Skip to main content
Loading video...

I Can't Be the Only One Frustrated By This | 5 Gaming Pet Peeves

Transcript 22:21

Something interesting has happened with the last few games that I've played. Every single one has had at least one major element that has sparked a question I haven't been able to ignore. Now, these questions might eventually become their own dedicated video, but for now, I want to present them to you all, the audience, the community, and figure out what your thoughts are on them. I also kind of want to selfishly know if you can relate with these five different questions. If you commiserate with the frustration that I feel or the curiosity that I have or if I'm just bothered too easily or completely insane. Now, you could still relate with these problems and also answer that I am both bothered too easily and moderately or significantly insane. I've got five questions, five board game questions, five frustrations, annoyances, curiosities.

Now, like I said, every one of these questions has been sparked by a specific game, but they certainly don't relate to that game in particular. I mean, some of them were sparked by playing and receiving the newest expansion of Root. I just played Gloomhaven, the tiny little buttons and bug expansion standalone solo mode this last weekend, and another question was sparked by it. But, the reason why I think these frustrations have remained is because I have a lot of board games. And a number of these games commit the same infractions, the same flaw, have the same original sin that these games reminded me of or demonstrated once again. So, before I prattle on way too long, let's go ahead and dive into these questions. Question number one, should the rulebook for any game, but in this case in particular, Gloomhaven: Buttons and Bugs, should the rulebook always be included in full?

This is something that I ran into over the weekend where I opened this up, set it up on the table, wanted to leave my phone, computer, everything turned off, and made it to the end of the rule book and realized that there were still some rules that I didn't quite know how to incorporate into the game. And there was a link to the full digital rule book and a suggestion that I should go online to read it. But, I have a number of problems with that. Now, most people are willing to go online, but reading something digitally isn't as good. Having to print out the rules means that you have a format that doesn't actually fit in the box. It's harder to carry with you, harder to reference, harder to travel with. Oftentimes, you want to travel and play games to get away from the digital world, the distractions that that tends to introduce.

And then on top of that, you might just be in an environment, an area where you don't have access to the online world. Opening up a brand new game, a game that you think is going to be solo, on your own, an escape, only to discover that it doesn't teach you everything you need to know about the game. Now, I get all of the arguments as to why something like this tiny little box would not include the full rule book. It could be way too big to fit into the box, although there is actually enough space in here to ship it with, I believe, a fully printed complete manual. It could be that it was more cost-effective, kept the weight down, made it so that the printing cost was reduced significantly, and then the cost of the game, therefore, is also way more accessible.

There's lots of arguments. There's lots of good reasons why and bad reasons why you might not include the full rules in printed form. But, I don't think I like it. That's my gut check. That's my general opinion. That's my first instinct. I want the whole rules. I want reference cards. I want you to go above and beyond to make the game playable out of the box. And yeah, I could probably come up with my own way to incorporate things like items, but there's some pretty essential rules that you kind of need to know. Now, it could be that people were assuming that you already know how to play Gloomhaven if you're getting Buttons & Bugs, but the format is different. The rules are actually significant. The gameplay style is the same, but missing some, leaving some out when the format is so, what I would say, well adapted to this small footprint.

I think it was a big misstep. So, that's question number one. Is it ever excusable for something as essential as the rules to be left out of the printed copy of the game? The rules to be entirely digital. Can you think of a game that does that that you're okay with? Or a game that does that that you really are kind of frustrated by? Where you had to print the rules out yourself or the reference sheet are hand cut and made by creators over on BGG. I have a lot of games, actually, that have printed papers stuck in them that yeah, it enhances the gameplay experience, but the fact that I had to take the trouble to go do that definitely takes something away from the game that I bought. The next question that I have, question number two, has to do with apps in games. And this has been one of those things that's been controversial for as long as I've been creating content in the board game space. We've seen a lot of games come and go that have incorporated apps, what I would say, well, and have incorporated them poorly. Some that have succeeded and some that have failed with the digital implementation of their title.

There's some people that only play Root and Wingspan through the app. And then there's some games like Slay the Spire, which is brilliant in both formats, but definitely stands on its own in both regards. There's similarities, but they're not the same game. And then you have games like the one that I'm currently playing with Shira, like Divinus. I don't have the box me, it's at our house, but Divinus is a game where we covered the prototype, enjoyed it quite a bit. It's a dice building game, you're adding stickers to your dice, you're rolling, and the whole story, the whole journey, the whole score system, the whole narrative adventure is laid out in an app. And the app actually functions well. The gameplay experience has been good. We're probably maybe three sessions away from completing the whole base copy, and we have the expansions to get to after that.

My question isn't about whether or not board game apps or games with apps included should or should not be included. They just are. That's the reality of the gaming industry at the moment. My question is more specifically about whether or not a board game app always universally, no matter how good the app is or how great the game is, always makes the gameplay experience a little bit worse. It relates to that first conversation we just had about wanting to disconnect from your phone, wanting to escape from the digital world. Here we have it, too. Is having a phone at the table, through the nature of the game, always going to be a little bit worse than not?

In my experience, I think that might be the case. I really enjoy some games that have apps. I even include games with apps or include fan-created apps, like the Gloomhaven app, in some of my gameplay experiences. However, I do think it drops a game like a point, at least. Like, if the game was a eight out of 10, it might go down to a seven just by the nature of that distraction, that pull away from the table, from the people that you're sitting around. Are phones a cardinal sin? Is a digital thing intruding upon our physical space an unforgivable fault? Maybe. It doesn't mean I don't want to play them. It doesn't mean they're bad, even.

But, do they always make it worse? Can you think of a digital board game that is head and tails better because it's digital than other games comparably that you would rate and want to play more than another game that's fully physical on the table? I don't know right off the bat that I can. The only one that comes to mind was a prototype that will never see the light of day. The game just wasn't received and it was so reliant on the app that the community wasn't willing or interested or able to give it a chance. For some reason, I'm completely blanking on the name right now. It'll come to me as soon as I'm done filming, I'm sure. It's the game where you're playing as a like 17th or 16th century feudal servant. They had a second copy of the video game come out to great acclaim. I don't know why I'm blanking on it. Question number three is going to incorporate our good friend Root.

This is a question about size and scale. You see, I'm currently going through and reorganizing my entire Root collection. Getting everything in baggies, replaying the solo mode, trying to learn the new factions extremely well so that I can do some teaching and some playing and create more content here on the channel. But, I think Root is starting to cross that threshold or maybe already has crossed that threshold where a game is just too much. So, that's the question. At what point for you do the expansions, upgrades, deluxeifications, big box editions when does it become so much game you don't find yourself actually pulling it out to play?

Root's close. There's so many variables, so many factions to learn, cards to shuffle in, things to reorganize, stuff to keep sorted and track of. It was almost simpler when you only had, you know, the core box and maybe an expansion box or two. And with games like uh uh like Too Many Bones over here or Marvel United or Marvel Champions down below and Marvel United over here on this side, there's a really strong argument in my mind about actually reducing the size of your edition, your collection, so that you're more likely to play it more often. There's too many options. There's too much that I want to explore, too much I want to organize, too many things I want to see and do that I just kind of put it on a shelf and bury it somewhere in the back of my mind. It goes on a to-do list of things that I would love to do one day, but are kind of too unimportant or too ambitious or overwhelming or exhausting for me to deal with in the moment. And then a month passes and six and 12 and 18 and I suddenly have a 2-year-old and I still haven't gotten Marvel United off the shelf for a whole season.

So, what's that for you? I I think my gut instinct, unless it's like one of my favorite games of all time, is that every expansion I get should be able to be incorporated, shuffled and included in the original box that the game came in. I don't really want these expansive upgrades to the system. If you're going to do that, I kind of feel like you release a new game, a stand-alone. You do something like they did for uh the cattle game that goes out west. Sleep deprived, so that might be why I'm blanking on names. Uh it's not Circle the Wagons. That's a lovely small box little game.

I literally feel like I have it sitting staring Great Western Trail. Like what they did for Great Western Trail, where you have lots of variations, lots of modules, lots of experiences that you can explore in this core game system, but each one is standalone. Each one is its own unique world to dive into. Now, I own all of that series. And I don't feel encumbered by it. Because if I was going to go to my grandmother's to play a game with, you know, some friends and try to teach some cousins how to sit down at a table and lose with dignity, I'd teach them by losing with dignity. I could just bring one of the three or four editions that are out there. Whereas with something like Age of Steam, where I have three boxes that need to travel with me, I try to compress it all into one box, travel with it, and I show up without any of the cubes I need to actually run the game, and so it's more or less unplayable without some modifications and those are never, you know, finding things around your grandma's house to modify a board game so you can actually play it with people who've never played it before.

That's not the situation you want to be in. So, that's my instinct, but I would love to hear from you. When is that threshold crossed? I mean, CMON had the policy of trying to give you a life, uh you know, a a a full uh lifestyle game, a full generation worth of game in every Kickstarter they ran. Ah. It's good and fun to back and buy, but I but I I actually I do think I wish they maybe shipped just one really, really good box, like they did back in the heyday, when they were coming to prominence. I mean, everything for something like Dogs of War fit into that original package. And the expansions they did, the Kickstarter exclusives, all of those tucked neatly inside.

There's an argument to be had that's actually what brought them the fame and the acclaim and the you know, the financial success and then eventual financial seemingly failure was probably due to massive oversized boxes that are fun to back and buy, but how much of those were played? How many of those expansions were dug into compared to something like a single box self-contained magical little exploration of friendship and puzzles. Question number four is going to be have a direct uh point at the big box of Too Many Bones. And that's because that big box, that trove chest, is glorious. I think it's super cool to have it on my shelf. I had so much fun scratching my table with the bottom of it and packing it full of all of the components until it's like 50 lb and literally can't come out of that Kallax square.

But I think a new thing needs to start happening. And again, I I might make a bigger video on this or do my own little additions in this way, but I would rather see, instead of a big box for something like Root to come out, which we know they're eventually going to do cuz reselling everything or tucking it all away in a big fancy box that fits like a lead weight on a Kallax shelf is a good way for them to continue dipping into the fan base they have and they're at a threshold of boxes now where it's becoming a little bit too much. But I want to see the trend of big boxes, I want to see it die down a little bit. Too much game. Question number four is about a preference for a travel edition or a traveler's box.

Now, hear me out and I don't have this perfectly formulated, but I want something like this, right? This size, classic root box with instructions inside and a beautiful organizing tray, components, everything. Maybe made out of hard plastic, made out of something rigid, something that'll last. And I want it to break down how to pack a portion of your game into this little box so that you're able to go travel and play it. Why do I want this? I mean, it touches into the conversation I was just having about when a game becomes too big, when it becomes too much. And that's sort of what I feel this might solve.

A traveler's edition wouldn't have to be something that you always use only when you're going on the road. It could just be a really nice way to organize and structure a compact version of your game, while the expansions either live in a big box or get tucked in a corner somewhere and you pull them out when you reshuffle and reorganize, but this would be a way to encourage the game to live in a space that makes it easy to pull off the shelf and easy to get down onto the table. Instead of having everything stacked, I mean, right now, my method for organizing Root is a box with all the meeples, a box with all the boards, a box with all the maps, with rolled mats way over here on the door. The full Kallax shelf tucked front to back full of these layers of boxes, so every time I play, I literally have to go digging through all of the components, all of the characters, all of the expansions. I have to decide what we're going to play with, pull all of those out, and then resort them back together when I'm done.

If this lived had a traveler's edition, had a shelf display unit, had had something that made it compact and beautiful and instructions and a system for how to do that, I just feel like that'd be really nice. Before people come over, I could redo my traveler's box if I felt like I needed to, or I could just always keep our favorites in there and pull one adjacent one out if a player specifically asking, but that could live somewhere accessible, somewhere decent. The rest could be tucked downstairs and I think I would play it more. The same would go for Kingdom Death Monster, for Too Many Bones, for Marvel United, Marvel Champions. I I mean, there's lists of games here that I could continue going through.

I mean, even big box games like Anachrony could probably have a traveler's edition. I don't know. Maybe it's a foolish, silly, ambitious idea from someone that feels overwhelmed by the size and scale of games and it's a problem that you just kind of learn to deal with. But maybe, just maybe, there'd be a cool way for publishers or content creators or someone out there to help us deal with it. All right, and our fifth and final question is going to be inspired from our lovely Dune Imperium. I do know some modifications have been made with the expansions that have come out with additions like Uprising, but the core of this question is certainly there with the classic Dune Imperium and I believe still exists with Uprising here, just maybe not quite as innately problematic.

Are there any versions of a brilliant game which has a two-player mode that requires, necessitates, includes, in order for it to run, a three-player AI, bot, card shuffle mechanic, someone there to block the path in front of you that actually improves, enhances, makes the game more enjoyable? My instinct is that these two-player modes that require an AI sub or even these one-player games that require you to play with two AI subs, they do let you run the game. So, maybe it's a fair thing for them to do. But, I always feel like those systems just kind of suck. I just kind of don't want to deal with them.

The old relate with that is that it's kind of the agreed upon opinion that, you know, yeah, it's supposed to be a three or four-player game. If you want to play it two-player, you want to play it solo, you got to include a bot, and the bot is just going to kind of be it's going to be lame. It's it's not going to improve the gameplay experience cuz the best gameplay experience is just with more people around the table. If that's the answer, like I'm I'm okay with it, but

[sighs and gasps]

and I don't know if if it's worth a full dedicated you know, cuz like they do unlock the ability to play the game still. Like, I've had some really good two-player games of Dune. The bot just always kind of makes them a little bit worse. It's not as fun, not as interesting. And I don't know if there's interesting things that people have done out there in the world where they've designed around this problem, or if there's games out there you can think of where the two-player version's actually enhanced by the AI or the bot system they've included because it adds an interesting or unique twist to the experience. There could be some cooperative games out there that that throw kind of a interesting wrench, but cooperative games usually don't need a a blocker or a fill space bot. So, what's your thoughts? Is this just an accepted thing that they always just kind of make the game a little bit more lame, or is there a game out there that you can genuinely point to and say, "Hey, this game's best at three or four players, but the two-player mode's really, really good, really, really interesting. I encourage you to play it because they included a bot that changes the nature of the game. That they included a module that makes it unique, makes it fresh. The solo mode is you know, remarkably interesting as opposed to a puzzle where you wish you just had more friends.

Let me know. If there are out If there are some of those out there, I would love to check them out. I I probably have some of them on my shelf and I just haven't explored the solo mode or the two-player mode in them. So, there you have it. Five quick questions, five things that have been bothering me, five things that might make dedicated videos, but they haven't quite metastasized into a full conversation yet. So, for now they're going to live here in a little quick conversation. So, thank you for watching. Thank you for being here. Whatever the case though, whatever you do, remember to do the important thing, get out and play some games. Even if it's solo with a couple of bots sitting at the table, it's still better than scrolling on Tik Tok. I'm mostly telling myself this. Uh and it's YouTube shorts, not Tik Tok, but either way, games good, digital space bad.

We'll see you later. Bye.

Progress saved