Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 50 Board Games of All Time (2025) - #20-11

Transcript 1:07:58

Hey, I'm Ryan. This is my brother Daniel. This is Rolls in the Family. And today we are continuing our countdown of our top 50 board games of all time with number 20

through 11. Maybe you've been with us through this journey. Maybe you are just finding this video. In which case, maybe you want to check out some of the rest of the list. Um, and actually there's a reason why you might want to do that besides just being interested in what games we like, which is that we are running a contest as part of this, a giveaway where you yourself could get one of the games off of our list. And each of these videos has a way that you can get an entry. There's a Google form in the description below. And I am going to tell you the secret word, unlike how I did in the last video where I did not say the secret word. That's that's that's a good teaser. I promise that there's a secret word and then just never say it.

Yeah, it was much more secret in the last video.

You really had to work

most of these ones. Yes, I'm sure it was on screen. But uh I'm going to give you a word that you'll need to enter in the uh form below to officially get the entry for this video. Today's secret word is final. Like this is your final opportunity to get an entry.

Oh my god.

In this giveaway. In fact, the window for this one is is smaller. It is because from the point that you're actually viewing this, assuming you're viewing it shortly after it has been

this isn't live

posted to the internet. Yeah. This whole time I thought we were live.

No, we we record in advance, believe it or not.

Wow.

Uh because of the timing of us needing to get out the 10 through one video the following week and have the winners announcing that video. It's a shorter time frame that you actually can get this particular. So, so don't wait. I I tell you, it rewards the more dedicated viewers, right? Like there's a lot of people that are not going to be dedicated enough to get that fourth entry.

We're talking to you. You're only going to have three entries maybe, but

uh you can however go back to all the other videos if you missed them and you can get all those entries. As long as you get them in before we actually do the drawing for that last uh video, you are good. some good games here to

be potential.

I would love to win one of these games

selected and they are good games that we're gonna have links to in the description below. So you could go check them out for yourself. Um see

you could buy in advance and then win the game and then return it.

Yes. Or just get a different game and then you get two gray games.

That's another option. Yep.

Look at that.

Okay, Ryan.

Yeah, let's uh let's hit it. We're top 20.

Yeah, top 20. So uh start with my number 20. This was a game that rhyme. We were just talking about

right before we started recording this video and I was expressing my grief that how could my 20th board game of all time not be in my collection. Uh number 20 goes to Ark Nova. Um as I was just sharing with Ryan, my deep uh grief in my heart that uh I don't own Ark Nova and actually used to own Arc Nova. Sold it to Ryan. Um, so does that make it hard or did you did you ever pay me or did you steal it?

I believe I believe I paid you.

Okay.

I don't think it was like a trade bartering or paying check on that.

Does it make it harder though seeing me, you know, like just enjoying this game?

It's awful. It's truly awful. So, I may end up getting it again. I've got a friend who owns it. But Ark Nova, um, it really brings together so many elements I think that we, uh, enjoy in board games, uh, especially in heavier games. Uh, obviously I think the theme, the zoo theme is just a really fun one. Um, you know, I haven't feel like there's not a lot of games that I've played that kind of uh lean into that and and having your personal board, you really do feel that uh the fun of building out kind of a, you know, a unique layout, but although also the constrictions of like a polyomino game where it's like, you know, how can I fit my enclosures, you know, in the best way best way possible. So, you got all that going on. You've got the, you know, continual getting of cards, which is something we love in a lot of games. I think of like a terraforming Mars or something like that where we're continually, you know, getting these cards that can be animals, they can be conservation projects, you know, all these all these different things. Um, but all of, you know, amidst it's a it's a fairly heavy game, right?

lot going on, but it all centers around just such a beautiful simplistic system of you have these five action cards and you are uh whenever you take an action, you take the card and you slide the rest of them down or I forget which direction, slide to the right or left. Um but they're getting more more powerful the longer you wait, right? from like when you take an action, you have to put it back at the bottom and the more it gets down, uh, the more powerful it's getting. It's such a simple thing. It is so great. Like the the puzzle of how to maximize your actions is so rewarding of, okay, sweet. I was able to get this one to, you know, the fifth position and I'm able to do the full powerful version of the action or like I really need to do this action again, but it's low and is that worth it? Or should I take another action, you know, in the meantime? I just find that's incredibly rewarding. You add on top of that, you know, I've played once the uh expansion Arc Nova, which I think you own now, correct? And oh my gosh, does that just really add some fun uh improvements even to that system cuz now those cards there's some v you know you start the game is it one or two of them are

two unique

two unique variable cards which Ryan and I are just like you know like that's just that's just that's just incredible. There's a lot of other stuff it does, but man, the the whole interaction of the personal board and the actions you're taking there, the shared like kind of conservation projects and that along with man, it's a game where there's a lot of comboing and you, you know, get this thing to then can then allow you to get this thing. Uh, this one's a ton of fun. It is. It's really, you know, obviously up there in in those uh uh heavier games uh that we enjoy. And uh it's held steady for me kind of 18, 15, and now now 20. And that's despite not being in my in my collection currently. But

yeah, Ryan, I I I miss it. I miss it. I have it back. Can I have it back?

Sorry. No takebacks.

Just my birthday coming up. You don't just give me uh give me your copy again.

Yeah, I'll think about it.

Okay.

Yeah. I think Ark Nova of games in recent memory before we had the chance to play it, it probably looked the best on paper of any game. Like as far as like,

oh, this could be one of our favorite games. Like, it just hit on so many elements. And fortunately, I think we both would say it uh

met expectations of how good it could be.

Cool. My number 20 is is a bit of a weird one here because I'm I'm marking it as new to the list,

but it's not. However, I have 10 plays of it that came before this year of a previous edition of it that were like 10 years ago. So, this is like a revival onto the list with a new edition

simply because now I have the new edition. You were actually the one to get it first. This is through the ages,

a new story of civilization.

Wow. Um, so it had been a long time since I had played this game because we had the the old edition and we had played it way way back a bunch of times.

Yes.

Um,

eventually gotten rid of it

after Yeah. I can only take so many of Ryan obliterating me with those uh wars.

Yeah. You know, and I think we got rid of it. It was It's a very long game. Some of that war stuff was pretty like swingy aggressive.

I still have P. Some of it was just back when our collection was

actually it's probably more back when we had so much time to play it was easier to like get pulled into like wanting to play other games and stuff. But this new edition it looked like some really good changes to it. You ended up

getting it cuz I think you found a secondhand deal or whatever. Really

enjoyed it. Um and the more I looked into the changes of it and remembered our experiences in the past I was like you know what I think this is a game I would like to get back in the collection. glad that I did and I got a play of it in the last year and was just reminded this it's not a new game but this is a solid solid system. It's long and people often talk about like, you know, especially cuz there's good app implementations and stuff like why would I play the physical board game?

But here's the thing. I think the length in some ways is kind of a feature because of how it makes you feel like you're going through the ages.

Yeah, come on. If the title ages, this better be a long game. you way you build things up and you see your progression from the beginning of the game to the end of the game. It has this epic feel to it that wouldn't be the same if it was streamlined down to the point where, you know, you played it in 2 hours instead of 4 hours.

Yeah.

Um

and so yeah, it's not one that's going to hit the table a lot for that reason,

right?

Um but I had a great time playing it again. Um, such a great system with just the the ongoing card river of things that you draft and you know, it's so cool the different things you can do in this game with like

changing your government to kind of change your action distribution or what kind of like buildings do I go into and just managing your food production but also your resource production and oh, I want to like go after a wonder too and um just very very solid game. I know you have the expansion but have not played with it.

I would love

because currently in the base game you basically use like all the cards every game and just having a little bit of like variety and like what leaders and

I think I want to say you shuffle in like these kind of uh proxy leader cards into the deck and then when you get one when you draw it you draw from the that's kind of how they manage the the distribution of it which is cool. Yeah, that's a good way to do it and technically leaves the door open to more expansions if I wanted to, right?

U but yeah, great game. Um

yeah, I'm glad I glad I have it again. Glad it can be back in my rankings. Um we'll see where it moves. I mean, I've only played it once in the last 10 years.

And that's high, but it was enough for me to put it in my top 20.

Speaking of a game that I am very high on, Ryan, we've got a new game coming in at number 19. And this is a game I also don't own. I think just my whole 20 through 11 I might

but is a game that I will absolutely own because oh my goodness did this just uh resonate me with me on such a deep level. Um my number 19 goes to Planet Unknown. Um, Ryan, I honestly cannot think of a game this, you know, recently that gave me such a positive first impression when playing it. Um, one, the presentation just fantastic. I mean, you know, obviously the lazy Susan, you know, looks great from a visual perspective, but incredibly functional, right? Like that is critical to how the game how the game is played. And it just from top to bottom the elements of this game are things that I love. So it's like okay the simultaneous play fantastic. You get done with a game of planet unknown and you feel like you have done so much when gosh we can play a game with a lot of people in an hour

about an hour. So you feel like you have done so much then and you know we've played with some of the unique maps like the maps feel very interesting and

and especially the corporations feel really really different

right so there's some like huge variability that comes with the the map and and kind of what you're doing there the polyomino like I love the tension of okay how the lazy hus is is turned you've got you know two options Um, and obviously most of the turns, you know, you're not deciding what your two options are, but what can I how can I make the best, you know, use of those two options. Um, and then you're also going up on these tracks based off what you're playing and you're unlocking stuff. And uh, and then you also have the the I like the shared objective that you have with the person uh, just the person next to you. So something with the person on your left that you're fighting over, something with the person on your right. Um, it just felt like this is the kind of pinnacle experience for me of a Polyomino style. You know, a little bit bigger, you know, there's lighter ones, but if I'm wanting like a little bit uh bigger one where uh I am, you know, on this big map and and unlocking stuff, this was so much fun. Uh it it it immediately I played it three times this year. It is on a must own for me. Um because it's really also not that hard to teach, you know, like it's not that complex of a game. Um despite, you know, the the table presence is, you know, can seem a little large. Um but it can go up to six players.

Oh my gosh, Ryan. With simultaneous See, that's the thing. Normally a game up to six players that's heavier, you're like, "Oh boy." But we would never actually play with six, right? Cuz

there's been some great new ones in recent years.

Like we talked about Heat as well as one that plays excellently at six,

right? So this um was just absolutely fantastic. And for I mean a game like that to immediately go up into the top 20 I think speaks volumes. So

yeah, I definitely have a there's a spectrum of how confident I am that Daniel's going to like a new game that I introduce. This one I was like if like this feels like just a guarantee. So

yeah, it was great.

Nice. My number 19 has been uh in the collection for about four years now and it is slowly kind of been moving down in my 11 through 20 range. Um, it's in the category like of weight complexity of some of my favorite favorite games, but it's just like a tear down,

but it's still unique enough and I enjoy it enough that it holds its place in the collection. And this is Underwater Cities.

Nice. um underwater cities. It's just got really solid core mechanisms with this kind of worker placement, but you've got these cards in your hand, and you always want to make sure you're going to take an action that matches the color of a card that you can play cuz then you get to do both. And then that's feeding into building out your own personal board with tunnels and cities and kind of optimizing your your production engine and everything. Um and just the the feel of it when playing. I think this is one on on the kind of heavier end of the spectrum of these types of resource management games. I think it appeals more to people that like kind of to be more tactical. Um because every turn you're playing one of your three cards and then you're drawing another card. So like your three options are constantly being refreshed. Um, and it really does change things depending on what colors they are, on what things they give you, you know, because suddenly you draw a card and it's like, "Oh, it would be amazing if I could get this played this round, but that means I need to go do a yellow action. I wasn't really planning on doing yellow action.

Could I make that work with my round?" Um, so I love that. I mean, it just is a very satisfying um kind of just main gameplay loop there. um and especially with like a lot of the uh expansion stuff that we got with the uh uh new discoveries expansion,

right?

Um is nice with kind of more cards. You start to get some of this like starting the game with a unique specialist instead of just the specialist that um and kind of a maybe unique starting resources

boards

and the recess triple layer boards and the boards now have the side that are like highly asymmetrical. So, you're getting a board that has different bonuses and different things.

It's like getting Oreos, right? You always the triple stuffed Oreos, you know? That's what it's like. That's what it's like getting the triple airs. So,

yeah. Oreo, if you'd like to sponsor Rules in the Family. I will eat Oreos on camera. Part of

part of our uh sticktick, you know. Just reach out to me in the Disco or whoever whoever owns Oreo these days.

Uh yeah, Auto City is great stuff. I'll always remember it as the game that I bought right uh when COVID hit. So, I didn't get to play it in person for the longest time. Um,

yeah,

but glad that it's uh stuck around.

Very nice, Ryan. Uh, my number 18 is kind of surprising because you would think, having played this game. I also don't own this game. I was going to ask. I also don't own this game. Gosh dang it. Um, you would think if you've played a game this many times that you would finally get tired of it, right? that it would start to drop or at least that it would stay the same. But no, no, no, Ryan. My number 18, Race for the Galaxy continues to rise in my rankings.

313 plays over here for me of Race for the Galaxy and got four plays of it this last year. Ryan Owens, our original copy. I mean, that box has wear on it. It

those cards have I have to say those cards have held up. They've got them. I know they are. They're it's honestly amazing. Um, but we got to play I mean obviously you know four games of it this last year. The you know I think in a you know earlier we mentioned uh you know that moment of us uh when we were at our family Airbnb and we're sitting side by side watching a basketball game and uh and got Race of the Galaxy. Ryan, this system is so just polished and just, you know, for us, I mean, we're at the point now where we can play a game in 10 to 15 minutes, you know, like we are just flying

and 313 plays later and it is still just as fun every single time to get that, you know, initial starting world and then a hand of cards and the very simple, you know, thing of uh your h your cards are both what you're trying to play and your resources. ources and then every, you know, every turn both players are selecting an action. You get to do the primary action, but it also triggers the secondary of of your opponent. And so, uh, it just creates a puzzle that is fun every single time. Every single time you're trying to figure out how to, you know, what are the best cards to to play in your hand? How are you going to create, you know, which route are you going to go? Are you going to go military? Are you going to go production for victory points? um paying attention to the pace your opponent's going at. Like if I notice race

Yeah. It legitimately is a a game that you feel the race elements cuz you know if your opponent's going military and pushing, you got to pivot, right? Because if your if your plan is to build up this long-term victory point production thing, uh that's that's not going to work. And so I mean I I just don't know what more you can say when we've played it this many times and it's in my top It's like

my goodness, if you can have, you know, obviously it can it can I've we've played it 313 times. I don't even know if I've played it like more than five times with more than two players. Um, you know what I mean? So, it can technically go up to six.

I mean, with the expansions, I think it's like six would be would be bonkers.

Yeah. I don't even I don't even know how that how that would work. um maybe it'd be cool. But if you have someone else who you you know enjoy um that kind of just tableau um you know trying to figure out the best way to play the hands in your card in a game that has truly like infinite replayability. Um this one has it's amazing to think how long I mean this was one of the first early on games that we got.

Yeah. And you think about how many games come into the collection and yet still this one holds strong. So there you go. Number 18,

the classic.

Yeah, we love engine building and Race for the Galaxy Versus is like the ultimate engine building snack.

It's like what in 10 to in 15 minutes can you get kind of as satisfying?

So true.

Nice. My number 18 is not playable in 15 minutes. It's usually more like the first round in 15 minutes.

It's like four to five hours. This is a long one. It's an epic one. Uh it's the ultimate game in a theme that I really enjoy the intellectual property of. This is War of the Ring Second Edition. It's the ultimate Lord of the Rings board game. If you're wanting a game that truly embodies the Lord of the Rings trilogy, the actual like real narrative story of it, no game does it better than this. You've got the massive board that's the entire map of Middle Earth. And you know, the game is basically staged with the fellowship having been formed in Rivendell. on one side's going to be trying to lead the free peoples in the fellowship while the other side is uh opposing them with Sauron and all of his armies. And just I don't think there's any game in my collection more than this one that makes me not care as much about winning as much as just like having a close game that ends up telling a good story.

Yeah, the story. Um, and it's it's a great game that like great strategic game. There's a lot of depth here um and and interesting decisions and you're obviously trying to win,

but it is such a fun layer on top of it, especially if you're very familiar with the original story to get to watch this alternate version of the story unfold where different things happen with the characters. The fellowship breaks up in different ways, different characters end up in different parts of Middle Earth than they ever would have been in the real story. Um,

and if this game can manage to stay close and come down to the end where Frodo and Sam are trying to get, you know, the ring into Mount Doom and uh there's meanwhile like oftent times these stronghold battles going where you might be hunkered down in Helms's Deep or something just it's it does such a good job of funneling the experience towards like the best parts of the actual story. um the best elements of it. Um it's a lot of rules. It's, you know, and you got to have one other person that wants to like you just take care of all that.

Um but there really is nothing like it. I got to actually play in the last year and I played with the uh first expansion for the first time which adds some more more complexity. It adds some more characters. You know, there's now something that like, you know, Gladriel can actually come out onto the map in Laurian and now you have this extra die that has some special stuff. Daniel doesn't know his Lord of the Rings very well.

Uh, so he doesn't know any of these characters, but

that's Froto's father, right? for again is if it's like if you're gonna do all this big experience adding in even more of like the world and what can come out like they're now the big balro could actually like come out onto the map and could even come out of Moria which is you know it's just like

if you want like Lord of the Rings fanfiction like this this game does it like none other. Um,

yeah.

Got there's also no other game I don't think that I intentionally put a soundtrack on in the background as we're playing it cuz you got to throw on you got to throw on the full Lord of the Rings movie soundtrack and

um it's good stuff. So, I'm fortunate that like the the friend that I played with it this year is one that's local, would be interested in playing again. So, I I have a path to

getting this one played. Um because before that it was you that I had played with. has another friend that is no longer local. Um, but yeah, it's it's it's really excellent if you love Lord of the Rings and have a tolerance for a very big, you know, complex game. There's there's really nothing like Lord of the Rings.

Well, and Ryan, what's the name of that little character in Lord of the Rings? You know, that uh

Golem.

Yeah. Yeah. You forgot to mention that you dress up like him every time you play.

Every time. Yeah.

So, be sure to role play.

Yeah.

Uh, very nice, Ryan. Uh, speaking of games that uh I do not play because of the uh theme and intellectual property, my number 17 goes to Lorenzo El Magnifica.

You know, it's not the worst theme, I guess, but um you know, this game uh was a game that when you introduced it to me, um I looked at it and said, "This is ugly." And

I had to put on my persuasive hat to be you really need to try this.

Ryan had to work Ryan had to work hard on this one. Um, but one play of it and there isn't a game that I think is on my list where I just feel like there's opportunities for borderline broken combos as much as this one. like you just uh you have this entire board of you know taking cards and whatnot and there's so many opportunities for oh my gosh if I get this with that card and I can create this little engine that can you know produce this thing and and whatnot and the potential is you know vast and so you uh it it just creates this such a rewarding system to be playing within because you have so many opportunities to uh do clever things all that around a really fun you know there's not a lot of games that do this where you know you the only other one honestly that I can think of is um uh Grand Austria Hotel a little bit has this but where you roll the dice and then it's like determining a shared thing for everyone at the table and I love that because it's it's like this shared moment of either yes you know sixes and fives we we can do so much or everyone being like, "Oh my gosh,

what am I how am I going to manage, you know, the fact that we rolled uh, you know, low numbers on this?" Um, this is a game that delivers far beyond what it looks like, you know, on just from a like visual perspective. Um,

I will say the the overall presentation of this game has grown on me quite a bit. It's got some of the endearing kind of old school Euro game artwork that honestly something like a Gricola has a little bit with like the cards and stuff. It's almost this like kind of I think it's actually well done. I mean the the cover I think didn't do them any favors with like

it's not it's not bad

catching them in the storm.

Right. Right. Right. Yeah.

But uh yeah, this one just uh is a Euro game that uh yeah delivers that potential of combinations and it is so much fun. We even have the, you know, we have the expansion that Houses of Renaissance and that just

arguably one of the best expansion.

I mean, it just it just levels it up, you know, and makes the potential of what you can do even greater. So,

there you go, Ryan. Number 17.

Yeah, you mentioned the share dice rolling and share, you know, sharing in that. Uh, the last time I played, one of the players had a leader that made it that they're they always got to treat the three dice as fives. So now we're all just we're like please don't roll low or like they're going to have such an advantage in that round.

Gosh, that's amazing.

It wasn't an easy one to get out, but it's an example in that game of there's just a lot of crazy abilities.

Yeah.

Uh my number 17 is actually one that I consider in a very similar category to Lorenzo Magnico. Dang it was not nearly as high on this one as I am, but it has uh well it's slipped a little bit. It's been staying up in my rankings. This is Tua or Troyus, however you want to pronounce it. Um, so this is a fascinating um or tro. Yes,

tro. Yes. the core dice mechanism in this game of you're basically getting to roll a dice pool that's based on where you have influence and then you're putting those dice in your district but then we are drafting the usage of groups of dice and you can use other people's dice as long as you pay them

is in and of itself a great dynamic interactive you know it kind of has this like worker placement element but like you know people can take your dice and so you really got to be clever about how you do things. There's some really nice dice mitigation things of like if I roll low, I could be spending um I think it's influence in the game to like either roll or flip my dice. And so there's some very cool things going on in that system. But then the things you're actually trying to do in the game, this is a game where you are kind of trying to look for that broken combo that can lead you to a lot of points. There's going to be these activity cards that are coming out revealed as the game goes on. you slowly see kind of what options you have,

but ultimately,

you know, you're throwing a group of dice through one of these activity cards to potentially trigger it multiple times. And if you can get a couple activity cards to work well together, like, oh, this one lets me store charges that later I can spend to boost my dice so that when I throw it into this other one, I'm going to activate it five times and get a whole pile of points. Like oftentimes your final score in this game, you'll have like half of it came from like one

Yeah.

strategy that you pulled off and maybe did like two times. Um, and I find it so satisfying. I find it so interesting and dynamic the interactions between the players. And the fact that those activity cards are different every game and there's so many of them. It just just talking about it makes me want to play Tuah. I did not get it played in the last year. I think I got it played either like just before. Yeah. Danielle might never play this one again cuz there's so many other games we might pick, which is a shame because I think it's better than he gives it credit for. But um yeah, it it really is one of my favorites, especially in this like closer to 90inut

strategy game weight. Love me some Tua.

Don't worry, it it made my top 400. Um, my number 16 uh is a game that takes so much of what we love about uh thematic uh games. Uh I think about how much we love the Lovecraft universe and that kind of theme and setting and it takes that and distills it down into an experience that feels incredibly refined. And this goes to Cthulhu, Death May Die. Um, this I honestly I think it's really amazed me because you look at the presentation of the game and it feels like a game that often times those type of games are very I don't know obtuse, very sprawling. There's a lot of rules, you know, to keep track of. That is not this game. This feels so streamlined in how they designed it. And I've I've honestly been so impressed like the um the actions that you're doing are very simple and clean and it uh so the learning of the game isn't that hard. You know, going throughout the you know throughout the map like it throws you into the action right away.

There is no wasted time in this game. It just you feel like you are in the excitement right at the start and the game just moves at this fast pace. Obviously, you know, different some of the other, you know, kind of Lovecraft games we have. this is a very like tactical dudes on a on a you know map um type of game. You add that with the variability it has around the combination of a of a like episode I think is what it's called and a you know

Elder one

Elder one and that you can mix and match any of them like that is variability heaven right there. Um, you know, because I think that's the hard thing with games that do just like a scenario is it's like, okay, well, will it be fun to to play that again, which I have played the exact combination before, and guess what? It's still fun. It doesn't lean so heavily. It's not like a

it's not like a really heavily a story

game. I mean, it's it's got some it's got some theme, but really you could play the same scenario, you know, over and over and be be fine. But the fact that you can do any combination and that each combination brings its own monsters and and unique things like the the you know episode that you're playing completely changes that item deck that you know you can search when you're you know by yourself in a room and like and it's thematic to to what's happening. So the theme ties in really really well but also has a ton of ton of variability in it. Last thing about it, like the whole system that as a character you get more and more powerful as you go insane and that's actually how you upgrade your person is when you hit those, you know, check marks. And so there's some character customization, but it is a game where you actually want to push yourself right to that threshold where you don't die, but you're also the most powerful right before you die. And so you actually might lose because you didn't, you know,

push yourself enough.

Flew too close to the sun there.

Yeah. So it uh it's uh this is one there's so much content, but honestly I'm like I mean I might get you know season two next, but I'm like holy cow. Like at some point it's like you don't I don't even need more.

Yo, some of these guys have so much content. people, you you need to sit down a little bit and do some math of like

how often am I getting this to the table?

Like I like I you know, if you're playing every week, that's one thing. But so this is a great and I'm just so impressed by the design. It's it really really impressed me. So that's my number 16.

Yeah, that that decision to make it that like when you don't have anything in your space, you get one of the location

Yeah.

items or whatever. It's a great way to make it that there's like no dead turns. It's like there's no turns where it's like and I do this and then I guess I don't do anything. Like it's like oh well you literally get to have an an item because of that. Totally. It's a clever decision.

My number 16 is one of my biggest risers on my list. It went up 10 spots. I think this one is going to shock you a little bit.

Oh boy.

It is one that you haven't played and is probably pretty unlikely you will ever play. It is primarily a solo game. though there is a new expansion coming out that is going to make it more able to do like a two multiplayer runs of it. But this is Paperback Adventures.

Wow.

And I quite surprising.

Played this twice in the last year and I feel like every time I play it, it's just been like rising in my estimation of it.

I mean, the way to advertise this game is it's basically Slay the Spire. Like as far as right

as far as like rogue like you're doing a run. It's so it's unabashedly inspired by Slay the Spire. It's got the DNA all over it combined with

the game paperback which is a wordb building deck building game which is where we're going to lose Daniel. I like paperback and I like kind of that word element.

Um and that's going to be what keeps a lot of people from enjoying this game. That said, even if you're not huge on the whole word thing, I wouldn't look past this one cuz it is such a satisfying, you know, rogike go through a run and upgrade and every run is completely unique and you're using a character that has a different card pool and different things like it just this game is so replayable and how everything's going to go go each time. But the core mechanism of making, you know, you're making a word to do your like attack each turn from your hand is like it's not like some word games where it's really going to reward people who know the most words and like like can come up with some crazy stuff. you're usually working with some pretty simple words like not a lot of letters

and it's more about what is the word that like puts the right card on top because it's got this really interesting thing that once you make the word you either spllay it left or right. So that's either going to make the top or the bottom card the top of your play

and whatever is the top triggers its ability. So, there's so many times in this game where you get your hand and you're looking at what the the enemy ability is because just like slight spire, you can see what their intentions are of what they're going to do and you go, "Okay, like I need to get this much attack this turn or something. Oh, if I can get this F to be the first letter, I can trigger this ability that actually will really help right now or will give me the energy I need so that I can use this item next turn or something." And so now it's kind of constrained to the puzzle of like, okay, well, I definitely want a word that has F at the beginning, but then like, you know, oh, I really want to make sure this is in it because it's got two swords on the the right side of it. So, I got to make sure it has this letter somewhere.

And, you know, I find that process to be very satisfying. It's very funny sometimes when you come to the answer and it's some like silly little word and you're like, yes, like that was so perfect for what I needed to do here. I I had one uh game that I was very satisfied that my winning blow on the boss was the word squish, which that's a hard that's a hard word to pull off cuz like to even have a Q in my deck and the fact that I had so that that was like an ultimate ending there. But

yeah, this one keeps going up for me. It's one of my favorite games uh to play solo. I have actually backed the upcoming content for it that's going to add a new character. Like I mentioned, it adds this new expansion that does let you potentially play two-handed. I don't know that many people in my life that uh that are this game would appeal to them.

Our mother,

but would love to. Yeah, maybe I'll get my mom into it.

Or our older brother is one that does enjoy this style of game, right?

Uh but yeah, all the way up to my 16.

Yeah. Holy cow, that's that's unruly. Um my number 15, Ryan, uh rose seven spots. Um, we got a play of this like a month ago at our uh, family reunion and this system is delivers for us I think the pinnacle racing experience. This goes to heat pedal to the metal.

Every time I play this game, I am just amazed again a little bit kind of like Cthulhu Death May Die. The mechanics are so streamlined. It is just it you know you know we used to play Formula D back in the day which you know is fun but I talk about a game that uh can feel like it drags on a little bit like this one just feels like it moves. You feel that racing feel and the whole managing of your car is such a well-designed system around the, you know, managing of heat and the fact in the game that, you know, it really is when am I going to push it? You know, when am I going to make those moves and take heat because it gets me that, you know, that thing. And I I guess I'm amazed in this game because, you know, you're not rolling dice. There's not randomness around that. Obviously, you know, there's randomness around what cards you draw, but I'm always amazed at how often someone makes a move and and we're just like, "Wow, that was a that was just a big move or that was

Yeah. Especially with someone who's like seems out of it." We've seen many times where someone who seems like they're out down for the

can make a big move it. Yeah.

And that's critical in a racing game, right? because you could so easily see how something like this could fall into like someone gets ahead and is just and then everyone else is like, well, okay, it's just there's there's no hope at this point. Um, it just feels like this game really does an awesome job with that. You add on top of that playing with like the, you know, garage module of now you get these like unique special cards that you draft for your car. We haven't even done the tournament yet, but I would love to I honestly want to do that in this next year of where you do three races. I think. And you uh you know, you can upgrade in between each each one. Um you have even a little bit more of this content than I do, some of the different maps, but man, Heat Pedal to the Metal uh is in my opinion the definitive racing game and is one that is accessible. It's one that uh I think just draws people in and ultimately it gives you the racing feel. And that's what I want in a game uh is I have this racing feel around such a welldesigned uh system that I yeah I'm not going to get tired of of playing that. So number 15.

Wow.

Heat pedal to the metal.

It's fantastic. It's a great game.

Speaking of great games, it's our generic segue.

That's when we don't know what to say. We just say

it works for every everyone on this list.

Uh this is a new entry to the list jumping all the way up to 15. My stock is high on this game right now and I have no idea where it's going to hold in the future. But this is a snapshot of right now and right now I am loving this game and I've played it eight times. It isn't like I just had a couple really really strong experience. I mean it is just every one of those has delivered. This is innovation.

I was wondering where this one was going to land for you.

Yeah, I've been speaking pretty highly of it. And I'm just I'm so fascinated by the system, you know, this this race. It's got a little bit of that kind of Race for the Galaxy cuz I've played it only two player and kind of, you know, you're jocking. I mean, it really is a race in this game of like usually you're racing for these six achievements. But if it isn't six achievements, you are racing to try to finish the whole game so you can finish with the most points before your other your opponent gets the six achievements.

But just every card in this game is unique. Every card has weird thematic dogma effects that are these things that you can activate them that might wildly change the state of the game. And so it's every every card feels like there's a situation where you could make it be useful. Like every card has a way that you could like base a strategy off that card if you had the right thing. And that's just so fascinating to every game be playing it and trying to find the way to to navigate it and the way the game works with the so many of the effects when you trigger them. You need to have if you don't want your opponent to also trigger the effect, you need to have more of that icon in front of you. And so there's kind of this you're

you're engine building what your top cards and what effects you have, but there's also very much this like

um your strength in all the different suits and like some of the effects in the game that let you play cards or things so that more of your icons are showing are very interesting because they give you more strength to be able to do these things or protect yourself against things that your opponent is doing, right?

Um I think it is a masterful design. I mean, this game is not new. It came out in like 2010 or something. Um, but I think it is it is a brilliant piece of design that's just executed really well. Um, there's going to be some people that really don't like this game. It's going to be a little too volatile for them. Though, I would hesitate to say random or chaotic only because this game there is plenty of room for skill. And there that is evidenced by you know sometimes if you want to know if a game is is skill-based or luck based go look if there's an online

you know community for it and if there's a community that consistently you know the best players are winning or whatever it's like okay there might be more here and that is definitely the case with innovation. I am so happy just continue playing what I have with the base game, but I do have the ultimate edition and I know they've made the expansion content easier to pull in. So, I'm very intrigued to try some of it. But

big big uh debut for Innovation on my list at number 15.

Wow.

I've got a new game coming in at number 14. Although new very questionable cuz it's not really new,

but it's kind of new. Um, this is a game that if you would have asked Daniel, I think even of a year ago that this game would be your number 14 on your list. He would have said, "You're crazy." But, you know, crazy things can happen in a year. And I think the amount of content I have for this game speaks to that. My number 14 goes to Arkham Horror, the card game. Um, I I mean, if you've watched any of our videos in the last like, you know, year, you've seen my uh you've seen my entry and now u uh all in on Arkham Horror the card game. I just played a game last night in the Dunwitch Legacy campaign right now. This game gives me everything I could want in a living card game. Um, again, I said earlier with Cthulhu Death May, I I just love this theme. It just I don't know what it is. really good setting for a cooperative game.

It is. It's just it's it's intriguing. It's uh it's got a little bit of the mystery feel. I don't know. Just even the time period. It's just it's great. But then this game uh is so much fun around obviously like the unique characters and you know, right now I'm I haven't even gotten into like building my own deck. I just use the base deck that they recommend kind of for a character. But even as you play, you're you're able to upgrade cards and and stuff like that. So, it's super fun how to play a deck because you know what's in your deck. And so, you know, you know the potential, but obviously, you know, you start off only drawing, you know, you know, five cards. And so, trying to figure out how to play your deck the best way possible, knowing what's later on in your deck, but also, you know, managing what you what you have right now. But then the game obviously you're playing through campaigns and and the game gives such a thematic feel and it's it's you know the one we were playing last night like it it's just like oh my gosh I I can visualize this all happening and um and the thing I actually was noticing last night that struck me the system when you know it like the rounds fly. I mean you like I'm playing a two-player game and and you know so I take my three actions, you take your three actions. Um, we then, you know, just go into upkeep, draw a card, get a resource, you know, the enemies resolve, and then and then do a mythos and boom. Like, it just felt like it's it moves really fast. Um, and yet

now that especially now that I'm entering into the Dunwitch legacy, starting to see them really play with the system more and do some really creative things. And I don't know, to have someone that you're able to share that experience with and be uh be playing through is is so much fun. So, I am thrilled. I have so much content for this. But I'm gonna play it all. Like I, you know, I've got I've got someone who, you know, enjoys that. So, I am thrilled uh thrilled with how this one has landed and it's really it's giving me everything I could want um in in a living card game experience. So, now I just get to

experience it all. So,

experience it.

That's my number.

Yeah, I mean, I'm calling it now. I bet this is even higher next year. Um,

keep playing it. Yeah,

you better keep playing it.

I don't know, Ryan. We'll see.

Yeah. Well, I will uh gladly take the Lovecrafty segue into my next entry. We have a number of Lovecraft games on this. This is one that we has been one of our favorites for a long time. It is moved down a little bit for me. It's been kind of trickling

down my list. This is Eldrich Horror.

That's too low, Ryan. And Dango, I knew he was going to say it's too low. It actually fell out of the top 10 last year. Um, dropped another three spots.

I love Elder Tour, and some of my favorite gaming moments have been provided by this game. It is a game that is very wildly swingy in the type of experience you might get. And I'd be lying if I said there weren't times in the past couple years that I've been two and a half hours into a an Eldrich game and had a feeling of like, ah, it would have been nice to maybe get another game. Victory is better, right?

I know. But you can get and but it, you know, it affects the ranking a little bit and my desire to get it to the table. It's a long game,

but I still have it ranked ahead of every great game I've already talked about on this list. It still

is fantastic. The cooperative experience, um,

it's such a like

few games give the same feel of just like experiencing something together as a group as Eldrich does. And like it's got the whole encounters that you're doing that you kind of are building up these little stories of what are happening to different people. Um but just variety through the roof with the different ancient ones and all the different

cards. And that's that's a lot of the appeal of it. I mean you think of like a game that's like a uh

like an exploration game. And the appeal of an exploration game is like what might we find? This is kind of that feel of like there's just so much content and it's this sandbox that it's like what's going to happen this time? what and even when things are horrible

they can be which they often are so you know things can happen that that open new and on the other side things can be going really well and quickly fall apart um

and so it's fun to play in this system uh we've had so many so many good games of it I mean I've played it 45 times this is definitely coming from a place of experience three in the last year I there's no other big game I don't think like more than two-hour game that has been as consistently played over the last decade.

Ryan has to argue against it now.

Yeah, I've it is a definitely a favorite in my group that gets requested often. Uh and it lands this year. My number 14.

Nice. Maya number 13 is a game that you owned for still own. You have a lot of content for this game and is one of the most unique games out there and it truly experienced nothing like it. So much so that I actually now currently own it. Have yet to play my copy. This goes to Millennium Blades.

This I mean you talk about the the meta of you are playing a person in a collectible uh you know

playing a collectible card

playing a collectible card game. So you are alternating between the buying packs and trading and all of that phase and then you build your deck and you get to play it. And you know, like it just so draws upon like the nostalgia of like I can think back to us like playing, you know, Yu-Gi-Oh and us like crafting decks and all that. And it's like it gives you that experience along with buying and selling, which you mean Ryan, you know me, I just talk about loves to wheel and deal

wheel and deal. This game is wheeling and dealing uh at, you know, it it at its heart. Um, but again, a game that it's like it's not going to get played that often. It's hard to find the right group for this. Although, if you find the right person, this is like one of those that could be like one of their favorite games of all time.

Um, but it delivers a wildly unique experience. There just isn't even a game that comes close to what Millennium Blades delivers that you literally have money that you're paying and and building and collecting and you do it, you know, over a series of rounds. Um, this one uh has stayed steady despite me not playing it. And that's because

you finally own it. It

I do finally own it. I will get a play of it. Um, but it the memories of it, it just draws me right back into uh what makes it makes it so fun. So, I will get to the table again. Maybe this next year. We'll see. We'll see. Okay. Number 13.

It's always sad if if I'm the only one that owns a game that you have much higher in your rankings than I love Blades, but you you did have it significantly higher than

What the heck, Ryan? Come on.

Yeah. What the heck?

Cool. My number 13 uh is actually another solo game. I don't know what's happened in recent years I've gotten into it. Just I don't do a lot of solo gaming, but I've enjoyed doing a little bit

annoying you.

You know, it's it's just a realization that like especially when you're in a seasonal love of life where you maybe don't get as many game days with people,

having the option to scratch the itch just on an evening of like

it's easy to schedule with yourself. It's easy to schedule with myself and I have scheduled many, many dates with myself with Final Girl.

Yeah.

Um, we've had a lot of content on the channel talking about Fire Final Girl. Let's see. I'm up to 72 plays. I've got 22 in the last year, which was largely because the series 3 content arrived.

You have another playthrough video coming out in a little bit.

Yeah, we've got a we've got a playthrough one on the channel. I've got rankings for the sets and the series and stuff. So, uh, if you're into Final Girl, there's in fact that might be how you found their channel, right? Uh, if you're into Final Girl, but, uh, this is a game and actually it lands very close to Eldrich for a reason. They're in a similar space of the type of experience they provide of this kind of horror themed what's going to happen this time. It's really hard, but it's very exciting to see how it might play out. Mhm.

Um I think where Eldrich it's like it's really long

and you might get a bad game. Final girl is pretty short and you might get a bad game and so it does make

it does make the terrible game not sting as much when you've only been playing for 20 minutes.

That's true.

Um but I have had so many memorable moments with this system. I've been amazed at how many times a game comes down to the end and a clever series. There's so many opportunities to feel like you're doing clever things. It's the similar similar to Eldrich where you're playing a lot with probabilities. There's a lot of make my decision but roll to resolve which is going to drive a lot of people crazy.

But that so drives the narrative of the game and the theme of what's happening and how your plans don't often go how you planned them in these types of settings. I think it's a brilliant system. I think it's brilliant how you can mix and match all the locations and killers. I am getting to the point where like I've got a lot of content for it. I actually sold a few of the sets, you know, I think a lot of people would have a visceral reaction at breaking up the series, you know,

drop your emoji down below if you're selling off individual sets, but I just realized like, you know, if there's ones that aren't I'm not enjoying as more like even playing 20 times a year, I'm like only going to be playing with, you know, some of the content like one time of Um, so it'll be interesting to see. I know they're releasing more and more content for this, and I definitely will be intrigued to try new sets. Maybe I get some new sets, and maybe some of my bottom sets keep leaving the collection as I kind of uh tune it to what I enjoy the most. But I've just had so many good experiences with this one. Uh, and I believe it is my, according to my rankings, my top solo board game.

Yeah, this is the game that if I liked solo board games, I would love this game. You know, I can just totally tell. So, makes sense. My number 12 uh tech dropped six spots. Um didn't get a play of it this last year, but um really really love this uh this Euro game. Uh this goes to Great Western Trail. Um this one I you know I love so much of the whole kind of arc of the game, you know, cuz it's it's this really interesting. You're going in a loop, right? and you're you're running this you're going to Kansas City and then you come back at the start again and yet you know you're building up this engine you know as you go both from a like deck building perspective of you're trying to make your cattle better so that when you get to Kansas City you've got you know the best thing to to you know present there and what's fun is that obviously it's there's random randomization with the what cards you draw right to you might not get your best cattle right there but you can stop along the way to like optimize things to spend this card to get this thing and then that lets you draw new cards cuz you're really trying to get the best thing by the end. I think that's the the thing I love about this game is uh there's I love tactical games and this is one where you just like okay I can stop here and I can you know do this and get this money and then okay and then I'll stop here and do this. It's always limiting your choices to like the next three.

Yeah. Next three spaces. Where are you going to go? Unless you obviously increase your speed and stuff, which is a big thing in the game. Like it's another one a little bit kind of like Race for the Galaxy. The pace of the game matters in a big way. If your opponent is able to rush Kansas City more, you know, without destroying themselves, you know, cuz if you if you ever can't go to a, you know, you fill up spots that you ship to. And so if you or you stop at and so if you ever can't go there, your hand's not good enough to go to the next one, you have to take like a negative going to Kansas City. So there is a little bit of risk of how fast do I go. Um but inevitably the faster you're going, the more you're, you know, getting getting to that spot. So really just I think it delivers such a you unique feel in that you know Eurogame kind of heavier weight of I just don't have a game that has that kind of uh cycle happening and yet it is such a fun one for me um to to do. And so this is one that has uh dropped a little bit probably just because it didn't get played but um I really enjoy the expansion for it as well. Uh that adds I think that just adds a lot more interest on the going to Kansas City part because now it's like even the cities you go to can you know can branch off. So this one's been a ton of fun. Uh and it's my number 12.

Nice. Yeah, that core the core system of like this rondelle that you're controlling your pace on and every time you get to the end you get to you know based on the quality of your hand. So, it just is a nice tension of how slow do you go to improve versus how many times do you deliver,

right?

It's good stuff.

My number 12 is a game that uh I have played six times it looks like and that's like six times over like five years. It's just been it hasn't been getting to the table a lot, but every time I play it um I have a great time in this. Last time I was especially reminded of just kind of how strong this game is is in the category of kind of like a more interactive um Euro game. This is brass Birmingham and

wow

brass. It's such a solid system. I mean the system itself of kind of this network building and the way that you're using resources and delivering goods and things and you know putting out tiles that you're ultimately trying to flip. that's like the main way you score in the game. And it's either a tile as a resource tile that is going to flip once all the resources are used by you or anybody else, which is a big piece in the game, or it's one of the goods tiles that are flipped when you're able to deliver that good through the network to one of the destinations, which can include

other people's links in the network. And so it's just a game that um it's so interesting to see how it unfolds, see what opportunities present themselves because of how your opponents are building around you and how the shared network is growing. But then it's all driven by these cards that most of the actions you just discard a card and it doesn't matter what it is. But if you're ever doing a build action, the card is going to determine either the type of industry you can build or the location that you can build at. And so that is very much guiding kind of where you might be able to play on the map. And I just love that it's added that tactical element into it that every game is going to play out completely differently and you always have to kind of work with the cards. Gives it this endlessly rep. It breaks down any kind of like optimal play uh in the game which is great uh for my taste.

Um so really really solid. maybe lacks some of the exciting variability that some of like my favorite games have. Um, you know, it's not one that at the beginning of the game you're getting your variable player power, a bunch of other stuff,

but you get into playing this game and it's the core gameplay is just so strong and so satisfying that it's enough that it is all the way up at my number 12.

Yeah, very nice, Ryan. I'm going to be bringing us home here with a game you mentioned on this uh on this list um and is one that uh my wife and I now have played several times together. It is quite long but delivers on just the progression and arc uh that is so satisfying. This goes to Through the Ages, a new story of civilization. And you were saying this earlier, Ryan, but the game, you know, it's funny. the game kind of you always feel like you're a little bit beh like not doing enough, you know, like there's always a problem in your in your engine like either uh my resource production isn't enough or uh the food isn't good enough or uh my government is limiting me, you know, like there's always so you're always solving pro, you know, solving problems it feels like and and yet the game with that river of cards um it that's so satisfying just how with this with these options of cards and obviously takes more actions to take ones further down can I best uh be upgrading optimizing and you feel over the course of a you know 4hour game that you did so much ironically as long as the game is I sometimes feel like it's not long enough like there's times where I get to the end of the game and I like almost wish I could have done even more in that like last stage when you're getting movie theaters and and like to go from a right where you go from a game where you're

starting out with like Moses and you know these like you know super old uh ancient people and you're ending with the internet and rockets and like you know it it's just so fun like to to experience that arc. Um, and it is such a well-designed Euro system that I think gives us this challenge that we love in other, you know, kind of Euro games of how am I going to solve it? It's hard, right? It's a it's this isn't like just a ah you can kind of do what like you are faced with hard problems of how do you keep this engine going and how do you uh make the best with what you have but

and how do you not uh ignore military and get absolutely destroyed by

Yes. a little bit easier in the new edition. A little bit easier, but uh no, it's very true. Especially the head-to-head, like you are very much paying attention to what your opponent's doing, especially when it comes to to military. So, we've had a we've had a ton of fun with this and need to try the expansion, but

yeah,

it's my number 11.

Nice. Just missed top 10,

as did my 11. Imagine that.

No way.

Yeah. Can you believe it?

I can't. This uh is actually a game that has been in my top 10 since it entered my collection. So I don't know how many years that is. It's definitely the you know three four years that we've been doing the whisp here.

Uh it was all it was down to nine last year. So it kind of has been dropping. Here's the thing. I haven't played it in 2 years which is a tragedy and I have to get it played. And a game has to start slipping if you're not getting it to the table.

It's a rule. Uh, it's a rule. In fact, I ranked it higher and then I applied the applied the math calculation. Yeah.

Yes.

Uh, to drop to 11. This is a feast for Odin.

I love A Feast for Odin. Um, it's got a core that is very much the Uve Rosenberg farming simulator worker placement kind of foundation, but then it goes in a wild different direction than a lot of his other games with this. the pieces are actually puzzled onto your board and you're kind of actually upgrading these shapes, you know, to to as the resources in the game.

Um, just a smoresborg of actions. I don't actually know how to say that. Smorges.

It sounded great, Ryan. Just stick to it.

Just stick with it. Um, so many actions.

That should have been the secret word,

but a very Yeah. And you had to spell it right to get your entry.

Spell it right. um so many actions but a very interesting system of like there's the column of if you send one worker and there's the column if you send two workers and three workers so it shifts the worker placement to be a little bit of like oh man if I often times sending three workers to do something is more than if I do three things separately but it's maybe less flexibility and variety than if I went separately and like

um but if I go separately maybe I can do more different things but maybe I'll get blocked on things I want to do and uh it's a really good core core system. Um, adding in the Norwegians expansion really just beefs up, it actually refreshes that board to now there's this interesting

powerful column that you can only go with your last group of workers, which I think is an fantastic change. It makes it a little more feasible to like rush your workers, do some really big groups, and then you get first access to this kind of valuable column. I think that was a great change.

Um, it's a hard one to get to the table cuz it's kind of a big teach and a big experience. Um, and it's competing with a lot of other games in its weight class. I will definitely if if mark my words, if we're doing our top games next year, and I haven't played a Feast for Odin,

you hear that listener, hold on.

I don't even know. I don't even know what the consequence next year should be, but I should get roasted in the comments for sure.

Um, but still a game that is very, very high in my rankings. And, uh, wrapping up our 20 through 11 of all time.

20 through 11. That means there are still 10 games better than this. And in our 10 to one, we will announce the winner of the giveaway. So, if you somehow got to this point and didn't enter your word, which is not smorgesborg, uh it is final. You can drop that down in the link below along with go back to our old videos and enter the secret word scenario and get up to four entries. Get you a good shot at being one of the three lucky winners. Um, but once that 10 to one video is released, it'll be right here. Go see if you won. Go see our top games.

Progress saved