Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Board Games That Lived Up To The Hype (Vol.2) - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 25:43

hey everybody today i'm talking about my top 10 board games that lived up to the hype so all of these games have reached some level of popularity or buzz um they might be very highly rated or considered classics or it could even be something a bit more personal where people have consistently recommended these games to me because they know my personal tastes and all of these games have been games that i've been late to the party on you know these games i've played once they've already reached a certain peak or certain level of buzz and naturally that makes the game it makes it more difficult for the game to live up to those expectations but in all of these examples they've still exceeded or at least lived up to those expectations because they aren't that good so let's get started with some honorable mentions so i have three honorable mentions i want to quickly talk through the first of which is smartphone inc i really like economic games and this one was one that i always heard a lot of good things about saying that it was so streamlined and clean but it still offered that rich economic feel and i think this one definitely did achieve that i love the um the action system in this game where you are you have these two basically pieces of card you are overlapping things to show which actions you want to take from that turn maybe it's going to be producing phones maybe it's going to be increasing your prices or lowering your prices or investing in new technology but i just love how cleanly this game is broken down into these different phases there's a good level of interaction to get the best technologies and to sell to customers who want particular technologies to get more money but you can alternatively undercut people and

try to sell to those before the other people jump in there with the higher prices so a really cool decision and interaction throughout this game and i think it definitely did what it was set out to do so i thought this was a very good game very good game that is smartphone inc the second honorable mention is the search for planet x so before playing central planet x i heard obviously this game very highly touted amongst them fans of deduction games saying this was a brilliant deduction game but to be honest i was almost set in my ways and kind of sat in my comfort level playing games like awkward guess which i thought was pretty much the pinnacle of deduction games and i still think that is the case but i do think that the search for planet x offers a different style of deduction and it manages to pull it off very well this logical puzzle of working out where all these different planets are or different astral bodies are and it uses this great time track system where you keep taking actions until you catch up with the other players um and i've never seen that used in a deduction game before and this one manages to merge those different ideas beautifully um very brain burnery but it's a lot of fun and it's a very satisfying juicy deduction puzzle so that is the search for planet x this one is excellent and the final honorable mention i want to talk about is spirit island now this is a strange one because this game isn't exactly my personal tastes but despite that i think the game design itself is phenomenal um so this one you are cooperatively working together as these spirits and all these spirits have unique powers they have strengths and weaknesses um but you can kind of cover

each other and fill in those gaps by synergizing your powers with one another um and it uses this very cool system where some powers are resolved quickly and some are resolved slowly and in between those powers that is when all these kind of colonists are going to react and do their thing but there's this constant struggle of pushing people around the map and fighting them off you know just killing them outright i'm trying to scare them and things but i just love how different everything is i love how these powers synergize with each other i can very meticulously map things out but that is kind of the double-edged sword because i think it's a bit too brain burnery for me um and i tried to map things out a bit too carefully rather than just going with my gut and um that can really draw the game to a halt but if you do like that style of gameplay um it doesn't really get much better than spirit island and i know a lot of people consider this the best game of all time and you know what i can't even really argue with that again it's not really my tastes but i still think it is a truly excellent design that is spirit island but let's get into the actual top 10 list so at number 10 i have cascadia so this one is actually one of the most recent games on this list this is pretty much brand new but this one has really shot up through the kind of board game geek rankings um it's got a lot of hype a lot of people enjoying this one and that's quite strange for a medium lightweight style game you know pretty accessible as you're trying to build up this grid of these hex tiles with all these different terrain types on you're trying to create the biggest kind of surface area of certain types to

get more points but whenever you take these tiles you're drafting them and they all come in pair with one of these animal tokens and you're basically trying to not only create this grid or this big big map of these hexes but also place these tokens on them to get additional points based on how these animals score so for example these elks cards or elk tokens might score by having elk in a straight row or maybe the birds want to have line of sight with each other so you're trying to make this most efficient puzzle as you can by laying things out and i'm just scoring as many points as you can but i just love how streamlined this game is i love how simple and accessible it is it looks nice it plays pretty quickly and there's next to no convolution in this game whatsoever just draft your tile and token place it on your map and try to do the best you can and i think this game does really strike that great balance of being accessible but still having enough going on to be interesting looking pretty and um those kind of games tend to do well and generally when that happens i i kind of think you know i can see why this is popular but it's not quite for me maybe it's a bit too light but this one it just satisfies me enough to keep it getting to the table and it's been a nice strong member of my collection since i've owned this one um i can really see myself introducing this to a lot of different people and i really struggle to see anybody not enjoying this one because i think it is that nice so that is cascadia my number 10.

my number nine is another recent one and this one almost has a parallel to cascadia where it's that medium lightweight style game but one that's become quite popular pretty quickly this is furnace so furnace um probably last year or throughout last year and into this year it's got a nice level of buzz going towards it it seems to be getting more and more popular and it's another one of those games which offers good decisions but it's still a pretty simple rule set and this game has almost brought back a almost a renaissance of this bidding mechanisms which which you don't really see too much in more recent designs and it happens to be one of my favorite mechanisms in board gaming full stop but this one it kind of brings that bidding mechanism to a whole new space that i haven't seen before where each game you are allocated a bunch of these desks i think is one to four then you are allocating them out on these different cards that are available to all the players the p the person who bids the highest on those um on those cards is going to claim the card for their engine which is going to act as a almost a converter to convert cubes into other cubes and things um but also anybody who's bid less than you on those cards takes another um kind of uh thing that's on those cards like resources and things equal to the amount of or the bid that they put on it so for example if i bid four on it or this card i would win the card if somebody bit three on it they would gain three times the resource on that card so i love that dual conflict thing where you want to get a lot of resources from these cards but you might not want to bid too much because you might not want to win the card itself so i thought that's a really

cool mechanism that has a load of room to be explored further just again very intuitive but just clever um and after that you are kind of running this engine of cars you know converting resources into other resources getting points and things and but i love this variant in the game where you have to play things in a fixed order so when you're running the machine it has to go that way every single time and things are locked in place it just adds a bit more tension to the game and makes your decisions that much more meaningful but yeah considering i have so many different bidding games i thought this one might struggle and be lost amongst the pack but i actually think it manages to hold its own very well and that's on top of all the hybrid had and i think it's a very nice game that um is rightly so um being so popular so that is fairness at number nine at number eight we're going with something a lot more classic this is going back to the 90s with tigress and euphrates so tiger street euphrates is considered one of dr reiner kenicia's best games um i was always kind of apprehensive to try this one because i thought it was going to be a bit too confrontational for me i thought it was a bit too in your face um but when i played this one i've really enjoyed it and you know every subsequent play i played this one i've enjoyed it that much more i think this one has layers it has depth and it's a very interesting design that hasn't really been um replicated apart from its um kind of sister game yellow and yanxi um but this one is a tile placement game as you are placing these different types different colors on the board um but you are trying to collect four different types of points all represented by the

different colors corresponding to these tiles um but only your lowest pool of points out of all those four at the end of the game is going to be your final score so you need to very carefully balance all of them and you can't neglect one of those colors but this game is again it's pretty confrontational as you can end up kind of connecting your cities with other cities and having a big blowout and kind of dedicating towers to win these fights and things but i think because this game isn't mean for the sake of it and you are actually trying to do well and get more of these cubes when you are fighting with other other players it manages to hold its own and it feels again it feels edgy it feels vicious but it still feels like you're doing these things for a reason and it has this underlying strategy and euro feel to it which is quite unique and i think this is a lovely design i think it's very clever i do have to be in the right mood to play it but when i am in the room to play it i always enjoy this one and i think it definitely deserves the hype and i can see why it has held its own for so so long um you know this one's been talked about and in the kind of board games like guys for 25 years which not many games do at all so credence to tigers and euphrates for doing that and an excellent game at number seven i have seven wonders jewel so this is pretty much widely considered one of the best two player games of all time it's a drafting style game as you're trying to build up the civilization civilization of cards um you're getting resources by building buildings some buildings are prerequisites for other buildings increasing your military by going up and

down this track i was apprehensive to try this game because i was lukewarm on the original seven wonders i thought it was a good game you know more traditional drafting style game but i wasn't blown over by it um but because this one was so highly revered and considered so great amongst so many fans of two-player games i wanted to at least try this one and i'm so so glad i did because i think this game is truly excellent i love the draft in this game as you have this pyramid of cards where cards are overlapping each other but when you draft the ones from the edges they are revealing ones underneath it which adds so much stress to your turns because you might really want a card but once you've finished drafting your card you might have revealed something better for your opponent to have so you almost have this this angst and agony of do i take it am i allowed to give or should i give my opponent that card and um those kind of games really shine for me i think this game is um smooth it's fast it offers so much so much strategy and different paths to go down and things to worry about in such a short time frame and i can i can't really disagree with this one being considered one of the best two-player games of all time um i think it's great i really do think it's great and um i was kind of going in expecting it to be overblown being um just just being a another another hyped or over-hyped game that isn't going to be right for me but boy i was wrong this game is as excellent as people say that is seven wonders duel at number six i have bora bora by stefan feld so a lot of stefan feld fans really do consider this game one of his best

um and i think a lot of the hype from this game came from the fact that this game is so hard to get because it's very limited there's not many copies out there it's not been reprinted in a long long time so it's rare and normally when games become rare they kind of get this aura around them where they're better than they usually are but i don't think that is the case with bora bora i think the game is excellent in its own right i'm so happy i've got this one in my collection this year because i really do feel like this is stefan fell doing what he does best it really it has all the best facets of his desires you know being a point salad style game being restrictive through the use of dice as in this one you are you are allocating dice to take actions but the higher dice are generally good because you get more stronger actions but the lower ones are great because every single time someone goes to an action that someone else has been to they have to lower the pit value so if you place a six somewhere someone has to at least place a five there and then a four and then three and so on so the low ones are great because they give you the flexibility to do what you want to do but this game does have that kind of mini game feel that a lot of my favorite stuff and fail games have you got some very simple kind of area majority you've got some simple set collection and you've got a little bit of engine building as you can utilize these kind of native villagers to give you a little boost actions and it's just a great package again all of stefan felt's greatest hits in a nice succinct time frame and i think this is fantastic and kind of a top tier felt game for me and um i think it definitely deserves the praise that steffenfeld fans put up on this one it is excellent that is bora bora at number

six at number five i have brass birmingham by martin wallace so this is widely considered to be one of the best if not the best economic style board game of all time and it's almost considered a lifestyle game to a lot of people where this is the only game people will play because it has that much to offer that much depth and that much nuance now while i don't disagree with that um i would i know i was concerned that this would require me to play it again and again and again and normally that kind of game doesn't suit me because i like variety i like to play lots of different things but i'm i'm very pleasantly surprised to see that this is a game that you can quite happily dip in and out of it's not terribly complex but it is it's different and i love the way that the resources work in this game because you normally have to build up this infrastructure of buildings and canals and trains and things in your network um but i like the way you can utilize your resources and utilize other people's resources as well you know when you build things or when you shift things around you can you can you can use resources that other people have placed but bearing in mind that when you do that you might flip their buildings over and start generating them a points engine and i also love games that offer supply and demand and this game does that very well through this colon iron resource where you can connect things up and end up kind of refilling the um the stores of coal backup and getting points for money for doing so and money in this game is very tight um i just think this game is very well done it's a game i do have to be in the right mood to play um because you are kind of getting into this new level of interaction and it is quite sophisticated gameplay

you for exploring it more and if you are playing with the same people again and again you're going to you're going to really raise each other's game and start to understand things about this game that weren't quite first apparent so i think this game is a a wonderful design it certainly deserves to play the praise that's received over the years and um you know it is considered one of the best board games of all time and it's another example where i can't really dispute that so yeah brass birmingham wonderful and certainly lived up to the hype at number four i have underwater cities this game really did blow up a few years ago a lot of people really loving this one this engine builder where you have um a bunch of cars being built in front of you which let you kind of improve on previous actions or do things that other people can't do or the kind of incentive of making yourself more efficient and gaining more and more points um i was slightly concerned about this one because i thought it was going to be bloated i thought it was going to be convoluted and just looking at the pictures and things it wasn't really my style of aesthetic i tend to like the more kind of beige euro style look this one is a bit more up-to-date and a bit more futuristic which is normally a bit of a deterrent for me but when i got this one to the table there was a lot of things i loved about it number one i love this idea of work placement but workplaces paired with the card so you basically have three different colors of actions you can take you're placing your worker down getting the corresponding action but you also if you play a matching colored card with it you also get the bonus from that card as well and these cars do loads different things it could just be instant resources and

things it could be again building an engine and stuff making yourself more efficient making yourself faster and better um but the way this game develops you really do kind of just increase your power and how much you can do with each turn drastically you know the game changes so much from start to finish and the level of satisfaction you get from this is almost unparalleled as you really do feel you achieve a lot so yeah i was concerned about all those things i thought it was going to be a bit too sprawling a bit too much going on but my concerns were completely um you know relieved once i played it this one i think it's brilliant i think it's one of the best engine building games of all time and um i think it's great yeah this one is very highly ranked on board game geek a lot of people speak highly of it it has some competition with some other games like terraforming mars and um i think this game is is sublime brilliant game and um certainly deserves the deserve it of the hype that is under water cities at number three i have another game that's considered a classic this is terra mystica so terra mystica is a pretty involved engine building style games you're trying to put these buildings down on this map and terraform the land as you go as you put more buildings down you are increasing an engine by getting points and getting money and things or getting these priests which let you climb tracks and things so lots of kind of synergies going on in this game um this game is another one of those ones that almost has a built-in fan base where people play this game again and again and probably play it to a very high level which was another factor that

intimidated me about this one i thought if i'm going to play this game with people who played it before they're just going to absolutely wipe the wipe the floor of me i'd have no chance of winning but if you play this game with people at the same level with you then i don't see why anybody can't enjoy this game it's actually not too complex at all i thought it was going to be again fiddly i thought it was going to have lots of rules of exception rules exceptions and little things that you need to remember and i was again pleasantly surprised to find out that wasn't the case it's actually pretty simple now there are a few little things that are you know do take it to that kind of heavyweight euro bracket but i still think it is fairly intuitive how it works as you're basically just trying to put these buildings down on the map trying to unlock income as you do so try to exploit your unique races power um because all these different powers you or races you play with each game have their own strengths and weaknesses um climb tracks and things you know a lot of things you'd expect from euros but this does have a slightly different feel to it the map does get quite tight as you go on and you need to very carefully plan things because once you upgrade buildings the actual buildings you replace come back onto your player board which can actually come to bite you in the ass if you don't map that out quite carefully carefully but i do think the game is very well designed i can i know it's what i can see why it is considered one of the best games ever um and i think this game out of all these probably is the most love it or hate it style games you're ever going to love the crunchiness of it or the all hate the kind of dryness and the almost

um you know almost a transparent transparency of things because you can very carefully plan things out to a t and that can almost introduce a level of analysis paralysis if you do have that slower type of player but i don't see that as a fault for the game i think the gameplay is so strong um i think it's a brilliant euro and it deserves it's almost classic and legendary status amongst board gaming so that is terra mystica at number three at number two i have arc nova so i can't really recall a game reaching a level of popularity or hysteria or buzz quite like arcanova has at least in modern memory so this one is a pretty involved euro as you're trying to build up a zoo from scratch really you're building up building the enclosures you're getting the animals in um you are trying to kind of connect create partnerships with all the different continents to get animals in at a better rate um you're trying to get money of course to make new investments and things this game has so much going on and it has a brilliant system as you are use using these action cards and but the longer you neglect using these action cards again the stronger version you get of them and once you use them they're going to go back to the bottom of the queue and be ready to charge it up again i love that system very clean very elegant um but i love the variety of this game this game has so many things you can do maybe you want to go for african animals this time maybe you want to go for primates maybe you want to go for reptiles and they all work in different ways and synergize with each other and

it's just brilliantly different things you'll find and discover with every single game of arc nova now i mentioned earlier this game does have a lot going on there's a dude there is a lot you need to manage a lot you need to juggle but i do love the way it is embedded down into that core system of using that card and i'm just doing what it says on the card and charging up again i think that's brilliantly done and it stops you from keep spamming the same action time and time again and makes you think outside the box and diversify a bit but i just think this game is a joy to play um it is pretty long it is pretty involved and i think maybe that is going to send some people down the wrong track because it does look so inviting you know with these really cute brilliant brilliant animals on the cover and stuff um but i i do think if you are into your engine building style games you like your slightly heavier euros and you want a nice inviting theme or maybe you want to try even bring someone into playing more complex involved games arc nova could be the game to do that with because it's not as bad as it looks and it is surprisingly intuitive and i think the gameplay is so much fun um and this game i was just expecting it to fall flat on his face because it was so popular it is still immensely popular and i'm so happy to say this one is as good as people say it is excellent excellent excellent top tier game and probably one of the best games of last year that is arc nova a brilliant design one world worthy of all the hype believe it or not that is received that is arc nova and finally at number one i have key

flower so key flower is widely regarded as one of the best euro board games of all time i think it's one of those games that almost flies under the radar a lot you don't hear a lot of people talking about it but the people who love it really love it but the reason this is number one for me is because um personally i've had a lot of people a lot of people say to me dan you need to play this game i see the games you have in your collection i promise you you will love key flower and that for me has always given me a bit of hesitation because i think you know this game is destined to fail i have so many people saying i love it and there's no way this game can live up to those expectations but it did live up to the those expectations and it completely um superseded those expectations because this game is utterly brilliant this is a worker placement and bidding style game as you are using these actions on these tiles to get resources and things and convert them into points but you can also bid on these tiles to claim into your own personal town and build up a bit of a little bit of a network really to shift resources around things but i love this idea of not only using these workers to activate the tiles but to bid on them as well and you don't even have your own personal player of work color of worker you actually all share workers amongst you but if somebody has used a particular color on a towel that means all the other people have to use it as well so say i bid um on a specific tile with one blue worker then anybody else can has to outbid me with say two blue workers or three blue workers and they can't use their other colors and that for me i've never seen

that used before i've never seen anybody else try to replicate that or even improve upon it not like it could really be improved upon but it's quite interesting to see how this game is remained unique after all these years it's surprisingly easy to teach but it has a lot of strategy loads of paths to victory um the interaction in this game is unbelievable because you can actually use other people's tiles that they built previously but you're going to have to give them workers for doing so and that constant economy and back and forth of the resources is so engaging and i love it love it love it so yeah this game has quickly become one of my favorite games of all time i think it is that good and um this is never going anywhere i think it is utterly brilliant and i would recommend this one to anybody if you're a fan of worker placement if you're a fan of mid-weight euros or bidding this game you're just destined to love it is that good so that is key flower at number one so there we go those are the top 10 games that have lived up to the hype for me personally now i will say this is the second edition of this video that i've done i have done one previously where i talked about another 10 games so be sure to check out that video um and be sure to subscribe hit like and comment if you did enjoy the video of course i might also be really interested to know what games have lived up to the hype for you personally i think that's a really quite an interesting discussion i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye now

Progress saved