this will fit all of the new new Realms all the original Realms and if you've got all of those ones that they did in between which is a whole bunch of

different games some we really like like the honey Buzz um Feast for Odin there's a bunch that we really enjoy in there but you can fit everything in this box and it comes with some nice big dividers as well so it makes it really easy to grab the different player colors there is also included a travel box so you can kind of pick some Realms or pick only like two players to put in that box I will say that it is not waterproof we learned that the hard way yeah so we had it in our backpack and it rained and so our corners of it did get a little bit worn and I do kind of wish that it was just a little bit sturdier because it is meant to be a travel box but still it's nice that it's in there they're also a new pair of big chunky dice this time they're purple which is great because I love green you love purple so we kind of we can use one of each even and both be happy with it um there's also just more pens more erasers there are are 12 brand new Realms so these weren't included in any of the expansions nor in the original one and there's a new solo mode too which I haven't played but you've played yeah and so the solo mode is interesting because so the original solo mode I didn't really get into that much but this one is like kind of a campaign mode so you can do it you can make it quite a long thing so it's based around the idea of uh football or soccer if you're in North America um division so the system how works here is you're moving up and down through divisions uh getting promoted or getting relegated and so you're playing kind of a bunch of

like league matches and then you're moving up and down based on the points you're actually rolling Dyson like autoing the other games as well to have in like the the score table for the season and basically it's just a a reason to play it and to play a whole bunch of games at it but it does get real challenging at those top ones because you get fewer fewer roles as you get into the higher leagues of the game but they're still like just as difficult to beat so it is pretty tricky and it also works with all of the Realms so it's not just the new 12 Realms they've also got um there's like little stats that you need for it for every realm that they put out so far and apparently they're going to update it with new ones too and there's a compendium so like a rule book that covers everything as well which is great cuz it's always tricky if you have multiple rule books so you have one rule book to rule them all but let's get to the actual realm so there are 12 in this box and we haven't discussed what our different rankings for them are and I don't even know if I've fully decided yet but we're going to split them into four possible tiers so the top tier is swap it in is like this is meant to be random you're meant to have three random ones each time but these are the ones that we'll kind of fudge a little bit and like make sure we play with then there's we're happy to see it we're just we're really happy if it comes out then there it's totally fine if it's there we're not going to complain about it we're not going to be

like over the moon about it but we're totally happy that it's there and then they swap it out and that's kind of the opposite of the top one that we might fudge it a little bit and be like you know what let's pretend we didn't draw that one and draw a different one so let's go through the different rooms let's do them um alphabetically maybe so let's start with adawa so what are your feelings about adawa so adawa was this is one that we have the original game and I will say that for all of the Realms I do feel a better connection when we have the original game and so I do like adawa I like that it's bats I like that it's easy to get three stars but then after that it's feels really challenging to get more than three yeah we kind of mathed out what are the minimum number of dice you need for each of these and add of what you need the most if our math correct and it very well might not be but we figured that you probably need 10 dice you could use the coins and whatever for it so it is one of the hardest ones to get stuff but it's also thematic and it it captures the game I think pretty well so for me this one's in the totally fine it's good to be in there I'm not like over the moon but I'm like it's it's nice that it's there yeah I had it there as well next up is dog park so how do you feel about dog park it is pretty simple so you're just just kind of you know you're just adding a number you're getting a re a resource you're trying to avoid the ball spaces of the dogs getting distracted and get to the end quickly

you can do this one in six dice if you get the exact right dice you got to use high dice for it you can do it in six dice so it's quite easy but it's not challenging so for me this is also a totally fine it's kind of in the middle of totally fine and happy but I think it's it's it's totally fine yeah I was debating between the two but I landed on totally fine as well next up we have got flamecraft and so flamecraft another one that we've got the game for and this one I think does a pretty good job of kind of capturing the feel of flamecraft what did you feel about this one yeah so because you have the two options of enchanting or gathering like you do in the game I really like this one and I like the bonuses that you get when you add a number because they're not just getting a resource and I feel like there's not a lot of Realms that give you like a specific other type of bonus so this is one that I have in the I'm happy to see is that the second highest category yeah yeah yeah yeah that's two out of four yeah I I I totally agree I like that this one has kind of Combos and that feels nice and I like that it wants you to be a little bit patient because it wants you to fill up the TP it's really easy to quickly put in the numbers and then you don't get any resources so it wants you to kind of put in those resources slowly and then do the things and then really get a satisfying combo but it's hard to be patient in this game so I appreciate that about this one too so totally agree in the happy one the next up is the Guild of merchant explorers yet another one we have the original game and I

really like the original game and I think this did such a great job of feeling like the original game what do you think oh 100% yeah cuz you are you're going around the map we love going around Maps we love Crossing things off on maps this totally captures it you've got all these different routes that you can take you can kind of Sidetrack to get bonuses you can go straight for the stars I really like this one this is definitely a switch it in for me so this is the top category this was a switch it in I love just the actions you're doing and how much it ties into the game next up is legacy of you and so we don't have this one we haven't played this game at all so I have almost no I really don't have any connection to it but what you're doing in this is you just have to write a higher number in the next thing and you can write two numbers and combo them together or just one number so you can do this one in eight dice we figure but it's very simple the thing that you're doing you're just writing a number you just make sure it's higher yeah so this is one that it isn't that interesting I do like getting the resources and it is sometimes nice when you have one of the three that is actually a little bit simpler because it's like oh okay I don't have to spend too much time thinking about this but because of that Simplicity as well I do have it in the lowest category and yet I don't know if I necessarily would always swap it out yeah I I definitely so far we're very very agreeable on this but I might swap it out kind of depending on what else has

come out if this is with two hard ones I'm probably would keep it next up is Meadow and this is one that we also have the original game and I really like the original game and it does a really good job of capturing that because you have to write one of the dice numbers on like one of the arrows and then you go that far in and you get to cross off one of those symbols yeah it's got Meadow's got this terrific drafting mechanism where you're where you're putting your little number arrows and then you go that far on the card Tableau that you drafted from this captures that really well and also captures the thing in Meadow where you're building your cards on top of other cards so you start with like grounder bugs and then you have things that eat the bugs and you have things that eat the things that eat the bugs and so on and this really does do like a decent job of all with what how simple rolling Realms is is so this one for me is a swap it in I really like this yeah this is a swap it in for me as well and part of what also makes it swap it in is everything you said but this is also a good one to use with lower numbers and there's not a lot of Realms that actually work well with lower numbers so I do like having one that like oo ones and twos are a good thing to be included next up is planet unknown and this is probably my favorite of the games of all of the games that are represented so that definitely goes into it for me but also this is is one where you're drawing shapes into a grid and that was in the earlier Realms in tapestry which was one of my favorite ones but so hard to complete this one also is pretty hard to complete not quite as hard as tapestry

but I I really like it it's got a little bit more flexibility because you're writing the numbers to decide the shapes that they are this is one of my favorites not just of this but of all of the Rolling Realms this might be my favorite rolling Realms realm that there is so this is Def definitely a swap it in for me yeah this is a swap it in I love the polyomino puzzle and like you say just the flexibility cuz we might be assigning shapes to totally different numbers and so that's just interesting because you don't get so much flexibility with these Realms and it captures the original one so I agree this is a swap it in next up is poker and this is a bit different from the rest of them that are like modern board games yeah cuz this isn't like an actually P well I'm sure it was published it was invented it was actually invented by Johnny poker in 1642 no he is making that up I'm sure it was invented by somebody but what you're doing is you have to write a number either on the Flop or you write both pairs of dice in your hand or you get to score combining the Flop and your hand and I think I think one of the tricky things with this is I don't play poker so I had a actually a slightly difficult time understanding even just how to score because I didn't know what the concept of the Flop even was I I originally really didn't love this one this would have been in the fourth category but we played it just recently again and I don't know it grew on me a little bit because there is kind of an interesting which ones are you putting in the Flop and then what is kind of the odds of what's best to combine with

possibly different hands and the math of it got like a little bit more fun for me so this is actually in the third category of it's fine if it's in there for me this is still in the fourth one I think I just haven't even really figured it out so I haven't got a lot of stars with it maybe I need to play it a little bit more but this is one I would be fine to swap out this is our first disagreement thank you Johnny poker next up is another one that is in the public domain and that is rock paper scissors and this one I really do find interesting this is kind of a brain burning puzzle and I think this is going to be an all or nothing for folks some people are really not going to like it for some people it's going to be one of their absolute favorites so in this you're always using both numbers and the numbers represent either rock paper or scissors and you have to write one in the first slot one in the second slot and then later you're writing other ones in the ver in the different slots and what you're trying to do is make it so everything in the left beats everything in the right and if it does that you're going to get a whole bunch of stars and you get a bunch of resources from it too I do like that you get a lot of resources and it is an interesting puzzle It's tricky because you have to win all nine to get all six so you have to do it just right and I think just because it's not a modern board game I don't feel the connection as much so for me this is in the totally fine to see it

category I've always kind of liked rock paper scissors so maybe that helps but this isn't quite in that top category this is I will be actively happy to see it but I may not switch it in next up is spaceship and this is one neither of us know anything about and that might make a big difference because what you're doing is you are pulling down two numbers from the previous column and you're adding a third number and then once your column's full you're again pulling down two numbers and you keep doing that so it is really simple because you're just trying to get those numbers to add between 11 and 13 so there's not a lot of thinking to it it's like do I have the number that gives me that great I'll use it I'll get a star so I find it one of the most simple ones out of all of them yeah and unlike legac it's very similar to Legacy of you but it also doesn't give you any resources so you either get resources or stars and it feels a bit like why would I get resources so yeah you're just putting in a number each time and then it kind of slides down this is definitely a switch it out for me yeah this is a switch it out if I had two really really difficult ones might be fine to keep but I prefer most of the other ones next up is tidal blades we have this game we like this game and and I like this too it's got really silly art it's got ridiculous art it looks like it kind of it's like Bazooka Joe cartoon kind of like it's in a bubble gum wrapper and I'm saying that in the nicest like I enjoy that I'm glad it looks like that and you can do this

one in Fairly few dice you're getting stuff most times you're putting things down it really is you just are crossing off the number but because I'm like killing monsters getting trophies moving up a track I like all of that stuff I like how it looks I like that it's tied to Tidal blades so I do like this one a lot yeah I do like this one too I think you can get it in not like the most amount of dice but only if you get exactly the right number so if the dice aren't rolling your way it could be really challenging but I do like how much it ties to the original game I do like that it's not you're never getting Stars you're only getting trophies and then those trophies correspond to how many Stars you get which is interesting and it is fun just conceptually to be like Oh I'm like slowly stabbing away this monster until I eventually kill it so I like this one a lot this one is a I'm happy to see it yeah I agree with that this is a happy to see it as well and you can do it in eight dice specifically lastly is wonderlands war and this is a bit of a gamble because you can add a number to any of the battle circles then on certain turns it's going to score but you're only going to get a star if your SU is higher than what's rolled so it's really tricky if you're adding numbers to like turn nine and you're like I really want that coin so I'm going to put a number there but I just hope I can win it and I hope that rolls low at the end yeah I definitely find myself kind of painting myself into a corner a little bit not having very good odds because I'll use

extra numbers I don't use other places and just be like well you know what I'll think of another number in in round nine later on because each one has two numbers that you're adding and then those have to add up to higher than the two dice in that in that round so I just think well you know what maybe we'll roll we've been rolling low we'll roll a one and two there and then we never do but I I like that a lot because then when you get to round nine you're invested just in what you roll which I like so I I really I really do like this one and I like the original game as well it's a terrific game so I like that too that it combines that and I think it does a good job of capturing how it feels so this is in the happy to see a categ guard for me yes I agree I was about to say it does link to how it feels because it's like should I even send troops in should I maybe just let it go and maybe I just won't get lucky with what I pull out in the bag for the original or in this case with what I roll it's in I happy to see it for me too so that brings us to our final thoughts and that's our first time trying a tier list so let us know how you felt about that but let's talk about the whole package and how we feel about that so I think really if you like rolling Realms you're going to like this this is more rolling Realms it but it's it's exactly it's exactly the same game how it kind of functionally works it's just that the Realms are going to be different it's got that big box to put your stuff in yeah I just like having a whole mix of Realms and it's really nice when you have a connection to the board game that it's based on and so I was

always like happy to see some of my favorite games being represented in in these different Realms and it's a whole mix as you saw we had mixed feel about it but what we're going to do from now on is I think just mix it in with the rest of the Rolling Realms we have and then being able to have just even more of a mix because you're only ever playing with nine yeah and I think if you're choosing between this and the original I think the original on average I probably like them more but this one I think the highs are higher the lows are a little bit lower but that might be different for different people as well and I think one of the positives is this is from a whole bunch of Publishers we love the original because it's nice it's a ston Meer game it's nice that it kind of celebrates ston Meer games but it's also nice that this celebrates kind of the whole Community but again if you weren't into rolling Realms it's not really going to win you over this is just more rolling Realms yeah and I think they're just like maybe a smidge harder on average than the original one as well so maybe that might influence if you don't have any as to which one you might get is whether you really want that connection to ston Meer maybe that slightly easier entry level or whether you want that mix of board games and a little bit more complexity but rolling Realms in general is a game that we like we we enjoy Rolland rights we think this is one of the better Rolland rights so we are fans of it we were fans of having more and that is it that is rolling Realms Redux or redo if you prefer to

say it that way and that is how we feel about the realm so please let us know have you played it how do you rank all of the different Realms in it and which ones of the other Realms that you can buy individually would you suggest we get next yeah we've already bought too many but if you make some good suggestions we probably will get those as well so thank you so much for watching as usual please like subscribe and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game

Progress saved