Skip to main content
Loading video...

5 Pitfalls That Ruin Board Games (and How to Remedy Them)

Transcript 11:20

hi my name is Ben this is board game dad and today we're looking at five characteristics of board games that I find to be major drawbacks if you've been watching my reviews for a while you've probably noticed this trend there's often but not always one element that stands out as a negative for me so in this video we'll talk about those five characteristics and I'll even name a few examples of some games that expertly avoid or even remedy these issues the first problem is something I often encounter in games that deal with a lot of cards so these are games like wingspan or Ark Nova in general these games are a lot of fun and the designer's intent is that over the course of the game the luck is going to balance out sure sometimes you'll have some really bad cards and it'll seem like no good options but other times you'll probably draw something really awesome so it's up to the player to make calculated risks and mitigate for bad luck and kind of deal with it but occasionally you have those plays where it seems like you've done everything right and the luck just isn't working out and it's those times where the games can get really frustrating for me especially if the game is a long game I don't mind it so much in games that are really short or games that can be played multiple times in a single gaming session but with big games I want to have more control over bad luck due to

card draws fortunately there is a remedy for players who like me don't like bad luck due to cards and that is multi-use cards so there are a few games that do this really well often times I see it in games where multi-use means that you can either use the card for its intended use or you can discard it to do another action so brass is a great example of this however the game that I think does this masterfully is the game CR cryo because in cryo every card is used for four purposes it can be used for a player board upgrade a form of transportation an objective for scoring or it can be scrapped for resources so this means that in a game of cryo while you are drawing cards at random there are so many ways that you can use the cards that you'll never end up in a situation where you really can't do anything a related problem are games that have what is often called a market refresh these are games where uh there are several cards available for all players that are face up and one of the actions that you can take often at the cost of spending some money or resources is to refresh the market and discard them all and bring out new cards instead if the market refresh doesn't work out then it can be a huge waste other times I see this in games where the cards can be either useful for scoring or they can provide objectives for the player and in cases where a Market gets refreshed and

it just happens to be that an objective card comes out that is already perfectly Satisfied by the player they just have to take it and then they immediately get points that just makes it feel like without investing any effort or planning the player has just scored points because they were the one who took the risk on refreshing the market I that drives me crazy that drives me crazy even when I'm the player who benefits from a lucky Market refresh so few things that I've seen that kind of Rectify this the first game I of sky is most brilliant in this because in is of Sky every player draws three tiles and the three tiles can have anything they can have either uh resources that help you satisfy existing objectives or they can have new objectives on them and it's the player's responsibility to put a price tag on each of the tiles but there's one more game that I want to mention because I love this it's games where the objectives are actually tracks that players can advance on so one such game is the game Autobon because in Autobon players are trying to complete the German autobond and as they do this they're adding employees to the company now as the game progresses they get to promote their employees and the department that they promote their employees in determines scoring for the end of the game so in other words there are no tiles to draw at all or no cards to draw at all for objectives rather it's advancement on these tracks and what makes it so cool is that all

objectives are available to all players and as you advance on those tracks everybody can see what your priorities are and they can start to make plans based on how you've promoted your employees I like the transparency of that I like how players can read more into their opponent's intentions and I like how the scoring doesn't depend on something that you take off the board something you draft but rather an action that's available to everyone in the game Autobon the next element is the end game trigger these are games where if a player satisfies a certain condition it triggers the last round and when this happens it is often the case that the player who triggers the end of the game receives some sort of award usually a few points now there's a lot of reasons why I don't like this but the most important one is that it incentivizes players to end the game whether or not they're winning there have been games that I have played where I have elected to end the game not because I thought I could win but because I wanted to lose by less of a lead and that's not a fun choice to make now the most conventional way to rectify this is just to have the end of the game be once a player is the first to get certain number of points that's always fun because usually the person who hits that threshold is also the winner which I enjoy but there's a

different mechanic that I like even more and that is the games that have a set number of rounds these are games like Gollum like Woodcraft like the White Castle in all of these games players know from the beginning that there's going to be nine or 12 or 14 rounds or B what it may and it they know exactly when the game will end the game becomes less about doing the calculation of who's ahead and whether or not it's the right time to trigger the endgame and more about being as efficient as you can be with the limited number of turns that you have the next problem that I have arises in games that have What's called the take that mechanic these are games that have something built in where a player can play a card that negatively impacts an opponent now I recognize that this is not uh necessarily unintentional by the designer often times in games with it take that mechanic it's because the designer wants players to be attacking each other and that's and I and I personally just don't like that um and that's me that's fine but the thing is even if you like to take that mechanic there is an even more interesting mechanic and that is it's a take that mechanic where the event that harms your opponent could

potentially harm you as well one game where you can see this is the game called Castles by the sea in castles by the Sea players are trying to build structures in order to get victory points every round and at the end of their turn they're going to be flipping over Hazard cards that could potentially damage their con their constructions however the damage that's done by the hazard applies to all players in the region where the hazard is what this means is you can deliberately trigger a hazard that will harm an opponent but if you're not careful you may be in the presence of that Hazard as well and I think it's worth mentioning that even though I already mentioned cryo cryo does this as well and the last issue that really irks me in games are games that are designed so that the longer you play the longer the game takes these are games like Great Western Trail everdell lost ruins of arnac in all of these cases players either get more workers or they get more cards or they get more destinations and as a result the board or the duration of the round just gets longer and longer and longer so you can get to a point in the game you're like oh you know we're halfway done because you know such and such has happened but the thing is halfway done is really only a third of the way because the second half of the game is actually twice as long as the first half of the game now the reason I think this is designed and the reason I

think this is perceived as fun is because it gives players more to do as they build their engine so they have more resources they have more cards they can do more things it allows them to have the opportunity to do more things that's the whole point that's why they do it I don't like it because I don't like the agony of the game getting longer the longer I play it just feels horrible to me so kind of going back to those games that I mentioned earlier the one with the set number of rounds another reason why I like that so much is that you can have a set number of rounds and yet as you get more resources the game is still more and more eventful so there are some engine building games that do this exceptionally well and I'm going to go back to the White Castle it's only nine turns long but the last rounds of the game are actually very interesting even though it's only three turns just like the previous two rounds I've got one more board game for you that I think is brilliant on two counts and in doing so I want to close this video by showing you how I found it on sale through the perfect board game.com this time I found it through simply browsing the deals it's on sale and it's good the game is Sky mines and what sky mines does is two things first it has that transparent like objective tracks where you're advancing on different company tracks and then how far you advance determines your you're scoring at the end of the game and the second thing it does is it remedies the luck of card drawing by using planned discard

piles so setting up for the next round you're always drawing a hand of cards from a discard pile that you yourself planned so in this way you're always controlling which cards you're playing together makx for some excellent decision making and that is Sky mines so those are the five characteristics that I often identify as pitfalls for games but I'd like to hear from you what are the things about games that really bother you and if possible have you found games that Rectify that in some way let me know in the comments so thank you for watching this video I'll see you next time bye-bye

Progress saved