Skip to main content
Loading video...

12 Board Games on a $500 Budget to Start Your Collection - Lost In The Shuffle

Transcript 18:51

Hey, are you looking to start a board game collection? Well, Paula's got a list of recommendations for you. And it's not going to leave you lost in the shuffle. Chaz. Yes, I'm You gave me a challenge, didn't you? I did indeed. It was, "Hey, here's $500. Why don't you build a beginning board game collection?" Exactly. And to be clear, I gave you 500 pretend dollars. Pretend dollars. No real money exchanged hand. So, you went out with the objective of with this pretend $500 budget, what games would I buy if I was starting a brand new board game collection today? Yeah. Cuz this can be a tricky thing, right? You've just gotten into the hobby and you want to start your collection. Do you just go and buy the first 10 games on Board Game Geek? No. Don't do that. Just don't do that. It's not a great place to start.

You buy the list that I've put together. Well, that simplifies things tremendously. No, this was actually kind of a challenge for me for real, Chaz, because I would want to tailor this recommendation list to every individual person because I think a lot of this depends on what you like. It all depends. So, I have no list. Bye, everybody. It's true. It is different for everybody. With that said, let's dive right into your beginner board game bundle on a budget to see what you came up with as a good starter pack for a new board gamer. So, the way I approached this is I thought of categories or genres of games that I think should be in everyone's collection and then from there you can really find which categories are you're really enjoying and then you expand on those. You should have a well-rounded collection, especially when you're just starting. A well-rounded collection. That's what you went for. That's a good way of putting it. Yeah. Okay. Well, what'd you come up with first? Well, the first thing I came up with was I thought everyone needs a big group game, a party game or something that can handle a large group because sometimes you're going to have people over and you're going to have 12 of them. Mhm. And you want something you can all do together. Mhm. So, my recommendation for your starter collection big group game is Times Up.

Oh, okay. So, basically, you're in teams and you have a deck of cards and you're going to be going through this deck of cards three times and you're trying to get your team to guess the cards you're pulling. And that first round, you can say anything except the words on the card. Yeah. I'd be like, "Uh, 16th president born in Illinois. Uh, president during the Civil War." I'd be like, "Yes." So, eventually you keep going that first round until all the cards have gone through. Everyone has heard everything that is in this deck. Mhm. Now, we go to round two where this time you can only say one word. And I know that it's one of the clues we've already went through in the first round. So, I start thinking in my mind, okay, we already covered this Illinois. Oh, oh, oh, Abraham Lincoln was way from Illinois. said that about Abraham Lincoln before. That's part of the clue she used. So, Abraham Lincoln and you start to kind of develop a little meta at the table. And then the third round, you can't say anything. It's all shades.

But again, still same clues. Same clues. You've already gone through these clues twice now. You've built that meta. So, I might be like hat tall hat so Abraham Lincoln. It's really fun and you create inside jokes while you play it. and I think it should be in your collection. So, this runs us $19.99. Okay. So, about $20 over $500 budget. Boom. Right there. Well spent. I think Times Up is a game that every collection should have. Next game. I think you should probably have a light Euro style game in your collection. And I actually ended up picking two for this. One that I think you should have in your collection to start you off with is Ticket to Ride. Okay. I think it's a game with huge broad appeal. It's super fun. It It's really fun for people who are just getting into the hobby and for experienced gamers. So, whatever your mix of people coming over to play games with you is, they're going to enjoy Ticket to Ride. It's kind of a classic and there's so many different versions of it. So, if you really like it, you can get a bunch of different maps for it. And that's going to run you, from what I looked up, $55 of our budget.

Okay. The other light euro game is a little bit different. This is Sigrada. So in Sigrada, you are building out the stained glass windows of Lasagra Familia. And you're basically drafting dice. You're rolling dice of different colors every round. And then you have a little board you have to fill in that might have requirements like only a three can go in this spot or only a purple dice can go in this spot. You're taking turns choosing dice from the common pool to take and put into your window. So, it becomes this really tricky puzzle and it's a great little puzzle. Every time I've played Sigrada, I've come away from it going, "That is such a good little puzzle game." Yeah. Yep. It is a $39.95. I think everyone should have a roll and write in their collection. Or something and something and right. So, you might roll dice for a roll and write, or you might have a flip and write, which is actually what the game I'm going to suggest is, where you flip over a card and that tells you what to fill in on your little sheet of paper. I'm choosing cgraphers for this. This is also another big group game. You can play this if you have enough pieces of paper. You could play it with 100 people. So, you're basically in a fantasy world where you're creating a map of a land you're exploring. That's what your piece of paper is. And you have different scoring objectives based on the season. So you can like prep, you see what's coming up on what you need to prepare because it's going to score later. And you're flipping over cards that give you like Tetris style shapes of different terrain types. It might be water, village, farmland, mountain, whatever. And you

fill the shape in on your map however you want. And based on where you place the shapes is going to determine how you score for the objectives. And sometimes monsters come out and you draw the monsters on another person's paper, which is very mean. It's great. I love it. And that one is $24.95. One of the neat things I like about Cartgraphers is it uses a variety of different colored pencils, which I've seen very few Roland and writes that do that. But the one I've played the most often that has that is the draft and write records where you're managing a record company. I love Draft and Write Records. Yeah, I I like that one, too. And its synergies, but uh Cgraphers, I absolutely cannot disagree or argue with that as one of the beginner picks. I love it. Okay, next up. Everyone should have a dungeon crawler. I think that because I love dungeon crawlers. So, you should get one to try. Now, I wanted to put on this list Chaz Descent third edition. Mhm.

But it is $175. And I just cannot recommend for your beginning board game collection, you spend $175 on a game. I absolutely agree. Yeah. So, I went instead with Gloom Haven: Jaws of the Lion. Good substitute. It's one where you play like on a book. So, you're flipping over the pages and it gives you a new map with the rules set up and then you're able to go and place your people out and move through a little mini campaign and it's $49.99, which is way better than $175. Gloom Haven. Jaws of the Lion is obviously a companion piece to the original Gloom Haven, which is this nice big 20 lb box of game, huge game. I've heard multiple people though say that they prefer the slightly optimized play of Jaws of the Lion actually over original Gloom Haven. Yeah. So, very good pick for that reason, too. Great.

Yeah. You need a tile lane game in your collection. I love putting out tiles and setting them next to each other so that they score. What a good scene partner I am. Quietly nods. Yes, tile laying games are great because of their versatility. Indeed. I'm very curious as to which one you picked because I mean tile laying games is such a broad category. You must have had a lot to choose from. There's a ton to choose from and a ton that I love because it's a category of game I really enjoy. Okay. I chose one of my favorites which is Cascadia. Ah, so in this game you are building out a habitat in the Pacific Northwest. So you have laid out different tokens which represent different kinds of animals and then different tiles which represent different kinds of habitats. And on your turn, you're going to choose a pairing of an animal token and a habitat tile and you build them out into your habitat. And so you're puzzling out the right way to place everything. So as you go, you're not filling in like a lot of tile games, you fill in. It kind of restricts as the game goes. And something I like about Cascadia is you're building out. So your options in a way almost expand as you as you play the game. And I really I enjoy it a lot.

And it is $39.99. Oh, and it won the Shield Dejar. I don't think I said that. Yeah. In 2022, it's award-winning. It's awardwinning. So it belongs in your collection. Almost like this show which is well not award-winning. Yeah. Not not award nominate. It's award cons. It's award considered perhaps or not. It's a award. Would you like to give us an award? Put it in the comments below and tell us what award you're giving us. It's award solicited is what this what this show is for your consideration. Okay. My next category might be slightly controversial cuz I don't know if everyone will agree with me that this is a necessary part of a beginning collection, but I think everyone should have a legacy game. Ooh, controversy indeed. I dig me legacy games. Love them. Even I have to admit, yeah, I don't know if they're a necessity, but they're definitely worth hearing about and considering. They're going to hook you. Okay, so a legacy game means the game's going to have like a campaign that you're moving through. There's usually a set number of scenarios built into the game that you'll play through.

And often the rules will change as you play cuz you might be putting stickers on the board. You might be tearing up cards. You might be finding something hidden underneath the insert in your game box. They're very cool experiences. And the one I think you should start with is one of the most popular games, Pandemic Legacy Season 1. Oh, it's going to teach you how to play regular pandemic. Yeah. And then it's going to expand on that experience and take you through a whole year of trying to save the world from an outbreak of a disease. It's a great game. The twists and turns in it are so good. I will recommend though when you play it, try and play it on a regular basis. Oh yeah, definitely. And don't let a year go by between um plays because you will forget. There's kind of this meta that builds over the course of the game as the rules are introduced and customized for your specific edition of the game.

Yeah. And it's cool because you're when you're done, your board for Pandemic Legacy is not going to look like anyone else's board. You mentioned specifically Pandemic Legacy season 1 because they made several different copies. Season two, there's a season zero. Yeah. Yeah. And I I agree with you. I think season 1 is the strongest of them. get season one and it will run you $69.99. You need a game with a good solo mode because sometimes you're just going to be by yourself. And I have found real joy in playing board games by myself. And also I think everyone should have a good hidden movement game. Are you combining those two into one selection? Combining them into one selection. I am intrigued. Wild. How can you have hidden movement solo? Yeah. What? What? I can't think of what game accomplishes that single player. Sniper Elite, the board game. Oh, it's so good. It's based on a video game. Uhhuh. And it has such a good multiplayer version, and that really makes use of the hidden movement mechanism. It's so fun, intense, and sneaky. And also, it solo mode translates what you're doing in the multiplayer version to a solo experience so well. Now, you aren't getting the hidden movement experience in the solo mode because who you hiding from? Yeah, right. Who you hiding from? Stop hiding from yourself. That one's not on. Oh, but so it's a great way to combine two of these categories into one. It's great

hidden movement and it holds up so well in it solo mode. Highly recommend Sniper Elite, the board game. Get it. It's going to cost you $68. Just like you need a game that's good for playing by yourself, you need a game that's good for playing with just one other person. Got to have good two-player games. And I have two here I've chosen because each of you can be playing one at the the same time. Play them just both. So, the first one is Lost Cities. Okay. Okay. This is going to run you 1995 and it is a two-player only experience where you are drawing cards and laying cards down into different areas on the board. You have lanes like five different columns of cards and each one represents like a different lost city that you're trying to find some different ancient world that you are going on an archaeological dig to discover an expedition you've embarked on in that location. It's kind of funny because as soon as you play a card down to one of those areas, you go into debt.

You lose 20 points as soon as you play a card down to that area. Got to pay for that expedition cuz yeah, you've gone in, you've invested, and you hope you're going to find something good to make it worth it. And the way to do that is the more cards that you can play in that one lane, the more points you're going to get. And you hope that you can get more than the 20 you invested. The cards are numbered two to 10 with a little handshake card. So it's not like you're reading a bunch of text and rules and have to, oh, this is this expedition and this does that. It's just, no, I'm playing a four. Okay, now I can't play a three there because I have to play higher than that. Yeah, you have to play higher than what you've already played down and you have a shared deck with your opponent. So, if they know you need that for, they'll keep it from their hand. They're not going to put it where you can get it. And it's just got that delicious thing of like holding out, holding out. I just I know I have the white seven and I know if I just wait, I'll get the white six and I'll be able to play it. And then finally, you're like, "Fine, I'll just play the white seven." And then you draw a card and it's the white six. Never fails. Every time. It's delicious. Yes. The other two-player game I highly recommend is Tari. Oh, yes. This one's so good. It's so unique. So, this is a worker placement game for just two people. And you have a little grid of cards and they have like a border and you have your workers, your taras I think they're called, and you place them on borders and you have three that you place out and wherever they intersect column and row-wise, that is the card in the middle you're going to get to take. It's either a good or resource or it's a tribe card.

And the tribe cards you're going to collect to build out in a little tableau for scoring. And it's just great. You can block each other from getting what you need. It's so unique the way you place your workers and the way you get your goods. And it just like ooh ooh. And it's 1995. It's one of my all-time favorites. I have one more actual game and then a little something cheeky to add. Oh, now I'm curious. I'm baffled. I'm baffled and curious and a little scared. So, the last game on the list, we haven't gotten a deck builder yet. Oh yeah. And even though Tari has worker placement, we haven't really gotten a really proper worker placement game yet either. Sure. And this game I think belongs in a beginning collection because I think its theme is appealing. It's not that hard to learn and it's one of my top all-time favorite games. It is Dune Imperium. And I'm specifically going to tell you to actually get the latest version, Dune Imperium Uprising. It's like an expansion, but it's a whole it's the whole game in itself. So it's like a new edition of the game. And I think it improves on the original, though the original is great if that's all you can find. It uses the theme of Dune. Well, you get water to go to the desert, which is going to get you spice, and you use the spice to bribe someone on the high council to go there. And then that's going to get you some points. And you're also using your influence points to like buy new cards for your deck. Then you might also put some troops out into the battle, and you might fight. And the fighting is going to get you scoring objectives. I just love this game. game.

I think it's a great combination of deck building and worker placement. It has like several different areas that you need to work with and influence, but they all tie together. Yes. And it's so thematic, but you don't need to know Dune to love it. I loved Dune Imperium before I ever knew anything about the actual world of the game. The game itself stands on its own and does not rely on its IP. Yeah. And I think it's a great little like deck builder worker placement game that I think people will want to try to play because of the theme and that's why I put it on the listing. Now we have roughly maybe around $30 left. Okay. Is this the cheeky part? This is the cheeky part. With the rest of this money Uhhuh. I think you should get a subscription to Board Game Arena.

Of course. If you get the yearly option, it's $3 a month. So that's actually $36. So maybe just go for a couple months if we're really only spending $500. But if you get a subscription to Board Game Arena, which you can also just play on for free, but with the subscription, you have access to everything in their catalog. 8 million games are on Board Game Arena. I have been exposed to so many games I would never have gotten to play otherwise through Board Game Arena. It is a great way to see what you like, what's out there, what other games are you going to want to add to your collection once you've gotten these and played them all. Play all of these before you buy any new ones. Kudos to you for thinking outside, literally outside the box. Outside the box to the computer screen. Here's the box. Here's your thinkings. I don't know. What do you think, Chaz? I think that that is a really good place to begin. And if you would add anything or subtract anything from the list, let us know in the comments. And especially if you actually are someone who has just recently started your own board game collection, which games did you invest in? Yeah, we would love to know and maybe even do a follow-up episode where we talk about what the community picks were. And if you're building your brand new first game nights, you can do that with the website game night picks, which I developed. And that allows you to get together with your friends and organize a game night. Everyone can suggest games that they want to play and then you can vote on the ones that you want and they'll bubble up to the top and that might even help people decide which games to go out and invest in. Yeah. In the meantime, thanks for joining us and

we'll talk to you again soon.

Progress saved