10 Years Playing The Wrong Board Games
Transcript
Today we are going to do something a little different. I am going to talk about something I have been sitting with for a while now and it is kind of embarrassing to admit. I spent roughly 10 years playing the wrong board games. Like a full decade of my hobby life chasing something that was never really meant for me.
And just to be clear for everyone listening, when Eve says the wrong games, she does not mean bad games. She means games that were excellent, critically acclaimed, beautifully designed, and just completely wrong for who she actually is as a player, which honestly I think is something a lot of people in this hobby can relate to, but almost nobody talks about
exactly. I had the shelves. I had terraforming Mars. I had Wingspan. I had brass Birmingham. I had a Spirit Island big box that basically needed its own post code. And if you walked into my game room, you would have thought this person knows what they are doing. But the truth is, I was bored. Not every single time, but often enough that I started dreading setup. Often enough that I was reaching for my phone between rounds. And the games I actually remembered afterwards, the ones I replayed in my head on the drive home, the ones I wanted to talk about the next day, they were almost never the heavy euros sitting on those impressive shelves.
So, let us rewind a bit cuz I think the origin story matters here. What got you into the hobby in the first place? And how did that shape the path you ended up on?
Settlers of Katan, mid 2000s, of friends birthday party. classic gateway story, right? And I think what people do not realize about gateway games is that they do more than just introduce you to the hobby. They tell you a story about what kind of gamer you are. Katan is a resource management game. It rewards building, planning, optimizing. So, I played it, enjoyed it, and concluded that I was a builder, a strategist, an engine assembler. And that conclusion shaped the next 10 years. Every recommendation I chased, every Kickstarter I backed, every game night I proposed was filtered through that identity. I was a Eurog gamer. Full stop. But here's the thing that Eve did not clock at the time. And I think this is the crucial bit. What she had actually responded to in Katon was not the resource management at all. It was the arguing, the negotiation, the moment when someone at the table accuses someone of roadblocking and everyone laughs, then gets defensive, then laughs again. She thought that was just flavor.
It was actually the whole meal. It took me a decade to figure that out, which is genuinely humbling. And once that identity was locked in, I fell straight into what I call the BGG top 100 trap. I treated that ranked list like a curriculum. I worked through it methodically, checking off titles, accumulating plays, building this mental model of myself as someone who had tasted the hobby's finest offerings. And look, I did have good experiences along the way, but I was also playing an enormous number of games that were objectively excellent and personally wrong for me.
And the tell was always the same, right? You would finish a 4-hour game of something critically acclaimed and your first thought would be, "I'm glad I played that once." Not, "When can we play again?" Just once, like it was a museum piece, like the point was to have had the experience rather than to actually have fun.
That is exactly it. The BGG Top 100 is phenomenal at surfacing games that reward mastery, optimization, long planning horizons, the satisfaction of a complex system running exactly as intended. Those are real pleasures. They're just not the only pleasures games can offer. And they weren't the ones I was actually chasing. And it got worse because I was also buying for a group that didn't exist. I owned three cooperative dungeon crawlers at one point. I owned a 4X game whose rule book my friends literally used as a prop for a joke about me being the only person who had ever opened it.
It was funny because it was true.
It was funny because it was devastating. But seriously, this is something I think a lot of collectors do. You buy games for the group you imagine you might someday have. the patient, strategically engaged group that is enthusiastic about reading a 12-page rulebook as a communal activity. Meanwhile, the group you actually have shows up on a Saturday evening, pours a drink, wants to play something for 2 hours, and politely glazes over when you mention that the first session is basically a tutorial. And the really corrosive version of that mistake is buying games your group will come around to, which is the hobby equivalent of recommending a book to someone who doesn't read and then being surprised when they don't finish it. Some people come around, most don't. And in the meantime, you've spent years watching people half engage with something you care about, which is a very specific kind of loneliness that's hard to name. You're sitting there at the table genuinely excited about this thing and you can feel the energy draining from the room as you explain the third phase of the action selection.
That gap between your enthusiasm and their polite patience is brutal. Uh I have lived in that gap. I have set up entire game nights around a title that I was convinced would be the one that converted people. And by the halfway mark, everyone is checking the time. Not because the game is bad, because the game needs a table of people who want to be there for what it specifically offers. And that table is not the one you happen to have. Okay, so here is where things get really honest. I identified as a Eurogamer for a decade. I believed that serious board gamers played serious games. Worker placement, engine building, resource conversion, and I believed that social deduction was basically a gateway genre, something you played with non-gamers at Christmas before graduating to something more sophisticated. I believed this not because I had thought it through carefully, but because the hobbies culture, the slice of it I was consuming, seemed to operate on this loose hierarchy where social deduction was somewhere near the bottom.
Uh, yes, the unofficial hierarchy where game weight equals game worth and anyone who prefers reading people over reading spreadsheets is somehow a lesser hobbyist.
Right? And I was wrong in a way that cost me years of genuinely great experiences. Because social deduction is not a lesser genre. It is cognitively demanding in ways that are different from but absolutely not lesser than the demands of a heavy euro. Reading a person across a table. Constructing a bluff that accounts for every piece of information your opponents might have. Tracking inconsistencies in a group conversation across 40 minutes of play. that requires attention, memory, and a kind of emotional intelligence that no amount of resource optimization prepares you for.
The difference is that social deduction does not announce its complexity with a 60-page rule book. It arrives wearing casual clothes. And people mistake the ease of entry for shallowess. But it is not shallow. It is just differently deep. And honestly, the history of the genre backs this up. Mafia, the grandfather of everything in this space, was created in 1986 by Dimmitri Davidoff, a psychology student at Moscow State University. He developed it as part of his psychology research, combining academic inquiry with teaching students. The game's focus on reading people and interpreting behavior meant it was later adopted by educators as a teaching tool for nonverbal communication and body language. It was quite literally built around how people read each other.
And the genre has evolved so much since then. The early versions had a real problem with player elimination. You could get voted out in the first round and spend the next hour just watching. The Resistance in 2009 was the first big leap because it removed elimination entirely. Instead of voting people out, you vote on mission teams and a single trader can fail a mission secretly. Everyone stays in the game the whole time, which sounds like a small change and turns out to be enormous.
And then Avalon took it further with the Merlin role. A good player who knows the identities of the evil players but cannot reveal themselves without the whole team losing the game. So suddenly you have this second layer of deduction running underneath the first. You are not just trying to figure out who is lying. You are trying to figure out who knows and whether the way they are behaving is because they know or because they are pretending to know or because they are evil and trying to make it look like someone else knows. The whole thing becomes this nested puzzle wearing the clothes of a party game.
And then Blood on the Clack Tower comes along and basically proves the entire argument. Published in 2022 by the Pandemonium Institute supporting 5 to 20 players plus a dedicated storyteller running the game. every player with a unique role and unique ability. The storyteller runs the night phase and makes active decisions to balance and maximize drama. Dead players stay in the game with their voice and a final vote. And the information environment is deliberately unreliable because some players are drunk or poisoned, meaning their abilities feed them false information without their knowledge. You cannot simply trust the data, only the person. And that distinction, trusting people rather than information, is what makes the whole genre click for me.
What Blood on the Clack Tower does is take social deduction from dinner theater to grand opera. It does not feel like Werewolf with better components. It feels like a different order of thing entirely. It won best party game at tabletop gaming in 2022. It holds one of the highest ratings for any party game on BGG. And what is remarkable is how it converted people who actively disliked every other social deduction game they had played. People who had sworn off the genre entirely played Blood on the Clock Tower and called it a masterpiece. That does not happen with incremental improvements. That happens when something fundamentally redefineses what a genre can be.
And I think what really convinced me was that first game we played together because that was the moment everything clicked. I remember sitting there after it ended and realizing that the feeling I had, that buzzing, replaying every moment feeling, was the feeling I had been chasing for 10 years and almost never finding in any euro I had ever played. It absolutely was. And this connects to something important about these games. They require more than just correct rules. They require the right table culture to function. A game of blood on the clock tower with players who refuse to lie or who take accusations personally or who feel the need to immediately reveal their role is a fundamentally different and lesser experience than the same game with a table that has bought into its social contract. I have seen both versions and the difference is night and day.
Understanding what a game is actually asking you to bring in terms of attitude and engagement is as important as knowing the rules. And that is something no rule book tells you. Some games require you to bring a willingness to deceive people you care about. And if you cannot get a group to embrace that, the game simply does not work as designed. Which connects to a real practical challenge with social deduction. Almost every game in this genre has a minimum player count below which it stops working. Werewolf needs a large group. Blood on the Clock Tower is at its best, in my experience, somewhere in that 10 to 15 player range. These are not Tuesday evening with two people games. They require logistics. You need enough people in the same room in the right headsp space with enough time. And you need it regularly enough to develop the table culture that makes the game sing.
But honestly, that is not a reason to avoid the genre. It is a reason to build your social life around it deliberately. And I know that sounds strange, but the best versions of these games function as social infrastructure. They give people a reason to be in the same room. They create shared memories and running jokes. And this accumulated relational texture that is actually quite hard to generate in adult life. Steven Medway, Blood on the Clock Tower's designer, has spoken publicly about designing the game to generate the kind of shared experiences that become stories people retell. and he is not exaggerating. The most memorable evenings I have had in this hobby in the last few years have been nights that produced a story everyone still talks about months later.
And that points to another trap Eve fell into, which I think a lot of hobbyists will recognize, the prestige game problem, owning games as identity signals rather than things you actually play. Twilight Imperium is the archetype. Genuinely great game. also a game that a significant portion of its owners have played once, possibly incorrectly and never again. The identity value of owning it persists whether or not you play it, so there is no natural pressure to notice you are not playing it. The shelf keeps signaling what you want it to signal. The game keeps not being played. Years pass. And the honest question you should be asking about any game in your collection is not whether it is a good game, but whether it is a game you actually want to play again right now with the people you actually have access to in the time you actually have. And if the answer is no, the game is not wrong for someone. It is just wrong for you. I had several of those prestige titles. I treated them as proof that I was the kind of gamer who could engage with this material. Looking back, I was the kind of gamer who could acquire and shove this material, which is a different and much less interesting thing. And this feeds directly into the whole FOMO machine the hobby runs on. Kickstarter forces you to decide whether to buy a game before it is finished, before reviews exist, before any meaningful information about whether it is good has reached the public. It rewards novelty
and punishes patients. And the community discourse around what serious hobbyists are currently playing creates this sense of obligation. You have not fully engaged with the hobby until you own certain games. Or so the discourse implies.
And the games that become obligatory are often genuinely good, which makes the trap harder to see. You are not buying bad games. You are buying games that belong to a specific taste profile that may not be yours. Your collection grows not because you are finding games that match what you love, but because you are tracking what the conversation says you should love. And the result is a shelf full of games you respect and a notable shortage of games you actually want to play.
So, here's where I have landed after all of this. The right game is not the game with the best design. It is not the highest BG rating or the most impressive components or the most mechanically sophisticated systems. The right game is the one that matches what you are actually chasing when you sit down to play. For me, that turned out to be the specific pleasure of reading people, constructing and dismantling arguments, the tense silence after an accusation lands. And figuring that out required asking questions the hobby doesn't usually encourage. Not is this game good, but what did I feel during this game? Not is this designer respected, but did I want the game to go on longer than it did? And the best social deduction experiences we have had share this specific quality. When the game ends, nobody immediately wants to go home. The conversation continues. People replay decisions. Someone defends themselves again. Even though the game is over, the game doesn't end so much as it transitions into a different kind of conversation that has the same texture as the game itself. That has never happened to me after a game involving resource optimization. Not once. And I don't think it's going to start now.
But look, I think the important thing to say is that the decade was not wasted. The collecting instinct taught Eve what serious design looks like. The heavy euros taught systematic thinking about rule interactions. The prestige games taught the difference between respecting something and loving it. The wrong player counts taught what coordination costs actually are and why it matters to build games into your social life with intention. All of that was useful. None of it was wasted.
It was useful, but I wish I had asked the honest question earlier. Not what am I supposed to enjoy, but what do I actually enjoy? The hobby is large enough for both kinds of player. The person who loves a 4-hour engine building puzzle and the person who wants to spend 90 minutes accusing their friends of being a demon are both having a legitimate hobby experience. The only mistake is spending years pretending to be the first kind when you are actually the second.
So, if any of this sounds familiar to you, here's the homework. Think about the last time a board game session ended and you immediately wanted to play again. Think about what that game was actually doing. Not the mechanics, but what it made you feel, what kind of thinking it demanded, what kind of interaction it produced. That's the data point that matters. Not the BGG ranking, not what your favorite content creator is playing, not what just funded on Kickstarter. What made you want to stay at the table?
Everything else is just shelf decoration. Thanks for listening, everyone. We'll see you next time.