Casual Friday - 10 Greatest Area Control Games of All Time
Transcript
john what are we doing here uh you asked me to come into your basement this is a studio it starts out weirder sounding that it was intended to and you said you wanted a top five list of area control games and so i made a list and then i said i'm not even sure what that is yeah yeah the area control is something that i think it brings to mind certain things like i don't know about you but dudes on a map first like popped in my head and i was like oh it has to be these battle area games where you have an elaborate map that looks like it was written by you know tolkien or illustrated by tolkien or something it it is essentially the representation of fantasy novels from our youth but that's not really what we settled on huh no because i think there's a whole subset of like the the somewhat eurogamer mentality i mean when i hear area control i go back to risk which is what i grew up playing well before the the the golden age of boar gaming hit us now uh and we we had a lot more variety than just that dice chucker um but to me that was what area control meant it was it was throwing your dudes out on the map marching across the board capturing territory holding territory was a key part of the game and and watching your army sweep across the board as the main focus of victory so so i think and i think that's probably why you even asked me why why pick area control because you know that that's you know something that i'm passionate about but i think there's a whole subset of people who would say well area control is controlling an area through any means even if that just means majority of peace is in a spot you know more of a euro definition i think yeah yeah
totally and the because in my area control we don't share spots very much well you also had risk as a foundational game which risk has been garbage since it came out so you know what you have your definition of area control and i have mine but i think we should start with bgg's definition because they actually have area majority an influence as one of their defining mechanisms for area control games so on risk or pretty much all the games that we're talking about today area majority and influence is what they describe and they have it as multiple players may occupy a space and gain benefits based on the proportional presence in the space in el grande for instance players earn their score in a region by having the most caballeros in that region and i thought that was kind of limited so when we were bouncing some text back and forth i kind of came up with this idea an area control game has multiple areas on the board in which players may be able to extend their presence and it's possible to alternate who is in control of those areas often this is done by combat mechanics sometimes by majority of presence if shared presence is allowed and for our list what we're talking about today i was thinking that the victory condition in the game has to either be established by or largely driven by striving for control of these games and that that actually came into play in some of the decisions like there were games that i put on my list i kind of asked because i was like i don't know that the area control element is enough of a part of this game
did you actually struggle with putting together your list at all um i can't about a half dozen entries that i absolutely was passionate about specifically because i would start saying man i really like this game i really like this this this and this about it it's got the conquest it's got the art oh wait a minute you don't actually control any areas you just kind of you get points but you don't do it by holding anything you just oh that's not there i did a lot of hamming and hawing so i think i came up with something that is a um a medley of all the the varieties of area control on a spectrum and kind of did away with some of those questionable entries and i i would agree my personal definition that i came away with was something in which the control of a region either through exclusive control by conquest or by majority or influence right was a driving factor in either winning the game or getting points to to win the game through possibly other win conditions but it had to be something like at least 50 you know it can't just be one possible part of a point salad it has to be a big driving force it has to be the the whole salad or a pie even it's got to be at least the lettuce i mean there could be croutons there can be bacon bits and and you used to put little like oranges yeah like you were big on the little oranges yeah okay okay well then why don't we actually get this kicked off with what's your number five so so might not really ranked all that well either because they don't work at such different games so we're really put together i kind of have a number one that's definitely the one i like the best and the rest are just sort of tied for they fit in a pisces exactly
no it's friendly ties it's all tied per second okay um so i think number five for me i'm just going to start off by being as cheesy as possible and say diplomacy by email by email explicitly by email i don't want to sit at a table with you and play that game it will bore me but the best part of that game is one of the things that i think is the best part about area control which is the the give and take the the despair of losing something that belongs to you and the the rush of gaining something that belongs to someone else coupled with the fact that i just spent two days emailing a friend to backstab another friend when i should have been working instead i i think that may be one of the purest area control games or really one of the purest games period i mean it's such a minimalistic game where like the the players themselves drive all of the fun and interaction of the game so that's that's an interesting entry that i didn't even think about when putting together my list see my number five i started with something that was like near and dear to our hearts and you know i i had to go with comment so like comment to me is uh a game that just encourages slaughter like you are from the get-go putting so much pressure on every other player and every decision that they make whether it's drafting those tiles or whether it's uh going to just take certain spaces on the board you are in the thick of it right away
and the the fact that there's such a limited space and everyone has so much access to one another as far as classic aggressive area control games comment to me was the one that came to mind it's definitely not my favorite game because i have tons of anxiety when i'm like oh god i'm going to do something that's going to hurt my my friend and i'm happy about hurting my friend but i know that like three other friends are going to come back and take advantage of my vulnerability but still commet is just such a brilliant game and i'm excited about it getting that new new version coming out gonna ask you that so so so i'm not getting paid for this um you know and i'm no one special but if you wanted to make me uh guys matago if you guys wanted to make me an egyptian god feel free you know here's your free plug i absolutely back the second edition it is one of my favorite games but it is one that i could not say met the cut from my definition in that oftentimes i get more points from killing my friends and from uh driving all those extra bonus points less so than the holding of the temples depending on your strategy you could make it an argument that it's more than 50 but that was my take and that's why i didn't make the cut for me well it's also because you have bad taste so let's hear about your number four here uh okay so number four is we're we're still pushing so if if diplomacy is holding area through force uh in its purest form then i'm pushing closer towards that euro definition with uh plague inc so i don't know if you've ever played the app i
i have it's it's the beeps and boops button pushing it's really fascinating but when you think about what you're really doing it's kind of watching things grow honestly watching grass grow um and take over the world and sprout from people's ears and noses and depending on if you're playing it with a fungus but no the um the thing about uh plague was that it is it is a non-aggressive game in that you really don't take stuff from people right but you try to it represents something that thematically playing risk growing up my little i would play a little army of darkness i'd play black was my color the horsemen of the apocalypse and to me it was it was emblematic of a plague marching across the world as every time i took more territory i got more guys to take more territory and it was like it was it was it was an it was a sort of a geometric progression like a disease as the armies march across the board and so something about plaguing captures that spirit of you actually are a disease and in the same way your goal is to just as effectively as possible march across the board and just claim territory in the form of people's uh countries but you have a messed up childhood if like you're imagining your risk characters going out it's like this is the plague i spread upon the leg absolutely uh so i played black as my army and and as often as possible we had the little colonial dudes and so it's you know cannons little soldiers and guys on horseback and every single time that i could it was guys on horseback that's amazing there's the horsemen of the apocalypse marching across the uh the map well for me i went with a newer game
certainly uh more modern than diplomacy again uh i went with eric lang's blood rage now i know there's an argument to be made here for chaos in the old world and i know a ton of people are diehards for that game but blood rage to me is where area control was starting to get played with and it was becoming dissected as a genre the dudes on a map portion of area control at least and i felt like blood rage is the first time in a game where i felt incentivized for certain strategies to die like you could go into a battle and it's okay to die if you outfitted your your team a certain way and that was really interesting to me and also i really like that the aggression is more posturing within the locations you know you move a unit in and then your opponent's going to go well there's such a limited space within that area and so they may as well posture in there and that encourages all of the following turns that people have but you don't actually initiate an attack with anyone else i i thought that was so brilliant the first time that i that i played it that you attack the land and then it becomes a battle rugby scrum exactly yeah it's like all right i'm kicking things off and i'm pillaging here and it's like someone threw the ball i don't know how rugby's played i assume there's a ball and i don't think so there's actually rules in rugby
someone throws the ball in the middle of the pile everybody realizes it's there and and then a scrum happens i think that's what it is but that's it's viking scrum it's viking rugby but absolutely and i think the cool thing about that is that it plays into the area of area control whereas something like you know you go back to the og area control risk type game or actually whatever there's a lot of logistics in it there's a lot of how do i get armies from a to b and how and if i'm spread too far whatever but this boils it down to i am jostling for space the truest definition of i'm fighting for an area really minimal movement right right right yeah and i i think that it's just one of the most fun games that i i still can play that i think is a pure but still inventive area control game like it it just brings a lot of joy to me except for the name like i i hate the name blood rage i think it is spicy yeah spicy vikings is infinitely better uh okay so what do you got what's what's coming up next let's do let's do okay so play on yours here i didn't do drafting i like i do like area control where they started to tack on other mechanics to say you know like we don't want risk we don't want to dice chuck we don't want this weird exponential growth of things so what we're going to do is we're going to bolt on other mechanics that are maybe more fun mechanics but keep the sense of capturing territory tyrants in the i was going to say tyrants of the underpants because that's that's the best game that's what i call it at home that's the parents of the underpants and i can't not say that sometimes but tyrants are the underdark um is it
possibly the first time a good d game was made that wasn't dnd a good board game of d d probably well no no no no i mean isn't that like the the follow-up to lords of waterdeep like lords of waterdeep is great game okay okay that's true fair enough but i guess it's very loosely yeah what makes it like an area control game i actually haven't played this game oh okay well so i'll bring that over next time we get together but um i mean it is it is true area control it's uh it's got dudes on a map it has it's got a lot of drow right absolutely dro trowel you're a bad person if you say dro so i think we can agree on that um but but yes it's got a lot of drizzits oh no that's the word right okay okay now i know where this is going no so so so you hold cities and the cities represent their spaces on the board you have to have majority control to really benefit um you have to link there's logistics you have to link adjacency from place to place so you build little paths of dudes but then there's ways to break that rule and and the whole way that you interact with the board is through a deck building mechanic through building a um a progressively better and better deck that does a variety one of maybe four or five or six different ways to interact with the board whether it's assassinating enemies dropping spies on the board what have you but i think it is one of the more interesting takes on one that is not a purely dudes on a map game right right so okay well you can bring that over but you know we'll see how i feel about dritz in your underpants
uh as for my number three i went with something that i think is a game that a lot of people have turned on because when i first played it i felt like everyone was all about this game and then now i feel like people only mention it when they're like oh god in that game that's ethnos i i was blown away when i played this game and i thought it was a very intentional like subversion of fantasy area control games like i thought that by having the the beautiful illustrations in it the john howe artwork and then this like very uh like very interesting like classic uh fantasy literature map that you play on and then having these like hyper techno colored skittle like plastic pieces that you put everywhere i hate those pieces i i thought that was brilliant i was like these contrasts so amazingly and they're garish compared to the john howard the color scheme was definitely tropical skittles yeah exactly which is very contrasted with the kind of like uh hildebrandt brothers type art that you're talking about like a classic fantasy art like that and then tropical skittles well i think that there are two kinds of people there are people who are like oh my god this this old fantasy artwork is terrible where i was like this is amazing and then there's also people who are like i love this very classy and refined fantasy artwork and how dare you pollute it with all these you know pieces here that are plastic and garish colors but the the the the juxtaposition
of these two elements old and new i think carry throughout the whole thing because the mechanics that you would think from the the box and seeing the map is that this is going to be a battle game it's going to be lengthy it's going to be something that you know you're going to end up winning by killing other dudes and really it's kind of like a ticket to ride light and you're positioning different tokens in areas by making these sets and even though there's all these different races that have asymmetric powers you're not actually those races you're playing from a common pool which how cool is it that you just build this deck out of what six out of the 12 races or 10 races that are in there so you have all these different combinations it's super fast to play it's very interesting and the area control aspect of having the most or uh having a majority in the region uh and getting ranked based off of that is brilliant so it is absolutely a fantasy area control game and it is absolutely not what you would ever think of in a fantasy area control game so ethnos is absolutely in my top list i think the only reason and it was high on my list too just because i do like the the the set collection mechanics the only reason i think i did not really steer that direction was that i felt that the area control to me was a byproduct of what the game is really about which was clever use of the the the set building or the uh the set collection mechanic yeah totally you can make an argument either way i mean the area control is absolutely
vital and the the majority of the points you score is driven by the area control but the the interaction with the area control it's it's i put a token down and not much else you don't ever kill anybody you don't cleverly switch tokens or move them around um most of the clever play is being done over here with the cards that don't directly drive those so that was one area where i was like okay well yeah but how good does it feel to have a wizard bomb where you know that dragon's about to come down and you drop six wizards and you're like yeah i'm going to draw the third dragon by drawing six cards and take that or the centaurs you know putting token after token on the board dude i need to play more ethnics i love that game so we we are coming towards the end of your tie for second place here what do you have as your next not as good as number one game okay so i have a feeling i have a feeling that i'm going to to uh supersede one of your games if i if i'm guessing correctly and i'm going to say battle for rokugan that's an interesting pick uh the probably the least plastic of any game that i've got um which is actually one of his charms it's it's kind of refreshing to have just a box of sort of it's almost purist in that it is just a box of cardboard chits that still somehow does everything that i want a game that is full of twilight imperium-esque plastic armies marching across the board right right um it has everything i love about a true area control and that there is um there's room for betrayals there's
room for sort of deal making there's a bit of the unknown when you're wondering what orders are happening um it's it's light it's lighter than some of the the absolutely heavy beasts like the twilight imperium so the really big slogs certainly lighter than that the slog that that risk used to be right right um so so what i grew up on this is considerably lighter but definitely richer experience so i don't know i think it does everything that a really heavily con conflict-driven uh area control game should do yeah and it's such a minimalist package it's so beautiful and it has that legend of the vibrance theme which i'm all about if i could if i could give you a brief tangent a game that i wouldn't put on this list because it's objectively not as a good game i live for brief tangents um i had this game wizard quest okay there was like a 1975 game that i found in my grandparents addict it was actually a christmas gift for my dad like in the 80s or something like that so this game is 30 40 years old at least right and it is very much a risk-like game the combat i think is even d6 versus d6 driven but what blew my mind when i first found this and played this was that okay risk you're camping out on this you know i've got north america and i'm slowly moving into south america and whatever and and this is this is my territory this is right my walls are built don't breach them because that means i'm losing wizard quest was all about marching around the board and yeah if you held territory you got more dudes which is a driving force behind the area control but then your goal was actually
to capture these treasures of yours you would have your three little treasures and they'd be splutter spread around the board and uh your goal was actually to capture them so oftentimes it turned into this amorphous like you would sort of migrate your army and as you lose territory over here you'd sort of migrate your kingdom further and further towards what you really wanted and then sort of go for you know punch in to try and get that that treasure what blew my mind about it though was it took that whole notion of like turtling and camping and this is what i'm going to do and it said okay well no you're going to move around battlefield rokugan does a good job of having a very fluid i don't hold territory sort of feeling it's unnerving when you play an area control sometimes and you really just want i want to put walls down and don't come across my walls so if you want fluid area control i'm guessing that i mean obviously small world has to be your number one right oh it was so high on my list i i don't know that i love that game as much as i did when i first found it right right but in some ways it is one of the purest uh just dynamic area control with asymmetry it is it is so charming and and for a brief spoiler here i don't think it's the number one in either of our lists but it really is a charming game and it accomplishes a lot in making this really really approachable um game that captures the spirit of like older games that you and i grew up on also it seemed like the most complicated thing in the world when you were first getting into like modern hobby board games and you're like i played ticket to ride in katan but this small world game is like the biggest
most epic game i've ever seen it's a thing and i think it boils everything down to the purest um we talk about you know these pure ideas of this okay this mechanic you know this is about majority and this one's about the movement right right so to me small world is about the cost benefit analysis of like how you can take any space on the board you want but how many of your little cardboard goblins is this space gonna be worth to you and it's about min-maxing that decision-making process to say this turn i want more points so i have to evaluate what can i afford to take right not what i can afford to hold you actually don't care about holding it it's but what can i afford to take yeah yeah well i i think we could do a whole episode on like possible runner-ups and that's one thing that you know as we come to the conclusion of this uh this episode here if people want to see more of like us talking about this stuff and just getting pedantic about the various mechanisms and that kind of stuff we could probably fill an hour just talking about the merits of what's actually area control or you know what are different games that we considered in preparation for this list but for number two i i do actually have some thoughts about the nature of area control and maybe it's indicative that i don't actually love area control all that much that so many games on my list are like subverting area control in some way or kind of riffing on the classic model and they're not those pure experiences and you know this game itself
it's not really like a pure area control game where you need to control the areas and i actually thought about axing it from my list but unlike games like say eclipse where i felt like it did have an area control element but it it was so minimal compared to the grand scheme of that that games ethos that i i didn't feel comfortable with eclipse on the list but number two is one of my favorite games of all time and that's root and this game yeah you don't actually get points from owning areas and there's a limited mechanic in there that you can gain dominance of certain areas on the board in order to get an instant victory instead of points but at its heart it has these various areas on the board that are going to force interaction because there's limited space and though you don't need to control an area in order to win the areas themselves are what's going to facilitate each of the different asymmetric factions to achieve whatever their their means are and the factions that don't actually need to control areas like i'm thinking about the migrating i played it one time twice now and it's been it's been a good spell so what a little migrating bandit dude or whatever yeah well the vagabond and then uh like the the lizards like automatically take control if they have a garden or i'm thinking of the corvids who don't actually need to have
control for the various types of movement that they have but the even the factions that don't need control they're defined as being an exception to this rule that establishing control is how you're able to move about the map it's how you're able to put things out it's how you're able to get points like control is such an inherent aspect to that game and it forces interaction puts pressure on everyone and i absolutely adore it i think from that we could probably take and expand the definition because i think it's a little narrow to think okay well area control is is the area defining the wind condition so much as okay the area needs to either define the wind condition to really be focused on area control or the area control aspect maybe is the main facilitating factor right to the other pieces that you're doing so you have to control the area in order to move about the board and accomplish whatever the other goals are i would agree with that i would say my experience with root it feels area control-ish enough to be in that category area control-ish where where where does do the deeper never pies come in and the dandelion wine yeah assume that's part of the win condition it has to be it there that's like the brian jake's secret award you know on the side like if you read the inside of the box or something you know you lift back a flap it's like you secretly win if you speak like a mole throughout this or or or uh can describe at least five food stuffs yeah exactly something about uh chestnut sprinkled with sugar dandelion wine it has to be really obscure like garden stuff too yeah
tell us the the the various permutations of log-alog of the the shrews of moss flower all right before we get to our number ones i wanted to actually bring up something i put online i asked people what are their favorite area control games knowing that we were going to do this and never losing an opportunity or missing an opportunity to take advantage of an audience to fill up time so i uh turned to the internet for uh what are the favorite area control games and this is what i got fellow alaskan and platypus con attendee and game designer and game developer michael dunsmore how many different titles could i give him okay so michael dunsmore says is this even a discussion everyone knows in their heart that is eric lang's masterpiece chaos in the old world extremely asymmetric play while still keeping all the core rules the same so that it's easy to teach and learn plus who doesn't want to be a god despoiling regions i don't know what do you think i i threw out chaos in the whole world earlier i still have it i love that game i'm just going to say this eric lang needs to not design any games that have three player requirements yes i'm looking at you blood rage and chaos in the old world i love those games but come on three players that is like the hardest give me something for two or something i don't know i think it's the required three minimum well i think blood rage actually plays two to four but it's just not exactly great
i think am i crazy internet tell us which one of us is right in this because i'm not going to go and check my shelf right now yeah now i want to know okay well if i'm wrong pretend i didn't say that if i'm right pretend i'm gloating right now being i think i just always had a hard time getting that one to the table but when i just just because it's an odd it's a strange number right i don't know what it is about having that number on the box that means i can't get four people to play it i don't know but that's just the curse um but absolutely a really cool game in that you the area control elements is more than just the dude you have on the board but also the corruption mechanic truth is i thought chaos in the old world was eh it's okay people love it a lot more than i do that's why i went with bloodrage now dr joe baxter webb says inish it's just so streamlined every area has a reason you'd want to control it multiple ways to win means you have to concentrate combat is so simple but so tense this is a pick that i can kind of get behind here it's psychedelic game it does play interesting riffs on area control i don't know do you have like a hot take on inish here i i have a passion for what i see is the like the mythology cycle i kind of want them to join these games i want madiga to come out and like make a battle of the gods or something because they do such a good job on that theme with the egyptian gods and income at uh cyclades and the greek gods and then inish in the i didn't realize there were celtic gods but or big celtic mythology um if it's not thor and lightning bolts then i'm confused
right right um but but uh the the thing about that one is it very much is a good example of area control in that it's all about getting dudes into an area and then supplanting the enemy not through combat but more through trickery and and manipulation of of location and or swapping guys in and out and things like that so there's a lot of meat to it i stray more towards like the comet side of things i want more combat i want more blood and guts i want more upgrades and powers right right right but absolutely deserves to be on this list and cyclades deserve some honorable mention on that on that list too even though that one the the the controlling of the islands is really minimal compared to the huge auction mechanic which i did actually in preparation for this i was out there kind of looking at what what do the other people think area control means right right someone made a very good case that if if controlling a space is putting your resource in the form of dudes on this this spot is sort of an uh bidding on a spot using your armies then auctions could be considered a more abstract form of i'm trying to control this god by placing my guys here so we could get extremely academic on this it was a rabbit hole it was a rabbit hole but it was it was an interesting point to make in a very long bgd pose right right okay well uh nate walker here speaking of academics says el grande is the once and future king boring and i just don't have well i mean it's fine it's fine i wrote
marshall scorpions across empires and caballeros i don't want to wear zarape as i march across the board i just kind of want i want my plague to conquer the earth i want my dark gods to rise up and sweep across the board i want to hold the honor of having castles before you know right and getting betrayed and i think there is a total argument for this you know el grande is okay um i think yokohama is a great uh area control game and i mentioned ethnos earlier as you know like a non-aggressive non-combat area control game uh so i i think these games you know like i i i think it deserves a mention but as far as personal preference el grande is the category but it's not something i'm gonna be jumping into right now uh fellow uh gamer viewer matt hallowell who has some excellent reviews and i think this is actually an excerpt from one of his reviews so i'll put a link into here uh he says cthulhu wars beckons you to unleash the eldritch power of the old ones i mean see he's responding to a tweet yeah i think i saw that blurb like on the kickstarter for cthulhu yeah exactly so layers of asymmetric nuance chest-like precision and fistfuls of dice bring both immense depth and surprise twists it has consumed my mind more than any other game the stars are right nap time is over well that is very eloquent and a beautiful way to put that he really digs through the
wars which i'm surprised hasn't been on your list yet because that's a hot game right yes i'm going to disagree just a little bit here that nap time is sometimes over unless you're playing the sleeper faction in which case absolutely it's nap time okay which i think should tell you right now that cthulhu wars is my number one um i have backed everything they've put out so that should tell you i'm a glutton for punishment uh financially yes you're single single handedly supporting sandy peters and games there's a man who out there who is able to design games wholly on the back of the financing i am providing at this point um and i'm pretty sure i've seen the pictures of his kids braces yeah orthodontia ain't cheap man so the thing is is it's a lot of plastic it is my showpiece of a game so you we got any review of cthulhu wars has to talk about the fact that that that it's a multi-hundred dollar investment potentially even if you just get the base box it's over a hundred dollars and you are investing in the flash and the flare but if you were to shove that and take for example this is why it beat chaos in the old world for me because you get the the dark gods rising and conquering the earth so get the theme but and you get the asymmetry and you even get that energy-based mechanic which i really love a round structure where it's it's asymmetric turns where if i spend all my energy now i'm out for the round and i could keep going as if i can drag my actions out i might be the last man getting to act in the turn um really great mechanic implemented in one of yours too bloodrage yeah um so i love to see that one but with cthulhu wars the the tense i love the phrase knife
fight in a phone booth feeling of of holding spots just by having enough big scary things on the board and always being one monster away from having someone topple you off the spot that you need it is such a good feeling and if i had a downside to it i would say the only downside to that game is that it has a high learning curve because of the the heavy asymmetry going into it i'm going to have an advantage because i know what everybody does but you're going to be focused on learning your faction and have no time to learn the other ones so honestly i i think if there's one downside to the game it's that it it is going to be a turn off to some people because you'll have this impression that the game cannot be that sophisticated like this just has to be a game that facilitates selling a ton of plastic and uh let's forget about this that's how i actually felt and i tend to be pretty like uh you know willing to try anything and i i think you know whatever i'll give it a chance and i did that with the wars with you but i remember going into it going like uh this is just going to be an excuse to have this like monumental totem to an eldritch god on the table and i was amazed with how sophisticated of a game it ended up being well and even the theme says the same thing this is a theme that's been hashed and rehashed and hashed and rehashed time and again and how many nuanced ways can you do the rising of the old ones and i'm going insane and the earth has fallen and so i i kind of you know i bought it when it first kick-started in like 2013
and this was only only four or five years into my heavy gaming experience um so i didn't know what to expect but even if i kick-started it now i would expect kickstarter bloat i would expect look it's an easy theme that everybody does it's bloated plastic it's probably not for me i'm glad i got it before i became that um reserved right i lucked out so absolutely uh definitely fits my number one and as far as area control goes it it doesn't have the aspect of conquering anything it's the tense hold it in the moment that comment or blood range might have and i think you ended up having to buy a larger house just to house all of the miniatures associated with that game or maybe the timelines happen to be coincidental there but okay well my number one is uh is a game that i think of as like emblematic to this genre it's the game that was probably the one of the icons of board gaming to me when we were starting to get really heavy into board games and now i think of it fondly as like kind of the the apex of like pure dudes on a map area control games and that's game of thrones second edition i i just i i know it's unwieldy i know that it takes forever i know that it doesn't scale particularly well with different player counts though there was that feast for crows expansion that did pretty well with four players and then there was also the latest expansion which i hear scales players better because of the like vassal system
i haven't actually played it yet but what i do know is that this game just all of the aspects of the game which are really well integrated both thematically and mechanically like you know it captures the spirit of game of thrones or song of ice and fire um but everything is in service of the area control aspect of the game because in order to win you have to have a certain number of castles and those castles are going to impact heavily your capabilities throughout the game at various intervals it's going to be checked and so you want to have them in order to to bolster your power but there's also this element where you might consider is it worth me giving up this castle if i can position myself into a more tactical uh you know environment or capture someone else's and yeah there's all this like political intrigue and everything going on which i think is heavily influenced by diplomacy um but the the game itself is how do i maintain control of the things i have and expand outwards and take advantage of little vulnerabilities because everyone is putting pressure on a few other people and if you capitalize on that well then you come out on top and i just think it's one of the most refined games in my collection it may not be my favorite it doesn't hit the table all the time
it is hard to get a group in order to play game of thrones second edition especially after everyone's lost interest in game of thrones after the abysmal eighth season and maybe like seventh and sixth season if you want to get into it but um yeah i i adore this game and even though root is one of my favorite games and probably i would definitely rank it higher than game of thrones in my personal list when i'm thinking area control that is the game that i think at the top of it i have maybe five things so i'm gonna try and focus on there's fun i went on a rant there you know i don't um i i don't think that i could say enough about game of thrones so i have maybe five things to hit on first uh funny stories that i was actually mad at you for buying game of thrones the first time because it is such a beefy game to get to the table and right it and it really doesn't didn't scale well at least in the early days for for sure i i can't say for the new stuff but uh i was mad because our social circles for gaming overlapped so heavily that i'm like now i'm never going to get my copy played because we game at your house so it'll be your copy played so now i've got this game on the shelf that i love and i'll get to play it but it won't be my copy but your copy is signed now yes so story number two is i actually got the most confused look i think you've ever seen from from an author uh when i took that game to comic-con in san diego and got georgia or martin to sign my copy of game of thrones and he's just holding the empty board game box because i took it with no pieces in my suitcase
yeah and uh he's just holding this empty board game box just kind of confused like there's a stack of of books over here and this guy wants this what is this well i was there like i i i actually got the book signed you know like a normal person and then you are like will you please sign my board game box so so i have that going for me too um but uh but one of my all-time great um board game experiences was a loss to you explicitly is if i wanna if i remember correctly it was the martells right right explicitly denying me the victory which gets to something set aside all the nostalgia for the game of thrones part of it but what makes game of thrones really cool that we haven't talked about for area control is something that actually gets a lot of scorn which is the idea that you don't win a lot of area control by being especially conflict heavy area control by being a head the guy in first place almost always loses right right because and it becomes like you ever see those games you have to like tap the button to make your little dude like just hover right between the the goal posts kind of thing as you travel across the the screen little time wasters it reminds me so much of that as a metaphor where you just you want to be in like the top two or three players but you never want to be the number one because you want to topple the king are you comparing game of thrones to flappy bird right now it was i absolutely it's it's a metaphor flappy bird is a metaphor for game of thrones you want to flap your little bird right below the obstacle of being in first because you'll get crushed
but but definitely not at the bottom you know the cardboard herald doesn't sell merchandise but i think we can make a shirt out of this there's there's an opportunity here there's a there's a meme to be had here with the first place player above the flappy bird but yeah that is something that game of thrones does so well because if you take an early lead you are destined to fail and it's only by being that guy who's just close enough to victory that you can then suddenly sneak your way to that extra couple of castles that's how you win that game actually really again tying back to the theme of being like it's never never the people who are doing well in that show because they ended up dying really quickly like oh this guy looks like he's in charge and knows what he's doing he's gonna die next episode all right well we have 10 games down plus a few honorable mentions and then of course the the games that the audience uh listed as their own favorites if you want to see more of these videos if you want john to come back on for some reason god knows why i mean he is the only person that i know like personally that has most assuredly played even more games of me and is really a part of the fabric of my own like gaming identity um so you know that we have a lot of camaraderie and rivalry there so if you do want to see more of these videos then i'd love to hear some suggestions and i'd also love to know how we're wrong specifically how john's wrong but i have a feeling that i went with the less typical area control gaze i'm gonna hear some flack for diplomacy by email
but i still contend that that is the most excited i ever have ever been to come home from work and check my email is is knowing that i was getting stabbed in the back most likely okay well uh you know let us know what you want to see in the future if you want to be one of the people who gets to give your own recommendation for one of these videos and you know when we're getting ready to film one then just follow on twitter at cardboard harold youtube is the cardboard herald i don't know handles are weird but anyway thank you so much for watching thanks john for coming on to the show this has been a blast and i can't wait to do it again all right thanks for having me i want to have a discussion about whether a flicking game could be area control by virtue of you having to actually put your piece to physically control an area moving a piece i think you could have a dexterity-based area control game like where it's kind of a shuffleboardy type like you're aiming to get to a region but still the holding of that is crocodile
if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcast and video here on our channel and website cardboardherald.com our content is audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard herald