Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Board Games from 2023 (Revisited)

Transcript 33:45

hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today it's that time of year again and it's time to talk about my favorite games of not this year yet I'm going to do that video next and post that later this week hopefully but let's recap some of my favorite games from 2023 and this is one of the First videos I post on the channel and I featured these nine games plus one on my top 10 list these were the games that I was able to play at the time this this time last year and rank accordingly and so these were these games were among my top 10 and so it's always interesting to see after being able to play more games or play some of these games a few more times it's interesting to see where uh some of them might rise or fall in my rankings you can go ahead and check out that video if you want to see the absolute rankings that I gave those games plus others that I had ranked at the time but let's go ahead and see what I have ranked thus far after a year of playing some games released in 2023 now I've forgotten how many games I had played that were released in 2023 and all of this is according to the date that is posted on Board Game Geek for that game's release it doesn't necessarily mean that the game was released here where I live in the United States at the time of release so there are plenty more games on this list now

compared to when I did this list a year ago and once again I forgot how many games I had played but I have now played 58 games from 2023 nowhere near the hundreds that many other uh players play but you know due to time constraints and everything I am fortunate to I feel have played these games and so I'm going to go over real quick some of these games that might stand out to you in the I guess honorable mentions section from 58 down to 11 now in last place is arboria this game I I I guess I really didn't latch onto this game as a lot of people did from last year I I don't I think I would rather play Zulan or other games in that ilk when it comes to that ratchet type of worker placement and um you know movement uh anyway so I yeah unfortunately arboria is last maybe some of these games if I had given it another player two might have risen or Fallen as such and so uh I mean I think there are some games here that might surprise you and for example Disney lurana has fallen very much down the Wayside for me the reason that I have dropped off of Disney lurana is one it's very costly to upkeep with new sets coming out every 3 to 4 months or so it's very difficult on the wallet to continue to build metad deex and it it just took a lot of time to if

if I wanted to print out the cards for example to go and you know print those out play those bring those to a lurana KN it ended up taking me away too much from other games that I wanted to play the the variety of games that I wanted to play as well and I also felt that the meta was pretty stale uh probably halfway through this year or even earlier maybe like quarter 1 or two so I I really bounced off of hard out of uh Disney and and keeping with the latest releases and sets so that's unfortunate Darwin's Journey I've had a notoriously difficult time latching onto this game as well and so I while I do play it and I'm happy to play it it's not one of my favorites Horseless Carriage was one of those games on my top 10 list it after another play or two it I don't know it might be a little too complex for my tastes to really understand and enjoy a very respectable design nonetheless and I still really look forward to splotter games as they come out I had the chance to play void fall I haven't done a video or anything about it but I another game that I really respect and enjoy and and I enjoyed my play I feel like once again this game very similar to Horseless Carriage is very complex to learn uh pretty complex to play there's a lot of iconography that you have to wrap your head around I feel like there are other games designed by at least artistically designed by iul where the iconography makes more sense to me and I feel like the space genre of

board games is something that I'm not super familiar with and so I perhaps mechanically and thematically did not have much to hold on to or to help serve as a foundation for me to enjoy this game to its fullest I really like the fact that you can play this solo online for free and so that did help understand the game mechanisms and the rules a little bit easier but it is a pretty complex game and not in my wheelhouse unfortunately so looking up path of civilization and Sky Team were among those games that I had played as well that were in the top 10 I think they've Fallen because path of civilization kind of felt a little too complex when compared to Seven Wonders and I would rather Play Seven Wonders and so I I think after a couple of plays on board game arena that dropped off for me and then for Sky Team I played this consistently with with a friend of mine and I really enjoy Sky Team it's one of the best co-op games that I have played honestly but it's not something that I would look forward to playing in person and I think that kind of goes into how I approach this list what factors come into play like you know what I want to pull out some of these games and play them physically if I had any game available available to play and I think this game fits very well for me to take a quick turn onboard gameer Marina it's not something that I would seek to to own and to play often but once again a

very respectable design and something that does a two-player Co-op very well uh Force Shuffle got bounced off as well it looks like world wonders didn't make it too high tangram City an Rosenberg game that I did enjoy uh it has very limited replay ability so at another time I might get into that but uh yeah I it's still an enjoyable experience for me and yeah my bias can only go so far I suppose when it comes to Rosenberg games and then finally I might yeah I spoiled the number 10 there but uh yeah Expeditions fell off the list for me too uh and up at the top I've got distilled beer Pioneer in Point City I guess a couple of these beer games really appeal to me I would rather play beer Pioneer than distilled honestly I felt like beer Pioneer was a little bit more mechanically up my alley with the amount of Euro mechanisms that were available there Point City was one that I think I reminisced a lot on while making this list and favored those memories highly I think it's a really easy game to play and offers a lot of variability too so it's you for for one who has limited time to play especially with other people face to face this game for now I think fits into my wheelhouse a little bit better than normal but yeah so those are the honorable mention for this list and let's go ahead and talk about number 10 so number 10 is Pirates of maraio this is the sequel to maraio a game by

Alexander Fister and designed as well by Ryan Hendrickson and Ralph Baner this game is a sort of a card version based version of marra Kaio whereas Mar Kaio itself is definitely card driven this one substitutes the board with a setup randomized Board of cards and so it's a more streamlined version of mar Kaio in my opinion it has a lot of the same elements with your tblo being able to advance up a sort of Tory to uh make your situation better essentially and getting victory points and resources in that regard and instead of moving around a circular map via orala Great Western Trail you're moving along this map of cards with a ship and you can move up to three spaces there is still an element of like an asymmetric type of round experience where you can move in advance as quickly or slowly as you want and can and so it introduces an element of player interaction based off of how fast other players are going as well as fying for some of these islands and cards that you're trying to hopefully land on first if need be so I like this game very much I've I've been playing it on board game arena it is an alpha publicly and I you know I I haven't played it a lot especially I haven't played it as much as marra Kaio but I think I can already already tell that this is probably more up my alley or something that I would rather pull out first compared to a game

like marra Kaio that would take a long time for me to play and this one seems to be a quicker experience with a lot of the same mechanisms and experiences that you would enjoy in marra Kaio which I think at this time is my favorite Fister game and so this reiteration this more streamlined version of my favorite uh Fister game is definitely something that I am looking forward to playing more so that's my number 10 Pirates of mariva number nine for me is going to be way points this is a game that I played this year introduced to me by Jacob the co-host of this this show and what a fantastic time this was I think part of it sure maybe due to the fact that I play this with someone else that I enjoy playing games with but way points in and enough itself a Matthew dunon and Ro Rory mold Des design just really hit the spot I think it created an experience that was very narrative in in I guess in in a way that it was mechanical the you know in this game you are exploring this uh topographical map by Rolling some dice to determine or a die to determine how far you can move and using those action points and resources that you kind of gather along the way to make things more efficient or to go farther than you usually can and you're trying to collect different icons for different scoring purposes which can be variable from game to game so there are some different scenarios that you can play with this as well so as far as

say fliping rights or rolling rights go this game added a some very unique twists to the experiences that I've had in the past when playing flip and right games that I just really enjoyed it it was kind of a breath of fresh air and it made me really appreciate this design of course this is a lighter game it's not terribly complex it's something that I wouldn't pull out if I had that opportunistic you know experience wanting to play like a deep heavy game or heavier game with friends it would be a great game to play online or to play you know asynchronously or before and after a big game I think this this really hit the spot and I really really appreciate how uh cheap it is component wise I think you can buy it since it's a postmart game you can buy it for like five bucks and have an experience that is definitely well worth and above what you pay for I think I think there are are definitely some other games out there that might be the opposite as far as cost and the fun factor is is concerned for me this is definitely a fantastic game and I'm glad that it came up onto my my list for my top 10 from 2023 that's way points my number eight is ancient knowledge this was a game that was on my original top 10 list and it's a game that I still have enjoyed playing on board game arena in this game you are playing a card onto your Tableau this is basically a card-based tableau Builder where

depending on where you place these cards adjacent to others they may have certain abilities that activate but at the end of every turn these cards will move down and be quote lost to time unless uh unless you take off these tablets that are placed on top of these cards when you build them they will will uh be lost to time and add negative points to your score there are a lot of different cards and abilities that not only deal with what is happening on your Tableau but even after the cards are lost off of the Tableau and you also have cards that the smaller ones that give you some ongoing and immediate abilities as well so a very fun card-based game I think I really enjoyed my plays of this I haven't played it in a little bit of time because I did feel like the uh the me isms were a little bit repetitive as far as the cards were I you know I think the additional expansion that came out this year would change a lot of this uh a lot of the variability that is inherent in this game despite it being a very large deck of cards you know I I felt like it was a pretty straightforward and and fun game to play definitely there is some depth to this but I I haven't gotten around to exploring those depths myself there are other card-based Tableau builders that I do enjoy more and we'll talk about those a little bit later on but for now my number eight is ancient knowledge my number seven age of innovation so this is the latest game in the line of teram

mytica type of games this is a sort of direct sequel to that game where it's a you know it's a fairly heavy game where you are placing these buildings on top of a static map you have your own Tableau which is a randomized well or drafted faction that the major one of the major differences between this game and teram mystica is the modularity of the faction that you get to play whereas in teror mystica it was very static you drew a or drafted a faction that was the same every time with the same powers and abilities and in this game not only do you have that modularity where you can match mix and match different abilities with your faction but you also have some other features such as a technology board that you can buy certain effects from very to guyan project and so I would say that this game is a sort of merger and I guess middle point between the flexibility and openness of Gia project and the static deterministic uh very competitive game that is ter mystica and so for me this is my preferred game out of those three I think this game does tow the line perfectly between what I enjoy about um uh you know the very competitive and deterministic type of experience that you get in the system of ter mystica now would I play this game over clans of calonia I'm not sure uh as clans of calonia is a very similar game with a theme that I appreciate more and some mechanisms that I enjoy more as well but

I have really enjoyed my experiences playing this on board game arena and if you do enjoy Gia project in Tera mystica this is a game that you should try out as well so that's my number seven age of number six is evacuation now the next couple of games I've only played once but they left such an impression on me that I would be really keen and really look forward to playing these games again if I had the chance I try to limit myself to a game or two on tabletop simulator where I most of these games I had played and tried during the year of 2023 but as games do come out in a more digital format that's a little bit friendlier to me as a consumer I definitely would prioritize and rank some of these games very highly so that's why evacuation is still here and high on my list it was on my top 10 before and in this game by sui you are traveling from and evacuating from this old world to a new planet and it utilizes a lot of Euro mechanisms but in particular you have an action-based deck where you take actions based off the cards that you have you do have a static and set different types of actions that you can take but you can play the advanced mode where each of these cards is an alter alation of some of these basic actions that you can take which I think is very neat and provides a lot of variability and replayability and a lot of tactical uh strategery you know it's it's it's got the Tactical nature of trying to figure out the best course of action based off of the cars that you

have but you're still trying to over you know achieve an overall goal of moving these across to you know your own pieces to the new world and other things as well building ships Etc so there is a lot to unpack in this game it's a pretty heavy game one of my favorite sui designs as as of late I don't know if I would prefer this over um like underwater cities which kind of give me the same Vibes as far as how to take actions where that is a kind of mix and match with cards and worker replacement this one just strictly deals with the cards I mean evacuation missina 13 1349 oh I for I already forgot the the year for missina and Woodcraft are some of my favorite sui designs and I think evacuation definitely fits up there at the top for me and that's why it landed as my number six for 2023 so that's evacuation number five is nucleum another top 10 favorite of mine that I've only played once but I think this game as you can see by the overall ranking is very well regarded and loved by many it's gotten plenty of support even in the last year with new expansions and that is plural it it does have uh more material for this year and for the years to come and so this is a very well established game already where it combines some of the mechanisms such as route building and uh I guess uh Tableau development on a central board as well as your own Tableau as you would

find in brass but also some of the the uh I guess goal progressions and trying to achieve a better and better score from round to round that you would see in barrage as well as a mix of some new and unique mechanisms such as how you take actions in this game where I guess kind of similar to evacuation where you have cards that can be variable in what types of actions you take you have these uh rail tiles that you have in your hand that can dictate what actions you take as well but when you do place a route on top of a a route tile on top of a route rather you lose that ability to take that action so you're constantly getting new actions that you can take and you have to decide which actions to keep in your hand to use a few times to achieve the goals that you want to get versus what you lay down to also progress your game so there's a lot of strategic goodness in this game and combines a lot of the mechanisms that I find in games that I have adored in the past such as brass and barrage I do own now a copy of brass and so I I mean that game it does nucleum itself does feel different and unique compared to brass and bming uh and barrage I do feel like it has its own you know strategic element to it that it fits you know in of itself rather than being like a sequel or carbon copy of some of these other games and so I I feel like I could own this game and have it on my shelf and it would still be fine you know to have and

I think I would prefer to play nucleum over barrage I still I would love to play barrage more it's you know it's a daunting game this one is too but I that one game that I played and the impression that I had on it as well as the knowledge now after a year that this game has expansions and has a lot of force and momentum behind it to uh you know buoy it up in the years to come makes me excited that hopefully one day I could either own this game and have more of a chance to play it or to have a digital version available to play this as well and to explore the game in that regard so still really enjoyed that one play and would love to enjoy and pursue new claim in the future so that's my number five so number four is the White Castle this is an isra C and sha s design from 2023 that already has an expansion that was released this year that I have not played yet but this game I only have played once as well but I think this is a game that I would really enjoy playing a little bit more than even nucleum or evacuation which are really heavier games and very you know they're they're like a highlight game that you would play on a game night right White Castle has the ability to be a kind of a highlight game that you would play with your friends you know if you had the time but you can play that game in a such a short amount of time like I let's let's take a look here it says like 80 minutes you know at tops uh I I think if

you really understood this game you could play this game even quicker and and so I really enjoy the this game and mechanically what you're doing is rolling Dice and placing them onto different action spots for different you know things that you're trying to gain and and place onto the shared board a little bit of area majority a little bit of this and that but this game very much like its predecessor red Cathedral is a medium sized appearing game in a very small box that plays really quick or relatively quick for its weight and complexity and that's something that I've come to really enjoy especially in this last year I felt like I have had a decreased amount of time recently to enjoy games in person and even online and so the designs that I have gravitated towards in recent times are very similar to this game and even games like glass Road for example which is something that I've been playing a lot of recently kind of Falls within the same complexity and time frame that White Castle is and I think that's why it appealed to me so much after my one play as I I think it really meshes the the timing and the complexity in in a in a very approachable and digestable way that you can do so in a week night you know you don't have to wait until the weekend where you have more time to play a big sprawling game right you can do this uh very very much so any day of the week and almost at any time so that's something that I really appreciate but also found enjoyable and fun to play the

puzzle is very tough especially if you play solo which may or may not be overpowered when it comes to the AI I think there are some changes that are mentioned in the forums but but the White Castle is is an excellent design and I hopefully would look forward to playing the expansion with it to see what it adds and to just to explore the base game in general would be fantastic so that's my number four white so number three is life of the Amazonia now if you were to ask me what games that I don't physically own that I would want to pursue first out of this list I don't think I would go for games like nucleum and evacuation which I really enjoy I would go for like the White Castle and this game I think this game is very I mean it's it's I feel like it's underrated for the score that it's received but it's overall ranking on board game uh geek I feel like could be a lot higher I suppose if more people had had the chance to rate it and play it there's only there's almost 2,000 only for this game but life of the Amazonia was a such a fun game for me to play I enjoyed it so much that I made a separate video on how to play this game and in addition to my reviews and ratings of it but in this game you are bag building uh these tiles very much in a similar fashion to games like quax of quedlinburg or alapo where in addition to building these uh you know building this bag with these tiles you're using the uh resources that are depicted to

move up some tracks but also to play your own Tableau kind of reminds me a little bit of Arc NOA where you are placing these tiles and trying to conjoin Cascadia a little bit as well actually where you're conjoining some of these tiles based off of their landscape type and you're also putting down these animals for you know spending resources to do so and these animals have different ways that are scored as well from game to game you can also start the game with a special animal as well to give you a little bit of a symmetry and so overall this game combines a really fun experience with deck or uh bag and pool building as well as tavau building and U you know resource management and token placement so in in game like other deck builders that kind of mix a deck or bag building experience with other mechanisms in the market right now such as like do an Imperium lost Runes of arnac Etc uh life of the Amazonia is kind of adjacent to those in my mind it's not as heavy uh I think it's it's only rated yeah 2.93 but this one really hit the spot when I played it I'm going to give it a a heart for for being a fan I I I I just really enjoyed this a lot and it's something that I could you know easily wrap my head around and teach to other folks in a in a Wider Circle of of friends that I would play games with and it you know in incorporates a theme that I find very cozy and enjoyable as well

it may not be the the highest and you know most strategic experience out there or on this list rather but it's it's something that I just really felt strongly that I would enjoy playing this over and over again just to have fun with it rather than to pick apart and really dive into strategically so this is probably my coziest pick of the Year actually it's not my number two is but but life of the Amazonia is a close third you know fantastic game so that's number two so number two is Earth uh I forget if this was number one or two from my list last year I think it was number two because there's a certain Rosenberg game that is ahead of it but Earth is you know I think I wish it was if you were to ask me if there was any game that should be in the top 100 I think Earth would be it Earth is a game that needs no introduction a lot of people know about this game and have played this game fortunately because of the popularity that it has gained and garnered in certain review circles but also being available on board game arena to play it was featured at the world series of board gaming as well so that that is awesome I think this game has gotten a lot of praise and a lot of attention that it deserves frankly and uh I mean I think it holds back for me for being like my number one game one because it's not a Rosenberg design if you haven't noticed I'm I'm very biased towards Rosenberg games but but objectively like I feel like this game introduces a little bit more of the randomness uh with the how how big the

the deck is and if you don't know this game is a tableau Builder with these cards that you are playing onto your Tableau your you know Gathering resources to pay for them and they build a sort of engine that you can kind of activate in a style very similar to wingspan and and so this game uh does have a little bit of luck involved when it comes to uh you know finding the right cards which I will say has been somewhat solved with the expansion that is coming out the abundance expansion that is also available to play on board game arena if you haven't tried that out it introduces some mechanisms to help you search for the right cards in your deck to uh fulfill the goals that you need to but but this game plays fairly quick via you know simultaneous actions you can kind of think of it as kind of like race for the Galaxy where someone takes an action and the others take a a sub action that is very similar to that at the same time and and so mechanically it works really well it has a lot of the things that I enjoy about games in general you know I really like card driven Tableau builders for example and it does it in a simultaneous fashion to make it very quick it's it's got great visuals as well components are great and it's something that I do own personally and have backed and so I always enjoy Earth it's a little bit closer to the I enjoy this game just to play it rather than I enjoy this game to really dive into it strategically as well it's kind of similar to life of the

Amazonia but is definitely a staple in my collection it's something that I would bring out constantly and have brought out constantly for others to try and it's something that I just really look forward to playing over and over again as you can see here so that's my number two Earth so let's wrap it up with the most mustard yellow game there is on the market and that's orani and burger Canal now this game was a game found SL you know Kickstarter crowdfunded type of game from Rosenberg uh last year and I fortunately uh grabbed a copy from that campaign and I'm so glad that I did so I feel like this game is one of my favorite games to play of all time I think it you know mixes and matches a lot of uh features and mechanisms that I find you know fantastically enjoyable in rosenbury games with the resource wheel a glass Road and or at labora the Tableau building that is spatially aware very much like I guess glass Road um or you know or at labora as well newsford a lot of those games you know not only is important where uh what tiles you play or cards you play but where you play them as well it kind of combines the quick and tight worker placement experience that you find in newf um it does so at a two-player capacity only you could play this one or two players and and so that's one limitation possible limitation that it has but the

more that I've been playing some Rosenberg games more competitively the two-player experience is preferred anyway so so I don't mind it as much in this game now I guess this is a chance to talk about the new reprinted version of can Canal is what it's going to be printed as by syx I think this is a company out of Europe that is printing this I don't know if this is widely available at this time it's either had a year release at essent time and maybe a more worldwide release later on probably next year there are some rule changes to to canal versus the original orani burger canal in terms of what I mean componentwise yes it's different but also like the bridges you can activate more buildings you know based off of bridges than you were able to do so and some of the cards are different as well and so that might be a video for another time comparing and contrasting some of those differences but either way I think you're still getting a fantastic game if you play the original version if you ever get a chance to get your hands on it uh I know I'm not giving up mine or the the newest version of this as well this is I think Rosenberg as at one of his finest uh it's one of his finest games um because of the limited uh print run I do see why this game isn't as overall uh ranked and enjoyed with only a th000 ranked Kings you can see that a

lot of people do enjoy it maybe it's just a part of a smaller circle of Gamers who really jive with Rosenberg games but you know this was the highlight from last year and uh that's kind of where I'll end it you know end this video I think this is a great list I'll just jump back to the original list here so you can see I mean the top 10 games I just really would enjoy playing over and over again if I had the chance and and some of the games too from from the honorable mentions as well are great designs and I think a lot of people have really enjoyed them as well you can see those on reviews and and lists that have been compiled elsewhere but yeah you know I I'm really happy with how and I just for your information I didn't change any of this uh this is as you see it as in in Pub meele you know I didn't rearrange anything and I feel pretty comfortable about how that was arranged so anyway those are my top 10 games from 2023 probably the last time that I will visit this that year and now focus on 2024 so that'll probably once again be the video that I put out next and would love to hear you know if about this video you know in these games from 2023 what your favorites were if you share some of the same games that on your own personal top 10 list or top list of games that were released last year what are some of the games that are the same what are different were there Games

Lower on that you would rather put up or games that I haven't even played that you would you know recommend me trying so let me know what you think and thank you for listening and hope you consult with me another time and uh I'll catch you on the next one

Progress saved