Skip to main content
Loading video...

10 Board Games That You Loved But We Thought Were S**t

Transcript 13:15

hello welcome back to the channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews play fruits unboxings which I'm really like to talk a lot of bollocks about table top gaming in general and in this video we're going to be counting down 10 games that you really liked but that we thought were complete a lot of dog [ __ ] so remember if you knew it then please consider subscribing to this channel hit the like button and we're at YouTube [ __ ] see you after this bollocks so there's no real order to this list number one isn't worth number 10 isn't the best way but if you are a CJ young acolyte then maybe you can find some kind of reason why some games are more reviled than others number 10 on this list is a reprint of a game that we still really enjoy right it's libertalia there's something or other of galequest right the original libertalia was great yeah in this game you will have a bunch of pirate crew everyone will have the same cards but everyone will be choosing a different card each round you'll be placing a card face down everyone will reveal and then you'll activate these characters in order of rank the idea is to get book and avoid getting tokens that will lose your points at the end of the game right the reprint was published by stonemar games they took all of the grittiness and all of the dirtiness out of the original game they replaced the quiet fantastic artwork in the original with some cartoon characters right and I took out all of the offensive material not that it was offensive in the first place yeah I mean how would I managed to boss this one up is beyond me yeah the

Windsor girl Crest is sterile as a unit that's had an irreversible vasectomy right I'm not saying libertalia is a [ __ ] game it's not it's just that there seems to be this movement towards removing any kind of material that is offensive to at least one person yeah and for that reason we chucked it in the dumpster it's number nine on our list of dog [ __ ] games that you loved and we [ __ ] hated is summon Awards yeah this is a beloved game I understand that right but I still remember my first game of Summoner Wars opening a box finding a shitty paper mat and finding that you're going to be using cards as units right the aesthetic of the game is complete crap it's like somebody has mixed up a lot of sick in a cement mixer and just splashed it all over the board right this game works on the principle of getting different factions yeah the master set gives you a few right but not enough you can have to go out and buy extra factions in order to explore this game and even then where each unit has its own special ability it's very difficult to remember what each bloody unit does I understand why people like this game yeah but for me it was like a boring slog I'd rather play games like Memoir 44 which at least have a little bit more of a cheery attitude right someone was recently got reprinted and I'd rather kiss somebody with the plague than play that game oh yeah so the next game on this list of our top 10 got awful Abominations is the detective going from Portal Games yet do you remember when Portal Games used to make decent games albeit with shitty

Rule books but do you remember strong old do you remember Robinson Crusoe escaped from the cursed Island right what the [ __ ] has happened to Portal Games yeah all they do now is just regurgitate stuff that was successful about 10 years ago and Chuck it on game found hoping to get two million dollars and release a pile of [ __ ] four years later anyway detective right it was a great idea in principle I was thinking why this was going to beat Sherlock Holmes consultant detective 2.0 right it was going to be a completely different game experience what we found was that the writing was absolutely awful it was like a five-year-old had been given a typewriter from 2001 and there were portions in the game where you just didn't know what the [ __ ] you were meant to do so you ended up just wading through a [ __ ] swimming pool of lead this was one of the most disappointing games for me I had really high hopes for this one but if you look at Portal Games recent track record then really it's like a case that you should really try this before you buy it right or just avoid portal games all together because for me if you add this to First martians and all the other debacles then it's really not worth the [ __ ] so ten nine so the next game on our list of complete and our cow [ __ ] games is the seventh continent funnily enough this is number seven on this list right we backed this on Kickstarter many moons ago and it was lauded as one of the greatest gaming experiences ever known to humanity in the universe right what it turned out to be was a fighting Fantasy game book laid out on a table yeah with some cards in this game you'll be laying cards on the table and uncovering a story it's great for the first hour or so and then the story just dissipates Into Thin Air right if you

add to this you have to discard items and different things in order to take actions it might be the case that you will be forced into a position where you'll be discarding items that you need later on you'll be thinking well [ __ ] now why did I discard that bleed next and when I need it now I'd just rather play a Final Fantasy game book then get involved in this year because it had a safe game system that allowed you to put the cast back in the box but then setting it all up again was a real massive pain in the ass CR7 continent it prom missed shitloads and it delivered [ __ ] all for me so just go and get a choose your own invention instead of spending 80 quid on this pile of crap so the next game honest list of games that you absolutely love and we absolutely hate it is Spirit Island and I know that loads you out there especially you [ __ ] at the bank really do like this game I'll tell you why in this game you'll be playing the role of spirits on an island you'll be fighting off these nasty little colonists that have taken root on your beloved Homeland and each of these Spirits has a load of asymmetrical abilities right it's a Cooperative game that sort of flips things on its head in Catan obviously you are colonizing the island but in this you're trying to get rid of the imperialists right the problem with this game is trying to teach the [ __ ] thing where everybody has got more from the not complex Spirit to work with if you're playing with say four or five players you're gonna have to teach each one of these Spirits individually right and if somebody doesn't understand site then really you are [ __ ] another problem with this is that you can get halfway through the game and know that you are never ever going to win right so

you just end up playing out the last hour or so for no point at all you might as well just say well I don't think we can win have a vote and then just throw the game into an open fire so yeah Spirit Island was another massive disappointment for us we got the uh the larger expansion hoping that that would fix some of the problems and it didn't it just exacerbated it so yeah we might be on the wrong side of history with this one but [ __ ] so the next game on our list doctor games is PAX Premiere second edition [ __ ] you now what a [ __ ] nightmare this one was yeah I could feel a migraine starting in the back of my head and gradually working its way up to behind my eyes right impacts Premiere you'll be playing some shitty cards you'll be putting these horrible looking blocks onto a fabric mat hoping to get victory points right sounds easy enough but the main beef I got with this game is that towards the end of the game victory points for doing stuff is doubled so you could do [ __ ] all for the first portion again wait until the last part of the game mop up a few victory points which haven't been any more difficult to attain and win the [ __ ] game how stupid is that [ __ ] eight packs Premiere I hate it because you get these people saying well you played the game wrong oh you've got to play it multiple times or maybe these complicated games aren't for you no I don't think so we knew what we were doing and it's another one in games that sort of ranks high on these top 10 top 100 lists and when you play it just leaves you feeling like you shouldn't have got up in the morning see a nice try packs from a second Edition but you might as well flush yourself down the toilet right so the next game was it number one two

three well number four on our list of games that we absolutely hated but you absolutely love is root so we got drawn into this game right cutesy little Fame of all these little woodland animals running around sort of Drew us in a little bit Yeah but we had the same problem that we had with Spirit island is the asymmetrical abilities right trying to teach each faction to a different player it's not on Impossible in our group you might love it yeah you might love punching yourself in the face but I would recommend doing that over playing root if you add to that some balancing issues a lot of games where you've got these sort of asymmetrical abilities tend to subconsciously favor one faction over the other and there were loads and loads of occasions on this game where you just sat there thinking well I can't do [ __ ] all well somebody else is out there spraying their jizz all over the map I couldn't even imagine playing this game with all those sodden expansions yeah can you imagine that it's like enough of a hot mess as it is and ordinarily I can understand why people like certain games like this one you might as well drop an anvil on your head because that is much more fun than this so you next game on our list of our top 10 completely not a dog [ __ ] games is the pursuit of happiness well I bet this on Kickstarter a long time ago when it first was released and I thought it's gonna be like The Sims video game translating into a board game right how wrong was I this turned out to be a bean count in an exercise where you just Chuck cubes out onto a board and going different things that have no thematic link to what you're doing so you might end up getting a new cooker and chucking a few cubes on it right for no reason at

all you might just end up moving into a bigger house because you do right one thing that's going to get right is that you move through life so you born obviously something at the back probably haven't even been born yet you go through puberty and then you end up getting old and you die right which is about what life is like you are born you do some meaningless [ __ ] stuff and then you die right so happiness was just an exercise in futility for me really really wanted to like this game and it just turned out to be completely empty a bit like your miserable existence so don't believe the hype yet it's not like The Sims if anyone tells you the pursuit of happiness is the Sims translated into a ball game they are lying out of their [ __ ] ass this is more like that horrible Will Smith movie where he ends up sleeping in a public toilet because that's where I put this one so the next game on this list of completely like dog [ __ ] games is dominant feces Freudian slip dominant species ordinarily we should like this game right let's work a placement you put your workers out on a board take the action right do something on the main board and that's all good and well I like that pausing again I like the way that it changes things up that you're not just uh raiding natives in the Caribbean right that you are taking control of insects or some kind of dinosaur type thing right the problem I got with dominant species I've got to stop saying feces is that you constantly have to check for dominance right and this can change at any time during the game you've got these horrible little cone things that represent dominance and then you've got these tokens that represent other stuff and you end up going around the hexes going right one two three four so I'm dominant there and

then you go around to the next one and say well he's dominant over there she's dominant over there hang on a minute I forgot to count that one so I have to do that on constantly checking the [ __ ] dominance in this game it's like a sex pest constantly checking for herpes [ __ ] a dominant species it's probably one of the worst games I've ever played right I tried this much times and every single time I just couldn't finish the game I had to stop halfway through because I was gasping for air I felt like I was sinking through the Earth's crust into the magma and just getting burnt from my toes upwards that's not to say that I haven't been tempted to venture back into this dark dank cave right I've been tempted to get this game again because things change don't know people's opinions change over time but I haven't mustered up the courage yet to filter through all of the fecal matter that makes up dominant species and maybe I never will the final game on this list of God awful games that you really like and I [ __ ] hate it's a game that I know all of you lot like everybody loves this game and I'm gonna stand outside the circle on this one because I [ __ ] hate it it's wingspan there's a couple of reasons why I don't like wingspan right one is it's [ __ ] boring yeah the theme doesn't speak to me at all I don't give a [ __ ] about bird yeah two it's basically top trumps with birds right you've got a bunch of statistics on a card and you'll be trying to collect these cards to give you points in a tableau right that's it it's top trumps birds mate the third thing is that they sold you a 50 Quid game with a load of useless bling you don't need that [ __ ] bird Tower yeah you don't need it just roll the dice on a table you don't need those fancy little [ __ ] Mini Eggs don't eat them

and you don't need these big old boards that are going to take up a huge amount of table space they could have sold this going to you for 15 [ __ ] quid in a pack of [ __ ] cards that's what I could have done but they didn't they wanted to rip you off and make you spend money on [ __ ] you didn't need and that really [ __ ] me off so when you've got a market employee that tries to manipulate the consumer and you've got a depthless and Toothless game underneath it putting two together and whilst I said these games aren't ranked I'm going to make an exception for wingspan in fact I'm going to make a I hate wingspan Facebook group and I'll probably be the only one in it so if you like wingspan that's fine go off and play Little Bird game yeah I'll stick with top trumps for Birds it's cheaper so you go that's art That's Not Top 10 is it but it's 10 games that you really liked but we really hated and we don't care about your opinion because we are always right here and you are always wrong if you don't like that [ __ ] off and have a wank in the bath see you next time

thank you

Progress saved